Daf Yomi Zevachim Daf 52 by R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning Rabbi boys. Before I get into all I have so many questions I guess that I don't even know where to begin. It's so smart to be back. You have no idea. I was only away for about a week. It seemed like months for me. It was to sit down and not to worry about the camera. You get the best technology and everything works and and the the my here all the people is just I can't explain it. They I gave at least four children like 2:00 or 3:00 in the morning over there. It was a it was a little bit of a disaster. So it's great to be back. I'm happy to be back. You know and it remind me it's coming to me now so I'm just going to say what what what's going through my head right this second. Yesterday I saw I got a Z. A big Z. I I didn't even see the news but I saw a message I realized right away. The matter is not good in New York. Not good in the world. That a socialist could win an election. A communist a self He says it. He says straight out. Where are we heading? And as I was walking here and I'm thinking this right now. This all connects. We were this close of having Kamala president. This close. And what that would have done to Israel and to Israel and to you then. Also not unless Russia. And you know what? >> [snorts] >> How many times do we think that Trump won? How many times? Once? No. You every day. Not me and not you and not you. And you know why? We get used to things. And I'm I'm saying this here. We're used to what we have here. This technology and you sit down and runs and it goes all over the world and and we don't appreciate what we have. And then and then Trump's in the this and that he he sends this and he sends that. The best friend of of of the even the best. And we have to appreciate it every day cuz what and then what second you don't appreciate then you have what it could really be. What it could really be. I appreciate it. The seat is even better. It's smart. >> [laughter] >> Everything I got my everything it's good. And my look at this guy. He's amazing. This guy you gave me a lot of this. Speak again. What's his story? You want to tell the you might so what happened but I said I got to send you a very emotional video. I don't even know did I show the video you sent me? The video of you seeing I didn't send I didn't show anybody? Yeah they remember. They remember. Yeah the speech the speech. You don't have to say anything. You want to say you can say. You don't have to what say say what's your what's your deal? The mic hold on. You I do I do have to give a speech soon so I was dating a girl for a while and about eight months we got engaged and unfortunately due to personal circumstances we had to split it off and it was a very very you know amicable split. There was no anger or anything between us. And you know one thing that I started during that relationship that she was very supportive of I started the speech and as you know the CM forever the Tsar came and I was saying my speech and I was just it just came to me that you know the speech completely changed my life and it really it helped me get through that situation completely and you know I'm just so thankful to to you and to you know learning and to that this situation just ended the way it did. And you know I'm just hopeful for the I'm hopeful for the future. Wow. >> [applause] >> Give you a I'm going to give you another one. Thanks. Wow. Beautiful. How long you been doing the speech? How long you doing the Since I started this in the beginning. Wow. That's not as well. And that was your first ever? First ever made in my life. How old are you now? 22. 22. Now you know that you're going to come pouring in now that they're going to see you. How do you Who's this guy next to you? How are you doing? What's Who are you You with You with Mark? Oh you're this guy. Yeah yeah. You know that guy. Yeah. Let's always listen to the story. This is you know like you go to a guy say come you should you should change your life. Learn learn the speech. Come join the army. So we have first time you ever heard something like this. David comes every single day. Meets him and says you got to do the speech. He says yeah. He sat him down. He opened it up and watched an hour speech with him to make sure that he watches it and since that day you haven't missed? I haven't missed and I haven't missed. Haven't missed. That's how you get a guy to join the speech. That's you got to learn from David. It's unbelievable. >> [applause] >> It's unbelievable. >> [clears throat] >> We have Vice Fish. We have the best over here. Anybody want to do or anything? Look at this. We have We have back. >> [laughter] >> Look. It's me. Look at me. Wow. It's What are you doing here? I got lost. >> [laughter] >> Who are you next to? That's the famous guy. Innovations. That's that's the famous guy. Get over here. COME ON. >> [cheering] >> THE FAMOUS GUY. JUST had a speech. Well we're going to we're going to start your speech soon. How are you doing? Wow. Wow. You got taller and bigger. How many how many did you do with us? You did six speeches. How many six speeches? How many is that? >> [applause] >> You can take more but how many do you know? Over 200? Over 300? Sister Tom. So that when was the Tom? Somebody do the new quick math. 350 what? You already since last Tom Tom. No that was that was this one but it was last one. It was December. Okay. 34. Wow. I'm going to wish you a lot a lot of luck a lot of you should continue loving learning. You're the best in your class. Okay. Go. >> [applause] >> What about you? You're back. You're back. We'd love to have you back. It is great to see you. All right who else is a guest? I saw you. You're you're not a guest. What? Not a guest. Well you know who is a guest? He's not a guest these days. Okay. Okay so I'm going to skip all the emails. What? Who? Who? Oh yeah that's right. You're a guest. How are you doing? You're sitting in the wrong table. There's actually one more seat over there next to Okay. No I'm just saying you belong over there with the the lucky birds. So what's your what's your name? From Monsey. How are you doing? Very nice. Thanks for coming. Um Breakfast is sponsored by Simon in honor of his first anniversary with MDY today. >> [applause] >> The visit MDY of the MET consortium the end of Shiva for Ezra Newberger see email. I did not see the email yet. Is it important for today? I was I check this out. This is our one and only. They're all here. Where where was this? Oh this is in Tiberia. I'm sorry what I'm supposed to I'm supposed to I'm supposed to read this now? Okay. I don't I don't start off with the with the Simon. It better be a good one. I didn't I didn't I didn't edit it. Nothing. What a day and what a year. What started out a year ago as trying to trying to learn has morphed into a new life and a lifestyle for me and my family. That's why I'm reading it. I know. I know this made a big You're you're been tired a real been tired but even a been tired could could use a little physical once in a while. I had a thought that normally when people try something new they're very excited in the beginning but then after the new car feeling wears off then so does enthusiasm and excitement wears over time. But my experience with MDY is the opposite. I spoke to many others in the family who concur. That the excitement only grows from day to day. That's a good one. I can personally say that I don't think a year ago I would have recognized that the the myself of today and where I've been able to grow. As you really mentioned the word from a few weeks ago of in Russia about being the greatest in his generation the the basketball player. I ain't Trump. That when a person is put in a position where people around him are better then they will help him up his game. Whether it's doing things that I would never have done on my own before because I didn't have the peer encouragement like in learning on the plane. More than the closing all the week stopping on you have to see client. And due to Ellie's constant encouragement everyone has catapulted catapulted cat catapulted No. catapulted catapulted catapulted catapulted is big. That's why I like to read these over before and go and go to Google this. Pronounced like this. So we'll all step up to the plate. In addition having this of meeting other people special people in the MDY family. Like for example our special guest for today Mark Ellie consortium. Anyone who knows them knows what they do for MDY. It's true. Not stop. Uh they don't know what they do for MDY. They think they know what they do for MDY, but there is many many hours they don't even know. And I would be remiss to not mention the kiss from Hashem how my 1-year anniversary lands on the last day of shiva for my rebbe Reb Ezra Neuberger, who is my rebbe who set me on a trajectory and steered me on the derech of always being a ben Torah and eved Hashem in everything I do. If I could share one lesson that he taught all his talmidim, which he truly lived and breathed himself, he would always say the chazarah is not just a way to retain what you learn. >> [snorts] >> A 13-year-old kid comes over to me in Far Rockaway. I Far Rockaway became very yeshivish. I even learned the new word fakacht yeshivish. That's what they say. [laughter] It's fakacht yeshivish. Anyways, it's it's a 13-year-old kid comes I'm not going to say too many details who he is. He comes from a he's from a chashuve family. No, no. No, they're not but they're famous family. Comes over to me and says, "Can I ask you something?" He said, "I'm a big fan of your shiur, big fan." He momzer, the way he said it like I said I I believed him for a second. >> [clears throat] >> And he's like, "So, why did you do chazarah?" So, huh? So, I said, "Okay." Yeah, we we try. We have a chaburah. And we encourage it. We even we had a raffle. I don't even know what happened to that raffle. He says, "Okay, good. So so so you're going to do chazarah?" Like, "Yeah, [clears throat] I just told you." He's like, "Listen." He's 13 years old. "I'm making you a shliach to tell the oilam that they have to do chazarah." >> [laughter] >> I said, "Okay, good." "I'm making you a shliach." I said, "Okay, I heard." How many times "I'm going to KEEP ON SAYING IT until you do it." >> [laughter] >> Maiseh shliach. Maiseh shliach. I did you shliachus. >> [laughter] >> The grandchild of the rosh yeshiva. He'd always say that chazarah is not a way to retain what you learn, rather it's part of the actual process of learning. And it is kisu malchu libacha that we are commanded to do. You'd always call it the briach briach hatichon of our learning. Meaning, it's the part that holds everything together even without being seen. Another word, learning culture. I'm sure we'll have an AI rep explain what that is. I know in MDY we say it's kishmo daf, but may I suggest we also add it's kishmo chazarah the daf. I'm making you a shliach. Here he is. Like I know I don't have a future as a rabbi or something. I don't worry, Nachman. Now that we have just the daf in 20 and 30 minutes, it makes it so much easier to be able to review and really enjoy the daf exponentially. It all goes on. >> [laughter] >> And it's 7:32. I don't know if I have chazarah daily. Uh personal assurance says, "Those who know can't answer." There's a famous phrase, "Yesterday is history, tomorrow's a mystery, but today is a gift. That is why it's called the present." My parting words to this holy chaburah He's parting. Reb Boaz says he's leaving us. >> [laughter] >> I'm working. I'm not talking anymore. Oh. My pa- That's a present. That's a that's a shvach of it's like saying I'm not going to sleep for 6 weeks. My parting words to this holy chaburah is that we capitalize every day on the gift of the present and make the most of it in our avodas Hashem. And I hope that on my next anniversary, I look back and see how much I was able to grow because of the MDY family I'm surrounded by. With Reb Eli at the helm, captain of the ship. Enjoy the breakfast. Ari Simon, but Boaz Kuminetz get over here. Ari, another get over here. This is Chashuv. Reb Boaz said, "What would the shiur be without him?" Chazak u'baruch. Beautiful letter. Yishar koach. Thank you very much. You're a big big part of this shiur, literally. >> [laughter] >> Chazak u'baruch. Because of because of this we're starting we're restarting the raffle. Gevaldig. Okay. Reb Boaz, we have a beautiful Oh, I have to see sponsorships. It's crazy. Okay, I'm skipping all those. David Solomon dedicated in memory of Avi memory of Avi Meiry Reb Shmuel Boruch ben Reb Chaim Zvi Dovid zechuto livracha. The circle sponsors an anonymous l'ilui nishmas Lady Shlomit. I just I don't think we ever started this shiur so late, but I had to catch up on a bunch of stuff. And I have a lot of chashuve guests. L'ilui nishmas Lady Shlomit Yehuda ben Reb Shmuel Chaim Zvi Dovid zechuto livracha. Shmuel Dovid Chaim anonymous. L'ilui nishmas Reb Shmuel Nachman Zvi ben Reb Shmuel zechuto livracha. Anonymous. And all of our friends may call back. Talking to Shmuel Shmuel Shmuel. For the lotion donation in this shiur, Dovid ben Reb Shmuel zechuto livracha. My father Jack Dovid anonymous. Reb Boaz Kuminetz. Both of these sponsors anonymous. Reb Boaz Boruch Pinchas ben Reb Shmuel Yehuda ben Chava Zvi Jacobs. For a full shleima for Boruch ben Chano. Ari Simon l'ilui nishmas Rabbi Meiry Reb Ezra Dovid ben Reb Shmuel zechuto livracha. Reb Boaz Reb Ezra Neuberger of Ner Israel niftar. Such a chashuve and true loss to the Ner Israel community worldwide. He's a weekly sponsor. Daily sponsors Chananya Pashkus l'ilui nishmas Avi Meiry Yehuda Aryeh ben Shmuel Meiry ben Shmuel niftar Yehuda ben Chashvan. Is it shuv should have an aliyah? Sholom Kagan in honor of our son Zvi Kagan who has not missed a daf since Avodas Hashem daf beis. Wow. >> [applause] >> There it is. Eli Epstein l'ilui nishmas Harav Chover Mordechai ben Reb Dovid ben Reb Yisrael zechuto livracha. Is it shuv should have an aliyah? Reb Yaakov Bleich in honor of the engagement of my son Avrohom Meiry Bleich from Kiev to Leah Brownstein from Minneapolis. It's gevaldig. Yeah. A shidduch. K Innovation LLC in honor of Mark Zvi Zvi 2.0 Aryeh Kalman. Of course, Yisrael. The chesed that you do for Klal Yisrael is new volume. >> [laughter] >> Welcome back, Reb Eli. You were missed. Alan Rabinowitz yishar koach. Yishar koach, Innovations. Alan Rabinowitz in honor of his daughter's chasan on November 9th. Their marriage should have shalom bayis. Alan, it's been a while. You momzer, for a tkufah. Gevaldig. In honor of Chaim Gideon Menashe ben Meiry from London on his birthday with admiration and dedication to learning. Wishes a full refuah from his family. Amen. And the Yahrtzeit monthly refuah shleima for Yonasan ben Dovid ben Meiry Boruch refuah shleima Mordechai ben Asher refuah shleima Yael Daniel Zev ben Yael Esther. We have to appreciate what we have. Momzer, our mishpacha, our life, our health, we only start crying about it when we start missing it. All of a sudden, a little thing is gone. We can't use your thumb. All of a sudden, you realize, "Wow, that's I need it." Without it, I can't do anything. What am I going to How do I pick up a box? All of a sudden, what? The bowling ball. A lot of things. How do I write? How do I write? >> [laughter] >> All of a sudden, you have a what do you call the socialist, the communist. And all of a sudden, "Wow." It's gone before that. Wow. All right. Good afternoon. Beis Medrash on top. O yei yei noi. We're in the middle of a braisa. We have a pasuk. O yei yei noi al mizbeiach shel oilah yei l'yesod. So, let's let's jump into this yesod thing here. Yeah. Yesod. Here we go. Ready? What is the yesod? The yesod is the base of the mizbeiach. I think by the red. You see the red? You should not do the zrikah over there, but by the green you could. Maybe that's what the pasuk is Who told you the pasuk is coming to talk about shirayim? Perhaps it's just the zrikah has to be by the green area. Wherever there's a base, cuz not the entire mizbeiach has a base. Rather than there's a base, then we do the zrikah. Wherever there isn't, no. O yei yei noi al mizbeiach shel oilah yei l'yesod. Says the Gemara, "Mi kaseiv el yesod ha'oilah?" Doesn't say the base of the korban oilah. El yesod mizbeiach oilah kaseiv. What's mizbeiach? Mizbeiach comes to tell us that all the korbanos, every single one, has a chiyuv to do the the shirayim over there. Says the Gemara, "E havei kaseiv el yesod ha'oilah." Wait a minute. It's not true. You're telling me that the word mizbeiach is extra. No. E havei kaseiv el yesod ha'oilah havei minah b'skiflei yesod. So, it goes like this. This beautiful over here, you could see it. This is the yesod, right? So, I think that you could put the blood We know that you have to put the blood on the green area. If you put it What if you put it on the red? Are you yoitzeh? No. That's what the pasuk comes to say. What it says is one area on the mizbeiach that you're not allowed to put it on. The area closest to the floor. I don't know if it's What the reason is? Maybe because it's No, not so chashuv it's next to the floor. But it's supposed to be on the green area. And Tosafos points out green and above. Meaning, of course, you could put it on a wall, but not the bottom wall. The top wall. Everything above the green. >> [snorts] >> Havei minah b'skiflei yesod. Has the same as Reb Shmuel mizbeiach oilah. Agag de'yesod. It's telling you that you have to be on the top. On the roof of the yesod. On the horizontal part of the yesod, not the vertical. Omer Reb Shmuel, "Gag yesod lo likro." Why do I need a pasuk b'klal for the the roof? The leftover blood of a chatas. It doesn't really do much. It doesn't create a forgiveness, kaparah. Yet, you must put it on top on on the roof part of the yesod. Kil yesod mechapair. So, certainly the beginning part of the the the zrikah the the initial parts of the of the of the korban which give a kaparah. And then shinu gag yesod. Of course, you need the gag. Omer Reb Akiva. And then comes Reb Akiva and says the same exact thing. The only difference between Reb Akiva and Reb Shmuel are two words that seem redundant. They're almost the same. So, basically, they're saying the same. The Gemara is going to ask, "What's the difference between them?" Omer Reb Akiva, "Same same same kavei chaimer. Ma she'yei chadashei mechapair." Oh, there's no kaparah. then he sticks in and they don't come to give a kapara. Who brought the copper? It does come for a copper. And it didn't same copper. And came out of the what I need a person. That's what we had yesterday. 10 years especially just means that the most go on the inside. Might be naive, but what is the difference between the same the exact same thing? Plus or minus this word by my copper. Who bought the copper? We just do the copper. He just adds who bought the copper. So, what's the difference? Okay, we came to the conclusion that you have to put the on the back. But, what happens if you don't put the on the back? You have to >> [clears throat] >> redo it again? Who might very interesting though. What does my happy mean? Up until now that known base 50 in the back. >> [snorts] >> What does my happy mean to you? What does my happy mean? Think about it for a second. It's my happy. And then what what do you do with my happy? It doesn't work and then what? Do what again? Did the guy get a copper? No copper. That's my happy. As you said over here he gets copper. It makes it makes sense. Think about it. Let's think now. Let's break it down. He did the four on the back. You got a copper or didn't get a copper? The second you do the last boom it's over. You got a copper. So, now what? Now I have to take the blood and pour the rest the left over on the and it's my happy. Not that it undoes the copper. You had a copper. You had a copper. So, then what's my happy? My happy that you have to shut another animal and and do another one. But, the copper happened says Rashi. Oh. Says Rashi, listen. She is not my happy. Don't worry about it. You don't have to shut another carbon. So, the something completely different. Let me show you this video. It's uh First time I saw it I I told them not to not to do this again. Because it's kind of long. It's like a short feature film. Oh my god. What is this? We have a deal then. Yes, a deal. >> [laughter] [laughter] >> All right. So, what do we see here? She in The same thing just like 30 seconds shorter for me. >> [laughter] >> All right. She might be my friend. Rashi the cool she in my friend. Don't worry about it. You don't have to go running in my friend. She in my friend it's not the end of the world if you don't pour the the rest of the blood in the bottom of the back. When you shut the bird there's not enough blood in a bird to pour into a vessel and and and and capture it and then pour it from there. So, what do you do? First you have to do a depends what kind of bird we said not community and let me see if I can find it here. Oh, this is a uh He takes it and he like a ball you have to toss it toward you're not hitting them with the bird. Something like that. Okay? That's a then this meets you. This meets you. You get a good squeeze on the actually We have another one. Let's do the other one. Here this cuz this is more for us. I don't think there's that much blood, but okay. You give it a wedge a good squeeze. Is that my happy that thing? What if you What if there's not enough blood in the in the bird to to give it a wedge? My happy so my whether or not the last bloods of the bird are my happy. I give it a proper. So, we have a right to a proper the word she in my happy like the base color it says by the proper Messiah the proper of the God all he doesn't have a hero. What is the proper saying the word proper? The proper needs blood on the inside the very ready. >> [laughter] >> I have a proper hammer. So, this is fat to me it's fascinating. I don't care if you guys don't think so. I think it's fascinating. You know in if the proper says something twice show the proper my happy. It makes it you have to do it. Says Rashi with as a proper hammer he's my happy. It became twice once in the proper second time in a proper hammer that's two. 1 + 1 = 2 my happy. That's what Rashi says. I wish my proper hammer my not that he's trying to say why do I need a proper in addition to the proper I have a proper hammer and I have two. Is it fascinating? No. >> [laughter] >> Fact checking checking. If you don't have to go and do it you still need a mission here's another fascinating thing. You read it it doesn't make sense. The proper home God all you don't have to bring the diamond to be funny. Of course you have to. So, why is why is the proper saying you don't have to? The answer is cuz he doesn't have to bring a carbon. He shouldn't do a cat. His cat is not is not necessary. If he sins yes you're right. You must bring it inside. But, he doesn't have to sin. He doesn't have to make mistakes, but you can keep it you have to bring every single year you have to bring a carbon you can keep it that's a must. So, you have a proper hammer is a proper God all who doesn't have to sin. Yet he has to put his blood on the inside mission of the name. The the carbon I can keep it that you do it year after year and you must bring the blood inside and it is certainly you need a proper hammer and I mission here one is once again. Who might be this is slightly different not the same as before. You don't have to bring the blood into the shut the door proper doesn't go in the what goes in the in the proper things. So, certainly the when you have to bring the blood into the certainly you shouldn't need the if the proper God all you don't need the you need the even though you don't go into the certainly when you go into the you shouldn't need the so. Now now we understand what the question is you can all know. I think this is my happy. Why is it my happy? Cuz they have two sources. One is a proper one is a proper hammer. Come on people make up the dish. Show me the proper cool on. In other words, once I do all this I'm done. I'm finished. The comes afterwards. What comes afterwards is not my happy. She is not my happy like the proper. Proper hammer the proper Messiah. We have a proper hammer before we learned the proper from God all. Proper hammer the proper Messiah. We have the mercy. Mercy He doesn't bring his carbon into the No. Mission of the name my happy Tony side. The frame over here is what? The heichal. Mishnah Rishon dome lifnim. Yeah. This is the kind of all of them. doesn't go to the Kodesh Kodashim, but it goes to lifnim. We know this dome lifnim bein chiyuv bein mitzvah. And you din sh'to inside certainly should require the inside. Yachol Yachneno, once again, I have a kav chiyuv here, so it's twice. So it's me'akev tam lomar. Ve'eitz kodama por yishpoyach. Should say b'shofach. Says yishpoyach nitka yakosuv. So yishpoyach like a like a mitzvah. You should take this and pour it. So the So it says the Gemara about so shiyurei mitzvah lo shiyurei me'akev. It's like a love I need to glass say. It's it becomes like a mitzvah, but it's not me'akev. Okay? So meila, we have you see like Rab Papa that shiyurei hadam ein me'akev. Bisor uvishmol. So now I'm just going to go back cuz the Gemara said, "Oh, what's the machlokes between Rebbi Yehudah and Rebbi Akiva?" The the machlokes is on something completely unrelated. Whether or not you have to you don't have what to squeeze out of the bird on the on the mizbei'ach yotzei or not. Bisor uvishmol means to have the soif me'akev what? Rebbi Shmuel actually holds that if you don't have enough blood to give a kvetch, it's me'akev according to Rebbi Shmuel. V'anishar badam lo matzei. V'anishar imotzei v'she'eino nishar imotzei. What? That if you don't have, you don't have. What are you going to do if you don't have? He knows. What? What happened? There's a whole this conversation going on here. What? He wants to Oh, he wants to remind me. Shh. Everybody, don't say anything. People live for this. Should have seen in Lakewood. When I turn the page, 20 people. Sponsors. Sponsors. So I I stopped the shiur. I said, "Listen, who who who Who raised their voice? Sponsors? Like 20 people." Okay, could I forbear you on what we just said last minute where you're like concentrating to say sponsor sponsor? Svee, you want to say it? Say it. Go ahead. Oh, you want to say the sponsors? Hey, let's go. Turning of the daf. Go here. Put it on the screen. Here we go. Read it. Svee, you read it. Uh go. You say Dar Global. Go. Say. No, here it is. It's on the screen. Too many words. A Dar Global Zelig Meir ben Reb Meir Meisels. L'ilui nishmas Reb Dovid ben Rebbi Shmuel ben Rebbi Nachman. Anonymous. As a zchus for Nachman Rochlis and Gashmius. Yehudah ben Rebbi Shmuel ben Basya Schlesinger for hatzlacha and simcha for Yoyo Yehudah ben Dvorah ben Rebbi Shmuel ben Rebbi Nachman ben Basya ben Rebbi Shmuel ben Miriam. Gevaldig. Now this is this is the famous maiseh that we got to say it over here. I haven't [clears throat] said it in a few weeks maybe. Days. It's shmack. I love this maiseh. It's one of my favorite all-time favorites. It's a classic. Classic goes to the Rebbi. Says, "Rebbe, I only have enough oil for Ner Chanukah or s'reifas ha ptilos." You know s'reifas ha ptilos. Which one should I do? Which one should I should I use the the oil for Chanukah licht or for burning all the the the wicks after Chanukah is over?" So the Rebbi said, "Of course you should do Ner Chanukah. What What's the shaila of a klal? The Chanukah of the mitzvah is greater than the mitzvah itself." So kind of reminds me over here. This is like Okay, if you have it, you have it. You don't have it, you have it. It's like I I did I went like this. I did the zrika. K'mo she's soref. So nothing inside nothing inside. The the the kvetch is not it's not the end of the world. So says the [clears throat] Gemara, "No, treitei noya v'al yedei Rebbi Shmuel. You're right. It it comes from Rebbi Shmuel, but there's a machlokes in Rebbi Shmuel whether or not you have to give it a kvetch or not. Our sugiya holds Rebbi Shmuel holds you don't. It's it's uh me'akev. And here it says it's not me'akev. Omar Rebbi Nachman bar Yitzchak. I tanna sover shiyurei me'akev. I have a tanna that does hold that shiyurei is me'akev. If you don't do it, you have to do it again for the shiyurei. Bisanyo. Hakoin hamachatei oiso. Here also, I'm going to give you a little bit of a maybe you didn't have this one when you're just reading. What's hakoin hamachatei oiso? The koin who does zrika, he gets to eat the the korban. So let's say Rebbi Schonberg does the zrika. So he gets to eat the korban. What about Donny Fine? Does he get to eat the korban? Yes. Yes. Why? The Torah doesn't mean literally the the koin that does it. The koin that's able to do it. Kohanim that are able to do the zrika, they get to eat it. Just the question is I I just wanted to throw it out. So what does it say oiso mean? Why does it say oiso? I'm a It says a koin chatei, the one who does zrika. He saw it. Oiso sh'nitan dam l'maala v'lo oiso sh'nitan dam l'mata. You can't mess up the the You know, here's the line. And there's dam that goes below the the red line. Oy vey. Not this. Yeah. If you put the blood above the red line where it really belongs, below the red line, you do it above instead of below or below instead of above, you messed up. It's me'akev. Oiso sh'nitan dam l'maala v'lo oiso sh'nitan dam l'mata. Okay. Amrus. What What do you put above the red line? Does anyone remember? Chates. What else? Oilos soif. Amrus. V'chi mein bozu, where do you get this from? V'kashan [clears throat] emar v'dam ze v'chochrei yishofei. Amizbei'ach. V'go omer. Adam ze v'chochrei yishofei v'gam mizbei'ach. L'madnu l'nitoin em b'matana rishona v'matana achas achas kiper. If you machuyiv you have to do four, the Gemara makes an interesting tzushtel. The the chiyuv is to put four matanos on four chates. It's supposed to be on four. Four kronos, let's say. Four. And you only did one. You only did one. It's good. So meila, the Gemara wants to make a little bit of a jump. And if you're supposed to put on top and you put on the bottom, you're also good. You're supposed to do four, you did one, it's good. So if you're supposed to do on top, you did on bottom. What's the difference? You're supposed to put on four parts of the mizbei'ach. But actually you only put on one. You're supposed to put on this part of the mizbei'ach, you put it over here. Similar. Yachol l'havin dam l'maala sh'nitan dam l'mata kiper. So I have the oiso says no. You're not You have no kapara. Just I wanted to stop for a second cuz I have nothing else to say. And it reminded me when it says yishofei. A guy was holding a a full cup of coffee. He's about to walk into the Beis Medrash. And he went in the coffee room. So there's a sign thing that says, "Please do not bring coffee in the Beis Medrash." Ayin Even Ezer siman sameach. So he's a big This guy is a big talmid chacham. So he's saying something So he's saying Even Ezer siman sameach. Oh, chukos nisuin. Chukos nisuin. What's shiyachus? Marriage with coffee? And he's trying to figure it out. He doesn't have. So he goes into the Beis Medrash and he pulls out the Even Ezer siman siman sameach. Opens up and he sees a tremendous coffee stain on the hole. >> [laughter] [laughter] >> All these bugoyim. All these bugoyim. They didn't even pay attention last time. I never heard you say that one. Really? And I never heard you say the other one before also. I never heard it. Maybe on Motzei Shabbos cuz you weren't here on Motzei Shabbos. Listen, some I say jokes on Motzei Shabbos also, you know what I'm saying? These are Motzei Shabbos jokes. You know what I mean? V'dam ze v'chochrei yishofei. Fine. Anyway, v'deinu. Namru damim l'maala. V'namru dam l'mata. >> [laughter] >> Please not. Oy yoy yoy. Wow. I think I took what you were saying literally. Fly more often. It's not like I flew to New York and back. I flew to to to Utah. From When I was in New York, I flew to Utah, which is another five and a half then back to Chicago, then back to New York, then back to Chicago, then back to Eretz Yisrael. >> [laughter] >> MDY. Cuz I As it was on the MDY private jet. Yeah. Zog die Gemara. Madom amru dam l'mata. Oh, where are we? Should we just start the whole thing again? >> [snorts] >> V'deinu. Namru dam l'maala v'namru dam l'mata. Madom amru dam l'mata sh'nitan dam l'maala lo kiper. The blood that you're supposed to put on the bottom. So Rashi says, "What's the blood that you're supposed to put on the bottom?" Chates soif. Why? Why chates soif? Cuz that's what it says in the Torah. The Torah talks about blood on the bottom by by the bird. By the bird chates. Madom amru dam l'mata sh'nitan dam l'maala you did it up above the red red line. Lo kiper. You don't get a kapara. Adam amru dam l'maala sh'nitan dam l'mata. The same thing. If you're supposed to put on top, it's a oilos soif. You're supposed to put on top. If you put it on the bottom, lo kiper. So we have really you don't need to comment on the oiso. It's more of a Let me just make sure I'm not missing anything. I think Oh. Okay. Got it. Says the Gemara, "Loy. In my mind with the two of them sh'nitan dam l'maala, you can make a distinction between the upper bloods and the lower bloods. Why? The lower bloods that you did above, she'ein tzei from l'maala. They they they don't belong on the top. They never go on the top. That's why lo kiper. Tanya b'eil yainam. But the upper bloods sh'nitan dam l'mata, She has my heart of the matter. Remember we had a Sugya similar and this drove me crazy on the plane because I thought I gave wrong shot in that Sugya. Why? I'll remind you. Tell me what you say. What the bloods that you go on the top, they go to the bottom. So, you remember we had that and that was right. And what what was the what did I say shot then? Why did they go on the bottom? It drips down. And I look at Rashi and Rashi says no. You put the Shirayim on the bottom. Like woah, maybe I said wrong shot there. But, no. Baruch Hashem, until I found it. It says over there, what? Yeah, Rashi over there says it drips down. Yeah, yeah, that was right. Rashi over there until I found it. You know what I'm saying? Khazain is a long time ago. Khazara. What Khazara? >> [laughter] >> So, over there that's the shot. It drips down. Over here we're talking about Shirayim. I wasted the whole Sugya Shirayim. The leftover. Oh, I got to tell you this Shirayim I saw it's a Maiseh Shehaya, but it's so it's so happened to me that I got to tell you. There was a Maiseh Shehaya there was a guy in the Ger Tish. You can imagine thousands of Hasidim. And this guy really wanted a strawberry. He wanted a strawberry. So, he screams out. He goes, "Benny tooth." Now, the problem is that the he didn't realize but the Rebbe went like this. He did like one of these motions that tells them quiet. And when he goes like this, it's quiet. Thing is he didn't see it. So, he screams out. IMAGINE. "BENNY TOOTH." AND THE PLACE is quiet and he screams, "Benny tooth." And the whole place looks at him like, "Woah." You want a strawberry? Okay, we'll say that. But, like in front of the area it's shush still. And they always this this guy's name everywhere he went for the rest of his life he's Benny tooth. That that was his name. Benny tooth. Like that's how you would know him. Now, for whatever reason is that Twillery? That that's the guy gave me that exact suit. For free. Like I walk in the Twillery. No, but I have I have ADD. Ah. Yeah. No, I want to say you should go to Twillery. I walk in there and the GUY GOES, "AH, >> [screaming] >> I CAN'T BELIEVE IT. DO YOU KNOW TAKE SHOES. TAKE THIS. TAKE THIS." HE GAVE ME like five bags. He sure goes crazy. Spicy. Spicy. This I never got so many hugs in my life. Never. The same guy. Kept coming over to me. >> [screaming] >> He's like attacking me. He's kind of sickly. The guy. You know what I'm talking about? No, I have. Okay. Oh, you know the guy I'm talking about? He has that kind of energy the whole time. I was like, "I got to hook you up with this This is a white suit. You got to see this. Oh, it's going to look so FANTASTIC ON YOU. SPICY." FINE. Back to the story. >> [laughter] >> To my mazel and it happened now also. I'm in America. I come back to Eretz Yisrael. I go to play Shmuel. And the guy goes We're saying Tam to the brocha. We're saying brocha. I scream out. And the whole place looks at me. >> [laughter] >> I'm in America when they change it. What a bizayon. And I'm like, "What? What Why is everybody singing at me?" they changed it. Oh, you know in front of 150 people. One year goes by. I'm in America. I come back. Same shul. Different chazan. The shaita. In the middle of Shmoneh Esrei. We're saying Tam to the brocha. And nobody's correcting him. So, I scream, "The same brocha." The whole The whole place mouth bush of what is the second year I'm like, "Oh, what?" And it just happened this year. It happened again. I'm in America when they switched it. I don't know. I have a mazel of going to America during the switch. Anyway, just thought I'd tell I'd share with you my bushah. Then he said he was here a guy he he he tells he corrects the chazan at the Sefirah timer. But, he corrected the wrong [laughter] day. The chazan was right. He was in America. He comes back. He's in the wrong Like he said he was in a different place. He corrects the guy. Anyway, fine. Zacht in the matter. Uh where are we? Damin Apnimim Yichihu She Yesh Mim Kor B'Chutz. The Shirayim. You know, even when you do inner bloods in the Heichal, you still have to pour the blood. Where do you pour? You don't pour it in the Heichal. There's only one place to pour the blood and that's outside. V'In Nosnim B'Techilah B'Chutz like Kipper. And if you do if you put it to begin with to start out with outside, there's no Kaparah. And the same thing should be with Shirayim. Lo. Remember the Damin Apnimim Shem Mizbei'ach Pnimi M'Markiv. No, you can't bring a Raya. You know why? Because the inner bloods that they they don't have um like a a Kaparah from the Mizbei'ach Pnimi. Torah B'Yanam Shari Kronos M'Markiv Eisam. What? Okay. So, it's really like a Kula. The the Chatas is much more Chomer. Why? If you miss one one um the Chazan you miss one Chazah, it's all over. But, Aliyonim Shari Kronos M'Markiv Eisam. They they they have a Kula. There's a That's how I learned it. There's a little bit of a Kula here. In Nosnim L'Matah K'Sherim. And if so therefore, it makes sense if you put it below the the line, it's Kosher. Tamud Lomud, that's why I need I saw I saw She Nitan Damin L'Malah Lo She Nitan Damin L'Matah. You can't You can't switch it around. If it belongs up, you put it up. You put it down, you're not There's no Kaparah. Mai Shem Mizbei'ach Pnimi M'Markiv? What do What do you mean that the inner Mizbei'ach doesn't give it a Kaparah? Lo Elo Shirayim. So, you see that Shirayim is Markiv. Omer Levi Yochai Eicha Tzeh B'Gava Chomer. So, L'Chorah according to what you're saying I have a Gava Chomer. Mai Shirayim Apnimim She Nosnim B'Chutz? The Shirayim the inner Shirayim. But, it comes outside. You have to bring it outside afterwards as soon as B'Techilah B'Chutz like Kipper. Nevertheless, even though eventually it's going to come outside. But, if you started the the Zois you do it outside, there's no Kaparah. So, certainly Hanitanim L'Malah She Nosnim L'Matah. When you put blood on top and there's no no no no reason to bring it below the red line. V'Nosnim B'Techilah L'Matah Yidnei Sheli Kipper. If you put blood where eventually it's going to go which is outside. Eventually you have to do Shirayim outside. And you start out the the Z'rikah you do it outside, it's no good. So, if you put blood where eventually doesn't go, of course it's not good. Elo Mizbei'ach Pnimi M'Markiv Bilvad Elo Paroches. So, we have to switch it around. We're not talking about You're right. We would have a good Raya here that Shirayim is Markiv. But, we're not talking about Shirayim. What we're talking about is Paroches. You have to switch and and say where the Raya is from Paroches. Here, this is the Zois of Paroches. That's what he's trying to say. Remember we had Zois inside? Inside means the Paroches. Torah B'Rabbonon, just one short Sugya here. Hopefully we get there before Shacharis. Torah B'Rabbonon B'Kipper and then actually we had this Khazara. This Khazara whoever did Khazara remembers this. It says two words, B'Kilah he finished M'Kaper. Which I don't know how to translate exactly. M'Kaper he'll get a Kaparah. Im Kipper Kilah. If he did the Kaparos if Im Kipper Kilah. It once he did the Zois he finished. He finished. He's finished his job. In other words, what happens afterwards the Shirayim is not so important. He did his He did the the Zois. Im Lo Kipper Lo Kilah. If he didn't do the Zois, he didn't finish. Divrei Akiva. Omer Levi Yochai. That's Divrei Akiva. So, we have a Divrei Akiva Divrei Levi Yochai. Omer Levi Yochai Omer Divrei Levi Yochai Omer Divrei Levi Yochai Omer Divrei Levi Yochai according to you it should have said not Divrei Levi Yochai Omer Divrei Levi Yochai. Why shouldn't we say Im Kilah Kipper? If he finished, he got a Kaparah. Not if he did a Kaparah, he finished. If he finished, he got a Kaparah. It fits better into the words. >> [snorts] >> But, basically they're saying the same exact thing. There's just what word do you say first? Again, Divrei Akiva says if he is M'Kaper, he did the Zois, Kilah he finished. And he's saying if he finished, then he gets a Kaparah. But, isn't that the same thing? Im Lo Kipper Lo Kilah Shemchizah Kol Hamitanos Lo Yotzei K'lum. If he It's coming to say that you have to do all the Matanos. That That's what Divrei Akiva said. Divrei Akiva said if you do all the Matanos, you get a Kaparah. Mai Beinaihu? So, what's the difference between them? Divrei Akiva Divrei Shmuel Levi. This is a Machlokes if there's a difference or not. No, no, no. They say the exact same thing. The question is how do you want to read the Pasuk? You want to read it B'Kilah M'Kaper or M'Kaper B'Kilah? But, they're saying the same exact thing. Chazal Omer Shirayim Makrivim Beinaihu. No, there is definitely a real Machlokes L'Maiseh. What if you didn't do the Shirayim on the Zois? Do you get a Kaparah or not? The Sta'im Divrei Shmuel Levi who the Omer Shirayim M'Markiv. It's Divrei Shmuel. We have a Machlokes between Divrei Akiva and Divrei Shmuel Levi whether or not there's a Machlokes at all. Here, we have a forced Divrei Shmuel Levi said that one of them somebody holds that Shirayim is Markiv. Omer Divrei Shmuel Levi the Divrei Omer Shirayim Makrivim. Oh, according to that person that says Shirayim is Markiv. In other words, Shmuel Levi holds one of these Tana'im holds that Shirayim is Markiv. Maybe Paroches D'Matah B'Techilah B'Fnim. You bring one You have to shecht from where we Let's say the blood spilled. So, you bring another par and you start from there. Because if you think about it, Shirayim means leftover of something. So, you got to shecht and then you have leftover. And you continue from that point on. Omer Divrei Akiva Divrei Shmuel Levi Omer Divrei Akiva also agrees that somebody says that Shirayim is Markiv. So, they're both saying the the thing. Divrei Shmuel Levi Omer Divrei Akiva. Yet, they're arguing whether there's a machlokes. How can what what do we do here? Although R' Yochanan lastly has four of them, R' Yochanan told R' Nachum R' Shimon Magrim. There is a man who says Shimon Magrim. So, what are we going to do? Yes, there's a tanna that says that Shimon is Magrim, but not R' Yehuda or R' Akiva. In our machlokes that we just brought down with R' Yehuda and R' Akiva, we still don't know who says what. It's Yes. Both R' Yochanan and R' Shimon Levi say that there is a tanna somewhere who holds that Shimon is Magrim, but we don't have a raya whether they're talking about R' Akiva and R' Yehuda. Raboisai, have a wonderful day. Merit the zchus of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shiur today. mdy.sponsor.com or [email protected].