Hagbah and Gelilah: The importance of it being done correctly - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

I gave a few extra minutes over here to be able to the fruits thank you very much for being appreciated some asked in the previous year I spoke about maybe was even on so a different opportunity we're learning obviously is when you lean there many was spending a few months going through properly the in the previous year we saw that besides the itself there's also before the after and tonight's year I want to focus on something else that's also not the C itself something that's Rel depending on the minic either before or after anybody the text didn't go out very good today going to focus just Ong and there'll be a future she as we mentioned hag some have the before the brings before because you do before obviously to close up the everybody does afterwards but the brings it earlier the by is to do it later what's the others we'll go into it a little bit more maybe in the next shaba what's the to do has nothing to do in the we'll see what's the says toi alsoi and the ran on in on the the last or so the said says in the secondat he says that theat is it's it's referring to somebody who doesn't pick up the sa and we'll go through somebody who's not of them that's what the is speaking about this this this um this horror says the of that we're going to speak about quoted in the valid B the of but to plug it in to the in the what does it mean is falling what does it mean so the Caron explains you're supposed to pick up the what's you pick up the and you show everybody what we just read you show you show the of the we're going to go through is hag it's it's on the also but it's on the it's referring to somebody who doesn't do so very interesting brings a story of a town that they didn't do there a not do he says it's I looked it over a few times meaning to say is that it isn't even a sometimes you can learn it's but it's it's not even a it's it's a it's a he continues on to be Matic why they didn't do it we'll get to it soon we'll go into it a little bit but even if no one was able to do it it was too heavy of a safe but before that what say is like thisa if the is that it's going to fall down so even if it's a even if it's a you can't do it we'll get to it soon he says that there isn't even a on thean how he learns he says that the but it's not but from the is clear that it's not a maybe maybe the whole that we're going to be speaking about tonight it's a very interesting CH speaks about when he made he gave in a so he was asked why when he made when he wrote the he made sure that the the CL were sewn together and also connected to the to the poles at the end of the twofold first of all like what's with with threads you attach it with threads as we see in our there's also like a piece of cloth that attaches maybe it looks a little bit like a band it attaches one armor to the next so in the TRU he he they asked him like where's this what are you doing both why says the following he says that's how he ends off and he says being that say I want to make sure and be careful that when you pick up the it should be strong not just with also with the CL it should be fast it's recorded in the more than once fell down because it got detached either both sides fell or even just one side fell it fell off it got detached so says want he doesn't bring that but he says that's why I did a double he says that however however you learn if it's it's a that's it's in other places as well also that if you can't do like you said before is gonna fall down you don't do it doesn't mean that you don't Lane you take out the and you're Lan and you don't do you don't do fall but interesting the brings he says sometimes it's hard to do ha you have a big sa you're holding vious you're holding the whole weight is on one so you can't do it so he says only otherwise it's you could roll the to the middle you could do HBA if the is regardless heavy and no one could do H you don't do it but you if you could figure it out by being to the middle you do it it's it's coming up now take a even though and it's pretty close by not to be here he says to be able to do you can be what you say not show what you oh oh so I wanted to get to it to where's the where does it say that where does it bring that you have to show Da what you read he just says you bring it up now we'll speak about it right now I couldn't find could there is a but if you have to hit the only problem is being is that why you being you should show what you read have people doing together interesting here why t not two people to do it we'll speak about it in the next year about splitting the H and Thea technically it's really one it's really one H we split it and then there's another ke it's not found so much but us the person that brings the the M the G brings that that's also brought but you say even the itself split it two people but if you can't interesting AA interesting that also how do you dogba when you pick up the say how do you dogba so it's what direction you're supposed to do a lot of say when you pick up the it's supposed to be facing outward understanding for us in our terms is what we do you pick up the say facing facing outwards that's talking a minut the when they show it facing it outwards and the reason the reason why to do it is cu when you pick it up if you pick up the way do you pick up the you're blocking you're blocking the good can pick it up very high up you're blocking that's one of the reasons why to face outwards to say it's not the way we do it but the pick up the and have the outwards they M their and like you could maybe say that even if you do it picking it up facing to you it's also behind you but they M he's M to say from that when you pick it up you're facing it outwards away from you the brings that the Min is not to do that the Min is to have it facing towards the mag facing towards the magia I saw but then I I couldn't find it afterwards the is is because to turn it around could be it's hard it's hard we see in a second that speaks about it that do only that you're sure you could do it safely without it falling say it's definitely harder to switch it around that's the reason the B says the Min is to pick it up in the way that it's facing the person who picks up the sa however even let's call it the that face when you pick up the you sees you could see the however the is to have the facing outwards away from the mag brings already the minut like that and these many reasons many bring the I didn't see this reason inside of the they bring to turn around to say before you pick it up you turn it around doesn't what say yeah does help meaning to say is you're saying if you're blocking you open it more the EM is is that you could also lift it a little higher above you also not the block and also when you turn around even if you just do three Amud on the side you can see yeahi the way let's call we do it it's you could see it's as much as there's a little bit blocking you can see on the side of the one of the reasons why other reasons is because to show to make a statement that this is the that that we read now was this is the that gave us or because it says that it's and to make a big deal out of it there's a lot of everybody gets an so it's always it's 78 n Al but over here it's the whole everybody was that's you turn it around you make as out of it but the say that it's only for the of maybe bous also but not ma ma you don't most a lot of places Turn Around by both all these reasons all the the reason of these are reasons and also from the but the is also to switch around bous not to switch around the ma good so we have over here you're going to be M show it to everybody what's the how do you do it how do you show it to everybody so the and it's also says how do you show it to everybody right to the left to the front to the back basically with a clarite everybody's supposed to see the so how how do you do it to the right to the left the Miss brings that when you start showing people you're facing M right you're fa you're standing by you're facing M you go to D towards d d is like the says po should a right so you're facing if you're facing misra you turn to the right you turn to the right buta when you turn to the right to the to the doram interesting who's the first people that see the have the smile the is that you first the people that see it you show it that's oh very good very good very good good good very good if it's outside if you turn to the right and talk to the people on the right see first but if you turn to the right but the inside the people on the left see first so how how do you how do you accomplish that everybody should see so these different that speak about what's exactly the Min turn to the right turn to the left in sh says these no CL the I is that everybody should see he says there's no circling these what happens if you're in a Sho it's a very thin narrow Sho everybody's behind the you pick up the sa and everybody could see there's no you have to circle around and go and go ah just make sure that everybody sees that's that's the brings that the the way he did it he picked it up like what says to the right and then he made a full circle and that's it so everybody saw being that theba we pick up the and pick up to be but you pick up the the of that you should be able to see it and like we just said you turn around you make sure everybody sees it and if everybody's standing right behind the sa you don't have to turn anywhere but you make sure that everybody should see it shim therefore the hgba has a respon the one who gets hgba has a responsibility to make sure that he does it you pick up and you do it quick and you know you people miss it so you're taking away it's not just the D that you pick it up and once you're picking it up let people see the whole picking up is so people should be able to see so do it slowly is there a they still have to walk up and see it if they're too far away or maybe you should walk around with the you're asking good how much do you have to go from far to close it's a good shil last week last year I spoke about to walk towards the says clearly doesn't mean to walk up all the way to the safe of of all the people it's a good child you're asking but how much to have do you have to strain yourself to be able to see brings from that when a person sees when he sees answer says that it's it's good to get you know involved to tap into the but a person should be careful from you in other words I'm not answering you shly it doesn't say that people from far away don't have to see it but get very intense that's uh for people that are under madrea not it's not for everybody again you're asking if a person's far how close to see it's a good the Ben says that there's a Mila for a person to be able to see brings that you should try to see in the the first letter from your name yeah if your name's aam try to see an Alf I didn't see that these re these you should see what what was laned frat let's say you laye on a Monday and a Thursday on one and then we're going to see more supposed to be on the on the seam where it's connected so either the go what he go rolls and rolls and rolls till he gets where the seam is or the H ready he rolls to where the SE where the two cloths are connected he picks it up over there so that's that you don't have what you just laay now like we mentioned before from the that says you can move to the middle of the he says not to do it you shouldn't do it if they didn't to show what you just laed you shouldn't do it speaking about looking at the looking at the of the the says that is not supposed to go on she shouldn't go on that's not the however what the is yes and brings it B even if she does go not to look at the of the during during specifically what' you say you mean technically looking down during the whole brings the SM on the that says of going not to go to but he says maybe what the even anytime maybe any other time how would she even see but there wasn't a second floor looking down that's from the IR a few more what say looking you say being to connect I don't I don't I hear we'll see a we'll see a bit more talking about Yan or it's cabala these everything these inan and everything there's another nuda during ha there's a few more let's called B the one [Music] who besides that you're supposed to look at the sa to see the he's supposed to stand up he's supposed to stand during HBA now even though it's not so POS even though when the moving supposed to stand up that's that's the whole so to speak by by dancing the is moving you should be standing that's not the discussion however if the is not moving you do not have to stand that's why when the is open is open is the same thing the is the is to stand what comes out is is not moving whatever it's the person in one place do not have to stand the says that only the people that are on the beima everybody else in the sh doesn't have to stack because they're a different however the brings it says that everybody supposed to stand you have to stand why since to show the stand stand talking abouta says even though you shouldn't have to stand during why because is not moving I want to read the lotion inside once they bring on the bottom in the once during the said what you have to stand no first of all the sa is not moving even if you consider it moving during but that's only the people on the be off the be why because while so he says but he says that's why you have to stand you have to stand by there's another says you're supposed to Bow you're supposed to Bow we spoke about it last by the last year I'm just going to say very says we don't find such a thing and he says you are maybe not but you are there are times that you B to one more one more nuda during hgba while you look at the O in the at that time sh says while you see the OAS cuz sometimes told the to you while you see the you're supposed to say then there's another part that's not brought in the it's the beginning of it's another piece of a elsewhere the of the a few more multiple different you say just to focus M for a half a minute on this other we're not going to go on this that a lot of but what a lot of says other piece that's a half a these multiple kasas multiple his son in the as well first of all it's not it's a half a the gar says you not you can't just stop say half a what's the combination between the two what what connection you taking from how you connected what's and the EM is that the the bat doesn't have it and S have it and they have the whole p in the you look some of them some have it in parentheses some have it even not in parentheses but they have the p and they have the whole so at least it's you can't just say half a the sh is how does this second come in how does it how does it come in so y La he says y says that the second part of is referring toed we find in other places also in the BR a lot of different places we find that we make sure to say that t has the same important as well connected those that that only believe in we just made a big deal in we just lay but we want to say it loud and clear that gave over what's not written says how does coming right after he says yeah we just laid in the this is also to say that we don't there's no yet to say it is it's referring to just to conclude we just said all of this is learned out it's a that's learned out from the says that even though the only brings all the the says that was half of half AO and every had a so we just went through now the some of the in if you have the opportunity to be to do and to do it right we have