Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay, good morning everyone. We're
continuing in
we're in
Alf.
Let's read the again.
When he washes his hands, he needs to
raise them.
The heads the tips of the fingers above
so that the water doesn't go out of the
area
and then recontaminate the hands.
So the Rama says when it says
he means the fingers
another option is you lower them.
from the beginning until the end that
would also be okay. You just have to be
careful.
You have to be careful not to raise it
first
and then lower it
because then the water is going to go
out of the area.
Then it's going to recontaminate the
hands.
Let's see the mish says
this is according to the say earlier
said it's enough to wash it until the
ends of the fingers
but according to the earlier
that we don't have that you need to wash
the the whole hand.
Accordingly, you would have to raise the
whole uh segment of the hand. Not just
the fingers, but the whole hand because
the question is how much of the hand is
required for
if it's just the fingers, you only have
to raise the fingers. If it's the whole
hand, you need to raise the whole hand.
There are those who explain
that when the RAM says the tips of the
of the fingers.
That's what it means. You raise the
whole thing.
Meaning it's not saying only the fingers
and not the hand. It means the hand as
well. But why does it say the fingers?
It's explaining the manner that you
raise it.
of that is the tips of the fingers are
above
and the palm and the arm are below. But
it's not to say you don't raise the
whole hand. You raise the whole hand but
the way you do it is with the fingers up
and the fingers will be higher and the
palm itself will be lower.
What are we afraid of?
Says
We're afraid that the original that
became will leave that area
and if you don't raise it
the water will come back
and contaminate the hands.
And
only
the same thing would be as if you lower
it
since it's lowered from the beginning.
So then the water never left the area.
You lower it
from the beginning until the end.
that is until after you put the there
but afterwards
after the it's okay to lower it. Um but
this is going on if you keep it lowered
uh from the beginning until end that
means until after the but afterwards you
could raise it even before the drying
you would be able to be
even before the drying
you just have to be careful
that not to raise it and then lower it.
That which the Garra says you need to
raise your hands.
That is
if you would keep it in a state of being
raised when you put the on.
The same thing would be if you keep it
horizontal.
We're afraid that the water is going to
go out of the area.
What the means you have to be is as
follows. If you are in the beginning,
you need to make sure you continue to be
throughout. Doesn't mean you have to
raise it. There's no den that form to
work your hands have to be raised. It's
just if your hands were raised in the
beginning, you have to make sure to keep
it that way.
Um
if you kept it lower in the beginning
then
um they will not go out of your then it
won't leave the mim of at all if it was
lowered the whole time.
Okay let's see one more today.
Again,
the Rama says that it's not necessary to
raise it the whole time. It's just the
way the Mishim explains if you start it
off with it raised, you have to make
sure it remains raised. But if you if
it's uh you could lower it from
beginning to end also. But
many question this of
for the reason is that if you keep it
lowered
Maybe the water of natil will never hit
the tips of the finger.
Not sure. Maybe if you if you keep it
lower the whole time, then you pour
water.
How are you going to get Yeah. Let's say
you you keep it like this. You're pour
watering. You're putting putting pouring
water. How's the water going to hit
there?
So you say well if you keep it like this
how is it it makes more sense if you
keep it like this there is no bottom of
the wrist the wrist is connected to the
hand you know luckily the the hand and
the arm are connected but when you go
like this how's the water going to get
the tips of the finger it will run off
will it will it run off and cover the
whole surface area so some question
Therefore, it's correct to raise them
by the way. Now, this would be a reason
to raise it. Even for us who use a raas
and we don't have to be worried that the
water is going to leave the area, but
still if you raise it, you got a better
chance of hitting the tips of the
fingers.
The
brings that it's
the
lame
literally means he shook them and he and
he raised them but it's a lame
you
Nowadays
the miners were not careful about this.
The reason is
we use on every hand
and we also raise the whole hand
nevertheless. Okay. So by the way
besides now we just saw a few reasons
why you should raise the hand. One is al
so that you get the tips of the finger
another is alpabala
we don't know what the cababalistic
reason and the gumar brings a remas from
the pak. So that those are three reasons
to doba
to get the tips of the fingers
and the
but we're not careful about this
nowadays. We're not mcductic with this.
Why
we use
and okay so how is that going to help?
is much less concerned that the water is
not going to get to to the bottoms of
the tips of the fingers.
>> See, see, if you use so much water, it's
going to get there. If you use
>> Of course. Yeah.
>> Yeah. I mean, is it going to hit it
straight or is a runoff
can't? By the way, if you keep it
lowered
cannot hit it, it's not possible to hit
it straight.
Right? So that as opposed to
again we're not we're not saying that we
do it lowered. We're just we we're not
makbid to do it like that.
We we we just we just keep it straight
basically.
When you keep it straight the truth is
you're getting the tips. Are you getting
directly here in between?
Unless you like you know shake it
around.
Anyway,
the brings even though
you don't need to do
says
why the
and the say to do it. So why not do it?
of
and the brings you should be
and say you should do it until your
head. Wow, that's high.
You know, you go to the sink, you know,
that's that's pretty high. The water is
going to spritz everywhere. You're going
to need to not do sponga after that.
But at least according to
it's very by the way that you should do
I mean the gar
is
so very good you use
okay
nevertheless even though
it is correct to be careful
yet you should oversee And be careful to
make sure that the water comes on the
tips of your fingers and on all the
sides.
Not like the multitude.
They only pour on their sides.
They're not careful that the water comes
on the tips of the fingers.
So for sure one thing the reality is
said
we're not the the people are not medic
to do hagba
just a careful reading of the mish would
indicate that there are legitimate
reasons to do hagba even if we do use
raas namely the garra says it and the
garra brings a rem there's a
cababalistic
Plus, if you're
there's no question you have an easier
shot at getting the water on the tips of
the fingers. Nevertheless,
you're not required to do a you are
required to make sure that the water
reaches the tips of the fingers and all
the sides. that brings from the
that
it's
even
because of the
and because of the cababalistic reason
and it's not a big deal. Where are you
running? You you don't have time to do
it. So if you do it
okay let's hold it over here.
Meny, could you call me after?
