"Fasten Your Seatbelts" - Imponderables on Parshas Vayikra

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay hi everyone your favorite time of the week some questions on uh parishes some impoundables um only very few this week but uh we'll see what you think now usually in English language you you usually say as follows you usually use a noun and then you could refer to that noun with a pronoun so I say Robert plagman came to this year uh it's only a few hours before Shabbos for him yeah so fine but I wouldn't say um he came to this year it's only a few hours for Robert plaqueman why because first you need to identify the noun and then you could refer to it as a pronoun but um it's very unusual to first use a pronoun and then use a noun so just could somebody explain to me the opening plastic in this week's Powershell Moshe and he called to Maisha yeah just tell me who called to Maisha a love huh since when do you talk that way it should say Hashem I don't know that seems like a simple question for me to me and he called tamasha who's the he who is he who called to Maisha all right it doesn't sound like it's Hashem because Hashem is a few seconds many years ago actually I had a when I was growing up the love of our shul was he was uh Adam uh never he passed away at a young age but somebody who made a big Russian Mommy he was the San glass and he would say over from the nasiva shoreline that the interpretation of the beginning of aikra and he didn't say this to answer this question but I think it does is the nasiva Sham would would explain this possible anything in life that occurred and called out to Maisha anything that happened to him anything that called to him whether it was a success or a setback or a failure or a difficulty or a challenge or a happiness anything that happened to Maisha moisha took it as Hashem was speaking to him it's a very beautiful Parish very important idea and perhaps it answers this question but I think uh it's a important question to think about what in the world does the opening Posse compassions that you cry mean okay next question I don't know what does it say over there it says the it doesn't it wasn't allowed it I don't know see does it float and if so then we don't need to say Hashem so why is Hashem only later on in the pasok but who called him who's the he then Rashi says that look how Rashi tells Usha El highlights she says if God called Maisha before he spoke to him I would think maybe God called him before the pauses God only called him before he spoke to him but not before recess why would I think that God called Maisha before recess what would he call him to do moisha take a break now so Rashi says no God did not call Maisha before recess he only called him tashir so what's the havamina that Hashem called Maisha For Recess actually come to think of it maybe you would say that Hashem made an official announcement okay it's recess now no God only let him know the Bell only rang so it sounds like we're actually saying the Bell only rang for sure the Bell didn't ring when Cher was over when Cher was over the share just stopped but the Bell didn't ring so now we could ask why didn't the bell ring why didn't the bell ring For Recess I guess perhaps you know the gemara says you should always be from among those who call that the share is coming and not be among those who let everyone know that the share is over so where do we learn that from if we learned that from my college World Hashem only made it an announcement when the share started he didn't make an announcement when the show was over okay something interesting to think about and then I would like I would have liked more time to uh Ponder this but I think uh think about this over Shabbos Rashi at the end of the parasha parakeet Zion Rashi says on the possible Rashi brings four differently move them from this passage what are we talking about here we're talking about a guy who ate two pieces of meat he thought both were kosher and it turned out one was halev and he doesn't know even if he inadvertently ate the Khalif so says Rashi says punishes someone who didn't know is there punishment for someone who does know says if you want to know the reward for Sadiq and learn out from adamarishan was only commanded on one love and he violated see how many missiles were penalized upon him so let's extrapolate if that is the punishment for one of era Allah become of someone doesn't do anavera how great the reward will be Ravi Kiva then says you want to know the reward from its life it says well if works with 2A then why do you have to say it works with three Adam the answer is it's three mahmer on the third Aid that if it turns out that we are amazing or Mak Hashem we're gonna punish him I but the edos didn't need it need him yeah but he tagged along and when you tag along to do something wrong you're punished if you tag along to do something wrong you're punished all the more so if you tag along to do a Mitzvah by the way we learned from the ramban last week that tagging along to do a Mitzvah is even if you stand around and your makhaven to be part of it like by the Orion we are so they were rewarded as if they did it says you want to learn the reward of midsize learn it from shikhra you hear you have a guy he forgot a bundle and anani finds it and he's missparnes the person gets a bracha Allah somebody intends to give sadaka certainly they will be blessed so I have one simple question the question is why did each of these respective teach this particular lesson why is robloxia Glee the one who teaches the lesson of being punished if you didn't realize it was navera certainly if you do why isi the one who teaches the reward for not violating Lavin why is Ravi Akiva the one to teach the reward of tagging along to do a Mitzvah why is the one who teaches the reward that if you're rewarded for inadvertent Mitzvah performance if you intend in other words why did each Tana why were they led to their particulars Russia I think if you study each Tana's life and history and shama it will yield a very interesting uh connection between that and the drushas that they plan that they taught clarystrom okay I want to show you something else here you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com