Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
How could God let this happen? How
could this happen to us, God’s people,
on the holy day of rejoicing in God’s
Torah (Divine teaching), on the holy
day of the Sabbath, Shabbat (Sabbath)?
How could we get hit in such a way?
We have to understand: nothing happens
in this world without God. And so,
as hard as it is to understand, we believe in
God. We’ve been hit before, and ultimately,
it doesn’t affect our devotion and trust in
Hashem (God). And we have to address it now.
So, it’s no secret that we have
enemies that want to kill us. But
I want to come from a little bit of a
reverse angle here and say like this:
There are so many people—we see it now
coming to the forefront—that hate Jews,
hate Israel, anti-Semitism, anti-God when
it’s all said and done, because we’re,
after all, God’s people. We’re
just pawns on the board here.
It’s God’s board. If you hate us,
you’re hating God, the Creator.
When you look at the Bible, when you read
the Bible, you see something interesting
that you walk away with. Whether there are
happy stories or sad stories in the Bible,
it’s clear when reading the words
of a prophet who spoke for God:
the perspective we walk away with is that
everything that happened was from God.
Now, don’t be naive to think that when
these stories actually took place,
everybody walking around had this
God-consciousness that it’s all God,
it’s all God, everything’s for the good, ein
od milvado (there is nothing besides Him).
That’s not how the average
person walks around today,
and it’s not how the average
person walked around then either.
And so, what’s the difference between reading
the Bible and living through the
history that the Bible tells us?
It’s the perspective.
The Bible’s perspective—it’s impossible to
get that wrong. When you read the Bible,
you understand: God was not only
watching, but God was manifest and doing.
And therefore, when you read the Bible,
it strengthens your faith in God.
And of course, we’re far away from the
tragedies. So we say, why did the Jews
suffer? Why did God let a nation come
and kill the Jews throughout history,
when we were exiled? And even before that, even
in Israel, when sometimes we lost a battle,
even though the battle was a mitzvah
(commandment), a commandment to go
and take over that nation, we still
lost sometimes and had casualties.
Why?
When you read the Bible, you see that it’s because
God decided that He was not going to be with
us at that time. God withdrew His protection and
His miraculous supervision and providence from us.
And when He did, we were subject to the whims of
nature. And when we were outnumbered or
physically weaker, then it was manifest.
When we were successful was when God
said, “I’m with you.” And if I’m with you,
then everything’s with you,
and nothing could stop us.
Very interestingly, the very first battle that
took place when the Jews were coming
into Israel was the battle of Jericho.
We see clearly: God said to
Joshua, Yehoshua (Joshua),
“Go into Jericho and wage war with Jericho.”
This was the first battle coming in for
the conquest of Israel in the Torah,
and at the end of the Torah, in the beginning
of the Sefer Yehoshua (Book of Joshua).
And we see God said, “Go into that city. Go
around and circle the city one time a day,
and on the seventh day, circle it seven times, and
the city is going to be placed into your hands.”
We did nothing.
We circled, we blew the shofar
(ram’s horn), and trumpets,
and all of a sudden, the walls collapsed.
Everybody was afraid, and we conquered
that city without almost any real effort
and certainly no risk to even Jewish lives.
No, there were no casualties on our side.
This is when God is manifest with you,
for you, helping you miraculously.
So this was the first war experience.
The very next experience of battle was to
continue on our, at that point in time,
mission—commanded to repossess the land that
was promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
And so we went to the next battle, and all of
a sudden, this unstoppable army was stopped.
We started a simple battle, and before you knew
it, we were being killed. We had to retreat,
and we ran away, with, as the expression
goes, our tails between our legs.
And the spirit of the entire
people was in downfall.
How could that be?
The people that are supposed to
come in and repossess this land
that’s supposed to be our land—and
we can’t even win the second battle?
We would have given up and run
away. You know, what is this?
So God makes it very clear. And
when you read the Bible, you see it.
God says, “Because I was not
with you today in battle,
because you turned against Me,
and I turned away from you.”
And in this particular context,
it’s insane when you read the reason
why. It’s all there in the Bible.
It’s because one person took from the consecrated
objects—gold, whatever—and took it for himself.
In the first battle of Jericho, everything
was meant to be consecrated to God. And
so one person was greedy for
money, for gold, and took it.
And because one person sinned, God removed His
providence and protection from the entire nation.
And people that were not even
guilty of the theft—people
that were not even guilty of betraying
God—because we were part of one nation,
were then subject to this attack and murdered
in that battle, or killed in that battle.
And when you look at the story,
you’re like, “How could this be?”
The wicked man sins, and the righteous
man pays the price and is killed.
How is that fair?
One person sinned, and the other person is
punished. That doesn’t seem to make any sense.
And so, from here, it’s explained
that because the Jewish people are
like one spiritual entity, when
we’re connected, the good we do,
everyone benefits from—and unfortunately,
the bad we do, we’re all subject to.
So what happened is, because one person failed,
Hashem (God) removed Himself from
protecting the entire people.
Now, it’s very important to get this clear.
There are two ways to understand what happened.
And with this, we’re going to come to October 7th.
The mistake would be to say that God, who is
the Judge of all the world and does justice,
would actively punish person
B for a sin that person A did.
That’s impossible. That would never happen.
It’s just like the Torah says: a child
doesn’t pay for the sins of the father,
nor does a father pay for the sins of the
child. Each person pays for his own sin.
So how do we explain what happened?
That one person sinned, and another person, and
other people, were killed in battle because of it.
So the real simple answer is this:
There’s the idea of God showing
His countenance toward us,
revealing His presence, that
He’s with us, protecting us,
and being involved in the providence of
what happens to us in a particular way.
And that’s what happened in the first battle.
So all God really does in the second
battle—He doesn’t decree that anyone
should die. He doesn’t say, “I’m
going to punish all of you and kill
all of you because person A got Me upset, and
therefore the judgment is that I’m going to…”
No.
We have a simple reaction, so to speak, from God:
“I’m going to step back.
I was invested. I was involved.
I was one of—I was with you in
the fight. I was in front of you in the battle.
All I’m going to do right now, after this—where
you didn’t follow properly My ways—is step back.
And you’re on your own.”
And so, when we understand that there’s a certain
type of providence that’s built off of inactivity
on God’s part—inactivity and strict judgment—we
understand that there are two modes of judgment.
One is a more loving and
forgiving mode of judgment.
One is a more strict, demanding judgment.
And so He’s now being more strict
with us and saying like this:
“You don’t deserve My protection. You don’t
deserve My extra involvement. You’re going
to go fight a war tomorrow. You’re going
to fight a battle. You’re on your own.”
And when that happened, the army
that went out to attack the next
city on their own wasn’t strong enough. They
weren’t strong enough to defeat their enemy.
In fact, they were weak, and they were killed.
And we had—they had to run away, and
many of the Jewish soldiers were killed.
But that wasn’t God killing them.
That was God stepping back and saying,
“I’m not protecting you today.”
Okay.
So now let’s look at October 7th.
And it comes back to the first thing I said.
People ask, “How could that happen?
How could such a thing happen to us?”
So I’ll ask the other question:
How come it didn’t happen before?
How come it hasn’t happened ten times,
fifty times, from our enemies that
would love to do this on a daily basis?
Sick, you know, animals full of hate.
The answer is because all those
other times God was protecting us.
God said no.
There are verses in Tehillim (Psalms):
the nations make plans of how they’re
going to destroy us, how they’re going to
attack us, how they’re going to kill us.
And God comes and disrupts all of those
plans and doesn’t let them happen.
But that’s God stopping it from happening.
But then we can, unfortunately, be in a position
in our relationship between us and God where God
says, “Okay, I’m not protecting you
today. And let’s see what happens.”
And that’s one way to understand
what happened on the 7th of October.
God said, because of this decision by God as
this stricter judgment—maybe because of our
behavior—we all have to figure out what we were
doing wrong that we were vulnerable on that day.
It’s called, in more traditional
terminology, hester panim (the
hiding of God’s countenance)—God is going to
hide His countenance, hide His protection,
hide His providence from us, and we’re
going to be, so to speak, on our own.
And then that could be a very simple
answer as to what happened, right?
What happened is that those evil people
were allowed to then bring their schemes
to fruition and actualize them because
God said, “Today I’m not stopping them.”
And that’s tragic.
And again, it’s hard.
And I’m not saying that I’ve solved
our problem. I’m not saying, “Okay,
great. Now let’s go home and be happy.”
No.
Why did God do that?
Why?
How could God decide not to protect us from those
ruthless, evil enemies of God and of God’s people?
How could He let that happen?
And so we have to go one step
further and understand that
there’s a right and a left hand
to the way God runs this world.
There’s a punishing hand,
and there’s a loving hand.
There’s a providence that loves, and there’s
a providence that punishes, that is strict.
And somehow, our actions
below cause a response above.
There’s a very, very well-known
saying: the way we act here in this
world will cause the Divine judgment
above to mimic that on some level.
That means if we’re going to be benevolent, if
we’re going to be loving and kind and create
unity and brotherly love, and build and
help each other—if we’re going to behave,
if we’re going to get along—then God
above, the spiritual manifestation
of God’s involvement in our world,
and our judgment, is with a smile.
It’s with love.
That’s how you’re behaving below.
That’s how I’m going to behave above.
When we’re the opposite, unfortunately—if we’re
hateful, spiteful, hurting each other, destroying
each other, when there’s fighting and when there’s
hate here—so then we awaken that reaction above.
And so the wrath of God’s judgment,
which is one of the modes of how
He judges us, can become ignited.
Now, again, I’m not trying to
blame anyone—certainly not any
one type of people, and not even us as a people.
Because ultimately—and I’ll preface
this with whatever I’m going to say
that follows—we’re all trying, on
some level, to do the best we can.
If I fall into anger and start
yelling and screaming at somebody,
it’s not that I hate that person from the bottom
of my heart. It’s not that I’m a cruel person.
It’s that life is hard, and we’re
emotional, and we’re unstable.
And so we don’t mean to do some of the harsh,
tragic things that we do to each other.
But nonetheless, we’re doing it.
And so let’s now look at
the other side of the coin.
Israel and the Jewish people, civilians in Israel,
were reaching almost a point where it
seemed to all of us watching the news,
listening to the reports, even just living
here, almost to a point of no return.
Think about where things reached.
I was amazed—but thankful, but
amazed—that it hadn’t reached
violence so much and it hadn’t
reached the loss of Jewish lives.
But I think we were not so many steps away from,
God forbid, beginning to almost kill each other.
Okay?
And that can never be.
That can never be.
I’m not blaming any one side because it takes
two sides to have a fight and two sides to hate.
It might take one side to start a fight,
but it takes two sides to have a fight.
So I’m not accusing any one side
and vindicating any other side.
That perhaps can be explored
at another time, but not now.
Right now, we’re saying like this:
What was the problem, and
what could be the solution?
We said, what could we do?
We could strengthen our faith.
We can pray for one another and
we can believe in one another.
We can love one another.
We can help one another.
That’s what we can start to do now
to rectify what possibly—and again,
I’m only speaking, I’m not a prophet yet—I
can only speak about what we possibly can do,
almost logically, and certainly to help
our standing in the eyes of God improve.
And if our standing in the eyes of God improves,
then we’ll see more of God’s manifestation
of loving-kindness and protection.
And that’s exactly what we said with the Bible.
That’s what the Bible shows us.
Don’t look at the stories
like it’s random history.
The stories are God’s stories.
God is behind, in between the lines.
He’s there, really doing everything.
And sometimes doing everything means giving us our
space so that we can do our part and
become partners with Him in creation.
Sometimes it means giving us space
because He’s punishing us and saying,
“You don’t deserve My protection.”
And unfortunately, we see what can happen.
October 7th.
Hitler and Nazi Germany, the Romans, the Greeks,
the Russians—they’re not such saints either.
You know, the people from Ukraine, generations
ago, murdered Jews like it was a golf activity.
You know, “Go, let’s murder some Jews.”
Pogroms (organized violent attacks
against Jews)—anytime they got upset
and angry because they weren’t happy with
their lives, so they take it out on who?
Take it out on the Jew.
So we’re not dealing with saints around the world.
You know, it’s funny.
The world is very conveniently trying
to define and label us as the devil.
Does this look like the devil to you?
We’re not the devil.
It’s the same anti-Semitic hate
for something and someone that’s
different from you and that is maybe
sometimes more successful than you.
That is why the entire world is
turning against a little dot.
You know how many times you
have to blow up the screen,
have to zoom in, until you can even
see Israel beyond all that green?
It’s sick, and it’s sad, that
these people call themselves
people that think that they’re using their head.
But that’s a discussion again for another time.
I told you, I told you—you can get
angry. You can start also to hate.
That’s what they want.
Hate breeds hate.
But that’s not our way.
We’ve always chosen life,
and that’s why we’re living.
And that’s also another answer to what we can do.
We have to do.
The only thing we really can do is
pick ourselves up, if we’re able to,
when we’re able to, and continue living.
Because everyone else out there that’s choosing
to kill and to hate—they’re not living anymore.
They’re stealing away their own
life and their own blessing.
And we see where that leads to.
Every society and every people
that have ever come to try to
kill us or destroy us are not here anymore.
So, what do you think is going to happen this
round, in this boxing match, round twelve?
What do you think is going to happen?
Who’s going to be standing at the end of this
final round of this boxing match of
hate and love, of goodness and evil?
Who do you think is going
to be standing at the end?
Iran?
That’s who’s going to be standing at the end?
Hamas?
They’re going to get the gold medal?
No.
We’re going to be standing at the end, because
as we stood from the beginning—and again,
everything that’s happening
is between us and our God.
It’s an internal thing.
They think that they’re better
than us because God gave us a
slap in the face, gave us a wake-up call.
They’re not any better than us.
They’re guilty in every country of raping,
murdering, kidnapping, human trafficking.
Just look at the news.
They don’t make the papers like Israel does.
But for simply defending ourselves
against annihilation, we’re the devil?
And again, that’s not the
main point of our discussion.
I made a point about it, but it’s hard to
escape the emotions and the unfairness.
But that’s dropping to a lower level.
Let’s read the Bible of today,
not the headlines of today.