Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
What the Torah Really Says About Moral Responsibility - Rabbi Dovid Gottleib
2,438 views
Can something be morally wrong — without making the person who struggles with it a bad person? In this deep and challenging Torah class, we explore a foundational Jewish principle that’s often misunderstood: the Torah distinguishes sharply between actions and people. Follow us: https://www.hidabroot.com https://www.youtube.com/@Hidabrootcom https://www.instagram.com/hidabroot_global https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbCYZjl1CYoa4ulQIK2q #TorahAnytime #TorahThought #JewishPhilosophy #MoralResponsibility #Judaism #HumanDignity #CompassionAndTruth #Ethics #TorahWisdom
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
When I worked this here out, I wanted to
call it something like homosexuality or
something. And I was told you can't say
that here. Really? Why not?
Don't we look life in the face over
here? Alternative lifestyles. Yeah,
fine. Okay.
Maybe we're saying deep in discerning
person, understanding person will
understand it. That's what it's about.
Uh I don't have to tell you that the
Torah is against
Um,
and what I want to do eventually is get
to the arguments of the people who think
that
these choices are personal choices and
there's no such thing as right or wrong
or good or bad and every ch lifestyle
choice is as good as every other
lifestyle choice and therefore it's not
an appropriate thing to criticize. I
want to get to that. But [clears throat]
first of all, I want to make the Jewish
position clear because I think there's a
lot of misunderstanding of the Jewish
position.
First of all, what is the status of
sense of attraction in the Jewish
picture of what it is to be human and
what it is to be uh flourishing and
human and the purpose of human life?
Well, for one thing, the beginning of
[clears throat] chapter 5 of the book of
Genesis,
it says, it repeats again that God
created mankind,
male and female,
and he called
their name Adam,
not his name,
their name. Which mean the word Adam
strictly speaking applies to a male
female pair.
It means real humanity is found in a
male female pair. Not in a male alone
and not in a female alone and not in
same-sex pairs.
That's deeply deeply prejudice, right?
Prejudice against all sorts of human
choices and so forth and so on. Yeah, it
is right. correct? Not not pretending
that it isn't. Furthermore, it says that
um a man should abandon his parents
and cleave to his wife.
They'll become one flesh.
Now, it is true that Rashi explains that
is that's how procreation takes place.
But the Raan others say it's certainly
true that that's how progreation takes
place. But after all that's what animals
do also and nowhere do we read that
pairs of animals become one flesh. So
presumably there's more to it than just
that. Doesn't say that what Rashi says
is wrong. Can't say anything like that
but there's more to it than that.
The
marital bond is something which
integrates them into this single joint
entity which is
the way that they procreate because one
of the things that they're here for in
earth is to be parents prov
to
by said in the plural that you should
have children. So you're here to bring
children into the world. That's part of
your purpose in the world.
And cementing the relationship is also
part of your purpose in the world. In
fact, there is an obligation on both
husband and wife for sexual intimacy
with the other partner.
Even when procreation is impossible,
even when the wife is pregnant, even
when they've both gone past childbearing
age, there's an obligation on both
sides. And in fact, the biblical
obligation is on the man's side. He has
a specific verse in the Torah that tells
him that he must be prepared to engage
in that kind of connection with his
wife. she has a different type of
obligation, but it's it's a it's a
necessary part of a
of a of a marriage in a in the Jewish
sense.
Now,
one of the challenges that people raise
to this idea is that
you don't have to be a heterosexual
couple to love each other.
Two men can love each other and two
women can love each other.
So why would you think that the
heterosexual is special since love could
be could be samesexual as well? And the
deep reans answer here is that yes
indeed people of the same sex can love
one another. That shouldn't be a
surprise.
After all, parents can love their
children even of the same sex. And
children can love their parents of the
same sex.
And friends can love one love one
another deeply. But each type of of of
um coupling has a different quality of
love. They're all genuine. They're all
true. They're all faithful. They're all
inspiring, but they're different. Woe to
the parent who loves the child the way a
husband
loves a wife. Woe to the teacher who
loves the child the way a brother loves
a brother.
They're different relationships.
Different ages, different different uh
responsibilities.
[clears throat]
And what what's being said here is that
the type of relationship that you have
between a man and a woman is a different
type of relationship that two men can
have and two women can have. And they
can all be characterized by some love or
other.
But the love that you have between
husband and wife is different from the
kind of love you have between man and
man or between woman and woman. And we
are created to have that kind of love
and that kind of integration and that
kind of marriage.
Not the others. Other relationships are
valuable in their place.
David and Jonathan are examples of two
people who would lay down their lives
for one another
except for some p pure ignorant benited
member of the knesset who wanted to
explain it in the most gross
inappropriate way. Uh you don't have to
see
dedicated and and powerful and inspiring
love as a substitute for marriage.
That's love between two men who are
deeply deeply friends loving one
another. So what has nothing to do with
marriage? Marriage is a different type
of love.
In particular since in the nature of
things men and women are different in in
significant ways. um forming that kind
of relationship between a man and a
woman means getting a little bit out of
yourself.
It means stretching yourself to try to
understand someone who's different from
you.
Learning to identify with what's
different about the other person than
you. And maybe this is grossly unpopular
today because everything's supposed to
be about me. But this is what's demanded
in a in a husband and wife relationship
where you step out of yourself and work
to try to climb into somebody else's
world that's different and see the world
out of their eyes and they see the world
out of your eyes. And in that way you
share a much richer experience than you
would have if you were simply alone. and
much spiritual experience than if two
men are together and two women are
together. So it's not a question of love
in that sense [snorts]
and because this is the background
homosexual actual actions are forbidden
though not in the same degree for men
and for women but they are forbidden and
um for women maybe that maybe that's not
something would say there's not not a
problem with homosexual actions and the
condition is not desirable especially if
in either sex it displaces your ability
to have a heterosexual relationship that
would be regarded as a a disability, a
serious personal disability.
Now, here comes a point which is in
general very important and very very
important in this particular discussion.
There's a categorical difference between
evaluating actions and evaluating
agents.
To call an action illegal, immoral, bad,
cruel, criminal, and so forth and so on
is reasonably objective and reasonably
observable. That's why you can punish
crimes because there's reasonable
agreement on the kinds of actions which
are
illegal and reasonable and I would say
immoral and cruel and so forth and so
on. But agents is another matter. How do
you evaluate the agent to perform the
action when you don't know what he's
living, you don't know what he's
experiencing, you don't know what his
resources are, you don't know what his
temptations are, you don't know what his
limitations are. And our sources say
that whereas you can evaluate actions,
that's why there are courts and courts
do judge actions.
But it's not up to us to evaluate
people. We don't evaluate people.
uh Ramba writes this explicitly only K
deos the god who knows the inner life of
the person can evaluate the person so
when you see someone performing let's
say uh SSA type action and you know that
Judaism say SSA is for short for samesex
attraction when you see someone
performing an action like that and you
know Jesus is against the action don't
conclude that the Judism is against the
person that doesn't follow. It might be
the person can't help himself. Might be
the person doesn't know. There could be
all sorts of reasons that he's doing it
which would result in empathy for the
person and sympathy for the person and
pity for the person and a desire to help
the person and aid the person and
shouldn't think that because we
strenuously condemn the actions that
therefore we're going to injure or or
disadvantage or hurt or exclude people
who have these conditions.
This doesn't follow. So a lot of the
Torah's description of the actions
when carried over to people sounds very
cruel but but carrying it over to people
is a mistake. I have here a bunch of
examples of where the Torah detaches
this act the action from the agent and
where the evaluation of the agent is
much much milder than it is of the
action. I' I've wrote down the sources
here if you want to share with somebody.
All the sources are written there.
So let's take a look uh at this.
First of all, ignorance. A person
doesn't know what he's doing or why he's
doing his what he's doing is bad. Hasn't
heard that there's any problem with it
is greatly greatly reduced in in in
evaluation. He's not doing anything
deliberately.
You could ask whether he should have
known better. That you could ask a
person should have known better. It's
what we call a show gig. That person is
semi-responsible for what he does. But
he's not vicious. He's not a criminal
actor. He's just irresponsible because
he didn't investigate. So ignorance is
definitely a uh a mitigating factor. Um
and if a person grows up ignorant then
even after he's not ignorant anymore he
may have a very large scale excuse
is writing about people he was living in
the time of the kites now the kites were
a Jew Jewish group who split from the
tradition by denying the oral tradition
and saying they're going to live just by
the book that is to say the book of the
of Moses
Well, that's a heresy. It's a terrible
heresy. Raam says, let's consider a
third generation kite.
He grew up with karite parents and
karite grandparents.
They had groups. They had whole
communities. They had a literature.
Indeed, in some places they they lived
in the Muslim lands. They had the
favoritism of the Muslim caiff from the
of the area. and they got support and
the those who were faithful to the
tradition were a separate group and they
were a minority sometimes and and they
were looked down upon. Now this kid
grows up in his family and when he's 19
somebody says hey your parents left out
a lot is the whole oral tradition. What
do you expect from him? Says Rambam you
can't expect anything from him because
he grew up with his training. All the
people he knows about, all he cares
about, all people whom he respects told
him a and now you're telling him it's
wrong. B is true. He is Ram says he's
like a person who's uh under duress
under the threat of his life and
therefore you continue to approach him
with love and with sympathy and with
concern. He uses a poetic phrase aosava,
cords of love, strings of love to try to
bring him back to a miracle. So now he
knows he knows they're the rabbinites as
they were called as opposed to kerites.
He knows the rabbinites are also Jewish.
He knows that they have a tradition and
he knows that you're not allowed to uh
to do things that are only in the oral
tradition. But he can't relate to that
because he wasn't brought up that way.
He's still regarded as almost completely
not responsible for what he does.
Then there's a very interesting uh case
that were in Shabas. A is chasing B to
kill him and B is looking for refuge.
It's life and death. And he has a
choice. He can go into the house of a
Jewish atheist or he can go to the house
of a non-Jewish atheist.
Which one should he choose?
And says choose the non-Jew
because his atheism isn't based on real
knowledge.
rejecting real knowledge of God, real
understanding of God. He's less criminal
than the Jew who's rejected it. And that
being the case, you should go to the So
you see how how serious it is, how
criminal you are depends upon how much
background you have and how much you're
denying when you take the wrong step.
And not everybody who's an atheist has
the same has the same status. Indeed, in
the book of Jonah, I think it was a
brisker who said this. Book of Jonah,
you have a very interesting set of
events. Jonah is a prophet. God tells
him to go prophesy, doesn't want to do
it. Gets on a ship and there's a
tremendous storm that threatens the ship
and it's going to go down. The sailors
ask Jonah, he's a stranger to them. Who
are you? He says, I'm a Jew. I serve I
serve the creator of heaven and earth.
And
says, "I know why this is happening
because I'm running away from God. God
doesn't like it." So he says, "Throw me
into the sea." And and the people there,
by the way, who are not Jewish, our
exemplary god. Halai, the non-Jews we
deal with today that we don't want to do
that. We your blood will be on our
hands. We can't do that. We take tribe.
They throw over all the baggage to try
to save the ship and they can't. Finally
they say God please don't don't uh
judge us with the he said to throw him
they throw him into the water and the
weather goes fine and they sail all the
way to port. Now these people who are
sailors on the boat who are they all
idol worshippers
say but he asks well isn't this a little
unbalanced? We have a Jew who's not
doing the right thing. Uhhuh. and
there's a storm and they who are idol
worshippers which is the worst thing in
the world and they get fair weather and
they sail the port and they collect
their salary and so forth and so on and
the answer is what do you expect from
them the whole society is out of
worshippers the whole philosophy is out
of worshippers they don't know anything
different you expect every one of them
to be Abraham that's not reasonable you
can't expect that of the Jewish prophet
we expect much higher behavior so how
much how much we expect and how much
will be punished depends upon what your
resources are, what could be reasonably
expected from you.
So that's uh
ignorance. Another case of ignorance,
the comments of the Gmorra that those
who are not learned in Torah walk in the
dark. That's his description. Now what
do you think of a person who walks in
the dark and stumbles and falls?
You know, okay, he's walking in the
dark. That'll happen to people when they
when they they walk in the dark. You
could say get a light. Yeah, you could
say that and it might be practical. It
might not be practical. But then he's
not guilty for flawing. He's guilty for
not getting a light. And if it was very
difficult to get a light and it cost
resources he didn't have, then he won't
be guilty for that either.
The Rambam as I as I said before talks
about individual circumstances what your
background is where where you're coming
from what you uh you know what your
desires are what your needs are what
your inspirations are what your
resources are all of that goes into
evaluating the status of the agent and
we typically don't know those things
then there's a something which comes up
over and over again
that the the the says
the says
is exacting. He's very strict with those
who are close to him, the righteous to a
hair's breath.
You aim for the target, you're off by
the width of a hair, bang, you get it.
But those only
the very righteous. The more
capabilities you have, the stricter the
standard by which you're judged. So if
less capabilities, you won't be judged
by by that kind of standard. You know,
the the medals of violin concerto is a
very easy concerto. It's really very
easy. It's not taxing or difficult at
all. And a person gets up there and
plays in public and and makes five
mistakes. It depends upon who he is.
If he's um Yasha Hifitz or Rene Capason
who's a wonderful violinist now or Julia
Fischer he made five mistakes in the
medson person's a bum you should be able
to play that blindfolded you know asleep
if he happens to be the concert master
of the local county orchestra that's a
very good performance we have different
standards for different people so now
the problem will be when I'm looking at
the person doing the action
I don't know what standard is holding
him up to because I don't know what
capabilities he has and what
difficulties he has. That being the case
again I can't judge the person on the
basis of judging the actions that he
performs.
There's a wonderful pitadic
um
tells the following story. One of the
great sages was in the marketplace and
someone there
um
was remarking about a third party and he
said,
"Look how ugly he is."
I'm sorry. No, the sage. The sage saw
someone and said, "Look how ugly he is."
Was he was he was shocked by the
ugliness of the person. It wasn't just
his physical appearance, but it was also
you could see his character. And that
person said back to the sage, "You say
I'm ugly. Go to the craftsman that made
me."
Oh, let's see now. Craftsman that made
me. Who could that be? Huh? Philip down
the street. No, the craftsman that made
me is God. He's saying, "You look at me
as ugly in this way. Blame God for it."
Now the commentators point out that this
ugly person was really Elijah the
prophet
and he was sent to provoke that response
from the sage so that he could be
answered go to the craft that made me
and the pit sadic one of the
commentators explains as follows
what was telling that sage is this you
get out of bed in the morning what's
your goal for the
Your goal for the day is to be perfect.
Well, who were your parents? Who were
your grandparents? In what context did
you grow up? What schools were you
educated in? Who were the examples that
you lived with?
Yeah. Your parents were great people.
Your grandparents were great people. And
they your society was the elite of the
of the population and lots lots of um
inspiration. And you had an exquisite
education. and you have as your goal to
be perfect today. I didn't grow up like
you did. I grew up in very mediocre
circumstances. My parents were not very
well educated. I had to leave school
when I was nine so I could help support
my parents. The people around me are
rough. My goal for the day is to be
decent the whole day. Your goal is to be
perfect the whole day. My goal is to be
decent the whole day. Who told you that
your efforts are dearer to a kesh than
mine?
After all, all you have is your effort.
That's all you contribute.
I didn't choose where I was put on the
ladder of accomplishment. And you didn't
choose where you were put on the ladder
of accomplishment. If the accomplishment
goes from zero to 100, you were put on
85, expected to climb to 95. And I was
put at 30, expected to climb to 40. If
we each climb 10 units, you know better
than I am. So why are you looking down
at me?
And that's the message here. When I look
at the second guy and think, oh, look,
he's just trying to be decent. You know,
what kind of life is that? You're not
looking at it from God's point of view
that we spoke about a couple weeks ago.
All he wants from you was the effort
that you that you put out. So when I
look at that action, if this action that
the mediocre person did was performed by
the by the sage, it would be a horrible
crime. But for the mediocre person, it
could be average and quite respectable.
Now when you look at a person to know in
detail what level he climbed on the
ladder at, how much progress he's made
and how much he's expected from him
again something which we can't know.
There's a fascinating Gmorra
in the book of Job. Job raises all sorts
of complaints about the way Kosha runs
the world and Gomorrah calls this
blasphemy. The long section of where the
failures and faults of Job are laid out
in detail and criticized at great great
length.
And then there's one verse which says
Job speaks without knowledge.
Well, when I first read that, I thought
to myself, well, then keep quiet. What
do you mean speak without knowledge? You
don't have knowledge, don't say
anything. Ra doesn't take it that way.
He says Yo was in terrible pain. He was
subjected to terrible pain. And because
he had terrible pain, he lost his
ability to understand things clearly.
And therefore, he's not guilty. He's not
guilty for all the terrible things that
he said because he spoke Bidas. If he
had spoken with a composed mind and and
deliberate mind and said these things
with purpose then he would have been
responsible and guilty but because he
spoke that way. So stress can produce a
reaction of of a person which relieves
him for a great deal of responsibility.
I told you that example happened to be
in Boston where the fellow came in and
was yelling at my rebby and I stood
between the two of them pushed him out
and the rebby was calm and I asked him
how could you be so calm and he said
because I know what's going on at home.
I thought oh
I don't know what's going on in his home
but he knows and he sees that he's a guy
who's under pressure and he's just lost
it. That's not the same as deliberately
saying terrible things.
Now here we're talking about SSA and
sexual matters is a very very
interesting tus
in in se in several
inh
let's suppose that a person is guilty of
deliberate
sexual crime. It could be
adultery or other other sexual crimes.
Certain types of crimes carrying certain
types of punishments disqualify a person
for testimony. It no longer can function
as a as a witness.
Ta says on the basis of certain
considerations that with its sexual
crimes, it doesn't disqualify the person
for
being a witness
because the impulse to sexual crime is
so powerful.
This doesn't respect this doesn't um
express the the nature of the person's
character. It's an impulse that he
didn't control. He should have
controlled it. He's responsible for not
controlling it. But it doesn't indicate
complete corruption of his character
like for example a paid witness does
eight kamas. So which does cost. So here
the the theus anyway is pointing out
that not all failures have the same
consequences even if the severess of the
punishment is the same but the struggle
to avoid them isn't the same and since
that's the case they don't have the same
consequences and sexual infractions have
less severe consequences than other
types of infractions.
So again, if we're talking about a
person who's involved in SSA and he
hears that we're against it, but the
question of how we feel about him, it
has all these qualifications built in.
>> Yeah.
to say that every man
when it comes to his uh
his game and his
progress in life. Is it to be able to uh
have
so we all have
things we have to work on and like you
said the sexual thing is what was the
term I was
should have had
control
>> right
>> so my question is do we all have a
responsibility to control our
>> so our main responsibility here is to
control our physical desires.
>> Uh I think that that's right. But it's
it's you see words are slippery. Words
are funny. That makes it only negative
and it makes it very very narrow. I
would say where we have the
responsibility to use this area of life
in the way that wants to use it. Both
control and expression and nuance and
timing and sensitivity and all the rest.
It's not just saying control makes it
much too narrow. The project is a much
bigger project than that.
Um I'm in the middle of a a kind of Did
you get an outline?
>> Yes, sir.
>> Okay. So, we're in the middle of of
number two number four towards the end.
The last one that I have here is this.
Um
yeah. Okay. There's another source
because a sexual crime typically is not
fully deliberate. The part of him is out
of control and therefore the
consequences are not as serious as other
consequences. So the bottom line of this
section is when you hear how much the
Torah opposes these types of activities,
you shouldn't draw a conclusion
therefore the people who do it are
really horrible criminals. No, there's
no jump from the action is bad to the
person is bad or how bad the person is
because there's a lot of factors which
could take a very serious action and
mitigate it to the point where person's
responsibility could be very little.
I'll give you the last one. I don't know
if I didn't put it in here because I
guess I took it for granted. Let's
suppose somebody puts a gun to a Jew's
head and says, "Bow to the idol or
commit a sexual crime or I'll kill you."
Now, the rule is he should let himself
be killed.
And the rule is people have free will to
do that. People have chosen to die
rather than commit one crime or another.
Many, many times in history, Jews and
non-Jews have done that. That's what he
should do. [clears throat] But suppose
he fails.
I suppose there are witnesses and
suppose he's warned. Listen, this is a
capital crime and if you do this, we can
go to the court and we give testimony
and be punished by the court. Suppose he
says, I hear you. I hear you. I just
can't let him blow my brains out. I
can't do it. I just can't do it. And
maybe he can. He doesn't realize he can.
Not willing to make the effort and he
and he fails. What then is his
punishment with witnesses and with
warning? The answer is no punishment at
all.
And this is not controversial
because he had it done to his.
So
that's not an expression of deep
uh twisted immoral character. That's
simply I can't die.
And why the way I put it is this. If
you're willing to die rather than
transgress, you're a hero. And if you're
not willing to die, you failed to be a
hero.
Is failing to be a hero. A big failing
or a little failing.
It's a little failing. Failing to be a
hero. You didn't get a 100%. You got
97%. Is that a big failing? You don't
want the absolute top, the absolute
best. That's not a big failing.
How many people get to be absolute best?
Right? So therefore, he's not he's not
punished at all. There are nuances here.
I'm not going to, but that's a general
idea. He's not he's not punished for
because he's under gigantic stress. And
that being the case, he has less
responsibility. So bowing to the to the
idol or committing adultery are terrible
crimes, but he's not a terrible criminal
for the fact they committed a terrible
crime. But you can't make the move from
the actions a terrible action to the
person's a terrible person. That's a
wrong move. It's a wrong a move that we
have that's not not
acceptable.
So that's the general background. Now in
the last section here, which I may or
may not finish today. Yeah.
>> Is this According to
Yemen,
>> that's a little different. Um,
in the letter to Yemen, there they were,
let's put this the Muslim authorities
were requiring that the Jews should say
in public, I believe in Muhammad.
Okay. Um
some Jewish authorities said for this
you have to die and if you don't die
you're going to be condemned by God as
someone who who pledged allegiance with
other religion and so forth and so on.
And the Ramba was horrified,
horrified with what this person wrote.
And he wrote a long uh letter to the
Jews um who uh to support them and to
say, first of all, it's not obvious that
Islam is idol worship. And second of
all, pledging allegiance to a to a to a
prophet is not pledging allegiance to a
foreign god. It's over and so on. And
and third of all, everybody knows you
don't mean it. And the Muslim
authorities also know that you don't
mean it. They just want you to say the
words. So to say that you're going to be
condemned and hated by he was really but
he he he said to them, "You're suffering
a terrible of terrible oppression
[snorts]
and no one should be should be um
criticized, you know, for for for saying
that in public." Anyway,
what I want to do now is look at the
arguments that are given by those who
think that homosexuality is an equally
valid lifestyle and see whether those
arguments hold hold logic. They hold any
water in ter in terms of logic. Uh you
can probably guess what I think,
[clears throat] but I'll give them to
you and I'll tell I have the rebuttals
here written out on the on the on the
list and we can discuss them as we go.
This goes back to the 70s. The American
Psychiatric Association
voted
that homosexuality is not a disease.
And since it's not a disease, it's not
undesirable,
nothing wrong with it.
And since there's nothing wrong with it,
it's an equally valid lifestyle.
Now, let's see.
Um,
undesirable means nothing wrong with it.
And since there's nothing wrong with it,
uh, it's an equally valid lifestyle.
Who are the members of the American
Psychiatric Association?
Well, they're psychiatrists.
um
is are they somehow specially qualified
to make moral judgments?
I could equally ask the question the
other way. Are they not perhaps
disqualified from making moral
judgments? But I won't ask it that way.
I won't say that. After all, to say that
it is or is not a disease, if not being
a disease means it's nothing undesirable
and is equally valid, they're making a
moral judgment.
I don't think that we have to trust
their judgment in terms of defi deciding
what is good and what is evil.
Um
and that's only one journal one
association. They did other surveys of
uh of of simil civil experts and they
get the opposite result. So it was a
prejudiced sampling in the first place.
So the fact that someone declares that
something isn't disease
uh doesn't mean that it's binding on the
basis of the fact that he's a doctor and
knows how diseases grow and how they
don't grow and how they if the
conclusion is going to be it's an
equally valid lifestyle then he as a
doctor has no has no expertise in making
that judgment and therefore
[clears throat] no one has to be bound
by the judgments of the American
Psychiatric Association.
I want you to know that when they came
out with this ruling, money for studying
homosexuality disappeared
because the motivation for dedicated
money is I want to help people. People
who are in a bad way. But if it's not a
disease as equally and it's equally
desirable and therefore it's equally
valid lifestyle, they're not in a bad
way. They're fine. So why study it?
Study something where people are
suffering and and are unfortunate and
you can help them. So all the money
dried up. I don't think that the the
judgment of the American association
associations is valid for that.
Now here's one that you also hear,
although people should have gotten
smarter over the years. Homosexuality is
a genetic condition. And because it's
genetic condition, it's unchangeable.
And therefore, you can't be responsible
for something that you can't change.
And therefore, it's equally valid. just
leave them alone.
Well, um, every clause in that argument
is wrong.
First of all, when you say something's
genetic, it could mean one of two
things. You could mean the genes
determine that it will be so. Like the
genes determine your eye color,
or the genes plus your intrauterine
environment determine your fingerprints.
Or it could mean that the genes affect
that outcome, but don't determine it.
Like for example, genes for great
height. If you grow up malnourished, you
won't be tall.
The genes don't make you tall. The genes
make you susceptible to becoming tall.
If you're wellnourished, so it's the
genes and the nourishment that make you
tall, not the genes alone that make you
tall.
No one said that the genes make you into
homosexual.
What they meant is that statistically
people who have these genes are more
likely to become a homosexual. That's
what they meant. That turned out to be
wrong also, but leave that alone. They
therefore is more likely. So the genes
have a role to play, but not that it was
genetic determination determinism. And
the proof of it is that you have
identical twins, one of whom is a
homosexual, and the other one is not.
So the genes are determining it. That
couldn't happen. But identical twins
have all the same genes.
So number one, it's not it's not it's
not fully genetic. Number two,
unchangeable. Now, if you have a
tendency or have developed, let's say, a
certain type of behavior and set of
desires and attitudes and orientation,
how would you know it's unchangeable?
That's a very, very gigantic strong
claim. Unchangeable means can't be
changed. How many different ways of
changing it have you tried after all?
Um, well, we tried these therapies and
it didn't work. Did you try combinations
of therapies in different orders,
different strengths, different
circumstances? Did you try it with
different cultures?
Unchangeable is a gigantic thing to say.
And we're careful not to say we no one
would say this disease is un
unconquerable.
say, "We haven't found a way yet, but
who knows? But tomorrow we might find
something." So to say this unchangeable
is just a a a uh a gross exaggeration of
what you could possibly know. And of
course there are therapies and of course
there are therapies that actually do
help. You're not allowed to say that.
You say that you lose your psychiatric
license and all the rest of it. But in
fact it happens to be true. People who
are in process of education know that
it's true. They know people for whom it
it's actually happened. So uh but but
just to say unchangeable in general is
now let's see let's suppose something's
a genetic condition and is unchangeable
suppose it were hence no responsibility
for what you do
really let's suppose a person is a
kleptomaniac
people who steal
let's say we're genetic I don't know but
let's say we're genetic and it's
unchangeable does that mean that he's
not responsible for stealing
Well, um, what about this? Hire a person
to go with the kleptomaniac into the
store and watch his hands.
As far as I understand, he won't steal.
The whole point is to get away with it.
So, he could stop the behavior himself
just by hiring somebody to go into the
store with him.
So, what we're interested in now is not
becoming a different person. We're
interested in controlling your behavior.
The fact that the condition is un
unchangeable if it were, it isn't, but
if it were, doesn't mean that the
behavior is not controllable. There all
sorts of techniques for controlling
behavior.
And let's suppose all three were true.
It's genetic and it's unchangeable and
it's uncontrollable. Does that make it
equally valid? How about color
blindness?
Color blindness is genetic and it's can
be anyway genetic and it's um
unchangeable and it's uh
does that make it equally valid? Oh,
there's no difference between seeing
color and not seeing color because
they're both genetic and they're both
unchangeable and not responsible for
them. So, if I have a way to give color
vision to a colorblind person, not worth
doing because it's equally valid.
Uh,
I don't think that conclusion is true. I
think we look at certain condition as
unfortunate.
They're unfortunate. Even if they're
genetic and unchangeable and you're not
responsible for them, they're
unfortunate
and therefore they could be changed. It
would be a gift to change the change for
the person.
So the the whole argument, every clause
in the argument is mistaken. Just just
just wrong.
Well,
uh, homosexuality is isolated, not
correlated with any other desirable
undesirable behavior. They were equally
valid. Homosexuals don't steal more and
don't murder more and don't cheat more
and don't lie more and don't like more
guilty of fraud and so forth and so on.
Well, maybe yes and maybe no, but that
wasn't the question. The question
wasn't, is homosexuality a marker for
other types of crimes? So, you have to
be worried about these people. The
question was whether homosexuality is an
unfortunate condition in and of itself.
So the fact that they aren't marked I'm
not sure that this is true but I say if
it isn't a marker for other crimes
wouldn't be relevant to the to the
argumented issue.
Another argument that's given is
homosexuality is problematic. People
think of it as problematic or worried
about it only because of social
rejection. society becomes enlightened,
people don't reject homosexuals, there
won't be anything wrong with it. Uh, and
the rebuttal here is social acceptance
does not render all undesirable behavior
valid. Consider the Nazis. If you have a
whole society of Nazis, that doesn't
mean being a Nazi is okay.
Means the whole society is bad. So, the
fact that there won't be attacked by
other people and won't be criticized by
other people doesn't mean that they're
okay. Could be that the whole society is
entirely wrong.
And then you have this attitude, who are
you to judge somebody else's lifestyle.
It's paternalistic to judge somebody
else's lifestyle. You should just keep
your nose out of other people's
business. Well, that's just not true. We
few days ago, we talked about the
article in The Economist about the guy
who killed himself because he got
positive result test for AIDS. I talked
about
he made a mistake in in statistics and
he thought that that the test showed
that it was a very high probability that
he had AIDS. He made a mistake. No, the
probability would have been 20% or 10%.
He thought it was 96%. And he killed
himself. And you hear him tell talking
to himself, you know, I'm I'm I have
AIDS. I can't live and so on and so on.
And you try to explain it to him and he
doesn't want to listen to you. It's
putting the gun in his head. Do you say,
"Oh, I can't judge his lifestyle. I'll
let him commit suicide." No, you knock
him down and tie him up. Explain it to
him and then he'll thank you for the
rest of his life. So he's not
paternalistic. People make mistakes and
sometimes other people can see they make
mistakes. So it's not paternalistic to
judge other people's lifestyle. And the
final argument which isn't worthy of of
mentioning itself a mention of
completeness is if you have anything
against homosexual homosexuals that's
because you're a homophobe.
You're suffering from homophobia.
You're really threatened and afraid of
threatened by and afraid of homosexuals
because you have inklings that you too
are homosexual and you can't stand the
thought. And that's where it's all
coming from. Well, excuse me. This isn't
worthy of a three-year-old. Let's say
I'm a homophobe. I gave arguments.
Don't attack me. Attack my arguments. If
you attack me, that means you're just
afraid of my arguments.
If all my arguments are true and I'm
prejudiced, you're in trouble because
the arguments are true.
So if you're attacking me, it's because
you're afraid of the arguments. I once
did this in public. A guy said this to
me and I said, "Thank you for confirming
that all my arguments are correct
because all you have left is to attack
me."
That's just when I was in university,
this was considered the lowest of the
low. It's called an ad hom attack.
Attacking the person rather than
attacking the arguments that he gives.
And I made this up, but then other
people picked it up. Not for me later.
What about if I say about homosexuals?
You know what's the matter with you
guys? You're all suffering from
heterophobia.
You're all dead afraid of the fact that
you can't make it with someone of the
opposite sex. That's why you're doing it
and you're covering it up and making it
an equally valid lifestyle. It's really
because you're afraid.
Are they going to be moved by that
argument? I don't think so. Why not?
Because it shouldn't make any
difference. Shouldn't make any idea. AMA
says that there there such thing as as
homophobia. Yeah, they say it.
Congratulations. More politics any more
than heterophobia is a is a so that's
that certainly shouldn't be taken into
into account. And therefore I claim that
there's no
stand no reason whatsoever to treat um
homosexuality as an equally valid
lifestyle that the Torah's view is is
not not
weakened at all by the arguments that
they present and that the Torah's view
has no objection that could be raised
against it. Now uh we went through a lot
today but and I I'm leading the outlines
here and we can start tomorrow if
anybody has any questions or you talk to
people about other uh observations we
can start with that and then tomorrow
I'll go on to another topic.