Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

The Truth About “Political Correctness” - Rabbi Yaakov Asher Sinclair

1,500 views
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism avatar
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[music] >> I just found out that I've got something to be proud of. I used to be just plain old bald, but overnight my life has changed. Now I'm part of a sensitive minority whose feelings demand to be taken into account. I am follicly challenged. Follicly challenged of the world, unite. You've nothing to lose but your wigs. It's ironic that as society becomes more and more insensitive to mindless physical violence, there's [music] a concomitant new sensitivity to the violence of language. And even the religious world is not exempt from this phenomenon. >> [music] >> In the Oxford University Press publication The New Testament and Psalms, an inclusive version, God loses his gender to become our father-mother in heaven. Of course, in Hebrew we don't have this problem because Hashem, God, is referred to by nouns of both genders. For example, Shechinah, the divine presence, is a feminine noun. You might, however, accuse the Torah itself of being [music] PC. When it tells us that Noah, Noah, brought the animals into the ark, the Torah describes the animals that were tame, [music] spiritually polluted, as lo tahor, not pure. The lesson of the longer phrase lo tahor, not pure, >> [music] >> is to teach us to be sensitive to the feelings of others. If the Torah goes out of its way to call an animal, which presumably isn't too much concerned about the niceties of language, not pure rather than polluted, how much more should we then be careful not to hurt the feelings of our fellow humans? But there's a big [music] difference between this and PC. It's true that the Torah never stints to avoid upsetting feelings, provided that the meaning and the clarity of the law will not suffer in any way. If there's the slightest doubt that a nicer word will not convey the same [music] power in communicating the law, there's no place for euphemism. A spade has to be called a spade. In the Torah, there is a place for the most explicit terminology in the appropriate context. And this is just more than concern for accurate transmission of the law. It implies that language has an absolute value. PC is a distortion of language because it is political. Those who invoke PC subtly invoke their own value judgments, which are at least as biased as those they seek to replace. More insidious than this, however, [music] PC destroys the integrity of the connection between the thing and the word, between the world of ideas and the world of concrete reality. This connection is fundamental and vital. Hashem created with words the world. God said, "Let there be light." Words are the bridge between the metaphysical and the physical. And thus, in Hebrew, [music] davar means both word and thing. When we politicize words that describe the world, we limit the palette of our own perceptions. We limit the colors of our sensitivity. We interpose a gray mask of euphemism. If we change words, the building blocks of thought and cognition, let us not be surprised if our mental landscape begins to reflect a terminal blandness and lack of color. You know, I was always perfectly fine with being bald. >> [music]