Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
GOOD MORNING BOYS
AND
SO,
WE HAVE A LONG DAY AFTER DAY hoping to
finish the
more of a dream than anything else but I
got to show you this.
The MDY Shabbaton everyone together.
An amazing amazing Shabbaton has come.
Wow, what a Shabbaton. Being part of
this is something that you can't put
into words. [music] The energy, the
actors, the speeches, the dancing, the
food.
We are here to celebrate ourselves, our
Simcha, and everybody else around over
here is celebrating with us. What you
see are Jews that are looking to
connect.
>> It's truly one big family here.
This is the longer board. Keep us
together modern Orthodox society.
Dancing together with no barriers.
I use the Shabbaton as energy for the
rest of the year.
>> [music]
>> The whole year I wait for it.
You also do, I know.
I always say MDYdaf.com.
The way it's going to work is that the
sponsors for the Shabbaton get obviously
first pick. Then goes the monthly's. All
the monthly guys get to pick first.
Then all the guys that came last year,
if there's any leftover rooms.
Last year we sold out quickly.
This year we're in a larger hotel. I
think we have another 50 to 100 rooms.
80 rooms? Okay.
Here, sir.
We had we had people waiting last year.
They
You know what it is. First of all,
people they you know, they they push it
off. They say we'll do it later.
And then
I think it was Taki. Didn't get a room
Remember Taki? Yeah. He pushed it He
pushed pushed and then but but there has
to be No, there's nothing. The other
thing I want to point out and I'm going
to make an I need to emphasize this. The
women really enjoyed cuz that's one of
the fears people have. How am I going to
bring my wife? What does she Who does
she know there? Who's she going to talk
to? No, no, no. It's not Just yesterday
a guy came to speak to me about
emergency.
He's like, I was at the Hebrew Shabbaton
and my wife bought a new stroller. I'm
like, stop stop stop stop. That's
exactly what we don't want. We're not
doing the new stroller, the new shaitel,
the new thing. That's That's why the
enjoyed it. It was low-key. It was
The women really liked it a lot. So,
tell your wife she's going to enjoy it
and I'm not going to do a lot of emails
today cuz we got to do a lot of
learning.
Hi Reb First of all, can't imagine what
you do for me. It's really
really unbelievable. I love it. I never
ever touched
The fear of all this new stuff and I had
no idea about it. You really bring it to
life and give me tremendous
I try not to leave my house in the
morning before I hear your share.
Reb probably didn't in Sofia, Bulgaria.
That's a new one, right?
Kazakhstan.
What is Yeah, what does he do?
He does the for sure. My work running a
hedge fund has taken me all to over 70
countries around the world. And the two
things that always come with me on my
travels are my passport and your share.
Best
Paulcheck, Washington Heights, New York.
Looking forward to meeting you in person
at the Shabbaton.
Here's a guy with a ring. So, the guys
with the rings can come to the
Shabbaton. Feel comfortable.
>> [laughter]
>> It's everybody. It's not only guys with
There's guys with the rings. Last night
at the
wedding, do we have any Oh, THE DOC IS
HERE.
YOU I BET YOU DIDN'T SLEEP.
That's a big Reb He just He's the father
of the made a
last night. What 1 and 1/2 hours?
>> [applause]
>> Gary, this is when we zoom in, yeah. Oh,
excellent excellent.
Oh, you could sit
Sit down. Sit down. We don't get up and
What is this?
We have a lot of people here. We have
Mayor We have Joseph
in giving this picture and the himself.
Reb is sponsored by David Solomon
dedicated memory of
Boruch Ber Dovid.
Sponsored by anonymous.
Dovid is
anonymous.
Sponsored by Capital and friends
Taki who missed the Shabbaton last year.
Who did not for the devotion to Torah
study. Were you there last year?
>> [snorts]
>> So, you also
Oh, and the share he does every other
Shabbos.
>> [laughter]
>> Don Gedalya's
my father Jack Gedalya's. Anonymous.
Monthly sponsors anonymous.
See, Jacob's for
my brother
what a friend of MDY.
Weekly sponsors Charlie Sayde. I want to
wish my
Toba a 50 years a happy 70th birthday.
Unbelievable.
Daily sponsors
LLC
Reb Mark Ari Dave Benny Shamshi Nachman
Noam Avi Fischel Elchanan Elvis Ethan G
Shimmy
Yochanan Mordechai I'm just
What is going on here?
Who let this in? And the rest of the
for making our trip one of the one for
the books.
Wow, Reb my mother-in-law Josephine
Jazid Friedman Basil and on her
first yard site from
her daughter Jacqueline and favorite
son-in-law Larry Pearl.
What?
This one?
Whose phone is that?
Who's who's supposed to sit over there?
That phone is going to turn it off
maybe. Yeah, yeah, that one.
I said he's going.
The monthly sponsors
for Nathan and for
Mordechai
for Daniel Zev Ben Ayel Dester.
So, Reb
we're holding by a brand new
that from base.
I have to tell you I started off this
really share yesterday. Said, oh maybe
is going to walk out on us
in the middle and after share a balance.
A lot of people came over and said, oh
it was a good share. Love the share. I
don't I'm not exactly sure why.
It's a fun
but you'll have to see for yourself.
Says the Mishna.
Again, we're looking at this chart of
Where is
Where
We might finish the today.
Sad. Eric with
in a famous is Where
Where do you all these
We did the all the all the ones on the
right. Now we're finishing all the ones
on the left. What's left?
The
on the bottom.
Where do we
these three?
The
the newborn, the firstborn, the the
10th, the I love the
I
It's
a good guy.
They
have a of
They're on the lighter side.
The
I'm not going to pull out this board
again but the
is in this entire area. Everywhere. Even
behind the
right over here. Even on the sides over
here. Everywhere. Now we know this is
the right. This box right over here is
the
No, you don't need You could go
go you could right over here. Okay.
So, this is different than all the other
that we saw that we need the
You have to put it on four corners. The
and the and the
and the
Two that are four. You hit the four
walls but only on two applications. This
one these three
Just once.
Just once. That's it.
So, you think
Just make sure they're going to hit
an area that has the green
over here which is the
the base of the
of the
which only goes on two walls plus a
little
on the others but you have to make sure
that there's a base. When you pour the
blood
hit this wall or this wall. This wall
for instance is no good cuz the base
stops right over here. No good. You
can't pour the blood over here.
There's a difference between these three
when it comes to the type of eating and
how you eat.
is only eaten by the men.
Not by the
Where is the
for instance?
My sir a lot
You could eat the
anywhere in your life.
The whole lot
Any type of recipe. Does that Huh?
Yeah, yeah, we're not we're not there
yet. The whole I'm saying to carbon
copy.
That carbon
Are you saying that
>> [snorts]
>> but all types of people but all my heart
Any recipe that does not apply to
Pesach it can't be any recipe has to be
roasted.
You
could eat the
for two days and one night.
And what [snorts] about a Carbon Pesach?
Only that night.
So it's very different. You can do two
days and a night like you right over
here.
A Pesach ain't no hello hello.
You could only eat the Carbon Pesach at
night. There's no daytime eating.
Different than all carbonas. All
carbonas you could start off you eat at
the day plus a night at least one night
even the following day sometimes. Over
here there's zero day.
And
you must finish eating it by hot toys.
You
have to be
part of the the
like this video that I showed you back
in the day we'll show it again why not.
They're hard like a
so wood.
Look at some real food.
Look at that Carbon Pesach. Look at
that. Look at that.
>> [laughter]
>> Okay. You can eat everything else but
the Carbon Pesach.
That's to be your best holiday today.
He's asking about the kiddo. I can't
have no kiddo over there.
It's in the what?
No no it's a nice it's a it's the
thighs. It smells like a pokey. It's a
shoyk.
Listen to this they say that's why a lot
of people are marked
a lot of people are marked not to eat
outside of their house on on Pesach
because
Mishnish.
A Pesach ain't no
way no
a bunch of no no no's. A lot of no's.
You can't eat it up until hot toys. You
not allowed to eat it only but it says
ain't no way. And you can't eat it
unless you are part
registered to that to that carbon.
They say that you used to say you used
to say to the
easy fast for the
easy fast.
Can't eat this can't eat that.
Bite this.
Huh?
That's
Montana
So who's the that says
Because we going to see holes. He says
you pour it onto the you don't throw it.
Who's the
that holds you throw you do a
one Montana
you do me me me.
I want you to remember this name.
Going to have him soon.
A beautiful here in the Mara.
This is the famous guy.
When he's already the
the sign
you are here.
It says
hello boy remember hello hello.
Why does it say hello
don't worry
hello hello it's a double chin.
We going to have a similar a limo later
on so long.
It's like it's a plural why plural?
Why does it say it should say hello boy.
It's it's fat. What's hello bum many
fats. Don't worry hello hello leave me
alone
my sir Pesach
teaches us there's other carbonas in in
addition to the car. You have the
>> [snorts]
>> the Pesach and the my sir.
It's a limo okay.
And how do you know that you must have a
base where you throw the blood of the my
sir and Pesach.
This
is this is a typical daf with you with
them.
And you stuff.
Why do you come here?
How do I know that by the
It says before the positive.
So that I know by
and I learned
from
my love.
If the love
has the two
to show it why not.
He throws the blood on one corner one
time but it hits two walls.
So maybe you should do the same thing by
the
my sir and Pesach.
Why do we say that one is enough? Over
by
Says about tremendous fish.
That
I forgot to show the I just want to show
you real quickly. By Pesach it says in
it says
you have to be registered. It also says
but you can only eat at night. It's the
age. That's to be roasted good. Next.
Now check this out.
We have two of them here. One by one by
by it says the word by the word of it.
Says the this is
which is a tremendous fish.
The idea of
that if the tire wanted me to learn this
everywhere so the tire would say once
and I learned for the rest of the tire.
Remember
I see this by by one carbon I do it by
all carbon.
What if the tire says it twice the tire
saying no only these two places.
But we're not even talking about
we're talking about
so you see that this idea of
works also by a limo of shova.
How does
ain't no way no way.
You can't learn out.
Many
times and I mentioned the last time we
said it.
I don't know how many times is in chas.
But many times. When the says you can't
if you have two you can't learn out.
What about if I hold like
that you could.
Two is not enough to to limit it only
those oh so I have a third
it says by
also the word of it.
If the tire said it by three carbonas
for sure that's only those three
no other carbonas.
Next year.
So this is really our right here.
It says in the
like Adam. A is is eaten for two days
and a night.
Let's just get that clear. Two days and
a night is what?
It's
not one. Car.
The day you had it the entire following
night and the following day up until
here.
But it doesn't say it in the tire.
So how do I know it? That's today's how
do how do we learn this?
So in the beginning going to say
uh
a limo then it's going to go to shova.
We're talking about it's a shova logic.
We going to have a whole argument
between a talent. It's a very cool
story. The back and forth is phenomenal.
And then the rabbit gives up. Okay
you're right it's not a shova. So then
the rabbit steps in and says no I have a
positive.
How
do I know this idea that a is two days
and a night?
It says by over
So this is a
we're going to use a little bit.
The meat is going to be
I saved you a seat even.
What's your name?
Come come now yes sit right next to me
the hot seat.
>> [laughter]
[cough and clears throat]
>> What a came perfect for the year.
Hello hello.
You
do the daf?
With who? Don't tell. Don't tell.
>> [laughter]
>> What do you do for a living? What are
you doing now?
You allowed to say? Yeah.
>> [snorts]
>> Working on
okay good luck. I want to say let's make
English
and D Y. All your stuff leave for later.
All your jokes
English and D Y. All right
where you know what starting from the
two dots. You got it?
No
no.
By the two dots like 10 lines down. So
it says in the before Adam.
The
car
is eaten for two days and a night. Turn
around. How
do I know this two days in a night? She
never
So this possible right over here
We have a heckish.
And we have also by
The idea [clears throat] of
what's shaq? That's the matana that we
give to the coin. The thigh and the
breast.
Just like is two days in a night.
So two before. Now here's the problem.
There's other things you can compare to.
You compare it to You can also
compare it to a taida.
And a taida we know you can only eat it
one day and a night.
You can also compare it to a hatas and a
asham.
Hatas and a asham how long do you eat it
for?
A day and a night.
No, I'm going to compare it to
Says the gemara this givaldik.
What's kirby avna?
Not the yeshiva, the idea.
Huh? Who went to you went to kirby avna?
You also?
The top guy I'm not joking these are the
top guys in the shear for real.
They know everything for real.
Kirby avna I think my brother-in-law
also went to kirby avna he's a you know.
Major Friedman you went to one of those.
Okay anyway.
Okay what's kirby avna? Kirby avna is
after the golos in yerushalayim
the the sanhedrin they went to yavna.
Now they didn't want the to know
that the sanhedrin typically sanhedrin
are in a semi-circle.
They lined up tables like this straight
tables like like a like a vineyard.
Like like a kerem straight.
So if the if the enemy came by and they
saw
a bunch of rabbis sitting at the table
they're not going to think it's the
sanhedrin.
But they did pasken.
There's a uh
If I were to ask you in novardok
novardok they worked on anava.
Anava.
So
who would sit in the front table the
front the mizrach table in yeshiva?
You're working on anava. So what who
would you put in the in the front table?
Why the top guy?
That's that joke the famous joke.
>> [clears throat]
>> The joke is true.
Huh?
He's the top guy.
There's a guy there's a guy that that
they needed
there's a shidduch him
and every every person he went out with
he said no no no no no.
So they told him you have to go to
novardok you have to work on your anava.
So what is this you think you're better
than every girl you go out with? So he
goes to the novardok for two years
and then they wrote him a shidduch he
says no they said what's the shaq? He
said
not only
am I who I was before but now I have two
years of anava on my belt do you think
I'm going to go out with this girl now?
>> [laughter]
>> So anyway in in novardok in novardok
they they put the guys the new shaqs in
the front. Why? That's that's based on
right to my shita. I don't talk about it
a lot but I always tell people stop with
the being anonymous. Anonymous I I gave
talk anonymous.
I learned 20 daf hazara anonymous no.
When it comes to be hazak the oilam
don't be anonymous.
You be anonymous you want to help a
yosam on your own spare time not tell
anybody great. When it comes to be hazak
the tzibur you tell I gave x amount of
money
to tzedaka so you should also that's
that I don't think it's the right place
to be anonymous.
Not to knock the famous anonymous is
from lakewood and anonymous from
But no seriously if if mo landi would
would have been an anav and not tell
people that he did they did all the
hazara on the airplane then he then
thousands and thousands of daf
would have been lost all those people
that made siyumim on the plane and all
the thing the hazak that he gave. Okay
anyway.
It's thought it's ara.
This
exact question was asked in kirby avna.
How many
days can you eat a before?
Now
let me ask like we said it before a
before is like a two days and a
night.
Listen to this it's unbelievable. There
was a
brand new fresh talmud first day there.
Shabal samedras of
him
says rashi this first time in the base
medrash. What was his name? Rebbe yossi
shmuel the same guy that we saw in the
beginning of shear.
He was a young talmud
but he's powerful.
And the gemara is telling us here that
even though it's your first day
you know in in my yeshiva where I went
to few of them when the yeshiva gave a
shear klali
oy vay voy if a young bochur asked a
question in middle shear klali. You
remember that in kirby avna is also like
that?
In what what?
No only everybody.
No I'm talking about only the chashuvim
only the shear gimel the the key bochurs
could ask. If you're a young guy right?
No?
Didn't have guts why because the guys
would beat them up afterwards. What do
you what do you open your mouth you
little shmendrick?
>> [laughter]
>> Nobody would beat you okay.
Anyway over here you see here's a brand
new guy brand new.
He asked the tarpon.
Okay but he was 18 years old
[clears throat] and who knows how old
he's a little he's a young he's a talmud
it says and he's arguing with the adom
tarpon rebbe akiva.
Rebbe yossi
omer loyi rebbe minayi locha who told
you bring the raya.
Omer loyi beni rebbe yossi says on this
gemara beni because he's new in yeshiva
he wants to be hazak he says beni my son
come here you're a little uh
a virus smile for the the first day.
Omer loyi beni kashim kalim
before kashim kalim you know what it's
simple let's use logic common sense.
You're talking about a we're
talking about a before how do you know a
before is two days and a night? You
learn it from they're both kashim
kalim.
How do you know it? What do we know it
from? What's the makor?
That's a pashut let's see and what if
what if you hold that it's one day and
one night then what? Then you you you're
going to have a big problem. Let's go
let's go right through.
Omer loyi
rebbe
I don't understand what you're saying.
The hatas and asham let's do this for a
second here we go.
Here we're learning before from
before I mean before from
Just like is two days and a night
so two before is two days and a night.
As as rebbe yossi
why don't you learn it from hatas and
asham?
Before
what's a before? Before the yisrael has
a lot of animals his firstborn you have
to give to the coin.
And what's a hatas and a asham? You do
an aveira you bring a hatas or you did a
whatever the thing is you bring a carbon
to the
base hamikdash and part of the
carbon goes to the coin.
I
don't understand it should be
you should learn from hatas and asham.
Oh the cigarette is back.
Why are you saying this?
Last yesterday last night
right before shear I see this guy with a
cigarette in his mouth.
Remind me of a of a guy that's been
sending me emails
like nonstop.
So could you stop with the cigarettes?
That's a you just one line stop with the
cigarettes. I don't like cigarettes you
have to stop with the cigarettes. Okay
I'm going to ignore it.
Oh.
This asham guy cuz this comes from a
hatas it comes from an aveira. Now the
earring I don't know about first of all
it makes it a bal mum but it's probably
one of those not
it's a clip on before.
But fine.
So
I come to shear
and I just ignored it I don't I don't
want to tell yossi that you know there's
a guy that's
writing me emails about this you know
that we get every day.
Come to shear the cigarette is out of
his mouth.
And I realized
that that guy's son
walked into the office
an hour before shear. Nice and shiny.
The guy's son I know for a fact he told
me I'm going to speak to yossi.
And all of a sudden I see the cigarette
I cover it away. So middle shear I said
yossi I know what happened but I need
the cigarette back.
So now I'm going to get another
whatever we're going to have to schmooze
with the guy.
Whatever
I don't know I'm not so pro the
cigarette I'm not pro the cigarette but
don't hack me about little things now we
have a lot of other things to worry
about. Okay good.
It's my doing. I I said you guys I said
you
and not me.
By the way shawn what's your name?
From where?
London? What are you doing here?
You have a wife shalom aleichem.
Anybody else a guest there?
Who?
No he's not him he's not new He's here
for 4 days. What's your name again? I
forgot your name. Eddie Jackson Eddie
Jackson, shalom aleichem Eddie.
Who else? Anybody else new? No, okay.
O my loy
Not on the
over and over and over.
Yeah, where the lines become wide. Let's
Let's figure it out. Let's use logic
here. Mashlama mean boy mal chet. Oh, so
hold on. Let's go back here. This is not
how does it work? What?
First he said it's cut. Tony should
learn from shalomem. He says no, it's a
matana l'koyem. Yeah? It's better to
learn matana l'koyem. So he says no.
Mashlama mean boy mal chet av korban bal
chet.
Mashlama shalom l'yom v'laila echad.
In in a bal chet.
We have another reason to learn from
shalomem says
Reb Tarfon.
I like to learn from shalomem not from
chazan ashem. Why? Because shalom
doesn't come for a sin.
Chazan ashem comes if you sin. Bal chet
is not for a sin. So let's go no sin
from no sin shalomem bal chet. I'm going
to learn bal chet from shalomem.
Av korban l'yom v'laila echad. Av loy
Rebbi not over and over and over. No, I
have another logic. Look at this back
and forth. It's unbelievable.
Chazan ashem matana l'koyem. Av korban
matana l'koyem. That we said already.
The
The shalomem goes to the owner. Av
chazan ashem mean boy min nedava min
nedava. Av korban einu min nedava min
nedava. Chazan ashem you don't bring it
as a as a gift or anything. It's If you
sinned by mistake, you bring one.
So too Av korban macha chazan ashem
l'yom v'laila echad. Av korban nachal
l'yom v'laila echad.
Uh hold on. Yeah. Chazan ashem don't
come as a as an nedava and av korban
doesn't come as an nedava. Av korban
Uh av korban matana l'koyem av chazan
ashem mean boy min nedava min nedava. Av
korban einu min nedava min nedava. Av
chazan ashem nachal l'yom v'laila echad.
So it should be one day. Where do you
get the two days and a night? It should
be one day and a night. Let's do two
days and a night just to remind the
oilam. Two days and a night when you
shecht day you shecht, the following
night and the following day.
So tomorrow comes Rebbi Akiva.
It was a bomb question. The talmid of
Reb Tarfon.
So Reb Tarfon steps aside. Comes Rebbi
Akiva and Reb Tarfon. Reb Tarfon says,
you know what? I can't deal with him.
Good kashas.
Rebbi Akiva who's
somewhat of a talmid of Reb Tarfon
but he's stronger than Reb Tarfon in
learning.
He says, I'll fix it. O my loy Harei
omer
uv'soram yeiloch. So that's the pasuk
that we saw before. Uv'soram yeiloch
here.
Says Rebbi Akiva, no no no, you're
right. He's right. You can't learn this
from logic cuz if you can go from logic,
he has he has more of a reason to learn
here. All these things that it it's it's
more it's similar
Av korban is similar to chazan ashem
more than it is to shalomem.
So let me let's drop the logic. Let's go
to pasuk uv'soram yeiloch.
Ekisha na kodesh l'chazon shalomem.
The the av korban
There is a hekesh between the av korban
and the shalomem.
It says chazon by av korban. It says
chazon by shalomem. We have a hekesh. We
have a comparison. Mashlama nachal l'yom
v'laila echad. Av korban nachal l'yom
v'laila echad. And guess what? Once you
have a hekesh ein mashivim al hekesh.
There's no
This makes more sense and makes less
sense. Once you have a hekesh, that's
it. You're locked in. You can't You
can't fight it.
O my loy
Rebbi Yishmael is not satisfied. Now
he's going to argue with Rebbi Akiva.
O my loy he kashe l'chazon shalomem.
V'ani makish l'chazon l'toda. Think
about it. Who's right over here?
If you could misvara, if you could
compare av korban to a shalomem which is
more lenient. You can eat it for two
days and a night. Or compare it to
something that's more chomer, one day
and a night, which one would you compare
it to? Logically, what should you do?
Huh?
Why? Why more chomer?
The fast maruba like the fasta.
Why you grabbing Why are you trying to
do two days? Give him two days. If you
Just go to to whatever is the least of
the two.
If you can compare it to av korban, you
don't know how many days you can eat av
korban. Compare it to a toda. A toda we
know you can only eat it for one day.
You could also compare it to shalomem
for two days.
Take whatever you can get. Take the the
least of the two. Don't be a chazer.
Don't Don't grab two.
>> days is more chomer two days. Of course
it is. It's a chomer thing one day. I
know, but it's more It's more It's more.
It's the fast maruba. No, it's the
fasta.
No no no. No no. The fasta More time to
eat is the fast maruba.
O my loy he kashe l'chazon shalomem
v'ani makish l'chazon l'toda. Matoda
nachal l'yom v'laila echad. Av korban
nachal l'yom v'laila echad.
O my loy he answers him. Harei omer
uv'soram yeiloch. Look Look at this.
Look at the pasuk on the screen for a
second.
It says in the pasuk uv'soram yeiloch
that means you get the minimum. What's
the minimum? For how long? The minimum,
one day.
But then it says l'chayei. Why does it
say l'chayei? It already says yeiloch.
The actual l'chayei is extra day.
So we have two limudim says Rebbi Akiva.
Yom v'laila l'chayei. Yom v'laila
l'chayei. Chozin kodesh b'may acheres.
Av korban. So you get two days and a
night.
Ukshe nemru dvarim lifnei Rebbi Yishmael
omer lahem tzu Rebbi Nuloy Rebbi Akiva
toisa. You made a mistake here.
Chazon b'may acheres. How do you know
the whole idea of chazon shalomem?
Mishalomem.
V'chi davar l'hekesh chazon l'hekesh.
The whole kodesh the whole z'vachim we
were saying Take a look at this.
Shalomem
We're learning shalomem from av korban.
Av korban from shalomem.
Now he said that you should learn it
from toda. The problem is
you cannot learn a hekesh from a hekesh.
The whole chazon shalomem
you learn from shalomem to toda and then
you learn toda to av korban. Chazon
shalomem. That what? That should be one
day and a night. Shalomem is two days
and a night. But through the hekesh
we're learning one day and a night.
But that's a that's a a hekesh after a
hekesh.
And in kodesh a hekesh after a hekesh
doesn't work.
D'lo l'hekesh chazon l'hekesh. Ein
l'chayei l'yom v'laila acher l'yom
v'laila rishon. So Rebbi Yishmael tell
Rebbi Akiva, why did you back up? Why
did you say you need another l'chayei?
Look at this.
The l'chayei on the bottom is Rebbi
Akiva's way of getting out of Rebbi
Yishmael's question. Rebbi Yishmael says
it's not even a question. You don't need
another l'chayei. What is he saying?
He's saying that you should learn from
toda. No. You In order to learn from
toda, sorry, not this one, this one. In
order to learn from toda, you need a
double hekesh. You can't do double
hekesh in kodesh. And m'meila, learn
directly from shalomem. And if you learn
directly from shalomem
and then you you wouldn't need a
l'chayei. Says the Gemara
Rebbi Yishmael ein l'chayei may avedei.
So he doesn't hold like Rebbi Akiva that
you have to use the l'chayei.
So what does he do with the l'chayei?
Limid av korban min shalomem matana
l'koyem.
If you think about it, the the kohen
gets the the first born.
What does he do with it?
What do [clears throat] you do? What
does the kohen do with the av korban? He
has to bring to the Beis Hamikdash. This
is a whole hassle. Goes to the Beis
Hamikdash, shecht, part of it goes in
the mizbeach, part of it he gets.
But if it's a bal mum
Should we show you this thing uh for the
new guy?
Where is that thing? The bal mum guy.
Here, this one.
Oh.
You have no idea how many kids came over
to me and told me their life has been
changed from this video.
Zero.
Why did you come here? Only sick animals
come here and you're completely healthy.
Why do you think I'm healthy? I have
ADHD.
ADHD is not a defect and you should be a
sacrifice in the temple.
I think I broke my leg.
Anyway, so a bal mum that's a big
chiddush.
The kohen gets a bal mum and gets to eat
it by himself. He doesn't have to bring
any of it to the Beis Hamikdash. That's
a huge chiddush. You think maybe if it
has a mum though you don't have to give
it to the kohen at all. Shalom mitzva We
don't find such a thing in the Torah. So
that's why you need a special pasuk
l'chayei to go to the kohen. Great.
Now that's something that Rebbi Akiva
agrees to. Rebbi Akiva y'all have law.
So how does he learn it from if he
already uses up l'chayei? Miv'soram.
Plural loshon. Chatam b'chat bal mum.
Miv'soram double This This two types of
meat. One is a normal animal without a
mum and one is a bal mum.
Rebbi Yishmael miv'soram the korban When
I went to Darchei I spoke in Darchei
last week.
Kids came over and said, we saw I have
ADHD. I'm like the goat. Seriously, they
they
These kids they saw the video.
B'chat bal mum. Rebbi Yishmael miv'soram
the korban. So what does Rebbi Yishmael
do? Miv'soram the korban is kol amar.
It's miv'soram the the meat
of the bull of the goat, of the sheep,
of all the types of korbanos.
Now
the question is
Rebbi Yishmael had a good time over
here.
There's a hekesh after a hekesh.
What does Rebbi Akiva do? What? He
learns a hekesh after a hekesh? Rebbi
Akiva says we're going to learn from
toda that it's
We go from shalomem to toda to av
korban. So it's hekesh after a hekesh.
What's Rebbi Akiva going to do with
this? He can't argue on that. Everybody
agrees that in kodesh there's no hekesh
after a hekesh. Says the Gemara Rebbi
Akiva m'maki.
Says the Gemara mar shalom einu min
davar acher have a hekesh u'mar shalom
leihav hekesh. The question is is this
considered hekesh or not? Why? Because
of this two points over here.
>> [clears throat]
>> There's the point of the chazon shalomem
and there's the point of the night and
the day. If by av korban it say
how how many how how many days, but it
does say it's like. So if you're using a
cash
that partially part of it you know and
part of it you don't know, is that
considered a full or not? Is that a cash
that you can't learn in culture? And the
gives a few examples here now.
According to small
it's
considered or I can't learn it. I can't
do a double or my son gives us it's not
considered therefore I can't learn it.
This is my my have a cash I don't
understand why I don't want to learn it.
Oh, so now the goes into a few different
things.
We have to pick up the pace a little
bit. But since it's a little tricky so
go slow but fast. Here we go.
We have the
remember how many sprinkles of blood you
do in the ocean?
Seven plus
one.
So seven.
But here's the let me before this let me
show you the it's very important.
By the by the ball it says
on top of the game.
On top you have to do a how many do the
third say? Doesn't say.
Doesn't say one.
But if
on the floor you do seven.
That's by the ball. So the ball we're
missing one. We don't know how many to
do on top. Now take a look at the next
it says the sorry. What's
the use of
what's it say? One. I like a virus. So
what do you say
how many should do on top? But it
doesn't say how many do on the bottom.
By the pirate says on the bottom I will
sit on top. So what do you do? You
combine the two. Now I know that the
ball the seven on the bottom one on top
from what? From the
and the learn the seven on the bottom
from the ball.
That's called a cash.
Then I have this.
So take a look.
By the ball the seven you see the seven
dots over there and there's one by
sorry. Because of a cash I'm going to do
I'm going to do both I'm going to do
seven and one seven and one total of
eight.
That's what we do on keeper a
a
that's that. Now
how about in the
to the left with the mirrors? Same exact
thing because of a cash. What is that?
That's a cash after a cash.
And that's for
that's for that that's for
so what do I do?
Says the it's the same ideas over here.
It's
a cash
we have a little bit of something else
that's in the plus a
the some that I know and some I don't
know. Sorry
one on top and seven on the bottom in
the ball.
The same thing I do on the left on the
ball.
But how many?
I'm learning
one from the other. So that's great if
you hold it's not considered a cash. Why
is it not considered a cash because I
have
some that I know without a some that I
need the for. And I have a but if this
is still considered even though I know
some of it but I'm learning
other stuff as well that's considered a
cash. I don't know if I can
after a cash and we know that in you
can't do a after a
cash. Says the two
interesting answers. I'm going to call
them interesting.
Answers that we have to put a little bit
more thought to it but because we're
doing that
we're going to fly through it.
One
answer is that it's two separate types
of
a cash. It's not a after a cash. It's
two separate occasions. One is
learning the from the ocean. That's
number one.
Number two is
I take the draft that I put on top from
the and I put it by the that's number
two. The types of is one the place is
another two different things. It's not a
from a it's two separate occasions.
words
the way I understand it is
by
if I did one
let's think about it. If I did one I
learned the from the ocean. How much
blood would I spill in the ocean in the
home? Without the second without the
first cash.
Does everybody agree with Ari?
Without the without the first how much
would I do? Seven seven.
By the seven. By the I'll do one.
I
have something. I have something without
the first I have I'm starting with
something.
The exact amount I don't know exactly
how much I need another cash. So that's
already not a from a cash. I got I have
something. I'm thinking by
I have zero without the first I
I can't even begin. I need a strike and
then I have to have the strike I can
tell me I can tell you how many days
you're allowed to eat it.
Without the
without the two occasion I have zero. I
don't know how much I can eat. Zero.
Now we're going to another thing and
then we're done with the 10 more lines.
Is still with me by the way?
For real? You're still here in this
year?
Wow okay give all of it.
I want to show you real quickly because
we just first I have to do the sponsors.
I have to change what?
>> [snorts]
>> To
Oh this is sponsors. So this is not us.
You want me to say it?
Oh.
The sponsorship sadly changed from to
the iron arrived there all this morning
for on Jason.
But what's the name over here?
The name is
no
Ben David.
Okay.
Turn off the app. I got global from my
from my from my from my
from my from my from my from my from my
So I want to show you real quickly.
We went up to 28 satellite locations
here in
with
in the Hebrew
we we bring them in during live.
So yesterday we were at um
How do you know?
Very good. Yeah you were the one that
did it. Yeah.
It was beautiful. How many there was
like almost a million over there?
And
it's going very very well and in America
and in we have 27 different locations
that gather.
I don't know how many of these are
daily. In they're all daily or maybe we
have some daily some not.
The
the satellite location thing is growing.
Here it is all in one shot.
Oh it says 29 locations. No no but they
took they took some of the Hebrew. They
some of the Hebrew on top. Four are not
so we got to take out four from that.
All right.
So I think you might have
This is my
all my all my
This is my all my all my we have you
have to stick in the word here. Okay.
So when it comes to
we know that you bring two
here like this.
Together with the
you bring here.
And you do
you have to you have to
wave it. Okay.
So
now we're talking about the
the we know you have to bring 40 40 40
40 breads.
loaves
If you hold it's not a cash
then it's great. I don't know
we learn from
same time we
it's already says the word that you
bring culture that may be
like a
how
learn from
what's
Today how much how what's what's the
amount of flour that you use in order to
to do a fresh challah?
About 5 lb, right?
5 lb, a little less. Okay.
Over here, each one of these challahs
weighed that 5 lb. Each one.
Yeah?
So, that sheer
goes to the title as well.
The what?
Each challah weighed about 5 lb of
flour.
So, too bad the title. Here, let's show
you something that's a little bit more
here. These guys.
Each one of these
is similar to the
to one
each one of the is like one
one is sorry.
Look at the two
together it's two
so maybe the whole pile of 10
should be two together not each one
should be one
but together should be two.
So, we have
a heck is here.
It's
each one and
and how do I know that this is also for
the ones?
Look at the I saw tonight. How do I know
for the matter? They saw for the matter.
So,
that's great if you learn that if you
have a heck is together with something
else it's not a heck is great. So, we
have a heck is after heck is over here
but we have
we have something to begin with. We had
something we just added to it. So, it's
a heck is with something else.
Have you a heck is Michael and Maymar?
But if you hold that it's considered
this considered heck is now you have a
double heck is
how do you have a double heck is in
culture? So, we're not learning from a
heck is. So,
the way you learn title is from extra
word in the positive to view not from a
heck is cuz it was a heck is
will be a problem cuz it's a heck is
after heck is.
That's it.
Done with that now.
What?
I don't know.
You learn you always learn from
my go together.
But I'm not I didn't see but that's how
that's how usually goes.
My go together.
>> [cough]
>> Okay. Says in the mission
we eat it until it says. Who is the one
that says until it says?
But I love you so.
Now,
it says not until it says.
There's a there's a here
that they asked the cycler.
He read the he said
until the morning.
It's a famous story.
But you don't do
it until you do with
it. If you hold that only goes until it
says. What are you doing
until the morning?
So, the cycler told him
but it's different.
It is different. I live there. It's
different.
Because
he rules
and holds
until the morning. So,
went like
you argue on it. That's what the cycler
said.
No, they mark it over there.
That's that's
what we're talking about
talking about
it in the first place. But
we're going to ask what you're saying in
a second.
Yeah, yeah, that's that's in a second.
We're going to get it. Over there ah.
You
should eat it hastingly fast. Actually
ask
what's what's
until the morning when
ran away from they left fast.
So, you
so you hear this
you're allowed to eat
the
until the morning.
So, it's very
there's a famous in there.
You know, like a lot of people are
rushing to eat the before
So, what do you do if you're in the
middle of the meal you didn't eat yet a
lot. You're doing all the
in the morning.
And yeah.
A person a person is ready he has to eat
but he has to do what what he do? He
looks at the
it's almost 1:00 in the morning it's
1:00.
So, the says what he could do is he
takes he eats you learn he takes a
piece
during the
piece of he says I'm going to eat this
so the share comment.
That's it.
Now, and he says that says he makes it
tonight. I'm doing this with us
who holds that you could only eat until
it says.
Now, according to
you could eat you could eat you could
continue eating.
The whole thing could you continue
eating your meal afterwards.
You did
beforehand and then you continue your
meal after
and and
according to anyway you could eat your
until the morning so it's not a problem.
There's a lot of who argue on him. Okay,
the mice you should try to
finish before but if not you could do
such a I'll go upon him.
Okay,
but according to you could go all the
way to the morning so why is it say
there?
So, more beautifully because if you
remember every single carbon like this,
yeah?
Every carbon has a day night day or a
day and a night.
But you have a day in there.
The only carbon that you can't eat
during the day is carbon so. She
like every other carbon you could eat
during the day.
That's the that's the
that this is a night carbon. You cannot
eat it anytime during the day so.
I he did a thing here for this but it's
not
whatever. I'm just going to show it
while I'm going to read the rest of the
I don't want to be late here.
What
the right so that's what was asking. How
do you know that it's do we have a right
so?
I thought I would have it.
I'll try.
Okay.
Oh, sorry. I
have
a right so
we had a number of times in this here.
There's a lot of could all even though
the they could eat a day and a night you
have to stop at you can't go to the
morning.
I saw once and I think I even showed it.
A guy went to sleep on a ledge of a
40-story building. He took his mattress
on the ledge.
So, they said what are you crazy? You
must be sugar. You're not scared you're
going to fall? He said I'm 50 years old.
I never once in my life did I fall off
my mattress in the middle of the night.
So, you think tonight I'm going to fall
off my mattress?
So, the
right there. You got to be careful when
it comes to have a right there. Treat it
like that. Okay, my so
hello awesome.
My awesome. Oh, so it says it says hello
all the it says eat it until
until what's hello what's the
sexual word hello? Hello meaning my so
I cannot
to tell us that
you stop at so.
Not because it's the
because it's a the
have a wonderful
Merit the of spreading Torah throughout
the world. Sponsor a share today at my
sponsor.com or sponsor at my daf.com.