Daily Gemarah - Tuesday Mar 5, 28 Adar I

[Music] the Bayaka for Stalin okay I also have to think about it if you could just put maybe then we'll just put the copies away so we'll have for tomorrow okay I always tell myself we're gonna finish on time you understood I didn't mean you Castro Shalom you understood that yeah but I didn't mean you I meant that we we had the conversation you remember about all the you have a them and if I had to mean you so then you could take it as you but I didn't mean I'm saying you didn't did you get embarrassed who me yeah okay because I apologize if it came across that way I didn't mean it okay did I like that I like that in July these are the real thing the real thing first of all anyone that sits here really so now you're saying they're not exes no right okay well some exes coming you would you would run away no he would come to the felonies didn't want to go on I know you see this okay and Duke item yeah it's a good my sister my sister yeah yeah yom kippur juice come in kipper juice come I mean not all Jews but a lot of Jews come you know the rabbi his name is rabbi dovish einer he founded what's called the Orthodox synagogue of Soho or Soho Orthodox synagogue I think this was the first year a second year he is but it's a general Orthodox synagogue I don't know I don't know it was the early years and he asked me and he asked me if I could come him Kippur to inspire the people so I K I thought it would be an interesting experience and it was it was very moving actually he made the synagogue I think a year after 9/11 2001 so he built it his Casa de was 9/11 he got married on September 11th half of his guests couldn't show up or even more because it was 9/11 I remember the Hopa outside an Eastern Parkway you could see the smoke and I was I was officiating I did I am see the hope around the Hopa I remember we could see the smoke of the twin that was that night it was September 11 that night so he decided with his wife that they're gonna go establish a shul in that area and a year later they moved out there and they built a whole killer there yeah because he got married at 9/11 at 9/11 he called me up in the afternoon he started to cry and he said how can I get you know nobody even knew then it was 3,000 people they were saying 50,000 dead nobody news not that three thousand is a small number but initially remember they were saying 50,000 dead the whole Twin Towers both towers and the Pentagon I mean nobody know what's going on so he calls me up around 12:00 or 1:00 or 11 right after it happened and he's crying and he was a friend of mine and he said how can I get married tonight I'm supposed to dance and be his happiest night of my life when when you know nobody you remember the shock then like America shut down nobody knew what hit them I mean they did a job they'll Qaeda did a job on us she said how can I get married it's it's I said why can you get mad he says it's selfish I'm gonna be dancing at my wedding when 50,000 people were lost right right a few blocks from me a few minutes from here this was Brooklyn so I shouldn't put something into my mouth literally I said the question of your wedding yes or no was not a question of joy versus sadness everybody is sad and you're being happy it's a question of good versus evil what they did was evil getting married is a good thing it's good you fight evil bye-bye goodness by building goodness that's how we destroy evil getting married tonight as a fight against evil you're building a life you're building a family you're building love you're building the world they'd want to destroy a world you're building a world that's what you're doing precisely tonight you have to get married at caiman tonight and it was very transformative for him so he decided as a result of this conversation that he's gonna get married and build a community there right away the Sun at his wedding and it took a few months and they moved there and they built the synagogue so he invited me in Kippur and he introduced me he said that really we're by Jacobson is the founding father of the synagogue not because he did anything but because of what he told me on the day of my wedding so he's like the founding father so to speak the it's nice to be a founding father we don't have to do the work right so it's easy to be such a founding father I mean I was I was flattered with the with with the attribution so that's when I went to the X when I went to the show he said come see the product so I went to the show when we did our kyurem experiment I still remember when I got up and everybody was on the floor few hundred people on the floor I assume so I mean I haven't this is quite a few years ago I haven't by Dovie shiner rabbi and rabbits in China his father is the principle of closin burg ah I think it's called the Orthodox synagogue of Soho or the Soho Orthodox synagogue or something like that Soho synagogue maybe yes I know I know this was mama after 9/11 and I think was the nexium Kippur maybe two years kippers after shortly after two or three years after okay as usually I apologize for my delay if I that's us in this I don't even realize and now there's a new clock here okay okay we're up to da feud gimel Amidala on the bottom Amish on the bottom four lines four lines from the bottom armored abusive mamas four lines from the bottom you'd gimble Amidala things on the Camaro told the story a very interesting story that somebody deposited a saddle bag filled with comets to a man named Johan and kakuka and mice came and perforated right made holes in the bag and the thumb had started to get depleted from the bag I guess because of the holes and he came to the abbey to read BW de NOC and he asked him what to do what to do with the deposit thank you so Rebbe said wait he came to him at six wait seven wait eight wait nine wait why the man gave you a deposit you can do anything with it he'll come and hopefully take it and Elite it then came the fifth hour the fifth hour would be would mean ten o'clock and that's when Rebbe said go and sell it go and sell it why go and sell it so as the Gemara explained that Rebbe meant go sell it to a Gentile because you can't eat it anymore nor can you sell it to an Jew because no true was gonna buy comets on the fifth hour because there's nothing for him to do with it all he can do is sell it to a Gentile so why should he buy it just to sell it if he can eat it he could buy it to eat it because he wants some food for him for his wife or his children for his family members anybody but since it's the fifth hour he can't eat it so Rebbe said go sell it what he meant was go sell it to a non Jew because in the fifth hour you could still have an offer from comets in this sixth hour you can't you have to burn it minty rabona seventh hour even in a Toyota but the sixth hour will be there are bunny you can't have one now but the fifth hour you could still sell it so Rebbe said go sell it to do the guy a favor because if you don't sell it right he may come now and sell it but he may not come in the beginning of the sixth hour is gonna come in so any ten o'clock eleven o'clock is gonna come and what's gonna happen is whole comets is gonna be coupled I won't be able to eat it it won't be able to have enough room it's gonna be how much other love a peso it has to be destroyed and there's nothing to do with it that least save him a little bit sell it to a ten o'clock whatever you'll get even if you're not gonna get cost prize but you'll get something and you'll give the guy a little money but till then Rebbe did not let him sell it why it's not yours to sell you gave me a piccata and you didn't tell him you didn't turn me into a partner that's not me to say it's not mine to sell I there are a bottom there are mice okay there are mice but I'm not let us sell it and because I'm not let us sell it to me so just wait wait wait in the fifth hour now if I wait I'm gonna cost it's gonna cost a person a great loss so Rebbe allowed him to sell it and that's what the Gemara concluded and from here we also proved that Rebbe held like review hooda that you can only eat comets till the end of the four hours cuz in the fifth hour you can't eat comets anymore and that's why that be said go sell it to a guy he said go sell it and we explained it that it means to a guy because tor drew it's not going to work and even though Rubio's have challenged that but as robada told abusive that he himself at an earlier stage said that that be meant to a non-jew and not to a Jew and therefore this story supports the of Rabbi Yehuda so that's why we have before Rav said a black man said in the name of rava logically reorder here we offer here we also have a support from Rebbe that halakha is like Rebbe Yehuda I want to tell you an interesting story that I saw his brought in the Yale could be Raymond and the Martin Amis if the Gemara in charset service was Yaakov Charles a Jewish was Yaakov hey like I love similar tests he tells a story am i sir with a person who deposited at Ava's Gura a clothes chest a box by his friend as a peckerton he gave it them the Shimer the custodian didn't know what's inside because it was a sealed chest but he took it but with one condition the condition was I'm not liable and taking a crisis in other words there's different types of Shyam right is a famous soccer there's a cypher there's a soil he wanted to be the lowest level of schmira meaning I'm gonna guard it I'm not gonna be negligent I'm not gonna put it outside I'm gonna lock the door at night what we call a shine machine up but it means I'm not taking a crisis crisis means if it gets lost if it gets stolen obviously if it's a natural disaster for sure or not but even if it gets stolen I can't say oh why didn't you put it in a safe why didn't you make another lock why didn't you hire guards I'm not taking a tries for it you're trusting me that I'm gonna be a decent but that's it that was the condition it came Pesach and the man did not come to pick it up the Schirmer didn't know what's in sought and he thought maybe there's hummus he doesn't know he doesn't know what the guy gave him there was lack that was sealed but maybe this comments let's say about a Jew okay so he takes the chest and he puts it in the room with his other comets and he sells it to a non Jew he puts it together with his own comments let's say with his pantry of of Moscow or or frozen comets with and it wasn't frozen then but with his comets and he sells it all to a non Jew this was a real sale torn Andrew what do I mean by a real sale a real sale means it was a real man Jew who got the key to the house and who actually bought the Comets so what happened the guy came and he took the chest he sold it to him he took it the guy comes back where's my chest he's just I'm not gonna have comets in the house for your sake and for my sake you know let have another juice comets in your house according to most points can a non Jew that you don't take away is your latter half a Jewish hummons in your house many buddies are your personnel that have push it for me and also for you that's your comments I didn't know what's there so they came to the shushakov and they asked the question does discernment have to pay for what the guy says was in his chest or not he said there was something expensive London with comets so how am I supposed to know there was no telephone there was no whatsapp I thought this may become it's at a Suffolk I was trying to save you and save myself I sold it to the guy did the right thing he says who asked you to do with you weren't allowed to do it I was never macabre triose he says yeah but you were approche yeah so I wasn't approche that's what you have to be for paisa I want you to pay me he says but I said I'm not taking responsibility not taking responsibility means if you're not negligent but you were negligent what was it out you sold it to a guy you gave it away he said I had to sell it to a guy was a shock omits the Safa comments you never told me what it is interesting question they came to this was a curve and they asked him what's the what's the locker okay maybe he doesn't have the power maybe he doesn't have the power he did [Music] maybe this is what happened and the gray took it well ruin dinner tried to take it whatever he got lost it got damaged they got lost he doesn't even say what it was exactly apparently wasn't comment he didn't know what it was so this was a Kiev thought will you figure it out and he said it's a buffet de sugar Mari and our sugar this is this story of yolk and I'm caca car and Rebbie that's the story why see he said as follows he said take a look what happened in ISIL again it says that he had a bag with comets and and mice came and perforated it perfectly made holes for how your comments move at speeds V I'd say Mossad speights means the Comets was dripping out seeping out licking out it was were falling out with watch Birds beards meaning who was getting lost and it was Arif pace why is that detail important he comes to rabbee rabbee says wait wait wait wait first our second our third hour for though fifth hour ten o'clock go Sal isn't the same question any bag with comments forget nice let's he do it no mice let's say it was a perfect bad with comets what am I supposed to do with it you give me a bag with comets a bag with pasta what am I supposed to do with it and I would come to that be I'm supposed to sell it it's your hummus why should I sell it the fifth hour that beam I tried have told me listen to this pasta here sell it to a guy and give him the money because if not it's gonna get burnt right but the governor has this whole detail about mice coming which look sorry why is that negated to the stories - Luciano said as follows this point in the story even if it happened seems superfluous why couldn't the same story happen without mice forget mice have a bag filled with comets what should I do with it it's area of paces it's yours what am I supposed to do look hide it if you would come to never you would say wait wait wait wait wait could the guy will come and eat it what do you have - it's a beaker then it's his comets the fifth hour it's already deadline the guy is not coming right if you wait a little longer it's gonna become a sore back he lent us a Bahama it's already awesome Arizona sell it at least you'll make 50 bucks a you'll get so he won't go with a completely empty-handed he gave you a Picard another hundred dollars at least you'll reclaim fifty dollars and you'll you'll give him the money he'll have something if not he's gonna end up with zero grant of course yeah it says it was it was this wasn't a secret a stash was Yakov Watson a gaya so you'll say well that's how the story happened the fact that's how the story happened the fact that the Gemara mentions it in the story means that somehow it's negated to the story why is that so negated to the story that there's mice so he says the shot is the shot is as follows very good he says well my nerf committed the same sack who cares if there's mice or not let's say there's no mice it's not getting lost what's the difference then you could sell it so he says the trapped is the Gomorra wants to say hum it's my vApp spits V I'd say because it was comets my fat spits V I'd say so he knew for sure that there was comets there because he knew for sure that it was comments there he's my crew you've to sell it what happens if there were no holes and it was a closed sack and the comes not my vitamins B I'd say then he wasn't Malouf to be harsh maybe those comets and therefore he would be forbidden to sell it to a non-jew because by selling it to one Andrew what's called a paella you're taking something that it's not yours and you're being negligent with it and therefore he says that the guy has to pay him back yeah that's why the gomorrah puts in my vag spits Vig why is that me gay no could be could be he did it with good intentions but he's still a per share per share doesn't mean he's a bad guy yeah yeah but but here he said the truth he wasn't denying it exactly yeah yeah for all the results yeah he made him pay yet to pay we don't know it doesn't say what it is I don't know if it was a diamond I don't know what it was a diamond I guess so I don't know you say why didn't just break open the box it would have been shorter but he probably didn't realize that the guy is gonna is gonna ruin it I don't remember I have to look it up you could look it up yeah yeah he was my even to pay yet whatever it was yeah I'll prove what it was how did he prove what it was how did he prove what it was I guess I guess he could prove I hear I don't know right maybe it was then it was broken whatever I guess yeah you're right he had to ascertain that it was there yes yes I don't know the answer oh what a thank you it's interesting the only the only R I want to say is that one of them is showing him that my rom Calva Robin immersive Calva what are they we shine among the gomorian soft him so he says a different reason why the Gemara emphasizes that mice perforated the bank and he says what was happening is that they were eating the comments the comments was falling out so the company I'll put it back the problem is not only the comments was falling I'm about specific I'd say means it was falling out and they were eating it they opened the bag and was falling outs and now that bar and we're making a party out of it so therefore that's what the Gemara means that even though the mice are eating it so that means the longer you delay selling it in three hours you're gonna be left with very little so you would think that rebbe would say go sell it for that reason not mid/side the Comets mitts are the guys budget losing his food so that's the hidden shove a Rabi that you still should not touch it and the reason you should not touch it is because the guy may still come and want his food and therefore you don't have to do anything with it until the fifth hour when it's gonna be completely destroyed not just the mice eating part of it but it's gonna be completely completely destroyed that's what he Titan is in other words if it was time a bag of comets it wouldn't be a Hindu shove Remmy the finish of Rebbe was that it's not stomach bag of comets every hour that it gets delayed I'm gonna have less to sell or you're gonna have less to eat so even if you do come you may be happy that I sell it now you know why because you're gonna get maybe more because you can only I don't know how much dr. Barr I'm gonna hand I'm gonna take the whole thing they're gonna take part of it still Abby was saying not that's how the Maruyama solvet idris elba sorry there's no half left - this part that the reason the gomorrah says this is that he knew that it was comets the finish a box bottom is all different there's that even though it's being depleted still you now let us up I just wanted to make that harder yes you have enough rise the only thing is you have to understand if the market from the Gemara that we're gonna learn now maybe this mystical or under my Ram cava I just want to point that out that says Mahalo sunder Gomorrah but we're now gonna see the suger continues and it could be that's why the shushakov didn't want to learn that way we'll see in a moment of course something tomorrow I'm gonna be a severe abuse if it's just mayor on yeah be commandos Lodge my to Debbie when Rebbe says you're allowed to sell a Picard I now that's a kinder stay a lot of seller peak are there because it's not mine in other words I could say it's not my sorrow that you didn't show up its comets Erev Pesach the sixth hour we're gonna burn it I should go sell something that doesn't belong to me without permission that's a give all they can finish it's a big finish in Halawa I'm taking your property that I do not own I'm just a custodian and I'm actually selling it without your consent why because I want to protect you that's a very interesting finish legally I could sell your property because I want to protect you not for selfish reasons so he says we did you Rebbe get this you soit it follows the birmingham leo that sananda Mishna says i'm off get paid assets elevator well admit see a la Monica's somebody deposits fruits by his friend a feel ooh pain i wouldnt even if there's mold or decadence and what happens is it's getting lost it's getting depleted Logica behin do not touch them yep Sherman Gamliel I'm emotionally Basden sell them under the authority of Bezdek so they should make sure that you get the right value because it's not your own loss it's somebody else's loss me pinay shabbos evade them this is actually hush of Assam aid it's called returning a lost item because since the mold or the mice are causing it to be depleted so when the guy comes back you're gonna give him less than he gave you so I'm it's not harsh of is evaded to give him back something that's getting lost to the mice sell it now and you'll give him the money that's from Zimmermann Gamliel skiddish Licari there ya be followed that Sherman Gamliel says I'm a lot of selsun that's not mine Frosch of a survey they here to four hours of a survey that this hummus is gonna be lost completely within an hour go sell it and you'll give back the vada in the terrine there in the form of money a Malay abaya a buyer said not not wrong the love it Merrill or did we not learn on that mission err on my Rabb of economy Ravi I shoulda known rabbit this son of ours understand they may be on a leash on the argument between the Hammerman affirming Hamlet on a common term homeless alarm bodacious Roy not only if the fruits are being depleted according to the ordinary routine of depletion there was basically something to be expected if you put fruits here for a month the Gemara goes to the judgment if you put for a month for six months for a year this is what you should expect to find based on the natural circumstances of decadence of becoming rotten of mice etcetera of all yosemite data sorry none if you see that there is a hastened process it's really getting depleted much more than regular then most run Bethesda n-- everybody would say to sell it in other words if it's something to be expected you could say since this is to be expected so this is what he expected why are you selling it he wanted to give you up in Condon yeah the famous expression of the Gemara other Maritsa become shallow Yosemite Jacob Michelle Kaveri a person appreciates one cough of grain that he worked for more than nine Cobham that somebody else worked for so even if he's gonna get less and with the money is gonna get more ten economist says a person wants these are his fruits it's his grain it's something that you work for something that you work for even if it's a little bit is much more precious than a lot that you didn't work for we all know somebody generates their own revenue right so even if it's a little bit it has a certain value to it that if you get a gift that doesn't really belong to you it doesn't have the same value all the roads become shallow Yosemite she accomplished Elko Nevada so as a result of that kind of Commerce says the person expected this and it's fine we're assuming a vanilla says you could still sell it Monsanto shoppers of ADA but if it's really getting depleted in a fast way irregularly then everyone holds much number best in a bazaar if this is true of a culture cane house adopts in the Montgomery if so everybody would agree here that you sell it why because it specifically gummy it's not just the mice are really eating it up and you're gonna have much less than expected here you can end up with null with zero cityliga me it's getting completely ruined as well actually says Chanel sorry and bhajana not only you're not gonna have anything to eat you not even have anything to feed your animals or to give us a gift or to sell it's becoming us and monarchs comments the beginning of the sixth hour becomes awesome I nominated a bonus beginning of the seventh I was at my nominal trainer and therefore even kind of karma would agree than here you could sell the Comets and therefore you shouldn't associated Africa with this two professional men I'm Leo cuz even if she minimally oversight of swimming upside trying to come up with hold that this is different you should tell why cause acidity lagana cousins completely being ruined but that's only when they became the fifth hour till the fifth hour Rebbe said that what you should not you should not eat it and this stum is maybe a hard on what the Maram halva says because he said that the fact that the mice were eating it right Rebbe should have said that you sell sell it but Debbie didn't say didn't say you sell it but look heard of the fact that you were comparing him to Birmingham leo and if Shipman Gamliel says that when mice are eating it you could sell it they Missouri Debbie should have said to sell it earlier it's time an interesting aura shushakov taka learns and it's just a whole different idea the whole idea that you should know that it's comets it's not the - bottom are eating it because then look light if you're comparing him to the birmingham lila should sell sell it earlier unless you say like the mosque um a stock of going come him and since it's normal thing that is my so maybe that be said you know let us sell it only later but I'll come bottom leaders was the Ark of it's very clear that it didn't have to do with that it's not that the mice we're eating it up instead the mice allowed you to see what's inside that's taken so that means that could be a riot to the circle that's been occurred in the Gemara and that's why he said that this show is not McCoy if to sell it if he doesn't know that his comments inside just has a Suffolk the occupy said lived in their 1600s right the concept of commercial sales to a guy started right before that started in the late 1500s in early 1600 so at that time it wasn't like today that everybody just sold it formally to a non Jew in those days there was still a lot of the real individual selling to one Jew you know you went to your neighbor and you said here take the Comets and it's yours yeah the concept started then because in Poland Jews owned inns motels correctness with bars with a lot of vodka so they used to sell it before paisa but it just became impossible because the would wait till Arif pacer and they knew that the Jews are desperate and they can get all the marsh qey and all the vodka for a very cheap price and they became a crisis so they're a bottom of the time in the fifteen hundreds of sixteen hundreds in Poland came up with the idea of mysterious come as the way we do it individual people wasn't a big thing because what did you have in your kitchen yeah - tickle kala yeah what did you have the concept of today with grocery stores and surplus and storages and you know and then it freezers and all that that didn't exist you cleaned up your comets and it was dead and if you needed you talk you sold the tool go that's why in gomorrah meanwhile having a later mission emotional emotional you could sell it to a guy but it wasn't a big thing in the Middle Ages when Jews for Parnassus started to own bars right Kretchman ins with bars which didn't exist in the time of shots that became a big issue now because now you have huge quantities of comets so you can trick the ball up before pacer and you could sell them all before Pacers but once the Gentiles realized it became a disaster people were using losing you use for losing huge fortunes of money so that's when they came up with the idea of everybody doing my serious comments right right yeah yeah no they had vodka distilleries but a person owning so you had to clean it up I'm saying a person owning a Barney had hundreds of bottles what is he supposed to do he could burn it all but it was just a huge loss of money so you figured it out but it wasn't a common thing of many many people in an hour generation of course it expands to the fact that we have big alms and a lot of food so that's another issue right with pantries filled with comments you can also burn it but so that's what my serious comments became a very big issue because they had to do my serious comments how do you do it that's when they started to develop it yeah shava surveyed I think is an example that you can find an animal you don't know belongs to you can feed till it's eat enough because of the turf right so then it's your own loss sometimes if you keep the evade that you're gonna lose money but here we're not talking about that this is peace because right cuz you don't want to lose money but he and I losing money it's just comments it's not an animal you're not losing anything jacques de cámara a number of you hood the Mishnah continued and told us a fascinating story that ever you'd also taught us that the were be hood is set in the mission on the field I'm your elephant base that they had two collars of Toyota two colors of Toyota that they used to place in the Huayra bias on a bench so people would know what time it is basically one of the car bonus that people would bring to the bay something this was a carbon Toyota carbon Toyota's a carbon of thanks gratitude if your life was saved from a dangerous situation from an illness or you went through the ocean the sea you travel through the sea or through a desert or a prison and came out what we do today with our gamma breakfast are going more person was very ill and they became healthy and they brought a carbon tired and the carbon tide comes with 40 pieces of bread the 40 pieces of bread 30 of them are matzah are made in a match the style and 10 of them are made comments carbon Toyota so they used to take two of those breads of the title as the mission is sector Buda said they absolutely were invalid to eat as we will see and they would place it on a bench on the Hara bias as long as they were both there everybody knew you can eat when they took one away they knew that it's the beginning of the fifth hour and you can't eat comets anymore but you could still sell your comments or benefit from your comments in another way because there was only one car then when they took both colors away they didn't the second one also they knew now at the beginning of the sixth hour and it's time to burn your comments this was a public sign that they used to do for everybody to know again since there were no clocks and you have to look at the Sun to figure it out and not everybody knew the right time so they gave this public cinnamon and if you're sure Lyon was filled with Jews and everybody was near many people were near the Huayra buyers they were paying for the carbon based us and all the other stuff so therefore on top of the Arab is on this bench they had the sign to Hollis title they took one away you stop eating comets they took two away you start burning comments you have to ask yourself but this was just a public service and then rumor had it if I was at the Hara bias right or a friend was at the Hara buys you go to your neighbor and you say what's going on and he says they took away one girl you know I guess rumor spread and probably people tweeted it also or scented what's happened as a result of that it got around for iw their stay follows something about a Toni tonic come a DW hood Itano here at Anna doesn't mean at Anna from the tan I am it means somebody who taught somebody who knew the mission is and were teachers so he was teaching the mission in front of review hood and he was quoting Robbie hood this is Robin Hood at the Tanner but he's teaching it to review hooded are Myron and he says that the two collars were a Yamaha its tava it's live amines a bench basically when they had benches people would sit on it was called an its diva like a chair a chair made of stone on my lathe you the test in Astana to this person reading the mission the helots neo newts arith the point was to hide these collars why is he putting it on a bench who's gonna help who's gonna be helped by it to me the way they have to explain the mission is Algarve ah it's de ver al gaga it's Devon not Algarve not on top of the bench but on the roof of the chair meaning on top of the chairs they had a cover to protect them from rain on the roof of that they put the chalice so it would be on display so everybody would be able to see it because we don't want to hide the palace we want to display the palace in a visible way oh my wrath of Hammurabi you hood ralph was said in the name of Robin Hood um and it's interesting toys for says here let me show you rob by mulac coral a Rebbe two lines ago we called him Ravi hood the suddenly became rabbi yehuda how does that work so he says really what's revealed because he was Anna Maria in bubble amount of time as they used to call them Ralph not Rebbe the time no Liam they called the Rebbe and I'm a rhyme and I just roll they called the Rebbe badami Raheem and bubble they called Ralph but because Erasmus Reber his personal permanent and most important trevor was Rebbe you who'd this so therefore he called them personally Robbie you hood and my teacher my my my Rebbe and my master so he said in the name of his teacher higher abayas the temple mound the mountain on which the base--emitter she existed was starved coughing haaaa it was built with a double row of benches like like in a stadium like in a in a theater in a lecture hall they have a row of benches in a circle and inside there was another row of benches stuff is a row of benches or or cheers made out of stone stuffed awful haaa it was circuits circled around and round the haribhai is two rows one inside the other Tanya Nami hockey we also have a price of supporting this Hara buy his stuff cough allaha the Hara bias was built with shears rows of chairs in a circle a double rows so that's way people could come and sit and as we saw before there was a roof on top of it to protect them from cold or rain or stormy weathers when they came to you or July so basically people came to the Hara bias and they could sit they could relax they could sit they can smooth they could take a rest whatever it was and on one of those it's the verse on the roof they put the two scholars everybody to see ah [Music] the two collars why wouldn't the birds eat it and if the birds took a little bite Mela you see all the birds would come to the harvest Ida they put it out in the morning they put it out in the morning six seven eight whenever in the morning early morning and then they took one away at ten o'clock if sunrise what says they took one away at ten and they took the second one away at eleven so you look to you so to Hollis you knew you can eat they took away one Holly have to stop eating they took away two kalus you have to start burning Tanya Nami how she hired by stuff couple aw dime interview this says Istavan as hoisin across stove the frenemies stuff it was called east of honest it's devon is what does he say in it's devon is a row of benches and it was called this Devadas which establish name is stove one row inside another room Oh a store front bencher in front of the stores they had benches cuz the shoppers did the store keeper the store owners would would sit there and schmooze and and put out for display their merchandise in the middle east much of the Commerce was done outdoors not indoors uh no air conditioning I guess and you know the weather is not the weather of Eastern Europe when the Jews went Eastern Europe so most most Commerce was done outside so they had benches and shears in front of the stores which was called East Ivana's and the haribhai is they had stove lift nummies stove one stove inside another stuff meaning it was two double rows and that's why they had this place where they could put the steak house it was a mountaintop yeah the Hara bias was in middle the base--emitter it was in the Hara buyers but on the mountain itself you could sit in the azure once she commented the territory the based on Victor she couldn't sit it's only multi based of it but outside and Arab eyes you could sit I mean you couldn't go on as the mission said Brooks you couldn't go in with mod and with the mud on your feet you have to clean yourself up but but you could sit there it was fine not shops no no the bench is similar to the benches in front of the shops stone benches you could see and archaeological excavations in there just roll yeah you could see these types of shears inventions right so you could see it it was made out of stone and you could sit on it you could sit on basically a stone that you could sit on and that was called its Deval Arista furnace huh yeah you could sit down yeah people would meet that's in da surah that's in the territory of the basin mikdash itself but this was the mountain around yes only mouths based on that yeah no no over the everybody could sit yeah if he said yeah then they would stand yeah yeah says the Mishnah okay so another little bit Sulis it was disqualified fair the Gemara my pursue lies I want every year you had to Hollis that would disqualify and like how did it happen how do they become Sulis what happened here so he says I'm gonna become into something very interesting the Turks are you mean rude boy sniffs always ballina there were so many carbon Toyota's brought on the 13th of Nissen that they couldn't finish all the bread so much of the bread stayed overnight untouched and in the morning it became disqualified we have to remember every carbon has a prescribed time limit for the carbon to remain kosher some car bonus you can eat for that day the next night and the next day two days and a night the carpenter they're not the carbon tide you can eat that day that you bring it and the next night but that's it so now if I brought a carbon Toyota I was saved I bring a company I have 40 pieces of bread look I can't eat 40 pieces of bread but I can eat it in your shall I am a whole day and a whole night I can invite friends relatives dumb people I can invite all the poor people in your shoe line come for a great meal and within 10 minutes all the bread is eaten up and it's fine you can eat it in your shall I like we say every morning hot tired of Al Nasser cut some column right now Columbus color ear hallo domme Boko Michael a young viola we say it every single day you can give everybody the hum say to eat it'll cut size but just fine enough we have a I'm being the carbon tied at 11 o'clock in the morning we have a whole day to eat it and all and I'm not much of the night to eat it this was a regular day the problem is most people didn't live in your show lion they're coming for Pesach anyway so I've had to bring a carbon toy I would bring it I would beat microvidia Malmaison everybody was Malcolm detergency Gillman listen so you had you could have had hundreds of carpenters with hundreds of pieces of bread and it's impossible to feed everybody with the McCallum so by hooker Barbara as a result of that and if subways ballina what happens if the bread or the meat stays overnight the moment morning comes it becomes puzzle it's like after the time limit after hit the time limit becomes nicer it's left of what's that lucky after burn it it becomes possum that's why it stays solid Sulis you download this and in the morning yet all these Hollis that you couldn't do anything there's only 1/8 said to burn it so you know what they did they use two of them for a cinnamon for comments it's called kill two birds with one stone here it's not two birds it's two breads with one stone not killing but instead of burning it is nicer we'll put the two together and we'll burn it as nicer and as promised it's also comets and in the meantime it's gonna be a cinnamon to remind everybody about the hours they took two of these collars which couldn't be eaten and any meat or challah that goes after the prescribed time becomes pasal because again only in its limited of time does it retain the traditions like expiration date there's an expiration date the moment morning comes it's expired you can't eat this meat anymore why because too much time has elapsed since the carbon was brought and basically it loses its its freshness in terms of spiritual kedusha and you have to burn it it's a very interesting I welcome it's a fascinating thing morning comes and it's it this left him as puzzle so kameena said that used to happen and explains why were there so many car bonus on the 13th of innocent the tiny will enterprise sir aim with the entire Bahamas you couldn't bring a toy on Pesach my play is common symbol because part of the bread has to be hummus so of course you can't bring a carbon tire on Pesach very interesting a lock shrew is is not a problem Lucas is not a problem but Spacek as a problem this is what the bryce is says says the Gemara in Bucek debates are quoting this Bryce obviously obviously you can bring a carbon pacer a carbon toy down pacers by your a by your mother you know you're gonna bake comments in the base--emitter dish it's by your elbow you're not saying right you know what I have comets for a carbon and also since you're not letting eat this comets so if you're gonna bring a carbon toy that with this bread the carbon is gonna be disqualified because the carbon could only have food that you're allowed to eat if you not let it it's gonna disqualify the carbon and you know that I have comments so obviously I'm worried about the Bhairava huh barb or us our skin on what the pricing means is even on your dollar Dennis an era of pace of in ala being a carbon tadaa because of our because the brystol holds a movie and culture base up so you're now allowed to make a carbon in a way that you're gonna cause it to become disqualified if you're bringing a carbon toy the era of pace and how much time do you have to eat the bread till eleven o'clock courts even me they're nice until twelve o'clock it's impossible to eat it's own little so you're gonna cause the maize it cuts them to become pasal you're gonna have to burn it because there's nothing you can do era of pace if you can't eat it anymore so it's gonna become sites comets and sites gonna become nicer you so you're making cuts and become invalidated and you now letter do that so therefore they couldn't bring it your Dollard miss and that's the hitters so what would they do the kulamish La Russa my salut so the whole world would do the carbon onions give on this and you couldn't do it I'm pay so he couldn't do it you doubted you're going home after pace you know you knew your limes and when do you bring it you bring it you'd get mo ohmmeter shame Anubis no sellers Belinda there was so many car bonus and your gimel miss and everybody jammed it into one day there were not enough people to eat the breads so there were breads that were left over til you doll admission in the morning they became disqualified through staying over the night there now parcel and that's where such State College Sulis they took two of those scholars which had to be burnt in the morning but instead of burning them in the morning what would you do you would put them on the roof of one of the benches on the Hara bias and use them as a saw and when you have to stop eating comets when you bring those comets and that's what happened rabbie sure ah the bullsháá how you gonna have Travis Crusaders on your dollars only if you brought the carbon on your dollar but nobody you know let it be bright Souls you know let Brinker bonus on your dollars so the only way you could be a carbon is you'd get moe so buy your dollar that's possible no it's a steak house tidy up soulless why would two collars of carbon tired to be opossum if it's regular palace is not puzzle parcel means it's it's it's puzzle it's disqualify the answers cuz it's a carbon and it went through the night and you didn't need it at night because you had so many car bonus so male in the morning it became post they had to burn it anyway so that before they burnt it they used it as a sign for some but you couldn't eat this collar the day before you can give all the people to eat yeah but because there was so many car bonus everybody brought and there were 40 there were 40 loaves of bread for each Carmen ten of them were some words but there were 40 30 were mob son you had to eat all of them you can't eat it all by yourself even with your family the box is a problem because it also gets disqualified the carbon tire gets disqualified out space of the mats is not a problem that's a carbon it's a problem so in the morning