Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Did Holocaust Victims Die al Kiddush Hashem | Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz

1,676 views
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism avatar
Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

Many, many, many victims of the Holocaust uh died in the ovens in the crematoria. Actually, they were killed first, but they they were burnt in the crematoria of of of Auschwitz. Uh so, the question becomes, what about the spiritual suffering of the soul? People who die al Kiddush Hashem feel no pain in their death. They only get uh that connection to Hakadosh Baruch Hu. So, this in turn opens up a huge question whether Holocaust victims are classified as people who died al Kiddush Hashem and does it make a difference if they were religious or not religious? The typical paradigm of Kiddush Hashem is when a person is given a choice, like the go over to a person and say, "Convert to Christianity or I'll kill you." And I'm willing to say, "I am willing to die before I give up my worship of Hashem." That's called Kiddush Hashem. The problem with the Holocaust is that there was no element of choice there. So, there were Jews who were religious, of course. There were Jews who were not religious, but the common denominator was they didn't have a choice. >> [snorts] >> So, if you don't have a choice, where's the Kiddush Hashem in your death? Right? Is it Kiddush Hashem when you you didn't have the choice of renouncing God or accepting God? In a letter of the Rambam where the Rambam does say or might say that anyone who was killed because they're Jewish definitionally is classified as Kiddush Hashem.