Disposable Items In Halacha - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] roof of my boy and Bechet me against your Tara I like to welcome everyone to today's year from of Yaakov Zev Smiths Lita and the topic disposable items in Halawa 3-shot family Valhalla forever liked updates goes to sponsor and share cool arrogant Shari Tyra seven one eight eight five one eight six five one unique Silas in the hospital they give these disposable hospital gowns someone comes to visit a patient that they keep them sterile they shouldn't get spread germs they have these gowns they used to make them cloth gowns now with disposable gowns made of paper and the typically after you finish wearing it you tear it off easier than pulling it off and the question is on Shabbos or Yom Tov is it matzah to tear the gown that's much easier than pulling it off when I want to tear a baguette the question is is a disposable gown can sit in a baguette and these weeks we heard the question about a disposable pot I couldn't believe such a thing I went to the store and I saw it I will soon describe it but a shaman pot that people use and you have a three-day Yom Tov Shabbos two days smooth so it's much easier to have a path you can throw out instead of keeping a part in the sink for over you know the three-day empty a disposable grill today they have the specially designed disposable Becca I was walking a number of years ago passed someone's house you gotta come with kharkom and the garbage is out for collection and he had a big bag and on it it said in big letters disposable Sheamus so that was certainly enough to put together a sue gear as well see in our disposable society disposable mentality everything is disposable we'll see we have Silas from the TOC Italian to the end of our kyuman and then a sprinkling of your a day as well but the crux of the issue is for many how lockers you need a Kaylee you need a Kaylee for kiddush and until your valium you have to toy ala Kaylee you can't destroy a Kaylee Kaylee is not mopped up until we the a Cayley was very defined appadas okay li a becasue Kaley a washing up of the Kaylee today we have disposable pots cups Becca gowns and the question is do we say since the disposable cup disposable Becca has the same benefit it holds the cut the wine it holds the water okay it's not as elegant this matters valuable but if it's a cup that pours water is good for the plc a value so who cares if you throw it out or maybe the fact that it's disposable you only use it once it doesn't have a sim Kaylee so the world disposable Kaylie might be a contradiction in terms so this is our question something that does the same function but it's disposable does it ever come Kaylee and there was good for the toaster dynamic in this or maybe not now again the word disposable you could call it cut Tommy like it's called today or I Roy but it's all the same idea a disposable item does it have the status of a cave and this is our privilege pleasure today to try to find a source in our toy us net shaft entity so responsive is a disposable Kaylie considered a Caelian I hope we'll find the first disposable in history now what's tricky is in this sugar there's no such thing as Homer or cooler you know some people say I'm a maker just tell me the coolest or I'm a maximum here there's no cooler or woman I'll explain imagine you come to a kiddie service and someone's making kiddush on a plastic cold cup you go what are you doing out there for case because what are you talking about a disposable by me is a full-fledged Kaling okay it's a free country you say what you want Sunday come to us he sees using a disposable pen yes and did you title it man I said I title it a disposable pans out of Kayleigh that's inconsistent is it a candy or not it asks for mercy that's coolest you know someone used a cup for kidness right and then by the kid that's after he finishes eating someone making a long long speech he's getting all nervous he starts crushing the cup you know people let out their frustration they crush the cup is that so sir Caylee if you hold it to Caylee like Abby kiddush then you can't break the cup then you can't crush our lumen and pen so really it has plumbers and coulis and you have to find a consistent approach so the hardware might be a source to ramp the chase after and kalynn pair of Zion or a skimmer lesson but after Carolyn Bava metzia hoister Kayla mine'll FS for s we give $1 high evasion now those they they didn't have tens or plastic they have to be very creative and they made vessels from vegetables from gourd from the last semester aghh and you made it as a receptacle to hold water how am to hire them even though you made it into a Kaley it doesn't have the status of Kaley and it's not macabre plumber like a regular Kaylee why here's the cat the punchline latisha FCC yama yama Adela's man morte these type of kalynn cannot last now in those days that was the that was the second best thing to a plastic a li so the flavor we see a ro not Tommy is not macabre Toma if it's not macabre come it's not a Cayley then who are then it's not good for kid this orphan at LSE Italian however and according to that a disposable also it also doesn't last but that's not true because try making a Kaylee out of an ester egg it might last the week but then it starts to shrivel dry and eventually rot the FAFSA a Kaylee made from these type of vegetables EF sister yaa murid Ella's minuite but if you take a plastic cold cup for 7 ounce Cole plastic cups and you keep it by your kitchen sink and use it for the next 100 days it will last doesn't fall apart doesn't shrivel now if you sit on it a breaks but then again expensive China also breaks easily in other words maybe a these the left as the last don't last by nature a plastic cup lasts as long as you want it to last maybe it's a cave where is this case F the ground which the Rambam and Kalyn bays I love quotes Lala huh when is this place after Amon apply it might apply to the paper cups that you get by the dentist the Dixie Cups is called those you use it once it starts to fall apart that doesn't last maybe that's not a candy grounder the same Rambam says if you make the paper into a Cayley it's the considered a Cayley some acaba Toma so here we have the following a Cayley that doesn't last out of a gourd out of the lass is not a candy but we don't see a sauce for our disposable cups plastic cups because they could rest now we do find this is a Gomorrah and Chavez Cookman involve its quoted in the beginning of senior dominance of Manara that a must the key is not a Cayley and a locker at least point to some sheath you lie to break it on Shabbos what's the most icky so a Kaylee surah a very shocking Kaylee that was broken and you repaired it so the assumption is if it's broken then there's no SEM Kaling if there's no simcha you gotta break it but again that doesn't have Sciences to our plastic disposable cup there's nothing wrong with it it could last it's not broken now you tell me but I throw it out in the garbage okay that's a different point so here we have to find the Raya that's something that might be a Kaylee but you throw it out is that a Kaylee or not so hear a voice I'm going to share with you a chase after grab also is a mission Calum they set this pair of rubber la jolla and since this isn't a coup the Mater Dei I'm gonna read the lawsuit Hisle cell tomorrow hey Faisal you know it's a puss akin Yehezkel to Zion valor crystal is a rapper Rashi teaches in the hustle to Zion valid creeps up The Forgotten in those day they didn't have cans or plastic they had to be very creative so they took the lulav branches like we have a crystal of the Lula and they made it into a kaeleen you know wicker basket that type of thing so instead of making a cushion I made it a little bigger and they put into tomorrow and the tomorrow ripen in this faisal in this case allah in this wicker basket is up to taste after if show us that level at tomorrow ullas ARCA Taher if after you put the tomorrow into this faisal you tore it open took out the food and throw it away it's not a Kaylee but the same Chrysler cost of lajas Missoula Heights Ibrahim and I buy this woman Asad up then its tummy if you planned on reusing it putting more things back and forth then it's time a cuz it's a Kaylee and the Rambam quotes this until to scale impair okay I love Italian ah now this is interesting because here you could reuse it and then it's a Kaylee if you don't reuse it it's not a Kaylee the same item is this a custom a dryer for our disposable items if you use it once and throw it out it's not a Kaylee if you reuse it the same item it's a Kaylee then it's good to the condition it tells your value and I must tell you that there are price scheme as well soon see that make this analogy a disposable cup is the faisal if you decide to throw it out this matter Kaylee if you want to reuse it and reuse it it's a Cavey but your voice say I must point out because it's negative to probably have all around with Silas there's a big big Malcolm low colic and I'll explain it because I think it's very Nagaya besides the Mitzvah quite the many ways items emits with their eyes to the table of Cayley there's an insert to use a Cayley that wasn't good table to now go home after the share and look in your fridge right now and you'll see you have a number of calum that were in good table how do I say that the creme jar bottle the mayonnaise my bottle the wine bottle even if it's a Hamish the brand it's met the bottles are made by which do you this advanced body how are you allowed to keep the mayonnaise the crane the wine in the glass bottle that wasn't good Tybalt you're using a bottle there wasn't guitar evil and indeed the head of the cousin is running with Brian item made by it and it goes to Cayley he would empty the contents right away and I want to use the crane week after week or the mayonnaise at a leisurely trouble but pokazhi developed his makeup and I believe it's a very good reason because a mayonnaise bottle is not a Cayley it's a wrapper it's a container varaha as soon as you finish the mayonnaise you throw it in the garbage when you finish the candy and a candy dish you don't throw it in the garbage what's the difference a candy dish is a kaeleen a mayonnaise crane wine etc tuna fish cam is a wrapper is a container if they would find a way of selling mayonnaise I've put it in your pocket they will do it but there's not sure if so they devised the way to give you a wrapper glass maybe plastic a metal and cans so the Hector of price though is it's not a kaeleen it's a container it's a wrapper it's a shell and if him any doubts listen to an incredible Mohabbatein Shinya dollar crest based on a coal boy the code base says hi Floyd mama shower case you're allowed to destroy it on Chavez Chico's that Kamisha shaver I graze him could they'll eat the lawyers will ship ahem you'll add a crack break this case along it's like cracking or not now what is the analogy to cracking or not the parrots is a beautiful analogy a coconut shell I assume is the pretty sturdy item and somebody's in the congos they might even use the coconut shell but no one's gonna say that a coconut shell is a Kayle that you're breaking it's a shell now if in the Congo they want to reuse it cousin date but it's not a Cayley rough moisture in our hiam I love cooker BAE's go so hard to say based on this clay so that me it could've been again he sees really maximum I love her but Mia coded in your ladder open a can on Chavez because a tuna fish can any care for that matter is only a Faisal it's only a cleaver there's an issue of making a candy but a cleaver is not a Kayleigh now mice at the end of the tumor says we shouldn't open cans or bottles or wrappers or bags but the point is a high so is a container for the food that's why it's not macabre Toma because a Kayleigh is a macabre Toma of container or wrapper a shell applies though a Khalifa is not so it's not because it's disposable but rather because it's not a Kaylee ah now you understand the second effort it's a scepter let's say you decide to reuse this clay so you decide after you finish the mayonnaise to reuse the glass jar to store things now repeat it's no longer Faisal you want to be used as a Kayle Kayle Kayle so the point is it's not the shock one use is a crystal and its moist and therefore disposable but if you use the faisal once it's a container it's a rapid medicating once you read aside to reuse it you strongly and making it using it into a Kaylee I bizarre imagine a plastic cup is a cup of Hazel F not a cop is a Cayley so how could you say hi so is the disposables not true my silicic is it conveys a container a glass jar is a container a plastic cup is a cup now if you'll tell me your Mikado from C night a disposable item is not a Cayley I could agree I understand you might be right but to say that a plastic cup is a place though is wrong a plastic cup is a cup now you want to tell me a disposable cup without of Cayley it's a free country to say what you want but the plastic cup was made to be a cup a cup is a Cayley so the point is a container that's not a cavies but a disposable pan or a disposable cup might be a Kayleigh now this is the crux of the issue maybe even though it's a cup but if it's only used once it's not a Cayley it's all right that might be true but let me just give you one more muscles I think to crystallize the point and I'm going to go in order of the cylinder imagine someone comes to a kiddush and as orphanage does everything there except for a baffle they forgot to get a bell so he has it so he says oh let me use a plastic cup someone says now it's the pasta dish you have to use something that leaves metal glass that's up you know what I have a good idea that's an interesting 8 sir but it's a good idea may kiddush on the bottle of wine that would be a better so his mind a glass bottle is a Kaling i think it's wrong you're better off with a plastic cup a plastic cup is a Kayle a glass bottle is a cry so that's the point let's apply this Lamesa and i think we should have a sheer delight the first question that people on the travelling in there and stay over the hotel overnight hotel is very accommodating but they don't give washing cups can you wash on a plastic cup so the truth is in cement I'll let Steve Zaillian the macabre says that even though you're supposed to use the kv-4 Nutella I am it's not Moroccan if there's no Cayley wash and make a brothel without a kingly so there's not too much discussion regarding a disposable cup as far as it tells you a diam is concerned but the big discussion is regarding washing for breads Simon : yes we're there okay Lee is Moroccan so here we have a Schuyler persons traveling in hotel there's no washing cupping use a plastic disposable cup so here there is one opinion in the pie skin why not a plastic cup holds two of these seven ounce cup is Corvis but maybe the fact that it's disposable so the fact that it's plastic is not a cesarean because all the plastic washing cups that you have in shoes are also plastic but the Shila is maybe since it's disposable doesn't have a stem Kaylee so here I found mama she I was lucky the mission is the active the composter oven sim involved regarding kiddush the Schrager humare in O'Laughlin hey regarding kiddush Anna till she Italian and our let's Ian and your olive of regarding POC Italian all say a plastic disposable cup cannot be used for the TOC Italian and they point to the Mishnah to the taste after that a faisal is not a Kaling so if you throw it out it's not a Cayley so regarding tilith I am and kiddush of disposable cup is a faisal and cannot be used for the mitzvahs a valuable kiddush however interesting the pupper of in his dhamma and there are buzz not and they are dumber to the to the Dragomir safer on the Tilted i am pissed izuta they both say you know what to write there that you can use a plastic cup paper cup until she'll die if it's not true like I don't know it's interesting ice comer that the arguments suck but both the Papa rub and refers to say your comparison to from a whistle to a paper cup is wrong a paper cup is a Kaling now if you consider it you don't like it because it's paper that's fine with me but don't say that a paper cup is appraisal and taka this is printed in his aiyaaa of olive sama hey he says I don't understand a paper cup that's made to drink from mr. Cayley it's not a Faisal Rab hencken in in the divorce elio pave of it says ain't any rubbish ostrich I don't see what's wrong with a paper cup the Oz Nick brew caleb of Memphis says I have known the car that oh I'm not Tommy is not a Cayley that a disposables not a Cayley the King and turn out of Memphis and Ravana in da house cometh to the safer saga Meredith will see Italian mamma says this if it holds the amount of water that's needed if it's not leaking what's wrong the paranoia inhaler gimel and hey and hey mem Aleph has a different angle he says regarding Appeals the Italian it's based on a mission up you could even use a Kleagle olam a most inferior kv made of the waist of an animal so how could a paper cup or a plastic cup be worse now the truth is the rally is not a rally because Ackley Clallam at least is used maybe the fact that it's disposable is not a caning and I saw them in cos it's cooking your Gitmo has this Tyner but the point is there are a number of Gedaliah pi scheme and there are more of that say even though you throw it out does not take away the Sham Kayley so the kiddush is even a paper cup is good certainly today's plastic cups is good for the TLC diet now I heard this more than once you can't use a plastic cup because it doesn't hold hot water now this is wrong for two reasons first of all plastic up does use hot water hold hot water and also has de piel look and cook from noon tests Dalit says there's no requirement that a cleaner tells you a dime has to hold hot water for karaoke bows to use cold water for washing now Lamar that's why La Mesa there is definitely of Malcolm Liholiho to use a plastic cup for the TLC Italian now I've heard this mamas are called away plastic it's better to use two cups than one so someone asked me that sure I said I've added two plastic type of machine I am an outlet but beyond that there's no reason okay if you hold one is no good so how does why is two better than the two adds up to zero zero so the fire up late all the mikheil em one plastic cup is okay for the Till's your diet now l'm ice up again there are some that amount as I told you and they consider it faisal but it's hard to understand this for someone who travels a lot to ask me can I use an inflatable cup for kid per washing I haven't seen it but the truth is if it holds the amount of water that's not leaking why not now the existence today is only today but the case itself is a good case what's the difference someone else asked me and this say he's to see this more often there you don't see it often these are collapsible cups you open it you close it so that is a perfect option again if it doesn't leak and it holds the reviews of water what's wrong even on Shabbos you could use that because a meet to show program that you have to assemble the pieces is no good this is one piece this is like a folding table a folding chair you could use it on Shabbos and weekdays and perfectly okay a styrofoam has one mailer that it holds hot water which is not much of a Milan but the fact is that a Styrofoam cup cup does last now you might say it maybe it springs a leak after a while so maybe it's not so good but if you careful with the styrofoam block IRA styrofoam the plastic up would be you can be considered a cave-in regarding these how long I was learning to cook and I found that a new Shila someone SD so yank efficient Avenue Cyril Hale attests in Milan it if it's if it's proper to use disposable plates for Shabbos Sudha I guess they felt it's not covered Shabbos it's not a Cayley so he answers like a godless boast to answer with say hope the women were caught enough a whole week that week enough when it comes Erev Shabbos to make them wash plates is unfair he says I didn't you don't use this by hasanah disposables but she says you use it by your bris take a leap and you're worrying about cover choppers so if the fish and the challenge and the kugel is good that's enough cover Chaves now he's talking like a god one of the words I bother ideally it's more cover job is to use China but if the women are falling apart as it is and they have enough work so leave it as it is it's enough of a Kaling Lisa planing cover Chavez kiddin to use a plastic cup for kiddush as Mama shower Indians the truth is that it is disposable you don't reuse but what's wrong it's a Kayleigh now Reformation has a tuba that is very misquoted the true ver was written in tough simcha press in our high end game a llama test he was asked about of paper cup nothing there was no plastic cups in those days nirisha has his kiddush that a choice has to be shoaling the mechana from says even if the bass the feast Allah is broken it's no good it has to be shoving so much says so I believe that a paper cup and it seems like because it doesn't last is broken before you start so therefore it's this qualified for kiddush how much does the average you can be mako Buttram isis problem was a paper cup in Topsham claw clasp that was something like the snow cones of today or the Dixie Cups that don't last now some PI skim interesting them in cuz it's insanely good have gambled at it silly as he obeys coffee mo girls need with I mentioned earlier all question relations act with great there are carrots and it's a row right now what's good who said he has to be a you know perfect perfect cup that last an SMS but where my ship probably felt that this is like a de las but that was relationships out regarding paper a plastic cup of today that does last maybe relations makeup so I saw two different quotations some quote are moisture that even plastic some say only paper but whatever the case is Romania stock was written regarding paper we saw already Rankin is maker regarding kiddush rapid our yank efficient tomorrow sabes que legality off cook noon fest is makeup i sir about Yahshua and Ashley is based on my face and a few places is quoted as saying a plastic cup for kid dish is fine now Avada all agree that a case of kiddush is a mitzvah and as the i saw the sound rub and others say this as well there's definitely an indian up sect a levy on value to have a real bethel if they're all a plastic up is not hither and once mentions in the shin of allah bus said it's a very surplus ik z k liy it's a good Kaylie buzz beyond value make it better so it's interesting reading but l'm ice ilaha illah all agree LZ k levy on value get a backup but if there's no better available then then the flavor in a plastic cup would be enough of a Kayleigh because it holds the amount of wine someone else be he goes to and us will camp and all they have is these backers and he's a more fun if he doesn't want to use someone else's back even if it's rinsed out so how could I tell him that he can't use a disposable cup according to many pi skim its cost to the hotel okay you try to have a regular case but if you can't use someone else's case a father a disposable cup is fine now today they manufactured the manufacturer specially designed disposable vessels now the truth is it's stronger than a plastic cup a disposable cup but it's not much stronger than the tumbler look look-alike glass cups that they manufacture it's but the problem is if you hold disposable is not a Kayleigh so the fact that you made a disposable better but it's still disposable so what are you gaining I think the real appeal of this idea is it's more of a Hitler Mitzvah it's maybe it's more zkb beyond value or maybe practically you can't put out plastic cups and tell people make it plastic cups doesn't pass for you but if you put out disposable VESA okay so it's a bet maybe that's the Mela but again if you hold a disposable Cup is not a Cayley then the fire a disposable bath is not much better now I always wonder there are some people that are very mocked it will not make kiddush unless they have a better but if they make kids on snobs they'll used a shot cup it's all it's the same plastic so if you might put on a case we've gotta be wine why you schnapps any different the other question that I mentioned if you don't have a backup which is better plastic cup or a wine bottle again our understanding would be that a plastic up you better up a plastic up is a is a price a wine bottle is a faisal now I looked into this again I found it is that the quoting of music to be wisest anchors on who once came to a kid ish and there was no backup so he made kid is on a plastic cup but he had a mind also that the kid is goes on the wine so just engage disposables not good you have this emergency hatch the bottle of wine interesting question moving on to a different Hill for Shabbos sugar something that was a was not look to Erev Shabbos can become look so on Chavez I'll give you a simple example okay leave that breaks on Chavez and now the broken pieces are not usable becomes look so as we said there are look like this last week ain't looks like aunty Shabbos means if it becomes ice looks it's okay but something that breaks is unusable looks a better Marshall a more common muscle a peanut Erev Shabbos and I'm upset but once you take out the nut the shells remain look sir now considering the following question you have a disposable cup plate or cutlery that are used on Chavez now since nobody reuses these disposable items are they look to uncharged a rapper that's sticky and is not usable Ohio's books on Java so when you take off the wrapper off the candy put it right in the garbage maybe it's grab sorry but a rapper that's unusable is MOOC so the question is on a used disposable item does it become mocked on Shabbos so here I think logic dictates even though no one we use that no one washes it but it's possible to wash it and reuse it I wouldn't say it's like a useless shell or broken Kaylee it's a dirty okay but you'll out of wash it so we could say that a use a used disposable play cup cutlery is not yet Musa because it is reusable on Shabbos even though no one else does it but listen to a more common question that has an important a laughing ramification thus open our attention that science says that a broken cable let's say our vows a broken hand you could use it to cover your cup of tea to keep it hot but you know it's not done typically so the sooner based on a gomorrah says if it broke on Shabbos and it's Roy so it's not looking so if it broke Arab Chavez and you threw it in the garbage Sheriff's Office and it was there been a small slice then it's looks tough because you indicated that he was not a Kayleigh so if you threw out a broken tail that's usable it becomes Moksa and cannot be reversed making the Kassabian smashes now the question is if you threw out a candy shoaling strange person if you had a full Kaylie so it's commanded by fairies at Isis in Cook Off a the mr. Bruin an owl a finisher at sea and points to that that Isis if you threat acavie Charlayne even Erev Shabbos it doesn't become look sir but Latoya you don't make a Kegley into ice cave he's only a Sheva Cayley narrow by family ask you a common question a person finished his water bottle Erev Shabbos or Thursday whatever it is and he threw it in the garbage or is apple juice battle now those apple juice scrape two plastic bottles are very very durable you could put water in it you could bring it on a trip it doesn't leak it doesn't crack you threw out a water bottle apple juice bottle Friday and it's not even dirty if you put it in the recycle garbage can can you take it out on job as you decide to learn outdoors you want to take some water outside to drink very interesting question it's not broken but then again no one reuses it how do you look at a Paley Shalom that's disposable if it's a kv Sholem it's now mop so if you can tell me it's not a Kaley then it's mopes but I'll give you a much better example people typically by a Simic are in a camper nice Eva they bring the garbage can to the table and it makes it easy to clean the garbage throw the garbage into the garbage can but this more often than that is a problem because if Danish ma scheisse there was only garbage in that garbage can the garbage can was the bus system looks up because all the garbage becomes mock debate as monsters miggy's gets elevator smosh beside the cooler youngnam the only exception is if you have a cliche lame in the garbage vanish Marsh ice which is not look so so that stays the whole garbage so some people put clean garbage bags in the bottom of the garbage can so it's always a bus this faretta so it's not looking so wonderful my question is let's say you're not so advanced you don't put God with clean garbage bags but in your garbage can there is a water bottle apple juice bottle grape juice bottle plastic does that make it all look some because it's not broken it's a cliche lame but then again it's the dispose but most people throw it out so this highlights our new question regarding disposable or disposable water bottle that's fully functional the same cover the same spout they threw in the garbage is that Moosa or not so the really the question is is it Charlayne or not but I think the answer is none of the above a water bottle is a cliche Lang but why does theis to say a CLE solemn does not become look sir because Buffett I say no one throws out a CLE solid but a water bottle that everybody throws it out I saw a number that I'm think of price can look maybe let's say for the funny discourse it's recording member Yash if they say that you threw out a disposable bottle it becomes look so iet's Charlaine but there's no busload I tell you so if so a CLE solemn is no better than a broken gaily and if you threw it algae makalah dies that it is not usable and therefore it becomes much I was thinking even more positive it's not a cliche Lane it's a cry so solid when you finished use the water bottle on Friday it was the container for the water bottle for the water now if you want to reuse it fine you making it advocating if you threw it out Friday afternoon you identified it as a non Kaley Hisle now Boehner smash is kicked in coy so is not a Kaley it becomes MOOCs up and that's why you can't use it when I saw from rabbi yosef in the Selma Uranus and gimble Samak babe this is coming very mascara a carry their brakes on Shabbos if the broken pieces are Roy is not Musa but the biologist said if you throw out a water bottle on Shabbos it becomes moccasin how could it be worse than a tailor shop so he says very very long to savour a Kaley banished mash ice was cool a run to make it look sunshine but you have to throw you have to do something to throw it out to muscle but it's still the same Kaley all those broken but a water bottle was only meant to use until you emptied and then it's woopsy so once you emptied it on Shabbos it goes back to its original status of a non Kayleigh which is mucked that's even a bigger city but I think we're comfortable to say that disposal bars were thrown out before Shabbos do become look one thing sometimes summer once the SP it's a real sila but he threw out by mistake he threw out a non used disposable item he threw out a plate or whatever mistake so besides the fact that it's not MOOCs because it's a mistake but if he bought mr. Cayley shelling see here we have Tice's Butler died and it's not MOOC sir listen to a more challenging than it sounds type of question because it's a big big sugar in our lockup but it's specifically regarding disposable items the shock on earth in three plays race time of chemo race time' Hague emotion you evolve and shinai man hey Dalit has a discussed a big circuit at in Sharples and abelian does it is submitter opponent in the movant Oakley Masonic you can take a usable Kayle and make it looks on Chavez a good a good example I saw this diminish lamenting Jana your festive cotton hey says if you have an air conditioner that water is dripping it's not dripping actually that's the condensation of the way the air conditioner works that water is looked because it's it's a Nylund it was created on Shabbos so a patient you're not gonna drink the water right but you can't take a soup bowl and put it under the water under the drip because your move out - female funny because after a short while the water is gonna drip into the plate the plate is a busses to mix up and now you can't move the plate and that's what the wrath she learns isn't it suffice to me drop on them you are ruining the Kaylee you can't use it it's a mobile so I like to ask a question so you're not gonna use a gel impact to catch the drip can you put a disposable pan under the drip and keep it there and it's double you throw it out is there an ISA of me vodka cream a hon I buy a disposable item no a new Shidler right but I'm gonna ask you a follow-up minik Israel to answer their question with another question how are you allowed to use a napkin or a tissue on Chavez after you use it it's no longer usable you dirty tissue is what's up okay why isn't about the female car night so the answer is very positive my vodka female funny means you Runa Kaylee you're not using its first regular use you're ruining it but if a cater was made to blow your nose or to wipe your hands I'm not ruining it I'm using it it was made to do that that's not ruining it I'm using it now when I finish ball my nose I shouldn't put on the table I super right in the garbage so I have to move them up so but I'm not ruining the Kaylee I'm using it this was talking Rachel I'm a giver quoting of Ayasha of this mere Shabbos sorbets cop test says this unique aside regarding a disposable item if it's made to use you're gonna use it on Chavez and it's not I'm about to cremate Hanoi not because I never see em Kaylee but you're not being a Vitamix you're using it not abusing it so I was thinking that might be the heckler also to put a disposable pan under the drip so the drip will go into the pan even if you say well it's a pretty good Caylee to me but if that's the intended use to use it once I'm using it once Roslyn hey Lee Krasner gimel speaks about putting a paper napkin under a wax drip it's also about that we make funny so he has the goes with the other side that I mentioned that may be a napkin is not a Kaley it's only a must icky it doesn't last too long so by a must icky there's no ystem about the cream it's all night because it's not a Cavey but the point that I think is important is that mavin Oakley mayor's Hanoi might not apply to a disposable item if that's its intended use next question I once saw the Shila some was making us hey mister simcha and he had what we called disposable dessert cups it's basically two parts there's the base so plastic and the cup itself with a stem and you push the stem the top part into the base and now you have a nice dessert or a fruit cup you forgot to make them before Chavez are you out to construct that's the right word put the two pieces together to make a disposable dessert cup it's all plastic you throw it out after the use people that need injections on Shabbos they have to put together a syringe of the needle they're also making a Kayleigh on Shabbos but if you know this to come and denominator both of these items are disposable one-use throw it out is there a Nyssa of Maktub a practice buy a disposable item now we did speak about once before so I mentioned earlier you'll have to open and close a table and a chair so why am I worried about this dessert couple of this syringe there's two spots it the folding is one piece that's why it's Muslim this is two pieces this your construct is like a meat the shop rockin so this I must tell you is a big sugar but one thing I think is klore that there is an S of maculopathy SH even buy a disposable item and here we're gonna find the first disposable item in history i SERPs my miss almond in memphis lomatin jana your test the Marcella yo and beige you'd get Moses Cone gimel both bring this Ryan it's a brilliant rally that there is an ism occupatus even buy a one-time use item similar that we all know and it's ignoring Balaam but gimel them happen soon for Vaes dollar quotes it you now to take a kisum a piece of a splinter of wood off the tree to make a toothpick to clean your teeth he's some lastest version of like mr. morality concaving question a tooth is only used once why is it is remarkable passage is Araya that even buy a disposable item that's only used once there is an is sir of mokuba punished there's actually a second right also a beautiful eiffel and also ignore that we are familiar with Lamar says they do not allow to that that if you that that had Assam that have too many berries enough another Maru Bob is not good for Hadassah but if you take off the berries and now did if the regular how does its caution but don't take off the berries on yum tip because it's ticking K that you're making the Hadassah either that's them I'm not a Kayleigh Gummer it's only for a few days of circus is there I even buy a disposable item because it is of macular partition and that's why the Marquez Elio that I meant in maceió actually earlier Kayleigh Bay's you'd get moe when he second base you'd get macaques of cotton gimel and discusses making a disposable desert cup he says this is a real problem now as far as this syringe you'll see them in cash lame is makeup for different reasons and their other maquila I don't wanna get into the I'll leave that for now but one thing I think is beautiful we found a source of the first disposable item in history it's key simlab sighs very Sheena if they made it and he threw it out right away if you want to know a really amazing disposable I think the good seitan today they have what's called dissolvable stitches they put in stitches that dissolve after a few days so that in a certain sense is a bringing disposable to a new level not that you throw one out it just self destructs so you could look at it like nothing but I saw it Robin listen Carrie Allison foot that Shawnee ahmud raised stuff he says Punk for character he says but you you make these disposable stitches you stitch the person then you tie it up you're making a catcher and the cashier remains as long as you need it you don't untie the catcher afterwards it dissolves but you made a catch to show Qayamat that lasts as long as you need it that would be I'm a lot of the riser of tyfa or christian even though it dissolves but it lasts as long as you need it to last and you don't untie it eventually that's his understanding so he have the disposable dissolvable stitches question you finish the food in there indeed the panthéon be chicken or the kugel in the disposable pan and you want to get it into the garbage it doesn't fit so you want to crush up the disposable pan that's no longer usable and throw it in the garbage is that a question of size - Kaylee if a disposable items at Kaylee then you can't destroy its size - Katie someone after a kid is wants to stomp on the garbage - all the plastic cups so there's more room for garbage you're breaking numerous Kalyan someone is sitting by his speeches he's getting all nervous he starts to play with a disposable fork and he breaks it bends it out of shape like Korea by Hamas a you know he's breaking something and a constructive way so the truth is if you just follow the pan in half so you could it's not broken you can open it and close it but here I would say the following imagine you see someone that is one with lung takes two key some lock the Machine of it makes it on Chavez so he's IVA and you break that key soon that toothpick isn't that an SSI sir the fact that it's only ones big deal but this I service a Yank efficient Amira Shabbos and saying the Dalit cafe and the faculty she toss say he says you can't you says he old you allowed to use a disposable cup for kiddush he said oh don't break the copper that would be sorry sir Kaylee now by gosh have said about cutting a pan but if you have a cook and you cut it in half that's also slice to cater you're breaking the depend I would have thought you're making it to to Caitlyn it's also problem but Lamesa if it's a ceilidh isn't itself çiçek a lis pendens ominous local enslaving your days osu was asked about a plastic up they got bent she says that's not broken it's like it's like a paper that got bent the opening is not it's not broken when it's folded slightly so that's not an issue it's like I have to get smash you got to fix it if it's not terribly broken but to break literally a plastic cup aluminum pan and crush it that's the issue of size - Kaylee I'll cap on em and it said there are blonde enough sighs - Kaylee which is McCulloch another typical disposable question if you put very hot soup in a plastic bowl it starts to deform let's see in a foam bow it starts to soften and lose its shape the mr. brewer in the beginning of senior class quotes around them that if someone's me rapid growth Kosta if he softens a hard item that's the malapa Bissell either hardening a soft item us to offering a hot item that's the maloca Bissell slicer by Yossef in them our shop is dialed on the tough cook-off says that's the problem if you know it's up sick racing and it puts very hot soup into a plastic bowl or hot water into a plastic cup and it's gonna be clumps off that's the Malaka of mirepoix guelph kasha but most place can that I saw a make up with a simple reason that that's not a my summer welcome you're not doing it for any constructive purpose and it's not even it's not it's not there are some things that an animal walks on unless you macabre to that you want to have a hot bowl of soup it doesn't move the bowl you don't care about it the saving allez viens fest nuns I endure can you entire ice of the shea butter cost see a very nice chew of ice one D big gonna sell a yahoo says it's only a soft beaker and it's colossi odd but the mice of the veldt is Mako and I understand the reason it's just not the tourist I'm a lava of Morocco Gulf custom the question of tearing apart a hospital gown is a challenging question because limey boy if you hold that a disposable gown disposable item is considered a Kaylee so this disposable gown is a baguette you can't tear apart a baguette I it's Michalka but solicitor Ivana but even if you're going to say a disposable is not a baguette but you can't tear a piece of paper even though it's McCallum either I bought it but you still can't tear something that's that it said they're abundant of Korea so imagine someone puts a a paper towel as a bib and peers their pie after words that would be at least the Michalka so basically the price game are seem to be masked mere just like I mean people are even more so they're worried about pulling on paper towels from the holder because they might tear the next one because tearing correa even Derek opal is awesome but I should mention Picasa crack there are two starting to be making on this issue there's the famous sheet of the reversal enough to be a lock and shim em you'd give up quotes it without a name the Rob has a finished that correct only size by something that was woven together like material the lesson that Bjelica brings Dover Auto for the narrow action it's varma gülfem Robin like in the irrigation of Michigan a beggar that was woven that's the issue of Korea but something like or that's one piece there's no Easter Korea so according to the Rav perhaps our pace the our paper God is different but these Emolga paper that was from Ward one piece maybe it's a Korean but to be a lawful approves that the Rav is not right from a Rambam he doesn't even quote his name I was covered so the Ralph says it but it's as fair as I have to be say my thumb there's another heckler which is a finish of the Reventon Peskov guess that to step on unbroken items there's no issah because once it's broken there's no it's of breaking it further so maybe at a gown if it doesn't have their love of a Kaylee maybe you could say it's not a brand that matter it's of Korea but certainly it's better to take it off even with needs a little difficulty because it could be the issue of Korea and last but not least the your a day of questions I hope I now should be simple is there a fear to tell you the old style is the table disposable pan so one thing I could say without doubt something you only use once the Ramos says clearly and cook rest cook off seat passenger idea there's a sea of Steel people say only once is part that's not true they're more says Italian where did people get this only once from from disposable but disposable gufu let's talk of the shot so to say a disposable pan is appraisal is wrong a part is not a consult right so a disposable pan is like a pot it's not a faisal it's not a container it's a pot but I'll tell you something rabbi yosef and the deputy of both say after type of disposable pan and that's very much the schita some because they both say you allow to make kiddush on the disposable cup because disposable cup is not a priceless Akeley so that she toss some if it's okay the other toilet so there are those that still table this bull pens based on this Qumran rather today they have many they made by Eden so there's no see if in the first place but I would say I think that veldt a maickel not to display that to title it so first of all we could say disposable is not a candy but the truth is without that there's a significant sound to be make up moisten your day a gimmick off gimel was asked about disposable items and his understanding is that disposable pans cannot be reused too much they don't list you make kögel the chicken it's come out impossible to wash it well you cut a piece of chicken in the pan you make a hole it starts to leak they aren't they can be used to long or a bizarre he sells pseudorandom we began with that if you have a Cayley of the lass it's not a cave so in other words even though it's aluminum but it doesn't let it can't be reused a plastic cup you use cold water because intake you could use it but aluminium pair misunderstanding is it is not reused now he does imply if you will designate it to use over and over the Marshall somebody asked me he keeps kala kalah in aluminum pan and he has to title it it could last and last and last but if you use it for a kugel for chicken that you can't reuse it the fire of the ducati maickel even if it's a Kaylee it's not a Kaylee that lasts now someone asked me he makes the cocoa thursday night he has to tie a mare from the kugel thursday night he used it Friday night go go go Shabbos afternoon and leftover Sunday using a four times but that's not for different use that's the same use that you just cause ring over the same use so that's not high even stealin grab there of moisture in your day a gimmick of basement behind given MSD archive so can lady has the beautiful tubing carved out of them and they all say that aluminum pan has another side to be maker independently and that is aluminum is not from the same axis that's found in the tire it's a we are more recent discovery maybe it's not try even Tillis Calum with ERISA it has changed to my boy mkford so aluminum pan at most is a fee of Drebin on and since we have these Goods far that it's not it can't be reused that's why the belt are Simas logical the Marcel Leo in Bay's nun says it's no sorry Malcolm at all he has a very nice Cuba iron some one of the hiding place I was surprised when he writes if you want to be really from take to the pan fold it up open it so like Haley show us that you throw and you're not try even Fela which is a pellet because when you fold it it's not broken so it's not broken it's not Kayla show us to you strong now I was asked once about a disposable pot I never saw it so I made it my business went to the store and I did some research and I guess that oh I'm not buying anything shouldn't be neighbors that's a yes the law he was very accommodating can I please see a disposable pot she told me was very popular for three-day empty because you have children Chavez in two days Louis what do you do with the charm pack basically the one I saw upon him the disposable path is nothing more than a reshaped aluminum pan that has a path has a cover and it's the same material and it's practical that is definitely not high even feel it's even probably less than a aluminum pan why besides that it's aluminum but it's only made to make sure not to keep Colin once you make Sheldon once you can't reuse it it's so oily it's hard to wash so that's one good reason that it's not hiding to deal up the good news also is it's made by eating because gram don't have three there youngters I should tell you so they have no problem so therefore go okay I'll see sir I was not shy even tila I also asked them to show me a but people asked a disposable grill so at least I'm pay the ones I saw there might be difference but he told me this is basically the two it's just two different size but it's the same idea a disposable grill the bottom is a regular aluminum pan that you keep the charcoals but the top is the question the top is the great and it's made of metal it's not aluminum it's like a lattice design it's made of a metal not a very strong metal but it's not as flimsy as a aluminum pan now the mohabbat of the Farish if you're grilling something the grate is kind in Fela but good actually the food touches but I was again I never used this but I was told by many people that you don't reuse the the this disposable grills it gets too dirty so even though it's metal meets out after if you don't have the cooler of aluminum a tour of aluminum that's not other ice up but it's La Jolla a disposable so if you're feeling is disposable I the Nash I even Tillich is only use once and thrown out it can't be reused that garage said that you can't reuse it like the de las then who have been a disposable grill bielski grabbed and is in the safer says yeah that you're off the table aluminum pans but in he does say the table a grid a grill fat Pamir ostomy mattress caution type of light brocco but I imagine what his words coming from is that since you don't have this out of aluminum so it's worse but the fiber the fact that it's disposable should be enough soir and that's them the vinegar them not to table aspirin club if I told you earlier I once what once saw someone have his garbage he has regular garbage and he had the this was lighted then he had disposable Sheamus now that caught my attention what did that supposed to mean so let me tell you there's no such thing as disposable shameless shame a shame has to be kept with the utmost kedusha the Terek days lease a solution will decay shamrock monoliths lon that's the way a person able to do something to cut is borrow food and anything that has Seamus Shem not only saved our through a mezuzahs but commercial said durum that have Seamus gem has to be treated with utmost kedusha the problem that we have seen in recent years is Baraka shame there's so much learning going on and there's so much different tire that that are circulating from all different venues you see this have worksheets and people of different IRAs newspapers we are we are overwhelmed with div rate IRA that it's partially difficult to start bearing world is very tight so there is a school of thought that Tyra story after you have to put in shame you have to bury it but there are those could tell you them see if I mean cuz it's got that felt they made this kill it if something has shame a shame then you can't do anything but bury it but did retire on the muscle a vote area the achiever works Affleck make a copy because I suffice in the newspaper articles and don't have say Michelle the kedusha comes because you're printing Tyra if the shots the printing you ever make it tonight it shouldn't be how could do sure I'm using it once and then I'm going to throw it out then you withheld the kedusha shame a shame bites me you say is college tonight as no but other did retire without shame I share button I helps now how do I know they made it tonight you have to be certain that they know that's not going to put a famous and it tonight was made but just like her shyness if they shine around but that's no condition whatsoever it specially che mimic you can't throw it in the garbage you can't be Mufasa do you have to put it in a respectable place so those good ol instead put disposed put the Seamus without chair myself in a separate bag not in the garbage with the Challon bone and then the dirty diapers and leave it out to the garbageman to take it so this person gave it a creative name disposable shameless but it's not disposable Seamus it's printed debris tire that doesn't have to do sure I couldn't talk to you all I said a voice I please stay seated for two minutes an urgent message from Jeroboam in our community by her Abu gorab ashamed now voice I'm going to try to make it in less than five minutes the worst nightmare for a Yiddish attend mama is when they get that phone call notifying them that your child cannot come back to you even your child doesn't fit the mold everybody say for those that experienced it know exactly what I'm talking about and for those that didn't trust me maybe should help you should never experience but trust me the heart comes to a halt the heart stops what am I going to do with my child what this child's future the parent could plead the parent could cry the parent could tell manam in our house I beg you it's Pakula pushes what is going to be with my child and the response we understand but we're sorry they go from one layer to the next and the response is identical how many tears how many sleepless nights if I say but there's one lace a local mayor said cold shall shall dismiss Yakov you probably didn't even hear about it the parents fear that there's a school that maybe this some hope they run down to that building the knock on the door the door opens wide and there you have the Merneptah man at the Manor Hollis or the Mahalo by Koga man standing there greeting them at open arms and then looking straight in their eyes and saying look at this child of yours with full confidence with sea otter - Maya this child is going to grow up to be a bossy sir she is going to be a you know you're going to see knockers some of all have I saying it always bothers me at such a great school why is it the only school there has to send home the teachers with empty envelopes and the answer is simple because the sudden will not allow the school to succeed because this school is the escalara god the sudden realizes that these girls if they go through this school they're going to be saved now they say we're back you open up your arms open up your hearts support the school and let me tell you something there are a lot of sitting here and a lot of ages we all know no one is immune today you could be their riches and the most wealthiest person have all the resources for professional help and Driver tutoring but you're not immune you could be running the most I'll see the show you're not I mean we're living in a great time but also a very difficult time before you write out that check say - boy I sure AM in this list I'm going to help out these children and these families I beg you vaccinate my children protect my children and it disgust Yogi's are you go Sokka Sokka he did not listen your children this was the meeting where this feel then it ever will many are aboard the community asking everybody over 200 girls are in the school over half year they didn't pay the teachers and the school wanted closed down and we asking everybody to give a thousand dollars a hundred dollars a month a credit card or whatever they could do monthly Todd saw us Natasha's Manish checks mater shell jealous about break-ins here one of the biggest condom of this moisted rubber cuckoo man comes from time to time please everybody to try to help out themselves and others to help out maker people in the bottom of the ocean like many did already to Mikasa cot solo some versions of this school this kilometers apparently khan sharmila tagore gonzaga certificate abram to mrs. Cheney Madonna's hope is Minh City oh yeah girl traviata' Kaddish a mine on my next week son is the last shape before the summit and the summation will start me after shame in two weeks after the July 4th weekend Monday night and all neighbors ballpark Williamsburg Flatbush now boys I please deulim I said take a credit card monthly or checks to pay out throughout the year team a with them hot solid enough foster solder a bottom the community called and asked they everybody she helped a lot over the school system it's is shakarez commission system it's a system is a place said please give bigger money a thousand dollars or other can score this kind of system credit card machine outside advice to give the hand this commits this take a card to fill it out he's enough using everything yeah yeah Myron motion his fish was added to be showing that it has to be the hard question Carson that's why he kindness that plastic is also fun it's not just paper even though the Cholula just about papers not ever cross today the truth I saw two sperm one cone even if it's hard for us to keep time I quote I said at page 44 another safe which is relative I'm above it so yeah coffee table [Music] please Soula stuff pushes okay Osiris misgiving a one-time secret of today's year but it's not disposable just saw some learnt a better Semak Lee that's made from a Veloster ahh --mess it's not a ceilidh because doesn't last and inferior your paper something also was not a Kayleigh because it can't last it can't be reused too often a must the key is a broken Kayleigh it's broken because it was broken and was repaired temporarily that's also like a broken Kayleigh but the sugi of today is the word Hisle the kreisel is a rapper usually that wraps the food but if you use it once and throw it out it's not a Kayleigh if you reuse it it is a Kayleigh so here the two ways of looking at our disposable Calum of our times some take the approach that anything that's used once not two three or four not many times is a clay so even a plastic cup or an aluminum pan and some say no that's a regular Cayley the fact that you throw it out does not make it I scaly it's not a rapper that's there to hold the food this is to drink from this decay Lee that is disposable so that's the two schools of thought above the cannoli up I skim either a feistel with any disposable item or a crisis only a Kayleigh that's used as a wrapper as a shell as a container now many are may Allah God until she Italian and never Vasa to use a clay a plastic cup because it is the Kayleigh it's not a fly so there's no Fiat to have a styrofoam because an old hot water that's not a criterion regarding to us the Italian there's no my love two cups versus 1 and then fatal an inflatable or collapsible Cup is okay as long as it holds the water it's not leaking to use disposable dishes for soother Shabbos I guess it's quite ich die so it's also called the Chavez and not to make it too difficult but hatela a becker is preferable but many mal to use a disposable cup and dispose the new Bertha's are our guests more xia keli beyond value but even a plastic cup is okay disposable cup or bottle of wine it's better to make on the disposable cup schnapps is the same problem a disposable cup those that don't use disposable schnapps would not be different use a disposable item that's used is not mucked up because it still can be reuse if you wash it if you threw out a water bottle before Shabbos that becomes mucked up because it's that's not but my diet if I can't but look I say I can't hear the but Medina is that you threw it out it became ice Kaleigh there's no denim about the clima hun i buy a disposable item specially it's my yoke of the car to use a is making markup of the is of macular partage does apply even to a disposable item like we said a kisum laughters machine of and therefore making a desert cup is a problem dissolvable stitches is a cancer cell Kaiama maybe it's a toy fur because it lasts as long as it's supposed to and then it doesn't get untie but it falls apart one should not crush or destroy a disposable cup or a pan but folding the pen just once I guess if it's not broken you're not breaking it you allow to use a lot of perhaps very hot soup into a plastic bowl of hot water into into a plastic cup even though it's softened slightly that's not the truest amalaka one should not tear a disposable gown unless this Josif car goggle because basically it's still the use of Korea which is Michalka and the mending is not the type of aluminium pens unless you you could reuse it and will use it many times a disposable path does not have entry lathela a disposable grill is similar to disposable paths that it's if it's not reusing off the table it and disposable Seamus is only a fancy way of saying if it's printed did return without shame a sham that you plan on throwing it out doesn't have a fear of putting with regular shames