Do Women Have a Mitzvah To Eat on Erev Yom Kippur? - The Great Dilemma of Rebbi Akiva Eiger

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com good evening everyone so in preparation for tomorrow which is the uh era of yum kippur the ninth of tishrei after all we know the german if they fasted on the ninth and the tenth so from here we learn there's a mitzvah irasa to eat on arab yom kippur so there's a big shailah and this is a shiloh that many of the khoinim are koiker and they they ask about and really the first uh the uh maybe not the first but the the resha in hamid abram the head of all those who figure out this issue is rebecca vega rebecca veger and the chuvas in cemetery it has a following suffix and that is our women what's a shama shadow is like this on the one hand it's a mitzvah di raisa it's a mitsubishma grama says mr chan's my grandma woman should be potter from eating on ibm kipper on the other hand it's learned out from the initial part of inisem is fasting on the 10th and eating on the ninth well if it's part of the ini some women are muhlen therefore they would be of in the mitzvah of eating on erbium kipper and robert kibager uh says that he doesn't have a chance to give a decisive answer to this question and he doesn't give a conclusive answer whether in fact women are machiavos to says that it depends whether the josh of the initial is a full-fledged joshua or just an asmr if it's a mitsudra banan te iran arabiyam kippur then women would be aways however if it's minatora so if the mitzvah taira so then like any other mitsubishi as my grammar women would be paturas the truth is when the min discusses the shaila he says that he once saw in a safer he doesn't remember where this sufficient whether women are voice in the mitzvah of eating on aravyam kippur now it would be doubtful that the milk is referring it has a wondrous name he brings down um that the earliest one who is mustapha and support about this was rabi swal najar the author of limu hashem uh he was the first to have be to present this suffering and that is what is referring to in the chubus of the kisab soy fair he offers the following reason why in fact women are definitely voice in the mitzvah of eating on arab yam kipra subsurface and simon kofi beings and he says like this what's the reason why we eat on erbium kipper one of the main reasons is to have strength to fast the next day which is equally applicable to both men and women women also need to fast so if they need to fast they need to eat the day before now so the shyla then would be well what if a woman is not fasting well it's not fasting in lahore there's no reason to eat she's not fasting the next day and it's the mr shasman grama so she's not going to be much of and she's not going to be of the having strength to fast well in such a case it could be a woman would not be much better as a male rabbi vegar leaves it off as a tsar and so therefore i think it's a very good idea for women to eat tomorrow just in case it might be a mitzvah and women are and even if not eating never hurt anybody so this is uh some of the londos of the mitzvah of eating on araev you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com