Gemara Pesachim 6a: When Can You Have Chametz of a Non-Jew

the yeshiva dotnet so what was the summation of Daffy Hamid vase and a Vova monolith that we have two distinct sukham about not having comets for seven days the first posture can partials boy Marcia Robin who says she Vasya mom's lawyer mocks a pivot a hub for seven days yeast should not be found in your homes he doesn't mention anything outside the house nor does he mention anything about yours all he says is so flat any type of yeast anybody's east can't be in your home that's how I would have interpreted but then a few verses later the new sock the text changes after they leave Egypt where Hashem tells Moshe that Laura la ha ha mates behold Volkov Allahu Allah so Arabic old volka you shouldn't see comets or east for yourself in all of your borders for yourself you shouldn't see so suddenly he expanded it from homes to borders and he limited it from flats comets - for yourself you shouldn't see comets for yourself which we interpret to mean shall hiya Terra you can't see your own but you may see in your property comets of others for example of a Gentile who's allowed to have comments on Pesach of course or heck dish the base are Mick dishes comets which does not belong to you at all so as the bracer and the Gemara explained from the contrast and the comparison of these two pursue cim we derive the various halakhah is about what type of comets you're allowed to have in your and in your properties and what type you're not the first posture gives me the lesson that I'm now lateral even hide comets even if I don't see it because it says it shouldn't be found so that's principle number one I'm now let out even hide comets yattaman because it's still found right the second passage gives me the limb or the lesson that anything that belongs to me any property that belongs to me is part of my domain even if I don't live there it's not my residence nonetheless I'm now letter have comments there as well I compared sir Irish soil which applies the Holocaust of the first person to the second and a second to the first which means even outside of my home I'm now letter hi comets and even in my home I'm a lot of have comets that does not belong to me that's not look ha it's not the Comets that is yours for you so I apply the stringency of the first in the second and I apply this leniency of the second in the first and we make absolutely no distinction of what type of comets you're allowed to have in your home as long as it's not yours it belongs to the Gentile I don't care if it's somebody who's not under me or somebody who doesn't live with me or even somebody who is under the domain of the Jew or even lives with them in the same courtyard which you might say over there the distinction should be made that you should tell them to get rid of it because you have the authority to tell him and he's with you and it's much more accessible nonetheless we say that Lahab means if it's not yours it's fine oh yeah oh yeah bottle okay Mitchell guevara and as Rob explained we have Tula cause we have the Loch Awe of marshes boy we have the local purchaser a which we can use as well and that is that el we've learned that every type of comets that's not yours it belongs to the gerontology field and yet the Bryce have made one critical distinction and set your ladder have comments of a non Jew in your home at a racial Hayden but you now let it be Makabe a Picard I'm in an artery you now let accept comments from a non Jew and keep it in your home or your property on Pesach which seems like a contradiction and this is where the Gemara explains that the price obviously distinguish between two types of comments of a non Jew there's the Comets that is in your home but you did not accept responsibility for it in other words it's exclusively his even though it's in your domain perhaps he lives with you perhaps he's staying with you perhaps he brought it in perhaps he gave it to you he gave it to you to watch the guard but you're not assuming responsibility for it that comments you're a lotta half you cobble picada nappy cousin is usually something that you commit yourself to watch meaning I take responsibility for it and then it's forbidden ah you'll say if it says Loyola huh that means you shouldn't see comments for yourself meaning comments that is for you how much that belongs to you why would this comets be considered belonging to you when it does not belong to you and this is the very important distinction between the fact that in the first parsec my shrah Boehner did not put in the word Lacan he just said law you might say beaver taken he could have said shiver shamans are well you might say lehem beaver taken that would have been appropriate just as he says later law you're all the costs are be called wool hog Valletta the fact that he doesn't say law you might say look hem ever taken is teaching me that he wants to teach me that is also a concept that seven days you now would have any comment while you might say beaver take him sir or not you're sorry not really much similar chemical be for you your own well you might say without Aloha why because you want to teach me a principle that all comfort is now gonna be in my home so now I'm left with a contradiction in one place you tell me that the principle of that having comes only to mine in another place the first place you tell me the principle is complete absolute cuz I'll are struggling with this why would you do this the answer is because we have to make a distinction and this is where they made this distinction between two types of comments that are not mine there's a type of comments that's completely not mine that I will permit because it says Loyola huh but law you must sit without with him teaches me that even a type of comments that is somewhere in twilight zone it's not mine and yet it has some type of relationship with me why does it have a relationship with me because I assumed responsibility for it it's under Mike here it's not just physically in my domain it's under Mike here I assume responsibility for it it has a connection to me that would be the Comets that even though it's not mine it's a Gentiles I'm forbidden to have in my house because it says law you might say without a look and even though rather applied the second law ha of layer of Marcia's Rachel or you might say the fact is he applied it it was a cut paste but it was not there and it remains not there it's some amino Union that itself is precise and meticulous I will apply it to teach me that the application of Sequoia to our goals on any type of gentle even a gentle who lives with me as one thing of not taking responsibility that's where I will use the look huh but the fact that it says no you must say without all the car overcome teaches me that is a situation in which no comments is allowed to be in my house even not my comments cuz it just says stam comments any comments but another pasa the answer is those comments that's in between it's not mine but I took responsibility that's where we say the Casal said we have to say from the structure of the sukham that that would be prohibited and that is the Halawa if a non-jew puts comments in my house and i take responsibility for it I take a cries for it I assume responsibility even though it's completely not my comments and if he comes back in middle of face of her after pacer he has a full right to the comments I can't pay him back with money nonetheless at how much I will be over on Bao he must say she massamba a robbery matzah she Michelle LOI mud say I will be over on that comets if it's left in my house for Pesach biblically because I took responsibility for it and the Gomorrah said it's not only because we hold over had veritable Imam and command dummy rip Shimon holds that something that causes a benefit for money it's as though you have equity in it meaning since you would say that if the Commons gets stolen by a thief I'm gonna have to pay back the 500 bucks so the fact that I have this comments in my house gives me some equity it's like one of my assets it's giving me 500 watts even though I can't sell it for five hundred dollars it's not mine but the fact is but the fact that it's here is allowing me to keep five hundred dollars in my bank right because if somebody steals it I would lose that money sort of Shimon holds that's called having equity in this common it's it's called that I have some type of ownership in this hummus it's giving me some monetary benefit that's not the Vaart because that would only be a coordinate of Shipman even according to the other opinions you say it's not called I have equity of this comments even though who would get lost I would have to pay for it but the bottom line is that it's not mine in any practical way but the fact that the plastic says law you might say without Allah hem that teaches me that when it comes to comments since if it would have got stolen or lost the burden the burden of loss that is on whom on the Jew just like if I have something and I lose it the burden remains on me so here even though I have no equity in this comments over a girl Imam and any command on but since I assumed responsibility for it I'm taking care of it I'm concerned for it and I would even have to pay for it so the targeted treats it like garbage comets as though it's mine because it doesn't say oh you're MOT say like him and that's how we explain the distinction and thus you cannot keep this hummus in your house so yes so you're asking a good question so how do people have refrigerators or frigerators or pantries with comets of an Andrew in their home they tuck it can't take responsibility well when it comes to selling comets to a guy I mean if if theoretically if theoretically he wants to pay up the money and take the comets he's allowed oh he's allowed oh you can't force him otherwise I mean we all trust that most Gentiles will not want to deal with the entire Muncey and coming up with I don't know a forty-five million dollars and buying off houses and apartments and garages and comets and so earth but Pratt but theoretically speaking let's think about it practically forget about everybody's selling their comments if you sell your own comments to a guy before Pesach right you have a whole pantry with I don't know 600 bottles of a vodka liquid that are very expensive it costs $20,000 and and you know you don't want to burn it you don't want it to get so you don't want to burn it right and and you sell it to him right it's his property now if he want now he may give you $10 as a deposit but he owns you he olds let's say $20,000 for it if he comes after pesos and says okay I'll give you the $20,000 I'll pay up my loan and I take it there's nothing you can do about it but he has to pay for it you may not want oh but the question is legally legally if somebody steals it are you massive to pay him for that loss no if you have to pay him for that loss it could be a problem well soon see an argument the next sigma2 naxi anti service what happens if you designate a special place in the house Komets do you still do you still are you still now let it take a tries but at least according to many opinions you're now let over some responsibility for it meaning if you have responsibility for his combats in your home it's a it's a problem that's law you must say you now let her have that comments and your hope even though it's not yours because you're a curious makes it yours according to this area psycho so when it comes to beer come if you if your insurer if you insure against that if the guy uses you as an insurance so you have a response very good that's for you have a neighbor a Gentile right he's going to New Zealand to see the Kangaroos and he stores a case of whiskey in your basement and you're not assuming responsibility for and you're not selling it to him cuz it's not yours to sell them it says that's what we're learning here that you're allowed oh are you walking in your basement and there's whiskey right dear and you never sold it any good but it doesn't belong to you it belongs to the guy and you did not assume responsibility for it which means somebody breaks into the house class for solemn and takes away this whiskey right you will not assume any responsibility for it right there is one opinion that I did mention yesterday and that is that even if you assume the most basic responsibility but most basic responsibility means that you're not gonna be negligent in other words you're gonna keep an eye on it according to many that is also considered an assumption of responsibility which is a much more stringent view in other words if the guy puts down the whiskey and I say listen I'm not responsible for this I'm not dealing with it I'm not worrying about it you want to do it do it that's fine right even if I assume responsibility basic responsibility that I won't be negligent but I don't assume responsibility if it gets lost or it gets stolen right according to many that would be fine that's the posture sagar mariano according to halakha at least one view in a locker very a very common view which you could rely on however i'm just saying there is a that said that even the most basic level of a highest meaning that I'm going to assure no negligence I'm taking responsibility I'm not gonna do X I'm not gonna I'm not gonna put in an alarm system for you I'm not gonna become a bank with a safe what no well if you're locking the book if you like you the door anyway that's fine we're talking if you tell them if you Makabe lock rious any point of our eyes it could be in it it could be an issue now let's see further so this is the basic structure of how the Casal understood these helices analyzing the bracer and putting all the sukham together again I can't say law you must say means that even if I didn't take a crisis I should transgress the is sir because it already says law you're all a cop so we already know that the trader allows you to see in your home or in your property come as it doesn't belong to you so I can't say law you must say I can't expand it and say okay no comments in my house I could have come it's in massive it's not mine so what's the logical division to make assume responsibility there's some responsibility we know also if we could go from the monetary to the psychological in psychology there's a concept called codependence anybody here it deals with called dependence what what's a lot of codependent system acaba la crise you assumed responsibility for what's going on in everybody's life in your house and it's a form of ownership even though you don't actually own it you don't really own it but in your mind you carry around and that people who deal with it know you're basically carrying around a lot of comments that doesn't belong to you because you take responsibility for it and you have to know when to take responsible you take responsibility for your own things you can't take responsibility for other people's comments you take responsibility for your own and when you take responsibility for other people's lives and other people's comments you don't actually help them eliminate it you just expand now the Komets into your property and only their property in fact that doesn't allow me to be part of the solution because I become part of the problem that's just how they recovered now we come to the next stage you could think about this that's part of enabling enabling and I become the guilty one and I take full responsibility there's no boundaries so Kabbalah zacharias is some form of ownership even though technically you don't own it but you sudden how became the owner suddenly but this Commons became my baby and the tire compares it to my comments even though monetarily it's not my comets and I may not or have equity and it depends on the two views of how you learned over algorithm the moment it doesn't have to be hidden no the guys home it does not have to be hidden you asked you a question why don't we tape the closet or why don't we why don't we seal the closet so we'll see we'll see later in the Gemara the government I love why we do that but as far as we're concerned at this moment you could see it and open you don't have to hide it while you're all the saw the comment that is yours your now let us see I will after oh yeah you could see him here yeah so at least when hot area we'll soon see the Casal were afraid of people eating it so they made a special precaution but at least when I turn I can have that whiskey on my counter in my kitchen huh in the open and I see it the whole Pacer but I'm not seeing my whiskey it's fine I'm seeing your whiskey it's the Gentiles whiskey or heck - based on McNish and i didn't assume responsibility for it it's fine we'll soon see a precaution about about not having it in the open completely so the pushers mitts out of fear of eating it because it's right there we'll soon see the next piece sucking tomorrow right there that Volvo mode Aleph one two three four five I'm sorry four lines from the top one two three four four lines from the top that last two words boom in a mere over another question which has to do with something that is connected to a non-jew but it's buyer jew-bomb in a manner where they asked a question from rather bahama our nuna an animal that is subject to royal taxes hi-yah verse baqara ain't reverse vampire there were rules in certain countries our noona is a royal tax 10% of your animal offspring has to go to the king this is called our noona which is a royal tax my sir but not my sir to the divine means we're talking about my sir a tenth that's going to the king the void here is not so much 10% of me 10% me 50% could be 9 percent or 20 percent the point is huh this is called the royal tax royal tax yeah hey yeah yeah hey yeah visible Prairie Evers mcclare very fascinating question is my boy the first male born am i obligated in the obligations of her or not what's the question we know the toyota obligates a jew that when you're domesticated kosher animals kosher domesticated meaning a cow a sheep or goat those three bucer sign sheep goats and cows give birth the first male born offspring of the kosher domesticated animal become sanctified it has a kedusha we say Kaddish LICO card it's actually the first instruction of moisture gave shem told him after callously called car right koko what's lost god there's a cop car Petric all wrapped up in a straw but Adam Hoover bahama legal and it goes to the column if it's actually a complete animal meaning its unblemished he brings it as an offering in the baser mikdash we read about it every morning hop higher my sir Pastor Scott from column a plural a Korean name belongs to the cayenne and he can eat it part of it goes on them as bed if it's a bomb boom if it's blemish then he can't believe all as a carbon then either it was born that way or later a blemish happened so then it's still the clients but it's about moments like a regular animal that he could use the way he would like to use it okay because once it's farther this boy in taxes no police mela mela the juice came early so what's the question what's the question the question is as follows let's see Rashi hi a visible Clara our noona her Malinois to assume in a Bama minute for the royal taxes the king takes 10% of all your animals and all your produce all your grain taxes I ever spoke wrote the kind alone we have our locker coal she had not any been some to them in operator just like the animal of a Gentile it spot to from Cairo he doesn't have to give it to the Cayenne whether the mother belonged to a Gentile or whether the fetus belonged to a Gentile which is why if somebody buys from a Gentile the fetus of a cow the cow is gonna give birth and you buy that fetus when it's still pregnant from a Gentile its partner from Clara if somebody sells his feet is to a non Jew it's pot they're from because I really because it says dick - steely cold Kirby is strong right cutters to cut practicum maybe salt belongs to the Jewish people what about if there's a partnership me and a guide together yeah by a cow the next year 50% 50% the next year she gives birth to a baby boy is that guy even brighter or not higher than player I own it but he also owns it we bought together a cow fifty-fifty this cow becomes pregnant she gives birth to a baby a baby the next year or whenever it is a male is a try of employed or not so now she is crime alone we have our locker cold she had not remember to demand upgrader as long as there is the hand of a Gentile involved it's exempt from questionnaire mark lee coke RB straw love Ali bhai Carly called her petticoat recommend a halt for this passage that he quotes here is it national eco car Bistro the sanctification is only absurd that is born among G strong meaning it belongs to and it says cold car which means then tie up lawyer has to be a user own not half of the clerk so therefore even partnership will exempt it now here's a question is this called partnership or not I own the animal but the king has a lien 10% goes to him now he may not take the boy he have to give him 10% but somehow there's a partnership in the sense that he has a hand yeah EMSA in these behemoths so now she says hey ders as she's Sushant well as beside this flock that 10% of the king is inside of it meaning 10% of it any 10% belongs to the mela I ever spoke earlier losses Leclaire not relish on my life so when the first male is born do I have the obligation to give the car in the bahar do I say no it's like a partnership that I have between me and a Gentile even though it's not a classic partnership we didn't buy the cow together but because of the royal taxes I'm obligated now basically basically if if it would have been a partner in all of the offspring it wouldn't be a question that he's exempt from kyra because as we said shoots first with a non-jew exempts you from Clara however the case in this tax has to do with this he doesn't take a tenth of every baby that would be very difficult he takes a tenth if you have a hundred animals right over the year he'll take ten out of it so maybe the coin could come to the Jew and say give me my pyre it's my baby so the Jew tells the Cayenne excuse me I have a partnership with the King he's getting 10% the coin will say one second you don't know which 10% the king is going to take maybe he's gonna take 10% of females maybe he's gonna take 10% of babies that were born later in other words your boy already has the caduceus player or maybe the owner could tell the client the mela has a stake in all of it he could take the part I can't tell him the car is not yours this is not part of the partnership and therefore bahama Snorri is partner from Croydon he has the right he has to write you on Milo who are the goomar explains yeah yeah is this call is this called should research not culture to us so they might call a to the matzo masala clabe Azusa logically we would say this wherever you could pay him up with money locally boil on the highest then there's no question that Luca OD would be higher in the tradition of higher why suck trashy the matzo masala Clayton Akamai slightly Boylan Kievan Ducati Lusaka not RIBA since the Gentile did not yet take it VD no a Nakuru ah behind Yoshimura Maya's and he doesn't have a stake in the animal more than the money it can remain Milo you Tim IB missile mas alla Maya's the client could say nobody told you to give him animals give him money in other words you want exempt her from kaduche you don't have a right for that he doesn't care about the animal he cares about the money it's the price so if you could give him money instead of it so it's basically just a form of monetary taxes it translates into animals but the ideas money so male the client could say this is not called a partnership in the animal it's called the practices application you could pay it with an animal you compared with money since he didn't take it yet he didn't take the PO obviously if he took the prey to look good and money you could give him so then you would say that your high key coming boil on the question is one second a turtle a matzo masala claim is looser if you can't compensate it with money in other words the taxes on animal itself my wall would be the halacha are the offspring are the offspring putter from crater not part of a murder on Milo who rather says Peter oh you're exempt why you exempt because even though it's possible that the king will take another animal and not the preferred but we look at the ploy to something that this Gentile has a stake in it he's like a partner in it even though he may leave this he may take another one but since 10% of your entire of your entire farm of all the animals that are going to be born belong to him and if he would want he could take the part it's not like he made a condition with you that toy is off off limits so the player only belongs to you there's no such a thing he made the ass he may not and you can't compensate with money so therefore rather says that this is like an uber a fetus of a non Jew or at least partnered with a non Jew it's exempt okay but can you question and how could you ever say something we have a Bryson hi Evers royal taxes you must leave in hire now doesn't say what we're talking about but the Gemara understood they were talking about animals so he's hustling demotic masala clay you could explain simply that rice is talking about in a case where the King allows you to compensate him with money since he allows you to compensate him with money as we explained in such a case it would be obligated to give the part to the client this is the story the way it happened according to one of her Academy there was another version on my robber r-robber said the Hema Sarno nappa to him in a polite Bahama sir no non animal that's gonna but subject to role taxes is pop the from crater I forgave the moxa masala clay according to this version Raoh was actually much more lenient even though you could compensate him with money and you don't have to pay the taxes through the animal itself as long as you didn't as long as you didn't the taxes applies to the animals and this is considered yad not RIBA EMSA Rashi says I forgot the matzah masala clay the whole camera the lights all coy because as long as you didn't you're the shy big behemoth you could say his hand is at stake he has equity he has equity and all the animals yes if you come with money will he take it yeah but the Masters on the Bahama sort of male according to the first version the time is that it's not considered a curry in the animals he has equity in your property but the second version is even if you could pay him with money since the mass applies to the Bahama so it's called he has a partnership he has equity in these animals and therefore every one of these animals that were born this year including the car whether it's from a cow or from a sheep or from a goat is a should suffice with the king and since he's not Jewish so therefore your partner from Korea completely yeah yeah yeah SEZ SEZ SEZ drove a further assassin una when it comes to royal taxes of dough remember the king has a royal taxes for your animals yo says a roll taxes for your grain gotta pay taxes on everything so when it comes to esis our Nona the dough that you didn't give taxes yet let's say 10% of your grain so now you have barley or spelt or whatever it is or wheat and you have to give taxes however spatula here you're obligated to give a holler I forgot little matzo masala clay even in a case where you can't compensate them with money which is very strange why let's remember what this case is the halacha is there's a midst recessive in aterna that if I need dough if I mix flour and water of any one of the five types of grain usually attributed to to wheat and barley and spelt and oats and rye growing in H is strong if the dough is of a certain size it can be a very small size but those are certain significant size the volume of 43 and 5th of an egg so they'll feel this to take part of this doll or the bread that I baked from this dough and give it to the client this is called column this is the Mitzvah of power in addition to the trauma that you have to give to the Cayenne before it became dough when it's still when it's still before before you grinded it into flour when it what still stalks or kernels this is something else this is a mitzvah I say that you have to give challah what happens if you don't give challah from a dough it's called Tavo you now let it eat it just like you now let eat grain from which you did not give trauma the dough of a non-jew is putter from challah the plastic says raices Irie say say hem your dough you have to give trimmer what about dough with is a partnership again you and I over the field me and I mean me and a non Jew owner field and we have all this gray now and we have dough that's comes from this grain so each piece of dough there's a partnership me and a non-jew so here it depends on the size if we would split it up into two and my size is decides that's makovan hala then I have to give collar from it but if if we would split it into two my part would not be McRaven hala would be too small so then we learn out that I'm putter from Kawa that's the halacha so rava says what happens if I have a royal tax that I have to give from the dog if I will give this part of the king yes very good if I will give this part to the king I will not have the shear of dough that's McCoy even kala nonetheless it's kyuman kala that's what Rashi says Easter sir no no I am but I forgot the is just not rip Torah even though the dough of a non Jew will exempt for ISIL you Straubel I shower and a Jew can eat it without Khalid re so safe M Civ Xue hai Avis this dough is obligated to give halibut why if I'm a partner with a non Jew and a dough let's say we both buy a piece of dough together we own it together right if it's not big enough that my own part is high even kala the whole thing becomes partner from Carl and I can eat it we could bake it and I can eat it ghazan teh that my family can eat it so what's the issue here why is Easter sir known as IRA so maybe you could say because you can compensate it with money so since you can compensate it with money like we explained before he doesn't have a stake in the dog but Robert said even if you can't compensate it with money which means which means he does have a stake in this dog and he's gonna want it so what's the justification that my timer why are we so stringent why is it so stringent why don't we consider the obligation of taxes as a partnership and even if you're gonna tell me or we may not take from this dough he may take from another though I understand that was the same case by the heard he may not take this animal but the fact is he has a hand in all of the dough's he could take from any dough and that's considered a partnership and if he takes from it it's going to be not cashier the answer is Bahama isla : silikal animals has a coil it's public knowledge when it comes to a doe Lesley color it's not public knowledge what does this mean so Rashi says in E C's are known as high average let's continue the Leslie color it's not famous for Haro your own michalowicz level and color somebody in your kitchen sees that you're eating dough without however the Bahama easily color buy a Bahama it has a coil by the time you high ever be sue the tiny so when the price it says you're high of in the dough you how you was talking about a dose not talking about a Bahama according to the second version we rubber says that a Bahama is always putt what is Rashi telling us what is it actually telling us when it comes to Bahama swen it comes to animals it's public knowledge everybody knows that this person has a farm it's public knowledge everybody sees it and everybody knows that the government imposes taxes and if you have a farm you can't hide your animals and confine them then I'm gonna be able to live they have to be in the open thereafter grace so it's public knowledge and therefore it's public knowledge that you own this and therefore it's public knowledge that you have to give 10% for taxes so everybody knows that the mela is a partner in your flock and therefore we're not afraid that somebody's gonna say oh this Jew doesn't give a fire because it's very obvious why he doesn't give a carbon prior to the ad call Ian because the King owns part of it however when it comes to baking Godot Leslie caller not every yen 10 yeah Keenan knows that I'm sitting and baking the dough in my house that the government knows exactly about what those I have a mouth what those I don't have a mouth so therefore you can hide it from the taxation of the King so therefore even in a case where they do know and he's imposing taxes on me a lot of people don't know and they might think that I'm eating tether I'm eating dough without garlic with its Leslie caller doesn't have a coil nobody knows what's going on so when they see me taking the dough and baking it and eating it and not separating collar the guests in my house might assume that what that I'm not taking collar even though the truth is that I don't have to because I have a partnership with with the mouse agent Kallus in economy in economy there are such you're right this is one way of learning it that basically people can escape it much more they can escape this taxes much more and sometimes if your King was a tyrant and and a thief and rats and you want to do you tried and people could starve so they try to do this but even if you're not and you're potter leslie color doesn't have a coil in other words the government mainly king may not know about it and therefore you may escape it and therefore people will think that you actually not giving taxes and it's your dome Amish and therefore you push it not not taking Colin there are shots ads I just want to say there are shots ads that generally the king didn't take taxes from the dough it's a little awkward he would take taxes from the grain you would take taxes from the grain however if you didn't get from the grain then they could take from the dome so therefore when he took taxes from the grain once you made a dough that dough is already yours because you really gave taxes right so this situation where he didn't take taxes from the grain and he's coming to take taxes from the dough it's not obvious to anybody that part of this is gonna go for taxes because you're supposed to get from the grain you just didn't and the IRS monitored you when they said well okay we'll come with you taking the dog so in this case if you don't take power somebody's gonna think you're mama she's not taking Charlotte because you're already supposed to give taxes and this collar is yours this dough is yours the fact that you're not doing it is because you're not much but in the midst of color and therefore we don't allow the stats right you know that if it would have a coil if it would have a coil if everybody would know that this dough is subjected to taxes and it wouldn't be a problem but since they don't know cuz they think that I already gave taxes from the grain so therefore this dough is just my daughter I really gave my taxes from the grain now I have no in my house this is completely mind there's no partnership here right and they see I'm not giving sour you're in my house I'm you're not gonna color what do you think I don't give Carlos yeah that's what it is even though I'm talking now I don't have to give collar because he didn't take taxes yet you're right that's the shot Leslie call the means it doesn't have a coil but says it doesn't have a coil people don't know that this is subject at the taxes cuz usually you supposed to give taxes from the grant there's two types and how to say Leslie caller then doesn't apply we're talking about a non Jewish King the Romans obvious to Romans yeah if I'm taco partner with a non Jew in a piece of dough yeah then pack I don't have to give how but in this case it's a little different because it's taxes for the Kings well no it's very important because if if I'm a partner with a non Jew in a dough and and together both of our dough's together both of our the versus in the dough there would be a sheer kala I would be Potter right but if in my part of the shits vez there would be a sufficient shear for kala then I have to be my fresh color in my part we're not gonna be eating this dough together you know from your mouth as to my mouth at some point we're gonna split it right huh like a bakery yeah yeah so if there's a shear kya van hollen in my my suits force itself in my part itself then I'm a - hallo so obviously the question here is that even if when the mouthfuls comes and takes its part that will not remain a shear still I'm Chi even kala that's the right up ms really good pass juice if it's joke the Jewish King it's different yeah I wish it is a she right what hunger a bond on the rabbi's taught luckily if you have a non Jew significant aside say to show you stroll he enters into the courtyard of a not of a Jew hoops akley beyond a and he has a dough of Hermits in his hand or should the practical situation a neighbor comes in to say hi to give you a gift to deliver something that came to his house in the mail it's a middle of Pesach and he comes in with a pie or pizza or he comes in even better eating a pizza I made soup they could be other a knuckler fire you don't have to say yep go do me a favor do me a favor I'm gonna come meet you outside stay outside of the house in other words you don't have a responsibility to get rid of this comments from your house you don't have to ask him to please let's go speak outside let's not speak in the house because I don't want comments in my house this is a very practical ulka which is based on the whole stogie before I'm allowed to have comets in my house if it doesn't belong to a drew so he comes in eating his pizza or he comes in with a pie of Domino pizza I don't have any responsibility to say Oh outside of the house it's paste I don't want practically you may want to be careful because you don't want pizza in your kitchen sink for obvious reasons I'm paisa but we're not talking about that we're talking about MIT's have LOI raw obviously you don't want to put the pizza in the couch and then your kid is gonna sit down and maybe eat the Domino pizza which is a shot not only pay sign but also oh yeah but the point is used okay if they get rid of the scum it's l'viyah to practically to say please let's go out of the house because I'm not let have this in my house why because it says la a la la Komets lawyer Allah call you now let us see comments that is for yourself comments served for yourself meaning come as that belongs to you which is reserved for you not comments which is reserved for somebody else because it's non-jewish if ki know yet slowly the price that continues and this is really a summation practical summation before what happens if he doesn't enter into your courtyard or your home God Sarah means your courtyard or your home with comments rather he died yet sly he deposits the comments by you that's a very different story he didn't come in with his pizza or his bagel or his cheesecake he's giving it to you as a pica dine and we're talking about with a crisis with responsibility he deposits it by you I want you to be the custodian for my hummus as Rashi says ain't a sucker clavier la he's Kiku Lloyd see us on our human abayas they don't tell you to take him out of the house to ask him to leave Kadam Martin about her show hey hey Skeever yets Lloyd the Kabul alia Reyes and you assume that her eyes give them a financial as the camara will explain Sacco clavier and then the halacha is you have to eliminate it from your house on pay somebody comes to you and says here this is a deposit and it's with responsibility and then pacer comes this was let's say a month before Pesach and pacer comes or coke levar you you know that I have this comments in your house you have to give it back you have to give it back to this man and if you aah or take off or iose or burn it and compensate them you could burn it and you'll pay him back you took a hiatus you'll pay him back but the comments is not to use it's not in the house anymore you said Lloyd is a new situation what have you designated a house for him what does it mean you hid my bias Rashi says Coloma like he Blair love he didn't accept responsibility Emily tells him hariya by useful for not for here this house is in front of you how much but access Mina's obvious go I have a big house go find yourself a corner yeah there's a lock of it as a shelf that is a cabinet there choose a corner and put it there that she says that's what shop you should load bias this is my bias means basically I'm not talking about the comments I'm not telling you here leave me the comments I'll take care of it I'm basically showing you a place in my house and I say listen I let you I let you use my house to store your comments so Rashi says this means he's not being makka belarius ain't sucka clavier then you do not have to eliminate this comets from the house shan mr the passage says law ye must say comets should not be found threatening about of my karma what does the law you must say have to do with this after on the contrary law you must say means you know that have comets in your house here you telling me that if he comes in with go into my house I could leave him there if he deposits the comets and I take responsibility I cannot leave at their pace but if I designate for him a place in the house and I let him put it there then I could leave it there shouldn't mr law you must say with his law you must say prove this point my karma what's that you're giving me a hat there that you're louder doing and then you tell me no you must see and I won't have comets the answer is a murder if Papa raesha call you you're right this pasa Chloe much is not referring to the last Clause it's referring to the earlier clause the hockey car mark 15 diets like if he deposits by you comets with responsabilities soccer club ieft eliminated should name my law you monster because it says law you might say and it doesn't say no you must say look what ambivert ate them it shouldn't be found for you in your home meaning the comments it's reserved for you it says law you must say any comets in your home so what did we learn from here that even non-jewish comets if you took responsibility you're assuming responsibility for this because then you're now what I have so ref purpose says the law you motsi is not referring to the last clause of the price it's referring to the previous one where it says you now that I have a tie of Leviathan neva Shiomi revoir she says Lola must say Furcal you know that's not true the possibly the Tanner brings actually refers to the last clause of the price I it says you're allowed to have it well hopefully come but this is how you have to explain you could lie by use if you designate a corner in your home a section of your home to this non Jew to POTUS comments and you're not taking responsibility as we explained if you say clearly you're taking responsibility then I don't care if you designate a coroner according to this explanation but if you see if it's clear you're not taking responsibility that actually clearly says you didn't take responsibility a knuckle avaya you don't have to eliminate it why Shan Emma and this he says LOI matza vive Tatum it shouldn't be found in your home bah ha and this comets love d-day who it's not considered his did not rica kamyelle because when the non-jew enters comets into this house the base of the knife shaker mile he put it into his home and it non-jew didn't assume any responsibility it says so our law you might say pivot 8 hem it shouldn't be found in your home here you designated a place for him that place is like his place where he could keep the Comets you're not taking responsibility so therefore there's no connection to you it's not like your comments this comets therefore is not considered your comets when he brings in comers to this house it's like he's bringing it into his own home it's not pivot fm if you would take a highest that would be different but since he's putting it into his little corner of the home that you gave him permission it wasn't a theft you gave him permission almost like you rented it let's say you rent somebody a corner you didn't rent it you give him permission but it's the same idea I let you use a closet in my house a draw they say go to the draw put the Comets it's almost like I'm renting you that drew even if it's not for money but the point is you have rights for the next 8 days or the next month or the next six months to keep your Mashka and that drawer put your stuff there goes update so in May let's not lawyer you might say before take him it's not considered my house when the guy goes in there well basically Africa mile it's like he's going into his own house Raschi says my car Meir hey Fiala famille oh you might say well am i safer below you might say marsh but when it says law you must say it's it means how matsui be your colour Hulka fades out law he must say means he must say means it shouldn't be found he must say also means available matzah means it's available it's common it's accessible so he says law you might say means how much would be up to local effects and it's available to you for any desire I knew the kabbala layer I used advocated a which would mean if you accepted responsibility which the halacha considers it as though it's yours when something is mine it's available to me for whatever I need if I have a sweater I could you wear it I could sell it I could give it to somebody I could use it for whatever I want it's available to me when it's Africa than it's yours it's not available to me but if I take a hiatus if I assume responsibility then what do we say then it's kiddy day it's as though it's even though it's not mine if a packet gets lost I think I have to pay for it but even before it gets lost I assumed responsibility for it I'm taking care of it like mine so the Toyota considers it kid d-day so therefore it says lo you mutts it has to be Matsui at silica Lahaul half a car so Rashi touches what does that mean it means it has to be either yours or like yours if you're my kabbalah friars cuz you're taking responsibility even though it's a cannot yours but you're taking responsibility here you did not take responsibility on it and instead you told him that he could keep it in your house but you did not take responsibility for it and therefore you are good to go so what is your bar what what is what is it of actually teaching us the bar she's teaching us that the only is sort to have comets as comets how Matsuri Loy it's accessible to you for your needs which means either it's yours or it's deemed like yours because you took her cries but if you tell them here is my house put it wherever you want or I tell you even where to put it or find a place it's not Maya Christ and therefore you're allowed to have this comets in in your home because it's not a gather of amat say so rabbi she learns this from law you must say Vivat a hem in other words in your house you have an issue though you might say but if I rent it or I give a part of my house to the guy he says this is true doesn't apply because this is not called Matsui the Comets in the rented home so to speak in the home that's you to the part of the Jews mother is not considered Matsui because I'm not taking responsibility for it I'm not taking responsibility for it but if it's in my house what do we mean it's in my house this is Austin Maya's but I gave this part to him and I said here use the drawer but I'm not connected to this I'm not gonna look after this draw that's not considered visitation and therefore he is good ref Papa didn't have to learn this limit of law you Matsuyama tell him because he holds that what he holds that it's a swara that if somebody says this house is your's he's not a Shimer he wasn't makka belarius he wasn't makka belarius and therefore he was amicable Elias it's not his Oishi though has this house suffered this extrovert of what you might say before take them it's not considered bassy if you want to know the Jew middle of Payson goes over to the draw takes out the Mashka and drinks it so he was over on a hill of Commerce banana buy a robbery matzah okay I mean by taking it probably the status change with Assad he stole it he stole it so became his right yes to pay for it now so yeah I'd only he'd probably be overrun by Eero to that moment when he when he when he picks it up I don't know if it's gonna work right says the Gemara LeMay Marie desirous Kanye are you gonna learn from here that something that's rented as long as he rents it it's considered belonging to the renter in other words the object that he rents or that which she rents whatever he rents is considered his do we say that it's the renters because he's using it or it's due the landlord because it's ultimately gonna come back to him as we'll see but non we learned to missioner the says in my second sub I deserve album akamaru lahaska in a place where they allow a Jew to rent out a home to an idol worshiper lullabies dear arm hrough it's never for him to live there with nation listen the certified is gelila we're talking about here an idol worshiper and if you give him your home to rent he's gonna bring in his getcha cos they're his idols there and a Jew is now that I have idolatry in his home so therefore even those who say a lot of rented to a non to an outcome torn over the Vedas are it's not it's for storage storage of animals or storage of objects or items but not not to live there now what is the background behind this behind this Mishnah the trailer says will hoist a carnival now let us sell real estate to an idolatry my second name to an AK l'm in Eretz Israel comes with mayor and if mayor says that Madeira born on you can't even rent fields or homes in area to stroll to an outcome why because you may come to sell it but say Surya what we would call this a Syria which is a different type of sanctity it's not air to stir all so the common only didn't allow you to rent fields because then they're not McCoy when the Mitzvah subtly as far as they won't do Thomas and my sisters because it's being used by non-jews but you could rent homes that's the view of Reb mayor the v.i.c holds that even they destroy a lot of rent homes the main is very stringent it's its law you can rent homes you could rent outside of a church so even in Syria not fields but the issue is selling but you can rent the home and edges sure that's not a problem says the Mishnah that even in those places we allow to sell a home to an idol worshipper either unites install the Pointer WC or in Syria or other countries according to the mayor it does not mean a residence because he's gonna bring in as a very deserving you know a lot of others are in your home it means he can use it for a stable or for other things not a place we is going to bring in avoid the idol worship he soccer I love the skirt on you but if you believe that a rented home is considered the acquisition of the rent as long as he rents it Kika mile evasive the mouth should kamiya when he brings another desire to the house he's been get into his own house when it gives you back to the house after the lease is over then it's considered your arm you have to get rid of that Vedas are but as long as I rent the house that the house is considered my house if you're telling me law you must say before tation does not include giving go you're right let's say I give him my basement and I say put your summits in your basement and that's not considered but a sham because it's like a rented place so to speak wherever there's even a closet even a draw that draws considered his draw so it's his house so it's not my house anymore because I was and I wasn't Makka belarius that's what about she said you saying a whole new you site here really so in Missouri why can you rent them a house and they're too strong or anywhere where a lot of rent let him bring in avoid this kick of him it's his house my house true I own the house he can't sell the house true it's gonna go back to me but for this year that he's renting it it says and for the Gemara so that so the question is we see that skyros is not gonna it's not considered his it's still considered my home and therefore that very desire that he brings in is my home so how can I designate a home a place in my home for his comments NEBOSH she said that from bottom I learned that if I tell you here's a place in your house for your thumb isn't enough to get rid of it from basis in other words the place that I lend to the non-jew to put his comment is not considered my own it's considered his home it's basically if you would rent the closet in my house you know people do it all the time in Brooklyn they rent garages yeah they read the classes they ran the garage shows there's so little space yeah so he rents might literally take say put it in the garage or go to the garage it's like he's renting the garage so I'm saying it's not my home it's his home that's AG about the hippie dish of of Rabat she it's considered mama SH his home sober mainly the gomorrah says if that's the case we have a big problem because this doesn't make sense the Mishna says clearly Spiros like Anya you're allowed to live there you'll have to use it but it's considered my home it's not considered your home that's why I'm now allowed to rent a residence to live for an avid could have him because when he brings in I dial it's considered me bringing it into my house even though he's bringing at him he's bringing into my house and it says la vie c'est al by circle the terror says in d'Ivoire and pairings Annie and I were to bring an abomination which is idolatry into your house and by the way this question is even according to the publication of purpose says the reason I let you have the comets in that corner I tape put the summit's in that corner I don't mind and we say it's fine because I'm not assuming responsibility I didn't tell you to bring the comets into my house right I'm basically telling you put it away summer if I tell you to bring it into my house it's a form of Kabbalah soccer is like I'll take care of it so the base of so this depends on saying if you say skier is Konya if you say that the place that I rent out it's considered your home so then when I tell you here go take the garage it's almost like I'm telling you put it in your house that's not caballes a crisis but if you say serious like Anja when you rent it's considered mine it's not considered iord so it's still considered mine so then right it would be like you tell me can I leave the Moskowitz and say of course put it here in my house which is a form of Kabbalah serious so the foyer when you tomorrow just says you should lie bias he says put it away in a particular place in the house I'd let you as Rashi says he tells him I read by useless Faneca the house is you you could put it in one of the corners right is that caballes a crisis or not if you say Cirrus kanya Sirius is corner then it's not couples of choice it's like telling you Oh find your house and put it there I'm giving you in my house a place that I'm calling your house but if it still considers my house it's like inviting it into my eyes which would be a form of Kabbalah sacra so this would be a question even according to your Papa who says it's all about a crisis so the gomorrah says the truth is it doesn't stop corner but shiny huh here is different you know why let's say if I could considered your house I don't mind I gave him a drawer the garage and it's considered my house and that's why by a voices or I'm now let it rent it as a residence that's true but shiny huffy here is difference you know why the FK da moneh balázs in law you might say the Turner employs the term lying matzah what does law you might say mean Misha Matsui biota the Comets that is accessible to you yachts are there she ain't a matzo Miata versus dis comets which is not accessible to you meaning says Rashi Rashi Shayne matzo Bianca sherry oysters of is mr. Alana three that corner is given over to the non Jew in other words the place where the Comets is you gave over to the non Jew to use it so therefore even if it's considered my house but it would be like I'm telling my friend put in the Comets into your home and I'm not being macabre la crise the main point here is that I did not assume responsibility for the comments because I didn't assume responsibility for the Comets even though it's still considered my home because cirrus like Anya you're allowed to use it but it's still considered my home as we see by my disorder but since the Tyler uses the word law you might say what does law you must say mean it has to be Matsui Bianca comets that's accessible to you what do we mean comics that's accessible to you comets if basically you told the guy here put the comments in a particular corner so that comments you gave over you told them put it in a particular place and that corner is given over to him for him to use this is not called Matsui because it's not called Matsui so therefore it's fine and you don't have to eliminate the comments even though the comments is in your house since you were not makka belarius according to this interpretation you did not assume responsibility how do we know you did not assume responsibility as Rashi says when you told them you did low bias you told them put it in one of the corners but it's your responsibility it's not my responsibility so even though it's still in my house but it's not in together since I didn't assume responsibility this is not considered my comets it's considered your comments and we say that even though it's considered my home but since the title uses the word law you must say so the issue is only on comment that's Matsui BRD what do we mean Matsui Bianca months of yoga means it's accessible it's available to you this comets in the house that is rented or given over to the guy is not Matsui because it's given over to him to use and therefore it's not considered Kabbalah Zacharias and I'm not over on this comments it's basically where Kabbalah chakras would mean I assume responsibility for it and it's considered Muhammad's even though technically it's not my comets but basically it's it's considered mine and therefore you need this concept of youth headlight bias it shouldn't be matzah it shouldn't be mass put away the even if you take a cries for summits the high do you ever you have an issue so basically what is they're actually telling us what is he telling us that if you feed low bias which means as Rashi says I did not accept arias rather I put that rise than you and you see it from my words because I said here take one of the corners of my house in other words I'm not taking responsibility for it that we say ain't no sucker clavier you're good because there was no cabal sir rious shanem allah you must say before take em it shouldn't be found in your home and even though it's considered my home cuz even if you're a renter it still considered my home the kilometers in my arm nonetheless this is not considered Matsui what do we mean Russia that crash he said what's before matzah he said Matsu years Matsui be absolute all cafe Sokka it's accessible to me for all my needs because it's mine or I was macabre rious but this is not Matsui and this corner is given over to the nori what's it mean it's given over to the nakri I basically said here take care of it it's yours even though legally the place is mine but the summit is given over to the nori so it's not considered Matsui it's not considered Matsui it's not really it's not accessible to me to use because because it's not Maya crisis right that's not my advice there's no relationship to me it's your summit you happen to put it in my house with my permission it's fine it's not considered even though it's found in my house but it doesn't go into the gutter bloody Maxime invitation why because it's not mine that's the ek right we learnt be full of your role a card this is not mine and it says lo you must have invitation it has to be Matsui Matsui means interesting that it's accessible to actually touches the Amundson means again it has to be accessible to me that I should be able to use it that this is not a gather of you must say we're fast Makabe Lara is then since it's far it doesn't say look how its considered mine ok I just want to bring out here that is one other major schita which is far more lenient and if you'll take a look at ty service you should lay by us just take a look this is quite fascinating Peter Shah countries the like cable all of our ayahs he didn't take responsibility on malaria by his love for NASA the house is your's put it where you want okay in other words I don't even have to know where it is by the way I revised the format so basically he's telling you don't even tell me where it is I'm not interested you know I'm not interested because I'm not taking responsibility that's how Raschi learns but Kaushal a real my area you can affiliative Nami if so why does the bride's to say you hid my bias even if not if Hitler bias even if he says here put it down but I'm not taking a hiatus it's good why does it have to be yet Hitler - maja Kaname Masek was so much remember the Spheeris Konya and at the end these taka he wants to say that serious Konya that Spheeris that spear is basically makes it his why is the Gomera looking for that the most trying to say that it's not your house anymore according to nationally who cares your house not your house the main thing is that horizon or crisis that's the main thing why does rashly say the main thing is he where of a couple of country home a couple of guys who cares if you put it on the couch I'm not taking us rice what's they gay and then you tomorrow wants the Saints because it's like a rental it's like he owns it and anyway I said no he doesn't own it finished up in a time that fellow bar is Miley the hitters of you said lay biases even I take responsibility for my sham Hakim alpha Camilo you might say and that's why you need lawyer matzo in other words if you say you weren't Makabe like rise then you already know that you're allowed to have it cuz it's not lawful here the finishes you assumed responsibility you give them a place in the house you say this is your place yours you could use it and I'm gonna be after I'm gonna watch this house I'm gonna make sure nobody gets there because you gave him his own house so to speak so we learn out from law you must say Beaver taste him it doesn't have to be in your house or at the ending of maurices from well you must say it's not mozzarella car it's not accessible or new limit the light hardship Matsui it's not a considered accessible bias because you gave them a designated place but if Papa is slim is smarter Republic doesn't even need a puzzler Papa holds that it's logical keeping she should lay by you since you designate in a place have a key looky below love a higher self MC shall not reap a based social mockery it would be like I assumed responsibility for comments of a non Jew in the house of a non Jew in other words let's say I have a neighbor son Andrew he's leaving stuff in his house comets and he says I'm leaving and I'm afraid could you guard this house could you make sure and you say fine are you allowed to do that on pay so he says of course it's his comments in his that doesn't make the comics mine the Komets is in my house and I'm a Kabbalah Freya's that's a lethal combination it's in my house right and I'm assuming I cry as that's considered mine but if the Komets is in his house and I'm a Kabbalah cries and it's comments then it's not a problem so that's the leadership tomorrow you Hitler bias when I designate a place in the house and I say go take toto take a drawer go take a clothes and go take a garage that's now considered your home and even though serious like Anya but it says low you might say you must say means it shouldn't be accessible to you since you made a special corner for him it's not hanging around you're going you're putting it here tomorrow you're putting it there it's a place where it's going to be designated cuz you gave him that place for him to use and you're not gonna use it you're not gonna go and change it and say I need this drum I'm gonna put it in a closet then it's a problem since you're making so that's considered as though it's his home you taking responsibility for the comments of a guy in the house of a God even though it's in your house but you designated a place it's not considered monthly so the law you motsi says that it's not much you're gonna have it so this is AG evolved to convert - he says you should lay bias is simply another way of saying you weren't Makabe love rice rabbina tom holds no it's a new it's a new hello you were my kabbalah cries and there's a special limit from where you might say that your letter have that comments in your house even though you'll my couple of rious why because you designated a special place for him and that place is not accessible to you because you're letting him use it even though a renter is not considered an acquirer that it says house it's still your house like we see by avoiders ARA but nonetheless because you designated this place for him to you and you gave them the right you gave them the right to use it not considered accessible to you like if I let you use a closet in my house so you go into your wife's closet yet Sakana stuff lucious if you start playing around there why you may own the closet I gave it to you to use it's not accessible to me what do I legally it's accessible to me I mean I could call you and I could say I need this drawer but the point is I made an agreement I let you use this place or I let you choose a place and I'm respecting it that's not considered matzah even though I was Makabe like rice it's just like if it would be in your house and it would be your comments a guy's house and a good something I'm not even by a robbery much you say what were you responsible for it what's so what I'm responsible for it so hot it's your house and your comets if it's my house and I'm a camel arias right he leaves it in my kitchen I just say you know what put it in the kitchen already I already deal with it you'll put it here I'll put it there that's already different cuz it's accessible to me and I'm a kabbalah crisis but if it's one without the other if you're Makabe laughs cries but it's not accessible to because you can't let my is I mean the time as a fiction is that happening tomorrow ain't no sucker clavier because it says no you matzah and all that it's a sweater just like it would be his own house Rashi does not learn that way rashly clearly learns from this Gomorrah that what if you macabre laughs cries I don't care we're in the house of this even if I designate a place in my house in my domain and a macabre lock Reyes what's the halacha I have to get rid of I have to get rid of that comments ah yes the guys house then everybody now still you would be fine if it's my house that's my house since Cyrus is not kind that would be the case so in other words Rashi Rashid this is the of Rashi is the of the ballas shelters it's also the of the riff and the Rambam how do we know cuz the Rambam and hooks us comics and matzah doesn't put in the case of if Hitler bias they ran bomb from the RAM you have to learn only what he not only what he write so somebody doesn't write he ignores this piece of Gomorrah that you should avoid bias in soccer clavier why doesn't it haven't put it in if you designate a place in the house you know if they get rid of it obviously there are mom holds it's just an extension of the halacha crisis since the Rambam already says if you accept our ayahs you now letter have it if you don't accept it guys you'll either have it to the random deletes this case because this case is not a substantial new case it's just a manifestation of the case the point is if I give you a place and house and I say here go find a place I'm not taking a highway that's why I said go find a place my house is your's treat it like you want and find yourself common sense don't bar it's basically a way of saying don't bother me leave me alone so the ramen doesn't have to bring this case because you ready brings the case of a rice so we're here we know that there are bomb and agrees with Rashi and the same is true the Rif who also doesn't bring this a walker in the whole office of the Gemara why don't they bring it because they hold that crash see that what that it's all about a crisis this is my bias is simply another way of saying that you were my Kabbalah rious and therefore it's not considered yours and even though it's considered your home right but I've actually believed that the law you might say the law you must say means it's not considered Matsui it's not accessible to you and why is it not accessible to you because there's no arise you have no relationship with it versus if you were Makka belarius then even if you designated a separate place it's considered motsi it's accessible to you for your needs just like it would be yours even though it's not yours but that's the finish that Kabbalah zacharias is what it's called shelcha it's considered yours because you own it you can see you're concerned over it we're up in a time and the other this twice verse another is shine and believed that it's not the case even with a Hayase even with a cry you see not McCoy if to be my violet why because it's like his home it's not considered your home even though even though comets of a Jew if I give from my own comets to a to put in his house then you would say you are overrun by your eval you might say because it's my comets if I give come if I give Mashka to a non-jew I'd say keep it for Pesach am I ever done by you not by him I'd say I would say yes because wherever the place that he put the Mashka he borrowed me that place he lent me he lent me that place so it could be considered mine but if it's his comets in his house and I'm a couple of tries we don't go so far and therefore in my house I'm not going to have it but in his house or a place in my house that I allow him to use it would be it would be completely it would be completely motor so according to thai service one of the two is fine even if your makka belarius even if he macabre cry as if it's a separate home [Music] I accepted responsibility for his comments his house but then it's far it's still it's still not mine it's still not my just like in his house it wouldn't be mine and even in my house if I designated a place it's gonna be mine this has the application to your question in the beginning of this year when we have comets in our house that belongs to a longer non-jew because we sell it to a larger right are we allowed to be macabre la crise according to the I'm in a time even if you're macabre like Reyes because because you designated a place huh and it's not Matsu to you it's not matzah - it's not accessible to you so that would be perfectly fine so even if you tell the guy right I'm assuming responsibility don't worry if somebody breaks into the house and takes the food I'm gonna pay you according to Rashi you would be overrun by your own body matzah but according to toy service you wouldn't be ever invited not by your mom say why because since it's a designated place that's not accessible to you you tape it up and you say this is your thing it's not my thing right so it's not a get rid of you must say and therefore we say just like if we would be in you're in the guy's house it's fine that could be macabre fries even though it's in the Jews house we have a special limit of law you might say that it's not motsi to me it's not mazuma to me it's not accessible yeah so this is a big McCoy curse in Hawaiian my skin are you allowed to let a guy put comets in your house and beam acaba la Reyes if it's a distinct place find a place but the point is you find the place oh you may tell me where that place is where I may show you but the point is it's a designated place it's not like I say you know leave it in the drawer and I already figure out we'll put it in the closet that we'll put it here then it wouldn't work then of course that's so that's enough second issue yeah when you're selling it has to be it is light because if it's his on my copy condo in which is different I'm just saying it's not the same case I'm just applying yes you know I'm gonna bring an avoidance R into your house what's uh BCA well they said no this is talking about a club talking about of non-jews today most non Jews are not where I'd I don't worship not nobody but there are but it's not the regular way this case of a modicum of the pastor's it's different in Union you did a born on yet it's not the same this is talking about a guy who comes into a house with a very disorder according to many boys skin put support salem according to the some point skin Christianity is not a vedas order for a non Jew because this though he's a lot of do islam for suppose if are a lot of believe in trinity name no yeah it's avala it's christianity prohibited for a longer because they believe in the trinity many posts come hold it's not they could believe that there's god with somebody else so therefore fish any wouldn't be of a deserter muslim religion is for shown out of a desire because mohammed is not considered a god he's considered a prophet but even christianity it's a Sheil if it's a fighters are or not yeah well only might say well you didn't keep it there anyway what's uh be civil so today it's a very different hello this is talking about even outside of exit show when they let you rent in extra strong many held you're a lot of rent many held not have mayor held nor to be a hell yeah but even outside where you could sister rent right he said don't rent it as a residence cuz she's gonna bring up a desert to your house sometimes they're too strong even cuts lawrence if you give him a place to live your house is gonna be filled with other desirously and i'm gonna do that you can give them a place for storage and other without for a deserter as to the Gemara fees a renter what do you care to his house the answer is no it's still your house serious light Canas serious kind that he could use it but it's considered your house this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate