Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Why Are There Contradictions Between Science and Judaism?
674 views
Why are there contradictions between science and Judaism? From Hidabroot’s “70 Tough Questions in Judaism” series. #ai #aivideo #judaism #jewishtiktok #jewishthought #torah #science #torahandscience #scienceandtorah #scienceandjudaism #jewishshorts #hidabroot
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Today, Torah and science are often
perceived like oil and water, completely
contradictory. [music]
Science represents the rational, that
which is factual and proven, while
faith, [music] many people look at it as
something blind, lacking foundation. In
the modern world, we've become
accustomed to thinking that a scientific
fact is an absolute truth that can't be
disputed. But wait, is science really
immune to mistakes? And does it tell us
the full picture? [music] It wasn't
always like this at all. The greatest
scientists explored the world out of
deep faith. For them, studying nature
was simply a way to trace the wisdom of
the creator. As long as scientists
maintained humility and understood that
science provides only [music] one
perspective on reality, religion and
science lived in peace side by side. The
explosion [music] began about 300 years
ago. Suddenly, a new approach emerged
called scientism. This approach claimed
that the scientific method is the only
and exclusive path to truth. At the same
time, science began to formulate
theories about [music] events from the
distant past, such as the formation of
the universe. Theories that relied on
hypotheses, not on 100% [music] proven
facts. And that is where the real
conflict began. To understand the limits
of science, you need to understand how
it works. Science collects data,
measures, and analyzes observable
phenomena. It's a champion at answering
technical questions. What happened? Or
how does gravity work? But science has a
clear limit. It is incapable of dealing
with questions of essence. It wasn't
designed to explain why the universe
exists, what the purpose of our lives
is, or what morality [music] even is.
These are questions of meaning and
quantitative science can't measure
meaning. Beyond that, every scientific
theory rest on axioms, fundamental
[music] assumptions that can't be
proven. Even the idea causality, that
one action causes another, is ultimately
a philosophical assumption. Add to that
the [music] fact that scientific history
is full of errors by researchers who
tried, even if unintentionally, to
interpret [music] findings just to make
them fit what they expected to see in
advance. To be clear, there is no
intention here to disparage science. Its
achievements are amazing and have
advanced humanity by light years. But
when there is an apparent contradiction
between science and the Torah Israel,
one must remember that science is not
the beall [music] and endall. Sometimes
it simply has to reach the truth that
will be revealed later. And history
proves this. In ancient times,
astronomers estimated that there were
only a few thousand individual stars in
the universe. At that exact same time,
the sages of the Taloo [music] described
the universe and organized systems of
galaxies and clusters and cited enormous
numbers. Numbers that today overlap with
NASA's estimates. Or take continental
[music] drift. Only in the 20th century
did science confirm that all the
continents were once one large [music]
continent that split apart. But in the
book of Zohar, which was written 2,000
years ago, it is explicitly written,
"The [music] waters brought forth one
land, and from it seven lands were
formed." Ultimately, the Torah and
science are not rivals. Science
deciphers the laws of the material
world, the way things work. [music] And
the Torah provides the full picture, the
meaning and purpose for which this world
was created in the first place.