Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb - Jewish Philosophy: The Ten Sinai Pronouncements
402 views
Follow us: https://www.hidabroot.com https://www.youtube.com/@Hidabrootcom https://www.instagram.com/hidabroot_global https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbCYZjl1CYoa4ulQIK2q Rabbi Gottlieb elaborates on the exclusiveness of the Ten Commandments received at Sinai. For more inspiring content: @Hidabrootcom
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Look, we're talking about this being a
post Shavuot year.
Talking about the 10 pronouncements at
Sinai.
Um I want to offer you some
observations, some of which are quite
fundamental. First of all, I tried to be
consistent in calling them 10
pronouncements.
There are two reasons for that. There
are no 10 Commandments.
It's just not true.
If you look carefully at the text, there
may be 15 or 16, depending upon how you
count.
So,
the term 10 Commandments, you know,
Cecil B. DeMille
notwithstanding,
is totally inaccurate.
For whatever reasons the Christians
called it that way, the blue book here,
which is communicating to Jews who've
never heard of of of Judaism, uses that
term, but it has no source in our
literature.
In the Torah itself, the text is
referred to as a Seres Had'varim,
which means 10 statements. In the
rabbinic literature, it says Seres
Hadibros, which means 10 pronouncements.
Nowhere is it identified as having 10
mitzvahs.
As I said, because that's simply false.
Now,
these 10 pronouncements form an
extremely fundamental part
of the Torah.
So fundamental that there was a time,
Mishnah records this,
when it was a practice to recite them
every day.
That was discontinued
because
people reciting it every day came to the
impression that only the 10
pronouncements come from God,
all the rest are somehow made up by the
rabbis.
And that's a disaster.
Because in fact, the whole of the
Chumash comes from God.
That's when they discontinued reciting
it every day. But it doesn't mean that
they were demoted.
They do form an extremely fundamental
part of Jewish thinking.
One is because of the form
that the revelation took, and the second
is because of their content. Let me
start with the form.
Uh because
it is fundamental and carries
it's only dependent message.
Um you know what? Take the blue books.
What I'm doing now is
telling you what's in Maimonides
Fundamentals of the Torah chapter 7 and
8.
Basically chapter 8. Take a look at page
403.
Here the Jewish people is at the base of
the Sinai mountain and this is just
uh the briefest prelude to the reg-
revelation Sinai. Verse 9. Hashem said
to Moses,
"Behold,
I come to you in the thickness of the
cloud,
so that the people will hear
as I speak to you,
and they will also believe in you
forever."
There's a lot packed into that
statement. It's a lot packed into every
statement in the Torah, but here it's a
little more on the surface.
"I," says God, "am going to
create a unique event in history.
I'm going to speak to you, you're a
prophet,
but I'm going to allow the entire nation
hear me
speaking to you.
Why am I going to do that?
Because if I do that,
then they'll believe in you forever."
Implication, if I don't do that,
they won't believe in you forever.
That's why I'm doing it.
Says Maimonides,
"Why do we believe that Moses was a
prophet?
And that he communicated to us what God
told him. Why did we do that?
Is it because he did miracles?
Said Maimonides, "No.
Miracles cannot be
a proof that God speaks to a person in
the first place.
So, he does miracles. So what?
All that means is that God either favors
him with special powers or when he wants
that something should happen, God
performs it. It doesn't imply that God
speaks to him.
The two concepts concepts are not
related logically.
And
if your only trust in Moses, let's say,
was on the basis of miracles that he
did,
it would always be possible for a later
prophet to come and also do miracles,
maybe even more spectacular miracles.
And then
you would have every reason to trade
what Moses told you for the later
prophet.
Couldn't be a prediction you believe in
it forever.
No.
The The basis of Moses' credibility is
not
that he did miracles.
That could be temporary,
but it wouldn't be absolute and wouldn't
be forever. So, the basis of Moses'
credibility is that we ourselves heard
God speaking to Moses.
Now, imagine a later prophet who arises
and says, "I'm a prophet from God. Look,
I'll do these and these miracles and God
says Q and we know that Q contradicts
what Moses says.
At that point we're going to say,
"I don't know.
I don't know how to explain the fact
that you did what you did,
but we ourselves heard God telling this
to Moses and heard Moses telling it to
us.
So, we know by our own testimony, our
own experience, our own observation that
God spoke to Moses, told him these
things.
You?
So, you did some tricks that we can't
explain. So what?
That doesn't imply that God spoke to you
at all
or that you're transmitting what God
spoke to you.
That's why Maimonides says this is the
basis of Moses' credibility.
And indeed, it's the basis of
credibility in prophecy altogether. Now,
that being the case, and Maimonides says
if somebody does a miracle, that does
not prove that he's a prophet. Why then
do we trust any later prophets?
Did Isaiah?
Did we hear God speaking to Isaiah?
Did we hear God speaking to Jeremiah?
To Ezekiel? To Amos?
To Joshua? To any of the later prophets?
The answer is no. We did not.
So, why do we accept them as prophets?
Maimonides has a radical idea here.
He says the only reason we trust that
anyone else is a prophet is because
Moses said to trust him.
Just like Moses speaking in God's name
told us to put on film, and keep kosher,
give charity,
Moses said, speaking in God's name, that
under certain conditions,
we should treat a person as a prophet.
If he's a righteous person,
and he's a scholar,
and
he
does miracles,
and he claims that God speaks to him,
tells us what God told him,
under those conditions, says Moses,
listen very carefully,
treat him as a prophet. Treat him as a
prophet. That's a law.
That's how I should behave.
Ask Maimonides, do I know that he's a
prophet? Says Maimonides, no. You don't
know that he's a prophet.
Any more than judges,
where witnesses come, and they say, "We
saw XYZ happen."
Ask Maimonides, when kosher witnesses,
who survived cross-examination,
tell the judge, "We saw XYZ happen.
Does the judge know that XYZ happened?
Does Maimonides? No, he does not know
that.
All he knows is there's a law.
The law says when people come and give
you testimony
and they survive cross-examination,
then decide the case on the basis of
their statement.
That's what you're supposed to do.
But you don't know that the events took
place.
So we don't know that Isaiah was a
prophet.
What we know is Moses told us to treat
him as a prophet.
What Moses says is binding.
That's what Maimonides says.
This means that the way in which we came
to experience Moses the prophet becomes
the source of all prophecy thereafter.
Without Moses as a basis,
there would be no other prophecy.
Now,
let's replay the scenario that I
mentioned briefly before
and I'll fill in a couple of pertinent
details and see how it comes out.
So-and-so says,
"I'm
a prophet. I come from God. I have
things to tell you."
Now, let's
imagine that he fulfilled the other
criteria in the case that I'm subtly
referring to wasn't true, but let's say
he did.
And the people say, "Well,
one of the things that Moses told us to
do was see whether he could do something
special." He says, "Oh, special?
Come with me to the park.
Come with me to the park. Watch while I
take a stroll on the lake."
I'm just making this up. You know, it's
just random. "Watch while I take a
stroll on the lake." Okay. Okay, let's
let's see.
And he strides out into the water
and he walks on the surface of the
water.
And we say to him, "Okay, Dad.
We're listening. What have you got to
say?" And he says, "First thing I want
to tell you is not everything Moses told
you is reliable.
Not everything Moses told you is
up-to-date.
Things have changed since then.
Not everything Moses told you is
applicable.
How are people going to respond?
What are they going to say?
What thought process is going to go
through their minds?
What they're going to say is,
"Listen, Dad.
We're listening to you. You have a
potential to have our ear
because Moses told us to do that."
The fact that you strolled on the lake
isn't interesting to us.
That doesn't imply anything to us.
The fact that you do miracles does not
says nothing about whether you're a
prophet or not.
We're not interested. Moses said, "When
a person meets certain conditions,
treat him as a prophet. Treat him as a
prophet."
You now are telling us that not
everything Moses says is reliable,
applicable, applicable, up-to-date, and
all the rest.
You just undercut your own authority.
The only reason I have to listen to you
is because I'm trusting Moses. You tell
me I can't trust Moses?
Then you have contradicted your own
authority to give a message.
And you're out.
That's one of the reasons that
Christianity was so dreadfully
unsuccessful in preaching to Jews.
Because you couldn't preach to to a Jew
in the name of God,
whether you called yourself God or not,
when we ourselves heard Moses prophecy.
We heard God speak to Moses.
And therefore we know from our own
experience that Moses is a prophet.
And anybody else's prophecy is is valid
only because Moses said to treat him as
a prophet.
And you now are telling us that Moses is
not reliable, then I have no reason to
listen to you whatsoever.
That's one of the reasons that the early
Christians were were very unsuccessful
in
influencing Jews.
So, the way in which
this prophecy at Sinai came
to to Moses and to the Jewish people is
absolutely crucial
for
the
credibility of the Torah forever. Are we
together so far?
I just want to tell you something.
Maybe someday
you'll have an opportunity to study in
detail.
Where the text says here you read and
they'll believe in you forever, I just
translated it the way
Even Ezra translates it.
Forever means in succeeding generations.
No one will come. You
You will be believed in. There'll always
be individuals who do things that are
not mentally normal, balanced, and sane.
But belief in you will continue forever.
What about
the rest of Moses' lifetime? Students
sometimes raise this question.
Okay, there was a revelation at Sinai.
And we heard God speaking to Moses and
and and God and and we know therefore
Moses is a genuine prophet.
But after that, a gigantic amount of
information came just for Moses.
After that, we didn't hear God speak.
How do we know
that at some future time
some future time, Moses didn't make up
some things on his own?
How do we know that he didn't
invent or subtract things on his own?
How do we know that it didn't happen?
Now,
I think there are two answers to this
question. One that I usually give and
then
one that Maimonides gives. You can bet
which one I think is superior. Right?
But I want to show you mine as a kind of
playoff to what Maimonides says. Look on
page 971. This is the end of the re-
repetition of the Ten Commandments
in Sefer Devarim, Deuteronomy.
Let's start with verse 19.
These words Hashem spoke to your entire
congregation on the mountain, in the
midst of the fire, cloud, and thick
cloud, a great voice never repeated.
And he inscribed them on two stone
tablets and gave them to me. By the way,
I have heard people ask, somehow,
somewhere, there's a false impression
that the people heard nothing.
Heard nothing. Everything came from
Moses. Moses went up the mountain, came
came down with everything.
There are at least six places where the
Torah is against that explicitly, and
this is one of them. These words Hashem
spoke to your entire congregation
on the mountain.
So, you you simply cannot
they didn't hear anything on their own.
Says so, word for word here.
It happened that when you heard the
voice in the midst of the darkness, the
mountain was burning with fire, that all
the heads of your tribes and your elders
approached me. Okay.
They've been through it. Now they come
to Moses and they say the following.
They said, "Behold,
Hashem our God has shown us His glory
and His greatness, and we've heard His
voice in the midst of the fire. This day
we saw that Hashem will speak to a
person and he can live."
Second time. So, He spoke to them.
But now,
why should we die
when this great fire consumes us?
If we continue to hear the voice of
Hashem our God any longer, we will die."
Uh
you may wonder,
"Aren't you contradicting yourself? You
just pointed out that you heard God
speaking and you lived. And now you're
saying we hear Him speak again, we're
going to die. We just saw that a person
can
hear God speak and live."
You can have an experience where you
survived,
but you know very well
that you survived by as what they say,
the skin of your teeth,
and that if it happened again, you would
almost certainly fail.
So,
you can have the experience of
surviving, but know that the survival
was so
precarious, so
thin, that you're quite certain that if
it happened again, you would certainly
lose.
Um
So, that's their fear. Their fear is
that if we have to go through this
again, we're going to die.
Uh uh 23 at the bottom of the page, "For
is there any
human that has heard the voice of God,
the living God, speaking from the midst
of the fires we have as we have lived
No one has ever had before. We did it.
We just barely made it. We're afraid
we're never going to make it again. You
should approach and hear whatever
Hashem, our God, will say.
And you should speak to us whatever
Hashem, our God, will speak to you. Then
we shall hear, we shall do. The people
are appointing Moses the intermediary.
It's their idea.
Now, I suggest to you that the following
scenario The following scenario is very,
very questionable.
The people hear God speak. They say to
Moses, "We can't take this anymore.
Please, you be the intermediary. You
hear from God and bring it to us."
Three years go by. Moses is giving
lectures. And then when Moses says, "No
cheeseburgers." "Ha! No cheeseburgers?
You made that up. You made that up. You
invented that. You have You want to
drive McDonald's out of business."
Excuse me. You put him in there.
You voted him in. He didn't ask for
this. God didn't dictate this. You put
him in there.
And now you don't trust him?
That doesn't sound honest.
You had proble- problems? You had a
worry? Then you should have gone through
with the whole the whole time with
yourselves.
So, I think that this is a very weak
position for Jewish people to be in. To
say, "No, later Moses lost it and so
forth and so on." If Moses was the kind
of person who could lose it, you
shouldn't have trusted him to be the
intermediary.
Maimonides has a very striking approach
here. And I must tell you,
I didn't think of this at all. If I had
read Maimonides for a thousand years, I
never would have thought of it. But the
Meshech Chochmah, the man who's the
author of the name of this Yeshiva,
there's a man
There's something that he brings.
Meshech Chochmah is a safer that he
wrote on Chumash.
An unbelievably sophisticated safer,
quoting from the Guide of the Perplexed
and the Zohar and every everywhere else.
He was a gigantic genius. He knew all
over.
In his introduction to the Book of
Exodus,
which in the Hebrew is only a few pages,
four five pages,
um he says,
"When it says they'll believe in you
forever, it means for the whole of your
life."
And since anyone who has free will,
you can't make such a a statement about.
And now the student he says, "Oho, I was
right. I was right.
What do you mean? How could you predict
that if you can trust him forever if he
has free will? Anyone with free will can
turn around. Anyone with free will can
fail."
Says the Meshech Chochmah,
Moses lost his free will.
That's why the Torah says you believe in
him forever,
cuz he lost his free will.
And if you look carefully at Maimonides,
this requires some careful reading,
which again, I didn't accomplish, but
Meshech Chochmah points it out and Rabbi
Eisenman, who taught me this, uh points
out, "It's quite clear because my my
Maimonides says among other things that
Moses became like an angel."
He became like an angel?
But doesn't that free you?
So, says
Meshech Chochmah, explaining Maimonides,
"That's why it can be guaranteed that
you'll believe in him, because you know
that from the revelation on,
he didn't have free will.
That's the guarantee.
That means the transmission is pure now.
Rabbi Maslow and I both recognized when
we read this that
after the revelation at Sinai, Moses
makes mistakes.
He does fail. There are several things
he does wrong.
The Meshech Chochmah doesn't address
that. So, I don't know exactly what he
means. We thought perhaps it means he
didn't have free will with respect to
transmitting the Torah. With respect to
other things, he might have had free
will.
We don't We didn't come to any agreed
understanding of of of that problem. But
that's what the Meshech Chochmah says.
The Rambam says it as well. He came like
a like a like an angel.
He retained in the state of being of the
revelation. And when you have
revelation,
then like that and
you don't have free will.
So, that being the case,
this revelation at Sinai becomes
the source of all the authority of all
prophecy. And it becomes the uh what
happened to Moses in the continuous
state that he was in becomes the reliab-
authority for reliability of the Torah
altogether.
Okay, are we together?
Okay. Now,
in the content,
there are those who use the 10
Commandments, the 10 pronouncements,
I'm sinning against my own
own rule.
The 10 10 pronouncements as an
encapsulated form of the 613
Commandments. Apparently, the Saadia
Gaon wrote a liturgical poem
for Shavuot,
which we have lost,
in which he actually classified all 613
Commandments
under the
uh rubric of uh
the the 10 pronouncements at Sinai. And
then those are reduced to the first two.
The first is
I am a sham your God,
whether it's belief or knowledge or
whatever. We'll talk about that in your
session. And the second is not to have
false gods in a certain sense. They're
encapsulated in those as well. So, these
10 are really
extremely fundamental. Also,
the commentators divide the 10 into five
governing our relationship with God and
five governing our relationship with
other people. Splits up first five and
second five.
Now, that split
needs a little bit of explanation.
The first five, you have
God's existence and not
serving other
not serving other gods, not serving
idols,
not taking God's name in vain in an
oath.
Shabbat.
Those sound okay.
They're governing our relationship with
God. The fifth is
honoring your parents.
Honoring your parents is not obviously
governing your relationship to God.
Honoring your parents sounds like
it's your relationship to other people,
particularly your parents.
Why would that go on the
man-God side of the division?
Well, one explanation is this.
Why is there an obligation
to honor your parents?
Easy. God told us to. Okay. Okay. Why
did he tell us to? What is there in the
parent-child relationship
that would, so to speak, give God an
interest
in our having special responsibilities
to our parents?
What do you say?
It's a sense that you can't
sort of have a honor for for your
parents who looked after you from birth
and
have raised you and sacrificed for you,
then how are you going to have a bigger
awareness of Hashem who created the
world for you?
You know, if you can't if you can't see
it from that small small scale of
honoring your your parents, you're not
going to you're not going to be able to
comprehend that Hashem created the world
for for for you.
Okay, let me say it over for the
recording, which I never remember to do.
And I'm just repeating that at the
moment. So, you're you're really talking
about the idea of gratitude. If you
can't have gratitude to your parents,
given all that they do for you, It's
more more than gratitude.
You know, that's on the
That's the basic I'm talking on
gratitude, but then it
it's that it's that awareness that
that
that everything that you you have is
ultimately because of them. So, it's
it's more than just gratitude of like
thank you. It's more like if it wasn't
for them, your existence wouldn't be
here.
Okay, but maybe there are two ideas
there and maybe that's going to help out
with the problem I'm going to raise.
But, let's start with gratitude. You say
it's more than gratitude, you are
agreeing that there is gratitude there.
Normally, a child owes it an enormous
debt of gratitude to his parents because
his parents provide him with an enormous
amount of benefit.
What happens in the case where it's not
so?
Let's suppose the conception took place
through a failure of contraception.
Which happens?
And
uh it's the parents would have
cheerfully had an abortion
but they didn't discover it till the
fifth month.
And then they were afraid to have an
abortion.
And immediately after the birth, the
parents abandoned the baby
with no thought to the baby's baby's
safety.
And the baby is picked up and raised
and someday discovers
who the parents are.
Hard to see there an obligation of
gratitude. Bringing him into existence
was an accident.
They would have prevented it if they
could.
And afterwards, they gave him nothing.
Hard to see as a matter of of gratitude.
Or
in even more horrible cases where the
parents victimize the child.
Caused the child psychological damage,
physical damage.
Hard to see there's any
obligation of gratitude
in a case like that.
Is there still a mitzvah of honoring
your parents when
there's no debt of gratitude?
Where the parents treated the child
criminally.
Violating the Torah's laws in treating
the child.
Is there any debt Is there any
obligation of of honoring the parents?
There's a difference of opinion about
it.
Let's consider the opinion that says
yes.
You still have to honor your parents.
Why would that be?
The answer now touches on the second
thing that you said.
But I would say just pushing it a little
further.
They are the reason why you exist.
Okay, but now
our existence ultimately isn't just a
happenstance.
It's just an accident. It means that the
creator used them
to bring you into existence.
They were the means that he chose
to bring you into existence. Then they
are
so to speak the locus of his activity in
bringing you to existence.
And that deserves honor.
That deserves respect because of
Hashem's involvement there.
It deserves honor and respect. This is
extension of an idea
which I
sort of knew about because I knew the
sources, but I didn't focus on it until
I read it
an essay by Rabbi Chaim Soloveitchik
whose essays and the parshas are
treasured in English.
And I recommend them to you.
They are very well written, very clearly
focused, very scholarly. Everything he
says based on a on a source.
Um I would say very original in certain
respect.
And they have a very great advantage
that they're very short.
Um and he has an essay there on what he
calls hakaras hatov,
which is normally translated as
gratitude.
And he brings examples of this sort of
charge to free. A very extreme. The
Talmud tells a story about
a man who was bitten by an arod. Arod is
some sort of poisonous creature, whether
it's a
reptile of some kind or a spider of some
kind. It's very poisonous. And the only
thing to do if you're bitten by an arod
is to run to a body of water and bathe
yourself.
So this guy is bitten by the arod. He
runs to body of water and wades out to
bathe himself. And what does he observe
but a person drowning?
So he goes and saves the person's life
and the person starts to thank him. He
says,
"Don't thank me, thank the arod.
Because it's because the arod bit me
that I came to
to wash and that's how I found you and
saved you."
Another example, Moses
after killing the Egyptian in Egypt,
runs for his life
and he comes to Midian and he saves the
daughters of Yisro from the local
shepherds.
And when they want to thank him,
he says, "Don't thank me, thank the
Egyptian who was beating the Jew whom I
killed,
which then
uh
caused Pharaoh to try to kill me and I
escaped and I ended up here. Thank the
Egyptian."
I don't think that that drowning fellow
in the Talmud story owes a debt of
gratitude to the arod.
I don't think that the daughters of
Yisro owe a debt of gratitude to that
Egyptian whom Moses killed. Gratitude
doesn't apply.
But it is this idea of tracing back the
circumstances
and taking account of every element that
God used
in bringing about this result.
That drowning fellow
is saved because God caused the arod to
bit this guy to bite this guy and then
this guy went to wash and saved his
life. So, the arod is in the chain of
events and you can see God's presence in
that arod leading to the chain of
events. I think really it's using that
chain of events to trace it back to God.
The same is true with
Moses when he says to the Egyptian the
Midianite
girls,
"That Egyptian was in the chain of
events. Of course, that Egyptian beating
the Jew and beating Jew as I came out of
the palace to see my brethren the Jews
and take care of them.
So, that was how God manipulated this
salvation for you. Similarly,
when a child is thrown away, happens
that parents
treat a child in such a way that he has
no great debt of gratitude.
Those who say there is still a
obligation of honoring those parents is
because God used them God used them in
their
in
in his chain of circumstances to bring
this child into into
existence and his honoring them is a way
of showing honor to God who used them as
those
tools. That's why it belongs on the man
God's side of the ledger.
Because that's really between man and
God. It's not between
uh
the child and his parents. Are we
together?
Okay, the same thing is true on the
other side. The 10th
of the commandments
which are supposed to be between man and
man.
The 10th is don't
uh
envy,
desire
things that belong to your
neighbor.
That's supposed to
envy or desire things that belong to my
neighbor.
Let's see.
I'm driving in uh
one of the suburbs of Johannesburg
which I have done several times.
They have great mansions there.
At least they were when I was there
last. Great mansions.
High walls with barbed wire and iron
response and people sitting outside with
submachine guns, you know. Okay, but
inside it's quite
fancy. And I'm looking to
buy a
winter resort so I can get out of the
freezing northern climates
which are
buried under ice and snow because of
global warming and to go to the southern
hemisphere and enjoy
January, February there.
So, I see one of these estates that's
really enchanting.
I go up to the door and knock on the
door of the owner and say, "You know,
um
I'm looking for a place and I'm a rich
American and you're a poor South African
so you have nothing.
I have everything.
Um
can I offer you
you know, $15,000?
$25,000 they're not worth much cuz
nobody wants to live there. $100,000 can
I offer you?
Am I violating a biblical commandment?
Biblical commandment?
Am I violating the prohibition against
desiring something that belongs to
somebody else?
Golly.
I didn't think I was doing anything
wrong.
I didn't know what I was doing was a
crime.
Vicious? Somehow immoral?
Now let's take it a step further.
Suppose the South African wants to sell
his estate
and he puts outside a for sale sign. Is
he tripping me up in violating a
biblical commandment? HE'S GOING TO
CAUSE ME TO TO to to desire his estate
and that way cause me to vi-
Is the whole of commerce somehow
viciously criminal?
You put out for sale sign for mugs.
Doesn't that cause you to want the mug
and
this sounds a little extreme.
Right?
So, there are those who say
of course you can desire what other
people have.
You only violate this commandment if you
make plans to get it
and start to put those plans into action
in some illicit way.
So,
hanging over this fellow's fireplace is
original
um
Dali.
Painted by Salvador Dali.
And I'm a Dali fan.
So, I offer him $237
million
for this painting.
He says,
"This painting is not for sale.
I love this painting. Besides, I heard
it from my grandfather. It's not going
anywhere." I said, "Oh, boy.
$237, and you said no?
Watch what's going to happen to you. I'm
going to get that painting. Either I get
earth-moving equipment and I hire a
couple of guys from Hamas to teach me
how to dig a really good tunnel,
invisible to the authorities on the
above, and I'll come under the tunnel
under his under his living room floor
and dig it up, or I will investigate
where he has his assets from, and I'll
cause that company to go bankrupt, and
I'll cause that estate to burn down, and
so on and so on.
I'll fix him to the point where he's got
to give it to me. Then, if I do that,
I retroactively violate
the prohibition against desiring
somebody else's object, also.
I violated both of them when I take
action to try to get it. Action to try
to get it illicitly.
So, that then becomes interpersonal.
Cuz now I've taken action to hurt him.
So, it's not just between me and God.
And that's how it can be restored. The
balance that balance is also between man
and man. You have a question? Yeah.
Where did he learn that
that it has to be up there?
Do you think he planned it to
do it in advance?
And he can't cuz he could learn how, but
it's still not happening in his mind.
All the desires or whatever
You know, that's something that I know.
I don't think so. Look,
I hear in your question
that as you
as you formulated it,
you began to feel maybe it was going a
little too far.
And that's why you used the vocabulary
at the end that isn't the ideal of how
we should be living.
Maybe it's not the ideal. That's not the
same thing as prohibiting each and every
case absolutely.
That doesn't tell me it's not an ideal.
That tells me it's always absolutely
wrong.
Now, sachmode in Hebrew is just
I really would like to have it. I really
want it.
Perfectly honest people can feel that
way.
So,
to
uh
prohibit that across the board as one of
the 10 pronouncements of Sinai,
if the person is completely committed to
only acting in legal ways,
is a little is a little extreme and it
will infringe on normal business
behavior.
We do have
We do have a principle of logic
which helps us interpret verses.
We don't just interpret I mean I'm I I'm
now
sort of trying to read your read your
mind a little bit, but if you don't have
this in mind, many people do. Many
people have the feeling
that the Torah told me to do it. Who am
I to make evaluations? Who am I to use
logic? God is infinite. I'm only finite.
I can't decide what the Torah means. My
job is just to follow.
Just follow. Turn your mind off and
follow.
But it's not correct. It's interestingly
not correct. Let me give you a very
dramatic example.
The Torah says the following words.
If one person's ox
gores
another person's ox and the second one
dies,
and the first ox
doesn't have a history of violence,
here's what you do.
You sell the live ox
and you sell the corpse of the dead ox
and the two people split the money.
What does that mean?
What is that What is that for?
Well, let's start with an assumption.
Let's assume that alive the two oxen
were of equal value.
$2,000 each.
Let's assume that the corpse of the The
ox
is worth $200.
So, if you sell the two of them, you get
$2,200.
Right? $2,200. Split it,
each one gets
$1,100. Right?
What's $1,100? Well, let's figure out.
The guy whose ox died,
what was his total loss? Think carefully
now.
The loss is 1,800 because he had a live
ox worth 2,000 and now he's a dead ox
worth 200.
Okay?
Now, he ends up with 1,100.
How much is he being compensated by the
other guy?
His loss was 1,800 because he had
possession of the
corpse,
which is worth
200.
At the end of dividing the money, he
ends up with 1,100. So, how much is he
being compensated by the other guy?
900.
He had 200 of his own.
If he ends up with 1,100, he's being
compensated 900.
His original loss was
1,800, and he's being compensated
900.
That's where we learned the law of Kansi
Nezik.
That someone who causes damage to
somebody else pays half of the damage.
If the animal causes the damage and the
animal is not known to be violent, so he
had no
direct obligation. Okay, I'm skipping
Kansi Nezik Kansi Nezik Kansi Nezik
Mamon.
Um
He had no obligation to to to guard the
animal. That being the case, he gets
paid half damages.
Are we good so far?
Ah, but we made an assumption.
We made an assumption that the two live
oxen
are worth the same amount.
What if they aren't worth the same
amount?
Let's try an extreme example. Suppose
the goaring remaining alive ox is worth
2,000,
and suppose the
dying ox
is worth
when it gets hit.
And the corpse is worth 100.
So then
when you sell the live and the and the
and the dead
you're going to get 2,100.
When you split it between them it's
going to be
1,050 each.
This guy had a live ox of
200 and now he ends up with 1,050?
Why is that?
He can make a gigantic profit on the
fact that his ox died.
Is that reasonable?
Now do it the other way.
The goring ox is worth 2,000. And the
dead ox is worth 5,000.
Okay.
So now and let's say the corpse is worth
500.
So
the
loss
of the
victim
is 4,500.
Right?
Now they sell
500 and 2,000
2,500 and they split and he ends up with
1,250.
With a loss of 4,500.
Is that reasonable?
Now here the super pious
tunnel vision personality says is it
fair? Is it good? Is it right? Who's
talking? Just human beings. You can't
use your concepts to judge God. You
can't use your criteria to judge God.
GOD SAID SO. FOLLOW GOD blindly to the
ends of the earth.
But that's not the halakha.
That's not the halakha.
The halakha is the verse is only talking
about oxen of equal value.
And therefore the verse is telling you
only the law of half damages.
And the law is half damages no matter
what the values of the oxen are.
Ultimately, the law is half damages.
That means that you won't carry out the
verses. You won't do what the verses
say.
If the
if the
values of the live oxen are not equal,
then you will not carry out what the
verse says. You will only pay half
damage.
Why? Because
it's just obviously wrong to do it that
way.
And Tosafot says there's no hint to
making this assumption in the verses
whatsoever.
No hint in the words that it's talking
about oxen equal value. Just it's not
logical.
Now, you could ask, "Well, then how do
you know where to use your logic and how
do you know where not?" That's a very
good question.
And I don't have a handy criterion for
telling you. I just tell you there are
many cases where the Torah is
interpreted using logic. And not only
that, but there are sometimes
differences of agree of opinion about
Rashi and Rabbenu Tam disagree in one
case about whether you should use logic
to interpret the verse or not. But it is
definitely a criterion. Of course, if
the Torah will explicitly contradict
your logical assumption, then you have
to give it up. But beyond that, when you
use it when you don't is a very
subtle matter, but you don't simply just
disregard logic. You don't simply turn
your back on logic. That's not That's
not what the Torah does.
Sometimes logic is overridden, but
but you don't just simply disregard it
on the grounds that you have to be.
So here also, if normal human economics
depends upon people wanting what other
people have and then making offers and
um
competitive sales and so on and so on.
The Torah's not going to prohibit that.
Uh that could be a just a obvious
observation.
And that being the case,
having said all of that,
only have a few minutes, let me um
handle a case for you, which might
seem contrary to what I'm saying and
then we'll we'll finish with that.
You know, probably all of you know that
if you lend money to a Jew,
you can't collect
interest.
Lend money to a non-Jew, you can.
Some think that's even recommended.
But you can't collect money from You
can't collect interest from a Jew.
Why is that? I want you to know
that in the Middle Ages,
Christians took on this idea also of not
lending money and collecting interest.
And therefore, if they needed a loan,
Christians were very un- unwilling to
lend their money cuz they lend you
money, you lose the use of it and you
gain nothing from it.
And they came to Jews to get loans. So,
there was this kind of
terrible
hate inferiority
complex where you have to come to the
hated Jew to borrow his money cuz you
can't get any money from a Christian.
And the crook the Jew is is
viciously criminal by taking interest,
but of course you have to pay him the
interest because
that's the way it was painted in the
Middle Ages.
Now, let me ask you a question.
Is there anything immoral about
taking interest on a loan?
Anything criminal, somehow
insensitive, less than fully fully
honest about taking interest on a loan?
I don't know. I was going to say was
there any reason that they did take the
interest? Was was that to cover
themselves that people were defaulting?
So, they had to make sure that they then
had enough say if they lent out to five
people Yeah. and only three of them paid
back, so the interest in three of them
would cover as if all five had paid
back.
I'm inclined to think that that's a
little too sanguine. It's a little too
forgiving. Uh the A stronger reason is
the fact that they were banned Jews were
banned from many of the professions.
They were banned to place to places for
owning land. How do you to a living?
Didn't people default on them as well?
Yeah, maybe so, but we're talking about
people who weren't running a free loan
society or running a loan society. I
mean, they were they were wealthy
people. It's one of the things they did.
At any rate,
let me ask you a question.
Avis Rent a Car.
What do they do? They have cars. They
own cars
and they charge people for using their
cars. Is that vicious? Somehow
underhanded? Somehow morally corrupt?
Uh you you go away for the summer and
you have a house and you rent your house
for the summer. Anything morally wrong
with renting out your house? Nothing
wrong with renting out your house.
Nothing wrong with renting out your
cars.
Why is there anything wrong with renting
out your money? You're just renting out
your money. You want to use my money. I
can't use it. Just like you want TO USE
MY CAR AND I can't use it. You want to
use my house and I can't use it. Why
shouldn't I charge you a fee for using
my money?
There is absolutely nothing wrong with
charging money for the use of your
money.
Why then
does the Torah prohibit
taking interest on a loan to another
Jew?
Because, as Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch
says, in this case and many other cases,
because the Jewish people is a family.
If your brother asks you for a loan,
then you don't take interest.
As a business matter, you'll take
interest. If your brother asks you for a
loan, you don't take interest.
And if you'll say, "Well, then how come
a Jew can rent his car to another Jew
and take money or he rents his house to
another Jew and take and and and take
money?" The answer is there has to be an
economic system between Jews. They have
to form an independent economic group.
But there has to be one symptom of the
fact that they're still a family. And
the truth is if you need a car and you
don't have enough money for a car, then
you can borrow money from me and get a
car. If you need a house, you don't have
a you can borrow money from me and get a
house. So, with the money you can get
the other things that you need.
So, here
the
the the
the starting point is the false logic
that something wrong with charging
interest. Once you get to the point that
charging interest is appropriate, so
then you have to explain why
it's you can't take it from the Jewish
people. Once you understand that we are
a family,
you understand that this is not a
question of justice, but a question of
sensitivity to a family. And this is
what the verse says. The verse says the
requirements of justice apply between
Jews and non-Jews. A Jew cannot treat a
non-Jew unjustly.
But the special
obligation that you have, remember the
family,
that is
built into the relationship between Jew
and Jew and explains many of the laws
that distinguish between how Jews treat
Jews versus how Jews treat non-Jews.
And by the way, that's built in the
title of the nation. We are called Bene
Israel.
Literally, Bene Israel means the
descendants of a man named Israel.
That's to emphasize the fact that we are
really a family.
Okay?
So, don't don't ever be persuaded that
your
logic and understanding should go on
holiday. That's not our That's not our
That's not our way.
Up next
24 recommendations shown