Do We Have Free Choice? Part 3 - By Rabbi YY Jacobson

[Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] how astonish they were when they finally saw the exam and it contained no more than two questions absolutely one question and the question consisted of not more than one words and the single question of one word on the exam was my question mark why the students began as we sing in there's mushrooms or sugar racking their mind their grades why what why when why we're and they tried to go in to all of the philosophical works that they have studied and mastered over years to answer this question why some of them began writing essays pages tens of pages to answer the question why every single one of the students fail the exam the sights to one received on a - and one got a plus only - the one who received a - he wrote why because because but he got an A - the one who received the best part he wrote why why not very good you got it you got it I see this review book because there are three types of answers there's an answer why I'll explain to you why there's another answer why because but there's a third type of answer why why not with the very premise of the question is challenged and some of these types of exercises we are going to discover today in various Jewish sources when it comes to the grand question one of the great questions of philosophy if human beings really have three choices the fact that we don't have free choice about everything were many things that's a given the question is to be have free choice about anything the question is really both a religious one and a scientific one studying the nature of the human mind and the universe from a perspective of science and physics the question is a very serious one is predetermine ISM a reality or is there any role in this world for free choice we should know it the tool modern age science modern science over the last few centuries came to embrace very much the idea of determinism meaning that everything was already predetermined based of the neurological chemistry of the human body and even that which we attribute to our free choice is real there any fixed in our biological makeup it's fascinating that it's only in modern physics particularly in an area known as quantum mechanics where no part of the universe is even considered fixed and all subatomic particles are considered to exist not an a fixed date but in a probable state and it's the observation of the human eye the human brain that actually determines not only our own reality but even the universe is reality but the question also exists from a religious point of view and that's based on God's knowledge of God knows everything for the future and his knowledge is absolute and accurate that means that already five thousand seven hundred and seventy five years ago might behavior today tomorrow as well as your behavior has been predetermined for certainly I can't disprove God's knowledge and this was the great topic we addressed in the first two survey the first two rules shield the first two classes on this question now we go to step next step class number three of the subject the primary answer that's been given by most Jewish philosophers from Rhapsody gone all the way down to our own generation has been that of course God knows everything but God's knowledge is a result of your choice it's not your choice which is a result of his knowledge when I know something I know something about you my choice stems from the fact that first exists within you say I see you doing something and as a result of that I know your behavior it's not that your behavior is influenced by my knowledge my knowledge results from your behaviors so God's three knowledge also results from our behavior because each wreck sends the realm of time and the future is the present many attributes this answer to the words of their alma dorama Manila's Trula maimonides and the laws of repentance chapter five raises this question of the contradiction between God's knowledge and our joist he's answered the question by saying I have no answer the writer grab into our own beloved criticizes their own mom on the spot say don't start asking the question in answer if you don't have a satisfactory answer don't go there why do you have to pique people's curiosity then you can't satisfy in any way at least somebody who has the question your anyway not helping them because you're telling them I don't have an answer and II for people who don't have the question what do you have to give them sleepless nights somebody asks me that above them my she says why why do you have to give a sheer about the subject the monitor if you're really gonna say something substantially set before me you're not gonna say anything substantial so thank you for the compliments he said main that made with somebody who thought about it maybe not gonna tell them anything that somebody didn't think about it they shouldn't come to the ship so if you never thought about it you should leave so you know they tell them I said that it was once a nuclear physicist who traveled to China to present his lecture on nuclear physics he considered himself a world genius and when he gets up to give the lecture he didn't know men to read so they arranged for a translator who would translate the letter as usual the case with translators I've done this myself you have to stop after 30 seconds 15 seconds and it's quite annoying and you have to listen to the translator translate your words in a language you don't know and then you wait for the cue when you continue I've done this quite a few times South American countries another country so this great professor gets up huge crowds in Beijing gathered to listen to his brilliance and he begins the lecture in English and after 15 seconds he stops turning to the translator that he may translate that the trance of the emotions to him to continue because for another minute stops continue continues five minutes continuing after 15 minutes stop stop [Music] and the translator looks at the crowd and he translates what he's just said in eight words eight words and then he said go up unbelievable another 15 minutes top translates it in another eight verse continues the lecture after the next 15 minutes it's now 45 minutes stop now we give seven words then he says continue those for another 50 minutes its full hour finishes the lecture and now we translate the last 50 minutes in three words the lecturer is a family he runs over to me racism he says what a genius you are how you had the ability to take my brilliance and compresses it sucks breathing it that's what congregants always ask the rabbis to do I know from experience he says I want to make you my primary pupil you must travel with me everywhere I mean and what have you had to say what did you say about my brilliance and how did you translate how do you do what this is I'll be very honest with you after the first 15 minutes I turned to the crowd and I said that mandarine I said he hasn't said anything new yet after the next 15 minutes I said he still hasn't said after the third 15 minutes I said it doesn't look like he will be saying anything new and finally when you were done I told them I was right so they can one say anything new can one say anything novel on a question that has perturbed philosophers theologians scientists physicists laymen and scholars women that men not for gender it not for on it's abuse but for millennia literally for thousands of years so the primary trend of many Jewish philosophers is that God's choice doesn't God's power doesn't proceed our choice our choice so to speak precedes is now that's not chronologically but thematically last week we showed how this expresses itself and I walk in the world of the news rises of the voices of Bengal and the rocket rubber God the real question is is this what they're on by minute I want to study together two pieces of romba one of them we touched upon but let's study them again and really delve into his words the first is Rambam hooks as you say they have tire irritated babies it's not Babli you say the uptight at baby face I don't know perhaps we choice to make that mistake it's a mistake with fish on a Mac you have ruined the yo yo Maximus I've read too much genre yo yo noise the reboiler survival God does not know his creations and recognize them as a result of their existence to my son reloaded myself like we know that I know you as a result of your existence I observe you I study you i chat with you I listen to you I study any physical phenomenon based on its existence and my knowledge follows its existing elements must ask my note in our sex cases the other way around he knows them because he knows himself the fishes that may show a day a smile a day a hot oil as a result of his own self-awareness he knows whole chapter miss Muffy obviously lying not a translator because everything ultimately is an extension of his existence so it was an extension of this existence it so to speak included in this existence so by knowing himself he knows existence so his knowledge of existence doesn't stem from existence on the contrary he knows existence from knowing himself now to understand this perhaps a little clearer and maybe in a different way take a look at source number three a piece of Tonya Lakota Amorian peyrac Memphis chapter 48 of the Tonya Austin behravesh news almond of Lee Adina out wherever the ballot Anya Marshall Canara who passed away in 1812 of dollar tears was born in 1745 and passed in 1812 dr. Tommy well the Caravela says from the ice through but there is much to make this idea discussed earlier more logical let me give a metaphor fascinating medical come on are those from excited bedight the asian dollar share all Asia oh yeah a person imagines in his mind something he swore he sees presently he made a Chicago fence in October now who the gaba the totally the t special cooling Matsuya went back to him a shock the nature of who was a shadow a you in any class Title II mu calf at my campus are cooler when a person imagines something in his mind in the you moines comprehension you imagine a person of advance a phenomenon any reality we say I have a picture of it at my mom and my enemy I've seen it yesterday I may have seen the ten years if I may be seeing it right now but this reality is in my mind and he says you could actually say that your mind encompasses the entire depth breadth internal and external aspect of that reality of course to the extent of what you see all of its dimensions all in your imagination we all know you may have been at an event and you could still see it you see it you see the people you hear the voices of course all in your imagination or sometimes and this is what we all know as the phenomenon of daydreams is one of the great gifts that the Shiva voice you wish worshipers have developed over thousands of years you're listening to a shear it gets pretty boring and you start daydreaming is no doubt some of you are doing presently and I really don't want to disturb you continue with your dangering but in your daydreams you concoct either future events or you're experiencing past events and they're very real until somebody wakes you up from the daydream where the shear of the speech is over of course your mom is in that reality you can even get upset you could even get a happy about your day trip so it's like manage the whole realities in your market rah-rah governor who look up the diaper too much after wraps angling look of the pile of mush didn't use enough service up in the night however we all understand that the physical body of the person is not on my mind right there's not the actual concrete reality it's just in my imagination a lot but there's Boris would exceed make you lame actually say much of a second and in my shower David I teach you a data : it rhodium my cap is called neutropenia may know about that disabling the takes place called Apollo manage weather invited islands knowledge is awareness of something actually actually compasses the whole reality of that creature of an existence lemarchal's Kadir Haaretz Hollow zoo take our planet planet Earth that ball that we call birth Andy Theo sagebrush meketa Scott BV cataratas his knowledge encompasses and clues and contains the entire depth of the Planet of the ball we call earth the scholarship the place and all that is inside that planet the toys pretty fun and inside the insides of that planet after he's safe from top to bottom I color the pile Mama's shiny need dear zoo he kawaii Kagura red school a be subtle semi lives because actually this mileage is what gives it existence somebody wants a who said they cart said I know therefore I am and the Valhalla is saying God knows they're for I so imagine in that date review created they dream in your mind right let's say Super Bowl you in your mind are now they dreaming about your attendance at the Super Bowl you see you see the tens of thousands of people you see the players you're even eating a kosher hot dog with mustard and sauerkraut and ketchup and french fries and chips and if you want to tweak a beer and of course you have the best seat goes at the daydream you don't have to pay for the ticket so you have the best seat you already seen the plays you feel your disappointment I don't mean to give an iron heart you feel your frustration you feel your agony all the celebrations and it's all my retreat up until if somebody wakes you up from the day treatments it's time to go to Costco it's Sunday no Super Bowl for you now we all understand that we created all those realities of the daydream and as long as we think about them they continue to exist the moment we stop thinking about them there's no characters in my imagination anymore why because their entire existence consists of what of me dreaming of them this is the metaphor the ballot finally gives for all of creation God dreaming that I exist that is my existence God's knowledge of new existence that is the existence that is what takes you out from a state of nothingness into a state of somethingness because of a like my daydream it doesn't really encompass the physical reality of the person I'm dreaming us it's simply a product of my own neurological waves and imagination abilities but in this case is he be actually consists of the real world and it is its it is its life which explains another famous doctrine of the Baal Shem Tov that creation happens every moment creation happens now it doesn't happen a moment ago and in order to live you always have to be tuned in to matter to the heartbeat of the universe which is taking place right now why the need for this idea and one of the explanations is this metaphor of the tandems because imagine in the daydream okay what has to happen for all those people at the Super Bowl to disappear from my brain what has to happen I have to stop thinking I have to stop daydreaming why why will they cease to exist and the answer is because the definition of their existence was nothing but me thinking of them so the moment that seems to think of them there's no existence because they don't have an existing outside of the reality of my thoughts this is true about all of existence the definition of existence is God thinking or speaking the world into existence that has to be perpetuated every single moment for it to happen which demonstrates the intimacy between Hashem and every creature it's not just a one time relationship 6,000 almost 6,000 years ago it's actually a relationship that is as intimate and as close as possible because your very being at every aspect of it is part of this desire and is now the dragna and a side note the reason we call it speech not thought in veracious we say a chef speaks the world that fits the world what's the reason I'll tell you because when I was thinking of you in my mind could you have and can you have an independent reality outside of me now because thoughts remain within us words leave our system they can be misinterpreted they could be distorted in the telephone game they remember the telephone day they could be completely distorted right how many times have I got equality I heard you said this last shot is how do you have this whoops book you know classic classic Jewish stuff like I never said it what do you need you never said and I heard two employment even playing the X Y Z I said I said exact opposite but he was daydreaming of course and he woke up at the end right so words have a life of their own the reboiler slurred speaks the world into existence meaning that we can perceive existence in a very different way than he does so this gives us some more depth and explanation to the ROM Bob's words that gods now that doesn't stem from existence to the contrary he knows himself and therefore he knows existence and about because that knowledge is actually the very source of the life of the existing reality now let's take a look around the mothership apparently [Music] they call my idea God knows the future so how do we have choices da should schumer cybozu I will Sumerians me to recover media this question is longer than the earth and broader than the see the comedy gunday lovara Grumman Korean bar many fundamental ideas and mountains are the Panda glimmers I will sort us out the later hovered with over session dealing but I want you to understand one thing I want to tell you cry-baby I'm going to pay - Amy Miller said the outfit I really explained to you in the second chapter of a second which we quoted a source one travelers furnish a birthday every data she comes to me memo came out and said that that looks like he doesn't have knowledge like we have where this thing that I know is completely distinct from me there is you and then I learn about you so my knowledge comes from you and who you Salish wave at I came out he and is now just one because everything he knows us from himself been diagnosed by the acid lovers Albury we cannot comprehend as well hookah Shan Shan cares by the possibility to say thank you so great it is just like we have no way of comprehending the existence makes truth of what God is nor can we comprehend what it means that God knows who shall love if I make you learn much the same actually I say from behind our faith from profit you Shia and avi says my thoughts are not yours my ways are not yours Viki much chicanes aim Manu class lately gave this wonderful opera in my eyes therefore we simply don't have the capacity to know how Hashem knows all creation that all of their actions I don't need them Alissa what we do know without a doubt shall I serve them beyond hardly our actions are dependent on us but a nugget as far as the mental abilities another glasses God was not fully wouldn't either actually doesn't decree upon you what to do the lady Picabo Assad possible later the celebrant is Bruce Madeira Hoffman it's not only a religious tradition which would suffice but we know it's also through the system of life with Lisette Harriman who worship Dominus other by myself is he my seventh item in rap the Third War II - she called me out of acclaim but the whole traumatic is based on the idea that human beings have reaches now I ask you a question do you hear in these words of the rambha the answer that Ramesh Amish any know that the men who smooth over the toasters yontiff give namely that God's knowledge does not contradict with free choice why because his knowledge stems from our free choice it's like I know what you have chosen yesterday because it happened already and by Hashem the future and the past are present and therefore he knows what I will choose the matter of small rights of this question the Metro school is a commentary on 30 August that was written by one of those moments of them is irreparable news EDA who lived in the 16th century in the 5th hundreds in spots and he wrote a commentary many schmaltz a lovely commentary and when he asks this question in picking others on the Mishnah called softly borrow shoes from the Sunna Kiva's words he says the cushy assume a car in a lesson the question doesn't even begin he says I don't even see a problem here and it gives a very lovely illogical essence and the answer is knowledge doesn't contradict choice I know what you chose and it doesn't contradict your choice you know why because you chose it and that's why I know it has said knows what I chose before I chose it the problem is how to understand someone being aware of the future before the future happens so that's a question of what does it mean something is beyond time and sees reality from a dimension that transcends time got that that's a problem but the many small says I understand what I don't understand and because I understand what I don't understand I say that she does not between choice and knowledge the question is how to manage that before the choice be similar to knowledge after the chess many say this is what the Rumba meant when around themselves we can't understand her sense now that what he means is how hash them understands palace' knows the future before it happened in our realm yet many books at this moment said this is not what their number was saved rambling is saying that it's a Russa merits Vida that to recover mimi um he gets involved in this whole idea that God knows everything from himself and not from outside the creation he elaborates how there's no way a person can understand God's knowledge and yet he knows and yet there's free choice and he said I really don't understand is there I'm I'm really giving the same answer that the men who small says so others many Irina's will see that their arm is not saying and yet arrived it says if he's not saying it yeah so why bring it up the toast was jumped obsessed dorama brings it up yes a good answer the answer that the men who shul gives us a great answer if we say their album is not giving that answer it doesn't seem that way so why really not especially as we understand what they ramp up selling hostesses so the attire that God knows everything from himself or is the time he puts it the life of all reality comes from God's knowledge now you can't give any more the answer or it might Samba she didn't win the madness more my knowledge doesn't interfere with your choice because your choices have nothing to do with my knowledge but what if your very existence including your heartbeat and including your brain power comes from me knowing mine knowledge is actually the source of your existence so then my knowledge precedes your existence my knowledge is the cause of your existence so is my knowledge not the determining factor of your choice here we have a whole other problem in others if we distinguish between Hashem is Judea and people's actions so God is just an objective observer then I could say Hashem transcends past present and future and he knows the future in advance and it doesn't influence your choice but if our shemin's knowledge of existence is coming from himself or even deeper have shadows knowledge of existence is the life of existence so now the knowledge of this existence including our choices are what allow us to make those choices so the knowledge doesn't follow the choice the choice follows the knowledge if that's the case the random can't just give this answer which is not beyond logic of the metro school to reconcile it and the rubberman Dida's rights for telling us that I have no way of understanding his idea it's completely beyond me and so forth which is why we now come to a different dimension of addressing this question in this dilemma outside of the answers that we have discussed in the other classes if you take a look in the safe relay verse Allah vollis which is one of the earliest book of Jewish it's written by Rabinovitch I even pakoda who lived in the 11th century it shatter I've read this on the Kim he writes in Paradise after going back and forth back and forth this conclusion is a very wise conclusion this conclusion of clever solvolysis that the most logical thing to say about this question is we don't understand that's what the fingers tell about possess and he said I'll tell you even more the reason we don't understand this for our benefits because if it would have been for our benefit to understand I would have allowed us to understand the fact that he keeps this mysterious beyond logic is because it's better for us not to understand he doesn't explain why it's better for us you can speculate on your own generations later the been a sucker one of the great aesthetic matchups really mellows of dinner writes in his safe return a sauce we're encouraged to Schrader's in the section of Tichenor and he also writes this in this commentary on Berkeley honestly couldn't miss month of May in sorceresses let me tell you what the famous olive of us meant seven hundred years ago when he wrote that it's better for us that we don't know what the reconciliation between Hashem is knowledge and our choices and the base of the offers two explanations one both very interesting his own his own unique style of you familiar with the style and thought processes of the holy place of so he says as follows this is number one there's a midst of a halacha the betrothal which means you have to emulate Hashem so God is telling us I want you to emulate me in this area as well namely you look at me and you say do I know don't I know if I know then I don't have many don't have choice if I don't know then you do a course but I don't know so it's like do I know I don't know I don't know it's not clear if it would be clear you would say of course but alas the padron he wants you to behave the same in its us possess madoff vision we initiative you have to know in relationships to see something and say no I don't know I don't know he says sometimes we see people these are his words and they do a lot of our failures they do a lot of since this is the last of it your honor and you decide there Russia they're bad they're terrible he says learn from God what have you learned from God understand to appreciate the fact that there's so much that you don't know there is a part I once heard from the heat his name is red label Posner he told me that he was once as a barter he was once by there I asked by the 6th and Obama to remember abrasive it's works Nelson who's your tech was just Thursday Friday huge he was traveling to communities to communities on Nicholas in the 1940s and he told them he fell he said they never told me this is where this voice and you dish I'll say they're not translate he says the - a fraternity he said you have regular letters they have large letters and you have places to eat in small letters right like that a lullaby he throws there's a smaller the ballot of extra this is why the mindless when I eaten documents in the Salinas when I hidden that Middle East Patterson I have to know you this forever the - when I eaten that means ends this is silliness were knots made are finished fires a meaning your virtues I have to see your flaws I don't have to oversee but I don't have to see them don't be naive somebody else flows someone's have to know how to deal with them but that's misfired is then you don't have to oversee them you have to appreciate how to hand you know but you don't have to see them the plane starts who says this no but don't know in a relationship even if you know some things you don't have to know it's healthier that way it's wholesome that way give people their space it's not turning a blind eye from naivete you know and you still choose not to know and then the place us it gives a second insight and the second insight has to do with the new suck of Midway of confession which he poses as a great challenge and we have it in the sources the last source on your first page no sir Kavita in our confession that cause al instituted this is what we said cybermats myself in which prepares my illegible I shoveled on her life it's a bleak I'll call up our lender chemists assist of an afternoon shop we have done the wrong thing we have made the wrong choices now starts a whole presentation my mother for maturation of mother - Apple finestra shredder good what should we tell you now they call it as far as my little us after your day you know everything that's going on actually there is a problem assistant coach ollie apples lifeless Co company about the diversion closes Mullane hinari now look at that luminous terminated at NASA you know all the secrets you know anything that's happening in my heart nothing that's concealed nothing is eclipsed okay who the same and thus who became and thus erupts in more finesse our symbol dependability of the same should disrupt normal cause have to say no simple and I'll probably say most couple the laptop change and thus we tell our sham please forgive us ask the basis or what's the message first of all of God knows everything why do just stand 10 minutes confess it just get up and say you know everything just forgive me no first we go through while hate the one I'll hit another hey can we make sure to go through the entire alphabet and to go through every possible now hate and the most important one is our hips at the whole philosophy is them as I see them used to say boa them a below you know the move ace of a mastiff innocently behind them you know but the lawyer I think we make believe that you don't know and then you fallible you know everything you know all the secrets so why you confessing number two you tell us them oh you know everything so basically I can't hide so you know mum - how terrible an oh but hey okay if I not know everything maybe then I'll forgive you if I know everything so why am I gonna forgive you what's this introduction says that makes us who were talking about something else with a mother philosophical problem we just took fest and we took accountability we took responsibility but then we say one sec do you know anything beforehand in that one we miss them in anything that huh you know the whole future so if you know the whole future and it was accurate I really did not a choice so I don't deserve any punishments I'm not accountable there's no remorse why am i confessing why am i doing Trouville so what's going on either that confess and I have remorse whatever you know there's a philosophical question that the person is raising according to the main star in the Vedic and the answer for this says the main sorceress I don't know it's exam it's a costume that's what the trainer says or the same so realize that the very basis and justification for me to take accountability and to do chuhwa is because trainer because I accept the words of training that has three choice so this means that even the greatest sinner in the world of mass Oscar says there is no room to punish him without trainer there's no room to hold them accountable and give him any sorrow English without trainer without his connection to Toyota does that in itself is the greatest limit sauce is the greatest source of merit for the Jew because it's only his relationship to tighter even allows them to be a comfortable that type of a cane based on this that you really know everything and the only reason we're doing children's lot because tell you this says so so that means we have an essential relationship with China so therefore Tanaka Malay mile Kolkata sagal and he says in the next world that's the same thing there's no room to punish anybody unless there is sexual relationship to tell you and then automatically everything is different the elaborate set late from this notion this is how he approaches comes the hey Latoya hi the owner of time if you'll turn to page two it's double sided in gracious at the end of passion gracious where Hashem says that when the bus it says a sham saw how evil the scheme of manners and he regretted the whole creation says the earth attire it's a quite intense and I would say a McMahon attire high-end offered by the banal hi I'm Ben heart the great sage of Morocco later made a yacht Texas talk to us a lion when he passed away in 1740 and is interred in huge alignment Harris a in the Mount of Olives near Alliance during a hiatus videre Haram Bob Iger the words of the Rambam are steadfast despite the criticism of their eyes PA life indeed is a sham who said missus Lena who may need Michelle McCaskill CBM and it may love who is going to attribute our type of knowledge to God's knowledge and use our India as a metaphor for his IDI vasilica let me explain to you what their Dharma means they are said you're from the show are you diem who said this video server bow hey Diana God has the ability to negate the knowledge that he has that he should not know what he knows to stay here to harden when he wants my saying cut has been his master's voice shitake I love my India below your dama a person can't do this if now reaches me I can choose to say I don't know this I do not tell us the jury's all the time judge will always tell the jury disregard what they write right who share Rama's I remember every night dish a lot in the struggle my house this is what the Rambam hinted on when he says we can't comprehend this knowledge create a search at IKEA although I am a asthma the team swallows maximum how is it possible that now that should reach Hashem and yet this very same knowledge should be negated by God to the point that he doesn't know who shower like a so this is what it says the pipes is baroque liheap it oven be actively rahama be strong he did not see iniquity among jacob or sin among Israel he was all right you see kissing it's a sham so loyal to us you slug her you did when I said chooses not to know he doesn't know how gosh I'm a hot summer even though with a human situation it will never happen I can't choose not to know if you choose not to tell me how your mother if you choose to tell me and I do no space so there is introducing a new concept but there are mom is saying is how shows now that doesn't contradict our free choice because he has the ability to choose not to know and that's part of his the hind doesn't explain this any further although he goes on to a different topic but take a look at another commentary written by a very different source there was a student of the baal shem tov known as REM you feel miserable slushious the helices lots of imagines he had a child whose name was Ruby it's Huck wrote a book called utter get suck in my tits Huck he quotes something he heard from his father the missiles watch Ellen May oh yeah colors a masseuse a yarmulke on I wanna share something for my father that missile to be feel missile of luncheon as I mentioned the second generation of hostages the pasta it says it to him every morning the end of Philip rallies mark Chavez believed ish but sandy sucker at Southwest my hometown white Maxim I sleep with a dirty murdering to you I'm right by a sip of a yarmulke accurate buckling up gathered by buckle are shunned Easter others gloss how do we translators you remember when you said it this morning how do you translate you were they trained ink okay it's Sunday morning but no confession there are many sports in the heart of a man but God's scheme this is what unders Hashem seems thanks forever his thoughts for every generation because he said and it was he commanded and it stood Titans of missiles much of it Jaime not as much obvious looked over dying believe me robberies Marcos we have so many different types of thoughts do this do this positive negative right wrong just I'm just sensitive insensitive respectful disrespectful cognitive emotional impulsive I will appear to some of the other other might be able to play but you have a choice to choose you can choose your path a lot of thoughts going on we have a lot of these speeds should I eat this fish my fingers I not say this I said this email what do i do how I respond but you have a choice the idea shy so she asked are the main in my shreya God loves knowledge that you can ascend doesn't force the cell this is what the pasta considers ravish my Shabbos blemish and you could choose what about hot sauce a sham didn't touch them have a perspective this is about secession he suffered he suffered God's scheme God's perspective stands I mean Sheamus really it doesn't force you it stands still so to speak versus my Island Tom boils it remains standing suyama shudder she gave us a gesture the Amendola ride will be hot Rafa his knowledge it is the earner and it doesn't force it less that would be a hollow saw the masses can hear us less you pick shoes but I won't be sure my shaft only by the dirty burger to my uncle but who way they of a cold Berkshire yes although in every generation here many knows what's gonna happen I was a UDA my mind really after this now it doesn't force you why Bozell who are my valet who Baris are in Mumbai Meera how did he create the world from saying he said let there be light and there was Lance the sake of my beginning Siva but when it comes to mitzvos commandments by gamba say caballo so birds who would see Bob by Yamaha suing myself academician yes don't see Basha gamma bleep oh Allah shall learn the habeeboo there is the creation of the world and all of existence through amar beginning and it comes into existence through his words when it comes out every Siva when he commanded by Yahweh there it stands in the sense that his knowledge does not force the person's actions well as L will be a sultan allah wait- heroes the limos for novel increment table the kind of its places but endless defeated signing up colleges and therefore we have a choice Caesars Palace Marcela's blemish that's a Sasha he saw one second that's a Sasha long Obama but maximize sleep on the donor throw into the whole Mesa going on that soon as few hours I get who see ma that's not binary by God wait and he continues Keauhou buffer no Yasha you stole the school bus he chose he chose they should have choice so this is very similar to verify there's a sprinkle from the Baal Shem Tov in Kester Shem Tov Simmons in Memphis so fascinating to go the Vinaya just say most pieces of kester Shem Tov which is a compilation are from different sources of students of the Baal Shem Tov this feasts however they did not find in any of the books of the students so we're exactly the author of cats except of gothis and attribute the name of the box relative is unclear I should just say this because this is quite a heavy piece of the motion still in should manifest like char the big silence have it's a bit wide initially Russian how are you there Caleb eh they evaluate should suffer be but that said clothing is being dishes any atomic in cable to fool the eye since I believe puzzle my scar victim the others who say you know I believe touch and lavish given solely the shyness is the osseous butterfly he's asking here the classical question if he knows what you're gonna do in this knowledge is accurate you are a forest either to be a tablet or a Russian it's completely predetermined but yes why manner here is an answer listen to these words he has not at what you're gonna do McCormick and hurrah suit somebody's father Steve Omar says his designer is that you should live in a process of wholesome godly way PL can see below no collateral Mitzvah son that's what he gave us Ted Mitchels bartilson box my monopoly dear virtuous on his will collides with his knowledge the usual utterly monstrous after its own our son his brother could see booyah the lawyer have idea and man has the ability to follow his will God's will in contrast to God's knowledge Charlotte sir yuria idea because God's will ultimately will define God's knowledge keyword shane Chaffetz the Ruxin our champion to Zuma my sister because God doesn't want this knowledge that he has that you're gonna sit this desire contradicts his knowledge and because as desire contradicts his knowledge man has a choice to follow his desire rather than his knowledge behind each element Aqsa his knowledge that you are going to who's destructive path is contrary to his will the mutes are automated myself commercial where lots of Josh I'm his mother but like yo you did be a shout silver absolutely how you did but there's not little bit wrong one second and if a person wants he can follow God's desire and not to lower himself to the state of God's knowledge where he supposed to sin he can go to the roads he how he just showed out who are not bad said she has a drafter God's knowledge of evil that is what it is shouldn't've Rasulullah sign outside thinking it was created by God's knowledge that should exist that's what gives it existence in order to give a test to the person commercial Asif Kidman now such a mother Kate semester P ILM has evolved on his site this is the world of tests China shaman ish letters from the I Savannah Sian by la maza the soul is sent to experiment experience these tests then vinyasa hey how I got an idea so if he follows the sin he'll be follow me God's knowledge which is the reason that it's it can exist then why a sir had a yacht after her Robson back serial monogamy dia and if he doesn't do it then I'll follow God's will which opposes his knowledge so the knowledge of the negativities dear to give the person the test and a lot of the person to say no to the knowledge and follow the will shall say memory Shane ray asked me fire flash' that's why by a carbonate says great ask me try up so cause I'll say knock a sewer fun I shall Marty then a separate so me my pleasure is I said but what happened was you follows my will for how hated and this I tell you to understand well anybody understands and your followers if then if you do good and you follow his will and his knowledge is horses right very good so you're because I have to do everything you could even change that which is Lahontan if I could say an anecdote they say that Yogi Berra soul of an Irish to summon his wife once asked them and she said no they better have a question for you you were born in Missouri you live in New Jersey and he plays with the New York Yankees we should I bury you he said surprise me [Laughter] the same man also said you should go to somebody's funeral if you want him to come to yours surprise me that's what the vault hunter is telling us God says surprise me I want and I need you to surprise me true there's knowledge box says there's no knowledge because doesn't exist there's no now somebody's saying it robot is purely philosophical this is on a different level yes doesn't he know the surprise as well if you surprise you know the surprise that's the office anymore that's the table the option you want this to be right right right so so what what are we here what are we hearing in these worries on a knowledge level he knows what you're gonna do see it another choice because you have to follow that knowledge but then there's something else there's what you might call his love his passion his desire this desire that you choose a relationship this desire that you write your own biography this desire that you create your own destiny that you tell your own story this is a deep desire a deep Allah that Hashem has and in words that he uses is rough sorry my Korea how you dia meaning this passion and his love for a real relationship with you based on your choice puts a lid on his unleashes a Michigan's means his his absolute knowledge his passion his desire for you for your contribution that love is so deep that it challenges and it limits so to speak his knowledge so it's like his desire to give you free choice to give your life your own individual dignity this cheering this cheering that you live your own life so to speak limits as knowledge it's like almost Hashem has a predicted future of what you gonna do but as that is happening he's standing and cheering and it's like go go go choose choose choose and you're like wait I can't choose you chose you did anything I'm just a victim and you're a buddy sir Williams response to that is that's on one level and there's another reality another reality where I have shrieked or limited or restricted that infinite hold and and and I cheer you on it may be it may be is connected to another fascinating interpretation by the student the Magadan is written of Gemara the Gemara talks about it's quite an intense game arm of Mencia about nothing to get involved in the details here about certain sages or pup others who are physically very obese and the Damara asks a question how they can have children how can they physically have children when there was no room for intimacy and the Gemara answers for words Alva the aspectus as a busser love shrinks the flesh the intense passion physically shrunk their flesh and thus they can have children says the magnetism is rich and the ballot kinda quotes at a time their favorite men tests chapter 49 this is not just the game already knows its cutest controverted a most intriguing just knows the story of my passion is infinite I have a pectus as a busser his love to humanity his desire is passionate to have a relationship with you on your terms not only on his terms caused his flesh is infinite presence to shrink what we call in Kabbalah that sits on allowing the autonomy of the human individual to chart their own course in life and both forces are playing themselves out simultaneously in a person's life so God is telling the person I beg you surprise me shock me so this will puts a lid on his knowledge and that gives the human being the power to liberate himself from the shackles of God's knowledge based on God's desire because God's knowledge is basically a quality of God's infinity God's passion is his choice for a relationship and it gives the person the ability to go to go to go beyond I he knows it and if he knows it it's the truth and you can't contradict the truth so it seems like what about some others say that the same God gave a person the ability to transcend the reality of the world and to connect with his will which is which is what Turner admits lists which is what Trey that Mitzvah starlets almost like this too that mentions to reality there's one reality when we are complete victims and that's actual reality it's a very true reality when we are just playing out of script there's another reality what the catches have to the same from God's will his desire is alpha the cactus of subasta where he says this is my essence this is my desire and you can lift yourself up from that world and you have to define that you ever define we now come to the next dimension and here we go to the writings of two great Hasidic masters known as the master layout and episodic acclaim of Lublin a few words about them the mayor Samoa is the commentary on commission Tomas that was authored by rabbi mordechai Yosef liner who was first a student of the COTS forever rubba Menachem Mendel Morgenstern school simulant elena and then he left coughs and he became known as the issue there ever is bit and his work is mayushii lay off why he left cuts how he left cuts is a intense story but it happened in the year 1840 tough race and he was a rapper he was a leader for around 13 or 14 years it passed away in 1854 ll tough Ridge you I'm sorry Tavis tough Ridge new downloads 1854 after he left the cuts occur 1839 1840 he became a repetition it's in the safe of Nashua extremely original Hasidic order he has students the student is known as you saw the cocoon of the Blin Southwark acclaim was al it's Bach fab rental it's luck what they would call a miss a great opponent focusses the story of his life is a tragic one he married at a young age he was a genius he was a genius just to describe his genius the Potala cockeyed used to make a seal on the set of shots every single day not every week and not every month every day he finished them a set of shots and mercy and if he sees writings you saw that he was a gun of panic Titanic proportions Naugatuck I am married his wife his young wife was work and her father store which was a wine store I told this once and people would come in and probably unjustly he became suspicious he wanted a divorce she didn't want the divorce he travelled to get himself ahead to Mayor abundant a hundred grand was to be able to marry a second woman despite because if you don't get a get some it's a failure of a negation acting mayor upon the man in his journeys in his journeys he met the solution Irene will told the man to do with the guy ever told him not to do it he did it and he but met Hasidim in the world of customers he became a Talmud of the issue pizza and after the passing of his own rabbit at labeler Edgar the grantor evacuated in 1888 reprobate became a revered the City of Hope live in Poland with a blade it was and he led for another 12 years till his passing in 1900 he passed away tough riche tough for his son so they could never have children and he attributed to the mistake that he made in aggravating causing aggravation to his first wife his writings are absolutely unique they're very unique yep the mass you love and the student both address this issue quite at length now many scholars have written about their perspectives but wolfen people say that southern can then make sure that don't believe in Peter they don't believe you have choices everything is determined and you could see why they will say them but they confuse it with the idea that they're saying basically do whatever you want because God is anyway pulling all the strings and do whatever you want you know you're in a bad mood breakers windows but it's a it's a very dishonest portrayed portrayal of most of subject and it's never the match in life it's it's primitive it's it's it's patching yourself to a few words and not seeing the whole context which is a complicated context there's no question but to confuse that with absolute determinism where a person completely is just an absolute there's no even need of telling you anything would undermine the essence of Judaism and Yiddish guy like a round mum says and it's simply not fear to attribute it to them even if admittedly it's very difficult to understand sometimes what they're saying let's learn a few of their work a few of their observations but I know that to appreciate it there's a few pieces of Gemara that I want to review with you and then we'll come to a few of their pieces brushes the pyramid out dr. Kumari bravas they're going to be very disconnected pieces of Gemara but we'll see how they come together how pillars Burroughs who hit me sir Myles Estey Obama Lilly shallow little bacteria South Island history yog was one of the kings of the Jewish people of Judea Hashem made us sick and he tells you Shayan avi go visit the sick remember by the other name Hollis whiskey all of us whatever you love you say o Muhammad son of evæmon of clamour our cents out of the basis of Khamis optimally city Mike he base a family system a SAP to boil impossible it to feel alone APPA shadow on of a thousand you are going to die oh my leg michael i why on my leg shy doesn't swim the last activity of Olivia you never actual dream you never got married risky oh I love each other to remain a bachelor not that church oh my lord Cecile said you know why mission because I adore how fighters did not skip midnight bun into my mouth I saw through us how cookies of divine inspiration that my children will be no good mix they're going to do troublemakers what do I have to bring children into the world oh my lawyer shia tells them behind tough come on the la mala why are you interfering into God's secrets my the myth goddess buddy the muffled methods when he told you to do you have to do oh my the miss had come a coach originally offered and what he wants to do let him do how your children are going to come out is none of your business you saw Bruce how clean this something about pixel my step told you prove we asked that the result is none of your business on my legs this skill was a clever man taozi Shia master hardly Bravo you know what give me your daughter after the garden exclusive the diva did thoughtful enough to midnight mom in the meow you know between you and me your sauce wife's clothes maybe for it the kids will have some hope what do they say in English my looks and your brains this can told you Shia are Nabi my system yours closer maybe and he marries you Shia on Ovie's daughter oh my lady Shia said fine because it all F of Zeta sorry this already Xavier you're gonna die come on the club it's a your practice CS ended leader tell me how you were repeating God's words now you're telling me it's hopeless now you're not online I'm not speaking the boy Ken's gave me sometimes once he became the Sperry it's peaked in this way right cash would complain he made based on bi bi hurts me to say that people care of Kappa molasses all summer all the money math women are asking them even if the sword is by the person you should not prevent yourself from compassion we know that sis here Mary deshyla's daughter he had children and of course the rural firefighters was riots Menasha became the mother of 55 years it was the most evil tyrant and despot in the history of Jewish Kings an ancestor all to the point that in the Morrises am essentially Obama's not meant test that he murdered who he murdered he murdered his own Seder you just learned finished give office mom nobody's letting if I must he gave up he murdered his own saving Shia movies he murdered this ad a shia movie you tomorrow saddest and son had good this year didn't give him an education says this he gave him every type of education in the world he sent them to 29 days she said the burners gulf sunburn is powerful that's one story in the sector brushed by the by the end of his life Menasha the children tomorrow says it's happened in 11th chapter EDA Trula the mala him said god no way and whether that sham do cut on my steer and he built a tunnel in heaven so that it not sure could come through the tunnel strange story who runs the show in heaven God and the angels we thought here this red tape but up there there's no red looks like this red tape there to the my lock you said nobody's going back to build a tunnel to let Menasha come in without the total he couldn't get in you think there's only God boy I'm here just go for it ok that's not good fresh there next stick of the martyr shop is not fake that's on the base the plastic says in years a patient Carson incursean with y'all be know if your sins will be like red scarlet they're gonna become white Mike saw that big America shoving me by inlay it should be singular just like it says kiss Shelly doesn't think a slug in it says kiss chelev it should say cash on me like a red spring mallet red screams I'm gonna be it's accepted me to come below knuckle is wonderfully strong God told the Jews in here - agent Colin Marlowe Lucius doula is somebody's change this may be wrenches man - Abigail be know if your sins are going to be like these years comin in the sense of years which are organized from the six days of creation and they follow in the journey of history if your sins are going to be like these years then they will become white like snow what does this mean if your sins are sprung shook like history they will become white next you Martin nasser got some gimel Emeth babes keep us all in mind or it not somebody eats a lot of a tumor smart me Mitchell under a sin done for the sake of God is greater than the midst of an unfaltering motives and the you moderate brings the story of who we learned to yesterday in the afternoon of Shabbos mashaallah the story of Yael sister ran away from the front he runs into the 10th of Yael what happens she feeds a milk so he becomes tired the governor says that Nasser Radi shadow believers they had relationship seven times to get an exhaust fit so she could ultimately take his life and deliver victory to the Jewish people who suffer terrible persecution from Sisera and this is the cadeau de la Vega the Shema the sin that Yael did in her relationships with Cicero that day is though the me mitzvah shall I lose more as the camera says at the end that's similar to a midsummer the mixed racial issue I believe deserted that food based on an out of tiny little intro there's a logical bit de la vie de Zara meaning if a Gentile builds a little nice get scale or idle he could nullify it if he says it's worthless it's north it's nothing that's just a simple rock it becomes nullified you could use it what about a Jew who worships on our wave is our aim my victim alumnus is nothing that you can do to ever nullify it it has to basically be buried destroyed there's nothing no way that he could convert it into something permissible so I'm thinking no because automata please don't mean I mean I mean why away this becomes a soldier to nagisa how do you know that an idol of a Jew needs to be hidden and cannot be converted into something permissible shanem are the past success in shyster like see fellas ha Shana called 8/8 on his base the planets extry of idolatry near the old term in debate some interest of the mission so we see that the tired of juxtaposes a tree of idolatry to the miss bay after Walters mommy's bay I told mr. Arthur Sheratons just like the Miss beta that can be used in other destroyers you know let me use it for anything else you have to hide it so I shaded the isle tree of jim has the same sadness like than this bad had to be something that was used for car bombers meaning in the sense of course nothing told in the sense that the kinesin can't use it for anything else it has to be him one last pickle Gemara human thought the government business operates much though the chuvash is doing this constellation with goddess Truman's foursome because it creates a situation where your sins that you did willingly are mistakes jenever Julia still have a similar castle people shout the bar Vanessa how amazing the cookery line Mitchell oh he means it was done willingly an attorney said it was just the mission was a mistake because Childre deems it a mistake God says it was a mistake vantika martini it's not true well we're suckers doing the troopers just doing this nonsense like a scientist rich luggage said it through children your sins become missus they're not mistakes in them are will be shoe rush samira steve austin wish but would soccer and layin yeah the sins become a source of life like our chances to come are there's no contradiction economy our economy depends if he repents out of all or out of love if he repents out of year out of reverence then this device the sins are considered mistakes if he repents out of love then this dullness nurses like recycles the sinners become mrs. we have now studied a few pieces of gomorrah Gomorrah roughness about the Shia Nami and riskier good Mariana Chavez to shun it cafes either summon if your sins are organized like the years of history they will be cleansed Kamara and Nasser about on our favorite leash mark greater than the mid specialist one tomorrow not really deserted that a Jews our disorders like him is bath which can never be used it must be hit meat of the Marlin Yuma that sure bad of love transforms your sins intimacies now take a look in the quote from Sitka oxalic they work right up saw the cation over the Blin Iseman he cannot River who what is true actually you're in Hashem enough Shuba is that God opens your eyes she used under his obvious that you sins become like menses what does this mean God opens your eyes that way since McCulloch mitzvahs writes my the Gemara means this shayok you beloved a person should understand shikko marshal Cutler hiya Duncan Burnside Michonne his body a person should understand that his sin was a mitzvah retro actively meaning that did that which he sent was God's will that's what sugar means to my charmeuse a solid breakfast Charlotte sucker he brings out the modern process with murder rings that weeps took him including what in the Oh 108 told her she'll the actor I see buddy says Lima actually Ronnie said we all know because of him you're the one who caused them to go astray or the closet says and meet her I said hurry I see our centers I'm the one who did all the evil mcmorrises Asuka Hashem said I don't really it's all right whether I did the bat okay Tom you do people should be in our reason the sort of sacred irony is shuttle Castle that arena has a safe recall I hope amazed shadow cursor at the end of that Seifert is a letter that the reason wrote to her saying to ask him about the question of easy and clear says if something could feel really diary sounds answer you'll see what he's saying is sheshna Jimenez both actually call X of the mahkum announcements each one in a different plane but monkey materia Shamim up and Lidia the mocking my you dear some badness a Malcolm appear in the place of choice there's no place for knowledge in the place of knowledge there's no place for choice okay sure Maggie lol awesome and when you reach this intense clarity disinfects lion you know when call from the world of choice to the world of knowledge our show calls the nice of built eosin may omit EDS a chemise burrows will Huma Thank You Sonya colossal suddenly he realizes that all of his mistakes all of a sense were a result for my feminist knowledge and he and his knowledge and his will I want in other words they were part of his will because he and his knowledge in his will or 1 ohm Africa shame is part of toxic Internet concise if I shall want it it's a mitzvah besides for the cup our evolution now he could be at home was it's a mitzvah says L so not Sawyer my sauce he says this is the secret of Asylum of the services he attended God he send it off to a mountain you cast it down the mountain to atone for the sins you don't offer it to God to be something they said she knew us all other paths may not leave without wages are gone for person a little takes an animal and he says you know what I'm offering it to some mountain this would be idolatry the whole life yeah sure you say : this is lesser sir the column is my size we're not sanitary but he would be violating the second commandment of the ten commandments why he loved her that came out here which is the source of all negative Commandments no other gods that shots fired why they have not solution is Burroughs show myths but some of the showers light line so it's out on the shelves with loin MySite myths of Lebanon but since I said tells him to testicles so suddenly an act which is supposed to be an armada becomes a mitzvah in that subjects mind what is this a metaphor all of a person's sins on one level they're absolute sins God told them not to do it any chose through sugar sugar out of love he reveals that God's knowledge and will defines all of history and life and therefore retro actively it became a mitzvah so the goat that would have been on Vedas earning them when you realize God commanded it that very same act becomes the midst of that twenty concerning kicker you're confused good I'm glad your subject has another safe but called given a safe room the section of Lakota I'm learning a session that begins in the encryption of Herod avoids listen to this mr. Castle Bobby disorder so you saw the aim of it'll help him amid crucial is back how do you know that a Jewish subway the CERN doesn't have it'll you can never notify your idol how from the miss bath the kymaro - says it's just like them is Beth the mists beta has to be hit you know who does not ask to be fredersen's I don't understand this is an altar being used fractions avoid this is idolatry what's this juxtaposition behind new davay disorder shall see you so badly a made the endless ll avoid the Russian when a Jew makes of a deserter the ultimate truth is what he's looking for he's looking to serve God le chameau to the Massa a la danza ha ha a brooder the whole my see saw her come to us a sham a machine clean the Kalika in our world we have the inability to see the clarity of things that everything that you does is a divine activity because the Jew is a failing economy my Amish so at the core level he and a sham are completely one and therefore his choice is the divine choice but the divine set don't do it so if something is saying we cannot comprehend how what he's doing in this world is essentially a divine effort when we call mcclain come on my shuttle Levante manage on the other hand this thought is also not enough to punish you so we ever an interesting paradox on thoughts you don't get punished come I summarize our condition I'm a stubborn I am attack for the mice a negative thoughts of that considered action so the thought you're not punished the action the public is saying is really really my session your mush of is either be God's will I want to go sit that's what he's doing but I shall be you don't get punished but I knew that meet dysthymic gracious to my services any strain you have mastered skirt so not some use butter because really the essence of the Jewish fourth is also only to do a shampoo commercial cost of around painted businesses gain is shown with Tom clay finish actually my red Sun the ramp-up says it looks as game a fascinating a lot of big things for the after divorce survive and the person doesn't want to and there's been forces to say I want to until again it's a good cat I said I don't want to I'm just being forth that's why I'm saying I want so there are mom says no because really you want the XRS telling you that you don't want so when you say I want you're giving the verbal declaration of your answers they do want even though you're screaming I don't want that's not their committee this you're not in touch with your own essence the sellers say they do create acceptance by are these are the same safe without admitted stratocast that indeed my Malcolm actually I read of a Malcolm and I'm somewhat shiny the number six are published music shop this is the essence of what their needs are answers about the theory that it's in two different universes meaning we are who know the mohkumat will explain that elsewhere it officer Lloyd my mama sh-t notes around published a media center chaos what did what i Riza was saying is he's explaining there now what did the I'm upset back to the ROM on knowledge is not like his mouth what did the number mean what did they're not mommy they romba meant he knows and he knows the whole future and we have a choice but if he knows we can't have a choice and his knowledge doesn't come from our choices his knowledge is the reason for our choices we explain according to the remedy knows assume he knows him say cuz he knows himself so we ever a major problem so chapters Lakers lead us Australia's Bharath a map reader Mukesh's clown I for PC make this idea Joyce doesn't contradict God's knowledge i it opposes his knowledge because it means I have freedom bf Sarah in the base Hough Cuba noise say effort you can't have two abbesses I'm not free who I'm not free either I choose or you choose and I'm I'm a victim you're you're just you're just pulling the strings even if I think you're not but you are similar campaign you know for us it's paradoxical both can't work on the gob reaction is where a heffa the concept of paradox doesn't apply to God because even the magic might have been created and therefore the laws of logic are based on magic so therefore this paradox which doesn't make sense doesn't doesn't pose a contradiction in his world the same Megami know how Peter or the Gavroche and in spirituality so therefore from our vantage point we see choice from God's vantage point he sees knowledge how can both be true it's not delusional we really have choice he really knows and both are happening at the same time so one second Ubah ms legardie actions burnish a malcolm appeal but since for him both are happening at the same time so therefore his knowledge of scutes choice hula cushion is fearless callous on the cusco actually asked the same acosta is bar estimation accustomed bah-bah-bah sir as system said they can't recover wish much look at if Miroku Oz needed a Malcolm look clear o'clock when will reach a place where we will see the world the way he sees it will see there's no room for choice miss out along with the coaches are so much much them is one of Emma's this is the world of truth she could feed my son who needed us say who are ms that's Lena who out here piano violin passer the ng D us I keep the end EDSA look at the osseous barrace after Lidia super illa massage the oil of my my sir Chicago sunshine his brothers L over Marcia she heeded my mother my Peter the Helen my dear - of Leesburg in our world he created the situation with clearer reins and it's true how can it coexist with his India and not to say it's delusional says hurts other Cockaigne paradoxes can exist there is clear and easy bein in a world where we could see reality from his perspective then everything is a result of this knowledge and will and our reality it's our choices what us to remain human Eve's reaching a place out of love where you could see the world from his reality and then the sin becomes a mitzvah Rexville absolutely how do the simple come a mitzvah because he wanted you to do it but he said you shouldn't do it in the turn and it was your choice and there's a punishment for it you're right you're right and then on another level I say there is you dia and that further Amba means there are means do it spirit and there's you theater but his idea is not like our idea and the cause it's not like our idea it doesn't conflict with free choice it's completely in a different realm and therefore the Rambam is addressing the answer question and giving them answer not an answer in the sense that we can comprehend how it works but an answer in the sense that when you start to finding his mouth that's based on your knowledge then you have a problem but if you understand that the knowledge is happening in a different realm so there's no contradiction I just want to point out one element before we finished the last pieces here and that is that when he wrote this or similar things were written and cup although I considers they would be based on a form of faith and I want to point out two very interesting things in modern physics everybody almost came to understand that if you don't accept the notion of paradoxes which are completely illogical you're rejecting the reality of phenomenon that we managed to observe in recent centuries there's a quote I quoted here from Einstein in your last source Einstein wrote it seems as though we must use sometimes the one theory sometimes the other while at times we may use either we are faced with a new kind of difficult do we have two contradictory pictures of reality separately neither them fully explains the phenomena of light but together they do what Einstein was referring to as something that developed specially after his life and in the last few centuries particularly and that's known in physics as the wave particle duality meaning every elementary particle in the what they call quantum physics quantum mechanics exhibits two opposite part two opposite properties on one hand look let's say at love light light behaves like a wave like when you throw a rock into a pond and the ripple effect like a wave that's how light behaves other observations showed us that light behaves like a particle which is opposite an opposite form of behavior then a wave so first for decades they were going back and forth like cats and dogs each one was proving each scientist was proving I'm right it's a particle no it's a way that the wave is not a particles and in recent years everybody lifted up their hands and they said like Asha it's not a contradiction you're right and you're I it's a paradox mom-ish and they said we have no choice there is a paradox in our observations and we cannot define its essence but all we know is that both things are true furthermore in the world of subatomic particles the accepted theory today in modern physics is that it moves around clockwise and counterclockwise simultaneously imagine a particle moving this way and the same time it's moving the opposite direction saimultaneously their knives with the calls the centrality service NIM not an annoyance complete paradoxes Steven Hawkins was acknowledged as a great physicist today once said I saw in an interview he said when you asked me about quantum mechanics I opened my drawer to take out my gum meaning I can't I can't deal with it in modern physics there's a famous experiment known as Schrodinger's cat because based on these paradoxes they basically came up with such a situation where a cat will be dead a cat will be dead and alive simultaneously and there's no way of dealing with the trash how could you be dead and when you're dead you're alive now in Poland if citizens this notion has been discussed for a very long time but there were no real anxious for it that was based on that moon okay today even even alimentary superficial reading of text of modern physics show you that you have to start becoming comfortable with the world of paradox especially with these these dualities the wave in the particle duality so now I say do we have free choice or does God know everything and answer is is light the particle or is by the way when you make one observation you see a party we make another observation you see a way but there paradoxical modern physics it's now commonly accepted that light or generally electromagnetic radiation microwaves radio waves microwaves x-rays gamma rays has a dual nature it behaves like a wave and a particle the same is true with subatomic tomorrow's matter it appears as a particle in a way that this is no small thing because they're opposites a particle is an entity confined to a very small volume while a way to spread out over a large region of space how light can be both a field of energy and a particle which is a discrete entity remains a mystery and signings but has been proven time and time again despite its inherent paradox so now now take a look at the next piece we see say Lila ice couple of episodic attire I will call his shawl cream in my room to measure custom the Daruma modality Columbia burritos exceeds Bharat the governor says every Jew even the Jew doesn't have a business called essentially essentially so to speak circumcise explaining Kagami Easter all had rocked my she didn't care so nice young news burnish Kamaishi hooter in Los it attracts over may off even the Russia whose sinning is really connected to God's will which we will only see in the future after super from law say yeah Torian Kishan demaiolo says do rows of bodies mache quinceanera nation's commercial cause of Shabbos papers that's the gomorian shop it is if you realize that your sins are organized in the history of creation then they'll become white then you'll be able to do to Ramayana cosmopolitan with soot emissions regulations sheriff's are champions burnish the osseous read the sins are organized from creation part of God's will the same coal our Vedas been installed hey my various wish ma have done at least mimics whistle uh destroy the sins of the Jewish people essentially is what the Gemara says a nozzle on a Vader leash Mart for the sake of God I will you old Rachel our sentence but it was home my same with shame shame I am Alex same Neela boiler houses in our world we don't have the vessels to comprehend it Valerie cherish Mitzvah Camilla shall I carve estranged I love the chambers Schumann was much lower their proper structure what Miller represents is that in their very birth there is an imprint in them that they completely belong to God so when the Gemara says I've been eerily schmoes equated this official either smart this means the two dozen Isaiah which is enough favorites to see you now how to do it and on a deep level it's hopeless mom because there's a component of the pure which is the essence which is a family Kelly comedy mob and therefore is completely one with God's will and God's knowledge which is his will and and and doing it for that forsake and on the other hand he has free choice why does he have free choice because even though Todd's knowledge exists he has features and what's it what is he choosing he's choosing to do something which on one level is a sin on a conscious level on an unconscious level because he's a part of God he's choosing to fulfill God's knowledge and God's will what is children Truman is going back to that place where there was never a separation between them and his choice was coming from the same local economy which was reflecting God's knowledge and therefore the sin becomes a mitzvah if he changes his paradigm and sees it from God's perspective so what would what we what we're dealing here with finis you could put your phones on vibrate please what we're dealing here with what we deal in it I guess you want to sweeten up the situation Bishop what we're dealing here with this a a paradox within a parent that's within a paradox because my life ahead of me do I have free choice of course a free choice he's not doubting that for one moment no one does he say oh this doesn't matter just gives in to everything no of course you have choice and God wants you to have choice and there's right it is wrong and how the world this is the truth and it's not only the truth because it's a delusional truth it's a real truth paradox doesn't be delusional paradox means real there's a real paradox that both are true and the tighter that demands of me and encourages me and empowers me to challenge myself and to be in a relationship with - summer with my truth with my god but what happens afterwards what happens afterwards afterwards I now say should I sit and wallow in agony depression and misery telling myself my loved ones my therapist my rabbis you know how many mistakes I've made in my life you know how bad I was you know how terrible I am you don't want to hire the mother I love you know the horrible father I am and war was you know how many sins you're nominating sakes oh no no no no now you're doing a second sin now you're doing a second set now you're denying God's involvement what I'm about to do something now I have to speak about my choices and not say oh I'm lazy God made me lazy I have to I have a bad temper God gave it to me after sweetie I'm a jealous person I have to behave in a in a narcissistic way no now you had a choice I did what I did I made a mistake now don't deny God's involvement now there's a capability of children what's true her sure it doesn't mean what I did when I did was beautiful was right to his noble or Russia becomes attack Shura means I opened myself up from love only true them they are natural Emir I opened myself up to divine perspective of reality and there what happened was based on the vine Providence and if it was based on divine providence it means there was a divine intention in exactly that because of Hashem wanting the growth the awareness the reality the repentance the love that grows out of all of those sins and all of those mistakes and retroactive learish love obsessed dispelling it suddenly became obvious suddenly it's a not very early smile suddenly cash a little vino it becomes white because you realize it was part of the structure of patience in my gracious suddenly you're ugly the Zoras like them is day out your every desire to motherland slime dismiss me miss bath why goes after sugar may i haha retro actively his negative act has become a mitzvah it's like the goat that was sent which is in the fire now a desert but suddenly and Kipp it becomes a mitzvah because that is the essence of Chava and that's where all of these gomorrah's flying together and sub it says that's the story of this year because this year Tokyo Sangha God's knowledge can't be challenged God knows these kids are going to be wicked he knew God's knowledge you Shia Hanavi said he didn't say it wrong What did he say but I think I've seen it up on a woman luck you live in this world you don't live in the world of quantum mechanics not yet not yet mushiya comes we'll all be quantum mechanics what do they say what's the difference between an auto mechanic and a quantum mechanic a quantum mechanic and get the car into the garage without opening the garage door no okay so remain an auto mechanic and it's love in the passionately mr. by picture his grandchild married about the tiniest grandchild they had a big fasteners Robin in the Ukraine at the wedding Friday afternoon they were going to the hook line the entrance to the Hoople was narrow only space for one trip Olivia talked about it she asked about planning to go first but he was older than the Commonwealth and he said no you must go first he said no you must go first so they got into an argument who goes first each one refused to let the other one go first they mean to let the other one follow so at some point the Hey look at my dick sugar who you know was was the petitioner he turns to his Mahoney says more cluttered what's the problem la we gained enough devant let's walk through the wall trust me two minutes this different version for the Palatine he said one of them is doctor never told him name zone deteriorated let the door become wider which essentially captures their two systems of thoughts the bad achiever was in a higher world the Bala Canas main mission statement was hakama bina das Chabad meaning he felt everything asked the ideas of God have to be internalized within the structure of the human system of the human and the universe which is why he dedicated so much explanation so much time to explain the ideas of Kabbalah and cussedness so you shine a movie he tells his je you don't live in the world of quantum mechanics but on the level of knowledge okay he told you to have a child follow what he told you and everyone has choices so crystianna we said okay please give me your daughter let's let's you know that the other huh increase on the odds it's actually increase the odds says it's updated marcin is inevitabie k shot the Desborough philosophy Yamashita castillo was supposed to be machinist in the rule of mushiya there's going to be the synthesis but nick looks like that Shannon you'll see the tail until it calming mouth you'll see that your choices are God's choices because your wanna so on one level when I'm choosing if I'm choosing sin I'm choosing sin deeper when I'm choosing even if it's sin on one level it's really sin on another level I'm choosing because it's a hella Telecom Imam how did my choice be real paradoxes exists and even my choices operate on two levels and sugar means expanding my horizons and therefore if you getting stuck in guilt and your whole life is regretting what you did I'm such a bad person and our people who make terrible mistakes in life no one is denying that because of choices that they made not always not always some people were victims of other people's bad choices and they continue this cycle which is vicious but at any point of the game don't think that you must remain stuck in endless regret of how evil you are because in here suddenly you're committing the second center what's the second sin you're denying God's knowledge and hence God's involvement and hence that from a deeper level those mistakes were part of Hashem purpose and if they were part of ourselves purpose what does it mean it means that there was a mitzvah in there what could be the Dutchman then they were destructive the answer they create a type of awareness a type of love a type of honesty a type of humility a type of vulnerability that one could have not reached without those mistakes they say that it the reason the Chinese survived so long as they operating characters the same character that they have for the word crisis it's the same character that they use for the word opportunity but in Hebrew it's much more dramatic in Hebrew what's the word that we use for a breakdown much better what does much better also meaning he broke bread is enough a birth a birthing stone the breakdown is also a moment of birth how can it be a moment of birth there was a breakdown this is the paradox there was Peter it was a breakdown on another level Hashem wanted it and even your pure cane because on another level here one with God but if you don't each other you remain stuck to the world where everything is negative if you do sugar now you are sooo much sense perspective on your life you reveal that you're a handle to the Tommy mile your mistake can become a mitzvah this time it's not so like as of this last piece I'm past second basis period the baby's mates are assemble the kin a lot of them later God tells the person McCauley except on awful potential mates I've asked labored on my cycle from all over the trees of the garden you shall eat but from the tree of knowledge of good and bad you should not eat we all know this must sick and we also know that the rest is history or more accurately the rest is her story not his story but her story especially if you know when the ballot or him says on these circle managed to get Adam to eat invades $1,000 to associate them together upon us says the nasty letter they Spitzer lawsuit so you suck on faith other marushin when the sin of of them will be fixed us here tariff up so that we're going to read the puss it very different we're gonna read the bus as follows me car late second on hustle title you shall eat from all the trees of the garden who made sometimes funny and also from the tree of knowledge that is goes we're gonna read the puck differently makan late Saigon all mates at the house life we're not myself but from the bad of the eight side eyes I don't want you to eat I knew I played along goes Laura Corrales the type of the money to me natira Buscemi's Pharisee virus and God will show and failure it'll prove will clarify killing off a rocket oil that really other made the good but hate my hydrography title and the sin was basically from his perspective he decided that he sentence from his perception he was detached from God Lepus are shiny like the the peel of garlic alloys that are not more real sin in other words is the belief that you sinned now that's very sensitive statements this doesn't mean this doesn't mean that it submits it to believe you then sin cops for Solomon that can create a terrible terrible distortion of Judaism and of ethics and the way people should live their lives what it does mean is it made us what it does mean there's never to wallow in your sin and believe that because your sins you're in a hopeless situation that you're detached because that is what creates the greatest attachment the greatest sin is to believe that I sinned in other words to believe that bad I'm detached I'm disconnected sonic says elsewhere the gomorian in kaduche enough tests the Gemara says how do we know that your MacTavish restart that you could patrol the woman through adapter so we're learning how also FEMA trucks the position of majesty sexy but not somewhat safe the cost of lost a few Chris's did not zombie yada we spoke about last week y'all look at sailor the yacht suddenly bass say behold her voice Alicia fit so yeah with your service she leaves and she remarries in the same posture so that's a heck we judge suppose one to the other Mike ish I really did see it might see a para fabulist are we compare the divorce to the marriage just like divorce happens through which pirates as clearly in the paucity states it could do the no so babyish time so he explains in every choose life there's two states we got service' visa is when your betrothed to god you're in a relationship we also is your divorce you're sent away my quiche alveoli it's really her vienna are very intimately connected because even when you're in the safe of the yacht saw you're still in a safer behind son how does that express itself in sugar it doesn't express itself by saying that what I did was right and I defend myself because that's not that's not real cuz they are not tuning into God's perspective they are tuning into the gate Sahara just to find its own demons if you would tune into God's perspective you would understand that the reason God wanted this to happen is these middle future so she could sure you recreate yourself as a result of the mistake then you tune in to the MS that it wasn't a simplest answer look as Martinez so the great tragedy awaits her bass wasn't there other ate from the tree you know the great tragedy rates advanced loss and when the age from the tree he decided that he's not connected he didn't realize how connected he is he didn't realize how intimate the connection is he didn't realize how good he is how holy is how helical it coming mom and now now this soon became a sin so is the sinner sinner it's not a sin you decide this is the story I told you once I think I said enough it was a genius it would go from city to city and in every city he would explain to people the greatest mysteries of the world and answer all the questions and he always had an answer one god one time a guy this islands gonna fix his wagon what did he do after the lecture questions and answered he's answering every question brilliantly he lifts up his head he has a closed fist and he says let me ask you a question mr. genius this butterfly that I am holding in my hand is it dead or is it a life of course he knows there's no way that person will be able to give her an answer if he says it's a light only does is crushed to death if he says it's dead all he does us open the fist and the butterfly runners is it dead or alive and the wise man looks at them and says the answer to that question lay in your head is it a singer of itself the answer to that question lay in your hand thank you you shall I with us yeah about what's all you in the world comes joining us you don't realize I sensed us do you realize how some stars there's no ish and that's really when you could use this if there's a give your steady remember Shalu if there's no use then you have to remember you have to learn some ways and I'm sure there's there are others farm there's other perspectives so thank you that is very so really you know things happening things that are things where my choice and God's part of it which is these are life I have I am the universe or I have the choice god s here is to realize that to realize there's another which is wants to surprise say hey what surprise so this must be wants to be this just want to let you know that the New York Jets I'm a New York he doesn't even realize that New York is not in it and then a question first of equality says that Shiva maha shiva maha be reasons to realize it that was the real center that is technically the shot it's not a shake the truth all the before us why is it double if you realize that it's an option at that point readings what's the question of those words yes why is it double Atari that's because of the size memory I've now aim to third you're really saying technically you have to be very super good but if you want the heart of real to her at that point you got to come to me like when you realize that you were always a I'm sure that point is good and its internal then you'll have like another thing he sensitive every are very technically she realizes in the mixer tomorrow says it's to malign mrs. Kennedy it's technically at everything they do is a mixer and in the fact that he says that the Mila this duration is also what we say by the American section that was the Hispanic women yeah you realize when you go into the bris your baby you really have no choice to say yes I know but you're still putting in because that was the will of God suddenly fathers does it the same thing at Toyota missus and muscle tone everything you're gonna do in life good or bad is also the same idea but choose the goods beautiful but the question that I had when it comes to the idea to say that we deserve to be the same or says maturity Veronica miser acceptable deserve our disorder Michelle is Miss Erica miser Thank You Lee the deed of the person did that was the roots nutshell but he still gets punished for the macabre itself because that is considered come I see he wants to say that all the good that did you really wants to do it right this dream is convenient but you have to understand I don't know we have to figure out some words that both dissolve itself I don't know don't think that look there there's a bigger issue baby dancer look into the whole thing okay now let me know yes the motion to thank you I like their weight you know that you know was accredited what simple I'm gonna fill that no no it's in casters shunted but Cassie Turner was a compilation by the way phoebius works and this don't exist in previous works and the question is I think it again it's a question [Music]