Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
As we are gathering today,
usually when we're standing here or
sitting here,
I'm sitting
next to Rabbi Hower and I sort of keep
thinking in my eye looking to the
corner, he's going to come running In
before we begin, we we are aware that
there are some potential Amazon Web
Services issues and Zoom services. If if
anybody loses connectivity, we're
recording the entire program here. So,
if you're joining us via Zoom uh and you
get disconnected, please know we'll send
out the recording soon.
We we've been sending out a number of
things via email, Shiva information,
signing up to learn Mishnayas,
uh an email address to share your
memories, slots to record your memories
on video today,
recordings of the Levia, various
housepad and so on so forth. Please keep
an eye out for emails. One of the
reasons we're asking you to share
is as you know I spent a lot of time
with him and he didn't really we didn't
hold anything back from each other and
yet over the last few days just smooing
with people
I'm finding out oh he was involved in
that oh he helps you over here and the
more we are able to share the stories
the more we are able
to share with each other how incredible
Rabbi Mosha Israel of binyaminhau
was and how important his legacy is. So
please we'll find other venues. Please
do continue to share.
I um
we have a bit of a program today and uh
we will we'll try to get through it try
to get through everything. To begin I
want to ask our president Mitch Ader for
a few words.
This really is just coffee
despite my inclinations otherwise.
So two years ago, almost exactly two
years ago,
on the first day back in the office
after Simas Torah, we gathered in this
room stunned to grieve, to cry, to
share.
It's hard to believe. Here we are again
two years later
and the shock feels even greater
and the loss even more personal.
I want to begin with a word of thanks.
On Wednesday night after you got the
news and we're all reeling in shock, a
number of you,
many of you sitting in this room, some
of you in in this room did not have the
liberty
to try to process the news because you
were working round the clock
as Josh mentioned, sending drafting,
sending out messages, announcements
to the staff, to the board, to the
broader community,
all while having to to suppress your own
grief.
You know who you are. I know who you
are. We're all indebted to you.
Each one of us knew Rabbi Hower as kind,
articulate, warm,
witty. I think the wits have gotten lost
a little bit in some of the some of the
eulogies, how funny he was. Um, and and
the puns that he used to use. Um,
unfortunately, I don't remember them. We
should have written them down. Um,
Ariadai is a scholarly principled
principled principal principal. We knew
him as a rebby, an adviser, a confidant,
a teacher,
a leader,
and most as a friend.
In all of these capacities, he somehow
managed to be a towering figure,
but softspoken and humbled at the same
time.
One time I scolded him for giving an
assignment to some some person here in
the OU who didn't report to him. He
looked at me like shocked. He said, "I
didn't give him an assignment. I made a
suggestion."
As Rabbi Hower, when Moshain speaks,
there's no such thing as as a
suggestion.
Among his many roles, Rabbi Hower was
our representative, the OU
representative, the Orthodox community
representative
on various broad communal organizations.
As I often got to tag along with him to
meetings and conferences, I got a
firsthand view of how Rabbi Hower was
both respected, incredibly respected,
and effective.
These are not orthodox forums to put
them.
But Rabbi Hower befriended people from
the far right to the far left
politically
from and from the far right to the far
left religiously.
He was universally respected as a man of
supreme integrity, honesty and
principle,
including by people whose outlooks and
values were contrary to his. Just one
example. Um, a week after
107, October 7th, two years ago, the
Conference of Presidents had a mission
to to Israel. I think we was October
18th, so literally a week or two
afterwards.
And
I don't remember, there were 40 or 50 of
us for for 48 hours together in Israel
and meeting with, you know, all kinds of
fancy people as well as um some
survivors of the attacks.
Um, and at each of the various places we
stopped, one of the one of the Jewish
leaders who was on the trip got to say a
few words. Um, the last night of the
trip sitting in a room um with um a
whole bunch of people who had been
displaced from one of the Kubam near
near Aza, Robbie Howard was asked to
give the final address.
He was the last speaker. They asked him
because they knew he could better than
anyone else. He could make sense of it
all and communicate to everyone. Right?
In fact, someone um someone who was
there just just sent me the uh recording
of it which I haven't had a chance to
relisten to, but I remember remember
distinctly. I remember I'll just mention
a a name that I thought about this this
morning.
So, one of the uh people who was on that
trip, a woman named Sheila Katz, who's
the CEO of the uh National Council of
Jewish Women, um who describes herself
as a reformed Jewish progressive woman.
Um um she wrote, and over the past week,
I was going to quote her. She wrote, "To
me, Rabbi Howard's larger than any
biblical figure. Together, we were an
unlikely duo that came together to
advocate against anti-semitism, to pro
to promote safety in Israel, and for the
return of the hostages. We learned Torah
together. We debated each other just
often.
What began as a simple coalition work
being true a true partnership and a
profound friendship. It's unbelievable.
It's unbelievable. And he was not only
respected, but he was effective. His
goal in every meeting, in every context,
in every interaction was to defend the
Torah, to to defend the Torah in halaka
and to instill Torah values in ways
large and small. I'm going tell a small
example,
not all that exciting, but from last
week, from last Sunday.
So the conference of presidents has this
group that's a sort of an umbrella
organization made up of 50 or a million
Jewish organizations across the spectrum
and they wanted to put out
a consensus statement on the release of
the hostages that we signed by every
single of the organizations. Now
you can't get all these organizations to
agree that it's Monday, right? I mean
there's just nothing, right? Okay. So
they wanted to do and they put out they
they sent around a statement. So I was
ner's role and I I got um you know I got
a a copy of the draft uh to sign off on
um and normally I don't read these sort
of things because Rabbi Howard does but
it was still nighttime in in in America.
So I figured take a look at it right um
before finding out if he had actually
read it. Right. So I I was reading it
along and then um I stopped when I came
across the following sentence and the
sentence reads, "We express a profound
gratitude to the Almighty for bringing
us to this day of relief and renewal."
I knew that right that moment Rabbi
Hower had had a hand in the drafting. He
insisted that God be mentioned in every
context and and he insisted, right? He
was he was softspoken, but he was
principled and he did not bend. And in
fact, when I spoke with him later that
day, he said, "Pretty cool. I got God in
there, huh?" Yeah.
If we had a game and we had to describe
Rabbi Howard in five words or less, my
offering would be Rabbi Howard cared.
Whoa. How we cared?
He cared deeply about the war, the
hostages.
He cared deeply about Jews on college
campuses. He cared deeply about the
Karedi draft and about lack of
commitment to Torah. They care about
every individual, friend, family,
colleague, stranger, single mothers,
especially his children. He cared about
singles and pushed relentlessly to our
CCR to publish his studies.
He hated Zoom meetings, right? Because
they allowed people not to be present.
He was always present. I worried that he
cared too much, that he internalized his
concerns. He always pushed me off and
said, "I have a great support system."
I urged him to slow down, to take more
vacation, he said, "But there's so much
to do." He just cared all the time.
Now, vacation was not the only thing
that he and I disagreed about.
Rabbi Hower and I had a complicated
relationship.
I was his boss and he was my rebby. It's
complicated.
We were lying most of the time, right?
But we also argued and we debated.
We're both stubborn.
We frustrated each other. We had some
hard conversations. But here's the
thing.
Every conversation ended with a hug and
sometimes a kiss.
Every single time.
Speaking of hugs,
it's been noted that the U um is a
hugging culture and um that's both
wonderful and complicated.
Haka dictates that I cannot hug half of
you
and that's challenging in a time like
this.
that I can offer each one of you a warm,
empathetic, virtual hug
from the tips of my fingers to the
bottom of my heart. Dozens of you have
contacted me since Wednesday via phone,
text, email to offer condolences and
support. I cannot tell you how much I
appreciate each and every message, the
love and concern.
is a testament to the humanity and
goodness of the people of the OU, our
people.
Within the next hour, we're all going to
go back to serving Cloud Israel.
That's what we do.
And we're going to do it without our
rebby.
That's be very hard for a very long
time.
But thanks to him,
we'll also do it with a renewed sense of
family and holiness
and brotherhood and sister brotherhood
and sister sisterhood that make this
organization so great.
Thank you. Thank you, Mitch.
Dozens and dozens and dozens of emails
and virtual hugs and actual hugs have
been given by each one of you, whether
to Mitch or to me or to each other,
because the only way we will all get
through this is if we get through it
together. And that's the way Rebah would
have wanted it to be.
One of the amazing opportunities we have
had to witness together is the coming
together of the whole organization
from CLA to Kash. Let me ask Rabbi Mosha
Elephant to share a few words.
So we in Cashris
who are having a hard time ourselves
accepting what happened here absorbing
had a very different relationship with
Rabbi Hower than most of you because
most of you worked for him. We didn't
work for him. We worked with him.
And it gives us a very very different
perspective.
There's a garra, the garra says shabas,
the rav, one of the great Amoroyam
who was about to pass away and he was
planning his own funeral and he told his
student Rashm Bash,
I am asking you to be the one to give
the eulogy at my funeral.
And he says to him,
Inspire the people. Get the people
aroused when you speak the homna
cuz I'm going to be there and I'm
watching you. What a complicated
statement.
Rav is giving him direction. Make sure
that you say something right about me.
And moreover, if Rav did not feel that
he was competent to say a proper hespid,
so then why did Rav ask him to say it
that he had to give him instruction?
So I think the explanation is very
different. Rav was telling him,
I don't want you to spend the time at
the eulogy to speak about me.
It doesn't make a difference anymore.
Everybody there knew who I am. I want
you to know. I want you to speak.
If I were here, what would I be saying?
And we've heard and there's so many
people who will be speaking I'm sure
here and in other places who knew Rabbi
Hower much better than I knew him and
could speak about him and defined the
man much better than I could ever. But
what I would like to speak about is
Kimna.
What would Rabbi Harris say? What do I
think Rabbi Harold would be saying ham
if he was standing here?
The Gomorrah says, and I think it's what
every person in this room is feeling,
if we have a group of people that are
joined together as we are particularly
now,
one of them passes away.
The entire group has to be concerned.
And the Garra questions, who is that
individual?
And one opinion is the galabura
the greatest person in the group and the
other opinion is the kotabur the least
significant person
and many explain it's really one and the
same who is the goabura
who is the most important person in the
group the one who is caught in shabura
the one is considers himself the
smallest
my first interaction with Rabbi Hower
was after he joined the OU. It was a
complicated time. It was right as co was
affecting all of us and we had just not
long before launched our program of all
daf all Toro and Rabbi Hower was very
excited was very very excited about that
project and we spoke many times about
his vision for that project how we could
expand the project and bring more Torah
to everyone in Claus
But every conversation,
every conversation that we had that I
had with Rabbi Hower
ended the same way. He says, "I want it
to be done quietly.
I want it to be done without much
fanfare.
I want it to be done shame shayim
but I don't want a lot of noise around
it
because as has been said and I'm sure
will be said many time many people
sitting in this room certainly I the
last time I heard Rabbi Harris speak
publicly was when we had the executive
retreat in September. He spoke
beautifully but he said something which
I think really is the husam kaimna is
what he was. He said at that event that
his wife's grandfather, Rabbi Alexander
Rosenberg, the first rabbitic
administrator of U Kosher, when he came
to our when Rabbi Howard came here, I
still remember when in all of our
offices, there was a picture of Rabbi
Rosenberg and it used to wander from
office to office and he said it ended up
in his office, I guess, because it was
his wife's grandfather. And he said,
"Everybody knew that the way Rabbi
Rosenberg lived and conducted himself
and conducted his affairs was with three
words.
Vos vilgot, what does God want?"
And that's how he acted. And I think in
every interaction Jab Hower had, whether
as we just heard from Mitch, his public
persona, whether running this
organization together with Josh,
I think every decision was motivated by
Vilgat, what does God want? And he knew
that God wants
he wants us to be modest.
But the only time that I saw that
majesty, that humble behavior
sort of crack
is when he came in contact with
children.
I remember that the individual who
dedicated and started ALDAF, Steve
Neworth, another great individual who
unfortunately passed away very young,
60 years old. And we had a hespid and a
sudismah by his first yard site in New
Relle in the shoe where he davened
and his children were there. He left
number of children none of them married
and he had one son who had just a young
boy barely by mitzvah and Rabbi Howard
didn't know that family I remember the
first time Rabbi Hower I introduced
Rabbi Howard to Steve Neworth on a phone
call and he certainly didn't know Steve
personally he didn't know his family
personally but at that see him
Rabbi Hower went over to Steve's son and
hugged him and cried with him.
And then we traveled once to Manchester
and London for a see him. And there was
a see him and we made the see him and
there was dancing and there were a
number of parents who had brought their
children in Manchester to attend the
Rabbi Howard pulled those children to
the side and sang and danced and cried
with them.
And lastly, we got an email when we
started this program. There was a boy,
his name is Charlie, I don't even know
his last name, who lives in Tene, who
started listening to the dafomi. And
every night he would gather a bunch of
his friends and teach them the dafomi.
And we even made a short video about
Charlie. And the following sukus after
we publicized that video, Rabbi Hower
was inlay for yontiff and he was in the
mirha
and he was there for the sima
and Charlie was there as well and how
went over to him and hugged him and
kissed him and said you're the hero
because you're the one that learns Torah
caring for every Jew, every young Jew.
But there's one more facet of Rabbi
Howard that I would like to speak about.
And maybe,
as I said, this is what he would want us
to be thinking about. And maybe that's
what he would want us to continue.
Rabbi Har, as we heard from Mitch, was a
very, very busy person. Maybe too busy.
We're hearing.
But what Har also taught me is that he
didn't forget about the individuals
and he we recently a granddaughter of
mine got married a few weeks ago and the
is from Baltimore and we were in
Baltimore for the Shabas of and it was
Friday afternoon and Rabbi Howard calls
and he says to me you're in Baltimore. I
said yes. She says where are you? I told
him where I was. He says, "I'm coming
over to visit." Says, "Rabbi Elephant
came to Baltimore. I'm not going to come
visit him." And then, this was on
Friday. And then Monday, which was Labor
Day, and we were all off that day. It
was the day of the wedding in Lakewood.
And Rabbi Howard traveled for over three
hours from Baltimore to Lakewood and
then back to Baltimore to attend the
wedding.
his relationship with us, with every one
of us. I'm not speaking about myself.
I'm not speaking about Rabbi Schuade.
I'm speaking about all of us. Was he was
our friend. It wasn't just that we were
colleagues. It wasn't just that he was
the big boss. He was a friend of ours.
We were family.
And he attended our simas like you
attend the sim of a family.
And maybe the lesson that we should
learn from Rabbi Howard is we're all
going to think about his legacy and
we're going to think about his ashkaf
and his philosophy and his approach to
all the problems that are facing Clausal
Rol. But one of the things that we
should be thinking about is what a mench
he was. And he treated everybody else
like a mench. And maybe the biggest that
we could do for him is treat each other
like a mench. Maybe tomorrow morning
when we come to work, we'll remember,
and I'm speaking to myself, we'll
remember to say good morning to everyone
and give everyone a smile and ask
everyone, "How are you doing?" At that
mid at my grandson's bitzvah
a few months ago, he came and it was
most interesting. He said, "We know that
every year tishab Hower did a program.
One year before he was here, he did a
program on and tishabove about the
clothesba, the separate story, a
survivor of the holocaust. And my
grandson's grandfather was a tal of the
closena lived in Baltimore. Before he
gave that presentation, he asked to meet
my grand my grand my son-in-law's
grandfather
to talk to them about who the closen reb
was that he would have what to say and
he came and he brought him to that the
Reb wrote.
He made the he spoke he made the
presentation and after tishab he wanted
to return the swarum and this man said
no hold on to them
14 years later he never wanted to take
back the swarum 14 years later this
man's greatgrandson's bitzvah rabbi
hower comes to the bitzvah and says I
owe this family those two swarm back and
he gave my grandson those swarm as a
and he wrote and I there's it's not the
time and place to read the last words
the words that he wrote in there but I
want to say two things about that
mitzvah the morning of that bait mitzvah
he called Rabbi Schuade he says you know
I'm going to come to the mitzvah you've
asked me to speak at that mitzvah I know
your your father-in-law Rabbi elephant I
have what to say about him I know you I
have what to say about him but it's your
your son's by mitzvah I want to have
something to say about him. Let him feel
special. Tell me about your son.
Tell me about your son. And he told him,
and then he wrote this beautiful note.
He told me he wrote it in the car
driving from here to Lakewood. And the
last words that he wrote to my grandson
are the words that we've heard so much
about Rabbi Hower.
He blesses him.
You should grow up to be anem which the
gar says that
what do people say about a good person
of shalom his parents are fortunate
ashray rabbi shalom
ashray clas
unfortunately Rabbi Harold was taken
away way way too young and we don't
understand but we don't have questions
but how taught us all how to live and
how taught us that we should all aspire
to be a that we should be a hashem that
every one of us should constantly in
whatever we do create a kdeshm
and if we will continue creating a
kdeshm in all of our activities
Humna
Rabbi Howell will be with us forever.
Thank you. Rabbi Elephant
Harris started at the OU a few months
before me.
So I would often go to events and say
could just if you know somebody there's
somebody you could introduce me to.
And I I was referring to the staff.
So one of my one of the memories is the
first half year that I was here. It was
January
and there was a nakyomi at congregation
Beth Shalom in my community in Lawrence.
And of course he didn't tell me he was
speaking. But I I wanted to go see it.
And I walk in and I see him.
He's like, "Oh, I want to introduce you
to somebody."
And he takes me over to a 12-year-old
girl who was doing being Messiah, who's
finishing all of Nak. And he introduced
me to her and he told me about her. And
then he took me over to a group of women
who had come in from. I I don't even
remember their names now. He knew every
single person. He had met every single
person. He had remembered who they were.
He talked about them to be able to
introduce me. That was, as Rabbi Alfam
pointed out, his ability to care about
the individual, remember their stories,
and speak to them. The author of that
event of course is Rabbitson Dr. Adina
Schmidman who's going to speak share a
few words with usim
leadership and my dear colleagues.
Thank you for the opportunity to share
words of hespid for Rabbi Mosha Yusra
Benbin Yammenhauer Zatal.
I offer my thoughts as part of the U
family, one of the many who was impacted
and inspired by Rabbi Howard the person
and Rabbi Hower the leader. It is a tall
order to deliver these words and so
please forgive me if I fall short.
I had the unique privilege to work for
and with Rabbi Mosha Hower for the past
five and a half years. And when I looked
through my files this week, I found
hundreds of files with his name. Meeting
notes, agendas, reflections,
drafts. Each one is a record of a
conversation, an idea, a question that
captured his signature blend of clarity,
humility, and care. His reflective
listening and insights, pointed
questions, and unfailing support.
Emma Katz, a member of the women's
initiative team, asked me on Friday,
"When Rabbi Howard joined the OU, what
was his vision for the department?
and had a hard time answering because
while he certainly had vision,
expansive, insightful, Torah driven, it
was never imposed from above. His
leadership was never about asserting
control, but about creating space. He
led by listening, by integrating, by
elevating others. His vision wasn't
about driving his own agenda. It was
cultivated together. And while I
genuinely felt that space, looking back
at all of these files, it is so clear
how much voice and impact Rabbi Hower
had on the department. Our first team
meeting was at the Asella Lounge at 30th
Street Station in Philadelphia. As COVID
was just beginning, it was a time of
uncertainty and fear. But even then, his
calm presence gave direction.
That moment set the tone for the years
that followed. Years marked by challenge
and resilience.
COVID,
war,
tragedy.
Yet under his guidance, we found
purpose. We found meaning. He reminded
us that the Torah does not pause for
crisis. that our aris, our
responsibility to one another only
deepens in moments of pain.
And that is how we learned from him, not
through instruction alone, but through
example.
For me, the moment that comes to mind
most easily, a defining moment that
embodies who Rabbi Hower was as a leader
and as a person is the Torah Halaka
initiative. Rabbi Hower wanted to see
women learning hala. As simple as that.
I raised a myriad of complexities,
issues that were very concerning and
that needed to be resolved. and he would
offer solutions, direction, back and
forth
for two years. I would put it last on
our agenda
week after week, hoping that we wouldn't
get to it because the issues seemed
insurmountable.
But he kept after it. He told me, "Don't
let perfection be the enemy of the
good." No was not an option because
Rabbi Hower wouldn't accept that there
was no solution until finally with
Hashem's intervention a direction was
found. And after we rolled out this
program, I loved sharing the feedback,
the impact. Even a few weeks ago, I
shared a message with Rabbi Hower from a
woman who wrote, "Thank you for the
daily halaka during Aser Tshua,
reminding me about the insertions in
Shimona. I'm not sure why it went out of
my head, but thank you for these emails
so at least I could fix it today.
There are several takeaways from this
experience for me and I hope for all of
us. You can champion a value and
advanced ideas relentlessly
without telling people what to do.
And even with all of the back and forth,
and it was not a simple program roll
out, two years of pushing is not easy.
Yet, I never hesitated to share the
program's impact with Rabbi Hower
because I knew that it would bring him
nahas and he would never say, "I told
you so." or "You shouldn't have waited
so long." There was no ego in the
exchange, just an understanding of what
women need and a respect for their
desire to learn and grow.
He was a cheerleader for projects,
listening to every detail, offering
feedback with patience and precision.
Whether supporting mental health for
women in communal positions, investing
in lay leadership, sharing insights with
mikvah professionals, he was there
speaking at our conferences, inspiring
staff and participants alike. He met
with the women who came from across the
country to these events, listening to
their stories, understanding their
communities, encouraging their
leadership.
In the last few days, so many have
reached out to share that when they
approached Rabbi Hower with a personal
challenge. His sensitivity and care were
healing, and his willingness to help was
transformative.
In those private interactions, as in
every public setting, he led with
compassion first. His empathy was never
theoretical.
It was deeply felt, reflected in how he
treated each person with dignity and
patience. Whenever I asked, he joined to
Hillm rallies, sharing words that were
simultaneously grounding and at the same
time uplifting, recording video segments
for Le Kenos and Tishabove programs,
sharing the values and connection he so
deeply believed resided within Claius.
in the days following his pass saying a
woman wrote to me. I really benefited
from the many times he addressed the
women on Zoom Aifas over the past two
years. He constructed meaning and
purpose out of challenge and despair.
And now we must somehow do the same.
Her words capture what so many of us
feel. that Rabbi Hower had the rare
ability to take hardship and transform
it into direction to help us find amuna
in moments of uncertainty.
And at the Tori Mecca Museum that Josh
referenced, his dire braha elevated the
event. His recognition and pride of
women's learning accomplishments
elevated the kaduca of the moment. His
words always had a transcendent quality,
uplifting, insightful, and exactly what
was needed at that moment. He knew what
to say and how to say it. My husband has
shared
that after 120 years,
each of us will need to face a din
a judgment and accounting.
But if you pause to think about this
phrase, perhaps it should be reversed.
First
and then din. First there should be an
accounting and then a judgment. So why
this order of din?
And additionally, Hashem is all knowing.
Does he really need to make a he knows
where everybody's account stands? All of
our deeds and misdeeds.
Perhaps because after a person's time in
this world, the continues every act of
kindness they inspired, every word of
Torah that spreads because of them,
every good deed that traces back to
their influence, it keeps adding, it
keeps growing.
And so it is with Rabbi Hower. Hisbon
continues. Every project he encouraged,
every idea he blessed, every person he
guided, they all carry his imprint. His
legacy will not fade. It will increase
exponentially with every person and
community impacted just as he increased
the light of Torah and compassion
wherever he went.
The loss is immeasurable,
but so are the deep feelings of
gratitude for having had the opportunity
to learn from him, from having witnessed
a life of humility, strength, and MS.
The loss is profound, not only because
of who he was, but because of all that
was yet to come. He was just getting
started.
There was still so much to build and so
much to do. The loss is beyond words.
But in his own way, he prepared us for
this too. His messages will live on. His
values, his insights, his direction.
His leadership was a lesson in strength
that is quiet and vision that is humble.
One of the gifts of working at the OU is
being part of the OU family.
The OU is such a joyous space. The
energy, passion, the excitement of
contributing to Clius together. It is
going to be an enormous task to
recapture that joy without Rabbi Hower.
We will need to be there for each other
to support each other and to hold each
other's pain.
As a family, we have this capacity. I
keep telling myself it is painful but
possible because of the legacy and
leadership of Rabbi Mosha Hower.
One of the things the Rabbi Hower would
often chide me about is my tendency to
exaggerate.
So, it's it's nice to have 4,000 people
in the room here today.
But I so I wanted to get this data point
uh exactly right. So I I I studied and I
looked up how many hours how many
minutes and hours a day on average we
would spend with each other in terms of
meeting times in terms of emails and
text messages and Hisha voice notes as
he used to refer to them as. And I did a
very exact accounting and specifically
and I found out that we averaged 27
hours a day together
aside from Mitch and me. I think the
other person who he may have spent even
more time with in meetings and smoozing
with was Rabbi Yakov Glasser.
I'm very used to the spaces where I
would speak with Rabbi Hower and I'd
have to lower the microphone after him.
I recall very vividly
where I was parked as Rabbi Hower and I
began our next conversation in
anticipation
of my coming to the OU.
It was a long conversation
for Rabbi Hower. A baseline meeting was
90 minutes.
Anything less was a check-in or a
conversation.
can't really get anything done in less
than 90 minutes.
And we had known each other before
through a shared rabbitic group that we
would gather annually and connect and
discuss communal issues in an informal
and non-organizational setting. And now
we were exploring
how my new potential role at the OU
would manifest in the context of our
partnership in representing the OU
throughout the Jewish community.
And he said to me, "Rabbiakov,"
he asked in a very soft and earthy voice
of warmth
that I would eventually purchase an
external speaker for my laptop to be
able to hear.
Rubyakov, in traveling on behalf of the
U for Shabas,
which communities would you prioritize?
So coming off of seven years traveling
for WAU and with a general sense of the
Jewish communal landscape and the
desired relevance and impact that I
imagined an international organization
would seek to have, I responded probably
the five towns, Bergen County, South
Florida, Los Angeles, Chicago.
And on the other end was silence,
a pensive pause
that I would come to fear
and to love, to appreciate and to dread
all at the same time.
And then he responded, "Rabbiakov,
that sounds like a fundraising list.
What we should really be thinking about,
Rabbi Howard clarified,
is where do communities need us the
most?
And I've repeated this story hundreds of
times because it captures the moment
that I became not just an employee, but
a Talmid of Rabbi Mosha Howard's.
Rabbi Hower woke up in the morning or
for what most of us was the middle of
the night and began his day with that
question.
Where are we and where am I needed the
most?
And sometimes the answer was the white
house or the kesset the
interorganizational tables of federation
and the conference of presidents. And
sometimes it was providing guidance and
kizuk and love to an individual rv a
struggling employee
a despondent congregant or someone in
pain that he encountered at min.
Where do they need us the most?
was the source of his unlimited
reservoir of compassion and empathy and
action in confronting both the greatest
challenges of the day and the most
personal opportunities to lift
individuals up from the abyss of their
chaos and their confusion and their
pain.
Where so many saw insurmountable
problems and unsolvable needs,
Rabbi Hower saw opportunity for impact,
for advancement, and for a word he loved
so much for elevation.
He was a god in so many things,
thoughtful, insightful,
creative, and eloquent. But more than
anything, he was a god in the Torah of
what it meant to look around a room and
while at once commanding the
intellectual and creative dimensions of
the conversation, somehow remain fully
attuned to any expression of
consternation of pain that betrayed an
individual in need.
Where do they need us the most? Wasn't
only about people in pain. It drove
Rabbi Hour to take an attentive and
active interest in the lives and the
work of thousands of Jews all over the
world. How many people have expressed
that they shared an extensive
conversation with him, gleeing advice
and guidance in their life without any
formal or institutional connection to
his work?
Where do they need us the most? so many
projects and conversations
that we were in the middle of.
So many people and ideas and efforts
that need him the most.
I can't stop thinking about the contrast
between the elating moments of Sim
that we experienced on Sim Torah and the
fateful calls that we all received in
the moments following Yum to a towering
whose life and work was entirely
anchored in Torah and in a hashem.
The consukus
depicts the image of an orodes on
simkas,
an ark that is generally full, hosting
an array of scrolls that embody the
essence of dvar hashem, of who we are
and of what we stand for.
writes of Utner that it is so striking
on Simas Torah to pause and to look up
and notice that the Aron stands entirely
empty devoid of any Torah presence at
all
explains Rautner. This image is highly
intentional in the context of our final
of
because it is intended to convey the
unparalleled
the desire the aspiration that the
Jewish people have in these moments not
to be spectators to the Torah's grander
but to embrace the world of Torah
amongst themselves
unwilling to leave even a single scroll
in the cushioned and dignified space of
the orin kodesh cl Israel hugs and
dances and connects with the entirety of
our Torah.
And in these few words, the reorients
for us what presents as an image of
emptiness
into a manifestation of the unbridled
passion to grasp and to internalize the
totality of our precious Torah into the
hearts and the souls of the Jewish
people.
Rabbi Howard left nothing in his
personal aren kodesh.
Every scroll, every moment, every
thought, every idea was handed to
another Jew to animate Torah values
within their life.
And he ensured
that everyone in that circle, no matter
what their life's circumstance or
capacity, had a chance to hold and to
ultimately dance with a safer Taurus,
Hashem. He found the right Torah for
every person. He found the right Torah
for every circumstance. And even if he
had to support the bottom himself, so
their particular weakness didn't prevent
them from joining the everlasting dance
of the Jewish people. That's what he
would do. Where do they need us the
most?
We're going to walk these halls
and we're going to see an empty Aron.
our precious safer Torah l no longer
nestled
in the embracing space of his office
suite.
No longer dabbing mka with usually in
the back.
No longer exuding that reassuring and
loving smile.
But we have to know that what appears to
us and what is experienced by us as an
emptiness and as a void
is actually the painful displacement of
Rabbi Howard's Torah into the arms of
his family, his congregants, his
colleagues, his students, and his
friends.
A Torah that he would want us to learn
and he would want us to teach.
A Torah that he would want us to rejoice
and want us to revere.
a Torah with which he would want us to
transverse the communities of the Jewish
people,
striving to discover how he could place
it in the arms of every Jew in the
world, no matter who they are and no
matter what they've been through, and to
help them dance.
This is the question that I will be
asking myself the rest of my life.
The first question that Rabbi Hower ever
asked me,
where do they need us the most
bor?
We drew straws as to who would have to
speak after Rabbi Glasser. I lost.
There are no words
because he is not here to write them.
There are no words because he is not
here to speak them.
There are no words
because he is not here
in his Yizkar Russia
for Yom Kipper 8 years ago before he
was at the U before I I met him.
It was entitled Never Stop Speaking.
And he said, "Hashem, God gave us the
power of speech in our lifetime. When we
follow the mandate
of nasa Adam, when we live our lives as
we should and complete his creation, we
grant ourselves the power of speech
beyond our lifetime.
We continue to speak.
Our life's message continues to be heard
long after we are gone."
Because of those words,
I now feel I have an opening to say
something.
When I first saw Rebbitson, Lindy
Rebbitson Hower.
She said to me,
"I'm sorry that we both lost our
partner."
It's true.
And I also lost a brother. You here know
that I I often refer to him as a brother
from another mother.
Once Shabas Saturday night, uh the
president of Israel, President Herzog
called and I was speaking to him and as
we were trying to there were a lot of
people trying to break through to get to
get to Rabbi Har's mother. He said,
"Tell me a little bit about her.
Explain. 94 years old. Kayahara
still strong
history Hebrew teacher in Montreal.
He said, "What's her name?"
"Ima."
Cuz he would stop. We'd be in the middle
of a meeting with government officials
and chief rabbis. It was 259 and 37
seconds. And he would say, "I'm sorry.
We have to stop or pause or end because
every day at 3 p.m. I call my mother.
First time I met Rabbi Mosha Hower was
technically in the spring of 2020
in the middle beginning of the pandemic
off the Jersey Turnpike at Thompson
State Park which he found because it was
the midpoint between Baltimore and
Lawrence.
And we drove there with our own chairs
and sat 20 feet away from each other
with masks on and gloves because we
didn't know what we were doing.
But almost right away we knew
that we were kindred spirits.
Now it could be because we actually grew
up less than a mile from each other in
Montreal. his father's shul, my father's
shul, very close to each other. Our
parents knew each other.
And it's hard to imagine that our paths
never crossed.
But as his mother shared with me when I
went to the Shiva Sunday morning,
she said that Montreal was special. It
was a place that built Torah leaders who
not only were knowledgeable,
but who cared about others and each
other.
The second time we met, Rabbi Hower
shared with me
two words that were actually on his wall
and the thin wall that separated our
offices
based on
the period where God
turned to Mosher Rabenu and said, "I
want you to lead Ben Israel."
Moshe says, "No, send someone else.
And in response, Hashem gets angry.
He says, "You know what? I I can't talk
with you anymore. Your brother's coming.
You think he's going to be upset that
you're taking this away from him?
He's going to see you and he's going to
be happy in his heart.
And he shared that with me, Rabbi
Howard, the second time I saw him
saying, "I see you and I'm happy in my
heart."
We talked about it a lot in front of you
and in front of lots of people, although
we're brothers and we loved each other.
And I know sometimes there were eye
rolls and it was good for show,
but brotherhood is not perfection. I
have two brothers and a sister who I
love I love dearly and who are amazing
people and I look up to them. We don't
always get along. We don't always agree.
And that was also the case
with Rabbi Hower and me.
I didn't know what Mitch was going to
say, but
it always ended
with a hug and sometimes a kiss,
even when we disagreed.
And so I realized
that he was happy
and that I was his brother.
He was all of our brothers. And so many
people felt that way about him.
A wise guide, a coach, a mentor, a
friend.
He had that smile.
One more story from Ema. She told me
that in the first weeks when he was born
in Montreal,
she would wheel him around in the
carriage and he had such a he had such a
smile that people would walk by and
said, "Whoa, what a friendly baby from
birth."
He had that joy.
How was the exemplar of a Torah Jew?
Torah framed his life and he used Torah
to frame ours. We literally spoke about
we had board meetings. We'd have
retreats. And it wasn't just we're going
to say a devar Torah, we're going to say
a word of Torah. In order to say, okay,
we did some Torah. It was to frame the
conversation. He would ask, "What's the
board meeting going to focus on?" Oh,
budget. Okay, I'm going to frame it with
Torah. And in that way, he infused
everything that we did, every
conversation that we had with Torah. And
it literally became known as Torah
framings.
One of the earliest moments, one of his
first frames for me, it was a troubling
and difficult time.
He shared the notion I I would sometimes
get upset
with the Jewish people and he said,
"Don't talk badly about the Jewish
people." Right? Riser actually spoke
about it similar. He said it said
something similar to him when in his
husband his son is
I said okay
how
says
who is the person who yearns for life
what do we stop saying you stop saying
bad things about people so I said okay
rebi my brother so how do I Stop. Very
nice. I love life. How do you stop? He
says, stop skipping the middle part of
that.
Be an Oyim
who yearns for life. Somebody who loves
the days and sees the good.
When you can put on your love colored
glasses,
when you put on your Hashemcoled
lenses,
then you're not going to see the
negative
because you're going to see love. You're
going to see the love of God and the
love of people.
And in that way, as Rabb Elephant
pointed out, he was literally a man of
God.
He told a bunch of us the story in that
amazing amazing speech
that took a lot of taxis, a lot of Ubers
all over the place. And he would always
say, "Thank you." But more recently when
he was getting out of the car and I
started to do this, he would say, "God
bless you."
to each of the drivers.
and the reactions that he got and now
that I see
where that wow, thank you for the
blessing. Thank you for bringing God
into my life. Wherever wherever he went,
people saw him as a man of God and his
midos's actions, his humility
is Mosha.
He was more humble.
And as Riser quoted and for the Gumar
and Yuma which also Rabbi elephant made
reference to
Shay
that whatever you do,
God will be loved through you.
This wasn't always easy.
He had to deal with me. He had to deal
with a world that began as foreign to
him, but he always responded with an
equinimity.
People mistook that that he was a calm.
People said to me all the time, he's
very calm. How is not calm?
He had passion.
One of the highest compliments he could
give anybody was like, "See him? He's
got fire in his belly."
Rabbi Hower had a fire in his belly.
When we put the word drive, when we put
the value of drive into the core values
of the organization, we all had an image
of Rabbi Hower who had drive. He came to
me on day 171 of the hostages, 171 of
the war,
171 or 172. I'll give him the benefit of
the doubt. It was 171. and he says, "Do
you think we could get
180,000 written letters to the White
House on day 180?"
I will not tell you what I responded,
but there we were
carrying I'm not going to exaggerate.
They only let us bring in a 100,000 on
the first day. There wasn't enough room.
We had to bring in 80,000 the second
day. But we are literally carrying in a
100,000 letters from CLA Israel into the
White House. And the most amazing thing
is not only that all of you pulled it
off,
but that as we walked in,
I was standing with I was holding these
boxes. They were heavy. We walked a long
way. And I looked at the room number
that we were walking into.
And what room was it? What room number?
180. And I turned to the White House
liaison and I said, "What a
coincidence."
And he looked at me
says, "That's not a coincidence.
Message received,
Rabbi Hower.
this drive.
What kind of impact that had,
message received
and he gave a lot of messages.
He was an incredible voice. And if I
think of a body part that I feel we are
missing today, my metaphor is we've
we've lost our voice.
When we were first putting together the
strategic plan,
I wanted to put in there
that the Orthodox Union is the voice of
the Orthodox Jewish world.
And at least two people will know that
he crossed that out.
He said, "We are a voice.
Leave room for other people because
there's lots of other voices out there."
But even with his humility, he was never
afraid to share his mind, to speak to
his convict convictions. Even with that
soft, still voice you had to lean into
sometimes
in order to hear. He always knew the
right thing to say and how to say it.
On those voice notes, those Haimea voice
notes, which I was just looking at my
the last wasn't our last conversation,
but the last WhatsApp
was actually written.
He wrote to me, "Shabbat shalom,
my precious friend."
He always knew what to say.
And that he was nif that he passed away
right as all the living hostages came
home, part of his mission.
And a number of you pointed out maybe
Kajesh Baraku said God said mission
accomplished
but we're not done. He had a goal to
bring all the Jews together.
He had goals
projects that were all still open.
Hauntingly a couple of weeks ago
in his message for paras 5786
which he entitled unfinished business
he quoted
who will live
and who will die
who will die at a predestined time and
who before that time.
His words,
these words remind us of our
vulnerability and of the possibility
that one may leave this world with
unfinished business. Yet this
Shabbasheshua we will read about how
Moshe lived 120 years to the day
indicating that God completes years of
the righteous
allowing them to realize their mission.
This is striking said Rabbi Howard
because if we think about where
Mosherenu
finishing and completing everything even
though he wanted to go into Israel he
wanted to be in Israel and he didn't
make it. We know said Rabbi Hower how
Moshe pleaded with God to be able to
bring us there but was all to no avail.
Can we really say that Moshe's life that
ended before he reached his life's goal
was not cut cut short?
But Rabbi Howard quoted the Mishna in
Aos.
It's not up to you to finish the task,
nor may you neglect to f to finish it.
Moshe may have had an unfulfilled dream
for himself and Claw Israel. But he
continued to work until his last day
towards its fulfillment.
Even on that last day, Moshe continued
to progress towards that goal.
And once he recognized that he would not
finish the job himself, he made sure to
identify and hand off the Jewish people
to Yahushua.
When I got to that line,
Moshe and Yahosua, his Hebrew name, my
Hebrew name, I think of the quote of the
Nitsv on that puck.
that it was like
the light of the moon that gets it its
light from the sun
and now I feel
like a moon beereft of its sun.
Rabbi Hower ended by saying, "We should
not underestimate our role as
individuals and as Claw Israel in
setting the forward direction of our
nation and the world. While we come and
go, we have the chance to build towards
the future by investing with love and
focus in the next generations.
It is not our task to finish the job,
just to continue it and never neglect
it."
Rabbi Hower, my brother, how do we do it
without you?
We we had a saying that we would often
say, I don't remember if he said it
first or I said it first. We often had
ideas come up together.
We would say, "We're just getting
started."
Rabbi Howard, we were just getting
started. We're not ready to move forward
without you.
We ask you to keep speaking to us and if
not to us, speak for us as a meosher for
all of the Jewish people and the world.
May it be so. Amen.
Please give your attention to the
screens for a few more words from Reb.
[Music]
We believed that the United States of
America, built as it is on the
principles of liberty and freedom and
civil rights, would never spit us out.
We never imagined that we would be
sitting here in this committee room
because of the kind of vile and terrible
anti-semitism which is being directed at
us on campuses. a fundamental Jewish
ethic is to be there for those who are
otherwise unsupported today. We need
their help and we can't find them. The
Jewish people are a very persecuted
people but they are also longlasting
resilient and that's the most
fundamental message that we as a
community have to take home which is
we're committed. We're going to
continue.
>> Looming anti-semitism is a major issue
that has to be dealt with. We are not
going to allow it to distract us from
the need to engage the community
primarily more strongly in Tyrone.
By the radiance of your presence,
Hashem, you gave us a Torah, a Torah of
life, the Torah informs our lives. The
Torah shapes it. What could be more
meaningful than really resolving that
problem you had in the Gomorrah? What
could be more fulfilling
and uplifting than some deeper
understanding into Hashem's world?
>> If we want other people not to have hate
and express hate for Jews, then we Jews
must not have hate and express hate for
Jews. Whether those Jews are to our left
or to our right or whatever other label
we want to put, we have to make sure
that in us between us, we are examples
and practitioners of AAS Israel.
There's so much more to be done and with
Hashem's help, we're just getting
started.
[Music]
>> Thank you everybody.
Please continue to share your stories
and thoughts. We'll send around again
emails to share. There's opportunities
to share to video uh recordings today.
Uh the I know a lot of people will be
heading to Baltimore. Uh there people in
Israel. There's there's opportunities to
go to the Shiva.
And um
as I mentioned before,
the only way we're going to all get
through this is if we get through it
together. And that's the way Rabah would
have wanted.