Gemarah Pesachim #6

the yeshiva dotnet one of the challenges is that a lot of boys and girls growing up in your Seaver school as kids they didn't understand what was happening and when they asked one question or two questions they were shut down in one way or another or maybe they thought they would be shut down therefore when they're adults they don't know that it's not supposed to be that way he's supposed to understand everything and you could on the step so what's a way to shut down people so I don't want you to carry that into this SharePoint's a new reality problem Hadassah's somebody doesn't understand ask it's fine not a mind explaining something five times six times ten times on the finest look if at the end you'll understand it we explored the last year the very famous and Big Mac Lakers I say it's famous even though for many of us the details are new a very big argument about the definition of sphere definition of sunset whether you still have your massage the sharpest copies don't have it let's go further if you have it just take it out and the key point was the key point of the argument was as follows what is called sphere what is called sunset the way the argument comes about is as I told you is an argument there's a there's a major contradiction between two brightest in moussaka soccer da-da-da-da-da dismiss after w-who deserves levy or did the town reviewed assess that from sunset tonight form from when the Sun sets till when the stars emerged which holds aseptic oven when the stars come out when the stars appear in the heavens in the skies is a shear of DA McMillan of four kilometres approximately four kilometres which as we said is approximately if you take a meal as 18 minutes although many states 22 and a Half Men is a 24 would be 72 minutes from skia tilts a secure shovel if you want to say that it's 24 minutes of milk so then it would be 2 million is 48 there would be 2 times 48 would be 96 minutes for great it should be very clear the only problem is that I'm a sense of Shaba stuff llama doll and diplomat hey you sugar about skiing osmosis and rabbit you hood at the same time be hood at the same person says that she bein our smushes which is called Twilight begins after sphere right by skier right by sunset and it continues till say circus comedy and he gives the shear for it and the shear for it is there's two opinions one opinion is 2/3 of a mil one opinion is 3/4 of a mil yeah the of Rama 3/4 of a mill which Liholiho we embrace w hooda homer and the of rabbit which 3/4 of a mill would be 13 and 1/2 minutes or even if a mill is 24 minutes it's going to be a 6 6 12 18 will be 18 minutes we all understand it's a huge difference between 18 minutes or 30 and a half minutes and 72 minutes this is like a huge contradiction so one place he says from Seattle to encumber 72 minutes and mr. sharp as he says from Seattle says it of which means which is also a name for bein a schmagges the twilight between sunset and nightfall says it the column which is mama SH night for Shore night is basically 18 minutes or thirteen and a half minutes again depends how you define a mil that's why I alternate which is a big argument in and of itself that's 18 minutes 22 and a half minutes of 24 minutes now this is like a huge huge contradiction it's hard to get around with it around it if it's 2 minute question five minutes NuLu Meili you say but here it's like a huge huge gap that we have so how do you deal with this how do you deal with this so debater Tom had his big finish this is a finisher Benetton and tysonis and soccer and in Shabbos which we learned inside and tom says that there is a major confusion because skia does not mean the same thing in every place it means sunset but doesn't mean the same thing miss after Shabbos is here I'm acceptable southern skier are two different skiers and this is the finish of an attendant when you speak about ski and how long so we're not always talking about the same term and the key point of Rabbinate tom was skier a is when the ball of the Sun sets which means when the actual Sun the Sun itself sets over the horizon that's still one skier too but still a lot of light there's still light we still can experience and appreciate and observe what we call the Rays of the Sun or the light of the Sun and therefore our part of the planet during that time they're still pretty bright and luminescent even if it's of course the light is diminished obviously the Sun has set but then there's a second skier that's the real skin not only the beginning of the ball setting but the beginning of the light settings in other words the light is already disappearing as well not only the sub disappeared from our horizon but the light this epitomizes and the beginning of that sphere that's the real alarm scheme in the sect of software I don't want to call it the fake skier but have assessed up something we talked about the first year from the first ski it'll check economist 72 minutes from the Sun actually setting until what we call complete light for is 72 minutes or 96 minutes in my sense of shoppers when we say from Seattle Jessica saw them as 18 minutes been our smushes you know with that skier starts that skier starts an hour after the first skier after the first ski when the Sun sets it's too light for a long time that's day that's not nice that's not banish nauseous that's fully day even though the Sun sets there's no stars out its day it's daytime it's mamas yawning even though it's called skier in soccer because the serve actually set but politically it's not paid much Martius it's not night it's fully days what's the difference is if you could do melaka for a whole hour Friday evening what's the difference well massage Shabbos you have to wait much longer which one do we hold that itself is an argument that itself is an argument that's why this key ever bingo tom is a separate sphere the sodium acceptable certainly wants to talk about how the day works in fact the circumcircle M is not talking about the home office of skier it comes in incidentally because of a different topic it's actually throw my paste our trainee Tommy and we're gonna get to it when we get to downtown big dollop in a few weeks and which skier Sun sets the Sun sets their argument what's the significance of that in our locker so w hood that replica tom says that a Quadra w hooda that's built state staged a when does banish mushers begin when our office begins three quarters of a mil three quarters of a memory for techs at github a meaning you go for mill right and deduct three go back three quarters of one mill in other words after three mil and a quarter that's when you're banished lushness will begin that means 58 and a half minutes or 60 minutes right if it's if it's 72 minutes so what would be three quarters of that but it's day I don't know a promise dates light outside well good the onset of Danish lucious happens when he says Ben - Marsha says three quarters of a mil which we explained to be 13 and a half minutes right poor or two thirds is one two or three quarters of a mil my lahu we take on three quarters of a milk but you can also go with two thirds another point is it's much much later so Ben our smush this will begin when thirteen and a half minutes before seventy two minutes so when is that gonna be fifty eight and a half minutes after sunset is full-day you can do everything like a day and on the other end but sorry Shabbos it's fully sharpest fifty eight and a half minutes after fully Shabbos no question after fifty eight and a half minutes it's Suffolk you're in Suffolk Lila now it's doubt bein as much as it's not getting much much darker already right it's still not steaks I could hug him yet fully we're not true but it says it to come but it's getting much darker because basically what happened we're waiting now this is the time of the skier of the second skier the skier of the light around fifty eight and a half minutes or 60 minutes it's this second skier and from that second skier you have now Bainer smashes between that and say circuit of them which says that the Kaufman's going to be basically the seventy two minutes of the ninety six minutes that's the bay national artist that was a bigger Tom's big citizen in this and as we said the fascinating thing is that the show tomorrow he'll for Shabbos I Mahalo Haskins like rabinal Tom however most of the restraining or I should say many many of most not most of the restraining disagreed with Lorena Tom they held that's not the case and this is known as Osaka Amon and the reason is because the argument there is from already the other opinion dates back before a Benetton rev shreyer gone and his son of high God and many others showing him disagreed with this completely they felt that what w-who the meant was here is the first year when the Sun sets I how you going to explain am acceptable soccer minutes it's four mill when he says there that Ben as much as is only three-quarters of a milk so one of the main interpretations for this one of the main axis for this is which the villa McGann gives in his beer had grown in Seoul tomorrow he'll cos hookers Shabbos will he argues with the macabre and he says it's not the right to temperance and the same answer by the bow Latonya in his siddur nominal come on he embraces the view of some tomorrow because that's what he usually did until tomorrow he followed the show tomorrow we just explained it more with regions but in the siddur he heavily argued with this and felt that it was not to that except that nobody should be lenient to light candles Friday evening late they should do it before the first skier and the reason was because the Mushaf Dubois from they both interpret to me say second of them there doesn't mean when three stars comes out it means what all the stars come out safe color pit cover and that's true 72 minutes or 96 minutes after the first year it's pretty dark I'm not gonna say it's pitch dark but it's pretty dark and you could see most of the stars even even the even the small the small stars if somebody only learned South America RAF like the Regular Show tomorrow would follow up in a time to you Danish master starts much later and for a very significant time after she is fully de and banished master starts much later and remember even been much much this is or something be nice much as the Suffolk as tysonis explain to us here soccer and in Chiapas and I'm soccer because artistic enough medals are not so simple what's called three middle stars three intermediary stars not big because big ones you could see sometimes earlier in the afternoon right and not tiny ones what appears tiny because that you won't even see them because they're tiny you'll only see later when it's really dark so the weather will the the darkness will allow the tiniest lights to shine brightly just like a little candle you know you won't saga materia my honey my own you won't see the middle of the day but the question is what's what is exactly what does what does that exactly mean and that's why there's a concept of a nice monstrous now you'll ask why is it one second why is it according to the regular to shoot the circle or even right after 18 minutes after skia we should already we should have nice nobody waits 18 minutes after skier right there's a lot of Syria but nobody says 18 minutes or thirteen and a half minutes I'm a higher after skiing and of course here we have to understand I'm not gonna get into this because this is really a whole Sookie birth Nats but it's not ultimately our main discussion but this really has to do with where you live in the world meaning in the horizon of bhavo and Heritage Hall on a day when when six o'clock was sunrise and six o'clock the Sun set what's called the equinox those equal days what day and night are identical in Eric's astral or bubble similarly over there w-who the spoke from that perspective and over there you could see three stars coming out which they s the estimated not as the big ones not as the small ones but I takes a click of him and just he made it a little earlier because of Ben hush monstrous that's true the moment you go up north more north like the Jews and later generations who moved to Eastern Europe you're dealing with Russia Poland Lithuania and even Germany and France are in a time who lived in France and you're going up more North everything changes which is why in Eric's is wrong the asylum was always accepted not a better time I got an extra should the Sun garden was accepted completely not like so tomorrow be nice Marshall starts right after she and say SEC economists soon after it also worked for them because over there the stars up come out much earlier we're up north it takes much more time and that's why the mission of brewery explains this at length the mission of Laura who's the Pyrrhus Nakamura of course brings the show tomorrow but then he says so many points could don't agree and therefore it's not so simple to follow him in a time and he brings the dome the gun and all that that hilarious oh he says that even according to the first and not to be no right we don't wait anymore just thirteen and a half minutes or 18 minutes we follow every hood and then after that we add two minutes for abuses should've been our sponsors and then based on where you live in the world looking at the horizon and how long it takes for the stars to come out they extended more time until they were sure that three stars came out three stars came out which they estimated what could have him bathing him but they weren't sure they were kickoff invading them they wanted to make sure that it's even the katana come out so for Shore night and that's why it was extended even according to the first - you don't just do jessica hovel 13 minutes after skia it it is it is longer how long have to do Scimitar Shabbos so again in the classic ideal situation you're dealing with approximately 18 minutes right but but that you for that you have to be in a particular remember ski is always relative to where the person is in Japan ski is at one point and Los Angeles it's another time you're shall I miss another time in New York it's another time so it's not about an objective experience so therefore you have to see what's going on by you that's why we don't just say 18 minutes after Shabbos is but so childish so W hood has said that it's three-quarters of a milk right three-quarters over which would mean 13 a half minutes or 18 minutes but we don't say okay so that's that's the hwacha because the buter was talking about in his place from his estimation from his perspective at the particular time of the year and because of that there's such a chocolate area you have to in there too strongly so I'm attack a much shorter over there they're the most lenient over there and over here they're much more stringent and in Eastern Europe they were also much much plainer to do this place yeah yeah no it's not a bit of time nobody tell me to wait much later it should this again him but even should this ago I'm in yes even should the circular item you can't do Milazzo it met many ways it's also more stringent because Friday you have to stop doing Malaga right by sunset you understand something has already been nauseous push it quicker that's or not it it's earlier than normal they're just a few minutes after you oh that's something else there's a one other sign of the uranium that Danish mattress starts approximately 18 20 minutes before skia that's why the concept of 18 minutes you like candles 18 and 3/4 sukhiya right one of the ideas is one of it because there's a to one shift of returned to say array of their blazer of myths who holds the famous monster starts before stage that's how he understood it because by H 1 star to be forced fear so ready you have to take your job as before she'd approximately 18 20 minutes yeah some add a little more it's approximately that area most part boat most of the restarted don't agree with this that's why we we stopped by skiing but anybody says that it's good to stop before ski because of this lists and then most places they do 18 minutes before some even earlier that's all in cities are going them it's all in citizen I'm just extending how long it takes to get from skier to testicle column to testicle cover invade I remember we're looking for safe secure car from valet to make it mature shoppers since it could call them Suffolk right it's earlier was over there maybe 13 and a half minutes like anything that's going to be hood has said yeah according to priceless taste a github in Suffolk is even a second after skier that's why it's been our smartest that's why it's been much much so remember take the car from Suffolk is very very early but what's exactly those click haven't been in them I go ahead after the sunset I see stars are those that can cover bathe in them maybe maybe that's why Spanish marshes that's what we don't call it for short day it may be Suffolk Lila right we don't call it for short day Friday after ski I have to stop working because it may be it's a second cousin it may not be but it may be thirty nine half minutes later eighteen minutes later 20 minutes later reviewed this says it's for short session to cover you go out is it art says I could have it they weren't sure made the attention come they wanted to make sure that we have Jessica have them but how do you make sure how do you make sure so they wait till the three small stars come out because of the three small stars come out then you know it's van de Lima again so that you understand what I'm saying it's all based on doubt in other words we don't know we want to be certain that shabbos ended how can we be certain a Chavez ended when Chavez begins we want to be certain that shoppers did it begin so we go there early as possible so we go till sunset or even before sunset because that me knows not since I could call them right again there's one that that there's a Suffolk even before here this is the same your name after Shabbos it's the other way around we want to be certain when I took away the Tom now we're talking dr. Bennett I'm I'm talking the classic that's a good right after skiers be much smarter than the time doesn't have a problem with right after skier ran after skier by him is big got a wall time for Venice masters but according to disagreeing and right after ski has been our sponsors you want to make sure it's fully night for that you need sensor to cover not bein US Marshals say secret rubber means you have three stars coming out three intermediary stars not three small stars because that is later rights a second of them is bein in them so we wait till chaser can cover market Amin the three stars come out which means for sure that sensitive come the bein in them came out because it's a really much darker and even the katana becoming a dick darlin could be by day before skiers the bane in them that's the beginning of night and the khatamun come out later she waits for the tournament you know for sure the been in him came out and that's why the been our smartest extends until then as a sufferer and that these arguments and the arguments are justified because it all it's all relative it's all about perspective w hood the gaben is three-quarters of a mill you're bi you see said it's clarified which is estimated as to minister of the time you said it's a hacks email and so forth so usually we go to be who do we add to be I see and then there's all the additions everyplace according to its its dimensions its its its properties yeah eastern horizon yes yes rises in the east and sets in the west the right actually you can see the stars much later three stars on the winner yes yes the events were you that - that - yeah so what is the mathematical formula for the Northern Hemisphere lights civil which is still is your wife for just six degrees or some below the horizon twelve degrees now we come to the next step if we look at this Gomorrah it should pose a challenge to the cigar you know why the Gomorrah said that are apparently means day and it's used in that way it's not used as a euphemism for night we want to say night so instead of night we say a nice word art but rather it means day because they're voracious is when you curl the kimba are um so the Kumari rejects them and says no who's forcing you to interpret it that way well or it could be a verb not a noun the new binder shall eylem called the process of the day becoming light day meaning even before it's fully light even before sunrise after dawn breaks we already call it jointly as the purse except that boy hoodlum a Yoruba carry on the process of getting light this called day so the Gemara says they can't be why because then you have to explain the continuation of the bus at the same way hashem called crisis Lila doesn't mean darkness as a noun the process the Madison who BA Carolina as it's getting dark as night meaning after sunset as it's getting dark just like after dawn break before sunrise is considered a sunset even before nightfall is considered night and that can't be because we have an air Halawa that defines day as going to occur covered which means magical ba is not lila so you can't interpret variations that way because if that's the meaning of aeration wouldn't contradict how the turret defines day and night so we're back to square one that oil means are now are is called pain and night and darkness is called night hunt Sakura Lila which would be a problem according to the Horner that he interprets our as day so therefore the Camargue it was a completely different interpretation to the plastic that it could work together with ruby hood them who holds that or it means night because my youth Korea is not a name I am summoned debris of early summon debris of Hydra and he commanded them to take care of what we call day hours and night hours so here let's think about us the Gemara rejects the notion that after sunset could be night because tilts a circus coven is your mama the Gemara rejects the process that after skia begins night lamar should who book are lie that's not true that's not sure whose does this work so well with rob a no tom Robina tom is the man who says an hour after sunset you don't even have to think about night or fifty eight and a half minutes you're good it's completely days like before she he is that man the on the other hand they actually hold the magical ball car he Lila they're the ones who say the moment spear happens whoops you got a fear that's night night is here they call it banish lucious look all you need is Gomorrah is a gevalt occur alia that after skia the status of day did not change just like we said the mayor of book RA Y which we accepted but LaMarcus of bukhara Lila we did not accept we said that wouldn't work it's not true snipe Lila I'd say city cover miss your mama the one that this works best with this rabbit town because the Cordish it the cigar in them the masterful work or Eliza you could say like Isis Cara Lila he called night to the process of the getting done because they hold at the moment this first some sense I say the first son the moment the Sun sets you already have to treat it as a Suffolk Lila this is a question that rebel command Wasserman asks in his safer covered Cedar Cove assume I'm a sect of soccer Vaman VASIMR was a student of rahim salivated of high risk and then the toughest guy a master of its kind he was murdered in June Thomas torsional of 1941 taken from the governor ghetto in luther way Nia and and murdered with many Jews in summer of 1941 torsion Aleph by the Germans and in his he was the receive of baranovichi she would call oil Toyota mironovich in Lithuania and the litter and herbal son of a Samana chemin could never wrote a safer called Kovac seorim UPS awesome they're very well known soir iman shots I'm soft him I saw he asked this question al-qaeda the good martyrs a stronger ayah to rabbinate arm against the Sergeyevna Sobel common answers as follows he says it's not the case it's a good deal but it's not the case why because they don't say that from sunset is night they say from sunset is Suffolk night it's been as much as the Kumari defined in Shabbos Boehner smush this is Suffolk min hire woman who Lila Suffolk cool I mean I am Suffolk cool Ayman al Ilah meaning there's three ways of looking at Baelish Marshalls one way is saying that's all day you really don't have to worry it's all day Robina Tom doesn't have a Suffolk he says it's completely dead but we're talking about legit the cigar in there what gia happens it made me fully day you may have full day and you're right but I have another issue it may be fully night-night may begin then maybe yeah maybe now and then I have a search Suffern Suffern caminar you owe me now Lila maybe it's half an ass maybe 90% his day 10% is night maybe 99% his day and night and what percentage might maybe 1% is day right and 99 percenters night I don't know maybe young man - starts 10 minutes in 5 minutes in 3 minutes in or maybe it's all thing the problem is I don't know if the PASOK would say but you crellick in with her she's like the hush of Cara Lila what does that mean Lamar she who Bob Corey Lila that the reboiler shall I them gave that time didn't a night he called that night or say Suffolk the say Suffolk it's not that so therefore even Sugoi all they're saying is after skia take a deep breath and be cautious they're not telling you after skiers Lila and that's why tequila halakha Bay not smash this is not like a second column right for example if you didn't do him a lot if you didn't do something on Friday it's no problem to tell a non-jew bein hops marches doing Bain Oshkosh this Friday evening you do any melaka for you even though on Shabbos that is rabbinic ly prohibited Amira lenore-- slows I can't tell a Gentile put on the light put on the fire I mean there are some exceptions but they're very rare and unique despite common myths misconceptions but nonetheless during bein hush Martius it's not a problem because men are smarter says none of that that'd be nice Marcus is a Suffolk so memorable comment ein is that if Lamar should who bought coral island that was the trap deposit then it would not work even like the cigar you know Emma's for sure there have been a time it doesn't work because he holds its managed a rewrite great but even the cigar him it's not like this Gomorrah proves up in the town when the tomorrow rejects it and admire says tilts a second column is young it works even with this aghanim I they say it's not your him it's a Suffolk line because I'm not sure but they also say it may be on so you can't Salem a about Curry Lila cuz nobody believes that nobody holds that they all hold it see I'm the problem is again as 2016 we don't know exactly when that say circa cover miss so when the Gemara says tilts a second column is joining those are interesting words because nobody really says tilts a second cover miss young right everybody holds his obnoxious even up in a time even a bigger table he's just starts has been as much as much later but nobody says tilts a second comment is really young so the truth is Lloyd ties to this we understand that because Tracy says till Jessica Cobb was young we just don't know when Jessica government's our problem with men are smart since it's not that we say it's Lila before Jessica covered till Jessica cover is day we just don't know when censing economists so when the governor says I'd say so to cover your mama who it means literally it is your we just don't know when that takes a commitment so that's why I make it earlier and earlier and earlier and earlier core diminish time we don't make it that early according to the garden we make it very early moments right after scarce a comma but the point is it's still a Suffolk we don't know what jessica cover miss and we say we can't Salem action above Cora Lila that the process of Manitoba is absolutely absolutely not so even though the DeMars has tilts a second cover miss yeoreum we would have to interpret doesn't mean literally we consider it the item we consider it Suffolk Lima may not smashes but we still call it your Mambo hope because it's still a Suffolk y and a Suffolk line I just want to add one detail and that is when the Gemara says of assets the Shabbos there's three doubts if you have the game or you could take a look the fourth line that flama dollar on the base turn it up on main are smarter Suffolk men I am in a lie the Suffolk alumina himself like alumina Lila you would think what are these three doubts they always seem the same the fourth line of the top Lama Dalai Lama base you would think like this the first Suffolk is it has day and night together meaning half day half night or part the part a part night second doubt is its all day third doubt this it's all night in other words we're not sure about that period of time had a judges right that's one way of looking at it so how do you touch Suffolk min Hyorin or min Hal ila Suffolk when I am an hour Lyla means it's a Suffolk that it's comprised of day and night how can it be comprised of day or night well you could say 13 and a half minutes half could be day half could be night five percent day five percent night as we said earlier there is another interpretation of this Gemara a very interesting interpretation and this is interpretation from the rugged shava god the sufferance primeira Boehner Yosef Rosen the way he interprets this Gomorrah and really it's already in one of the is shown in the Ritz law says this is Mustafa Zuma the morale also gives this interpretation is suffered when I am an alignment means that Bennish marshes actually has a different Suffolk it's a Suffolk min hiya alumina viola together then every minute of Manor schmagges is comprised of two opposed entities the entity of day and the entity of night meaning once Suffolk is the Venice marshes is fully night another Suffolk that has been as much as is fully day which would also include part a part night that's what if that would be just an extension of the first two straightest but then there's another type of Suffolk perhaps there's a Macias called Boehner smashes which is min hi-yah Amina Iowa bianna that's what the Kamara means I mean how yellow Mennella means that part a partner the whole Boehner smosh's is something that's made up if it's a synthesis it's like an Android goodness there of each other says you know and I'm dragging us it's a new type of midsi is that soccer and a cave it together it has Halawa to unity or the gomorian speaks about a koi a certain type of koi it's a higher of the hay more not a higher not of a a more a new type of entity some states of buffalo huh yeah it's with a to become synthesized and integrated so it has both day every makuta of it has a gather of your an together of lila which according to this explains a very strange mission the Mishna says a prickly August the 5th chapter a solid volume Nibiru by Erev Shabbos been harsh monsters 10 things a chef created Erev Shabbos during Twilight now what's that famous mushers according to everything we explained is only a problem from us not for God he doesn't know one tastes like a governess what type of penis watch this is it for the Republic shall I long it's your stars you'll figure out what is it the government's I understand I don't know I don't know throw them katana Beynon them I get migraine headaches I look at the Stars I don't know if I'm coming or going if it's day or night I say Bane ice monsters but if anybody knows how this cosmos works and how astronomy works you should know what you're the creator your very face if you're the one who makes inflation it could have them Cemetery what subpoena smashes with the minister's you could say he created Arab shoppers before shoppers by Hallock in buying my three cause I'll say Rashi brings that business can hook a siren and he stopped mom it's a second before what's this idea of been our smashes what makes it better for us then I smash this seems like a minion of Suffolk so they're every trouble explain that snapshot there's a new software can be much much it's not a gather of Suffolk its again Theravada that is a time that's not day and not night because it's both day and night that's the problem that's why you can't work that not because we have a Suffolk with us often because there's an aspect that's nice because there's a real thing that's part of my and the other women so Shabbos you can't get beat you can't start doing Molossia goose is an aspect that stay I don't know Suffolk Hashem knows very much Marcia but there's a third dimension of being much much is that there's an entity of time and that entity of time has both components of Y and Y were together and the only problem is we don't even know when that time is we don't know when that entity of time being our swatches is that itself is a question if that's the entire time of banish monsters where it's in the middle of that men are smushes and the rest could be om and Lyla that's just one of those that's why it's one of the doubts we don't know when that kind of been our swatches but if we would know when that time of banished marshes is and there would be a mitzvah that you have to do by there you could do it if there was a mitzvah you have to do at night you could do it there was a mitzvah that day disqualifies or night disqualifies then you can't do it but if it's a mitzvah that needs day and it's not disqualified by night the trouble goes to a whole Kira that there's some mitzvos that when it says to do it by day it's not that you need the day that the night disqualifies it mitzvos at night that the day disqualifies but the sub mitzvahs it's not the night of the day disqualified it's just you need day but - came in at this type of Bane as much as he would be able to do those mitzvahs if you woods all the time because it has joy and it has Lila the only problem is it also has the other one so the other one disqualifies it then you wouldn't be able to do it which would explain why the things that were created Erev Shabbos Ben are smart shirts are all unique types of things right bill um the mouth of bilham's donkey the mouth of Balaam's donkey what else did it the RAM of aroma vino Hawks our midst of the Lucas suave spits wasa tsuya what the tongues yet transmitted sorry yes sir massacred all in your men that don't mama sure fit in into the regular structure of the universe because the power to combine day and night comes from a place that transcends both the ability to synthesize two opposites means you have to transcend both in order to synthesize them a translator from a French book to an English book or from Hebrew to English or from Russian to Hebrew whatever it is he has to have a better Russian and Abed in Hebrew he has to have in order to be able to be good please you have to know both languages but yes I have to be proficient in both languages better even than the original writer to be able to create read that transition you have a psychologist for children you have a psychologist for adults right somebody who is a psychologist for adolescents for teenagers we they're both children and adults has to know more than both psychologists in order to be able to master paradoxes you have to transcend both of them so all the things that were created in our schmagges our alum alumina Tavor they don't fit into nature because when our schmagges is rooted in a place the transition from light to darkness or dough is a very very profound one and that Mehmood sir that intermediary must have both the translator has to know the original language as to know the second language and then has to know how to synthesize them and combine them if that's shot so then there's a to hold deeper your schmuck and I'd say so I could cover your bubble tilts a second cover miss your mama because it's packing your you if you learn bay - marshals like this then I'd say second cover mistake to your mama even though it's not your mama it's not really a mama because we treat it like - I explained it stack of your mama according to this get it have been our smushes you can't sail a magical book hurry Lila that's not the catalyst ain't nothing on me Amos Kaname we don't treat it anymore as you're him but it's an Indian of your mama because it has urine Danish lucious is mamas Union it's also a Yamaha it's also Layla but it doesn't take away from the fact that it's Jennifer Caird it has an element of Ewing that's deeper than anything else generally all transitions in life are very complicated they're very nebulous they're not easy transitions this comfort zones and this transitions may not show monstrous is not a comfort zone men are smarter sister chuckles it and in order to go through those moments you have to have extra confidence you know it's easy to live in your comfort zone I don't mean this to make it so psychological but I am it's easy to live in your car it's easy some people are good at by day some people are good at night you know some people are good at darkness some people are good and brightness some people enjoy darkness some people enjoy light but I smushes but not so much this is where the challenges is it Suffolk yo Suffolk Lyla or really Suffolk when I am in la la' so it's mounting the whole Union Wyatt the Gemara says with her that fishness I'd say she could have him your mom Oh even the Gemara is not arguing with the Mencia Sabinas russia's that all the cars I'll embrace nobody says this camera doesn't say there's no Matt sees have been our swatches and yet the tomorrow rejects the idea that from skiers called Lila it's completely not Kemal so it's not only Machop Suffolk it's also as we explained like this how long it because it's time to gather of you but that's idea of a nice luscious but there may be an entry there may be an entity which we can't identify exactly which has both components and that's when these things were created so even from her shirt it's called a that's monstrous not because he doesn't know whence it occur place was the whole emergency personal Jessica government's fine you clueless if you would know if we would be W hooded of you they knew what the baton him before then he had a problem because it was a Suffolk we have to extend etcetera but if you would know if you admonish no you wouldn't okay so we just don't know because it's pain in them so it's very hard to ask the man according to this it has to do with a deeper a deeper component of a nurse marshals know entities no we want to say the marshals were trying to negate the marshes of baccarat Lila we tried to negate the idea that it's called Wireless Morrison at second home as a gather of um so we're asking I'd something you know banished nauseous that was the coma students question it's a big support for up in a time right that it's not called her sure so he answered rightfully because it's still Suffolk right it's still Suffolk um it's not coral island I'm just adding one vard that access at home near mama who that it's that cutting you know viewing it's that go gather of Yahoo even though it's also a gather of rival you can say the magical bar coral island in the morning he called day and this he called Mike when he called it a night when it has an element of day also how can you say that there's something wrong and that's why you can't touch the pasta that way that's what the Gemara touches our pasta very different well that depends again if it's a type of Mitzvah that requires day or night or it's a type of Mitzvah that gets puzzled by the by the choice of Lila if Lila is up soon then you wouldn't be able to do with that right if you just need yarn but Lila is not up soul then it would work I mean the pilots theoretical because you know what the time is they don't have to be much when there have been a time even though DISA garden because if they hold the first skier it's a different skier so W Hooda just tells us you have to wait slow Circle K mill so maybe even if you can extend it more and more they hold that the first ski happened already but the first clear happen you're right tacky in the north up north arena Tom made made sense for many generations the reason it made sense so many generations is is because the tacit took much more time they went out after sunset thirteen and a half minutes no stars eighteen minutes no stars nineteen minutes no stars I mean you'll have the stars that you could see during the day but you're not going to see stars so that's where I've been at Thomas we understand took root because it took much longer when it got dark are suddenly you see stars you look 72 minutes after ski gonna see stars you'll see it's a second you will see your stars are gonna top says that's you're chasing a common it made a lot of sense but like disagreement with your skier their skiers begin is is as much early as it if they didn't have to extend it so much even with hotel homra is that it's a second of W who do we have to extend but not not so not so not so long okay I think we can go another 15 minutes yeah since we started late huh okay so we'll go we'll go up we'll go we'll go to line 45 okay so let's now continue here actually this is this is very appropriate now quality there bazerman bays one two three four four lines from the bottom the bazerman bays Mesa Mesa so let's recall this entire Gemara is trying to explore the meaning of utter earlier balsa Nebula says it means night una said it means day and the Gemara understood was a pillar there a boner that really means you have to be by the Comets on the day of our boss sir he was very explicit the Mishna says irony bonus says don't make a mistake or means day of noob Dicky's comets in the morning the builders said absolutely not the Mishna means night and the entire Sookie is trying to either embrace or reject your vulnerability by bringing proofs both from the Tanakh and from wish niacin Bryce's how the term or is used throughout and the Gemara here without a concordance IAM before Google Londo figured brought and brings out every time it says earlier in the Tanakh in a context that we can use in here to either prove or disprove one of the two one of the two you tomorrow continues now Mesa they asked the question aim must see in my size illallah hiders shanira Bismol a la casa the new question is that we have we have a branch so that says you don't Kindle torches must see it mysterious our torches you don't Kindle torches only on a month when the moon appeared on time in order to sanctify it I'll explain in a moment the very must side masse and my source and when do you like these tortures and the answer the bright sir gives us which is the key with the key words here low oil abhorrent at the oil of its Ybor which Alma this shows us hurry or two who are means night rejecting the buna and supporting review hooded what is the price assay the browser needs a little historical introduction and context we know that for many generations including in the time of the Mishnah and the earlier time of the Gemara the wavers her dish was established was not through a calendar in fact you never knew when the next month is going to fall out there was no such a thing sending out of a mitzvah invitation a wedding invitation and saying the wedding is gonna be on Monday scientists live or Tuesday cast kiss love you know why your guests would show up the wrong day perhaps there was no such a thing as sending out a calendar sending out a calendar sending out an invitation with days every month you have to figure it out anew because as we know refer this there's a challenge with prescribers the challenges there not to get to astronomical the orbit of the moon is complicated it circles the earth the moon circles the earth and it finishes its orbit after 29 days and 12 hours and change tough test you debase and tough suits are the gimmick owacan as we learn to mastectomy Shoshanna lat length and therefore regardless is of course the new month what do we mean the new month the word hoid is going with hitters it's when the moon is reborn what that means is when the moon appears for the first time after the moon is in conjunction with the Sun and the earth and therefore it's blocked we can't see the moon because the entire half of the moon that we see is facing the Sun and therefore from our perspective we see a dark moon when the moon moves a little bit away from that and you could see it the witnesses who observed it that's called recitation and the way what happened was the orbit of the moon is 29 and a half days so after 29 and a half days the moon finishes its orbit it meets the Sun and you can't see it then but then it moves away a little bit and it starts moving away from the Sun you could start seeing the moon when witnesses saw the moon they right away two of them came to best in the new Russia lion or wherever the Supreme Court was they testified and they may grow childish that's how it was as a result of this when did you see the moon because the moon finishes its orbit after 29 and a half days so therefore the atheists would see it at what point if 29 days passed from last month - first rate is 29 days so sometimes 29 days the night the middle of the night the beginning of the night later early morning they could see the moon if they could see the moon they could come to best in the next day and best it will make that day destroy - and that means the month had 29 days and they 30 became Aleph what happens if witnesses didn't see the moon because the moon did it show up yet or because it was cloudy or whatever reason they didn't see the moon so day 30 could not become a Reuters because there was no testimony there was no bastard day 30 by default fell back to the previous month this was called ahoy dismembered which means a pregnant month why is it called a pregnant month because pregnancy means you have an addition inside of you like a baby and a pregnant month means that this month has an extra day to it or a sir no more barriers is a leap vehicle it's a pregnant year like this year to the second other the year is pregnant with an additional month for the month is pregnant with an additional death so the witnesses would come on day 30 they could make prescribed Thursday 30 and therefore the month will have 29 and 30 will become one if there's no witnesses on day 30 or automatically day 31 becomes restraint dish and what happens day 30 is the last month and that's called the Hydra Schmerber or in your small way a pregnant month or a full month in our calendar today what we do is since we're straight this would be after 29 and a half days because that's when the orbits finishes but you can't make a restraint there's a half a day the terror says return has to be a full day so we have a problem was 29 and a half days you can't make a risk register 12 hours there's Riggins me for 24 hours so when do you do it if you make day 29 we're huggers right it didn't finish its orbit if you make day 30 to ascribe this it's too late already so what do we do so we do six months prescribed this is the month has 29 days and which hydrastar trite after and six months where so it starts right after 29 even though the orbit didn't finish but they have to wait 12 hours we ran away started training and six months we have a month of 30 days and which riders only starts the next day which is really day 31 in other words we're straighter starts late one month it starts early one month it starts late but in that process it equals it out yeah and that's the consistency of our calendar 5 & 5 the only thing that remains is fashion and Kistler freshman and Kislev is a problem cuz it's not mom is 12 hours we Mama's 12 hours was we perfect it's not mommy so catch them and kiss love can either be 30 days or could be 29 days depends on the year like this year freshmen as we know is 30 days and restraint as crystal therefore is two days today you have a calendar how did they notify everybody when we're sky dish was so they used to light torches on the mountains and one mountain would light the torches in Yerushalayim and then the next mountain would get the queue and with light all the way till Iraq so Jews living as far as Iraq and bubbled with no interest right this was that's what the mission is say if witnesses didn't come and recite this wasn't made till the next day day 31 they wouldn't light torches and when you would see there's no torches you knew that risk registers an extra day now this was very very important because this meant when paces circuses the M Kippur as everything was based on this so these torches were critical so that's what the barristers say a must see and masseuse LLL finish near abysmally Licata you don't like torches only on a month when the moon appeared in its time what's trapped in its time if it appears later it's not in the right time the moon appears when it appears but this money would mean the initial time which is day 30 look at straight to sanctify it because it's day 31 they didn't sanctified according to most opinions who just became his creditors by default the Amos I must see it my sous la i rebooted when do you like to torture us by earlybird Alberto so now she says what doesn't actually said eight Marcia masseuse I'm hookers but actually hearted I wish loose a peasant icing like dear sir I am future business offenders LLL finish native is one of the cockshott the young solution scenario the Kadesh the e looks our traditional uber boisterous registration mask of a macaque sure no search too quickly to show my in if your fetish is delayed Benson doesn't sanctified heaven already sanctified a pashmina and height Anna our trauma tells us that a hacer of linen my sewers you only like tortures if the month is missing a day meaning of its 29 days but on my way on a full month lawyer of dinner masseuse Shane Troy mi soo is here you shall furnish a little bit when they didn't see tortures they know automatically that responders was a day later that means pay such as a day later so if I'm sitting in my house in in in Iraq and buffle wherever I live and it's nighttime and everyone says oh there's torches on the mountain so what do I know I know that we've heard this happened that day and tonight when I'm seeing the torches is already Bey's I'm already on the second day of the month because we're try this already happened the day before it's not day 30 it's day 1 of course if I don't see torches I say Oh today was day 30 tonight as day 1 and therefore of course pay stuff is going to be a day later yom kippur will be a day later because tonight is not - tonight is that's how critical it was as you probably know this all change the middle of the second towards the end of the second base submitters do with it's ado cube who wanted to fool cloudy straw and they would light torches on the wrong night just to create a ruckus and nobody could stop it nobody could stop it so they changed it all they started to send Slocum emissaries out to the towns which created a major problem cuz it took ten days or 15 days to get there a torch you light a torch you see the torch mountain to mountain to mountain to mountain or shouldn't we go through all the mountains all the way till Iraq it was pretty easy took a few hours and everybody know what slew them they have to travel once islands why they didn't text that's a good Schuyler but for whatever reason they didn't use text at the moment at the time or what's up they had to search look him and that's when the whole yom tov Shamy crisis began meaning everybody had too many jews had to celebrate two days of young active because their Slocombe didn't come the tortures they didn't see and they didn't know when patience is when circuses when your Kippur is and other young entitlement therefore everything became two days because you don't know you don't know if today is pacer you don't have tomorrow a spacer if first cottage was a day early then today's Pesach fork rings with a day late today's era of pace to come tomorrow is basic so we do everything two days which is shown in two days in Kippur thank God not that's possibly could because because Memphis in other words to listen to the house and twice to the server two days everybody would die not only once but twice cm Kippur they're like ok we're not gonna deal with that plus fasting is hard for some people for two days and and but all the other leaders became two days because they'll move out all this but this Bryce is talking about at a time when they did tortures and therefore they used to do the tortures loyally Buddha Takashi outlaw OD border layer of our solution lady or so yeah miss garbage they did it in the night after 30 to tell them that the date was worst rated in other words they mistress Troy - they didn't notice grudges the main thing is near so I am they male solution for F heart mr. figure sorry say but let's go elsewhere Samba a club the night of 31 or guys to Masseria shots is gorgeous yo I'm solution carry Ibero I'll send Sabina offenders from uber Saint Haven by a suicide dish youngish Larsson was always called um he bore the pregnant day because that is the day that is added to the month if it doesn't recover its credit that's called so when it says are you boy what does it mean oh you mean boo right Alma or to dr. Ashley how do you know Bobby Ewing ain't my sewage solar near my rock because by day nobody's gonna see torch this farm I mean if you need a mountain you'll see a torch of fire by day but the whole point was it should travel miles and miles and miles by night I'm a person lights a torch an amount that everybody sees in certain proximity certain distance if you're gonna do with my day it's going to be ineffective so when it says Lori Borei what does all you mean or it doesn't mean the day of the eboard are means the night of the a boar now you can't even say oh you're boring maybe means I wash our car but at least I already means I shop at dawn break it's still pretty dark maybe that's when they lit the torches how does the governor know or you means night maybe earn means the early morning I voice not shot her is earth like we learned before about doing below carapace with Michonne saw or you could say it's a laser shot maybe it means that what do you think how did the Gemara proof in tonight maybe other means a laser shocker what's up stone huh for us some research after Steve done with them I listen to how no sleeping you need a few hours for the torches to travel by the time you wait a few hours ago scientists think nobody's gonna see your torches anymore by night you have a whole Minds Messiah of a homebody mother the kids lit firecrackers so you and leva think it was it was a you know became let me think it was a love the commander but he was excited no you Sheba the next day and everybody was lighting everything so the mela we see art or - oh so ah well of course Suffolk restart dish I would all set but you said that some surfaces I think I would all sad to tell them to do it by voice are shafts are wouldn't be a good strategy one of the witnesses coming in all over the day one of the witnesses come 11 o'clock so nobody's gonna know any more you do it the night after you're always good right because witnesses who come a whole day so what if witnesses come two o'clock in the afternoon 1 o'clock 12 o'clock 11 o'clock so you didn't do torches right if your policy is to do it in the morning yeah because unless you would have to do the morning of 31 but that's not a Bora so Mela what's Laurie Bora it has to be nice the night after 30 Elmo or to smile mean ah this is a good terraria then the camera says may swell brighter question the question is the price is higher a matte color I love maca vellum is beta a Korean was up all night offering sacrifices on the altar what are you are talking of should I am very glad what is the meaning of this the meaning of this is a carbon you can only bring my day beyond some voice say the past success it had to be by day but what has to be by day slaughtering the animal sprinkling the blood all has to be by day before nightfall before evening before sunset for banished washes right that has to be way that you bring a carbon Minister any carbon has to be by day what about the burning of the actual flesh or fact of the carbon on them is bad that could be a whole night that we say in Paris South so oyster your cellular he or her Mike tell him his bed call her Lila add the bike it could burn all night and the Cayenne could put it on the fire sometimes you had young teeth yet other times they miss bachelors full full full year thousands of cabañas was impossible to get everything consumed and turned into ashes during the day hours so this datura allowed to do a whole night so you had a car yet and a whole night he was being mattress now comes morning and the hawala is that a Cayenne before he starts to avoid there every morning when the company's mothers I had to sanctify their hands and feet that appear a washing basin and they had to put their hands and feet under it and wash them and cleanse them before they can go into the Masonic dish this was a heel and a strong penalty without it what happens if you were there a whole night and you were there and morning coming you want to continue that later the new avoided a new day there's our new day avoid the carpet Ahmed the Qatar is the midnight or whatever it is you're doing do you have to do conditioned fabric onto the Bryce it says yeah well earlier tone condition I'm red wine nasty because sub are Debbie Lima play sellers peculiar diamond red lion staying over the night even though you didn't go to sleep and you didn't leave the base um if this you have to do in return to the fire taboos waffle did this is a of rebbe what do we see from here what's loora loora means that night means my day he says he was standing all night obviously it means wiring the day for the Gemara are you a shiny others different meanings of gosh she hasted the tummy owner would probably grab you to do low chignon which says the word owner the buda also hold that means they in other words are eww who this says is nice too euphemism for night I hear Lisa clearly in the mission in the browser and today w-who the holes that the word Ida is different in are obviously earlier means light like hood in my Sawyer it also means life so already says is used as a euphemism for night but earlier you go back to the regular translation of later which is lipstick right and therefore the view that says that it means day and therefore there's no contradiction to the view hood there from this price what's your question the rocket over the source the rocket refer says this many many times there's a safer called my funniest swoon aspire of car sure yes and over there he creates a compilation of the main ideas of the record cover so there's a whole section there bein arse monsters how the rocket Rev understands banal nauseous right so what's the problem oh you mean why the three doubts well it seems like according to his interpretation that all three components exist meaning there are like almost three banished monsters let's put it that way right there's a banner smashes that is all day it's really day in other words even after sunset there's a time that's day to zerbino schmagges that's all night even before say ii of him our taste cook oven what we call to the government's already night but then the three painters Martius abhinash marshes in between that is this synthesis is the integration of yemen lila together with the to merge into a completely new entity which must come from a place that transcends both and therefore it could unify opposites because they and night are opposites light and light and darkness are diametrically opposed we see here how much the Gomorrah struggles if it's night or day or day or night or light or darker they're two opposites they're so different and we know daytime and nighttime are the two polar opposites yurts are very efficient so the fact that there could be a time in which both are integrated and become one to the point that yes but min hyeyeon a min challah according to the Ritz vine there are catch up in the morale and others who say that it's both this is a middle time so that would mean that there were there are three banished mattresses have been - marshes that's all day they've been our smartest that's all night they're banished marshes that is day and night together there's only one problem we don't know when it begins when it ends that's the problem so we treat from skia filter circuit oven we treat it as Suffolk um Suffolk Nayla but what we're learning here is that there's a concept of been hush marshes that is that is join right it's young there's a kind of inertia nauseous that's the Oh him that's what it seems to me yeah perhaps you could say that as well Rubina Tom we have been at UM holds that after she is still day by a bris yes that would be that would be a very important consequence that would be a very interesting question that's a good quiz yes let's think about it for a moment if a baby is born on Friday the bris is on Friday right the 8th day for baby is born on Shabbos the bris is next service because stay eighth day and you could do a bris even on Shabbos as long as you're doing the bridge some time yes the Khazar now that a bris a circumcision overrides Shabbos even though it involves violation of Shabbos but you could do a bris on Shabbos if it's the eighth day what happens if a Jewish boy is born Erev Shabbos Boehner schmagges Friday at Twilight Twilight let's say ten minutes after sunset what's the halacha you can't give the bris on Friday you know why cuz it made me night already so the baby was born on Shabbos if you give the dress on Friday give me the bris on the seventh day in Olano could you make the bris on Shabbos no because if the baby was born on Friday then Shabbos is the ninth day and you now let it do a bris on Shabbos if it's not the eighth day and again the baby was born 10 minutes after sunset so could be your Shabbos then you could do it on Shabbos but it could be was Friday if it was Friday remember it's Suffolk yo himself a Goliath so could me was Friday if it was Friday can do the Brits on Shabbos so Wendy do the bris you do the bris on Sunday you do the bris on potentially the 10th day you can't do it on Friday because it may be the 7th can do it on Shabbos because it may be the ninth so when do you do it you do it on Sunday which may be the tenth day since birth could of the baby was born on Friday Friday is 8 Shabbos is 9 sunday is 10 right that would be according to the Sugoi in him but according to Ben no tom we're bein harsh Marcia's only begins much later after sunset around 58 or 60 minutes after sunset almost a full hour after ski so a baby who's born Friday 10 minutes after skia when do you do the bris you do the bris on Friday cuz that's the eighth day you do them yourself Friday so now here is an interesting reality Kay you have two children they're both born in Muncie okay one is born one is born five minutes after sukhiya one is born ten minutes after skia okay one is born five minutes after ski one is born 10 minutes after skier the first baby is born into a family that follows the shittest are going him right the of the Vilna gone the to the Domitian of brewers has to be Marsh made the ballot Anja in his sitter that the shitty cigar in them yet the second boy who's born later rose is in a family that follows she just Rubino Tom you know the Hungarians and certain Polish communities who follow pitches have been at Tom completely know what's the halacha what's that Lhasa the boy who was born later he has a bris on Friday because they followed him into town and this boy was born on Friday because it was only ten minutes after skia so the boy has a bris on Friday the boy was burnt earlier when is his bris his bris is two days later on Sunday Kulik whitish it's a cigar nice watches that would be a very interesting very interesting ramification yes acquainted up in a time you could do work for an hour the bottom line is that in America and many other places even those communities who follow up in a time like Satmar Hasidim and other custom Belzer Hasidim there were many most of them many of the hungarian communities Elysium is some of the many of the polish communities who found a vein a time nonetheless usually they do it only for stringency not for leniency at least publicly so for example Friday you will not see them doing you know driving around half an hour after Shabbos a half an hour after sunset you won't see them driving around the car privately is a different story but but publicly they they will they will conform to the conventional to the conventional sharpest equation to sectarian amia this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate