Daily Gemarah - Monday, Apr 8, 3 Nissan

[Music] thank you same thing same thing sometimes when you you make up a mixer for your child or you marry off a child and you see the next generation developing on their own you feel malthus you know what I mean that's what it is it's not stumped you're happy of course you're happy you're very happy your daughter your son it's a deeper element of self that comes out there's a part of self that you couldn't feel before you couldn't feel it and it's only because they're going independent as your children move away your daughter gets married your son gets married or another stage in life and they they make a life for themselves in that separateness you become a melih you become a new person there's something inside of you that comes out that never came out before what is it it's that quality of mal hosts that can only happen because they have made choices as a result of your influence that have created a new independence for them yeah listen there's another side to it yeah yep the Rambam and hillcrist river chapter 5 says that free will is the foundation of Tiran mitzvos and the Emam is the great advocate the free will we're very strongly how all of Judaism is based on it and despite the fact that we're born with dispositions the Rambam holds that way Kira Kira clutter okay darlin trash Tannen yeah this is so cool talk you'll see you have to go to Shabbos he's dealing with young tip now you'll soon see what Shabbos is this is all young tough it's not Shabbos Yom Tov is simcha and then there's deeper than simcha yes supremacist altas Panama is done you're stuck in consign leus you're stuck in fit sign is there's no good sign here sir there's no stick no stick nobody's making with their hands and nothing is based on manipulation protects your family Masseria traditions my solution garnish it should fit in it should look good had tables garnished ah norther a Burstyn so the Norden a burster look at the tail is only the a brush to garnish nothing else half lover fella [Music] yeah yeah biscotti of hollow le laasa Begala is niggler love irony levity hija simcha gala mustangs and the Elizabeth II essentially does the although being aware of its ela is there any assembly even before anything else the weirdness of your ela you're ready there I mean to a significant degree the ultimate in law of course that's the father and mother here that's the ill of in La Scala Elise there's an expression in the ballot Anya in La Scala in Las Positas College simmers the ill of all the ilis the word ill I think it's connected to the word owl which means that which is on top but not in space and concept the seed the sperm which is the source of the child which comes from the father which comes from his father which comes from his father etc or mother Adam and cava with the ela for the first child for the first children who became the ela for their children and then that's all so essentially you can trace yourself back all the way to the source Adam and hava the ultimate programmer right the first code the first coat okay let's move on we are up to the Cubs are in a mood Alif I'm going to try to push a kayak I'm gonna try to teach a little faster today without taking away the hopefully without compromising the clarity because I want to really get into the thicket of pesach we don't have so many days left to pay so so I'll try to move we're up to deaf coves and I'm at Alif close to the bottom of the page the second line of the wide lines coves iana mat out of the second want line of the wide lines Lavy shoved our Laila Rebbe you see the line starts a love of Zion I'm at I love the second one of the wide long slavery shoddily Rebbe lavey shudder laylee Rebbe Chikara Bartley sir magani Lavy cent Rebbe beer made of dates but it was made of 13 bundles of crushed dates 30 bundles of crushed dates makini means crushed so the shitara the day that beer came from place are from 13 McGinn a crushed dates he basically took water he poured it on crushed dates and then took the same water and port port port it on another bundle of crushed dates to absorb the taste and ferment and he did this 13 times so that the beer really absorbed the flavor and the taste of 13 bundles of dates this wasn't just a process once but 13 times this is what he sends as a gift to Rebbe Tom a Rebbe taste the beer have AB awesome Tuva it was delicious did I translate Boston right it was exceedingly flavorsome Omar Rebbe says K goings a royal ekkada such a beer is worthy to make kiddush on the lime well of course she does research muscle cimbalom and to recite on it all of the praises and songs all over the songs and praises to the remaining Loyola on this type of beer story is not over Balala nighttime comes oh yeah it's IRA did this beer cause um aggravation the rash balm says that basically what happened was shushil it affected his entire digestive system and at night he had tremendous aggravation amar he responds me Yassir on who me face this beer that causes so many syrup should be the one with which we appease and we thank the reboiler shillelagh sorry he changed his perception on the beer I'm gonna be fabulous have said enderbury Robin delay st chakra i'm going to make a public vow that I will never drink beer of dates because of Yosef understood the consequences and he also understood the temptation so he said I'm not gonna make a private valve I make a private Val then I could come to a great sage or three about three and say and they'll explain to the last me if you would have no in the circumstances and how would unfold what have you making the vow and there's something called right a tourist in the Dharam we undo we undo the Madera retro actively what I'm gonna do with burr table and I'm gonna do it publicly and according to some opinions and that's really stuffs opinion if you do it in the public only at Quora they can't undo it that lockers they could still undo it unless you do it all - rob him unless you do it on the mind of the rabbit on their mind not on my own mind then you can't undo it but a country abusive and others even if you do it were a bum you can't undo the nether on my rubber of it said Ashton Mazur you and Willie Ashleigh chakra I will drink even water in which they soaked flax water that was flax was submerged in water which doesn't taste good but Valais yesterday's [ __ ] I will not drink beer of dates Behrami rubber rubber osa said to have a shock you say she sure Amanda McIntosh Akira he who makes kiddush on beer his drink shall be beer meaning it's a disrespect to kiddush if you choose beer over wine and therefore somebody who disrespects kiddush because he doesn't use wine for kiddush let his drink be beer he won't be able to afford wine but only beer by his denigration of kiddush he cheapened the kiddush and as a result of that he will not have the money to be able to buy wine but his regular drink will be beer Rav Oxford area Bruna Ducati chakra one day the bonus sees that Roth is making kiddush on beer of dates on Millay he says to have char a Abba l'm McNay Easton and machinery it seems like that Abba this was his term for ralph name was ABBA or was the name of respect it seems like Abba started to make money off beer basically you went into the business of beer and now you're buying coins through your sales of beer which is why beer became so delicious and pleasurable for you and that's probably why you're making conditioned beer which means he probably Sourav make kiddush on beer even though wine was still an option wine was a possibility because beer was very beloved for him and therefore he chose the beer over the wine we learned before about Roth that sometimes if he liked bread if he was hungry with make kiddush I'm bread not on wine so in the same process Roth felt if you really like beer make it some beer but why is he liking beer sir a bonus says probably you went into the business of beer and it's doing very very well so the beer has a special affection by you and therefore you're making kiddush you're making kiddush on beer in this case by him it was a brook by him it was a brother because it came it came from his love and why would he considered more cover than wine because he was generating tremendous revenue from it that's what rabona said the strange thing is that huh the strange thing is that earlier the Gomora says that you have said not to make into some beer and I mean not to make up dough long beer even if it's Kamara Medina that's what RAV helped so suddenly suddenly what changed I look I see NAR been a phenominal it's a story about grab a bar bar corner which is a different story but perhaps what I was thinking is maybe that's exactly what happened to Munna knew that Rav holds you don't make kiddush on beer and suddenly he's making kids of sham beer so that's maybe what prompted rabona to say this that something happened for which beer became beloved so it's Bianca maar Medina but that's what your Puna tells around no that's Rebbe Lavy gave the beer to Debbie this is Ralph that's the next generation tolerable and the rabbi's taught a Makhachkala yayan mainly work in Halawa ryan you don't make kiddush on any beverage only on wine and you don't make a brook on any beverage only unwind asks the Gemara really add to a shifter of a miami liam of arsenal are you shocked only a bit vara you don't make a brach on beer and water shackle near Bhavani what do you mean you know make a brook only a wine I'm a rabbi or hockey karma the bride cement ain't I have a costa brava lavoris allah lion not you don't make a broker only on wine you don't say bring a coastal broker to bench a special cup of blessing only unwind that's what he means a movor Candela yeah and it's not talking about business and then in you make sure hot cooler or on other fruits i eighths are dumber what we're talking about is because her muslin costa brava when you're looking for a cup of which to bench you have to use wine again most posts can say that if the shaker is kamar medina right you can also use shaker for for benching because we say you could use a travel dollar certainly you can use it for for breakfast amazon half dollars mama sheltie of breakfast a muslin it's not even clear that it's a fee of so i just wanted to mention that that according to this gamar it sounds like you can only use wine to use a cup of wine for benching is not the same fear of like abdullah and if we pass can that five dollar you could use Hammar medina if there's no wine certainly for breakfast a muslim I'm just mentioning that Liholiho that if there's no wine most points can say to use Kamara Medina for benching as well if you're gonna use a cup prevention okay yeah well problems in social knowledge because Hamas and cough pays the pisacas he could use Kamara Medina of course it's better wine Tundra bonham if there's no if there's no wine yeah there's no 100 opponent a Makhachkala shaker another Bryson says don't make it a sham beer masoom rebel Ossipon of Shem Elam Romek action but in the name of your beloved the son of the persimmon he holds you couldn't make it a sham beer and the Bryce's says Matt MSE I in culture who after kiddush when you taste the wine you have to taste anything even culture even a little bit maybe I sleep are you who do I remember loyal lucuma no there bilasa holds you can make into some beer another how lucky is after you make kidness you have to taste the wine he says you could taste even a culture who would abuse Emory who died my Malloy in the lucuma not a call sure you have to put in wine which is Malloy Dogma means a cheek full of wine but chic full of wine means not that the whole mouth is filled with wine like this but that if you bring the wine to one side that Sheik will be filled with wine on one side that's what Molloy gloom of means if you bring them at the wine to one side of the mouth the entire cheek the entire cavity will be filled with liquid and this changes according to the size of every person's mouth but generally a regular mouth we say it's a little less than a reveals a reveals is between three and a half and five and a half ounces according to Luke I am naw it's between three and four ounces and this is the majority of a reveals which would mean a little more than two ounces according to the share of crime now that would be regularly Malloy illumos Amira Bruna my Rob Rob unison the name of Rob the paint on it up Kindle de manera Sh if giggle from a place called nourish oh so said I'm a cottage of a tamil elugu malayalam malavika if you made kiddush and you tasted a cheek full of wine you really kiddush if not you were not it's a knish how much you have to drink after kiddush how much you have to drink whatever you're making condition whether it's beer or wine Milou in the gloom of it has to be man if not Ramona taught in the name of Ralph you're not you're not yet sir yeah yeah yeah yeah you have to taste yeah when you make a Brock on wine whatever the Brock on wine is you taste a little bit of the wine by kid this she says it has to be Maloney looking off a cheek full of wine and I should say that the guy in him Hall that it has to be the makan dish himself like the Gemara says that the makan dish with tamil elugu malayalam but most of the pipes came including their arm right here says that if somebody else tasted it it's oh so good even if the one who made kiddush himself was not time so there's a big mark like to see how to tie to the Gemara Niraj mom says doesn't have to be the one who made kiddush anybody in the crowd can taste it and that would do the trick but the guy named hold that no kiddush is not like any other broca's kiddush the makka - himself is the one who has to taste from it these are these are the two shits Molloy look him off Molloy look Marissa taste yeah there was a third [ __ ] that you don't need one person to drink Molloy look him off but a few people could drink and together it should be Molloy looking off that's one [ __ ] all the three shits are brought into tomorrow the pile has its broad as the best is of the makan - himself drinks Molloy look him off but even if not even if other people drink Molloy look him off according to most [ __ ] - she was still urine if just one person not The Mikado drinks but the Ghanim don't agree on Rubin Africa my Instagram now from in the son of each hook said I'm not torn in la loi be idle by Menasha of a like a Doberman you Miele giggle stahma I have learned this Brice about the fact that you have to drink Molloy look him off to be odd sir not in the name of Goodell bar Menasha not in the name of Goodell barman you me because before we had it in the name of Gilda min Irish I heard in the name of giggle stop they just said Ruth giggle Frank tomorrow my knife came in oh who cares the answer is la mer mer the day of the day it's very relevant in Amara could we make a contradiction from one position on another position if we know which table Gadol it is everything is on file then we say what there's an inconsistency here he said this and then he said Dan and the two don't match but because it's triple star so don't bring me one quote and then an opposite quote because that could be two different of Godot so that's why it's relevant exactly which trig indels said what if in case we have a contradiction if it's a contradiction that's real or it's a contradiction that can easily be dismissed consistency the murmur the day of the day to refute from him on him the day from him add the day on him since we don't know which to begin two litters we can't question from one rib Kindle on another replicator because not the same person they don't have to people don't have to be consistent one person when it comes to a local or to be consistent in his views the Gemara now there's two dots in the camera goes on some alumina noose tickle we learnt in the mission at the opening mission that Erev Pesach some alumina close to the time of Mendelssohn you should not eat a meal until it gets dark we wanted the appetite to be intact for the Seder for eating matzah so we said summer Clemenza before Minister no meal until it gets dark drag the game re-boil ooh they asked a question some of them in signal attend on a Dilma Samuel Clemens atomic cloud which Minister we know there's two times from India in a theoretical sunrise in a day when sunrise is six o'clock just for simplistic illustrations we'll use such days in the next Soviet sunrise is six o'clock the end of six hours is 12 o'clock right 12:30 is minister Judeh Allah six and a half hours as Mandela why because that's the time when they would start offering the afternoon carbon Thamud that's called Minister God Allah a big man eliza called the big minister cuz the day is still big oh darn god but then this Minister Kitana Smallman because the day is very small and that happens nine and a half hours which means 3:30 and the reason is because you could bring the carbon Tommen at 12:30 but usually they would bring it and offer it at 3:30 and that's called - a katana when you say you now let heat Erev Pesach before Minister some equipment which Minister I might now let eat at 12:00 I mean I let eat at 3:00 big difference can I have a meal at 1:00 can I have a meal at 2:00 that's the big question it says some aluminum and the Gemara explains sawmill Amendola tonight the diminishment mean that you can't have a meal before men singular mission pacer because I'm afraid of the carbon pacer Dilma steel mmm sure it may be a gavel - Camille and you're gonna have a great time and it's gonna continue Vasily normal I'm a bad person and the person will not bring the carbon base he'll become so immersed in this meal my dilmer maybe some alumina Cataumet non the mission of mint you shouldn't have a meal before minutes a katana around three mission matter because of the motsi you gotta eat at night do more hace la misma Lamar Sahil Agha so I'm afraid you're gonna come and eat the matzah I feel a gas attila massive because it means a coarse type of eating which means no appetite no flavor because you're already satiated from your grand afternoon Erev Pesach meal so I'm worried primarily later in the afternoon minna minna katana and I should just say there's two ways of learning akela gasps aw one is the way Rashi and Raj bomb said it in the mission er that it just means it won't be with appetite because you're so full you know you're eating something your stomach is not empty and we wanted the Mitzvah should be done with enthusiasm with fervor lit a oven because of the Hitler Mitzvah you'll do the Mitzvah but it just won't be beautiful because you're not really interested there's another interpretation that toasters brings I feel agasa means that it's actually not cold eating there's two types of a hill Agha so one is I'm pretty full I can eat more but I'm I'm not interested there's no great taste there's another type of a Selig are so you're so stuffed that they eat more is actually disgusting and that's not called a HeLa for example um kipper if you eat till you have kipper so much that you're stuffed and then you eat on Yom Kippur it's not called the hailer it's not called the healer even if you eat a lot you don't get a nice icarus why it's not called the hill it's actually called Mazak you're damaging yourself and I'm eating you're destroying yourself so there's two ways have a learner actually Lagaan so one is I feel agasa you're gonna eat to the point that you're gonna be full and therefore you can eat the matzah but it won't be with a dish Marcus you're not that full you could still fill up more but it's just not with passion because you're full or I feel the gas actually means you won't be yo to the Mitzvah not only won't you do hinder me don't be late to the Mitzvah because you're so packed you know you know those failure after those meals mechanics ultimate right uh let me push it now to eat you're not doing the myth it's not called evening it's called damaging your stuffing your stuffing down food you know in a garbage can is that the shot is that the shot in no carbon pacer had to be done in the afternoon in the afternoon in the afternoon so what shot is it the car basil you could start doing right after the Talmud theoretically 12:30 from 12:30 you could do the carbon base after cuts ice yeah when you when you you're Potter from from chorus chorus yeah yeah yeah it's fascinating I'm Raveena Raveena said touch ma I'll bring you proof the browser says I feel oh I prefer sumela even Agrippa the King Agrippa was a Jewish King from the family of Hoarders from that from the dynasty of herders he was the king who experienced the cordon based on McNish in his day ii the struggling suckin me some medicine seven the app in his days and he was a fine man he was a fine man we have different stories about and he was a god-fearing man who rug a little bit a shoe choice he usually has his first meal beginning of the ninth hour of the day which again if sunrise is 9 o'clock at 6 o'clock he would have his meal at - after - his first meal 2 p.m. even he I say I admire your collection Tasha even a gripper a griefer shouldn't eat Erev Pesach that day until it gets dark little history during the time of the Gemara they would have two meals a day not three meals a day very important there was no breakfast lunch and dinner there were two meals a day one was by day and one was by night by day could be either morning or afternoon and then one in the evening that the morning meal was not uniform we learned before and a few days different people at different times of eating most people a pasar reveals char Revere's would mean again at sunrise at 6 o'clock with me 9 o'clock fourth hour right 7 is the beginning of the second our eight in the beginning of the third our nine is the beginning of the fourth hour that's when most would eat a Griffis would eat the ninth hour his first meal his first meal would be two o'clock interesting why it's not clear why why would he delays a king why would he fasts till two o'clock did it come because shave of him how nice and he wanted to Isis brings a theory to Isis bring the theory because Kings get up begin messiahs Kings get up three hours later that's why career schmuck can go three hours after the beginning of the day because Malakal my most arts and tell me the cumin would eat in the sixth hour and he behaved like coming they're coming and because by him he would get up the third hour so therefore he pushed off his meal two hours so it became the ninth hour but then typhus those first rejects that but in any case the price it says even he shouldn't eat Erev Pesach tiller get stock so ravenous I I'm red bush Lima Samuel Clemens eaten Aetna if the Mishnah meant you know and have a meal by McDonough high knew reversing that Rufus now I understand the finish of a Christmas that even though the Easter of eating only starts at 3:30 which is nine and a half hours nine and a half hours the end of nine hours and he starts eating already in the beginning of the ninth hour so that means when he starts eating you still allow to eat nonetheless you're saying even that grippers shouldn't eat because he knows that his meal is gonna go into the time that's forbidden la I'm with some of the militant on but if the prohibition is beginning from twelve o'clock my reversing the Griffis what's the finish that a Griffis is prohibited call Easter la mejora obviously he's now let it eat because the Easter is already calling him from the capsized which is before the time of his meal so why would you permit him to eat a meal I mean even though he didn't eat yet anything in the morning that's why he's allowed to eat after the time of the is sir has come the time of this year has come wake up early and eat backer if US so if the Easter starts at 12 o'clock why would be a hitter's that a Griffis would be allowed to eat if the issuer only starts at the end of the ninth hour meaning 3 o'clock then I could understand a Griffis would start his meal a little before let's say 2:30 accorded 2/3 right so you're sitting down to wash and you know that in 10 minutes and 15 minutes and 20 minutes yeah it's over so I can understand it's a kiddush what's the kiddush this is that he's now letting eat he stood there today because he knows it's gonna go into this amount of Easter I he didn't eat yet he didn't eat yet and he's starting before 3 o'clock right he's starting not at 3 starting 2:30 according to 3 to 15 whatever nonetheless he's now louder because he's continuing into the time of the issues he has the fast on her face that I understand is the kid is a big finish but here the Easter is starting at 12 why would you think a Griffis is not included in it it doesn't make sense that's what he says my arugula so let me cut ello some alumina katana katana so you have to say the Mishnah means before mins exam very much south-south might have boosted a Griffis still why did the bride steps make against the story with a Griffis a motto is - sooner before he finishes eating this man of the issue comes three o'clock does one of the sister comes why should he be exempt from Claudius aw we don't believe that anybody is above the law just because we don't say even that Griffis has to eat kosher even the Griffis has to have a say there you're a Jew you read you I don't care if you're a king nobody's above the law so why would what's ultimately the hit is why you're talking here about a green fuss that hip sees now let it eat even if it's McDonald why should I want to eat you're starting a meal 5 minutes before this money is so 10 minutes 20 minutes for this money is why would we allow this the Morris says I'll explain to you how the time I would think Taoiseach show you slug ruthless harbor show is loaded on dummy in terms of his inner biological clock for him to a clock is liked by us 9 o'clock his body is used to eating at 2 and used to eating in the evening your body develops an appetite based on its nature based on its internal biological clock just like when we eat mine o'clock in the morning area of pay so it's not a problem for the say there why our appetite is going to be intact as everybody knows even if you had a nice breakfast at nine o'clock in the morning Boracay Shem you'll be able to eat the matzo with appetite for a grievous two o'clock is like our nine to thirty is like our 9:30 the same thing because his his his biological clock is used to it and at night he eats dinner why does he eat dinner every night if he ate two o'clock why does he eat dinner the answer is cuz he gets hungry so maybe you would think for our grief us the system would change it wouldn't disturb so now I still wouldn't make a new religion we don't change halakha for every person oh you have a good appetite but since he's starting before 3:00 after understanding tomorrow if he would start after 3:00 we would have make an exception I can also say I'm gonna eat a meal at five o'clock and I have a good appetite right a lot of people can eat then eat the need unfortunately we don't change how long but since he's starting before three you're gonna allow it even though you know he's gonna continue because he's starting when it's motor and it's not gonna take away his appetite that's what we'd have thought this is the Harv I mean that's the have Amina Atossa come marshmallon the Brice's is naho even a Griffis who has Baruch Hashem a healthy appetite and eating a meal at a quarter to three even if it continues won't won't compromise the mitzvah of eating mats at night it won't be on appeal agasa whether we touch I feel agasa disgusting or a heel agasa is just not not enthusiastic still they didn't allow him to be over on this Easter you want to eat at two o'clock no problem with three o'clock you got a stop you want to eat a quarter to three but you only got 15 minutes eat even a Griffis I'm gonna be icy or other are going to some Arab I see we're gonna discuss right now I'm an ambassador bass he said this is only talking about a real meal does it really mean that four o'clock Arif basically now that I have anything since I've Ahmad bilhuber minotaur GameA a person can dip is food into various fruits and meat without bread in other words if it's not going to be a satiating meal a person is gonna eat a snack or eat fruit or eat even a little piece of meat we're not talking about eating a point thump to eat something if you sit down for a meal you're washing your washing now you're not washing on comets cuz it's Arif pacer you're not washing a matzo toys vez says you're washing on matzo Shira which you're not allowed or matzah shooter would mean matzah that's made with may Paris with with apples where you can't be yo to the mid so with that matzah that you're not allowed to do to sit down for a meal you know egg matzah but to eat some fruits or to eat some snack or to eat some bus or if it's not going to satiate you that that her comin did not prohibit they did not prohibit the question is what about commish's mean a dog and other grains if of course we're not to not to Muhammad's you know what he'd comets right yeah so many are many argue that that also would not be would not be allowed because it's a grain and that's where the cameras has only min a true gamer there was an argument about that there's an argument about that in in pie schema so the bossy says you're allowed to eat even in the afternoon foods that will not satiate you as long as you know it's not gonna take away your appetite in the evening the reason they use the lotion mat bill yeah yeah so rashly says something interesting Rashi says the fisherman calamari day table basically that was their euphemism for eating they always dipped so when they say dip that means eating that was their way of talking about eating that's what Rashi says they used to eat most of their foods through dipping ah so McCullough Leila's a no no Madeline a Philippa Maha interesting yeah that stung tables tomatillo was at a table repeat shocked my table will be our key rebukes hook used to eat vegetables on Arif pacer in the afternoon eat even after the time of minister summer Clemente we need vegetables Tonya Nami hockey which is a proof to this mimic that you could Tonya Nami huffy we learnt a price that supports this the price it tells us Arif pay Stephanie afternoon Hashanah SHhhh the waiter the servant Metabo bourbon Mei Yin he could dip his food in been a Mayan Bane Mayan are the intestines of the animals that they're shouting and they're using for the night meal for the pace of the Camille he can dip in it like he does a whole year whatever he's eating he's eating a vegetable he's eating a food he could dip in the kishka if it nice and low finish him and then he could give it to the guests for the meal the FOP Shangri la-de-da was a salad over we don't have a clear proof from a positive the prices but we have a we have some testimony to it shan mr the past success in year Mia Nehru lock em near vault is ul kotzen you got a plow the earth you got a plow the earth and make a photo in the earth and not to plant with thorns in other words if you want to have a successful planting you have to make sure to first plow the ground plow the earth so that could and take away the weeds and the thorns because if not nothing is going to grow well that's what the poster says and this is what the Bryce brings here to support this idea what's the connection with this bus like this could the connected the buzzer there's two ways of learning a trashy and there are shoe bomber ah she learns that basically the plastic is saying don't plant and nothing will grow well because you have thorns everywhere and you didn't plow the earth and then you won't benefit from your work you won't have Henault you can't tell us Amish work with food a whole air of paces and you can't eat anything it's just not fear you can't have a person to work and not enjoy it the enjoyment of ash Amish is that he could hop abyss in the middle right don't tell a guy who's working behind the restaurant the whole day and you now let it touch the food than if you tell you you know such restaurants very good they state they state yeah you can have a person harvest the field and not benefit it's just not fear you can't have him work without I'm not that's why the Shama SH can eat on their faces and use that meat in the kishka stew making a dish maka meal that's the interpretation of Rashi the Raja bomb gives a different interpretation and he says that basically when you plow the earth you make it fertile that it can absorb the seeds he says you have to eat a little bit in the afternoon to open up to open up the system to actually increase the appetite too much hunger is also not good even for the appetite you have to open up the system huh yeah so in other words it's not just uh allowed but it's a positive thing suddenly rebuked would use vets would eat vegetables it was a Hector it was actually he felt it was a positive thing that's a different interpretation but then Vinay ston the fineö RS him you would tie according to this you should give it to the guests so so let them have something it could be cooked could be cooked intestines yeah eating brings on the appetite yeah you're saying the usually was bread I guess in this case it wasn't bread so they would use vegetables or fruits yeah I guess vegetables you know like the carrots that the cucumbers you did FINA sesame seeds rather have a shot see camera cooler Milo yeah I'm at the Pisgah fascinating rather would drink wine a whole era facer a whole era of pace of y-k hatred the [ __ ] a little eBay he felt that drinking abundant wine Shriekers his appetite it arouses his appetite when you drink a little bit of wine and it actually satiating but he didn't drink a little bit it says cool in milah a whole day he would drink because he says he felt when you drink with with large quantities it actually opens up the appetite the nasal maps its fellow artists so you should be able to eat more matzah at night more maps at night in order for him to be able to eat more maps at night he drank more wine on Erev Pesach it's a Shiites it's a Shiites yeah am i Robert Robert said me not middle or the camera middle regard we did I learn this when did I learn that wine develops the Apple that what do they say develops the appetite it's what's the appetite we did I learn this how do I know this the tanana have a Mishnah i have a Mishnah doesn't say I learned to from experience he said I learnt it from a mission the Mishna says I'm some interesting Mishnah Bey narcosis halal ooh in rut siliceous Euston between the four cups of wine you can have a drink between the first cup in the second cup right we make the first cup we say kiddush the second cup is only at the end of saying the whole Haggadah between the first a second you could drink between the second and the third you can drink right we do the second cup and then we go washing and we do matzo Morrow carriers so scenario and then we're gonna bench you can drink in rutte solution you don't have to be initially reveal oh yes between the third and the fourth the third is been [ __ ] and then we start saying hallo and we finished the gud then we do the fourth cup over there you should not drink the e I'm with Missa Sayid if you believe that war wine just ACH you and takes away the appetite my sister why do they allow you to drink between cup one cup two and between copy two and cup three holomap sir I feel like a sir you're gonna eat the matzah you look guys so just like you said you now let me eat in the afternoon because to not to eliminate your appetite it's gonna cause you eating of matzah to be a course eating Elish mama no me Gregorio is Araya you drink enough wine don't worry it whets the appetite it doesn't ruin it and therefore there's absolutely no concern and that's where rather learnt that wine is good to drink to whet the appetite it doesn't go into this category of taking away your appetite yeah the appreciation of a Yosef botanical Molly I'm at the pizza the appreciations used to fast or hold the era of pace the exact opposite a whole day he would fast even in the morning even in the morning so the question is why no he would faster precious with fast a whole day and let's remember Maseca so from says that the program faster of Pesach soul yeah Naima reflecting tomorrow why name customer appreciation perhaps if she's holds that Psalm eliminated I'll attend an omission Pisco maybe the appreciation is holds when it says you know let me eat some Allah minister it means Minister God Allah which means 12 o'clock because of the carbon pacer Dilma mentioned wasallam normal I'm a vet pistol ho we're afraid that you may eat and be consumed by the feast and not do your carbon pacer and it's interesting rip say she's lived a long time after the [ __ ] based on McNish but the point is that they will miss akan it then and it didn't change even later because things that were done by the baser minutes we didn't change surely after the harbin that would be an interesting comment here now but here is one more vignette the sovereign lucky had the artificial variable Lhasa perhaps an obsession agrees with the view of the motion in a metabolizer masher hi mm Sarah map a structure chakra the chakras barbar ah sir lachemann omits safra's man piss who the cooler you I'm a causal epistle there is one view that holds that you could bring the carbon pacer from the morning one view most views hold only from 12:30 from after concise but there's one of you PEM serie used to mock beat kasia a pacer that you slaughtered in the morning of the 14th wish my wish mine means it has to be done for the further with intention for the person who's bringing in the pace because if it's not done for his intention then he wasn't yet sediments of carbon paste has to bring a new carbon paste it has to be done lish boy it has to be done with Schmo so from the morning as this man of pace the suburb him say to hold Boehner by a means been area of the s my lair of the hardener between the end of last night and the evening that's about to come Bain are by him is an interesting term we don't know what it means it means Bain are buying means between the two nights which two nights we translated most of us in halakhah we usually a bain are buying between the first era and the second what's the first the first is when the Sun starts dipping to the west after midday as the Sun starts dipping to the west of the horizon that's called Arif one night one evening one Arif to is when the Sun leaves the horizon which is basically sunset Bain our buyer means in the afternoon that's how we type in our mind then sail attached main harbour between last eras and the new area when was the last era right before dawn break when night ended what's the next era of the coming evening that's the time you macro the carbon pacer meaning that in the afternoon but throughout the whole day from morning till evening that's Boehner by between the two evenings meaning between the end of last evening which means right before dawn break let's say 5:00 in the morning right until the evening that's baby Seder if an obsession is holds like that so then when the analogy eat Arif pacer if you read if you page Minister Minister gala and he holds like them to save their carbon pacer cuz the whole day you know I need a whole day that's why he fasted but illogically think my says no no no no no no no need no need to do this I'm relying on oh it could be he hold that the mission that means Minister katana three o'clock shiny obsessions the Easterners however the precious was a delicate man a sensitive man his metabolism his body was sensitive Ito him bits are for a MIDI if he we'd if he would eat anything in the morning or till I have a man Eli McClure by night eating would do nothing for him it would just be a difficult task some people are with me Anna filagot sir some people food is difficult they eat a little bit and they're done you know you see it you see some people they can't eat more on the plate I'm striving to get to that moderator one day but I haven't hasn't been successful yet maybe if I juice for a few weeks about it huh you admire it yeah they eat and their body right away tells them more too much boom and they really don't they don't eat yeah I'm married into such a family or my brothers or sisters a mom a little food they're ready satiated they're nauseous and so forth yeah yeah yeah yeah depreciation was that type of person so that's why he fast it was a personal thing he knew to enjoy the say there he needs to fast Thomas asks even though there's no carbon pay stuck now so why would depreciate us be worried but I says the Easter of this man habius he holds would not be bottle twice vez says toaster says that la pila you're supposed to bring the carbon pay second the afternoon according to everybody because it says you're not supposed to be in the car Basin when those comets and comet starts in the afternoon so even if you heard the member sailor would agree that look how pale you have to bring the pace up in the afternoon when there's no comments but since but the evidence if you do it in the morning the precious would hold that you now wanna eat they not eat leave in the morning that's the Hartmann of the Gemara that's to have a min of the Gemara sake the Gemara was not gonna give Mario a feel ooh unease should be stroller your collection Yossef the mission is said even a poor man shouldn't eat until he reclines that's what the mission is said in the beginning of the period Itamar we learnt matt said Sarika saber what do you mean you have to recline when when you eat matzah you have to recline why do you have to recline because matzah we eat commemorating the freedom the Jews were expelled from Egypt and they didn't have time to bake to allow their dough to ferment right like his big butt circus so it commemorates liberation that's when you recline which is presented above the Royal aristocratic way of eating murder ain't Sarika saber why murder represents the subjugation not to freedom eat my wish major urban acumen and we learned the name of a black man sorry to say I'm sorry yeah and when it comes to wine intermission we have National Psoriasis saber replacement toward wine yes the intermission might have been after man ain't sorry to say but there were other students who said your document said you don't need a saving by one so the Marvel hopefully they're not arguing Hobbit Atticus Iike my habitat across a bus Roy one view was thrown with the first two cups one view was Tom at the last two cups and the Gemara says but we don't know what that means I'm really the high gear I'm a little high guess you can explain this in two opposite ways I'm real Elias you can explain it in one way tray casi como Ebola saber where the binoculars the first two cups need reclining you know why the hash to who the commercial of Harris because now is the time that our liberation is beginning when do you do the first two cups for kiddush and at the end of the Hagaddah that's when you're telling the story of ETS miss Ryan that's when you should recline but tray kasi bursaries the last two cups lipo was say but why might however it was we already we already spoke about UCS with Sam we left with Ryan we're good now you can just drink regularly regular in a regular fashion I mean la hagas those who say the exact opposite either up Trey Cosima celery boa saber the last to need a saber because I he cited the cavea status that's the time when you are already free Trey kasi Kimora Lee Boas say but I can t have other my you know karma her in the beginning you still have other very deep question whether you celebrate freedom when you're working on it or when it happened they're ready in many ways when you're working on it that's the first [ __ ] to the second to this is no that's when you're at Everett it's after your haters so what's the conclusion hash to did to my house convey to my hockey now that we have a paradox here what do we say IDI VD by a saber both need a saber the to life first two cups the last two cups of all four cups to be a saber because the obnoxious said something we're not clear what he said and therefore we do everything yeah second opinion no you still in slavery you go out now out of slavery to get out when you get out of it you can celebrate yeah practice very interesting what if I decide to lay down on my back you ever saw a person you bring the bed a cot you lay down Proctor leash mayor saber this is not a saber lying on the back or by the way on the stomach that's not called a saber has saber seemed in lush my saber has sabers you mean meaning if you do it on the ax men on the right side it's not a saber the classic reason for this is Brooklyn there a bomb because most people are righties and therefore from with my right if I'm reclining on the right I'm gonna bring the food with the left hand which is uncomfortable so therefore you should recline on your left side that's what the rash bomb teaches us Vallejo Oh Malloy I'd furthermore La Chambre yack Tim Connell of a shirt Rio Villa de sac on the food may enter the windpipe before the food pipe and the person could cross for some long soak who can endanger him Rashi says that this is referring to the practice when you're lying on your back and eating so then what happens is when you're lying on your back on eating so rashly is saying that can cause a danger because when you stretch backwards so what can happen is the epiglottis that the glottis is the the flap we have on the throat that protects the windpipe right so that when you're lying back that big lattice can open up and the food could come down the windpipe that's what Rashi explains Rashi says talking about practice when you're on your back Dhiraj mama says so why does the Gomorrah say it after the case of reclining on the right so he says it's talking about when you're reclining on the right when you're reclining the right he says that the two are near each other and it can open up the windpipe and the food could come down there it is problematic to understand this Raja bomb because as we know the food pipe is behind the windpipe right so it's hard to understand what the rush bomb means that that that it's on the right it's very hard to understand the food pipe is directly behind the windpipe directly behind so it's unclear it's not sure what there's bomb means when he says that that the esophagus that the that the food pipe is on the right side it's hard to understand what he meant but that's what the rush mom says rashly said it's talking about if it's backwards rush mom says that the statement is referring to when you recline on your right so he says that when you lead on the you will you lead up lean on the right it's a choking hazard that's what the rush bomber says now really the food pipe is directly behind it's behind the windpipe why did what does it arrive I mean when he says in the food papers on the right side it's hard to understand I saw that the art scroll says that there are animatic on and an anatomic there are differences in anatomy between the left side and the right side you know the right bronchus branches of the windpipe into the right lung at a far more gradual angle than the left one does into the left lung which might account for why leaning on the right side presents a choking hazard we're leaning on the left does not according to this even somebody who's left-handed and therefore each with his left hand should not recline on the right side because according to the Rajah bomb that would be a choking hazard ISA it's al baile y bar has sabor a woman in the presence of her husband doesn't need a saber the Mishima chuva he if she's a hush of a woman a prominent woman meaning if she's a royal woman through her saber she does she does she does need reclining now it's interesting that many texts of the Gomora take out the word aitsl baila just as ISA a woman doesn't need a saber without aitsl baila just a woman doesn't need in other words even if she's not married and the reason is because this was not the Darracq of women because it was not their way so therefore it's not it's not freeing for them but if she's Anushka shuva meaning if she always does it this way if that's how she does it then meter saber our gear sis has it's al baile specifically the presence and the presence of her husband but many gears has just says it's Tom doesn't need a say but any Isha and if she's an issue ver she just sure she needs a she needs a say she needs a saber and the Mordecai brings and it's brought in the point all the points come today that high um call Hashem Lacroix is her service all the women are called the kasha voice that's that that's what's brought in halakha all the women are called her service yet the way the Shannara carafe puts it in a tough iein bays a woman whether she's married she's a widow she's a divorcee doesn't need a saber cuz it's not the Derek of women to be masive it's not Harris for them they don't think it's exciting if she's a prominent woman and her Derick is to recline she needs it for Kohanim chillon Unni cries hushed voice all our women are called her service this comes from the murder hi Rob a New Jerusalem and they Rama Rama is relationship America Samantha fiim bass says this all our women are called car service nonetheless there are ma says the meaning is that women do not recline why if they're all cold her shoe voice today right why don't they recline and the answer is and this is very interesting because there is an opinion it's a very interesting opinion the Ravagers opinion that this man has ER there's no need to do any reclining all these gomorrah's completely are nullified today why they said today reclining is not a sign of Liberty a whole year huh you think it's inconvenient okay you say to do it by the mario based on this in other words even a whole year we don't recline right even the greatest kings and noblemen sit regularly so basically these rishonim it's deriving in the Rav your whole that there's no fee of a saber today cause it's not a derrick of graders today others argue others argue that since it was the Derek of Harris I would say Pesach was all about history and the past is the present so we still do it but since there's a [ __ ] today you don't have to so the women rely on that [ __ ] and they don't they don't they don't recline I never heard of that I never heard of that but there is this [ __ ] that they were Simas on the words of Ravi ah that you don't need a saber today you don't need a say but today but because there is such a [ __ ] there are many leniencies if somebody ate without his saber about doing it again as we will see there are lenient sees because there is that [ __ ] in halakhah it's not accepted by most posts cam but it's a shitty that's brought in a locker there are mob brings in about women that's why they don't have to do a saber in other words since women but cloud don't need a shape the only reason in our times they would have to is because they're called hasshu voice so because there's a [ __ ] to that nobody needs the same but they rely on that [ __ ] not to do her saber the main thing of this how loss is affirmed that all women are called hush overs the gomorrah says been eights are loved by her same a son by a father needs has saber a boil etomidate Sarabhai my what about atonement by the river does a talmud need a saber touch ma o meerabai abaya said calvin and may mark when we learned in the base marriage of the master robber Seguin on a burka da da dee we reclined on the knees of our friends you're basically sitting there you have ER and you reclined on his knees and you ate okay a sinner and labate abusive after Robert passed away and abusive became the Russia Shiva instead of robber armor Lonnie told us Lloyd sweetie sue every you don't need oh my robber Kamiyama freaky OVA says the or of your teacher is like the O of heaven and therefore in front of your teacher you're not moving a saber because there's a missile of Moira Rama which cancels out the mitzvah of a saber which is a certain form of uninhibited nough so you don't have to [Music] Mesa the price so they asked a question it says in the brycie my coil other mesa rifle etomidate's or a boy you should do a saber with everybody even a student by air ever the mother says caitanya he must surely Aiden ugly that Bryce is not talking about a teacher of Toyota it's talking about an apprentice by a carpenter Talmud by a rebus and apprentice by a carpenter and him you have to do is say but if you're sitting by the carpenter over that you don't say murder robbed of the camara chimerism I am and by the way the Gomorrah doesn't say it's talking about robbery she ain't no move like not your permanent data from here we learned that any Rebbe any Rebbe you don't do a saber of course ravish a muscle alkaloid Accord the muscle the forevers Merkel on his cover that's fine and then they could do a say but he's not obligated to be Merkel on his covered and they're not obligated to do a saber unless he says I want you to do a say man I forego my honor and everything but an apprentice by a carpenter you still have to do the saber imagine you sitting in front of a lab as it stars I was this I know I know he's doing it for matzo but it's it's a certain form of royalty in front of her abuse it with with with all with reverence with respect I said them and going to their a but they wouldn't sit down why sitting down is not a bad thing I'm just giving an example there's a certain form of respect father comes and you stand up was sitting is not bad but it's just a certain respect that you show says even the post can say that if you're sitting at a seder with the Talmud holcomb off little bit dirty right or unique tomahawk him in the generation even if you didn't learn anything from him he also don't do a saber just a certain huh well Obama should ever would do this aided by his father he wouldn't do a saber the year after his father passed away he didn't say that they did a saber the RAF could be Michael that's not a problem he doesn't have to he doesn't have to because the midst of my rear Abba doesn't get doesn't get pushed away he doesn't have to ya know because it's a Shamala cafeteria the robbers tell me there's a common so there's a limit from Toyota so it's stronger than a saber sabers only a fee of their opponent Tom wouldn't have come amiss that's a similar cafeteria I think that's why it's but it's learned from s yeah yeah and the Rambam brings it as one of the mitzvahs to be macabre Tommy there's a comma so that includes over ever that's why it doesn't take away from his saber it that's why it cancels the same unless the rav is Michael on his covered yeah a boy aloo they asked shaman my what about ash Amish a waiter does he have to do her saber tajmahal will be sharable AV Hamish uncle cos I is not sexual masive yot saw a shaman who eats a keziah smarter reclining fulfills his obligation what do we see from here masive in lime a Savoy smarmy na boy a saber mommy no we're sure ballet v says he needs a saber at least a Casillas matzah which by the way from here you learn that look at some of the myths women are most curious to recline by the whole meal it's just if you did a cos is matzah it's enough it's enough because usamos you can't make him recline the whole meal he's a waiter I mean he's not gonna be able to do his job but but the ever defeat so cuz are you smarter it's good so we already learned that matzah needs a saber that what kosis need a saber an interesting question is when you say matzah many posts can say it means the first cause is of Marx and also the afikomen but not everybody some say not now a climate well we try to do that with clayman we try to do the afikomen also have a wonderful day [Music]