Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Praying at Graves of the Righteous: Myth vs Reality - Rabbi Eli Deutsch

889 views
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism avatar
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

Okay, so I figured we start off talking about kibrei tzaddikim praying at the graves of righteous people, which is often not discussed and worthwhile talking about cuz people have a lot of misconceptions about it. Firstly, we have to start off with a disclaimer. We are not praying to the tzaddik. We're not talking to the tzaddik, to the righteous person as if they are the source and the one who's totally in control the way Hashem, the way God is totally in control, right? Just like if you were to go to the Kotel, to the Western Wall, you're not talking to the wall, right? But we go there because it is a holy place. So similarly, it's taught in Kabbalah that the world was created in three dimensions, in the time, space, and being. And so whatever there is in time, there is in space. Whatever there is in space, there is in being, etc. etc. back and forth. And so just like in time, you have a holy time such as Shabbat, such as Rosh Chodesh, such as Rosh Hashanah, such as Yom Kippur, so also you have this in terms of space, in terms of location. For example, the Holy Land, you have Yerushalayim, you have the Kotel, for example, and the Temple Mount as well. And so also you have this in terms of being, in terms of the person, right? There's an aspect of the objective person who's uplifted, which is the concept of the Kohen, and then there's also the aspect of the person who has made of themselves to be great, right? The person who has been who has refined themselves to be holy. So just like there's an idea to pray in a holy spot, just like there's an idea that Shabbat is elevated, so also if we can connect to a person who is righteous, that's also uplifting for us as well. And when we're there, when we are speaking, when we are connecting to a righteous person, so we can we can on the one hand, we can talk to the righteous person as well. Just like you can go to a tzaddik, a righteous person who is alive for a blessing, you can also go to a righteous person who has left this world for a blessing of sorts as well, or to pray for you as well. Matter of fact, the Gemara teaches that more than a righteous person can do for us in this world when they are alive, they can do for us when they've left left this world. Why? Because they've left the physical constraints of this world, the lack of clarity that this world comes with. And in this manner, we're able to be in touch, we're able to communicate with someone who is a righteous person, and they're able to get bring us bless send blessings our way even more so than when the person was in this world. In a similar manner also, we can say that the righteous person as well can be looked at like we have actually a concept in Judaism called zechut avot, that we do things in the merit of our forefathers, and we can take the same concept and bridge it over to the concept of connecting to tzaddikim, righteous people as well. So, let's talk about this concept for a second. What does it look like to be connecting to our forefathers? So, it's kind of like imagine you have two people who were in business together, and after a number of years, after perhaps even a few decades, one of those two people passes away, and he leaves his business to his kid. But his kid was born a little bit with a silver spoon in their mouth. They did not have to work for it in the same way, and so they this the kid cuts corners, doesn't dot all the i's, does not cross all the t's in the same way that the father did. So, imagine the business the the other business partner says to the kid, "Listen, if you're anyone else, I would cut you out right now. But because of the relationship that I had with your father, so I'm willing to continue on the relationship and and let's see hopefully things will improve or um hopefully things will will get better. You'll you'll learn it a little bit more. So you see he extends him, he gives him a little bit more rope or he gives him more business even though if this was anyone else he wouldn't. Why? Because of the merits of his father. A similar idea we can say over here that even if we're not holding on the level in the of the in the merit of our forefathers, so there is Hashem goes ahead and and extends us so to speak extends us a little bit of rope or also get does favorable things in the merit of our forefathers, right? So similarly also this is an idea as well of having when we have a certain connection to a as well this also brings us to to be to have certain advantages if you will in the in the merit of our connection to him. Another idea of going to the graves of what do we want to be focused on? So there's a few options. Number one like we said we can be speaking to in a way of asking for blessings and also asking for that the should pray on our behalf should beseech Hashem on our behalf um and this is referred to also in certain sources in Judaism as being a heavenly for us. The truth is we can also do this with also family members that of ours that have passed away. Anyone who we have a connection to we can have we can ask them to be a heavenly advocate for us. Right? Additionally when we go to the graves of righteous people also there's an idea of connecting to the teachings of those righteous people connecting to their particular traits the their way of service of Hashem, right? They're different they're different characteristics and attributes, what they specialized in, what their emphasis was, is something that we are looking to connect with when we are at the graves of these righteous people. One more deeper idea about going to the grave of a tzaddik, of a righteous person, is something that's referred to as as ibur neshama, that when a person when we One one aspect of reincarnation that is often not discussed is >> [clears throat] >> is very different than the typical understanding. The idea of what's called ibur neshama, that when we are going to a a righteous person, it could very well be that the righteous person can connect with us temporarily, can come into us or be added to our neshama temporarily in order to give us an uplifting. And the more we open up a space for that, the more that can be the the more that something that the possibility of that is achieved. And when that happens, so then we can we on the we get an uplift, but also the righteous person has an opportunity to accomplish more in this world. Right? So even the righteous even though the righteous person has left this world to a certain extent, the righteous person is able to be involved in this world through their connection to us, which is a great opportunity because it's an opportunity to do more positive things, even though that this righteous person has already left this world. Um so questions asked, okay, well what about connecting with a righteous person even when you're not specifically at the kever, let's say, or not particularly at the gravesite. Let's say you can't make it or let's say it's a long journey. Um is there any is there any way or any value to connect to a righteous person without that? And of course the answer to that is yes, right? The we can also be conscious anywhere. Remember there's a concept of soul. A lot of times we think of souls as here or there. We start thinking physically about that which is spiritual. And so there is an aspect of relating to it from our physical perspective from our physical reality. And at the same time though also there is an aspect of connecting to tzaddikim no matter where you are. So yes, can I have a certain quote-unquote conversation? Can I speak to the to a tzaddik or to the neshama of a tzaddik anywhere? Yes, we can do that. And another way that is also helpful and advantageous is if we can also be connected to the ways of that tzaddik. Take on certain things that the tzaddik was emphasizing in his or her life. In this manner we are connecting to that tzaddik even when we are not in in in in the graveyard next to where that tzaddik is. And it's very worthwhile and important to to consider and to visualize and to have in mind that that tzaddik is standing there right there with me because of course that is the reality, right? So to have in mind that the tzaddik is there with you when you're speaking to the righteous person. People sometimes will ask of course where where this is sourced. So we we are familiar many people are familiar with the fact that this is that this is well spoken about in the chassidic world and definitely very much practiced in the world of chassidus. But the truth is this has this goes way back and certainly this is a practice from the tzaddikim from the righteous going all the way back. We find this in probably first we see this by Caleb when Caleb needed some divine assistance when he was sent as one of the spies. He went to Ma'arat Hamachpelah. He went to the Avot and the Imahot, the forefathers and foremothers in Hebron, in the Tomb of the Patriarchs, to pray to pray for his success and for his strength. Also, we find the other other person who the other righteous person who is sent as a spy at that time who made it out saying a good thing about the land of Israel was Yehoshua bin Nun. And he got good words and words of encouragement and positive positive things from Moshe himself, from Moses himself. Again, a tzaddik that was alive. And so And so we see from this that we can draw strength and there is something to this idea of praying by the graves of righteous people as well as connecting with righteous people. Now, also we find that so people will ask, "Well, hold on a second. So, why is it that sometimes we don't see this?" It would seem that over time we'd see it would seem that during during certain times in history with certain things within Judaism it would see that it would seem that over time in certain situations certain practices were de-emphasized for certain reasons. For this one, it would seem that with the advent of Christianity that probably there was a move in Judaism to de-emphasize certain things such as this in order to make a clear differentiation, a clear difference between Jewish practice and and what and what was Christian practice. However, certainly even throughout that entire time there were Mekubalim, there were Kabbalists, there were Tzadikim who practiced these kinds of avodahs, these kinds of spiritual paths and as well as also even writing about it. You find writings about it in the Maharal of Prague, you find writings about it in the Ramchal. So, before the times of Hasidus as well.