Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Guys, Pirkei Avot and the ethics of the
fathers,
we have a tendency of going a little bit
deep and try to give you insight that
you can take all your life.
We try to challenge you to think because
there's a lot of pathways in the minds
that are usually unopened and are
closed. They exist, but they're closed
and we try to open it up. Um, and get
the muscles going and give you something
tasty. You see everything is connected.
And every that's how we make oneness.
That's what we say Shema Yisrael Hashem
Elokeinu Hashem Echad. The point of
making oneness is connecting every dot.
So, now we have the ethics of the
fathers that we're going to look into
and try to bring something deep
out of it for us. Rabbi Yohanan ben
Zakkai says, "Go and see what's the best
trait for one to acquire or attach to."
And he says, "What's the worst trait one
should distance from?"
Okay? So, let's see what he brings. He
brings five opinions, five rabbonim,
five tannaim.
We have first Rabbi Eliezer. Rabbi
Eliezer says, "The best trait for you to
attach to is a good eye.
Find get a good eye.
Comes, what's the worst trait? An evil
eye. Distance yourself from an evil
eye."
Comes Rabbi Yehoshua.
Rabbi Yehoshua says,
"What trait? Good friend. Be a good
friend.
And what's the worst?
Evil friend. Distance yourself from
being evil friend." Comes Rabbi Yossi.
He has a different opinion. He says,
"Be a good neighbor.
And comes, what's opposite?
Distance yourself from being a evil
neighbor."
Comes Rabbi Shimon.
Says, "See the outcome of things. See
what it leads to.
And the worst trait?
One who gets a loan
and does not give it back."
Comes Rabbi Elazar,
what's the best trait? A good heart.
And what's the worst trait?
An evil heart. And let's try to ask a
question. Looking at the pattern, is
there something is there a pattern? Do
you see something that doesn't match?
Rabbi Shimon.
He says, see the outcome. And instead of
saying one who doesn't see the outcome,
he says one who gets a loan and doesn't
pay back. Beautiful. And why that is cuz
some people don't have a deep vision, so
he says, that's not a big problem if
you're not seeing the outcome.
But if you're somebody give you a loan,
he gave you the loan,
and you don't give it back, that's
stealing.
And one steals, he's not close to a
shame. He can't talk to a shame.
The shame doesn't really want to accept
that guy.
And that's what happened in Bene Noach.
Bene Noach, the whole stamp, the final
stamp of the generation of Noach who
happened when they stole,
and they got the flood. So he says, one
who gets a loan
and does not give it give it back,
right?
Now, Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai said
these five opinions from his students.
Which one does he choose?
Anybody wants to guess?
What would you choose if you could
choose
one of these five opinions?
>> I don't know.
Good heart.
>> He chooses good heart.
And what it why? He says because having
a good heart, huh?
It's the foundation of all these.
Right? Now, clear up to now, any
questions?
Any questions?
Okay. Let's move forward. Let's try to
connect the dots.
Let's look at these five traits and try
to analyze them. What does that mean to
have a good eye? Okay? A person who has
a good eye, okay, he looks at everything
positively, at people, right? And he
wants the other person to have what he
needs. If he needs a a
house,
he has a good eye. He doesn't good eye.
He doesn't want the guy to suffer. He
needs a house, right? So, that's a good
eye.
He gets what he needs. That's the key.
Right? He doesn't want other people to
be lacking.
Comes Rabbi Yoshua, a good friend. What
does a good friend does?
A good friend I put a plus next to it.
Why?
Because all these, if you look at the
pattern, I put an extra plus in every
level, it's something more.
A good friend
is attached to his friend. A friend is
attached to you.
And he gives a good advice. He worries
for you. He doesn't want to do drugs. He
doesn't want you to follow with the
gangs and, you know, be problematic. He
gives you good advice.
Right? To protect you. To lead you
directly.
Comes Rabbi Yossi, says, "Let me give
you an extra."
Plus
a good neighbor does good deeds. You
know, I don't know here, but every time
somebody's missing some a couple of milk
for the baby
or some sugar for the cake or the car
isn't starting, needs to jump start. A
good neighbor comes and acts good deeds.
And why is this more? Because a good
neighbor is not your friend. He's not
attached to you like a friend.
So, this is a plus, extra plus. He needs
He needs to go a little bit more out of
his way. And he gives you something that
you need.
Right? Comes Rabbi Shimon
and says sees the outcome of things.
Right? He says, "Look, what? I'm going
to do a kindness today.
Right? I'm going to do a kindness today
and what happens? 10 years down the line
somebody will give that kindness back to
me. Right? Somebody will give it back.
Today I'm doing it.
Right? I'm spending time and effort in
doing kindness today, seeing the
outcome. Down the line, somebody come
and help my kid. Right? That's what we
say, "Shimon."
Now, there's one place when you do
kindness and you don't get it back in
this world. Anybody wants to guess? You
can also guess.
You can do a kindness in this world
and
you're you don't expect it back.
To who?
What?
So, that No, you tzedakah you get back.
What you give, by the way, I put not 10.
If you look at the word the Hebrew
letters of not 10 or natan,
it the is basically is the exact same
you flip it around is the exact same
thing. What you give, you're guaranteed
to get it back.
Right? But, there's one place our sages
tell us don't expect to get it back in
this world. You get it back in the next
world, but not in the reward will be
fully in the next world. And that is
for a dead person. A person who's dead
and you have to bury him.
Right? He can't come back and give it to
you, right?
But, then in the next world you do get
the reward, but in this world don't
expect it. But, as we Shimon says,
>> Is the lesson here to bury people or
>> No, no, no. It's a mitzvah. It's a
mitzvah to bury the dead because there's
a respect for every human being and they
have to be buried. So, there's a mitzvah
to bury them. And a dead person who has
no one else,
you know, just happened to be that, you
know, maybe he has nobody else and he's
in a tough situation.
>> Convert.
>> Convert an example. Um or for there
could be There are stories. And if
somebody goes and helps does kindness by
burying him, now he's dead. How is he
going to give it back to you, the
kindness that you did? So, then you
know, you won't get it back, but in the
next world, you know, Hashem knows how
to do cheshbonot calculations. But, we
see something
>> What about mitzvot? We we said that
really there is no reward for mitzvot in
this world.
>> Right, we say in the
Right, in mitzvot we say we you know,
I've heard that we get our expenses paid
in this world, but the real reward is in
the next world, right? So, that's also
true.
So, come I I put the letters for Noten
or Natan to see that everyone goes
around comes around. Now, Rabbi Elazar
says a good heart. What's the difference
between a good heart? A good heart wants
to do kindness to the other person,
right? Even though if he loses money,
right? Even though at his loss, right?
He has a burning to give, right? And
that's Rabbi Elazar is the you know,
opinion chosen by Rabbi Yohanan ben
Zakkai. Why? Because as everybody said,
this is the root of it all. Now, I have
a question for you, right? Let's let's
let's dig deeper.
We only have five things to attach to.
There couldn't be six, seven, eight, 10,
three, 20 things to attach to. That's
one question. And the second question is
if the root of it is Rabbi Elazar, a
good heart, why isn't the other Rabbanim
other opinions just pick the good heart?
The good heart heart has their opinion
in it, right? You see the question? You
see the problem? Anybody wants to take a
stab at that question? Any questions?
What's I mean, just just say the good
heart.
>> Maybe I'm just going to make a joke and
hopefully they'll laugh at this one.
First one is because there were only
five students, so there can't be more
than five answers.
>> No, no, no, there were more students.
That's that's the next question. We'll
get to that. That's up ahead. You're
ahead, but there are more students, but
there's a beautiful you you you you have
something there. We'll get to that.
Anybody wants to to get a stab at it? Or
should we try to go at it one by one?
So,
let's look at it together.
Before Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai brings
this Mishna, there is a previous Mishnah
in Pirkei Avot
says the following. Rabbi Yohanan ben
Zakkai, right, had
the following five disciples, exact same
disciples who would give their opinion.
Rabbi Eliezer, Rabbi Yehoshua, Rabbi
Yossi, Rabbi Shimon, Rabbi Elazar.
And he counts
their praises. He counts each of these
five students' praises. And let's look
at what he praises for each student,
okay?
Rabbi Eliezer,
who said good eye, he's a cemented
cistern, meaning whatever he learns,
he does not lose.
It's a cement. Okay, it's strong. It's a
box that whatever you put into it, he
doesn't lose it, right? Rabbi Yehoshua,
who said good friend,
he he praised him that fortunate the one
who bore him. Who's fortunate? The
mother of Rabbi Yehoshua, who bore him.
Comes Rabbi Yossi,
a good neighbor,
a scrupulously righteous man, hasid.
He's a he's he goes beyond the letter of
the law.
Comes Rabbi Shimon, who sees the
outcome,
he calls he praises him a man of fears
sin. You see fears sin, because he fears
sins.
He also sees the outcome. You see the
correlation.
Comes Rabbi Elazar, who says good heart,
spring spring flowing strong and
stronger pump. A heart is a pump.
So, he's praising these five students,
and Maharal asks, by the way, the
foundation of all this knowledge from
Maharal, amazing amazing insight.
Maharal asks, why did Rabbi Yohanan have
only five students?
He had more students. You are close, you
He had plenty of students. Why only
five? Why did he only pick these? I'm
sure there were plenty more tonight with
him he could have mentioned. So, we have
now three questions. Why only five
things to attach to?
Why only Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai
praises only five students?
And
why isn't the other rabbinic to name go
Rabbi Elazar Rabbi Elazar a good heart
is already including
right the other opinions in it. They're
not saying you know, they're not saying
they could be saying good heart and
they're in it. They're not missing a
point.
So, to answer these questions
let's think together.
A human being
a human being, what is he known to have
as a basic level? Basic basic level.
Five senses?
Well, you're on the five. It's something
with five, but um
>> Five fingers.
>> Five fingers. They're they're all the
you know, five. There's there's five in
there. There's five in there. But, you
you guys are on the pattern. So, on the
basic basic level
we say a human has a body and a soul.
A human is is made of body
and a soul. And if you dig more
into the books
you see suddenly these body and the
souls
they refer to them
as three things.
Nefesh
ruach
neshama.
And if you dig more more into Kabbalah
and maybe some other books or people
Hasidim, I don't know.
>> Ruach isn't just wind, you know.
>> Yeah, but some say it's a speech is less
has wind in it.
So, there's a we're not getting into the
detail what that means, but they say a
person is made of nefesh ruach
and a neshama.
If you look deeper
suddenly you see a person is made out of
five.
Nefesh
ruach neshama chaya yechida. And it's
possible why they don't mention chaya
yechida
is because in this generation we have
little access to them. I mean, no access
to them because that's really high
level. They say
that Yohanan have reached the level of
Chaya and they say that
Chanoch
this tzaddik, the righteous, reached the
level of Yechida and became an angel.
Very high levels. So, people usually
don't mention to Chaya and Yechida.
But, basic level that they mention all
the time is nefesh, ruach, and neshama.
But, in reality, in in in truth, there's
really five levels of souls.
So, the reason
that Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai
is really mentioning only five students
and five things to attach to, right?
is because and the other rabbonim saying
something, they're not saying a good
heart is because every opinion is
focusing on one of these five elements.
Root of all is Rabbi Elazar.
And then you have the soul level level
called sichli.
Another soul level called nafshi.
But, you need a carrier, you need a
vessel to hold these levels.
And so, there you have four and a fifth
level is the root of all, the heart, the
pump.
So, these five opinions
each is really reflecting
one aspect of the five souls. Either the
root
or the vessel, right?
Which is a carrier. Everything needs a
carrier. Like a human body is a carrier
for the soul.
And the mind is a carrier for a
different soul called neshama.
And then you have the soul of the mind
and the soul of the nefesh, right? So,
that answers
our questions. But,
and and if you look at it, right? You
see here.
Rabbi Elazar, who said good heart is a
spring.
Rabbi Yehoshua,
right? A good friend,
right? fortunate is the one who bore him
is the mother, is the vessel, right?
He's a carrier. For who? For Rabbi
Eliezer who says good eye.
Cemented stone who doesn't miss a beat.
Now,
something interesting, Rabbi Eliezer and
Rabbi Yehoshua were Havruta.
They were Havrutas.
And the big debate in Bava Metzia about
the
about about
the the vessel was between Rabbi Eliezer
and Rabbi Yehoshua.
And then comes
Rabbi Shimon who fears sin is in the
mind level
and you need a carrier, Rabbi Yossi,
who's a good neighbor, who's a Hasid,
who's kind,
goes beyond the level of the law, beyond
the letter of the law, and he, when you
go beyond the letter of the law, you're
a Hasid, you're preparing the body, the
carrier, and that's the reason
the Kohen could serve in the Temple. He
has to have a clean, pure body. If the
if the body is impure, you can't enter
the Temple.
So, we see based on these
five opinions, that each one is really
reflecting element of the of the soul,
right? So, that's why they all said
their own different opinion, and they
now didn't stick to a good heart.