0:00 / 0:00
Don't Bring the Times Into Shul | Parsha Perspectives | Acharei Mos-Kedoshim 5786
1,515 views
It’s subtle. It’s constant. And it’s shaping more than we realize. === Series generously sponsored by Becky & Avi Katz and Family in memory of David Grossman z"l, Dovid ben Menachem Manis z"l, their beloved father and grandfather. === The pressure to adjust, reinterpret, and “keep up” with the times isn’t new, but the consequences are real. In this week’s Parsha Perspectives on Acharei Mos–Kedoshim, Rabbi Efrem Goldberg explores a powerful idea: are we using Torah to understand the world… or using the world to reshape Torah? Because the difference changes everything. Subscribe to @rabbiefremgoldberg for more Parsha Perspectives
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Good morning, everyone. Welcome back to
Parsha Perspectives for today. This is
one of those weeks we have a double
parsha, double whammy, Acharei Mot and
Kedoshim. A daunting daunting task
because both parshas, each parsha,
Acharei Mot and Kedoshim, we could spend
an entire day, entire week, an entire
month on to try to cover and offer
insights on both in one class is
daunting indeed, but we'll do our best.
I want to thank as always our generous
series sponsors, first of all, Becky and
Avi Katz and family in memory of Becky's
father, David Grossman, who passed away
last year. May his soul have an aliyah.
Our learning should be in his memory.
And also, the other series sponsor, the
Deichman family in memory of their
daughter and sister, Danielle Rochel bas
Shalom Ezra,
passed away tragically in childbirth. A
very very special woman of tremendous
emunah
who loved to learn with us online, and
certainly our series now dedicated in
her memory as well. May her neshama
should have an aliyah. Today, she is
sponsored anonymously in the merit of
Abner ben Avraham HaCohen,
Yosef ben Levi, anonymously in honor of
Lloyd Hoffman's birthday. Happy
birthday.
And by Colin Stein and his children in
memory of his beloved wife, Feiga bas
Mosha, whom we miss. May her neshama
should have an aliyah.
We miss her in our community.
Anonymously for the full shalom of
Yitzchak Menachem ben Karen ben Yosef,
who should have a full, complete, and
speedy refuah shleimah. I also want to
dedicate our learning. Today is Yom
HaZikaron,
and there are so many who gave their
lives. We don't have to offer We don't
have to wish that their neshama has an
aliyah because it can't go any higher
because those who died al kiddush
Hashem, those who gave their lives
fighting for and defending the Jewish
people and the Jewish homeland, their
soul sits right next to the Kisei
HaKavod, next to the divine throne.
And so, while their neshama can't and
doesn't need to go any higher, certainly
we dedicate our learning in their memory
with endless and boundless gratitude for
their sacrifice,
and with their family very much in our
hearts and on our minds today, Yom
HaZikaron. The parshas we're reading are
called Acharei Mot Kedoshim. After the
death, Kedoshim. And those more than
25,000
who over the course of Israel's modern
history gave their lives fighting and
defending too many over the last 3 years
in the war
that is not yet over.
I reached out today. We've hosted so
many in our shul in our community and on
our podcast conversation with parents,
wives, family members of those who lost
loved ones. Our learning is dedicated to
them and we join Klal Yisrael. We join
Klal Yisrael around the world and today
feeling and thinking about their loss,
their memory, and their family sending a
lot of love, strength, and comfort. Page
636 in the Or Hachaim Chumash. Vayedaber
Hashem el Moshe acharei mot Aharon
b'korvam el Hashem vayemusu.
Hashem speaks to Moshe after the death
of the two sons of Aaron b'korvam el
Hashem when they brought a sacrifice to
God that was not uh
sanctioned. Thank you. Vayemusu. And
they paid the great price. There was a
death. Vayomer Hashem el Moshe, God
speaks to Moshe, "Daber el Aharon
achicha, speak to your brother Aaron." I
believe in last year's parsha class we
dealt with why is Aaron identified as
Moshe's brother as if Moshe has to turn
to God and say, "Wait 1 second. Which
Aaron? Speak to Aaron, but so many
Aarons in my class. Which Aaron? Oh,
Aaron achicha. Oh, my bro Oh, my brother
Aaron. Why does Hashem have to identify
him as Aaron achicha? We dealt with that
last year. Vayavo Yisrael el hakodesh
mibais haparoiches el pnei hakapores
asher al haaron v'lo yamus. Kee van
Aharon el hakapores. Moshe is
instructing his brother Aaron, "You
cannot enter. Don't just walk in
whenever you want. Al yavo b'chaleis.
Don't ever get too casual. Don't ever
get too comfortable. Familiarity breeds
contempt. And therefore, if we want
sanctity and holiness, we've discussed
this too in the past.
So hard. I have my favorite divrei Torah
in every parsha and to have the
discipline not to review it because we
want to get to new things. I'm not I'm
not you for a sympathy for me. It's not
a tough life. I'm just saying this is
what I go through. In any case, I have a
whether it's in marriage, relationships,
sanctity of the shul, the base
hamikdash, you exit in a different way
than you came in. Don't ever become too
familiar. Don't ever get too casual. We
have to keep the the spontaneity and the
holiness and the sanctity and the love
and the connection alive. And that was
true. That's embodied here in this
warning
but
you cannot come in whenever you whenever
you want. Again, we did that with this
much more in the past.
So don't come in while you have a place.
Don't come in on a whim. Don't come in
casually or comfortably. Don't come in
whenever you want. How should you come
in? How do you enter the holy? With
only with a sense of What is this?
With
this.
What's this?
This is ambiguous. What's this?
Mysterious.
Then we elaborate a little bit of young
bull for a sin offering and ram for an
elevation offering. He puts on his
sacred linen and and the parsha goes on.
I want to start with a few insights of
the
I told you last week a new edition of
the
Sachs who lives in Chicago the
son-in-law of
Frank the great grandfather of Sachs
from
the land his family a new edition of the
came out with bonus extra amazing
I'm a big fan and I love to quote the
I have a
he said you shall be close.
The time
says on the
A lot of
a fair
there's a at the very at the
chapter
119 the one that goes according to the
alphabet and the iron
A A lot of
a fair
and the brochos elaborate on this
and says host
eaten or is a fair
the says A lot of a fair.
Now the simple tight the simple
translation of the words are ace lasos
lashem in a time that one has to do for
God a fair resource you're even allowed
to so to say with God's permission
violate or sacrifice or compromise Torah
because it's for Hashem. Indeed this
possible was invoked when the dynasty
and also the great leader of the Jewish
people took the incredible courageous
but also controversial decision to write
down the oral Torah to write down the
Torah
he invoked this possible ace lasos
lashem a fair resource
Torah was lost if he didn't codify it if
he didn't write it down if he didn't
capture it by sterility it was in danger
of being lost. Therefore because it was
an ace it was a time lasos lashem he had
to do something drastic for God he was
entitled he had license a fair resource
that's a simple understanding of the
possible. However, the army brothers at
the end of the ninth paragraph writes
how also Torah so eating what is the
word eating means
the times if you turn the Torah into the
times the times how is that may fibrous
you're violating the covenant with God
because a fair resource ace lasos lashem
how also Torah so and Torah so you want
to meet
the bottom eating the fair resource man
the ace care ace machine
to Torah so you know
how is that may fibrous The word of
seems actually understands that it is
if you try to distort Torah to make it
conform with the times that you're
living. So you open the newspaper and it
says you're supposed to believe this and
you're supposed to now use this new
definition of that and you're supposed
to now see this policy as this you say
okay I guess we're going to have to
adjust I guess we'll officiate it this
and we'll attend that and we'll
compromise on this and we'll allow that
new rule here if a person
brings that attitude, they're may fair
have bris, they are compromising and
corrupting the very covenant with the
almighty.
If you think you're going to make minor
adjustments, if you think you're going
to try to make Torah conform to the
times,
in the end you won't even have a
recognizable religion. In the end, it
won't even represent Judaism.
It's a different touch. It's a different
way of understanding. Ace
loss of the sham, if you're going to do
for God based on the times, literally
and figuratively, you're going to open
the times, you're going to open the
paper and you're going to see what
you're supposed to believe, what's
popular, what's in, what's current, and
you're going to adjust or distort or
pervert or make Torah conform to the
times, you'll end up a fair or sore or
sucker, you will distort, compromise,
corrupt Torah.
The Torah was given to us is immutable.
It's non-negotiable.
Certainly, we innovate even within
Torah.
We have a shabbos elevator, we have a
prism ball, and we have we have all
kinds of innovations, but they're
operating within a system, we're
operating within Torah.
But you can't change Torah. We don't
change axioms and basic definitions. We
don't change halakha. Halakha of the
house.
Lote mukhlafis, and that's why the Torah
that's in our hands is given to Moshe
Rabbeinu lote mukhlafis lote Torah
one of the 13 principles of our faith is
it is immutable. It is non-negotiable.
It cannot be changed or compromised. It
doesn't conform to the times in which we
live.
So when the kind God will enter the
kodish kodashim holy of holies, when all
the Jewish people were watching him, and
he was going in and out to atone for the
people, "Mitzuva betzavta yucha al yavo
b'chol eit."
Listen to this new interpretation. I
love the Menachem Tzion. Says the
Menachem Tzion, "Lo yavo b'chol eit."
The simple understanding was, don't be
casual, don't be comfortable, don't just
walk in whenever you want, don't open a
door without knocking, don't come in
without being invited in, don't be too
comfortable. That was the simple
understanding. But the Menachem Tzion
says, "You know what it means? Lo yavo
b'chol eit." When you come into shul,
don't bring the times with you.
Cuz the inside of shul could care less
what it says in the times.
The inside of shul is not concerned with
its definitions and its policies, with
its approaches and its perspective, with
its ideology and its philosophy. In
here, we open the Aron and we open a
Torah and we see what the Torah tells
us. The Torah projects on us, we don't
chalila project onto the Torah. The
Torah dictates and determines what we
believe and what we practice, our lives
and our lifestyles, and not the
opposite. So, when Aaron would enter,
when the Kohen Gadol would enter the
Kodesh Hakodashim, "Lo yavo b'chol eit."
Don't come in with the times. Who cares
what it says in the blogs and the times?
Who cares what's popular to believe?
"Lo yeheina l'hachnis rosh ha'eit al
hakodesh." Don't bring the mentality and
the attitude of the eit. Well, you come
on, get with the times. Get with the
times, you're so archaic, you're so
old-fashioned. What are you doing? Come
on, get with the time. Your times? You
could take your times, we don't bring it
into shul. "Lo yavo b'chol eit." There
is no subscription. We canceled our
subscription at shul, to the We never
had it, but to the times. "Lo yavo
b'chol eit." We don't bring it in el
hakodesh, el hakodesh. We don't bring it
in here. It's a whole new taitch, a
whole new way of understanding.
A whole new way of understanding. He
goes on, that's not all, but I want to
see further insights that he has. You
see this also,
he doesn't bring this, but I'll tell you
another vort.
It's more than a vort. The Gemara
Shabbos says that after 120 when we come
upstairs we're asked a series of
questions.
And one of the questions the heavenly
tribunal asks us is Kavata itim l'Torah.
Which again we simply understand to mean
did you set aside time? Tuesday mornings
9:30 a.m.
Did you set aside time to learn?
Wednesday mornings 8:05 Tanya, 9:00
living with Emunah, Sunday morning
Smicha Shiur, Friday 10:00 Friday to
Erev Shabbos, Friday morning 10:00 to
Erev Shabbos. Did you set aside times
for learning? See what I did there?
Did you see a little shameless plug? Did
you set aside times for learning?
Did you see Kavata? Were you Kovea? Did
you establish itim times to learn?
Not just learn haphazard. Not learn when
it was convenient. Not learn when you
felt like it. But set consistent times
to learn.
However you could really you could
understand a little bit differently.
What really we will be asked after 120
when we come upstairs is Kavata itim
l'Torah or Kavata Torah l'itim?
Did you establish the times based on
Torah or did you establish the Torah
based on the times? Again that word
l'yavo b'chol eish itim itim. Kavata
itim l'Torah. Did you look at the times
and say I have to interpret and
understand the world based on Torah.
Who is Iran?
What do they represent? What is good
versus evil? What is Amalek? What does
Hakadosh Baruch Hu want? What is Ribono
shel Olam? What is Hashgacha? What are
miracles in our times? I'm looking at
the world. I'm looking at how it's
defining gender, identity, orientation,
relationships, institutions. I'm looking
at business practices. I'm looking at
every aspect of life. Kavata itim
l'Torah. Did you look at the times and
>> [clears throat]
>> understand them,
interpret them, experience them, process
them through Torah? Or God forbid Kavata
Torah l'itim?
Did you try to make the Torah conform to
the times? It's challenging. There's a
lot of pressure on us.
When one lives in a society in a world
which you become like Avraham Avinu, the
Ivri, may ever run the other side and
we're standing nearly alone and we're
desperately holding on to some of our
beliefs because we know they're true. We
know they're true. So, that same word
etim kavata etim letora lehavo bechol
etz. Don't come in with all your etim.
Don't bring in the times. Here,
we're living lemala min ha etim. In
shul, in Yiddishkeit, when a person's
living Torah, we're transcending the
times. Our truths are not dictated or
determined by what's popular, by what
the polls say. Just look at the
phenomenon we're living in we're living
through. We're watching so many of the
problems that we have are because of
gripers and grifters.
Ask your grandchildren what that is.
Gripers and grifters. Gripers and
grifters are media personalities who
don't have principled opinions and take
stands. They look at what will be the
most popular. What will attract the
biggest audience. What will bring in the
most money.
And then they ride that wave. And that's
why they flip-flop. That's why they
change. That's why you can make videos
that show what they said yesterday
versus today, today versus tomorrow
because they're just going with the
wind. Whatever will bring them the most
followers, the greatest influence, and
bet the most money. That's not us and
our people. We have principles and we
have truths and we stand by them and
they don't change. Lo yavo bechol etz.
When a person enters kodesh, you don't
bring a mentality and attitude to bechol
etz. What do you bring? Bezot yavo
Aharon el hakodesh. What's bezot? That
word zot we said is ambiguous. Know what
zot is.
Next piece in the Menachem Tzion. Hamila
zot
e vesod yesod bechol hatora lekorna say
yesod um kruchim kulam ba. That word zot
is fundamental, foundational, that the
whole Torah and all its principles
stands on it, is intertwined with it.
Just think about how many pesukim we see
that word zot that you think is so
ambiguous and mysterious. What does it
mean? And yet, it appears in so many
places.
Lo yavo kashur yesod um yesod um.
the future, God will turn to the nations
of the world who will request from him
reward and he'll ask them to pass again
Yeshaya
me by him you give those
because I'll say in those Ella
Torah. You know what those refers to a
life of Torah, Torah philosophy, Torah
ideology, Torah behavior.
How do you know that? Because what do we
say when we lift the Torah and we do
with Hagba Monday, Thursday, and
Shabbos?
The Zos ha Torah she saw Moshe lift me
the name of Israel the Zos ha Torah. In
Zos Ella Torah whenever you see the word
Zos being used, it is an allusion or
reference to the Zos means Torah. In
Tehillim, we just sang it on Pesach and
then Rosh Chodesh Me'isa Hashem hayesa
Zos hinifla'os be'eineinu. From Hashem
came Zos its wonders in our eyes. Pasuk
in Yirmiya Mi ish hacham veyavin es zos
asher dibber Hashem elav vayagidennu.
Never in Tehillim we say
ba'al lo yedah uksil lo yavin es
Zos. Yeshaya [snorts] asher enosh
ya'aseh zos uven adam yachazik bah.
Hashem turns to Klal Yisrael Malachi
ucheneni na bezos uchanuni bezos amar
Hashem Tzva'os. Zos Daver el Machir ben
Menasheh im takum alav milchamah beh
Zos ani bote'ach.
You can have a lot of fun. The Medrash
says
what did Yaakov end with? Zos bezos
asher dibber lahem Avihem. Moshe gave
Klal Yisrael a bracha where did he
start? Vezos habracha asher berach Moshe
ish ha'Elokim es Bnei Yisrael.
We don't have enough time left in the
shiur or the day to find all the pesukim
references and allusions to that word
Zos. The fool uksil lo yavin es zos.
Me'isa Hashem hayesa zos.
With the Zos bezos haTorah and bezos
Yavo Aron Hakodesh. So, what is the Zos?
The diamond brim. Zos, Rebbe Kaddish.
Zos, we have to have clarity, we have to
have conviction, we have to have
courage. Zos, we have to be able to
point and know this. I'm not confused.
I'm not somebody who can change based on
who I'm talking to. We don't take a poll
and our opinion is based on what's
popular. We can point with our finger
and say Zos. Zos. And that's what the
fool doesn't understand. Be principled.
Be consistent. Turn to Torah because
it's Hashem's infinite word, his
blueprint for creation. That's the
bizos. That's the bizos.
And the Kohen Gadol, the holiest person,
went to the holiest place on the holiest
day of the year in order to atone for
his people by all of the people.
What did he bring with him? Zos.
Conviction, courage, a clarity of Torah.
Bizos Yavo Aharon El Hakodesh. Come in
knowing who you are. Come in knowing who
you come from. Come in come in knowing
what you stand for. Come in knowing what
your mission is. Come in knowing the
truth that you represent unequivocally,
unconditionally, unwaveringly. Know who
you are and what you're about. Bizos
Yavo. So, don't come in Lo Yavo B'chol
Eitz. With the Eitzem. Don't bring the
Eitzem in here. Instead, now you
understand Eitzem and Zos are two sides
of the same coin. Don't bring the times,
what's current, what's popular. What
should you bring? Zos. Clarity, courage,
conviction, the truth of Torah. That's
who we are. That is how we enter. Perek
Gimel, Perek Chos rather. We are
skipping right along because I want to
get to Parshas Kedoshim. Last year here
the double parsha, we mostly covered
Acharei Mos, so I made a commitment to
myself that this year we would cover
mostly
Kedoshim. So, what's the rest of Acharei
Mos? We get into Yom Kippur, the whole
process of Yom Kippur, the two goats,
one is pushed off a cliff, one is
offered to Hashem, the lottery, fate
versus the recognition of of our place
and Hashem's role, Azazel, who is Uzza
and Azael, this voice in our own head.
Ah, so much to talk about over here. The
ketoret, who we allow in, the confession
the Kohen Gadol has to for himself, for
his family, and for the people in that
order, cuz you can't atone for the
people before you first take care of
yourself. After the
um avodah of Yom Kippur, we get into the
prohibition against eating blood, our
obligation to cover the blood. We've
covered this
in previous parsha classes, and then we
get into the laws of forbidden
relationships, perek kuf ches.
It's familiar to us. When do we read
this?
Yom Kippur mincha. Vayedaber Hashem el
Moshe lemor, page four 648 in the
ArtScroll Stone Chumash.
Speak to the Jewish people and tell them
Aniy Hashem Elokeichem, I am the Lord
your God. That is a very popular refrain
in these two parshas. Aniy Hashem
appears six times in
parshas Acharei Mos, and how many times
does it appear in Kedoshim?
I don't remember. Maybe 18 ti- many many
many many times.
Many many times. That's not
coincidental. Maybe we'll get into that.
Speak to the Jewish people and tell them
I'm the Lord your God. And therefore,
kema'aseh eretz Mitzrayim asher
yeshavtem bah lo sa'asu.
Don't perform the practice of the land
of Egypt in which you dwelt.
Ukema'aseh eretz Kena'an asher ani mevi
et'chem shamah lo sa'asu uvchukoteihem
lo telechu. Don't walk like an Egyptian,
the place that you lived where I took
you out of,
nor
nor adopt the practice of Kena'an, the
place I'm taking you to.
Differentiate yourself. Have the courage
to be different. Have the courage to
stand out. Live the blueprint, the
prescription I'm giving you, says
Hashem. B'zos Yavo Aron. Know who you
are, where you come from, how you're
meant to live. Live Torah.
Don't be k'ma'aseh Mitzrayim and don't
be k'ma'aseh Kena'an, says the Menachem
Tzion, our last one of the day. Eina
k'vana l'ma'asim meguneem v'asurim.
Sha'arei Yishar Soros M'yucholos. What
is the Torah telling us? When God says
don't be like the Egyptians, what does
he mean by that?
If it means don't worship idols, so you
don't have to tell me don't be like an
Egyptian. The Torah already tells us an
explicit prohibition, don't worship
idols.
So when the Torah's telling us don't be
like an Egyptian, if don't be like an
Egyptian means don't do the prohibited
behaviors of the Egyptians, you don't
need to tell me don't be like an
Egyptian, the Torah explicitly tells me
the the prohibited behaviors of the
Egyptians. So what is this Azhara
M'yucholos? What is this specific
specific
prohibition? Ela k'vanas Hashem lomar,
says the Menachem Tzion, k'ma'aseh
Mitzrayim asher y'shavtem ba, lo sa'asu.
Ma'aseh zeh she y'shavtem ba y'shivas
keva, u'k'ma'aseh Kena'an asher ani mevi
eschem, einchem holchim ela b'os
nafsh'chem, ela ani mevi eschem b'al
korchem. You need to know that your
address, you got your mail for a little
while in Egypt.
But don't ever, ever dwell there.
Don't ever assimilate and integrate.
Don't ever think you're permanently part
of that world and that life. That is not
who you are, that is not where you live,
that is not what you are about. You are
just passing through. You are just there
temporarily. That is not your home.
Yes, you're a citizen,
you're a resident, but you're also a
stranger. And that's ever since Avraham
Avinu, Rav Soloveitchik's insight, ger
v'toshav anochi imachem. I'm a resident
and a stranger at the same time. We are
part proud Americans, patriotic, we're
citizens, we contribute to and benefit
from society, but make no mistake, and
they are making us remember now that at
the same time that culture
and those attitudes, they're not ours,
they're foreign to us. We're not
permanently fixed here. We are in galus.
We have to know we're temporarily here.
We're on a business trip. When you go on
a business trip,
you find a nice place to stay, you eat
in restaurants, you don't have to suffer
while you're there, but you also realize
all along that you're there, you're not
home.
So, we're on a business trip, and
there's nothing wrong with staying in a
nice place and eating nice meals.
There's nothing wrong with set ourselves
up to enjoy while we're here on a
mission, but we should never get
confused to think that this is home.
That hotel or Airbnb is not home. No
matter how nice one you reserved, no
matter how nice a one you're staying in,
it's not home, and this isn't home.
That we need to know that this is not
This is not home. And that's the
prohibition. That's what Moshiach is
warning us.
It doesn't mean any of their particular
behaviors. That we already know, that we
already have in the specific
prohibitions, explicit prohibitions for
those behaviors. So, what was the Torah
telling us? Don't be
Don't be
Don't integrate. Don't settle. Don't see
yourself as a citizen. Know you're on a
business trip. Know you're there
temporarily. Know that it's not
permanent, and you're not there forever.
Know that that is not home. Sorry, one
more on this parsha before we turn over
turn the page.
Observe my decrees and my laws which you
should carry on and by which you shall
live. I am Hashem. The by them. The by
them. That may be familiar to you that
expression. The by them. What does the
by them mean?
The by them means
live with them, live through them. And
in fact, this is a halachic mandate. The
Gemara Chazal understood "v'chai ba'hem
v'lo sheyamus ba'hem." If observing a
Torah mitzvah, if observing a halacha
will cost you your life, "v'chai
ba'hem." Hashem wants us to live. And
therefore, if there's a conflict between
observing a halacha or preserving your
life, what do you do?
Pikuach nefesh doche
Shabbos doche Torah except for
the gimmel chamuros. We have three
exceptions, the three cardinal sins.
Gilah Arayos, Shfichus Damim, Avodah
Zarah.
Murder, idolatry, and
illicit
behavior relations. Those three, if they
would cost you your life, you give up
your life rather than violate. But other
than those three, the other 610, you
give up your life rather than violate.
Why? Chazal understood that from "v'chai
ba'hem." "V'chai ba'hem v'lo sheyamus
ba'hem." The whole purpose of Torah is
to give our lives meaning and purpose.
If observing Torah will cost you your
life,
then that defeats the very purpose of
Torah. And therefore,
which one supersedes the other?
Preserving your life supersedes
observing that mitzvah. In the Sefer
HaChinuch,
Rav Sherira Gaon quotes Rav
Soloveitchik, the Rav, who saw this
interpretation "v'chai ba'hem v'lo
sheyamus ba'hem" as a
core principle of the Torah. "Niro lomar
b'zeh HaRambam meivi es halacha Pikuach
Nefesh doche kol haTorah kulah." Where
does the Rambam bring this law?
That
that Pikuach Nefesh, saving and
preserving a life, supersedes all the
Torah except for the gimmel chamuros.
Where does the Rambam bring this?
The Brisker's. Those who study Rambam
understand not only can you learn from
the actual text of the Rambam, but the
Rambam organized as an encyclopedia, he
organized halacha. And where the Rambam
chose to put certain laws itself tells
you how he understood them. Aside from
the text, the words themselves, but in
his organization of the law, he was also
offering commentary.
So, where did the Rambam put the
halacha? Pikuach nefesh is doche kol
haTorah kulah?
He put it in the fifth perek of Hilchos
Yesodei haTorah.
Therefore, ne'eman zeh, dedina devachay
bahem velo sheyamus bahem chume yesodei
haTorah.
That the halacha devachay bahem, the
halacha of preserving your life
superseding Torah
is a halacha in yesodei haTorah.
This is a core principle of Torah.
And the Rambam says, this is the lashon
of the Rambam there, she'eim mishpetei
haTorah
nikhbe'u bahem al rachamim vachasadim
sheba'olam, umishakholek al zeh, hu
kholek al yesodei haTorah, ulahakhi
harei hu bikhlal haMinim.
Let's say someone says, "You know what?
I'm so holy.
I'm so sacred. I'm such a tzaddik.
It's true that you're allowed to eat the
non-kosher in order to save your life.
Somebody, God forbid, says to you, "Eat
this non-kosher or I'm going to kill
you."
It was hard to imagine that scenario
until the last few years where hostages
were held and who knows what they could
be told or threatened with.
But a person, an enemy of Israel, takes
a Jew and says, "Eat this non-kosher or
I'll kill you." What's the halacha?
Eat the non-kosher. Let's say someone
says,
"I'm going to eat non-kosher.
I'm a tzaddik.
I strive for greatness. I'm not eating
the non-kosher. I'm not eating the
non-kosher."
So, you might think that person is
exceptionally righteous. According to
Harav Kook, according to Rav
Soloveitchik, based on this Rambam, such
a person is a kofer.
Such a person is a heretic. They're
bikhlal haMinim, because uvachay bahem
velo sheyamus bahem is yesodei Torah. It
is a core principle and value of Torah.
You're not entitled to give up your
life. For the big three, you have to
give up your life.
But other than the big three, you're not
entitled to give up your life. And you
think that you're going to be more
religious than God and give up your life
for him, you're not doing it for him.
That's not our religion. That's a form
of heresy. That's a form of heresy and
that is a terrible terrible mistake.
It's a good opportunity for me to offer
an apology, a public apology.
Many years ago, several years ago, I
said in a in a
interview, in a conversation that I
challenged that the Klausenberger Rebbe
Excuse me again, I'll let you know.
That the Klausenberger Rebbe went
through the war and never ate
non-kosher.
Never actually ate non-kosher.
And I said, you speak to survivors, they
said that was impossible. And I spoke to
somebody who knew someone who went
through the war with the Klausenberger
Rebbe also said that was impossible and
I challenged him. And since then, the
author of the biography of the
Klausenberger Rebbe was in touch with me
and shared with me what the
Klausenberger Rebbe himself in his farm
alludes to and thanks Hashem for the
miracle that he was never in a position
that he ever had to violate kashrus. He
would have if he had to to save his
life. As we're learning, it's a
principle of Torah and it's heresy not
to. But the Klausenberger Rebbe
testified about himself, so who am I of
course to challenge that? So, I offer
this public apology to the Rebbe um
publicly for even suggesting that that's
not the case. But the Rebbe himself
would have if he had to. He thanks
Hashem that he was able to go through
the war in such a circumstance that he
didn't need to. Without of course
impugning or challenging those who did,
they did the right thing. Anyone
[clears throat] who went through the war
and had to eat non-kosher to save their
life, it's not that they made a
concession they should feel bad for or
need forgiveness for. It's me as so they
are Torah, the Rambam puts it. Pikuach
nefesh doche kol haTorah and yesodei
haTorah.
And had they not done that, they'd be
b'chlala minin. Had they not done that,
they'd be included among the heretics.
And so, you see this very important
understanding in in the in the Harei
Kadim, how he understood it based on
where the Rambam codifies it. Rav Volbe
also in the Al She'eilas HaBayis, Rav
Volbe, the great Mashgiach also
addresses V'Chai Bahem. Gemara Makkos
daf Yud tells us if a person
accidentally murders, they flee, they
run where? To an Ir
Miklat. They run to an Ir Miklat. Why?
Because the family members of the victim
are entitled to pursue and therefore to
save himself, he goes to the Ir Miklat.
And there the Torah says about the
individual, he can run to one of the
cities, he flees to an Ir Miklat and
what does he do there? V'Chai. He runs
to an Ir Miklat V'Chai and he can live
there. He can live there. And the Gemara
Makkos daf Yud interprets that a Talmud,
someone's learning in the Yeshiva, a
younger man in Kolel, Chas V'Shalom has
an incident where he killed by accident,
he has to run to an Ir Miklat. Do you
know who goes with him?
His Rebbe.
His Rebbe, Rav Asher Arieli, he's giving
the biggest Shiur in the world in the
Mir. Chalila,
sorry, stop Shiur, you're going to move
into the Ir Miklat. The Rebbe goes with
him. The Rebbe interrupts
the Rosh Yeshiva?
He's running the Yeshiva, he's giving
the Shiur, biggest Shiur in the world,
and he stops to run to an Ir Miklat?
Why? So the Gemara understood V'Chai.
Because when this individual runs to the
Ir Miklat, we have to provide him
everything he needs to live.
What does he need to live? Wi-Fi?
Internet connection?
That's not what Chazal say.
What he needs to live is his Rebbe.
He needs Torah in order to live. That's
V'Chai. The Rambam codifies Hilchos
Rotzeiach in the seventh perek. And the
Rambam there writes that when a Talmud
is exiled, we send the Rebbe because the
Torah says V'Chai. And for those who
seek wisdom without Torah, it's as if
they're dead. If you don't have access
and you're not learning Torah, then you
can't achieve and fulfill V'Chai. You
see the very definition of V'Chai is
what's V'Chai?
A life of Torah. You're only really
alive if your life is informed and
inspired and guided by Torah. By Torah.
It's possible for a person to know an
enormous amount of Torah, writes the
writes the Mashgiach of Vova,
it's possible to know an enormous amount
of Torah
but fail to v'chai. You're not living
Torah. How can you get to the level of
Torah as part of your life?
So, the Reb compares it to our life.
Can you be alive if you forget to
breathe?
Breathing has to be uninterrupted.
If a person
struggles to breathe, they gasp for air.
It's an emergency. It's We call a code.
It's a problem.
If a person's heart Can the heart be
like, you know, I've been doing this for
a lot of years.
I've been doing this now for a lot of
Give me a day off.
Can't give me a day off? The heart says,
"Give me 1 hour. Let me rest for 1
hour."
If you think about it, it's
extraordinary.
From when we're born till we leave this
world, the heart doesn't get a break.
Not for a day, not for an hour, not for
a minute.
And if the heart were to stop, if the
heart were to be interrupted, if the
heart were to stutter,
we call it sala, you'd be in trouble.
How is it that we live physically only
when we live uninterrupted? Instead, the
Reb said the same is true spiritually,
v'chai.
How do you live? Only when your
spiritual life is uninterrupted. If you
say, "When I'm on vacation, I leave the
Torah and the halacha behind."
There are people they go on vacation,
they dress differently,
they eat differently,
their priorities are different when they
go on vacation. There are people all of
a sudden they're on a beach and the
wardrobe, the rules, things change.
V'chai means consistent, constant,
uninterrupted. Just like your lungs and
your heart, you're only alive when
they're operating uninterrupted,
spiritually only alive when your values
and your lifestyle is uninterrupted. And
our whole day is guided by Torah. Ah,
but you're going to the parsha shiur
this morning and then maybe only you
come back to the mitzvah shiur tonight,
but you didn't learn in between. That's
called uninterrupted? Yeah. If
everything we did in between, we did
guided by Torah, that's called
uninterrupted. Our Torah heart is
beating. Our Torah lungs are breathing.
Uninterrupted. Uninterrupted.
That Rabbeinu Chaim has a shtickel based
on a Tosefos. That's how birchas haTorah
work. Birchas haTorah is a bracha we say
before the mitzvah of learning Torah. So
you said a birchas haTorah this morning.
I hope you did. Before you came to
shiur. In davening, when you woke up,
you said a birchas haTorah. Lasok
b'divrei Torah shebicharanu,
v'ha'arevna. There are three parts of
that bracha. They correspond with the
three types of bracha. Birchas Shevach,
Birchas Han'a'ah, Birchas Hamitzvah. Not
for now. But you made a bracha before we
learned the birchas haTorah. But now
you're going to go to the gym, you're
going to the supermarket, you're going
to the doctor.
Unlike you, some of us have to work.
You're going to go to work. And then
tonight you're going to come back,
you're going to learn more Torah. How
come you don't have to make a new
birchas haTorah?
If you make a bracha you sit in the
sukkah. And then you go on a tiyul for
the day. Lion Country Safari. When you
come back for dinner and you sit in the
sukkah, do you have to make a new
bracha? Of course you have to make a new
bracha. So how come tonight when you're
going to learn again after you
interrupted during the day you don't
have to make a new bracha? Do you ever
think about that? Ever bother you?
There's a Tosefos a bracha and Rabbeinu
Chaim understood, you know why? The
bracha you made was not lilmod Torah, it
was lasok. To be occupied by Torah. If
Torah governs the way you do business,
if Torah governs the way that you check
out at Publix, please and thank you and
use the name of the cashier, the way you
park the car, between the lines, not on
the line.
If Torah guides the way you operate, the
way you behave, and who you are, then
you never took a break, you never
interrupted. You don't have to make a
new bracha. You didn't leave the sukkah
of Torah, so to say. That's the Rabbeinu
Chaim. That's how Rav Wolbe understood
Rabbeinu Chaim. Rav Wolbe understood
Rabbeinu Chaim as Rabbeinu Chaim means
just like our breathing, and just like
our heartbeat is uninterrupted, so too
Rabbeinu Chaim, our spiritual heartbeat,
the Torah, our life, we're never on
vacation, we're never on a break.
Our relationship with Torah and Hashem
is like marriage.
I don't have to finish this metaphor,
but when a person goes on a business
trip, they're still married.
That's part of their core identity.
That's who they are. That's part of
their consciousness and who they talk to
and how they talk and what circumstances
they put themselves in. They're not on a
break. And that's V'chai. That's V'chai.
That was the pledge and promise under
that chuppah. It's like the air I
breathe. V'chai. My marriage, our
relationship, it's part of my core
consciousness 24 hours a day, 7 days a
week for the rest of my life. And
V'chai, that's my relationship with
Hashem and that's my attitude towards
Torah. V'chai. So, the individual who
runs to the Ir Miklat, the Rebbe goes
with him V'chai cuz without Torah you're
not alive. And how do you then define
V'chai? Consistent and constant. Just
like our heart, just like our lungs,
that has to be our lifestyle of Torah. I
was going to share with you lastly a
piece by
the Gaon Rosh Yeshiva of Shal Alter
Shlita in understanding V'chai Bahem.
But, I want to get to the rest of this
parsha. So, I told you enough on V'chai
Bahem. Believe me, there will come back
to it in the future. Let's go to Parshas
Kedoshim.
Page 656.
Perek Yud Ches.
Pasuk Yud Ches. Let's go. Kedoshim
Tihiyu. What is Kedoshim Tihiyu? Be
holy. We're learning now Kedushin Seder
Nashim.
Kadosh Kadosh Kadosh. Holy holy holy. We
use that word holy. Holy is not a Jewish
word.
Holy comes from other religions.
To define the word Kadosh as holy. What
is holy?
Did it help to say holy?
We don't know what Kadosh is, so we say
holy. Good. Now, what's holy?
So, previously we went to Rashi, the
Ramban.
Separate, apart, different. What is
holy? How do you define it? We talked
about that in the past. And the Parshas
Kedoshim is shocked, full of a plethora
of mitzvahs. And the challenge of
learning Parshas Kedoshim is to weave
through the common themes and
denominators and what's happening, why
they brought in this order, and what's
the relationship between them. And so
the Torah tells us all of these
incredible laws between us and Hashem,
between us and others, and between us
and ourselves.
Carbonos, gifts to the poor, honesty in
business, don't steal, pay people on
time, don't curse, don't put a stumbling
block.
All these alachas, don't gossip.
Lo sis, don't hate your brother. Rebuke
when it's appropriate, how, who, when,
where, which brings us to Vayikra Tes
Pasuk Yud Ches, chapter 19 verse 18.
Bottom page 660. Lo Sikom Velo Sitor,
don't take revenge and don't bear a
grudge as benei amacha, to the people of
your nation. Vi'ahavta lere'acha
kamocha, instead love your neighbor as
yourself, Ani Hashem. Love your neighbor
as yourself. I have to tell you
the Kapishnitzer Rebbe
Zatzal, Kapishnitzer Rebbe had a
beautiful explanation of Vi'ahavta
lere'acha kamocha, love your neighbor as
yourself. Listen to this quote.
If you love a fellow Jew because he's
learn
learned, that's an act of love of Torah
scholars. If you love him because he
supports Torah, you fulfilled the
requirement of the love of Torah. If you
love him from admiration of his or his
his or her tzedaka, that's a case of
loving tzedaka. But if you love a Jew
who's neither a talmid chacham nor about
tzedaka nor a supporter of Torah, that's
ahavas Yisrael.
That's ahavas Yisrael.
If you love a fellow Jew because there's
something about them you love, then you
love that thing, you don't love them.
But if you love a fellow Jew even when
there's nothing to love about them, but
you choose to love them anyway, that's
ahavas Yisrael.
What an insight.
When you love someone cuz you say, "Oh,
that's about tzedaka, that's about
chesed, that's a talmid chacham, they're
artistic, they daven beautifully,
they're
uh you love that thing about them." Then
you don't love them, you love the thing
about them.
But when you love the person when
there's nothing you could find about
them to like, that's love. That's love.
The way I see it and the way I always
understand and try to work on this
possuk,
it's easy to love the people you like.
But the mitzvah of ahavas Yisrael to
love a fellow Jew is to even love the
people you don't like.
Like is an adjective. I like you. I like
spending time with you. I like a lot of
things about you. I like you.
Love is not an adjective. Love is a
verb.
Love is a verb.
Love is loyalty.
Love is support. Love is unity. Love is
care. Love is concern. Love is showing
up. Love is defending.
Love is not an adjective, it's a verb.
Like, like is an adjective.
And you can choose who you like. And if
you don't like someone, you don't have
to be friends with them. You don't have
to be around them.
But you have to love even the people you
don't like.
Not in my family, baruch Hashem, but
there are people who have individuals in
their family they don't like very much.
But it's too bad they still have to love
them.
You still have to love that member of
the family that you really don't like.
You have to love them. What does that
mean?
You have to be there. You have to defend
them. You have to be loyal to them. You
have to show up at their simcha. You
have to show up in good times and in bad
times. You have to not stab them in the
back. You have to be loyal. That's love.
You have to love even the people you
don't like.
And we are all one big family. And we
have to love
even the people that we don't that we
don't like. Even the people that we
don't see in them something that we
love. One of my favorite stories of Rav
Aryeh Levin, the great tzaddik of
Yerushalayim.
Rav Aryeh Levin, the great tzaddik of
Yerushalayim.
So, there was a boy who grew up in
Nachlaot, Rav Aryeh Levin's
neighborhood.
And he was no longer as intensely
religious as his childhood, as his
education. He cut off his peyos and he
took off his yarmulke and he changed his
dress and his garb. And when he did, he
did anything in his power to avoid Rav
Aryeh Levin.
It was awkward. He'd be uncomfortable,
he'd be embarrassed and ashamed. He
didn't want to make the tzaddik
uncomfortable, so he'd walk the alleys
of Nachlaot trying to avoid the tzaddik
Reb Aryeh Levin.
And one day he turned the corner and
punt.
There was Reb Aryeh Levin, there was the
tzaddik. I He was embarrassed, he was
ashamed, he didn't know what to do.
But Reb Aryeh Levin, the great tzaddik,
just said to him, "I haven't seen you in
so long. How are you? What are you up
to? What's doing?"
And the boy said, "I have to admit I've
been trying to avoid you.
I'm not religious anymore. I don't wear
a yarmulke anymore. I cut off my peyos.
I don't dress necessarily like an
observant Jew. I was embarrassed. I
didn't want to see you."
So, Reb Aryeh Levin, the great tzaddik,
looked at him and he said
he said, "You know, I'm a very short
man." Reb Aryeh Levin was very short,
4-foot something, very short man.
He said, "I'm a very short man.
I can only see what's in your heart. I
can't see what's on your head."
Isn't that beautiful?
I'm a very short man.
I only see what's in your heart. I can't
see what's on your head.
We all have to be a little bit shorter.
We're so focused on looking what's on
someone's head.
Are they wearing a yarmulke? Is it the
same type of yarmulke I'm wearing? Is
she covering her hair? Is she covering
it the way I do?
We're all busy looking at what's on
someone's head. We should get a little
bit shorter.
Stoop down a little bit. Instead, look
in their heart.
If the last 3 years haven't taught us
anything,
you know, the war with Iran that
on the one hand, God forbid it shouldn't
start up again, on the other we want to
finish them off.
It didn't matter, you know, millions of
our brothers and sisters were running to
bomb shelters.
And at the entranceway and doorway of
the bomb shelters, nobody said, "Let me
check your yarmulke before you can come
in. Let's see. Let me see how you cover
your hair before you can come in."
Nobody said, "Do you go to the army? You
don't go to the army? You go to the
cheder? You go to this school? How do
you observe your matzoh meal? Do you
make a bracha, no bracha, hallel? Did
you eat a blue and white cookie? Did you
wave a flag? Did you do dog walking? Did
you stand still for the siren?"
On the way into the bomb shelter running
from the missiles.
People loved each other and they let in
even the people they can't like, even
the people they're struggling like
anything to like,
but they open the door because they love
them. That's what it means Israel.
That's what it means Israel, to find
that way to love even the people we
don't like. To talk, to talk to them
and to find something redeemable in them
and to feel a shared history and a
common destiny
and even while there are very, very,
very significant and important
differences and debates that are
happening in our people
all over the world and particularly in
our beloved homeland.
Today
tonight tomorrow
these are times if we want to show them
to not regret the miracles he did for
us,
we have to demonstrate for them our
ability to get along, to love even the
people that we struggle to like. That's
what you have to learn.
Okay, that was my little editorial
comment on the side. Back to partial,
back to partial class. You have to
come over. That's come over. Love your
neighbor come over as yourself means
see the piece of you in them. What do
you have in common? What's redeemable?
What can you find in them? Look in their
heart not only on top of their head. You
have to
come over.
We've quoted this before. You have to
come over.
Presumes if you love your neighbor
as you love yourself presumes what?
That you love yourself. So I said to
myself as you see from here there's a
myth for to love yourself.
Now some people are a little zealous in
fulfilling that myth.
They could love themselves a little
less.
But sadly and tragically we're living in
a time of such mental mental health
mental health challenges that come
because people who love themselves too
little.
And we have to remind them
to love themselves, forgive themselves,
give themselves the benefit of the
doubt, believe in themselves.
You have to
come over.
Come over.
Love your neighbor as you love yourself.
The premise the presumption is don't
forget to love yourself.
There's a mitzvah love yourself. Why
should I love myself? So narcissistic,
so egotistical? I should love myself?
No, we love ourselves cuz it's a piece
of Hashem, Ani Hashem.
Khelik Elokah Mimaal Mamash is a piece
of Hashem in us. Rav Tzadok Hakohen
famously writes, "Kshem Kakh, just like
there's a mitzvah to believe emunah in
Hashem, there's a mitzvah to have emunah
in ourselves." I, how shall I faith in
myself? Myself, who am I to have faith
in me? The answer is, Ani Hashem.
There's a piece of God in me, there's
therefore that which to have faith in in
myself, in myself.
Now, this pasuk combines a few mitzvahs.
Lo Sikon Velo Sitor.
By the way, first I'll tell you, in the
Tshuvas Yakhin Yisrael, anyone know who
wrote the Tshuvas Yakhin Yisrael?
Former Chief Rabbi of Israel,
Rabbi Yisrael Meir Lau, Zolz ein
gezunten shtark. Rav Lau, in his Tshuvas
Yakhin Yisrael writes the following.
Vihafta Lereakha Kamokha and Kamokha
Kavana Kamokha Mamash Elo.
There it is. Love your neighbor as
yourself. Doesn't mean literally
yourself, like yourself.
Kamokha, like yourself, or Kamokha,
literally yourself? When he says, "I am
he." He says, "Let me finish." Birayon
Nifla, Anema B'Shima B'Shem HaTov. He
ends with an insight of the Khelik
Elokah B'Shem.
Umeduyak Balashon Mitzvah Zoo.
Lefei Haklala Midotav Demoded Kakh
Modedim Lo. We have a rule, the way we
act is the way that God acts with us.
Hayima Adam Mekabel Skum Sefer Panim
Yafos. Eino Metzaer Et Khavero, Kovea
Itim L'Torah, Sameakh B'Simkhaso. Do we
greet others with a positive
countenance, dispositions? We smile, are
we warm and welcoming? Do we feel the
pain, sympathy and empathy? Are we
happy? Can we forgive others? Only Allah
Kolan, on top of everything else?
Omed Liyemino Bekhamatzo. Do we show up?
Do we stand by the side of people in
every situation? Zokho Et HaAdam, Bekakh
Hakadosh Barukh Hu Misnaheg Imo.
We want Hashem. Hashem is a reflection
of us. Hashem is our mirror. How we
interact, how we behave, what part of
ourselves we give to others is how
Hashem interacts with us and says of Lao
in the name of the Bashem, that's what
it means vihavta l'rei'acha
kamocha. If you love your friend
kamocha, that's what Hashem is going to
do to you.
The way we interact with others is how
Hashem will interact with us. The
mitzvah is vihavta l'rei'acha kamocha is
totsa mikiyum hamitzvah.
You hear the Bashem?
Vihavta l'rei'acha love your neighbor.
Love your fellow Jew. Love even the ones
you don't like. Love. And when you do,
kamocha, that's how Hashem will treat
you.
It's a whole new way of understanding
that possuk. Nice, no?
Beautiful. Vihavta l'rei'acha kamocha ki
keshes shechina kodesh baruch hu zehu
kamocha. Kidargas kirvas shel adam el
Hashem yitbarach kach kirvas hakodesh
baruch hu elav. Our closeness to Hashem
will determine and dictate Hashem's
closeness to to us.
Now, this this possuk is complicated. Lo
sikom v'lo titol, don't take revenge.
Don't take revenge.
At the core there's a beautiful Sefer
Hachinuch. Sefer Hachinuch says
mishorshei hamitzvah, the root of this
mitzvah sheyehei adam mitaleh libo ki
kol asher yikreh mito
It's an amazing Sefer Hachinuch on this
possuk. Lo sikom v'lo titol, never ever
ever take revenge. What's the difference
between two lo sikom v'lo titol?
You came to your neighbor and you said,
"Can I borrow your food processor?" And
they said, "No."
When your neighbor comes to you and
says, "Can I borrow your blender?"
Lo sikom means
don't take revenge by saying, "No, you
can't borrow it." Lo titol means don't
take revenge by letting them borrow it
but saying, "I'm not like you. You
didn't let me borrow the food processor,
but I'm more than happy for you were
borrow the blender."
Two separate prohibitions. One is don't
take revenge by not letting them. The
other is even if you do let them, don't
remind them or highlight that you're
different than them. Lo sico lo sitor.
But the general rule is don't take
revenge. One does the safer explain why
not?
Revenge is
sweet.
Revenge is sweet. Somebody harms you,
somebody hurt you, somebody injured you,
somebody insulted you, somebody degraded
you, somebody made fun of you, somebody
defamed you, and you got the chance to
get them back.
You got a chance to take revenge. Sweet.
So why does the Torah say you're not
allowed to?
I would have thought what's the reason
for this mitzvah?
Don't be a man of all. Who are you?
You know, be a mensch. Be bigger than
that. Be better than that.
Treat them kindly. Be above that. It's
not what the Torah says.
Says the safer explain me shashe
hamitzi. You know why?
Because
if something happened to you, maybe that
person was the shliach, the conduit
through which it happened.
But it was only the will of Hashem. You
weren't meant to have that food
processor.
Somebody dinged your car? Don't take
revenge against them.
Because your car was meant to get
dinged. Now, the safer explain is clear
that you're allowed to, of course, be
made whole. You can seek compensation.
If somebody's harmed you or injured you,
you're allowed to take them to a din
Torah. You're allowed to get payment for
whatever they did.
But that's There's a big difference
between being made whole,
defending yourself, and taking revenge.
The moment a person seeks or takes
revenge, they're knocking God out of the
equation equation. They're saying what
happened to them wasn't from God. I have
to tell you, baruch Hashem, hasn't
happened often.
But as a public person, as a community
leader, you get people who
can post things nasty about you online.
Many years ago, once a time, people put
things in most of the mailboxes on Tory
Circle.
There are things that can hurt. They
they they you feel them in your kishkes.
I learned the safer when I was going
through one of them and it entirely
changed my attitude, my approach. It
helped me heal and let it go.
Because instead of focusing on who did
that and what can I do to get even with
them, you start saying, why was I meant
to experience this and what am I meant
to learn from it?
But don't get me wrong.
We'll find out who that person is and
>> [laughter]
>> but
to take revenge is to focus on the
person and to attribute all that
happened to them as if God had nothing
to do with it.
But we as people of faith are meant to
interpret and understand everything we
go through, everything that happens in
life. I can't believe that person
sideswiped my car. I can't believe that
person this happened, that happened, the
other happened. Okay.
Collect their insurance information. If
necessary, take it to a din torah. We
have to do what we have to do in life.
But never with an attitude of revenge.
Why? Because whatever we went through is
what was meant to happen.
And all of a sudden now we can process
it and experience it entirely
differently. That something that
happened was for our own good. We're
meant to learn and grow from it. It was
by design. It wasn't random coincidence
or chance and we don't blame it on some
other person. It's an incredibly
important safer.
I wish there was time to read you the
entire thing inside. We need to feel it.
Yargish v'eitan a leebo. Feel it and
place it in our heart to know that it's
all coming from Hashem. That's why it
says the Mashgiach of Don's cycle.
That's why it's also on the heels of the
last pasuk. Lo sisna es achicha
bilvavecha. Don't hate another person in
your heart. Lo sikom. Don't take
revenge. Meaning, if you come to hate
the person in your heart and you want
revenge, it's because you think it was
all them. God wasn't part of it. But the
moment you realize God meant this day
for you to go through that experience.
Something nasty was posted online.
Someone embarrassed you in public.
Who do we learn this from? David
Hamelech.
David Hamelech
was insulted horribly.
And his advisors said, "Let's kill him."
Shmuel ben Gera. And David Hamelech
said, "No, I was meant to be
embarrassed. I was meant to be insulted
publicly. It wasn't him.
Hashem chose him to be that messenger
through whom it happened, but the
message is for me to get and not and not
and not to blame that individual.
It's a very powerful example David
Hamelech set for us, and that's what
we're meant to follow the Sicha Malchut
but there's one last question on the
Sicha Malchut.
On the one hand, the possuk says you're
not allowed to get revenge, and on the
other hand,
whom do we describe as somebody who's
almost consumed with the pursuit of
revenge?
None other than
God Almighty. Keil Nekamah Hashem
veyinkom leineiynu all of Av Harachamim
which we say even during Tisha B'Av when
we bench Rosh Chodesh,
even if there's a simcha, why? Because
it was written for the Crusades, the
martyrs of the Crusades.
And it applies in our time, too.
That's why Moreinu Rabbeinu Shlita
paskened throughout the three years of
the war, Av Harachamim was said, and we
followed that in our shul. Even during
times where ordinarily you don't omit Av
Harachamim, we said it.
As our people were martyred,
as we lost holy soldiers, kedoshim, we
continued Av Harachamim. And what do we
say in this tefillah of martyrdom of Av
Harachamim? Yizkor heim Elokeinu
letovah.
God, remember them, shaar tzaddikei
olam. Veyinkom leineiynu nikmas dam
avadecha hashofuch.
And God, remember them and take revenge,
avenge their blood.
Ki dam avadav yakum venakam yashiv
letzarav venikisi damam lo nikisi.
Nikmas dam avadecha hashofuch. Over and
over again. Two nights in a row here in
the galus, we open the door, and what do
we call appeal to God to do? Shfoch
chamascha al
God, pour out your wrath, take sweet
revenge.
What do we say in Halacha?
Shulchan Shavuot Hadash We call God the
most kill big run on the head of the
people of the Adam la sos.
Nakam bagoyim.
La sos ba mishpat kasuv. God is the God
of revenge.
So which is it? Isn't there a
prohibition of lo siko?
Or is God a God of revenge? Which one is
it? Which one is it?
I think this is important to learn and
remember today Yom HaZikaron.
Which is it?
So the first writes
The Yinkom Yizkarem
Listen to the first. The one factor
which more than anything else has
protected us from being the from the
base impulse of vengefulness is
constituted by the recital of these
portions in our prayer book which teach
us that we must leave all vengeance and
retribution for that which others may do
to us to none other than Hashem.
Throughout its long existence the people
of Israel sorely tried like no other
nation in history has borne again and
again the most outrageous atrocities,
maltreatment, cruelty without ever
raising an avenging hand against its
foes and oppressors and without ever
attempting to work retribution upon the
peoples and rulers who had unleashed
upon Israel their excesses of fanatical
inhumanity. The reference here to the
statements throughout our sacred
literature with regards to the promises
and reassurance that Hashem will bear
reserves himself the exacting of
retribution for every ill that we have
suffered at the hands of our foes is
only due to our trust in the validity of
these promises that we found the
strength to submit to murder without
ever becoming murderers ourselves. We
are able to defend ourselves and fight
for ourselves but never lower ourselves
to their level of looking for revenge.
How and why says the first?
Because we have faith that Hashem is the
one who will take care of all of our
business. Hashem will get it all done.
Hashem had to avenge Hashem Yikom Damam.
It was only through these tefilos that
in the midst of a populace that derided,
hated, and mistreated us we could
maintain loyalty to the rulers of the
land to which we have been dispersed to
keep alive within our hearts sentiments
of human sympathy for their peoples.
Our appeal to Hashem have helped us
remain human and kind.
Our commitment to losicum,
where do we find the courage
to have the commitment to losicum? It's
because we have faith that kill the
comos Hashem, that Hashem is the one
who's going to get it done. Hashem is
the one who gets it done.
Um, wanted to get to a lot more in
Kedoshim. Let's try to hit on one or two
last ones.
Perky test pasuk lamed gimel. Let's go
to what the fair schmool.
Kriah gorit chage ba'artzechem losonu
perky test pasuk lamed gimel 19 33.
When there's a stranger who lives lives
with you losonu
oso. Don't taunt him. Don't aggravate
him. Don't aggrieve him.
Don't aggrieve him. Why? Cuz the pasuk
goes on as achi kemi al achi
ya'agareitchem, make him a citizen,
welcome him.
Vi'ahavta lo kamocha. He's giving me
some maritz mitzrayim. Be loving, be
welcoming. Why? Because you were
strangers in mitzrayim in Egypt. You
know what it was like to be a foreigner,
to be an outsider. It's the fair schmool
show bear bam writes here inyan ger ein
adaf ki ger mamash. When we talk about a
ger, we're not talking about a convert.
even is gayer el akol isha bami
makam rachok. Here the Torah is telling
us anyone who comes from the outside,
who feels like a stranger,
gam kein nikra ger is called a ger.
Ger is the opposite of toshav. A toshav
means a resident, comfortable, fits in,
belongs.
Ger is the outsider,
the immigrant, the person feels like a
stranger. V'yesh b'chol tzibbur zeh
l'karvo she'hu kamocha echad mikem. What
this means is make him or her like one
of you. Lo kamo is zar. Don't let them
feel like an a stranger. Ke'azrach mikem
ya'ager gar. U'k'ma'achein and show bear
bam learns from here. Bachur chadash
she'magia l'yeshiva. A new kid comes to
the class. A new bachur comes to the
Yeshiva. A new person tries to join the
shul. A new person moves into your
neighborhood. Tzrichim l'karvo b'yosuv
b'chol minei ofanim k'dei sh'yargish
noach b'Yeshiva Chadasha k'mo sh'ar
talmidim k'ezrach mikem. How do you make
the person feel
I'm a long-time member of BRS.
I've been going to the school forever.
I've been working here forever. I've
been in this Yeshiva forever.
Make sure they have a seat at the lunch
table. Make sure they have a seat in the
shul. Make sure they get invited for the
Shabbos meal. Sh'lo yargish k'mo sh'hu
ger. Because we knew that what that was
like. We understand what this is like.
Yosef HaTzaddik in Parshas Vayeigash es
ha'am avirah mimitzad Gush Dan ad
Mitzrayim ad Katzei Ha'Aretz. Rashi
writes, lo diya chashiv k'shelo Yosef
sh'nisgav l'hasachir b'me'achav sh'lo
k'mo sh'ar am golem. One of the things
that Yosef tried to do when his brothers
came to Mitzrayim was to integrate them.
He had a tremendous welcome committee
and buddy system. He made them feel not
like strangers and outsiders, like they
didn't belong, awkward. He made them
feel like they were there. That's this
mitzvah. That's the Torah's telling us
about geirim. We have modern-day
application. It doesn't just mean the
convert, who this certainly applies to,
who's trying to navigate very often
awkward, complicated situations. That
convert, I would say,
an extension of that is the baal
teshuvah.
We have in this room, we have in our
community,
we have among the Jewish people, you
know, we have sitting here, you can't
pick it up on the camera. We have a page
turner.
And we list, we have the incredible
Weiss family and others
who keep people on the page.
And sometimes, from people from other
neighborhoods, I won't mention which
general area geographically,
will at best ask about it,
often be cynical about it. Yeah, what
kind of shul page turner, what are you
doing, what are you announcing, what's
going on there?
I explain to them, if there's one person
in the room who doesn't know what page
we're on,
and you know, we don't know that
experience. You want to know that
experience? If you're Ashkenazi, one
time go down with this fire dome.
You want to know that experience? If
you're in Rome, don't go to the Chabad,
go to the Rome shul that is still fire
and you don't know what page, where
they're up to, what's happening here,
what's going on.
You'll know what it's like to be an
outsider. You'll know what it's like to
say, "Can someone show me what page?"
But I'm embarrassed to ask. Do we stand?
Do we sit? Does everybody stand? Am I
supposed to be What's happening right
now?
Do you know how horrible a feeling that
is for someone? I don't know what page
we're on. I don't know what they're
saying. I don't know if we're supposed
to stand or sit. I don't know what's
happening right now. I'm just imitating
others. No idea what that's like. No
idea what that's like.
We have a page turner. If one person
doesn't have to be embarrassed, is able
to see it and know what page they're on,
therefore can daven and feel like they
belong,
what a mitzvah that is. At what expense?
At what cost? Just for putting up a page
turner? We're getting the renderings of
our new shul this morning. We're still
finishing. It's going up. It's building.
With Hashem, we're going to be in
November. Part of the conversa- Where
are we going to put the page turner?
How could you have a shul that people
can be in and don't know what page
you're on?
You can't have such a shul. I don't care
how frum you think you are, how far you
think you've come, what you're trying to
prove to whoever you're trying to prove
it to.
Isn't it more important that every Jew
isn't a fulfillment of this pasuk? Ki
agur itcha ger. Somebody has the courage
to come to a shul who hasn't been there
before, who didn't grow up that way, who
doesn't have the education. Do we begin
to understand the courage it takes to
come across that door?
We don't begin to understand the courage
it just takes to come on that campus.
We shouldn't make it as easy as possible
for them.
Do everything that we can for them. Page
turner the least of it. The least of it.
Be welcoming. Have a seat. Hand a
sitter. Offer to show the page if they
look like they're uncomfortable or don't
know what.
Tell them what you've done.
Ki agur itcha ger. If somebody lives
here, that's what you got to do. That's
what you got to do. I don't want to
embarrass people in this room. There's
somebody who started out later in life
coming and somebody else said, "I see
you use a little They recorded for them
the davening. Here's what we sing.
Here's how it goes. Listen when you
want." I just did it for you. You don't
have to. You have it if it'll help you
in your davening. That's a fulfillment
of this mitzvah. That's unbelievable.
Cuz we know what it was like and we were
there. And that's what the Torah is
telling us. And it's not just talking to
the kid in Yeshiva. That's what Shmuel
Baron Barta for Shmuel is directing it
to. It's talking to every one of us.
Adults can be bullies. Adults can be
unwelcoming. Adults can fall into
cliques. Adults can be callous. Adults
can be sarcastic about page turners much
worse than children. Sometimes they get
it much faster than we do. What a
mitzvah. What a beautiful thing. Even
though there was so much more, we will
leave it there.
And uh may we pick up next week.
Please stay for tillum. We're still
davening. So much to daven for. We'll
finish all safer tillum. Everyone takes
a booklet. It'll take just a few
minutes.