Gemarah Pesachim 7b - The Fascinating Story of "Ezra's Immersion"

the yeshiva dotnet says the gemara the Kula Alemannia make our rabinin lavrukhin everybody holds whether you hold Livia Alby reverie buddy holds that the broker has to be make RMA Cara means before in the beginning before you do the Mitzvah that everybody agrees with the question is what should be the broker ruff puppy said Lafayette and riff Papa said al beer how do you see everybody agrees because we see clearly that the Gemara explained that everyone holds that it has to be La Habra it has to be for the future the question is what makes it La Havas or a puppy said Lee and if Papa said al but obviously everybody held that you focusing on the future the question is how to describe that so is it lit or Al frag the Gemara be Nolan what's the source for this like what's the premise why is what who made this premise that a Brock has to be said before the Mitzvah Dahmer abhidharma Shmuel if you descent in the name of Shmuel says the Gemara Cola Mitzvah suave Oracle a novella see also all the mitzvos a person ought to make abraca Boyer adazi Austin a velocity Asin means before they're done the blessing always must precede the implementation of the Mitzvah Oh Iver means before the hacia before the action not a long time before right before that SIA you make the brach that's what to be older taught in the name of slaw frag the Gemara he says over he doesn't say koi them isn't working over my marsh mother hi / listener dr. DiMaio how do you know that the word / represents before says all the Mitzvah see make abraha / lasse awesome so we said it means before that's what we're trying to bring out but whether you see the word / that it means before / means pass over like what it over lousy awesome I'm Maria blocker my Itskov the unmarked car of national assembly that said amakura the posix says this is the PASOK in small Bayes small to chapter you test chapter 18 and the background behind the story is Dava de Mello had a son whose name was off Shaolin half Shalem staged a very vicious heinous and successful rebellion against his father he tried to usurp the kingdom and of it was forced to flee the palace and yerushalayim from the wrath of his son who wanted to kill his father at the end it turned out that dove its side was victorious and after l'm was ultimately killed he was riding on his donkey and his hair got stuck of Solomon's very very long here and his hair got stuck in the bushes and the branches of a tree and his horse his horse as his horse continued running and he remained hanging and one of David's men came and killed off solemn and the rebellion and the mutiny was silenced and of it dove it was saved let's destroy we learn enough so the passage says he quotes the posix via rats Ashley Mardell haqiqa man named Archie Mars ran there is a kicker through the plain via VAR s a cushy VY average the keyword biographies he passed before the coup Shiite as Rashi says ever come I carried them ivory means before come IV avarice a cushy Cod may be missus of shala he wanted to be the first one to tell David the good news good quote unquote that the one who rebelled against him his own son of Shalom was killed so the crew Shiite was about to go to tailed of it and now he mots by a ver he he he passes but what cloudy passes like with the car yeah he wanted to get in front of him so by Yahweh he got in front of in front of the cauchy two-tailed Ovid the news of course the response of dove it was not what everybody expected of it broke down sobbing eight times he spoke about his son his son I wish I would have died I would have died instead of you even though this son tried to kill him but nonetheless dove its love Tov solemn came out and to the point and his general said to him that this is really not good because you're destroying the morale because everybody who's been fighting of Shaolin now sees how sad you are it's really not gonna help the future of this government it's interesting the primal leverage was the receiver of Mir and one of his students and relatives told me that he would go very often - Davin at the yadhav Shaolin it's not a place where people go so she would go there and he would say that why I've shelled them because I've shelled them did the worst things to dove it but nonetheless it was his child because it was a struggle the love remained very very intact that was unconditional I'm the only unconditional despite the relative shallow wanted a murdered of it the affection that of it had to have Shalom remained to the point that he wished that he would have died instead of our Shalom he said it's a very good place to Darwin to tell God no matter what the love to a child is unconditional and absolute no on his own so the Gemara says that this is how you know that ever means before now it's a very strange Gamora who said the word over Shmuel Shmuel isn't a murderer be hood in the name of schmoes so the Gemara is now explaining the words from an admirer based on a word in Tanakh usually you want to understand what a word in Tamil means so you bring different proofs here it's an interesting thing when our murder says a word he could have said a different word he used the word are you very so I'm saying what did he mean by the word ivory we'll see from that I want to used and they find this passage by avarice Akash it's very interesting ah oh yeah trying to prove what it means yet the beginning of Sock'em exactly we won't know what the time that means when it says oil and what sure meant when you use the word over yet in the Gemara itself yeah tanah Merah yeah and I might know nobody's arguing with small yeah yeah yeah nobody's arguing with small yeah watch small meant with the word over uh if it means before yeah yeah yeah i buy your my bias as my haka there's another pasa safer voracious bashes my Ashla who of arleth mayhem what happens is a sub is coming to Yaakov with 400 troops Yaakov sets up he separates the two camps and he has his wives and all of the children and then it says for who and he of our life Nahum what does oval Afeni means he passed before them and he bowed down to ace of seven times so the word over again means he passed ahead of them before them so I realize see us it means you pass ahead of the mitzvah doesn't mean you pass over the Mitzvah boy every means you make a brush over you before the Mitzvah you run ahead before the Mitzvah to make Abraha not after the Bravo or middle of the Mitzvah the boy same another way of proving this of the deucing this is Mahakala from a third verse in the safer of me huh the Navi Micah chapter Bishop Eric base speaks about the time of BS Amish aha machine comes and the PASOK says just to quote the context carbides accomplished ABC strong terms I'm going to gather all the remainder of the Jewish people via ver Malcolm with Nahum varsham duration and their King Malcolm a Shia Malcolm their King will pass via ver will pass before the Jewish people mushiya will go ahead of the Jewish people he will lead them for Hashem Barossa says my Evert Malcolm lifts Nahum lactam Leila's bearish their king mushiya will again lead them he will go at the head he will lead them he will pass before them from all these sukham from the first parsec via various a cushy in small base from the second pass second my you schlock woohoo over Laflamme and from the third pass second mija by a ver Malkin barium we can clearly see that the word over can also represent the meaning of doing something before so when SH wall said kilometres of Oracle in over la see us and all the minstrels you make abraca are you very lousy us and it means before you do the action and that's why it's so important to have the right text which denotes that you're going to do the Mitzvah in the future it was not yet done I'm sorry what'd you say oh man I'm a haka Lloyd I'll call you I'm shy of Allah Shah so give me Nicola yard you mean middle of the shear beautiful Thursday morning it's actually a great day to happen yet all of sharat whatever a better day huh before the snowstorm yeah and before the barbecue and before breakfast all the mitzvahs can't believe name but the meats are for lighting is always after so so so here we'll also order both so without the minutes because the shop is my personal life and then say bro that's a very good question on Shabbos the broth is made after you light the candles not before you light the candles that's a wonderful question the answer for that is I'm gonna see now a few details connected to this issue but generally speaking when it comes to Shabbos the problem is as follows when you make the bracha we'll have the commercial Shabbos dish according to many it's accepting Shabbos Kabbalah Shabbos once she accepted Shabbos on herself she won't be able to light the candle that's why she likes the candle before she makes the bra on the other hand you'll see the mimic by most women is to light the candle and then they'll go like this their eyes make the bracha and then they'll open their eyes and the reason for that is for this very reason because even though they lift a candle they shouldn't yet enjoy the light and remember also lighting Shabbos candles happened at a time the hazael instituted it a couple years before Thomas Edison so when you came into your house on Friday night if there were no candles you didn't come in to a house that's lit up with fluorescent lights or lamps or other lights it was pitch dark which is why the hazael instituted the minister of lighting Shabbos candles because since it was the only day of the week where there was a mitzvah to have a meal at night on Shabbos make a dish and have a meal and people would literally sit in the dark we don't appreciate what Shabbos candles really is because we live in a time when we have other sources of light at night the midst of Shabbos of Nayer Shabbos it was for her nose for Shalom bias it should be peace in the home it was for addictions for the pleasure of Chavez and for peace in the home I was once in the Catskills for sharpest in the country and there was a blackout right before Shabbos and it was the Catskill Mountains you know one of these colonies that's when it gets dark it's dark it's not like in the street we have some you know some generators some lanterns some trucks with headlights whatever there's always some light but this is we're up there in the mountains so we sat down for the Shabbos meal it was not stomp dark it was pitch pitch dark but my wife has lit candles so on the table there were candles I said you know at last we can have a taste of what the mitzvah of Neriah Shabbos Kurdish actually was designated for now you see the difference we're eating it was still pretty dark but the candles gave it actually a very beautiful and warm feeling you could see each other you could see the food you could see the house so that was the reason they made it so therefore she closes her eyes so she won't have Henault from the light and then she makes the Braja and then she opens her eyes she takes off her hands from her eyes removed her hands from ours so that way she could now enjoy the light as though she just lit it so in that way the bracha even though it wasn't done before the kindling but the brush has done before the benefiting and the lights over there you have an exception because it's a problem to light the candles after the brother if you say that during the bracha you accept Chavez there are ways around it but they're complicated if she has mamas qivana that she doesn't want to be my Kabul Shabbos it could work but generally you don't want to do that so we do the broke after you do it yet well she lights in Toronto he does it she's not yet focused on that yeah yeah yeah so that's why the women it's one of the reasons why they cover their eyes yeah that's a good question why Moshe Rabbeinu you asked Oh ask poses calm yet very nice you say they go like this to gather in the whole family and the whole week and the whole energy and the whole class is distraught okay I never heard that song the Gemara so therefore Broca's done before the MIS Bay Rav Omni in the basement wish of Rav they thought that all the mitzvot see make abraca before gutsman had to Villa Versova except two mitzvahs submerging in a mikveh and blowing show furnish Hashanah and the Shiva of Rav said in these two mitzvahs he make the barakah after the act yeah yeah yeah this is the yeshiva reflect the Gemara one sec this slam at villa I understand why the Ashima of RAM they would say when it comes to the mikveh you make the brush after why ducati Gavriel oi kasi because there are some types of to mice some types of impurities where the person is not worthy the person is not in a state where he could make a broker before mixer so therefore there was no chant there was no ability to do it so you do it afterthe Fela that I understand we're going to explain what this means in a moment I will show you from my timer but why can't you make a brother before you blow safe I understand why you can't make a broker before mikvah who I be for so now what do we mean by mikvah so let's see Rashi Rashi says very interesting okati Gavrilo kasi could going through loves ballet Carrie we're talking here in a case where a ball carrie has to go to the mikveh now this this is a very this is a very interesting idea in in Jewish history in Halawa a person who emitted semen which is called Sushma Zahra the sperm the seed of life that person for whatever reason whether the person did it consciously in terms of a marriage or or if a person what's called McCrea Lila and himesh meaning it just happen in the middle of the night the person who wakes up in the morning and he realizes that he emitted during the night the seed of life this person is called an Aloha a bowel carry that's isn't it the halacha is he becomes tummy there's an impurity as a result of that minute IRA you now let it eat car bonus you now let a trim off your car yet you now want to come into the base of mikdash but it's not a big tumor meaning you go to the mikveh you wake up you go to the mikveh and you become tired after nightfall after nightfall that day the day is over and you went to the mikveh you become tired you can all tell me something she can eat through me you can eat car bonus else is good ok a person whose tummy is a lot of davin person who's Tommy's a lot of learned person as Tommy is allowed to say Krishna because Tommy's a lot of say it's not a problem I mean I tell you a tumor doesn't stop learning or domine however as you are safer Ezra the scribe who was one of the Jews who rebuilt klaudia strong in the beginning of the second base of McNish era when they came back they're too strong from the babylonian exile ezra made a very interesting tikona and he said that is one tomb if a person touches a corpse and their tummy for seven days he didn't make this tikona or any other tumour the tomb of Kari he excluded that this person when he's a carry should not davin should not make any brothers should not learn until he goes to the mikveh the moment he goes to the mikveh now he could do everything and he doesn't have to wait till nightfall like when it comes to coming to the place of meekness but Mayor the Gomorrah says about Kerry he woke up in the morning six o'clock he runs to the mikveh he can't make a broker before he goes in because Ezra made at econo that about Kerry can't say a broker borosilicate MLS column or three law so the afforested wait till he goes into the mikveh and after they make me could make that Kathie Gavril louis ozzie Oh usually you can make a broker but he's now on I make a broker that's the reason he's going to the mikveh so but mainly he has to wait till after it now you'll say but it's after the Mitzvah you can't make the broker because there are many the ones the mid surpasses you're now gonna make the brachot around my mold once you did the Mitzvah you can't make the brock anymore but here is different why cuz over there he could have made the brush and he didn't make the broker here he can't so the rabbi's look up he'll have made the takoma that the broker should be after because you can't do it before so therefore in this case you could do it after after the tefillin now since the majority of mikvahs were because of Kerry because this is so common right every time a person was with his wife he went to the mall in the morning to the Meeker you have to go to the mikveh couldn't come too sure he couldn't come to yeshiva good mister give em right everybody went to the Meeker so therefore huh Ezra Ezra cypher was miss oculus as our cypher was moussaka in this everybody went to the mikveh in this uh yep soul said Nikolai libido Vanya since most villas were carry that was the majority of reasons now with majority of people went to the mikveh when after my woman's make her for NIDA but majority of men who went in the mikveh was for what for carry so therefore that have come already didn't distinguish and they said that for all the thrillers you should make the broker not before but after that's what Rashi is saying you see the climate lumber brokers Duff have shut us up at the military will be broker the Ezra ticket vanilla ballet carryin with the retainer so Meili can say abraca omission mahute Villa tikkun but how it's real is real hustle herbicides so even another situation for example a woman who could make a broker before mikvah Anita's allowed to make a broker a woman when she goes there ready sex you should also make the brush all three lies or another reason you're going to the mikveh because already they're not gonna distinguish this victory yet this McLean that that's that that that's that's the reason just just just to give clarification adult um again to this so again most points came not all but most parts came hold that villas Ezra was obliterated in the times of the Miriam which means hundreds of years later it's a very interesting thing it's one of the decrees of Hazael Ezra was not just cos alpha margin and that they they obliterated and the reason was it was not sustainable it was simply not sustainable here yeah if I make a Shana hasten McClure negates Assad may have many mcfist it was not sustainable you know what I make if it looks like that right huh either you found the power pond or you found the sister and we're not gonna talk about the the weather what did the temperature of the water and the cleanliness of water it wasn't so easy mikvah wasn't such a push to think it wasn't a push to think so they obliterated they obliterated this Tacoma and that's why today about Kerry could learn and kendama and can say breakfast without McVeigh there are those few points can will hold that it's not so partial that's Phyllis Ezra was bottle which is one of the reasons that many Jews continued and continued to be marketed on what we call Phyllis which means in these situations to try and go to the mikveh in in in the morning but the interesting thing is that once they made the broker after mikvah they never changed that even though they will move a portcullis Ezra they didn't change the brush the bracha remained even after that's an interesting thing right because just like Rashi says they didn't distinguish between this table and another tree law you can add and even after this Fela was gone once they already did it by all the michaelis they they kept it they kept it in place yeah of course of course I don't mean Asura himself no one person yet it was best in this excellent question how do they have the rights to do it the Rambam says that if Bezdek makes at econo and then it's realized at some point that it never save ashamed river to be a highly moi meatball so then it doesn't work it doesn't have the halacha Kothari yes yes yes yes it was simply not sustainable no you don't make a bra cause if there's no he of mikvah enough to make a Brooke yeah well let me give you a little background I think it will cut it will become clear and then you'll understand the argument also okay the Gemara thousands of a sexism of a comma that Ezra instituted ten Tucanos one of them was that a balcony has to go to the mikveh meaning mean hot area doable carry can't eat rumour he can't eat car bonus but Azra came and said that he can't even learn tyra until he doesn't go to the mikveh can't learn turner the rambam teaches us in history law that the best in after Ezra added then he can't Davin about Carrie Kent davon which means saying all the brothers saying SH ma sang Schmoyer Astra all these brushes with our shams name he can't say until he goes to the mikveh so this is the Tucanos Ezra then when the bell Kerry wakes up in the morning he wants to go down and he wants to go learn he first has to go to the mikveh now step two there's a Gomorrah massage his Broca's now have base is going to be quoted in Thai service that review there was a story there was a student who was a base med rich and he wasn't he wasn't sharing words of Tyria because he was about carry and reviewed of him said we told them open your mouth div retire are not macabre Toma even though you're about carry you could still teach Tyra and the Gemara says over there that but Liu Allah to Allah so that they nullified the halacha of Tillis Ezra and the halacha decree rhythm I'm serious typhus is going to quote a Gomorrah that the world follows remuda member sarahx that when it comes to Tyra about Carrie is allowed to speak Tyra even though he did not go to the mikveh now you asked a question how could this happen if Ezra made a tack on with the best and after as it made at econo another best in can't just nullify at econo unless they're greater in in numbers and wisdom how can that happen how can have you them say dramatic on a sensor so so the biggest answer the main answer that's given in most poised scream is that the tikona never took root among the Jewish people it spread but it did not spread among all the Jewish people in other words it was never it was never accepted and the reason is cuz it was almost impossible it was almost impossible and some say that even if it was accepted but ultimately they saw that it's not sustainable people can't do it so they could nullify it because it doesn't have that hawa Hawk Authority there are even reshawna mu say that when Ezra made the Tacoma he made a stipulation that it could be obliterated it's like he inserted a clause that this Tacoma could be obliterated so therefore they could know if I it but now there's a very interesting much likeness if the bin full of the Tacoma was for everything they're only for Tara in other words when they obliterated the Pecan of Ezra to go to the mid class of all Kerry is it only for Toyota or also for Fela there's a McCoy because the riff mrs. Broca's brings two opinions he says one opinion is that they completely obliterated the institution of Ezra for learning for Dominique enough to go to the microphone but then he brings a second opinion second opinion is it was obliterated for Tyra if you want to learn turn it off to go to the moon but it comes to dominate when it comes to Davin Inc you still have to go to the mikveh or at least even if not going to the mikveh you have to wash yourself in a certain measurement of water nine cabin of water and the rift quotes your High God who says since there's no clear halakhah the minik by old Jews is that somebody who admitted seed about carry even if he doesn't have water even if he doesn't have mikvah he should not have an until until he bathes so this is a big big big big McCoy because it's already brought in there is shining him yeah the Rambam Rasheeda rush - behold like the first opinion but her being a phenomenal derive it to wreck a half the SQL of him other is showing him hold like the second opinion that it was only taken away for learning not for darling now the halacha intial tomorrow in our higham is that they will move a table Phyllis Ezra both for Tara and for Davin Inc which means even about Kerry is a lot of learned tire in the morning he's allowed to say SH MA he's a lot of Davin even if he didn't know a good mikvah if even if he didn't bathe but because because there are we showing him who hold that it was not nullified for Fela therefore throughout the generations many were very meticulous about the Phyllis Ezra meaning in the morning before they went to Davin as a preparation for nominee they went to the mikveh even though how logically you don't have to but since many was showing him hold you have to say therefore this was a very accepted custom until today by many Jews who will go to the mikveh some some go to the McCleary day but some go to the mikveh when under these circumstances yeah the Rambam himself South says in August Fela the Rambam himself writes in August Fela that the mimic the mimic in Iraq and in Spain the miniguns sinner and in Spain is that our ball carries somebody who emitted semen does not Davin until he bathes his entire body in water the Rambam says that's a preparation that's a preparation for Dominic that's a fact yeah in fact there's an incredible Trouville of the Rambam fascinating fascinating chuva of the Rambam a letter from the rambha that they asked the Rambam why he was so lenient about about harry going to the mikveh and the brahmam says that he never ever nullified the concept of going to the mikveh by bukhari he just could not write in his safer only that which is obligatory in halacha and since it's not obligatory in a locker therefore he can't write in a safe you have to go to the mikveh but he says he was not move outlet a Finnish office in other words the concept is still a very powerful concept it's just not how logically neither logically how ethically obligated the famous comedy revenue Jana who says the Broca's that according to everybody that feel is much more accepted that Fela Davin is much more accepted when it comes following following mikvah yeah there's a famous rush the rush says don't Davin without clean hands and without purity because the Fela won't be heard as well etc the Miri says I mean a lot of the reassuring them say that it's filled before domine is a special condition and call a maximum authorial of bracha the main recess in any way in any case there are many many sources that the treeless Ezra was not bottle for Fela only fat area and that's one of the big sources why there's a haka pada to go to the mikveh and more often but how logically how locker cleans not it's not it's not obligatory what did the Gomorrah say that everybody holds that abraca has to be made before the mitzvah that everybody agrees with the question is what the text of the broker should be but the fact that it has to be before the myths everybody agrees what's the source for this so if you would have told us in the name of Shinhwa then all the mitzvahs one has to make a broker over last see us what does over me Boyer lassie yes and thank you so the Gemara brings three silken antenna which all have this word either one is its small base pay Rica tests a man Aki mats runs by avarice a cushy passes before the coup Shiite two-tailed of Adar Melek about the fact that his child is son of Shalom was slain and thus the rebellion was over by a verse so he ran and he passed before the coup Shiite so when you say all the myths all the brothers should be dawn oh you very last see awesome it means it should pass ahead of the action it should happen before the action a buyer brought a person from yakima vino vu who of our life Nahum he passed before them before the rest of his family his wives and children to meet and greet and bow down to Asaph and then there was the third person from Mika about Messiah by a ver Malcolm with Nahan Varsham biracial their King Malik a messiah shall pass before them shall go ahead of the Jewish people to lead them towards the Ghulam so this is the source for the concept that a broker must be done before the mice or Varanasi awesome which means it must pass before before the hacia pass ahead of it now you might say why couldn't you all just say call them to say koha call a mrs. Merkel in coitus cuz call them just means before before could mean an hour before before could mean a half an hour before could be for two minutes before be not supposed to do that a brook has to be made immediately before the mitzvah meaning in the closest proximity to the mitzvah there should not be half sick between the brush and the Mitzvah that's why even Lula why don't we just say leave the lulav on the table and make a broker little Oh them and then pick up the lulav we don't say that we say you pick up the lover then you make a broker which makes a problem because once you pick up the lulav you already did the Mitzvah see after Salatin lost Lulu and the answer is because the mitzvahs to be done right before the activity there shouldn't be anything separating between the action and the broker even the fact that you have to pick up the lulav which is already some type of half sick and it should be recognizable by the broker that you are already involved and prepared to begin the Mitzvah and hence he uses the word over which means it has to pass before the Mitzvah it's like it's like literally you're both running and you go right ahead of the Mitzvah so the over is obviously in close proximity because he passed you somebody who passed you has to be very close to you if not he couldn't pass you somebody passes you on the highway obviously he's very close if he's a mile ahead of you with three miles a day you 100 miles ahead of you he didn't pass you he still ahead of you so every means I passed you but I'm very close to you I passed her I just got I'm right ahead of you that's what it means I passed you as in these in these bucum who over elephan am Yaakov wasn't a mile ahead of his family he was with them he just went right in front of them or a few moths wasn't miles ahead of the Khushi at the passive you just want ran in front of him and mushy richard says well yeah ver malcolm lifts mayhem so in all these situations it represents i think that the why he uses the word over because the mitzvah must be done right after the brachot the brothers here right before the Mitzvah then the gomorrha said that in the yeshiva of RAV they said that there are two exceptions mikvah and Schieffer so the Gemara says we understand mikvah that you make the broker after because the person can't make the broker before Fela Rash explained and this was referring to hey pal carry somebody who emitted semen and ezra made at econo that about carey should not learn and should not davon and should not Karishma and should not make broca's until he goes to the mikveh in the morning and then immediately he could do all of this so when this person goes to the mikveh which was the most common mikvah because it's the most common source of Toma because it's just part of of life any time there were relations between a husband and a wife or whatever the situation was that a person willingly or unwillingly at any point of the day or night emitted seed they went to the mikveh this is called the bowel carry so this was the most common source of mikvah and you can't make a broker before why can't you make a broker before cuz you're not supposed to make a broker but that's the whole point is we going to the mikveh so here I understand why you make the broker after that so rashly explained the Gemara and since they did it for that Fela they already did it for alt realize that you make the broker after the mix well on this they did a broker because it was Nokia as I mentioned the thrill of Ezra was obliterated it was later the time of dom Miriam they obliterated the tikona right but what a woman does and a convert us because we don't have today a mitzvah of mikvah we don't have the mitzvah heave of mikvah so the time of the Miriam most her logic authorities believed that the chronovisor was obliterated the time of the Gemara already and therefore the bracha doesn't exist but the but but what happened was they still they still retained since they made the broker to be after the Tavella because of the tikona of Ezra so therefore the broker never change and after three law you still all the brokers whenever you make a Brock of a mikvah it's done after mikvah so the gomorrah says ok limit to be lying this time to be law ducati gavrillac aussie because the person is not suitable to make a broker before ll show you from my time but why Schieffer what's the problem with joyful why do you have to make a Brock after the long on the chef he tamer you might say from Dilma Michalka Latakia maybe that kia will not be done efficiently it will be ruined in other words perhaps the person won't be able to admit the takea and therefore he won't do the mitzvot and with mitzvah is not done the brother might be a broken vein so perhaps that's the reason that the Shiva of Rav they said wait till after Shaffer and then you'll make a bra says the Gemara really hockey if that's the case a foolish little Miller then even by slaughtering an animal or by circumcising a child they should also not be a broker before you do it here too you could say the person won't do the right Street or sure if it could make a mistake and if he doesn't do the right so then it's a brothel about taller the same is true Mila in other words he is chauffeured requires skill slaughtering an animal requires more skill circumcising a child requires perfect skill so if you're gonna tell me that my Tiki ashore I'm concerned that the person may air and even though they may have been prepared they may have not been prepared that the Kea won't come out well and therefore wasn't a mitzvah and therefore it turns out there was a brothel of a taller so wait till you did it once you do the job and we know it's a job well done then you make the brother we should say then she tell you should have make a brother till after the schita because in case it's not a good Street ah so then you didn't do the myths from sheet to the middle shitless to Shack not to kill killing an animal is not a mitzvah on the contrary is the Mitzvah so totally you do this don't make up rock me with the same thing if he didn't do the right or if he didn't do if he didn't know what he was doing and he didn't sometimes it happens you know I've seen it happen a moil doesn't know what he's doing or whatever for whatever reason or he you know his hands are his hands or whatever it is somebody else has to finish the job he didn't do the job so you should make the brush after so why did the Shiva Rav only exclude Vela mikvah and in Schieffer should have put into that list Rita and Miller if this logic if this logic was true but Rob did not do that he only excluded Vela mikvah and Kia Schaefer what do we see that by other mitzvahs Ralph would agree that you make the broker before you do the Mitzvah in other words we're not afraid that it may not be performed well Bravo billable time we understand why we trust if you're getting up to circumcised charlotte least let's pray and hope that you have some practice if you're getting up to shift an animal let's hope that you have some skill but that doesn't require skill listen you could decide not to do it when I'm talking about somebody who decides not to do it somebody who wants to do it but but but but they push it lack the skill well they made a mistake on the mitzvahs you don't have that problem putting on tefillin I'm gonna put on fill enemy with why wouldn't you eat why not it doesn't take skill you just have to do it well they learn they learn under a mentor you have to learn onto a mentor you watch and he observes you yeah yeah just like just like surgeons and hospitals yeah of course must they have to jump of course yeah I have seen sometimes they get older sometimes something you know so they had practice yeah yeah something happened or they got confused yeah the incident that you saw was really young a young fellow yeah so his internship yeah yeah and also mistakes a person makes malpractice insurance there was uh there was a mice in Pittsburgh a few years ago a seasoned moil and a fine man at Southwark a wonderful person and and by mistake he severed he severed the whole the whole piece and he himself took the baby and rushed the baby to the hospital and says saved it he knew what to do immediately he didn't lose himself I'm saying he was a season of practice yeah of course yeah yeah say Hawkeye Felucia tamilan ami for the Gemara this is two of a big question a llama refused abuse at hood Smyrna thrilla Belvoir it mire there has to be a mistake interesting he says it doesn't make sense in the yeshiva of Rav they did not exclude Schieffer they only excluded the Mitzvah of to Villa but Kia chauffeur obviously would make a broker before you blow chef I we have hoods minutes Villa Versailles fur the priest is convinced that this was an error that that crept into the tradition because it has absolutely no watch it suddenly from all the mitzvahs in the world Schieffer was discriminated against that it doesn't get a brother before the priests that cannot maintain this he feels that it's completely senseless and indeed Tonya Nami Hoffy we see that Krishna may have been right because we have a price in the browser says Tov all over all about we see that the achiever of Rav was correct the way rubric is interpreted pavalamalli Yasser when somebody went to the mikveh and he came up from the mikveh when he comes up I'm ray he makes the broker Baraka Tasha Malik animal asylum I sure could Hashanah Mamet's race of its Ivana ha Vela again we're talking about when there's an obligation as a mitzvah either biblically rabbinical II actually immerse in the mikvah which does not exist today for men no well he could give the chauffeur to somebody else no no because the broker that we make before Schieffer includes the whole crowd and everybody hears it and says I meant even though yeah because because when the person blows joy fir the the bracha they make is to his encompasses everybody that's listening to the chauffeur because everyone is McCoy Irvin Schieffer so why don't we all make a broker the answers we listen to the Baltic Aires broker we say our main no ever blows is fine yeah that's why the broth is Baraka no wish my Akash I fir it doesn't sail it Korea I'm blowing but I Salish moiety here because the Mitzvah is not to blow you don't have to blow sure person if they hear stripe from Russia shot as long as you're here you could blow too when you blow you hear but you don't have to blow the mitzvos to hear so that Mitzvah is for everybody in the show lose here in chauffeur and they are included in my brother if I'm blowing so somebody else could blow us so to Vela the way Rashi says it is because the person was Tommy the ball Kerry couldn't make the broker he had to wait till after magnify so there was no choice no other mitzvos you could do everything way while you Tommy could do most mistress while you tell me it's not a problem the Ezra made at econo on one tumor the turn off carry of emitting seed which was later nullified it was later bottle that a person shouldn't make a brough that till he goes to the microphone so for that it's really yes the wait till after the MacLeod yeah even after answer you did all the mitzvahs when you're down there yeah it was just davon in Korea and Broca's let's take a look at toy service a lot Sevilla Nora either it is that a different tradition or replace the felt then it just it was not defensible it was not a he felt there was absolutely no logic to it it could not make sense that Schieffer would be excluded would be no rationale for it why would Shaffer being excluded take a look in the toy Souris al Hut Vila I'll have to fill it the second to the last toy was an ops IANA midbass he complete he learns it differently very interesting I'm Arab a new Canon Elba Shane MacGowan Robin O'Connell said in the name of a Goan the Daath gibbet villas game when I've said that bite really you make a brush after talking about a converse oughta say why the like Aussie called them to be law because before he goes to the mikveh can make a brush why not the way Matt Salemme Merv its Yvonne oh he can't say and he commanded us that kotti not Rio coz he's still a Gentile and he's knows now a mitzvah yet you're not obligated to become a convert there's no such a mitzvah you chose to become a convert the premise of conversion is voluntary not an obligatory there's no reason for a Gentile to feel that he has to become a convert a non Jew could live a perfectly moral good life as a non Jew right that's one of the uniqueness they completely unique elements of the Jewish religion it doesn't say there's no salvation outside of Judaism as the expression there's no salvation outside of the church for example from the Christian perspective if you don't accept Christianity you're doomed to purgatory the same is true with most other religions in other words it's my way or the highway the uniqueness in Judaism is as the Rambam famously puts it Hassidim asylum the Ashlyn kalloch Loyola ma ba the good the pious people among the Gentiles have a portion in the world to come so there's no obligation to convert to Judaism not only is an obligation we are actually obligated to dissuade somebody who wants to convert because he was bought ah interesting sure been a phenominal said that a non Jew when he converts after he goes to the mikveh he becomes Jewish he has to go through a bris but then he has to go to the mikveh time to miss a meeting she would also bring a carbon so after the Mickey becomes Jewish so that's when he makes the brother because we make the broker before the mikveh more guitar strumming okay well hello my sugar this Shana limit soy submits Yvonne we never gave me such a commandment rhapsodic gone yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah her Nana lived in the 10th century in North Africa yeah we have it on the right you see rabbinic enamel on the right yeah he has his parish yeah yeah usually a gun is absurd to God oh so late they began another that's what the Gemara is talking about he can't save it Savano because he was a Gentile evolved shark' of its feeling balcony vacated by Mutola vara unlike Rashi another time you make leave in mikvah like a ball carry you could make a broker Kadam linear pay admission may sue as the gomorrah says in my circus brokers no gaol market losses avi the world behaves like the three sages which and about three different a lockers and one of them is the halacha of Rebbe Hooda member sarahx who said bal carry that Yahoo Lewis Powell of order Philomath contempt Villa bidam sailor holds that even a bulk area davon and make a broker and learn before mikvah so therefore according to tie service this is not a shot in the Gemara the shot and the Gemara is that we're talking about a gay miller you make before city make before ah no but the mile makes the bra the one who gives the one the mile makes the bra cannot take care but here you want the gear to make the broker so you can only make the broker afterwards FRP cane so this is the tough tyson so rashly he'll do tomorrow was talking about about carry and about carry can't make a brussels before because of Tucanos Ezra but Tyler says no because if the gomorrah says that the world behaves like a rhythm i'm sarah who said you're allowed to do this brother before Davin a before mikvah so therefore what is the Gemara talking about only a gear a gear has to make the brush after we understand why there's no way to make the brother before he doesn't have a mitzvah to go to the mikveh after the mikveh now he's a Jew so you could say now I should get a shot of him a choice of it Savano Hashem did to give me a commandment I shall did give a commandment if you want to convert you gotta go to the mikveh by going to the Mikkel you fulfill the commandment of a Shem but that rocky could only make afterwards not before that would be his first Brock as a Jew a lot Vila afterwards yeah there's an interesting question an interesting question why we don't make a broker for every myth so we make a broker well not for every Mitzvah for many Michos we don't but there's a question why some mitzvahs you don't make abraca one of the mitzvahs the question exists is Pesach Cypriot es materia there's a mitzvah to tell the story we got it a little while ago why don't we make a broker you make a broker motsi make a bra con more you make a brach on the wine you make a rock on the why don't we make a brother on the Mitzvah yes work from professionalism Silvano will sapper BTS Messiah how good sympathies with Ryan why why not that's a question it's a question some answer because it's like you don't make a broker for a broker you know make abraca that Thank You Hashem for giving me a mitzvah to make a broker since Cypriots Eastman I'm in a way is like a broker it's a form of gratitude and Thanksgiving so therefore you know make a broker for a mitzvah that is a bra that's one explanation there are different explanations but if some sofra says that the reason is because when a person sits down for the say there they're supposed to re-experience ets messiah the jewish people before you teach much time were considered semi non-jews and my Matt and Tyra they went through a conversion they had me law they had Fela they brought a carbon they went through a conversion so the sum so first says when you sit down for the Seder you can make a broccoli sappy and see as much time feels like a guerre before the mikveh when do we make a broker when we finished the Hagaddah before we drink the second cup we say barakaatuh Shambala kendama lukayla our goal on / goalless of a saint no cane yogi anil Amaya the Manoa kosher Manaus lock him in up Zuckerberg Havisham gaudy straw he says that's the Brooklyn after he went through the Haggadah now you can make the broker like the Gare after the mikvah that's what there's some safe explain oh you saying every day we have a mitzvah every day we have a mitzvah right but the question is because the heart of Pesach the midst was different the midst was to tell the story at length to your child every day right every day to Mitzvah and we make a brach on Tyra every morning we make three brothers he's saying before the Seder it's like a Jewish before conversion so to speak because every year sky about the melanocytes with chiliad supplements Ryan so therefore you make the broker after the Haganah alpha became I married nonetheless theory says the a-league urban ocean shema versus accurate thriller many women when they come out of the mikveh they make abraca after they come out of the maker after the mixer I according to the read you should tell all the women to make a broker before because the only when time you can't this by a Gare he says not there's no reason to get upset when they make a broker after make low when they come when they finished neither why the e-cat Phyllis Gare de l'Est Motilal Vora like he'll cool because what happened war since there's a type of trela we you can't make a broker before so the Casal already didn't divide and therefore even if they make a broker after Mickey even though they don't have to a woman is not a gay she can make a broccoli for but it's completely fine to make a broker afterwards because they're really not gonna make a division other ones once they said by a girl you have to make it after so by every Mikula you could do it after the Haines been Attila she died the same is true by washing your hands like he'll Cobain Attila shall akka Baisakhi say the way mochila verified the same issue we have right Attila she died when somebody comes out of the bathroom and does the Tillis ayodhya so he can't make a broker before because his hands are tummy so he has to wash his hands first to make a brother so once in this situation you make out Mattila cioud i am after you wash your hands so they already didn't make a division between washing hands after the basic you say and other times let's say you're washing for bread we're essentially if your hands are not on me you could make a brother before but you can always make the Bruck that after you wash your hands cuz again just like by trilha they're not making the division between this type of nutella see that i'm since sometimes but until this you die and you can't make a brush before why can't you make a broccoli before cuz your hands are tummy so you have to wash them first and then you make me broccoli to listen I am so we're ready every time you wash your hands they said you can make the brush after you are stands even in a case where it's not muck roof you don't have to because your hands are not tummy happy holiday so Casey you wash your hands but here we're talking about a case where you make a broker so that would be let's say in the morning right in the morning we make a brach on the Tillis and I am right so so even a person who knows that during the night his hands didn't touch any part that's impure but he goes to the basic EC in the morning so ty says he can't make on the Tillis you die him before he washes his hands right so you have to make after watch the answers so ready every Mattila see a dime even though you know your hands are not Tommy you let's say you wash your hands for breading you know your hands are not Tommy know I'm the last you make up until this is the item you could make it after you wash your hands because again they're not divine why didn't your abs you Shiva exclude Mattila see and I am also because it's ready the same sweater like Vela just like the veal all you have to do it after until they said IMO see after it's not a pizza finish me you've been Attila - Thomas yeah but by washing their hands is another reason why you can make the broker after levar it a car until the coid them nickel in order that you should make a brush after washing before you wipe your hands Kadam Reno we learned the Gemara says inciter oh it's a lesson baloney via Diane kilo I shall s I'm coming somebody who eats bread without wiping their hands it's like eating impure bread meaning it's repulsive it's like eating in purebred the hands have to be dry so therefore driving the hands as part of Nutella see and I am so as long as you make the brush so before you draw your hands it's still the middle of the process it's still you didn't finish the action because you can only wash yourself to dry so therefore by night ELISA time is an extra component that doesn't even exist by trela that you can do it after you wash your hands the yes there is also the mimic by some that's brought also an Al Aqsa that they will what rub their hands against each other after the bracha so they're actually not even finished Nutella yet not only it's not drying it you're still bringing the water and rubbing them together after the Branca so you're not even finished Nutella see a dime but tightens even without that just wiping the hands is part of Nutella Sid I'm very far from there are those who say the basalt villas come Rina that actually when the Gomorra says here that bite feely have to make a brush after it's not only talking about a guerre it's talking about every type of mikvah you have to make Nebraska after why the Gavriel lloyd kasi because the person can make abraca before why for a completely different reason the koi beam she hurried l'm i am a nerd sonic lavoris before you go down to the water you'd have to make a bracket why cuz we're afraid dilma mission be a soo said the maya because of fear from going into the water minimal light tava he may stop himself and I'm going to the mikveh but after share did once he goes into the water us who are amis naked fossil Evora he should have make abraca mushroom the laborious ever caused his heart and and private places are in are on the same level it's not covered so therefore he makes after Twitter so here we have a completely different interpretation right if that's the case so here we have the who here we have a whole completely different reason you have to remember that Mick was then were not clean and warm and very often they were absolutely freezing and dirty and disgusting and therefore it's a natural consideration that a person is gonna chicken out and say I'm not doing this so if he makes a broker maybe a brothel of Attalla so therefore by every type of Mick where they said wait till you come up and that you'll make the broker nothing to do with conversion nothing to do with val carry a completely different interpretation which would mean that it exists by every single type of maker it's not that you say it exists by garum and therefore you do it by others all services by mal carry do it by others but rather like a pillar was contraindicated in to the water he went man nobody hung out of the mikveh he came up he covered and he made a blocker a lot feel yeah we learned to remember those Kimmelman bays remember but the carbon paste suck you remember that story the person who bragged that he's eating the carbon paisa and he said you have to ask them for the tail they tricked me yeah what we spoke then it's a question when Derby the mime sailor lived with a 2w Damaris or one it's not so clear because there was a later one yeah so some say the Murat ski says that story happened after by a knee actually but they still continue to do the carpet basic and they were afraid that he's earth it's espionage here that was one very logical interpretation of the Gemara so it actually would have been after the Corbin yet today women make a broker after after mikvah after the macness no the women make a broke after mcli after you go down if the water is open and clear right so when you're under the water you don't make a broker because the heart because the heart and they ever see each other so to speak so yes the wait till he comes up so it's not five minutes it could be a few seconds he just after she Oded the Wharram so therefore he does it after yeah no no no if he comes out of the water and the the the heart is above the water and the air for the private place are under the water then it's fun that's fine so he doesn't have to wait till he gets dressed okay so therefore in conclusion by three will you make the Brock after by chauffeur you make the bracha you make the broker be before I saw a beautiful Vaart that's brought from the sushi her in the first Gary Reba it's brought in 6/8 avec and he says a beautiful insight you saw at the back of the Miss if Tiger Morris they bring different ideas from soir the SIP states are the quarter ski survey says this that I mentioned it says impartial ski Savoy that when a person did we during my sir they confessed that they already did all their tidings so what did they say that and their confession that really my say this person said that what's the language the language is so much sure anybody has a Hamish Devore impart risky silver-blue March on my hair how much thank you well the vitamin Mitzvah Sacco thank you very much so person fourth you had to make a declaration that he did all his tithing so the expression is you have to tell her she'll be RTI Kurdish Minar bias I removed all the holy food from my house I gave it to the lady the garrison Mahna Mahna layer vitamin Mitzvah ceremony Shakti I was not over on any of your mitzvahs Volusia cook they did not forget what didn't I forget he's saying I did it so obviously I didn't forget so Rashi says well I shut off the maneuver ethic all of Russia's my stress I did not forget to thank you to make a broker the question is the broker on all the mid service is a rabbinic obligation how does rashly interpret it in the words Felicia Hardy I did not forget the liver Africa very strange he's explaining the sukkah mcComish I was not over Anya Mitzvah and I did not forget he says what does it mean I didn't forget I did not forget my liver Africa - thank you how could you explain that's where the words Volusia huxley when it's a rabbinic obligation that came only later it's very difficult to understand you understand the question yeah the posix says lower vitamin myths we shall cover logic octi I did not transgress your mitzvot right I gave all the maestra said I did not forget what didn't I forget the Mitzvah obviously if you did it you didn't forget right so what's that what this volusia shocked to add you want to say you did it you saying I did them it's right then everything perfect I did it right and now bless us of course you didn't forget so actually says it means you didn't forget to make a bracha how can you took with the words Volusia sake don't forget to make a broker when these are the words in Hamish and the broker was added many many years later when the Cohanim added a broker because it's only a rabbinic obligation to make a broccoli form it's loose but the posted Malaysia tea is not before actually but circulation trust is not from rash it was original mesh I didn't forget Rashi saying what it means I didn't forget so the position areum says it's an interesting thing here who is the one who says you have to make a broker before you do a mitzvah w-who that says it in the name of small and the expression is I'm reviewed on my small column it's whisper vertically in everlasting us all the mid soos you have to make a broker boy Everlast see us so the Gemara wants to know what does the word over me and then where it brings three sources from tamaak he said it's another strange thing you have her a number of small he uses a word anything Amara wants to analyse what he meant and you go back to the Tanakh to figure out what he meant it's a very strange phenomenon usually if he tried to figure out a word of Tana you explained it through another Tanakh you explain one plastics to another person here in a Myra who's living how long after the Tanakh he's living the Tomas was written whoever the flame is from parshas voracious he's dealing with small small lived after kerbin by a shame so from the Jewish people wanted to stir all 400 years till by restriction and then another 400 years is 800 years 1500 years almost 2,000 years he used the word over use a different word no use some obscure now how do we figure out what he meant let's go back to the time actor figure out which movement this is very strange phenomenon to analyze an arm iris words through the word of tonight living without thousands of years later so the fiducia area has a lovely explanation here and he says why did the Casal make a broccoli for mitzvos what's wrong to do a midst without a bra you put on film without a bra like they did it in the olden days eat matzah without a bra so there were no process we make a Brucker on everything we making out on everything but I'll hourly you make Nicolas how much you make a brush like Hanukkah candles abraca put on a palace you make a brush put a number Susan make a brush I mean I tell you this didn't exist you put up misses without a brook you did all the mixtures without a blessing why did the Cazale feel the need to add this what was it why they do it so he says the reason is because essentially a Jew who appreciates what a mitzvah is has a tremendous enthusiasm and sense of simcha before he doesn't mince it's such an exciting opportunity that naturally the Jew bursts out in thanks and joy and dance and ecstasy from the privilege of knowing what he or she has now an opportunity to do so when Rashi says Leisha hasta I didn't forget to bless you he's not referring to the bracha that the rabbi's instituted he's referring to the fact that they always had a Brooklyn without a text without words it was just a sense of of wow I can't believe that I have this opportunity a tremendous sense of simcha person has an opportunity to do something like a mitzvah it evoked tremendous joy and what was the reason that evoke tremendous joy because this was literally an opportunity that our Schramm gave the person to connect and to connect to him in the most real and absolute and infinite way an eternal way so they couldn't believe their good lucks that's the logic on D so this was an essential and essential experience that came naturally he didn't have to say it as generations progressed and sometimes spiritual senses get dolt so the kazow institutionalized it that a person should understand what he's about to do don't just go ahead and do it you're thanking our sham before the mitzvah it puts the person into the mode a mindful consciousness to be able to appreciate what they're doing ah yes he say today the brush also needs a broker you have to make a broker before the broker so you should know what you're doing yeah the problem is in with over safe deliver Africa see taxes will very few cars - thank you - thank you he says that's why he uses the word over not see could have used another word he used the word every because of these sukham these pursue camp and not just to prove what he meant it's to prove the concept says what happens in these Soviet half shaman was killed somebody went to tell EE third of it is gonna celebrate it because I've trouble Moses enemy actually moths rushed before him because he wanted to be the first one to tell dove it in other words it was about enthusiasm that's what he's pointers or even means you're running ahead of it before the mitzvah yeah you're so excited that's the mitzvah that's why uses the word over the word over in the pursuit can bring out that there's an excitement as a passion I'm running ahead of you why am i running ahead of you cuz I want to get there first why do I want to get there first because there's something very positive about it very exciting Yacouba vino wanted to want to appease Asaph swiftly mushiya wants to leave the Jewish people to the Google after he marks wanted to go tell David what happened in all these cases it represents a tremendous excitement a tremendous passion that he wants to go ahead and do it that's why I used the word are you with all these sukham in order to convey this idea that before the mitzvah he wants to so to speak pass ahead of the mitzvah because there's a tremendous excitement that the Mitzvah the Mitzvah represents for the Jew so therefore he uses the word over and that's why Rashi says was a custom Oliver and that's what he brings and then he adds very interesting insight he says that one of the main reasons for the weakness that people haven't avoid is that the eighth Sahara puts in false humility into people's hearts and the false humility tells them that they're unworthy to serve God Who am I I'm a nothing I'm a nobody I'm worthless God is not interested in me there's nothing I can do to serve him you just give up on yourself and he says that's the greatest lie the greatest law is that a person thinks that his Mitzvah doesn't mean anything his avoid this Hashem is valueless it's worthless so the barakah is trying to change that the brothers trying to reverse that that the person should realize the specialness of it for him and for Hashem oh so this is Baraka partial internal intensive in Silvano it's it's meaningful at something God actually wants me to do this he actually wants me to do this this big infinite God wants me to do this mitzvah for him so that creates a simcha also of the dignity of the person that our son wants this Mitzvah mamala finish em neat similar from a local art squid the imam battle of immersion Claudia's relief it move the Caronia so what's the summation of it all in summation we had a mock likeness between a puppy or of Papa whether to make the brothel of via comments or to make the braja I'll be your comments ruff puppy said levar and reporter of puppy said l'viyah and ref Papa said I'll be your and the Gomorrah said that V Xhosa said Allah he is I'll be your comments I'll be R how do we understand now I'll be your comments how do we understand the significance of Al beer comments why do we say I'll be a wise doll Locker to say I'll be or not Olivia what's the reason so the toy Swissvale kiss our beer comments gave two interpretations one is you could say I'll be your comments meaning there's no advantage in it it's maybe better to say live iron but you could say all beer or the second interpretation is no you should say our beer the first interpretation is basically saying levar is certainly good you thank Hashem he's given us a mitzvah l'viyah comments to dispose of the hummus you could say I'll be your comments thank you for the opportunity to destroy thank you for the opportunity of destroying the comments or regarding the destruction of comments even though if puppies said that that sounds like it happened they're ready and it didn't happen but riff Papa said it sounds like the future more than the past so therefore you could say I'll be your oh so you don't have to say Livia you could say I'll be an even though you didn't do it you could say well everybody could sell beer the second shot anti-surface was no Daffy gal beer you have to say Daffy kalbi or not and on this toaster said the yesh Tom maracas if this is the case you have to say all beer that means there's some reason by breakfast to say I'll be or not l'viyah which seems strange and he says Vereen lie matzah Tom la jolla broca's Denis did not find a reason for this to understand why some brothers do we say live and some breakfast we say al what's the logic according to the first interpretation entices it's not a question you're right there's no reason you could say live if you want you could say al that's the point you could say live value can say all being the same is true with all the other mitzvahs you could say ly you could say how the second interpretation is mr. Salvi or comets means you have to say I'll not live if you have to say I'll not live the question is why what's the advantage of al over al in there has to be some reason and he says do you read they couldn't find the reason why some brothers this way some brothers that way so it's completely two different interpretations in the Gemara the he'll just say I'll be your comments means the hill sister also I'll be your comments certainly la fireworks or venosus said I'll be your comments only beer comments and Lavanya doesn't work and according to the second interpretation which means you have to say I'll become but he says he doesn't know the reason why doth Cal beer what's the advantage and this became a fascinating suger here in the Gemara among most of the rishonim to try to figure out what was the system of the hazael when they formulated the brothers when did they put a lammott and when did they put an owl can it be figured out can it be figured out the first view is the view of the rambo the view of the ramen we already addressed and hopes was Broca's panicky Dolloff you have the copies and the Rambam formulates a system which is all based on this Gomorrah and the RAM bombs formulation is a fascinating formulation and the way it works according to their album is he analyzes based on when we learned around mom and we look at the Gemara it seems like he analyzed the Gemara and from this he made a formulation what was the formulation there are three conditions that are needed to sale it if any of these conditions are missing you got to go to Al what are the three conditions required to be able to sail it condition number one is you have to be obligated it's not voluntary you have to be obligated condition number two you have to be doing it in order to fulfill your own obligation not as a favor or a messenger for somebody else to fulfill this obligation condition number three you have to do it before the Act not after that let's give an illustration for each one if I'm sexting an animal am i obligated there's no obligation you don't have to eat chicken you don't eat meat you could be a vegan to be a vegetarian if you want to eat chicken you gotta just it you don't have to so then the rabbit would say no live owl and we understand why think of the words I should get a shot of it slice of its Eve on a leash right God commanded me to slaughter he never commanded me to slaughter didn't tell me gold slaughter I don't have to slaughter them you could not slaughter your whole life and you didn't do any sin there's no bits for the slaughter if you want to eat chicken is a mitzvah how to eat chicken such an invisible Silvano I wash Lita he commanded us regarding he gave us a mitzvah regarding relating to shittin that's a mitzvah to Mitzvah and Claudius wrong which includes me without a specific commandment to go shot it's not it's not something that's a commandment so that goes into our rule number one rule number two it may be a commandment but I'm not doing it for myself I'm representing somebody else example am oil if the father is alive he has the mitzvah to circumcise his child not anybody father can't say it's not my issue you take care of it the moil works for the father he's hired by the father he's Ashley of the father like we do today most cases that mile the RAM bob says can't make the midst of a shed of the shahnameh choice of its Yvonne o la mole he doesn't ever mix with the circumcised and stop actually the son of a civic SI 100 ha meelo regarding circumcision because it's the father's obligation rule number two rule number three even if you're doing it and you're obligated and you're doing it for yourself not for somebody else you can only sale if it's before the Mitzvah once you did the Mitzvah you can't sale anymore cuz Lear sounds like I'm about to do it God commanded me to to go ahead and do it now you have to say al it's like you're thanking gosh em for doing it the example you pick up a lulav you picked up a little of once you picked it up you ready did the Mitzvah so what's the broker should the Shantou civic Savano i'll little Olaf thank you our sham firm shaking the loose for the Mitzvah of shaking the Loomis not for the Mitzvah to go shake the loo love to shake the lulav which sounds like I'm about to do it for the mitzvah of shaking the lulav which sounds like already could also sound like I did it already it was done ah sumaya coal sulfur you're going to blow chauffeur you're about to blow chauffeur csail am it huh you're about to hear it here yeah you didn't hear it yet why should be all right right you didn't understand Liz before the action I was after the action first honest foolish more oh thank you for the mitzvah T here call chauffeur which is going to be now do the first two elements he's required and he's doing it with the filters on obligation even though everyone else's three conditions to Saylor condition number one that has to be an obligation not voluntary like schita right chef is obligation condition number two it has to be an obligation but I am fulfilling my own obligation not yours right condition number three it has to be done before the Mitzvah and he is so when I put on tefillin I say learn the act villain why it has all three requirements am i obligated to put on tefillin it's not voluntary map located am i doing it for myself from doing it for you I can't put on tefillin for you sorry that's true that's true when I say you broke good point when I say the Shema call chauffeur I'm also be might see others but I'm also be might see myself mat villain you have to put on your own filler right it can't be much of somebody else with filling I can't tell you do me a favor put on tefillin for me today I'll watch you some people do it they seneschal and watch other people but I'll fill it doesn't work if he doesn't know anyone know why bytes fill and you make Albert's worst villain it should be it should be what again money excellent right filling you change to our but we understand why according to them you say Lani if these are the three conditions around my past you lights and he gets all three from our Gemara yeah you wonder why all mitzvos okay so this will going to explore makes Hashem tomorrow to understand the of the Rambam and see all the brothers how they come into it and then we'll see the of rabbinate amo as a second done and then the of the ran who has a third sheet owe a huge argument of the reason and when you say lip and when you say owl and everybody had to fit their schita into all the blessings to make it work that is going to be our theme tomorrow base or assembly not to have a wonderful day this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate