Daf Yomi Zevachim Daf 30 by R' Eli Stefansky

It's all [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] shy [Applause] [Music] anybody. Yes sir. >> Y right now. >> Yes sir. >> No. Thank you. Uh is it is Yontiff for anybody? No. Okay. Some people by by they're by Cass right now. >> Zoom. >> No. You allowed to leave it on maybe. I don't know. This is uh Yante. I didn't have a chance to I still didn't have a chance to see all the I'm sure there's a lot of videos circulating and all that >> and uh I just want to share with you one in case you didn't see this one I liked a lot because um he came with a little of an esrig he prepared he bought a l of anrig for his son he said is coming out during and he got him like on the tail end with just a few minutes left when when was it it was 10:00 10:00 by us in the morning. So, it's like towards the it was the last day towards the LA here. He is um I couldn't edit and I couldn't take out that my computer was water spilling and everything. So, I as just to throw it in from this point so you don't really see the little Vanessa. It's there. I saw it, but there's a woman holding it. So, we're going to go from here. [Music] It's unbelievable. No, that he could say he could say the braha at that point. I don't know how he had the to say the braha. Unbelievable. >> Headed straight >> tolli and those involved in this holy work. I wanted to thank you for 358 days, 514,560 minutes, 30,873,000 seconds since I started learning the D with you. In addition, I married to complete another year of something that hasn't happened many times before. What a joy to dance to with such a bundle of in my hands. I asked Chad to write a blessing fork in honor of and this is what I got my thanks this way but honestly it made me laugh so I decided to send it anyway this was we all hope you'll dance with the at least the way you explain a difficult tus with lots of hand motions a smile and medu and a voice that reaches all the way to the mean and flatbush maybe continue spreading smiles like you spread diagrams in the she entices himself wouldn't know exactly how he got there may you never run out have sponsors and may you merit many more that I'm not sure about that's when you give strategy in other words he's saying a lot of people should be nif even if not everyone pronounces it right may the garra always remain for you not just a d but a daily daf of joy may always find a place to throw in a mahay withki even if it's not exactly on topic that was a good one okay may we all know that with gumar art school ribbelli you can reach the Sum even when you're listening at two times speed. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Momo Cohen Elite. >> Who's >> No, it's not your son. No, no, no, >> no. Sh doesn't have a son that old, I don't think. How's your oldest? Shabsi doesn't have a mom. >> 20. >> Oh, yeah. Okay. That mom is >> We have We have the guy himself. Hill himself is here for the You said it in Hebrew. Get get over here. Say it in in English for a second. I said over what you said, but if you're here, you're already here and you're wearing the MDY cap. >> Hold on. No. Stand next to me and you can hold this now. This is a little bit more. I'm sorry if you're unprepared. Go. >> Go. >> Well, you first I'll I'll preface this that you didn't want to speak in public. You said it's not your thing. But when I told you that it's going to be one of the yid, you said, "Okay, I'm doing it. Let's go." >> Thank you. Thank you, Ellie. It's really Bisutka and Bisut the Dafyomi. I managed so much this year. Uh I I've been learning for over a year now. The Duff I started in in Babakama um with with MDY and because of this I was able to earlier this year to the first time in easily over 20 years to be to do the whole and finish Srias beginning to end. Uh and and I did and I did this year for the first time I I did mikra katarum. I didn't even know that such a concept existed until this year. >> We have as well we did it together >> really the whole tour. And I I was told earlier today, you know, I I cuz in the previous video I said if I can do it, anybody can do it. But everybody has their bundle. Everybody has their package. And you really you just need to try. You just need to to to to start take the first step and commit yourself to day by to every day. >> How many minutes does it take you a day? >> It depended on the on the part. 10 minutes. 10 15 minutes every day. >> How about you? >> A little longer. >> Little longer. >> Yeah. >> It depends on your reading skills. Yeah. Yeah, >> if you read quicker, it's quicker. If you read slow, it's fine. About 10 minutes. Okay, >> 10 minutes. >> Thank you very much. Thanks for the Wow. But you know, there's going to be people out there. They're going to start and because of you. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Sponsored by David Salomon. Dedicated in memory of the sponsored by the following five people. sponsored by Sky Brook Capital and of our friends mayor Kovac Taki and John for the devotion study and the shar join my father jacked anonymous ubiashmas mdy coffee corner month rift gun drpstein pray for complete and speedy recovery for Dr. Harold Goldmire monthly sponsors anonymous from London Father your big heart and giving to the community is inspiration for all of us and Leo anonymous in honor of her birthday for raisingly sponsors Hey HK ventures and forma Elabascano anonymous in the merit of Braha Bakana for good health. Daily sponsors Rabbi Fishelad in memory of my grandmother and family. Hashem taken by the Nazis. The second days of sukus. Amen. Here we go. We could just go back a couple of lines from the end of the Mishna on that base. You go to the Mishna on the end of and you go down the Mishna. It's a long Mishna that we said it was pretty simple things that concepts that we're familiar with and it says Omar by me. It's eight lines from the bottom of the DAL. This is the rule. We're actually going to talk about there's a rule. When you have a rule, there has to be at least two things in the rule. Has to come to include something else says. So all is saying depends. We're talking about somebody that had uh more than one thought in his mind. So we're talking about pagaz is when a person thinks in his mind as he's performing the mdash, he thinks that he's going to eat this animal. in a year from now. He thinks he's going to eat it past the permitted time. So if you're allowed to eat this animal for 2 days, he thinks in his mind he's going to eat it 3 4 days from now. And then he goes ahead and eats it. Here it gets a little people have a little bit of a hard time here. He eats it. Then he's when does he eat it? Anytime after the he has to do all the four. [Music] Um after this he ate it okay then if he didn't eat it we saw malus according to says if a person had two thoughts it depends which thought came first did he have the thought of or the thought of mak we didn't discuss mak it's the same idea he thinks in his mind that he's going to eat this carbon outside of outside of the base of English. If it's a carbon he can only eat in the base of English, he thinks to himself he's going to eat it in. If it's a carbon that he can eat in because it's so he thinks himself he's going to eat it. That's never gets cars. So says if you allow the of time to catch on because you did it first then it's cars. But if the first maka was the lesser one that you're going to eat it outside of your and only afterwards you had a thought of but what does it mean you had a thought afterwards? What's afterwards a minute later two hours later? Maybe it means in a different you had one by and then the second one you had by or maybe it's within the same thing. It's one after another. Boom. Boom. What is it? So, let's skip to the where it says we're talking about that he had one thought of I'm going to eat it outside the time by let's say and then by this he had another that is he's going to eat it outside the place and that says that you get kus. Why? because you allowed the in between. There's two different avoidas. One was the kabala, one was the zer. During the kabal, you had a perfect thought of I'm going to eat it outside a lot of time and you let it grabbed. So that's it for that moment. It grabbed. So now 5 20 minutes later you uh you went and you did and during that zika you thought okay I'm gonna eat it outside of your salah. It's not it's not good enough to undo the you had before the thought that you had before but if it's during one performance of you you were receiving the blood and it's second number one you thought to yourself I am going to eat this outside the latter time and then 10 seconds later as the blood is flying into your cle say oh and also I'm going to eat it outside of your that's a combination of two different thoughts And what happens when you have a combination of two different thoughts during pigle it doesn't work. Ple has to be pure to be one thought only not two thoughts. So according to if it happened during one it doesn't matter how far apart within that avoid let's say let's say took him he's a really disgusting person he or he's old and he has a really rusty knife and he'sing slow. It's a twominut. It doesn't matter. It's within that two minutes. He had one in minute number one, another minute number two. It's a mixture of two different thoughts. Then it's not a real pigle. You don't get cars for that. Piggles by itself. One thought by itself. And this is going I really should have done maybe Gary could do for me. I like to do those, you know, over here. It's the mus called you should grab on to the first thing that comes out of the guy's mouth. We don't really care. We're not going to ask him any questions. We don't we we're not concerned what he thought and what he's going to tell us later. We're concerned about what is normal. When a person says something, he says or thinks something. In this case, he thinks slash he says it even with his mouth. He says, "I'm going to eat it outside the lot of time." Boom. We that that's the one that goes twice. Let's let us pay particular uh uh focus attention to that what he said afterwards is the shen I don't care about I care about says even if it's one one during he had two thoughts we go with the first one you could say here I don't know if it's you could say if somebody found it in some sort of safer great you say this has to do with not talking during kadesh different. You should grab your tongue first. Grab your tongue first. The things that come out of your mouth are the most important things. Maybe >> it's your okay. You don't want to give credit to Okay, I got it. >> They can take it, but it's yours. >> I don't know. Maybe I heard it once. Never heard it. You know all you went through them all. You're the Google of Shabarts. I'm going to fire you now in front of everybody. >> He's the giggle. He's the giggle of all. Very good. [Music] Okay. Whatever. You heard it here first from the Zen. Blame it on. Okay. He doesn't want he doesn't want to take credit for this. I can understand why great does a classic thing this whole long Mishna it's actually a very long Mishna because this is the tail end our Mishna that we see here on B we already learned is the safe of the Mishna that we had earlier. It's a long Mishna but don't we want to be consistent in the Mishna? Don't we want to be if the beginning of the mish is talking about the guy had thoughts during two so then the end is also two or no we're not so concerned so says the case that he when he did and then he did the two different so it makes a lot of sense now we're talking about two different that's what says matches the ratio matches the beginning of the mishna which I'm not so bothered by the was bothered by it. So the world knows better the rat is talking about two different well the ra is talking about one kazay and then the is talking about a half a kazay there's a lot of different cases in the mishna no for some reason let's be consistent the ra is talking about cuz maybe if you're not explaining oh that's the if the mission is not going to explain itself so once I know that we're talking about two so the whole the rest of the mission must be talking about the same case otherwise it's going to explain it maybe that's okay we're talking about one not in yes you could say but we learned in the number of I pointed it out you just read it this is the rule of cars if the pigle came before the then it works then you get cars because we're talking about one according to according to it's only in two accord either one two doesn't matter so I have room in my rule my rule is one or two that's why I have to say it comes to include even one but says it can't be talking about one avid it's two separate aid so what's this big rule that you're telling You saying one? Great. It's not a rule. Kasha, you're right. I got to tell you this. I said this to the guys in in the Hebrew here. Very, very important stuff. Mayor Plano, we all know Mayor Planka. That's it. He went back to to he told me we're not going to see him anymore. He's not coming. He went back to Toronto or something. He's on his way. I don't know. Gets her. I was walking with him. He's walking home and he says, "You know, in Toronto, we don't have a satellite location." Nobody wants to do a satellite location. That's what he said. There's no such thing. We got to get a satellation there. Say, you know what? You you make a video right now, 20 seconds, and I'm going to send to a certain guy. Maybe that will give him or I'll get sent to the whole group. I said, "Okay, go Toronto. Whoever jumps in and becomes the satellite location, the head of the satellite location is going to get all these going to have a crazy amount of people in these locations and you're going to be the one be the So, they sent it to the group immediately." this guy, I don't know if it was the one that he meant or not meant. I'm doing it. I'm in. We're starting Thursday right away. Thursday, the first day and we're going to do Thursdays and is into it. We'll do every day. Okay. Just wanted to say that's how it works. Got to go got to send the video got and go with it. Says, and if you weren't listening to the emails, today is the day. Today was after I actually saw somebody from the he was doing braces before I said that you're cheating not cheating and then everybody jumped on him and they they attacked him. The imams attacked him and said >> look what you did to me because whatever. Okay. Anyway, >> huh. >> No, he he it's him. He didn't say that. Anyway, the point is now is a great time to touch. Not going to talk about it much more. Here's your chance. Here's your warning. The year is going to go by before you know it. It's here and you can do what I did. I messed up this year. This summer I mish fell off the bat. It's very hard for me to do. You lose your consistency. You're in a different place. This Utah so I missed a bunch of but I made it up. I did my I did the trick. I did all the the ones that are and then I started plugging away. I saw that someone from you make it up at the end of the day. You make it up. >> I had you in mind. So you're Yay now. >> You had all of MDY in mind also. >> Everybody I got >> so nobody has to do it. Awesome. >> Have me in mind for the D too. I'll see you later. Okay. Awesome. He doesn't know what m should be gi [Laughter] [Music] awesome. Gi is your body otherwise known as goofi. >> Okay, good. Not awesome. Awesome. We're going to come up to a video. What's going on here? I heard too much. Oh, you guys not awesome. We know tomorrow. Everybody in MDY knows tomorrow. Hopefully the whole class knows what tomorrow is. Tomorrow I designate this animal as a carbon. All of a sudden, a much nicer beautiful animal shows up and I say to myself, wait a minute. It's like a Srig. If you have a a gishmak ring and then you see even a nicer you get the nicer right this beautiful I want this to be instead of this that is a isa why I don't know that's what hashem said and they both they share now they this one becomes like this but that's it he's stuck they're both at and what he did is wrong no good now what if a guy says he look he has he's walking with three animals he has a and a schlam And he sees this beautiful atom. He says, "You know what? That beautiful atom should be both an you can't have two two coronets in one. They're contradiction. Goes in and you burn it completely." Is something you could eat. No connection, but that's what he said. Now, there's different ways you could say it. It's a little bit of what we're going to be discussing. Not a little bit, a lot of bit of what we're discussing today. How he said it and what did he mean. Look at look at what is he says this giant beautiful fat animal is a he says two times the word what he could have said is no no no he says now I could explain it that he yeah he he uh he he messed up he realized immediately he messed up he says no no no in his mind the nose was in his He repeats the whole thing. Why do you have to say another word? He could have just said if he really meant to be crazy and to make one animal two, he should have just said that's not what he said. He said maybe without a pause with a pause. Doesn't matter. But he said the word twice. Here, check out this video. Love it. There's a lot of humor in here. What? >> Yeah. Here he is. Here's the on the right on the left. What should I write on the sign? What should I What am I? Who am I? What? What do I do now? >> Okay, you might. He said a little funny doesn't know what says but okay. So what's that is here we go with the first what what do we call that? We grab the what if the first thing that came in his mouth was he said a second later. No we go with the first one. Now I want you to pay attention here because the is going to say doesn't argue with and immediately the shuts it down. What do you mean they argue here? This is right over here. So remember it. If if he really wanted to to make both of them, he wanted to make that one giant this guy right here on the screen. He wanted to make him and what is he supposed to do? He's not there. How how is he supposed to say it should be both? So he said that's what he wanted to do. I raised it. Oh. So in other words, I say what he's saying is I say that it should be both. Both of them should be it should be both. So we have to remember this because we're going to this is going to come up two three times maybe three four times even. We might not even mention it one or two. But let's say now what happens when it's both? Well, okay. It's both. Now what? What do you do? Huh? What do you do? It's both. Now what? You're not going to bring it as it's cooler. You're not going to bring as because what do you do? [Music] >> So you bring it to land. [Music] This is what we call giry stove. You let it graze until it befalls the moon. Either they have a special part for this or not, but you let it and then you sell it. And now he buys with the money he buys an. And what do you do with you put on but in this case Rab say in this case you take the money and you divide it half okay this is an addition to that video in other words first you make sure it gets a boo boo a mum a real mum broken leg then you sell the brokenlegged animal carbon whatever money you got 100 bucks 50 goes to 50 goes to why because it's both it's a Great. Okay. So, we're going to see that three times today. It's not important to the I'm just telling you what what happened. But says continues. If he said, "I want this to be I think everybody knows the the answer to this question." He said, "I want this." Then he took a nap. He paused and then he said, Haruo. He made a nice pause over there. You guys are getting uncomfortable. No, >> you're like trying to help me out. He made a pause. He stopped. So, of course, the first one goes, "Okay, so does he argue with?" Absolutely. Saying something completely different. What if he removes that word? Yeah, I think we had I didn't even show this on Friday, but I mean it's not a big deal. The first one was in other words, he says the word twice. Now we're asking what if he says, okay, he just took out the word. This is a lot what a lot more likely. He you're serious about making this one animal two two different things. [Music] Now another question here. Maybe you don't need the lam over there. The point is he's literally dividing it. He himself is doing the division. This last case is going to say that he he he didn't there's no retraction here. He's actually explaining what he wants. He's saying this one giant animal this 200 pounder 100 pound he's not retracting anything he's explaining what he wants and that's why both of them are it's both and even in this case where he says check it out he says and you grab the first language and what happens it automatically spreads to the rest of the animal even though he said Mayor you say that this certainly there's no saying what about we had in the person he says one is for I'm gonna eat it in three days from now and one I'm gonna eat it in other words he in one. Isn't that you have you have one animal has a bunch of kazm. What's going on? >> It's a hangover. >> Very good. Very good. So, some noise coming out of there. Me and my noise. So in the in the oneita he's doing two things. He's saying one for one. He's doing and he told me that in this everybody agrees that both of them should happen. If if you're talking about that, when does the happen? That's that's another when does when does the occur? When is when he starts cutting and let's he goes let's he has in order for him to chef and he has a very dull knife to go back and forth four times. When did the happen? throughout the entire four times or all the way at the tail end when he got the two seim on him the trachea and the esophagus boom he cut them that moment that's so we have so if you say it's the last moment then the the two the two the happened simultaneously the same exact millisecond because the happened in one millisecond so the occurred in one in one millisecond. But you should know a guy when a guy is cutting the it's a long process and therefore as he's cutting the trachea he thinks as he's cutting the esophagus he's saying it's two different sim we're not going to go into the The point is it's like a whole thing in itself >> for what >> like two >> not okay two is a little strong >> two parts of the one a for instance is going to bring in a second I'll give you a a guy's walking with the blood from point A to point B it's 25 feet to get to the every step that he takes is is part of the but it's it's another thought one thought two thought three it it's a process it's not a millisecond it's a whole process that I could throw in different especially if it's a whole like he said it's a whole piece it's a it's a whole esophagus and here's a whole trachea it's not half of the esophagus and another half of the esophagus it's this whole sim for this for that as very nice But you can't say when it comes to to to taking a fistful of of flour because over there there aren't two parts. There's only one part. It's this. That's it. How you going to divide this into two? Let's see it again. Now there's a little bit of a different one that Yoshi was able to make. This is very complicated to do this in AI. Why? I don't know. I don't do AI, but he explained to me that it's the the detail and the control. Still going a lot, but okay. That's another coin holding it. He's supposed to like Okay. With his thumb, with his second first part, he puts a second part. >> No, but that's already two aidas within the one a >> but is going to say something similar. See in a second says one there's one says you know we had this this is the leav right frankincense right over here something like that okay the I don't know if this is exactly it but on top of the flour there's also a spoonful of this. So when he brings it, we're not talking about the say we're not talking about the kam. We're not talking about this part. We're talking about a part that he's not showing in the video. That's the part putting it on and this goes by itself and the flower goes by itself. So it's two different parts. That's like that's like this that we said before says very good when he spoke when he when he thought about it was when he was doing the the flower when he's thinking about was when he's doing the so it's two separate things. sinners or a guy goes into and he can't afford a regular carbon and he can't even afford a bird. So he said, you know, bring 25 cents of flour over there. There's no remember said and Rashi explains, we don't care about your Hashem said it has to be a terrible like a ugly carbon without any oil, without any frankincense, nothing. Plain flour. So over there, how you going to say there's two parts? There's no two. There's only one part flour. You're right. And there's over there. No is over there. and comes around say you know what maybe there's over there see us because as he's walking with it in the there's each each one is another when it comes to when a person says he talks about one animal he says half and half there's no everybody agrees that he meant to to to split it up that even in a case He said holds like is still going with that what we should really make you gave up on me right we're going to do the whole thing with it. It's not we learned in our of course depending what comes first. If comes first so goes when you really want to look into it. So I pointed out before we have they say straight out it's love they argue what they argue they don't argue what they don't argue meaning that they both agree that you don't say twice a second ago we said that mayor you say twice no they both agree there's no when a person says I want this to to apply itself. I want it to be and then and he says and afterwards I want this to be and afterwards it should be because he said it first should be this and then it should be that. So the first thing is is is what what applies itself. But if he says, he makes a stipulation, he makes a condition, he makes a the only way I want to work is if so I'm sorry we're talking about an animal here I the only way I want this animal to be a is if it's so then both of then it becomes both it becomes and what do you do land then you take the money and You put it in the pushka. You put half. What was your name again? >> Uncle Benant. >> Bellfant. >> From van. >> Born in Sweden. Danish. >> Wow. >> No. Stop. Stop right there. You live in Sweden. Unbelie our first helmet from Sweden. Give. >> Okay. New. And then afterwards I lived in Switzerland after >> Yeah. in >> all the exotic kind of places. >> My wife passed away and moved to London. >> Wow. >> Live in. >> You live in London now. Welcome, welcome. Okay. Oh, sponsors turning of the Dar global specialist in international financial services anonymous has anonymous and this in support of that all test should come back 100% healthy for me and my family. Okay. Um says when he says the double lion here if you want to see the top one he says the the lion that seems like he's saying two different things he should have said this the middle line he should have taken out the word and he didn't do that obviously he's retracting he middle in middle of a middle. Oh yeah. No, he couldn't have said this. The middle line over there. He's thinking to himself, how could I say that? That would mean 50/50. Each one this animal should be 50. No, I don't want 50/50. I want 100% 100%. Whatever that means in his mind, he wanted it to be 100% 100%. And what do you do? You're actually and you divide the money. Have your I say that they do argue. In other words, even when a person says the middle line is going to hold I go with the and I ignore the Here's a Gishmakya. It It's just a It's a fun suga if you but you got to pay attention. It's it's it's it's really interesting. Like you'll see what I'm talking about in a second. So let's let's say here let's talk about this. It says in the Mishna this is just a quote from our Mishna. If a person says or So we have what's look peaks because he he mixed the two what's since he mixed the two the It's possible. It's not. It can't be pigle but it's possible. Okay. Now here are the options. Did the mish say? It really says that's what it says by us. If we read in the what it says want to know maybe it said this. That's what he really said. Now what's the difference between the two things? >> Do you see the difference? What? >> Oh, you're an Israeli kid. You lived here your whole life, right? >> Huh? >> Still the same car. >> It It's more both than the first one, right? >> Why? >> The only difference is that one VV. That's the whole difference. The first one I could maybe meant. Oh, no, no, no. Cuz maybe there's a little bit of a retraction there. I don't know. But when a guy says, he he's he's actually he's putting them both together. What about this one right over here? He says kaz once. He's like putting two things into one gaz. That would be the most the most likely that he he meant business. He meant to put both of them. The one on top least likely. The one in the middle, >> I don't know. Somewhere in between. >> What? >> More likely than the first one. less likely than the last one. Two is in between. So says comes and he says, "Does anybody here in Bville? I'm here. I'm on a trip to B. Well, I need to know if you what do you sayanistan? What do you say exactly?" So the explains [Music] maybe the the mission was talking about but when it says now the two thoughts go together and what happens when they go together is it pigle or not pigle this is a trick question >> huh >> why not >> because you have to have a clear pure masha and when you mix two mash together it ruins it it's not real pickle it might be possible but not you don't get cars perhaps. No, it's a number two. He breaks it down as two separate thoughts. And what do you do when the two separate thoughts? Very good. If the VV, which is more likely that it's one thing, he breaks it down to two. So certainly if there's no it's completely to and therefore and whatever he said first should go. Oh here it gets super interesting. You need this chart like you got to flow with me. 1 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 1. Okay. We're going to do it slow though. Well as slow as we can do before the Israelis start coming in here. Ley asks Rebi, Rebi is the one that authored the Mishna. Now he could ask him whatever he wants. What did you write in the Mishna? What's this question? What number did we just say? Three. You said the word once. It's both means. That's number three. What's that? He asks Rebi. Now why didn't he ask Rebi any other question? That's the of the Gom. He had the opportunity in front of Rebi the Galad. Why don't you ask him what's what's that of? So we have to figure it out. It's like one of these riddles. I'm serious. You know those riddles that you see a guy wearing a hat and there's no mirror. How many hats are you wearing based on how many hats he's wearing? It's a whole do a whole because if I was wearing two hats and he would have seen that I'm wearing two hats and he would have gone out the door and you know you know those riddles you have no idea what I'm talking about. I don't either know what I'm talking about. >> He had a rule only one question for sure. >> Oh very good. He had a rule. You see it's one question for sure in the one question you have to figure it out. So the is going to do it. It's very cool. >> I'm serious. And just to understand how deep Rebi was and what he put in the Mishna. He wanted he said one of the eyes and you're supposed to figure out everything else. So let's see. Wow, that's a very good question. You should know the number three like we kind of anticipated. It's a mixture of because he stuck it into one. He didn't say he didn't say one. Boom. You're done. That's the most obvious, but it's a good question. He tells him So now Reb's son, he has more access to his father. He says, listen, didn't you teach us in a could be these were even before Rebi? There's a says it says that's number one. all these cases. So, Reb's son tells him, "Why does the Mishna use case number one? Tell me number three." I'll tell you why. Because case number one, you could separate. You could say, "But not in case number three." That's why you you didn't put case number three in the Mish. You said case otherwise you would have put in it's obvious from the Mishna that case number three. It's so I don't understand why Levi even asked you. He should have just read the Mishna and see that we're talking the Mishna says Kazay and I would obviously come good. Oh yeah. He said, he's not exactly upset at him. He tells him, "Listen, you don't understand. I taught you one thing and I taught him something completely different. I taught you one and two." Yeah. So you can figure out that number three is is part of it's a mixture and there's no people they but ley I only taught him one which one let's go with number one [Music] and he heard say that they learned two one and two even he heard them talking about then he thought himself the what what what what Rebi taught me which is number one is that's the only one he taught and they messed up a little bit they added number two there and it's a mistake and number two would be probably a mixture of just like number three number two is also cuz he said kaz when I say number two and everybody's like on Spotify and they don't see what I'm talking about I feel bad sometimes I'll explain it Number two is Kazuk. Okay. But he's conf he was confused there. Maybe Revi actually taught them that one and two you could break it up. And and he he didn't tell me everything. He only told me one. So then just like he he didn't tell me the rest of the the rest of the cases. He only gave me one case. He didn't tell them all the cases and he probably left them. Case number three and that would be and that would teach us that what that the case number three is of. Now which one did he teach his son? Uh sorry Ley. Which one did he teach Ley? Which one did he teach him? Did he teach him number two? The middle one. And that's considered what? Two separate. Because he said even if he said above. Now if that's considered too what about number one >> 100%. Even if he says which is more likely that it's connected and he says it's not connected. So of course number one where he doesn't say he says it's certainly not connected that's considered two separate that's he didn't leave anything out of course is going to hold that's in number one that's certainly separated now it says so obviously he told him number one that's the one he told him and he didn't tell him what the rest of the are number two Three. Now ask why didn't Ley ask. >> Huh? I skipped what? >> Ah, I thought I said that. Oh, says obviously he taught his son the first one cuz if he taught him the second one it would be obviously what the first one is. They don't first one. Now the question is what did he teach? I'm sorry. Why didn't Ley ask him a different question? >> Why did he ask him number three? What's plain? You should have asked him what's his I'm only like like said I'm only ask him one question. So let me ask him one question I'll be able to figure all this stuff out from it. And here it goes. If I I can't ask him if I ask him. So depends what he's what is he going to answer me? I have to anticipate the answer. It's cool. I'm telling it's if I ask him number two what is he going to answer me? It depends on what he answers me. then I'll know where I won't know. If he tells me that it's mixed in, everything's mixed. It's one. So then if number two is one, then certainly number three where he only says one, everybody agrees with me. That's posh. But the problem is but what if he says number two is you break it down. Now I'm stuck. I don't know what the law is number three. If you break down number two, for sure you break down number one. But what about number three? I don't know. So that's not a good question to ask him. Listen to this. Hold on. That's not a good question to ask. I only have one question because I don't know what the answer will be. Depending on the answer, if he answers me that it's broken down, number two is broken down, then I don't have a good answer in number three. Did I skip that? Did I say it? But if he tells me it's broke, number two is broken down. I don't know. Says, so what did he gain? And what did he ask him? He asked him number three. So why is that good enough? That question. If he says that number three is broken down, then the whole list is broken down. That's for sure. What if he ate like if he tells him it's it's mixed. So now he only has an answer for number three and he won't know what to do with number two on that. The Gar says listen to this one cuz are you is anybody holding with me here? >> You won't know anything. >> You'll only know three. You won't know two and certainly not three. Yeah. You won't know anything. Yeah. says, "Listen to this and then we're basically done." You have to you have to use uh body language over here. It depends how Rebi answers. If Reb says, "What are you talking about? Of course, it's it's mixed makavas." Then then then number two is also mixed makavas. Like what's wrong with you? Why are you asking me such a silly question on number three? But if he says, "Oh, that's a good that number three is mix." Then I'll know that number two is not here based on his on his on his on if if number two is is a mixture. Number three is certainly a mixture. What are you what are you asking such silly questions? So that's why he said I'm going to pick this question and not only going to listen to what he says it's a mix but I'm going to say how he says it it's mix like not the he didn't not going to say that he'll say with a with a red face I do we have a second there >> second no just the it reminds me of the mice of salant he said he he I forgot exactly that he had to do chuva that what happened one time in his life he got upset he said that he He made this thing that um there was a mafa there was a how do you say a plague famous story there was a plague and he had 150 young guys deal with the sick bathe them and he gave them very strict instructions you have to be mal shabas all the time heat up the water this that don't skimp up skimp on the and he promised them that nobody's going to get sick even though they're dealing with these sick people so a guy came to him and said Listen, everything's good. It's beautiful and everything, but they're very they're not they're not mas like they're just and he got very upset at the guy and he said, I forgot the exact I don't want to mess it up. Something to the effect like you're not allowed to say that. I don't want them to be scared about Shabas for even one moment. They have to be Shabas in seconds and don't ever talk like that. And and then he said something like, "Do you think I would promise 150 people that they're not going to get sick if I wasn't sure that they have to be in Shabas and how important it is to save lives?" Oh, but he he got upset and for that one little cast he held he held it against himself for the rest of his life that I had to do chuva that he got upset at this guy for coming. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.