Daf Yomi Zevachim Daf 9 by R' Eli Stefansky

[Music] Thank you for coming. We're just recording the shar a day earlier. We're actually going to give this exact shar tomorrow on rash cuz we the daf never stops. We learn every single day. Some of you are going to be here twice in a row. Thank you for being here on this is a huge thing to come on. Uh just to show you the schedule tomorrow at 3:30 this exact shar minus the uh digital stuff going to be here at 3:30 dest following that is going to be a shar in Hebrew on daf there will be here after the Hebrew shar with tash. So this probably you could do if you're coming just for the English here be fish here but it's hard to find even a river or anything like that. I don't know what does and m y is regular 9:30 and 10:30 and then there's going to be another shear at 11:30. Okay. Uh we do have to uh move quickly but I do want to show you here. I got I received a a text from Kobe. a famous uh TV personality/radio personality. He's pretty famous. He actually came to the Hebrew uh the Hebrew Shabbaton two weeks ago and he gave everybody set of in the room. So he says, "Rabbi and I want to thank you." And uh he goes on to this whole thing how I had a great year and uh I wish you a great year, myself a great year and I'm a person who gets emotional very quickly which I don't know if I I'll share with you a little bit of the Hebrew what he sent me. And he says this is the first time my life I'm doing a mikra and that I was able to do something for a full year straight. Uh sir, I was accepted upon myself not to talk during kadesh. I'm going to try really hard to stand with that cababala. Thank you that you're in my life. Happy sweet year. That's what he writes to me. So I wrote to him. I I asked him if I could repeat it, if I could show it. So he says, "Listen, probably it's not the best idea, but if it's going to help another person come to Tyra, the answer is yes." And then he sends me this. He sends me the it's a voice note. And in the voice note, he cries in the beginning. So I cut that out. I don't know if we'll a little bit. I'll explain it. I just want to show you when he chokes out. [Music] Okay. So what he's saying is his spouse he has a friend for 15 years and he went to visit him. The guy does kosher program in Austria. So we went to the hotel and the guy noticed that between when everybody goes for coffee and then cake and whatever he was sitting learning he turned on the sh put his earphones and started learning. He says if Kobe did that you didn't push me. I saw it on the status. I saw you said the sh but you didn't tell me to do the shir. That's what your life is about. You're serious and I want to do it also. to the point that this guy started a remote location in so the point is a very very strong point that you don't know what kind of effect you have on somebody else without talking to them. Somebody sees you learning. Somebody sees you opening up a when you're in line in the bank, in the bakery, whatever it is, you're serious. You don't know who walked by, saw you, and said, "You know what? That's a good idea. I'm also going to do when I wait in line. I'm also" And the guy, not only that, not only does he do the daff, but he opened up a remote location, which is difficult, you know, to man it and to be there. Now he's a he's fully into the dus. Somebody did something on the side saying this because if you're that guy that says I saw Grieman, what's his first name again? >> U Grieman Shabas, which turns out it was his son. He walked over to him during kades and said, "Wait, he said it very nice. I noticed it. I don't know who else noticed it. I'm sure somebody else noticed it." People see and then people say, "You know what? It's not a bad idea. Maybe we won't talk during he's doing it. I'll do it. You have you have ashba on other people like you don't even know. He was so emotional when he said it. He was mish crying. You didn't know. You didn't know that. And sometimes you'll never know. That's the thing. Sometimes you'll never know that you're mashia on somebody else. You had the influence on another person and then ask you know this guy's your this guy's your tal he does the xyz because of you. He learned from you how to give it daka. He learned from you how to do this etc etc. Okay. We're going to skip the rest of the emails. We're going to go right into the DA. So, we're holding on the bottom of the B. Again, I want to thank the it's a tremendous thing that people come here on Y on Y. All jokes aside, I know there you come to get away from the cleaning in the house and helping your wife. It's not like that. I know it's it is difficult and I appreciate it. last line similar to the question that we asked earlier. We're discussing if you have a carbon pes that's before pes let's say a month before pes like I showed the video of the guy going to the mikdash on he has to bring his carbon pes then learns no matter what if you think that it's you think that it's a whatever you think it is it's going to flip into ask the why say if you took this car and you turned it into let's say you said it's a a should be a why does it turn What are you trying to do? So, we're going to go step by step, but let's say he took a carbon p and said it should be that doesn't work. It could only turn a sponsor. >> Oh, how do you know that? >> I was thinking maybe. Is he really? >> Yeah. >> What a nudikar. You got to do this to us. We're getting away without the sponsors. Yeah, by memory of I just had to do that to Mark because I I worked on myself this year. I didn't insult anybody during like right before the end of the year. One insult. Hi Mark. sponsored by capital in our friends and takalis father jacked coly for London from London southern business. >> It's 5:30. He's in Phoenix. 5:30 in the morning right now. >> Oh, it's 5:30 in the morning. Wow. What time is it in? Uh so is that it said he's the only one on online monthly sponsors TCS Israel power talking save Aron Gler in honor of the marriage of my son and my daughter and my relocating to Eden gardens in Orlando Florida from London also >> yeah a lot of people online >> there's a lot oh they're starting to come on >> look at that monthly sponsors you in honor of my father's sixth tag your big heart and giving to the community is inspiration for all of us Rivka and Dr. Aram Ebstein, pray for a complete and speedy recovery for Dr. Harold Goldmire. >> It's Rafy's day. >> I know what's going on. >> I don't know. >> We can't talk about it. HIPPA. Tell me afterwards. Sheldon D. He just lost his wife uh a month ago. >> Wow. >> 50 people on Zoom. >> 50 people on Zoom. Wow. Ye may have and may have a speedy not for a year full of daily family auri ai may today's learning be forces and thank you to stfansky for filled with maz. Thank you for this to honestly donate on the first day of the year. Daily spans anonymous wishing 10 star another year of you inspire us all with a so here's the question. Let me just show you this list for a second. Why not show it to you anyways in a minute we're talking about carbon pes you had in mind one of these carbonas over here turns automatically into asking why whatever you think of that's what it should be you thought it's on the right side let it be on the right side no what you we're talking about a pes obviously you're supposed to eat it now you're supposed to eat it you're not supposed to leave open one little What is it called? I'm looking for morsel. But uh how do you say um Okay, whatever. >> Crumb. That's what I meant. Yeah, it doesn't work with meat, but one crumb. So, you can't make I don't get it. Even you get to eat a little bit of it. Part of it goes on, part of it goes to answer your radical but can't you cannot take a which not everybody could eat. I rather make it into where everybody could eat it. Oh is on the list on the left. You cannot take a a carbon pes which is also on the left and make it into from the list on the right which is the severe the heavy duty carbonas. These are serious carbonas can only eat them in the mikdash etc. A lot of alas that are very you can only eat a one one night one day. The other ones are lighter. The ones on the right are heavy weights. So you cannot you can't mix the two. is a lightweight. Lightweight does not become a heavyweight. Great. Very interesting name. So now we're going to go through basically almost entire list on the right. Very good. I accept. You got me. You cannot make it because that's what making iter. So we're going to start from the bottom, work our way up. What's micer? Micer is a person has a bunch of new newborn animals. He puts them in a pen and he counts them as they come out. When he gets to number 10, we have a very interesting number 10. I didn't pay attention. I wasn't going to watch the whole thing, but during the year she also number 10 came out. Very funny. Not exactly sure. Guess it's part of a sug. It's an elephant. I don't know what it is. Elephant sheep. Great. Back in the day, I remember we had some funny suga like a mud animal comes out. So this guy has a carbon pesh. He says to himself, "I want this carbon pes to be the 10th meer. Is it the 10th?" No, I want it to be that. So I got to tell you there's a famous misa I looked it up today again so I didn't I couldn't find the the version that I'm familiar with like 90% the end there's one piece that I was looking for I couldn't find was walking on Russash and he sees the guys from yeshiva coming back from Tash all excited says guys come come to the I got to talk to the pen gets up. He says there something called me. He describes to them put all these animals in the pen and they come out one by one and the 10th one gets a a red thing. He said in Yiddish gets a red a red streak. He says the 10th the 10th sheep has no idea he has a red thing on him. And even if he did, he doesn't know what it is. What does it mean? It means in in just a few hours they're going to take him up to your line. By the way, m behem is like sheni. What's my sheni? We take 10%, we give it to ourselves. We bring it up to your we same thing with animals. 10% of all animals you bring up to your you eat it as a steak. Great. says, "If this sheep knew what's about to happen to him, he would run into a river, wash himself off, he would rub his back until it went off. But he has no clue." He says, "We have no clue. The imams don't have a clue." Sitting, everybody thinks that we're not part of that group of people that get sick. We're not part of the people that die early. We're not. Those are the neighbors, the the other people, not us. How many people we know that are young in our shar alone in the the Hebrew shar? We have a guy that lives in Abi Kamyansski's building a few floors above him. He's 14 15 years old. He has the maka going through treatments and this and that the whole did he know last last no had he known had his father known it would have been a different dying completely been crying and screaming erase that red the right to pass him says how many right to pass him do we have and we don't even know about it how do we know we'd act a lot differently the part that I remember is I that I didn't see but maybe somebody will find it that he scream of veno There's like a whole they're crying. Okay. Right. The passive obvious on purpose. We don't know cuz if we knew then it wouldn't be but that's the we got to feel it like pretend it is says. Okay. So you took your your PES and you made it into a micer new. So So what did you accomplish? Nothing. It's the same. It went from Per. So what's the difference? There is a difference. So what's the difference? It's interesting how the Gmorra injects like these little here there. Hopefully we get a much better understanding of when Msiah comes what we're going to do with these carbonas. Schlam, you need to bring wine with it. We learned the other day is a zahar. It's an ava. It's a sheep. It's also a cow. Remember we learned in rash. You start repeating this that maybe we'll get a better muslam. We have to bring wine. No wine. If you try to sell it over here, you go means to sell. If you're going to try to sell it to somebody, you sell it, you're going to get malus not says, "Your carbon pes cannot become a micer. Only this one is nothing else. Okay, great. You got rid of the one on the bottom." What if he took this and said it's I want this to bear. Super interesting. It's not a it's the fifth one. He his mother had five other ones before him. No, I wanted to have the the same idea of a again if it's you don't have to bring wine. If it's a you don't get to eat it like you have to give it to the says I have a says and by it says so now I learn from so we just established that does not apply to carbon so too doesn't apply to carbon says I think this is super fascinating to me what's tomorrow? We've been learning about tumor over and over here and there. Everybody MDY knows tomorrow number one thing. What is it? I I designated this animal as a carbon. Then I found a fatter better carbon. I said this is not the the carbon anymore. This is the new carbon transfer the duch. So has both of them are over is not doing that over has one carbon. I want it to be I want it to be the the of it should be like a should be like a what did he accomplish he's going to get malus for it because it says don't do tomorrow you can't sell it you can't redeem it says in the par you can't do it on a curb It doesn't work in a car. So what do we have left in the list here? We're not going to address Nazer. We're going to go to the last one called he took a pes before pes comes along and he says to himself I wanted to be a carbon. Uh the guy he came off a airplane he he came off the river. He came out of jail. He's saying I want this. I don't have money right now. I want this carbon pes to be my carbon. What do you gain by it? So he said it now you're going to have to bring 40 loaves of bread with that carbon pes you brought this as a carbon. You don't bring 40 breads and if you mess up and you do you bring it early so you're gonna have to bring 40 breads. Is it possible that what what is it now? We said a current that you do any other carbon what does it become? >> Anybody needs wine? So how's that possible? If it's current basil there's no wine. Now all of a sudden you need wine. She says he can borrow. Uh yeah, sorry about but how can you all of a sudden add wine to carbon where before you didn't need it says this is what I meant when a gets lost. Yeah. So this we have over and over this idea any carbon that gets lost and you replace it. So let's talk about a carbon. You had a carbon t you're going to bring to the base of and it ran away. So you go ahead and you buy another carbon tidal and then you find you sh the the second one and then you find the first one. What do you do the second one doesn't require bread. You bring it as a carbon but you don't bring bread with it. The first one bread second one not so says that's the question. The replacement of the original doesn't require bread. But the replacement meaning the carbon you switched into does require bread. Impossible. And therefore a carbon cannot turn into aid. So in case you're watching this now, you're on Zoom and you're I don't know Marshazzi or anybody in the room. So you probably know I don't have the best filter. I work on myself but it's not it's not uh not there yet far. So over the year I did insult a bunch of people here and there and I'm asking from all those people the ones I know about the ones I don't know about and uh some do it on purpose you know like when a guy makes noise in the room I have to you know come on but they get insulted they know they come to the lines then over here it's dangerous I need and also I'm going to ask for me I need the should be Smoother year this year no uh dig all these side things that could take me away from learning help easy name Benus only two what's your name you have a whole >> No you have two name right the double name is >> I think basically everybody just one except for one >> you did >> I think I think the ask was into one for it was okay I heard like no Don't do two names. >> Yeah. Which one do you do? Two names. >> Really? Oh, yeah. Cuz you had your girlfriend. >> Everybody's named after somebody, but it just worked out that way. >> Got it. >> Mark says Michael. Michael. >> It keeps going and going to Michael's like him out of bed at 2 in the morning and telling him, "No, no, I'm not ready yet. Go back to sleep. Come back in half hour. Where did you get this whole? It says in the and we decided means a carbon that use a flack of sheep which is a carbon pes. Guess what? There's another carbon that it could be. Maybe talking about asham. You had a asham that you decided to turn into something else which you also bring from the from the it's a flack of sheep. And then what? So if you turn to something else, it automatically should turn into just like you just said by you try to do it. You try to make a carbon turn. So you try to make it turn you could use a goat and a sheep. But he can't use goats only sheep. So it's not in the flock. It's not all over you. You say that the word in the comes to exclude stuff. So Rashi says I'll give you a bunch of examples. He says from means he can't use an animal that was done to it or if somebody did to the animal comes to somebody what's an animal somebody said this is designated as anara that doesn't work can't use that as a carbon in other words. It's a it's a it's a it's a what I said before what was the word I used? It's a limitation over here all of a sudden using it. No, over here we're also using it as uh limitation that cannot be older than 2 years old and it cannot be a female. It must be a male under two years old. So talking this is talking about the puzz with a sheep and a goat. We already know that a carbon is what? No these brings down doesn't say both of them in this one. The next one is the is the next one >> two. Okay, fine. I see. Both. >> Got it. Two separate. But the point is that these we know already that a carbon pes is a is a is a sheep is a goat. So why is it repeated? Obviously we're not talking about here. By the way, they discuss this. This I thought is interesting because that's not the first thing that came. What do you say Rabbi Rabbi Schoberg? If a cipher writes by mistake instead of he writes KZV or instead of KV like in this P he writes Kev is kosher or not kosher what you say not kosher. So those who say it's kosher because it doesn't change the meaning of the word. Kev and Kev are the same word. I thought it's a pillow also. Right. Okay. As long as I'm not crazy like well I might be but not there's not a good what >> they say that like I've been taking after >> you don't have to take out another safe if it doesn't change the the meaning of the word mean >> you hear that one Dave >> I'm saying you can't use it then it's kosher it's not kosher >> here just hold this on the side by you then give it to me after the share please so Okay. Um I see starting the emails are starting to come in now like >> No, I I don't get them direct. I get them from Shimmy. >> He goes through them and I don't know where he is. I think he might be in America. I haven't seen him in a while. Is Shimmy in America? >> Yeah. >> So by him it's what time in America? >> He's like it's all theiffs and everything. Okay. says, "Did it ring again?" >> Stop. Okay, good. Okay, we said already. No, we need these for something else. Look at interesting. It says, so they probably change it on the side. >> They wrote >> Yeah, you have to change it to It's funny cuz when I read it in Hebrew, I wasn't paying attention. I wrote I said kev and they all screamed. So like oh they thought I did it on purpose. I'll just say I didn't I didn't pay attention to look at the okay here. You you should be mac of this part. So Rabbi Weissfish sent me this. You see the right and the left the two different animals. They're hanging on their legs. That's the tail of a sheep on the right. And the one on the left is the tail of a goat. says orv comes to include the the tail as well that you have to take the aliyah and put it on the misb says that it includes other stuff not just that part includes all the way down you cut it down to the to the to the kidney the rabbi, excuse me. Comes to include a carbon pes that's already more than 2 years old. And anytime a carbon pes turns into it, you have to do all the what? You have to lean on it with all your weight. We have to bring we have a new one. Here's that over here. No tray anymore. And the co puts his hands under the isl. I don't I I hope that's the right way. I got confused. Is the isl under the meat or the coin under the meat? I don't know. >> Yeah, that's what I said last time. What's this? I'm just thinking. [Music] >> Oh, that's pigle. I shot in the wrong place. But since we're not going to show [Music] Okay. So, that's piggle thinking about that you're going to eat it after the lot of time. So, he's showing that it went through the winter, through this. I didn't see this yet. So, that's why. Okay, that's tomorrow. We're not going to get there today. I don't think you want to see this. The person thinks to himself the first one was is this you don't get carus and this the first one's called piggle. You think the wrong time and this is the wrong place. If it's a asham, you must eat it inside the azara and this is outside of the azara. [Music] Yum yum. >> Yum. Yum. Huh? You're getting hungry. Wait for tonight. All right. stops. You don't have to put the tail of the goat on the says you're telling me that when you have a carbon pitch into something you try to switch into another carbon in other words oh no we're talking about now that the the animal became more than 2 years old no good I have another positive tells me it's no good. In fact, bring two more. That's no good. Okay. Which is really goes on and I learned from this more than that. I have another source. I have leftover. In other words, I try to make a another animal into another carbon, it turns into why say cattle. We know that a carbon cannot be from cattle. It can only be from goats and sheep. We had this Russia before that turns into because something that turns that could be cattle, could be sheep, could be could be. The problem is why do we need three sources for the same thing? Loc one of them is the worst of the worst. It's older than 2 years old and it's past Passover. You like that? It's past PES. So it has two. It's too old and too late. You also have something that's in between or let's go to the other side. It doesn't have either. It's before Pes and it's a year and a half old just he had in mind that it should be an oil and they have something in between. What's the in between that is one out of the two problems. It's it's older than one and a half years old but it's not Pes it's it's it's uh Yeah, it's not P. Is that the second one? No, it's Yes, it's past. It's only one and a half years old. It's not two yet, but it's past. So let's see inside first words has writers it's more it's after it's more than two years old it's after it's the right age it's one and a half years old it's already too late what can you do with something like that what can you do with an animal that's one and a half years old but it's after pes use it for This one is perfect. It's right before it's not even two years old. The problem is that for another animal, so it turns into all three because only say one have the worst case scenario. It's more than two years old and it's past. This guy's completely out of the parish of but what if it's after but it's not too old it's only year and a half not two years old yet it's good for maybe it doesn't become it says these two at the end of the day something got pushed off here nothing went wrong with it it's still less than 2 years old and it's not even yet physically bringing it for but you messed up with the shouldn't flip into turning on the sponsored by global specialist in international financial services anonymous is anonymous in the in support of that all tests should come back 100% healthy for me and my family >> made another seriously interesting name I don't think it's anywhere in sh is the name of mal. So let's just do a very quick we learned that if somebody has a carbon kas and he in and the kay instead of thinking that this carbon kus which is fora for fat the messed up and said it's for the blood it's good they're very similar they're both in the same so he messed up in the thought it's good what if he thinks to himself that instead of this carbon should be for fat that it's for a carbon of what does that mean? Why did he bring a carbon? He didn't do he didn't sin. So why is he bringing a carbon? >> What the first one? >> It was the first one. It was in a da for the B mikdash for the brand new Mishka. But it's not because he sinned. So maybe if I take a carbon that comes for a sin and I think to myself that's not for a carbon that's for sin. It's for another type of carbon. Maybe it should it should be bad. It's not a good carbon. When is it good when I take two the same instead of it goes for but for sins over here it started off as a sin and it went for an no good. He says, "No, which is what I would call this aes he went from that's for to by the way it's all it's just the ones the the brought for the inauguration of the mikdash. There's a very interesting p in because we're talking about the inauguration and when there's the the so there's certain aus or things that you're not supposed to be doing. Hashem said it's okay today. It's good. Like by they ate on it's okay. Hem said there's a I thought is very interesting that might apply also to shing. What does it mean? What does it mean? It's a beautiful saying. It's I'm eating the here. Oh, has to do with I'm eating the honey together with the yari, together with the forest, together with the wood, together with the bed, however you want to translate yari. And they explain it's literally like a and a where from the side. Women also have the same exact thing. But when you get married, don't tell me you didn't have this. Everybody has this. You get married and all of a sudden, like two years later, 3 years later, 3 hours later, whatever it is, all of a sudden, what did I just do? Like, I didn't notice this. She was always like this that I'm not saying this. The say this. It's the it's the excitement that a has with a and he he overlooks the cuz everybody has flaws and you overlook the flaws but then when you settle in all of a sudden like wow I didn't notice this flaw. So on the he overlooked the flaws there are no flaws you're eating it's not not today we're getting married it's the beginning of the year should overlook our flaws and like does otherwise I guess nobody would get married if you saw all the flaws right in front of you. Wow. If they told him in the thing, he says, "Oh boy, your I'm assuming your wife is not watching this year right now. Dead giveaway. You're looking at me like I'm crazy. You don't know what I'm talking about. It didn't happen to you." >> He says, "Perfect." >> What? Perfect. >> Perfect. He knows what to say when his because his wife is watching the share. I know your wife is watching and his wife is not Why is it that I I designated this sheep for my eating and I by mistake the by mistake decided he's going to designate it for a special as a gift to Hashem. Has nothing to do with the It works. It's not a problem. Why? Because there's one for all. So remember this one is going to ask a question because it also says so there should be one. Okay. He said this over. So somebody asked someone asked. It's interesting because just like our mess starts also starts we're going to get there very soon. same exact kind of Mishna. All the that you thought about a different thought. Here it is. What's get a It's not It's not good yet, but it's You know that magic trick that they do? They take a flour. They pour it into the hand. And then the guy goes, there's nothing in, nothing falls. A second later, he closes his hand. He goes, he pours it right into the hand. It's a great trick. How's it work? They have like a a thumb made out that matches his hand and it's upside it's inside out and when he pours it, it goes into the thumb and when nobody's looking, he puts his real thumb into that thumb, pushing down and then he he opens up his hand and you don't notice that there's an extension to his thumb and all the flowers in there. Oh, you want to show how the trick works? Anyways, no, I was just thinking because here it is. Show this. This is my the trick. I was saying if anybody has a question on what's going on here, you're supposed to take your three fingers, go into the flower, and whatever stays in those three fingers and you go with your thumb and the the pinky. Here's the trick. It just keeps on going. It's the chem that keeps on going. It's Babasali Kmak. Anyway, one day we'll get it right. The flaws of AI. Let's give Vic stuff. I'm enjoying it. I don't know about you guys. I love it every day. If you do the with the wrong intent, it's good because different I'm just throwing like the we discussing. Check this out. I sent this to Yoshi this morning. I got this. I stole this out of the uh book. >> No, no, no. The the mifa >> and he made this into this beautiful stuff. A mahas is a flat frying pan. There's no room for oil. Although it has the same amount of oil as a mashes. The mash is deep. It keeps the oil in there. So, it's a deep fry. What happens when you take a potato and put it in a deep fry? What comes out? >> A French fry. It's nice and soft. So, check this out. That's hard bread. But if you put it in the mashes, it's going to be soft bread. That is super hard because the oil evaporates and there's nothing left and you have a very hard. Now, imagine taking that and making a out of that. Not not all mas you do a out of flour. That one you got to do out of the the calls that the the the the super super hard the impossible to do. Rabber has been practicing this for years to go like this with your pinky. Break that bread down perfectly that it should be flush with your finger. You got to break hard bread with your pinky. It's very hard. The other thing I if I recall was to take the the feathers and throw from one side of the m and land on the other side. You have to have a tremendous arm to be a quarterback. 60 yard throw, you know. Okay. Huh. >> Have to attach a stone to it. >> You can't. No, no, no. That's That's no tricks. It's a I forgot the Lion. It's very hard. So, anyways, what's going on over here? The bottom line is that any with his right mind that's not drunk and and his two feet on the ground, he knows that this is a this is dry and there's two other ones dry and soft which we're going to so if he he messed them up that's not a mistake when it comes to and they're all the same the same way the same way that's the so let's You can look at it. You know what you're doing. This is hard. Or you take another type of which is dry. Has oil mixed into it. Look at it. This one is dry. So I don't consider it a mistake. When it comes to it's not like that. All the are the same exact says but it seems like because you could prove it from what you're doing in the you wouldn't be if you changed the thought and said oh this is a instead of am I but based on what you told me before you said say the same thing should have should be kosher another. No, you didn't understand. We were talking about they try to change it from to of I got to I forgot to mention this. I got to I got to say this. We're talking about it's to remember was the one that jumped into the ocean and there are people that are jumping into the ocean at every every given time. people that start a new satellite location in Brooklyn or in Phoenix and Los Angeles. Now, these are the nings of the world and they get tremendous amount of scar. The guys who stopped talking during kades, they're the first one stop talking in kadesh. Extra duper. They get extra. You need it. We're in a new year now. We don't know about the right to pass him. The right to pass him got to be Ask. Sorry, did I skip something? No. No. Yeah, of course I did. I went back too much. This is what he's saying. It's not a It's another person called. We're not talking about chino kesh. We're talking about shinoi bim. You changed ownership. You change it to a person called and that rais is kosher. Why? Nakshin is dead. Nach is no longer alive. So if you want to change it to the the it doesn't it didn't it didn't take effect on by the way the maram says that this idea we had a problem there's no part for dead people so why do we do why do we d for them why do people do and take and sh and all this stuff so it says he says you cannot you cannot bring a carbon for somebody that's not alive anymore can't get a kapar through carbon. But you can learn Tyra for him. You could elevate his inshama with Tyra. You could elevate his ina with giving daka and then somebody pipes in there and says, "No, no, no. Only if the guy gave duck when he was alive, but he was car guy that never gives daka." Then you're daka that you give after. Seriously, I didn't make this up. And it's very similar to the kadesh thing. The kadesh only works for people on this world. We have a chance to change it. says, "So why do you jump? Why do you call it? I I brought a I want a for dead person that if you treat it like a like a live person then it will be possible that the really is like a what's a Nazer didn't sin another a has to bring when he wants to bear that would be possible that's a different type of ka that's a different type of kas you're right is the Okay to another is very different apostle as the wait a minute why let's treat that of that of as the of it's like an it's an it's a gift toe and we said already that if you change designations from a kus to somebody else's to give it's Okay. Says, "Okay, let me change it again." I do and I go from my to somebody that is another of then it's and he explains why because the reason why it's kosher it's not possible it's kosher cuz I'm going from and that's okay yeah you got what I'm saying going from toah but not my his he's so I'm saying my should be his and that we said is okay that was one of the seven things rabb said so now what's going on here is and maybe we'll stop over here needs to go so we'll just suffer a different time it's not it's not a short over here but okay in reality the is not arguing on the first but all they're doing is saying that the first one was talking about and that's why it's kosher. The is saying that he was talking about and that's why it's possible. There's a kosher and apostle but they're talking about two different things but they agree with each other. If you take a and try to make it into that's possible. Why? Because it's a different type of so you're changing the you're changing the type of why are you calling it just call it a which means it's a it's a because I'm I'm I'm using the first ever what was the first that ever existed that's the he brought the first Ever should hear all our >> merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.