Daily Gemarah - Friday, 22 Kislev, Nov 30 - Pesachim

the yeshiva dotnet so the Gemara asked a question if somebody rents a house on your Dollard do we assume that it's Bethesda's Bardock right that it's checked it was checked the night before and therefore you don't have to do it because comets or don't we assume that it's possessed cos but look that was the question Nasser of knocking by its hook the Gomorrah said that he said to them why don't you just ask and the answer of course was we can't ask they're not around so he wanted to prove from a Bryce that all the houses have a eskas but look why because we believe when it comes to beer comments we believe everybody even minors we believe them to say that there was Abdi can be or hummert's in this house why would we believe them usually they are Apostle a a this sort of natural basic wants to prove that what because it has a Cheska's bug because how I'll have a roommate so clickers comments when it comes to tickles comments we consider everybody to be zealous and meticulous and therefore we're not really relying on their testimony because we assume that all the bottom of our ask us boudic but the gomorrah says how do you know that's the case maybe the case is because of their testimony but then we say no it can't be because of their testimony because we don't accept their testimony so it's not their testimony it's because that's because mother but if that's the case the prices should have said not that everybody's believed of your comments but that all the bottom have asked us a Kazakh of being boudic so you have to say that what it's because of their testimony somehow we believe them because of their testimony which means you can actually prove the other way around that it's not because cause Bundick and that's why you need their testimony so that's actually what you could prove from here the exact opposite of where Barack was trying to prove so the Gomorrah says actually that is not a refutation of his position because you could say the bryce is talking about a situation where it's potestas not badhak because we know that the person traveled or the person was very overwhelmed and therefore we would never assume that it's bothered because it's very likely that it was not according to our perspective and it's their testimony that is being MacArthur's they say that we were my dick we are the ones who were by dick and the kiddush is we believe them in the reason we believe them is because it's only an obligation when there are modern because bitl would be enough manator and therefore they're abundant chose to believe them in something that is madeira abundant but therefore there's no proof from this Bryce one way or another way we could say all the bottom are Velasquez Murdock they are absolutely the haskers Budnick and the reason we need to believe these people in this situation is why because here there was cus cus ain't a buttock or we could say actually that all the bottom are not but has cos Murdock and and therefore we believe them it's not clear in the Gemara what the conclusion was the Gemara doesn't conclude because it was just a discussion about urban occupy its refuting the evidence that he brought from that Bryson just to summarize this the halacha Lamesa the way it's intial Honora in hill cos pacer simin Tov la med cement off la made Samantha Flom at Zion is and I'm going to read it to you the weight central Canora harav cement of lamin Zion somebody who rents a house of his friend on the 14th day or in middle of the night of you Dalit after the time when thickest commits his obligation began in other words after the time when the landlord should have and could have been by the Comets and you're not sure if he did it or not so if the landlord is in the city or his wife or his family you should ask them if they did because comments even though every Jew does because comets according to the obligation of the command every Jew has a husk ascaris every Jew we assumed to be kosher to do the right thing so look IRA it should be obvious that he dipped Dicky's comets nonetheless you're still obligated to ask and the reason is because throughout the year the house has a Kazakh that it has comments people use comments in their house now the Kazakh that he was boy dick is trying to take you away from the Kazakh that there's comets so therefore in such a situation you don't rely on the Kazakh in a place where you can ascertain it in other words it's not just you hazaki that it's badhak the Kazakh David's body is trying to eliminate the first Kazakh that there's comments there now you're not sure that this comments but there's a has occurred in his comments you're not sure he did because coming within Kazakh did because comments one Kazakh is fighting another Kazakh right we assumed his comments we assumed there's no comments both are clear assumptions there was comments and we assume now there's no comments in such a situation you try to bheemavaram if there's nobody in the city so you can't ascertain what happened last night because the landlord is not there his wife are not home they traveled or whatever the situation is then you rely on the Kazakh and the halacha is in tarantula Honora that it's kaskus but the key rely on the Kazakh and you do not have to do Vedika however what you do is you do bittle bitl you do because that's what you need minute ira right so you do bitl but you don't have to do but it can you rely that the mosque you didn't even though he may have not done predict the tempted his mind you can do a bit over talkie before this man ever faced us in the morning after this man of Dicker's comments after this manner because comets the middle of the night yeah yeah if he has family in the city even though we know that the landlord was not Voytek but one of his family members says that he was boy that even an avid a slave or a miner again a miner who has das a miner who has a form of coherent recognition or his wife any of them we believe them and you don't have to do another Pittacus comets even though you know for sure the landlord was invited because they say we were burned that again this is what the gomorrah says clearly because because comment says my opponent so therefore we believe that now it's important to emphasize what the price can say this is all if the site of the renter was Novato all the Comets in the rooms that he rented he was Movado all the comets but if he was not Movado or for example he gets the house after midday when you can't beam avato so now he can't rely anymore on this previous hector that it's only madeira bonham why because since there was no bitl now but it can become has been our toyota because you're not gonna be unboxing i'm moving two o'clock in the afternoon I don't know if the guy was by dick his child says yeah yeah I did knickers comments the reason I could believe the child is why because it's all him in there a boner but here it's not me there abundant anymore here would be me not Toyota said therefore I would have to do as the renter I would have to do dick in all the rooms where men have tired I have to do be dick and this is Colin as us and and this this would be the case because I cannot do Biddle tomorrow is talking about only in a case where there is there is little let's see now ya know we assume that it's Jessica's buttock if we know for sure that he was invited for example the landlord just doesn't live here he's not in town then we could rely on anybody who was made that there was thickest Commons you understand we assume that it's buttock but what if we know that it was not verdict the guys away so then have to be bite it but what if somebody there's a child who says I did because comets he's a ten-year-old boy 11 year old boy right a nine year old boy I could rely on I could trust them why because Nicholas comment says they're abundant so their abundance said you could believe because little is enough it was enough to take you away from the issue of by a robber you might say so this is even a cotton you a believer and according to toy service not shame and avoid them also not shame as well even though you always believe them even in history Tyra whenever they have the ability to fix up the Easter for example the NIDA who says that she was Toyo right of course she believed even though it's an Indian of Tyra in dealing with a question of need of Korus as we said cheetah Nick or true miss Maestas nonetheless the way Torres explains from the you shall me because comets is such a tisha it requires so much effort and there's so much pressure very often they'll do a little bigger and they will feel that it was sufficient and therefore the harkaman will only trust it in a case where you only need it to deviate from because then even if they're wrong okay you didn't violate a Toyota prohibition because it's so difficult to do again we're not thinking saying the is going to lie as I emphasized but she will she might not be as zealous and as meticulous she has all the pressures in the house because comets is really a big Terrica Nicholas comets is really a big Terry you gotta get down and go to the Hiram and there's docum remember they didn't have vacuum cleaners then and they didn't have the mechanisms that we have in order to clean everything was a real real big terror and therefore it has to be Madeira Bannen in order to believe not Shamanov awesome even though we always believe them and anything if they have the ability to to take control over okay I don't think so by the way estamos I saw somebody more a comment on this year and the website and even that net or one of the so somebody sent a comment that the luck is that a king you also don't take us in a this amela so it's not because you mistreated my life I can't understand they were in you know you certain you don't put the king into the arena of it was a very it was a very interesting idea now I was bringing either the pasola aid this is not because we say their lawyers or their with their image sure their babies or or we have to keep them stuck in the basement and lock the door etc you know on the contrary Imelda Theo so don't bring one of us without my look we don't respect we don't believe in Melek we think the king is a liar the King has no respect for carrots I'm possible akamalik after fear the king of the respect the king it's it's it's in order to it's because of the dignity of the king so we treat our women as kings so therefore they don't go as ate this Queens yes ah yeah I don't know I never I was never in the position but I'm sure it's also pressure yeah okay now we focus on the statement that the Gomorrah really said there is a Gotham or just said it in passing but it's really a fundamental idea in the homeless activist Arkham that made the rice and a bit Obama Sangha the mana Tara Bittle is sufficient and we do not need anything else but bittleman and therefore bleeker's commences marijuana so we saw in Rashi right we saw in Rashi yesterday take a look in the ration let's just read it the submissive Alexis Navarro wash bus and the LaVey ash masa Rashi says that the proof for Bittle comes from the word ash be sued the trailer could have said to vara which means eliminate right through her tumor every minarets which Patti BRT a Kurdish Mina bias etc it says - be sue which means there's another alternative to physical extermination or obliteration of comets which is that the Comets ceases to be not through a physical mechanism and as Rashi says hosh possible a it's a mental a mental mechanism as well actually puts it under mm at all of you divert your minds from it and you consider it and they clear it internally mentally as afar meaning as useless as futile as the dust in your house and that is sufficient to extricate yourself from the Israel by Arab or matzo which is really a fascinating concept as we explained in the beginning of soccer when we learned Iran a Jew is in his house it's 11:59 a.m. on Arif pacer your house is filled with comets you stand up and it takes you two and a half seconds to say that this comet is off are worthless meaningless I'm not interested in it I don't need it I don't want it I have no connection to it for me it means absolutely nothing it's as precious as the grain of sand or or a piece of grain of Dalia a particle of dust in my home and you're good to go and the comment is there you're not even out on by a row not on value might say you were McIntosh Ebisu Rashi says you owe me vato and you're good to go it's only the Cohanim who said that's not a sufficient and we have to do because because how much which the Gomorrah doesn't say here the reason why that was discussed enough Bayes but that's what the Gomorrah clearly introduces here so that's what title actually is my Kaddish from the word hush should be so well you raw you shouldn't see and you shouldn't have and while you might say [Music] cuz it's not comets it's considered offer for you it's not comments it's not bread that's what I should be sue says - Basu means it ceases to be because in your mind it's not bread yeah babe it'll buy Alma babe it'll bowel me you see it's right in the middle of the page that dollar limit base you seem a bit Obama yeah so Ashley says the substantive issue by the way if you open up a homage and you look at the targum uncle is there a mega translation of the word touch me so he says - VAT l'm targum onkelos which is the authorized Aramaic and true light translation of how much that was written shortly after the destruction of the second base i make - the targa my uncle is right under where - basu on the first day - Basu is Tuvok lon you should be Moffat all right he doesn't say to burn to destroy to be mavet all homage wasn't mean to be move Apple comments it's a form of nullification as we're actually says that is internal not physically nullifying it or burning it or destroying it or even casting it away but rather what in your mind your ma Vatel your move out all the comments now let's see what Isis has to say about this and here we are introduced to a major argument between Russia and anti-surface how we tied the idea of little you see me derisive little bomber soggy it's the second Taurus under of dollar amid base socked ice Vesperia Sh'ma countries Rashi says pillars but containers Rashi told us mythix if - Basu for like sifter Varro Alma Hodge possible a V that's rushing it should have said to Varro which means get rid of it doesn't test ashes Basu what does - be so mean it's make it into a massive of Shabbos it should cease like chávez's is cease right there's a pasta can Hamish valois Sarvis Mela may al bristle Akasha you should not eliminate salt from every carbon every carbonate to have salt Lesage bismillah right you should not - this is a state where the Comets ceases but not through physical physical activity so rashly says from here you see there's something called hash possible life the cautionary this interpretation in the Gemara is difficult to remain on its hook the high hash busta have re it's clear that this hash basa touch basu means burning it Malloy beetle and not something you do in your heart it's not something you do internally why I'll tell you why later the next daft of hay which we'll get to soon base Russia the Gemara asks a very big question it says in the posit FBI hari shine touch the bottom on the first day you should eliminate comets from your house what is the first day we would all say it's the first day of Pesach yet that's not when we do be your hummus we do beer comets a day before pace Arab pacer it's before the first time the question is why does it try to say on the first day so the Casal brought different proofs that the first day doesn't mean the first day pace it means the day before pacer which is going to be soon the next sugar of Gomorrah is gonna be that how did we get from Pesach to Erev Pesach when the Torah says do it the first day which would mean Pesach so we have a lot of proofs one of the proofs is the time you brush my tin we learnt in the Gemara da fermo days rebbi akiva rebbi akiva says ain't sorry you don't need look it's like in a vibrant ain't sorry you don't need any other proofs there's different proofs that are brought there in the Gemara that you burn comets the day before peso you don't need all these proofs why so Rebecca says hi ray you I'm ER the passage says FBI marushin Tosh B so you should eliminate the comments on the first day and rebbi akiva says who Madsen who love or is she of Malacca but making a fire is a nav melaka it's one of the 39 forbidden categories that you're not supposed to do on Shabbos or on Yom Tov Cerebus Kiba says how could my yahoo should mean the first day of pace are you now letting make a fire on the first day of Pesach to burn your comets so it must be that your Mauritian doesn't mean the first day of Pesach because that's yump if it has to be Arif pace this is Ruby a key was proof again listen clearly don't tune out aqua by marushin touch business I remember take a means on the first day Ruby a Cuban says you should burn comets but how could you bring comets on Yom Tov you now want to make a fire on Yom Tov we'll get there but the point here is you're not making a fire to cook you're making a fire to burn hummus so rabii Akiba says you're not gonna make a fire on yom tov it's an avi locker so how can the Turner would tell you to do this or the trainers contradicting itself here it says do not let him make a fire and suddenly it says he make a fire so Rebecca Kiba says obviously you have to interpret your marushin as Erev Yom Tov what do we see from this Gamora what does Tosh be so mean touch bristle means burning have aura so it's clearly contradicts Rashi rabbi akiva clearly says in the more attention Vincent means have our and that's his proof you can do it on your teeth because it's a knife Malaga if it's such possible Avis not enough Malaga so this is proof that Rashi his interpretation of touch base was erroneous Veidt more the touch be so I mean on the come on we're gonna learn soon in the Gemara about touch Basu that ah he liked by your Imahara sharing means Erev Pesach but when in the morning no from the word Ark only on the first day the camera is gonna show that we split the day in half and Theresa was only from midday meaning mache show us Allah my Allah from six hours from the end of six hours and further when it says asked by my reach and touch me so it doesn't mean Pesach it means Arif peso but when an Irish paisa I feel like it's a middle of the day we're going to learn how we figure that out then it's a middle of day not the beginning of the day in other words touch these two begins when midday Erev Pesach that's when there's a mitzvah of touch me so at the end of six hours from Shia Islam Allah if the day begins at 6:00 a.m. just for practical except for a clear illustration the day begins 6:00 a.m. so six to seven is the end of one hour seven is the end of one hour eleven is the end of five hours right seven eight nine ten eleven twelve o'clock 11:59 is the end of six hours 12:01 begins the seventh hour that's what touch Basu means that's the time when touch me so apply tomorrow is going to derive that clearly from the Taira that's one touch me so applause yeah fractal is a key leg show me she show you Scylla Milam so when it starts to be so after six hours the a Kairos oodle mi honey beetle and after the time of the easter you can do bit tool anymore so how could rashly say tosh p su means bittle when is the time of Tosh basu time of Tosh Basu is 12 o'clock p.m. 12 o'clock p.m. and I want to do bitl anymore because we learned a mega marts gonna explain it later that the only time you could do bitl comets is when you still own the comments after 12 o'clock the comments is not yours anymore to be my battle because you know that eat it anymore you know lettuce salad you know what a benefit from it the only time we could do bittle comets is Erev Pesach till 12 o'clock once 12 o'clock hits you can't do bittle anymore so Rashi says how can you say Tosh whistle means little if you say - Basu means B or it means to burn the comments to physically destroy the comments then you do it 12 o'clock FBI memories shine touch pieces remember tiesm when it comes Erev Pesach at the end of che show you seem a very comments but loiter ashy that I should be su means what bittle the hot Lopez everybody holds you now that I do bit could you put the cell phones on vibrate please but if you say that there should be some means bittle not beer so how could you say that the time of Tosh Basu is when I asked by your immigration midday you now let it do bit till then anymore you're only a lot of do bit though before this man of a sir so this is a major major problem how could rashly say touch me somethings bit too when the camera is gonna give a time that touch be soo is till she shows such Brits who begins after change tires and after tracer is he now gonna do Bittle bit was only something you could do earlier in the morning so touch me sooo can't mean bit though because there should be so has a time and that time in our I do touch P so according to Rashi so it's a funny thing quote there actually the tyre is saying at this time you should do touch bit so it means bit ly can do - bit so that so it must mean the touch be so doesn't mean little means beer vo you could do 12 o'clock 12 o'clock p.m. arrow pace if you go you destroy the Comets but I tell you that's perfect but bittle you can't do that you can only do earlier than that so these are the two major issues that exercise with Rashi number one Derby I keep a clearly set touch missile means burning and that's three how he proves it can be unarmed tip and number two if there's business bittle we have a major problem because FBI mission touch missile refers to error face of midday and then you can't do bitl Erev Pesach midday what can you make a fire of course that trivia key was proof that by marushin is not pay so it's error of pesos then you can make a fire you understand but the second question is asked teaches us that it's not in the morning it's in middle of the day for the middle of the day you can't do brittle anymore cuz 12 o'clock bit tool is done that it's dead end little has a time once you hit 12 o'clock you can do brittle anymore bittle you can only do before this manner is or not after this manner is so because it's not yours to be my bottle beer you could do Rashi bitl you could do before 12 but it says touch me so what is the time of touch missile ask me I'm aeration midday but midday you can't do bittle anymore but the Gomorrah will explain that after means at 12 o'clock at the end of six hours that's when there is our obligation of touch missile but how could that mean bittle when you can't do bit to that time so then it's not the time it says occupy Mauritian is at the end of six hours and that's when you do touch miss so that's a clear posture can commish FBI marushin means midday of era of pace of hindu touch missile so how cutters Bisou mean little when you can't do bittleman it has to mean physical destruction of comments which you're allowed to do at that time that's the big big problem here in Russia huge question we do bitl after we burn the comets yes before yes you never wait till 12 o'clock you can do bit laughter words there's no bit laughter words you can do Bittle 12:1 - there's no bittle anymore you could do beer you have to do beer if you have how much but you can't do Bittle it was done finished from then until after pace if you can do little bit till you can only do before this man of the is er right so this - Bisou is this at the end of che show you say can be middle because you can do bitl that well i Marie so therefore he has a completely different interpretation limited I seem a bit Obama soggy the reason the Gemara says diminutive bittle is enough is me tom they may after shibito have 1/2 curvy yacht summer shows Bittle is actually the concept of Hefner it's making it ownerless and once you're more vital it became ownerless and it left your issues but mela motor and then you can have it in your house me the calm linen since we're gonna learn later that the passage says Loyola how come it's so we learn out shall Harriet era you can't see your own comets have a lot Harish la caída Michel Guevara but you could see comets of other people and comments that belongs to heaven commerce that belongs to the base of each dish so therefore the moment you make the Comets ownerless the moment you declare your comets half care that is what bittle means bittle does not mean hash Basu believed Bittle means it's me Tom Hef care you make the Comets ownerless once you don't own the Comets it may be in your house but it's not yours and the issue of comets is Laura look ha you now let us see your hummus shall call yet today I would like to Roya shall I hate him you could see other people's comments or Heritage's cummins you could see ownerless Commerce Clause doesn't belong to you that's why bittle helps me not Ida Rashi says bittle helps because there's a Dean - Basu and - miso is a hidden that is a way of getting rid of comets through bittle toys vs. no it's part of the regular generic concept of half game bitl is a concept of Hefner bitl means you nullified what do you nullify you nullify your relationship to it your ownership of it your my vital to come it doesn't mean you move battle physically the Komets it means you nullify your connection to it I don't own this anymore it's like I say this is healthcare and anybody can take it and then minute order you could leave the comments in your house a whole Pesach and you're not or even I'm by your oh you're not over number you might say why because it's not your comments shall call you today about literary we're talking about you don't need a posture should be so for this you don't need a plastic for it it's half care it's Africa there should be some means to physically burn it - Basu means to physically burn it so how do we know that you're at a doob it'll wash it because the traitor says you now let us see your own comments but if it's half cure it's not your comment so maybe that's how we know bittle Bittle as part of the genre called half care in a locker becomes half grand therefore it's not your hummus yeah why why do you do bitl you make it after you make anomalous bitl is making the hum it's Africa have a half kiveat some officials say he doesn't want it to touch me so you'll how to make something half care you let him make you watch Africa touch pistol means burn the Comets however if before this man you make it half care it's not yours you know if the Burnet I don't the burden I don't have to burn comets that I don't own I have to go and define all the summits in New York City and Rockland County and Burnett's I have to burn my comets touch me so means burn your comments what happens if before this man of the Easter it's not yours because he made it half cur your bet so when there I submit about my saga means what I mean I try to you don't have to do dhikr and often do beer why make it heavier and it's not yours i'ts in your house it's not mine so sorry after their military took the way if you didn't do bittle then you got to do touch missy you gotta get rid of the comics it's not yours and if it's cause it's yours because it's and if once this man of the Easter comes you can do bittle anymore it's not yours to be mascar I can be masking your house I can take your suit and say it's ownerless it's not mine I could be masking my suit not your suit that's why after this man of the issue you can do bittle it's not yours no we in our gnosis we do bittle twice we'll soon see why but we do bittle twice but same thing the same thing well we say when our bit will we say if i know about it if i don't know what i see what i don't see why you move at lit after you burn it no no you beam about all the comments that you're not burning the how much you're burning you're good let's say in your house is a sticker mark up a bottle of marsh can they didn't find so you move out to let your mouth curat technically if you get rid of all your dick and all your beer you're good but but the how come him said even if you do dhikr be you should do bittle gomorrah says later and evolved because shamayim is a glossary offer maybe your dhikr wasn't so good and you're gonna find this to combat the middle of face right and you'll find there's tickle comets and you may delay five minutes of burning it and those five minutes you're over I'm by your Abba you might say because you have comets in but if you move ah too late it wasn't yours so unit is a bottle of mash can you under your couch I don't kits not mine so toys first learns bitl matam pefki yeah yes yes the deadline is 11:59 the Gomora just said minute ID you don't need because comets you could do only bitl bittle is enough and that's it 11:59 you could get up and be Movado your comets and you're good to go for pacer biblically that's it ah how do I know that from so there's a McCoy Kakashi toasters Rashi says from the word Tosh Bisou Bisou means bittle believe that's why it doesn't say too viral that's what it is and Torah says absolutely not that's not the choice because Tosh Basu means burning right anti Swiss the second question is what touch Basu is when 12 o'clock and 12 o'clock he can do bit though so ty Swiss Miss su means what burning so what does bittle mean had I nominate or you could do bit though because bittle means you make it ownerless and the easter of comets is only your Comets and therefore if you do bittle before this man of the issue you make it ownerless you can have it in your house minute Ida oh so now let's take a look the hard time remembering it Dharam the cameras in the Dharam have given a choice have casted me in front of three people and when you move Apple the comments there's no Holika they have do it in front of three people answers the toe Swiss made a rice saying sorry I mean not tighter you don't need three people to do a skirt you can even do it yourself and even in your heart and here we're talking about midnight writer we're talking about a ricer something that Tyra even if your own heart you make the Comets ownerless right there's no three people observing it I mean hot toierate still have care so Melia won't be overrun by a raw you matzo the ha ha Meem came and said we don't rely on this we are obligating you also to do - Basu which is checking for the comments and of course exterminating physically burning physically burning the comments no I mean that Tyra this is good yes yes yes yes you could do it on the comments right your mouth kiddo how much do you have what did you ask yes yes yes yeah maybe not today he says been a traitor twice which says you don't need me so they can do various conditions we have about Africa that it's believed that between various missions we have about half kisses when I told all these conditions are not necessary and that's why when it comes to comments when I trader the bitter will be sufficient that's what ties first learns so tell you doesn't have a specific I should be superb it'll you don't need a passage but there should be so that is a special concept of middle according to Rashi little comments ups a special thing quarantine is just regular half Chris is making an ownerless and it happens to me that the trader shows us from the words layer at all a car that you're a comedy now let us see what other people's comments you wanna see so if I'm ownerless comments in my house I am good to go after cuts ice you can't make it ownerless you have to do touch B so you have to physically destroy the comments by cuts ice bitl you can only do before this man huh yes sir Mathias comets is the comments that unibeam a battle it's two separate things yeah Mathias comets means if you have a whole refrigerator in the basement filled with comets or filled with bottles of vodka right you're not being Moffett all their comments are you really really huh you sold it and sold it if you sold it units not used to be Madeline's belongs to the Gentile you understand you're not burning it the comment said you need they can be or want you to be your comments on that comments let's say your move at alert right first of all you're not move on to it you really don't want it okay ah so what that's a partial what you're saying because a person like that according to Rashi hash possible avi fossa you have to really mean it that it's offer if not it's ash ash that was one of the rounds explanations why the her comment didn't rely on bittle because it could be not believe Shalom the bitl may not be believed Shalom and then you have a problem okay that's number one number two the very fact that you're selling it means you consider it valuable you don't sell the dust in your house to a Gentile that means the very fact that you're selling it means that you don't believe in bitl here it's not bottle you don't sell things that are bottle you sell things that have substance and value okay a third point is remember the hum and don't rely only on bittle they make you do batik and beer so evens considering you did bittle and all that Mashka you still have to destroy it right how could you get away with not eliminating it from your house burn it or throw it away what's the answer to that how do you get away how do people get away with having comments in their house sealing it off because it's not yours because you sold it before to a Gentile so that's why it's essential because the fact that you did bitl first of all I'm telling you the bittle is not a real Bittle here but even if it would be it wouldn't be enough you understand what I'm saying it wouldn't be enough metal means a lot ah the missing this comets that you're selling is not the common team of Apple two separate things the come is that you sell you're not being the vital thing these are on you have to be honest about it when we do bit till we say right called Chimaera become Mia yeah the bottle larvae have Khafre the iris as valueless as of it's not as valueless is offer maybe on a doughnut fine on a piece of Pete's on a bagel on a shower yeah and that's why the whole concept of selling started matira materia has to happen before this man of the is sir just like Mittal just like you can't make an ownerless after 12 because it's not yours you can't sell it after 12 because it's not yours you know whatever not from it it has to happen 11:59 the matira or actually mean there are born on its earlier I mean not Toyota would have to be 11:59 the rabbi's did it an hour earlier so 10:59 yes by the time what no not necessarily people do be or 8:00 in the morning 9:00 in the morning Commons has not sold yet how do you sell comments what you burnt your not selling of course not well if you sell it it definitely could sit on alert the sale takes place before this mana issue yeah you're not saying coke Amir on the comment that you're selling the Inca beer should see that's going to be mine they can be should see shoe see that's gonna remain in Myra shoes when the Easter comes of course that's gonna main am Irish roost when the Easter comes so I want to be move out on their comments yeah but if it's not Cole c'mere c'mere the Inca beerus you see it's in my domain it's my authority it's my property it's my comets and there's gonna be Colin Easter on this so I'm saying now it's half gets got for the IRA ok what did you want to ask but this man of touch be sues after cuts always that's the cash of choice is what do you want to ask a person may want to buy the Comets back after pacer but it could still be a legal sale because the Gentile is not being coerced I may sell you a house because I need the cash right and in a year I want to buy it back from you ok and if you're my friend I may trust you but it's the legal I could sell you my house get the money right you may want to hold on to it I rely on you I trust you you're a good guy you're a favorite you'll sell it back to me but nobody's gonna say it's not a legal sale you don't know for sure the guy says no you're not it's completely irrelevant to legalities I may have a best friend and I sell him the house for a month because it's not supposed to be under my name is it called legal or not of course it's legal okay so that's the details of how rabbis do it there's a mice so they say and hungry yes well he's gonna have to pay he's gonna have to pay a lot a lot of money he's gonna have to be he did pay already he gives usually whatever time uh-huh a deposit let's say $20 $100 whatever it is five dollars and the rest is it's like a down payment and now he owns the rest of the money if he wants to keep it no problem just pay all the money yeah there's a mice that happen once in Hungary in a shtetl the rough sold all the comets of the oil of the Pakula and by the say the middle of the Seder at night the Gentile worked into the Seder and he said rabbi I told my wife what happened and she said you're crazy Jews it's very difficult to deal with them and and and they're gonna delay you a cup and and this is this is crazy and you should have never done it and and you don't and he said they're putting a lot of pressure I retract this wholesale and that's it give me back my money whenever I gave you and I'm giving you back the Komets the middle of the Seder the middle of the Seder they were holding over there by choice a Moscow and it was a huge say there and it comes to the Rabi said I regret everything the sale was done but I regret it please we have to redo it I don't want this I made a mistake so the whole crowd went crazy buddy what are you gonna do now right it was assailed with a good sale it's like I come back to you six hours later give me back the car I'll give you back the money this was a crazy deal but here it's not just a car it's a whole stock it's all stirred so there up there up so the rough says ok I understand I understand the concern because because so many people were involved okay give me eight days give me eight days those eight days hold on to it okay I'm gonna make a meeting and I'll convince everybody I will convince everybody to retract the sale and you can trust me it's gonna work but does give me eight days trust me and then we'll come back and we could undo it that if you still want he said fine cousin to hate and he left to say there and all was good I say that South Manya am ice now now I know he didn't poke he didn't pull out he wanted to pull out so the rabbi said in eight days we'll pull it no problem I just need a half since I did it with the whole city so I just need to meet all the people it's gonna take me a few days to get everybody together and then what no no no you sign after Pesach after Pesach you buy it back you give him back his deposit and there's no loan anymore there's no down payment if he may know that you're gonna come back after Pesach who's he already using him for 69 years because he knows of course he knows so you understand it's very important understand the Comets Yuma Vatel you're not selling it has to be honest the comet stream of Atholl you're not selling after the Irish dust it's worthless I'm a safe - I'm not interested it's heavier let's say it's half care and then I'm selling half care to separate it on them it's two separately no no he has to know what's happening it's it's it's it's it's an acquisition yes to know what's happening and that's why that's why mysterious comets is more serious than a lot of people imagine because it's the Comets that you weren't Movado so if you don't if it's not a good sale if it's not a good sale at least according some argue with this but according to many the ballot Anya was had as a whole country's mysterious comments he was very cautious about this that if it's not a good sale how logically you're over done by your own by your matzo minatoya so it's a crazy thing people don't realize in my refrigerator in the basement is frozen pizza or Cheerios you weren't move on too late because I'm selling it to you for a thousand bucks that's called bit full you sell dust those two four thousand dollars don't lie right so it may lie wasn't and I yes dick you on it or beer on it they in the refrigerator so what happens my comets I didn't sell it so that's why so it has a big enough come in if you say that the comments that you sell is not bottle so this there's a lot of discussion about this but it's not such a push to think okay perhaps interesting interesting but now I want to say ah yeah to sale yeah okay how we do the king in will discuss at a later point because that's intricate how we do the Kenyan different things that were instituted in the King in the console you are of karbolyn will get to that base rush em get in the sugar of selling the comments so now let's understand this the question of toy service is looking a very big question on Raschi how Rashi learns this light a very powerful question that if if if you don't realize how powerful the question is that you didn't understand the question because it's a very serious question on Russia so I'm gonna tell you one of the explanations that's found in the Minister Skinner the minister Skinner says of course a commentary on the safer action earth which is an encyclopedia of all the 613 mitzvot written by Rob Yosef Bava that's called min casino he passed away in the early 1900s 1920s release valve Aden is safer minhas penis mitzvahs essay tests he offers the following explanation to explain the argument of Rashi anti-stress and what he says is there's two ways of defining the mitzvah of touch we saw two completely different ways one is come vas a and one is cheval tossa meaning one way of understanding it is that you do touch missile through an act and the way of understanding Taj basu is that you fulfill the mitzvot through a passive through a passive through a inactivity but it's still fulfilling the mitzvot let's give an example two examples sits us how do you fulfill the midst of senses if you have a garment that has four corners and you want to put it on you're obligated to first put sensors on it and then when you put it on you did the mid sum of tsatsis right we put on a tower so we put on sensors we make a broker all Mitzvah tsatsis or less active but sits is whatever is what happens if I don't have a garment that has four corners and I don't wear it I'm not obligated to which senses the obligation of sits assist if you have a garment that has four corners you need scissors we put on since at school who want to fulfill the Mitzvah because if I'm not gonna wear a garment the four corners I'm not gonna have a sin but I'm not gonna fulfill the Mitzvah the only way I could fulfill the middle of synthesis by having a garment with four corners like a Tallis or a towel is cotton or anything that has focused putting on senses I'm wearing it and then I can do the midst of senses nobody's gonna say if you don't wear it sits as you're doing a sin that's not true there's no Easter not to wit census right you don't have to wait census there's an insert to wear for garment while corner of for garments without census but there's no is sir not to wear it at all or not have census but there's no issue but I want to do the mitzvot I still not getting the mitzvot I want to do the mitzvot right and because I want to do the midst I make sure to we're a garment with four corners and put on sensors so here the mitzvahs congas say you have to go and do it if you don't do anything if you sit on your couch and you don't do it you're not gonna be macadam in substance but now there's there another Mitzvah so Mitzvah and Shabbos well by Yuri Mari Tish boys you have to rest on Shabbos that's a capacitive commandment you're now going to do work on Shabbos we have the rest of them how do you do that mitzvah of resting on Shabbos by not doing melaka by not doing melaka and others by doing nothing by being passive i fulfill a mitzvah so say of tishbite by being passive i can't fulfill the mitzvot it's us if I'm tired I'm not gonna fulfill that I have to get the garment and put it off but by being passive I fulfill the mitzvot sesay of shoppers cache miss so which category does it go into is it like census or is it like Shabbos let me give you a simple example let's say I'm on a gluten-free diet a whole year no bread no grain goes into my house my house is a place where there's absolutely no comments huh okay so no oats either no spelt no rye nowhere of course come it's free completely and four years so there's no comments in my house nobody walks into my house etc okay so now when it comes era of Pesach I have nothing to do I can't do boudicca's comments cuz it's not a place with those comments I don't need dick I have no beer comments I don't own comments I'm now let it eat it I'm not I don't have it okay so comes Arif pace I have nothing to do I have nothing to do nobody ker no beer no Bittle no sell in comments I don't own any comments not liquid and not food I don't also have beer comets I'm I'm acai in the midst of Tosh be so or not am i overrun by Yoruba you might say of course not I don't have comments but I'm I'm a guy in the midst of touch me so what do you think what do you think I'm I'm a guy in the midst of - be so I did nothing but I'm I'm a crime - be so or not or you say listen you're a good guy but you didn't to touch me so just like if you don't have a garment - four corners you're a good guy you're not sitting we didn't do tenses you didn't get the minister of senses oh I'm a crime that should be so or not it's not so Pasha what do you say depends how you define touch me so if you define the midst of touch be so as an action I didn't do anything I don't have comments the burn I'm sorry if there's bees so means you got to do something I didn't do anything I just sat on my couch I didn't get a sin I don't have comets no by your own know about you might say but I also didn't touch missile but if you say - be sue is like shabbos what do you do what do you have to do to get the mitzvot resting on Shabbos nothing so maybe touch means to me is like Shabbos that what the mitzvah is you shouldn't have comments that's the Mitzvah how do you do the mitzvot by not having comments the fact that you don't have comments all year great are you McKay in touch with you through an act Kumba say like going to buy a garment and four corners and senses and if you don't do it you don't get a sin but you don't have a mitzvah of census or you make I am the Mitzvah through Sheva al-hasa in other words is Tosh Bisou an obligation for an activity or is it an obligation for a certain state which is passive that you can achieve through activity of through passivity if you have come it's you have to get rid of it and if you don't have comments you still make I'm Dutch Bisou Bisou is not you have to do an act of touch base ooh that should be so is there has to be the result of the Act which is the hermit's should be mush bus there should not be comments by you that's the Mitzvah how do you not have comments by you if you have it you have to get rid of it if you don't have it you got to do nothing so what does touch be so it's touch me so an act go be mosh pits comments and if you don't have comments then maybe you should go by comets if you want to do touch me so and if not you're not my kind touch me sue or we say no - be sue is a mitzvah not to destroy comets the Mitzvah is that the Comets should be mush bus it's the result of destroy comets I want you should be comets free is the mitzvah to get rid of comets or is the mitzvah to be comets free what's the difference if the midst is to get rid of comments then if you have a comments free how did he do the mitzvot not why because the mitzvah is to get rid of comets but if the mitzvah is to be comets free right so then did you do the mitzvot yeah cuz you come it's free no sign but it's much more swish coos okay fine so Mela - come in what would be the difference practically what do you think would be the difference practically between the two I'm calling to both you're not supposed to have comments right we know that what's the difference if you say Tosh Basu is a mitzvah for an activity or touch me so is the result of the activity that your house should be hum it's free what would be the naff demeanor so this is actually would be an extreme example than the Minister Skinner says and it's even see it's a little humorous if you say that this was an activity he says if you want to do touch this so you gotta go by comments gotta go by comets acquire it and get rid of it it's not you're a good guy but you didn't do touch me so you weren't everybody so you have to go by comets another interesting example would be lets say it's Erev Pesach in the morning right and I'm about to burn comets and somebody grabs it for me and throws it into the fire in other words he grabbed the mitzvah away from me and he did it instead of me the hollow confession wish but is he owes me a penalty he has to pay me back somebody caps away my Mitzvah let's say Keesha Adam to cover the blood of the high or the chicken he has to pay me cuz he grabbed away my mitzvah says Dementors goodness a guy who grabs my comments and throws identify those heroes he owe me a class because he took away the mitzvot no what do you think the answer to that is depends if the Mitzvah is what's the activity he hopped away my Mitzvah but if the Mitzvah is not to have comments he didn't happen way by mitzvot he just did the preparations for the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is not an act the Mitzvah is a state and I don't have comments I did the mix work she didn't have to weigh the mid so for me he actually helped me yeah it's like he went to the store to get the asterik he didn't take away my mitzvot he helped me he prepared the Mitzvah because the Mitzvah is not to get rid of comments the Mitzvah is what not to have comments the Mitzvah says he's not and he helped me she's gonna take away the Mitzvah he doesn't owe me a class take a look in Christian mission pay base closure mission with Simmons shinpei Daisy he'll have the details he hop away check the chicken yeah somebody comes back up iris takes the earth covers the blood I want the mitzvot they have to pay you so the mrs. Kim says does the guy have to pay me cuz he burnt my comets he has my helmet right he helps my comments he loves fires or maybe he doesn't have his own comets and he comes my comets that would be another another another difference a third difference would be very interesting let's say I have comets right before pacer and I eat it I eat the Comets I'm now allowed oh but I do was iMac I'm touch missile if the Mitzvah remember mitzvah Baba Vera you don't fulfill the mitzvot even the Mitzvah of touch missile is what the act of destroying it in other words eating it one of the ways it's mitzvah baba very and I will need comets now you did it too late but if the mid-south - minsu is what not to have it I was told my kind touch miss so I don't have it how okay yeah wasn't a good way to do it but it's a separate thing because the midst of itself didn't happen through that way with two separate things that various eating it and the Mitzvah is not having it so you still be become the Mitzvah but there's one more difference between the two and that has to do with time if it's a mitzvah of conv say right so usually such mitzvahs have a time for example suka has a time seven days lulav has a time seven days Chanukah has a time eight days McCrea Magilla has a time Purim shallow cabanas any Mitzvah you do right sixes has a time during the day not during the night you don't do misses at night children has a time during the day not during the night not Shabbos not jumped off that should be soup would have a time the tire is telling you to do something it usually gives you a time you don't do something 24 hours a day seven days a week 365 days a year you don't blow show for seven days a week every Mitzvah that's Congress a sphere assignment right it has a time 49 days at night chauffeur has a Seana everything mats as a time verifies clematis you don't make somebody do an activity seven days a week 24 hours a day 365 times a year so cumbias a has a time when the trader usually prescribed it if the midsummer touch Bisou is not an act but rather not to have comments so here you have a big difference if you say Taj Ibiza was an act so then you could say probably the trader gave a time for it if touch Basu is not to have comments right so then the answer take defender ah she becomes very clear choice was held that touch Basu was an act rash she held the mitzvah was a passive one boom Mela the time of Taj Basu is at the end of six hours but what is the Mitzvah if the Mitzvah is an act that means at the end of six hours you have to do Thursday so what if the Mitzvah is not an act of mitzvah is passive so at the end of six hours you don't have to do that you pursue you just have to be in a state of - miss so sober Mela Lloyd Rashi Teresa could mean what bittle are you can do Bittle at the end of six hours I don't care if you don't the bit left the end of six hours you're not make I am - - at the end of six hours by doing something you're my client I should be sue by not having comments if you did bitl in the morning 12 o'clock do you have comments no it's confer adhara so maybe you will my client touch me so at the end of six hours I at the end of six hours you can't do bit though I don't care you're not McCann touch business through an acumen kind touch Basu through the fact that you don't have comments you did bit tool in the morning you don't have comments now so you might I'm touch miss but if you say touch me sue is an act so when the Toyota gives a time you have to do something how can it be bitter you know let a doob it'll then you're calling the beer so light toys first etosha resource converse a so it can't be Bittle why can't it be bittle because at the end of six hours you can to be clean that's the time of the Mitzvah so you have to do beer but like thrashing it's also the time of the Mitzvah but what is the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is not to have hummus at the end of six hours right what do you do not to have come it's whatever you do I don't care three months ago you did bittle I don't care three months ago you did beer I don't care because the Mitzvah now is not to have that's how you fulfill the mitzvot I don't care for a whole year you don't have comets I don't care if the last 60 years you didn't have comments if you don't have comets in your house you did touch me so how do you not have comments in your house whatever it is touch Basu could mean bittle when is the bittle the bittle is before this man of a sir because the Mitzvah him moosh was very mad how do you make few bits of comets according to Ashleigh Whittle some Mela according to this the typhus and Ashleigh the reason is such an argument says the man whose chemical it's two different ways of how to understand what the mitzvah of tar should be sewers if the midst of Tosh missiles converse a or the midst of Tosh Mishima came through several thousand meaning through passivity okay this is divorced with a minute the skin of the mistress essay tests have a wonderful Shabbos a Fralick and Chanukah I'm away next week of a simcha and the she is going to resume after Chanukah Tuesday yeah Tuesday morning bays are assembling either afraid look at Chanukah to you and your family but Claudia strong are getting Shabbos our Shabbos schedule is regular she Orem yeah yes happy I must be yeah yeah yeah yeah this class is brought to you by the yeshiva dotnet please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate