Daf Yomi Yoma Daf 56 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] today's share is sponsored i think anonymously in honor of the sponsors and the tutsis and mark ashkenazi and uncle phil befrat the flatbush mdy chavez mavor milava malcolm and zooming share it's so right now in new york in flatbush i don't know if there's a live picture or not the one that shows the most people that's that one they're all showing themselves they see ellie daiquim and i see mark ashkenazi oh here's the oil on my nelly diamonds let's see dikeman here we go wow wow look at that look at that oil that's a beautiful sight wow wow no he says that there's more people in flatbush than in this place matters it's kind of weak today actually let me hear you no come on don't make me join this [Music] [Applause] is [Music] oh [Music] [Applause] [Music] my [Music] hey it looked like the only guy singing in flatbush was fishel i don't know a little shop over there i can't hear exactly what he's saying but okay a big kayak and kiva zigler and mark ashkenazi for taking care of all the logistics and arrangements the evening expanse of this course for shidduch for sarah lina bass gold what she didn't get engaged yet money back guaranteed contributing to the food simon zellman ellie berman it's interesting because i was looking through my emails this morning and i saw an email from simon zellman i'm not sure if i read it or not it could be it sounds familiar he says like this but it's kidai the khazara i know i get these emails all the time but i feel that each one is a sheer that shared gives you as well as everyone else tremendous yesterday while waiting for my flight from miami to new york at the prompting of my wife i decided to watch this year earlier than usual across from me it sounds familiar this one across from me was sitting in family that you wouldn't be able to tell was very jewish now having to look up for a second notice that the father seemed to say bracha that's when i said the mice of the bracha yeah he's watching me learn couldn't resist to ask can you imagine a on the day of him kipper my surprise said yes he told me he's on the second cycle of the fioimi and he learns every day which moves a bit about the deaf how beautiful it is even around the world able to talk in their learning every day what a kabura and here it is tonight in new york monsieur chavez in new york sunday morning there's a stroll you then around the world talking and learning simon zelman from jay nathanson hey rebelli long time no email i would like to get into the hack about shaq otherwise known as hakashak khame vinoven hakashak the hak not the hack the hak okay there was a daf about a month ago where you showed a certain cartoon character depicting maharis i have it with me because today's daf was going to use it on today's dive but we'll use it for the email that day an hour of shabbos i was having a hard day but the picture lifted me up mom has changed my day who knows if your shack picture did the same to someone else it did tanakh mcseltzer keep trusting your gut he was having the best day ever and when i picked up that picture he's like no it went downhill came home he showed the shack picture again keep trusting your gut and call too nathan over there abby mandelbaum chavo atoll from teaneck i'm sitting here learning today's daf and you asked where do where do we hold like ramirez last night i asked the gemara passes like your mayor like you say 21 not 120 where do we say 120 in yiddish kite so he screamed out i yelled out since i have headphones in my ears sphero and kissy woke up as parents also all all the amazing edits answers from raviolis of billyak have been amazing can't wait to be home and back live but we'll miss the edits avi not anonymous mendelbell what else do we have here we have a picture there's a murray to get picture of reby stroll goldstein in mezvich look at this it's like it's literally from the storybooks it's good stuff and here he is here it is the vicar look look you can't you can you can't even make this up peel paint that's unbelievable yeah he's a photographer he's a photographer yeah next next one will be on the roof with tillow's thing all right when the islam in new york said that they wanted to do a special lava malka i spoke to the editors of uh izba hadar and decided to go a little easy on the island they're going to be able to leave a little earlier we got a two-line ahmed somebody i said that this is my favorite ahmad in shas and somebody said that i'm a big amarettes he wrote he wrote in he says what about lazar nazir deflaming bays guess how many words there's nothing let me give you a little base zero because the whole of the base is tysos so you see i'm not at mars i of course i knew about that one a magician needs to say something i can't just not show up so over here it's two lines and and it's quick if it's zero it's zero that that doesn't count that's not part of it our boy side here we are we are holding on daphne on the base we left a few lines here so it should be ganski schmuck today and we're in the middle of the suggest follows we're talking about a macholic is rubber yehuda in tanaka how many bases are there outside of the kardashian kardashian for to put down the blood there's two types of blood the blood from the bull and the blood of the goat is there two bases or one base rebecca is of the opinion that we don't have two bases because he might get confused and like this he gets to hold it in his hand and he has to do a switcheroo and like this will remember what he has in his hand but if he's able to put down the two bloods he might grab the wrong one when necessary he might do this recus with the bull blood instead of the sawyer or vice versa then the kimora says so why doesn't he just write down make two and right sawyer para and he'll know so the gemara tries to say the reader doesn't hold of siva in other words even if you write it down he can be confused but the gemara says how can you be confused famous i'll use this because i didn't use this last night even though i brought it here there there are 13 shy fries there are 13 pushkas of dhaka each one has another depiction on it it says nadava levina atesim so writing does work there's no confusion here it is you have you start from tickling tickle hatterton is number one take lonatika number three and you go in a circle where this is from that number 13 is right next to number one that was the idea then that's why they have to be in a circle then the dava is next to and if you go i brought this because when i was in new york last time the guys in new york look how beautiful they printed it unbelievable i think it was kraus i'm not even sure marcus chicken has a craft over here this is not so eska halton it's a beautiful uh drawing to show all the chauffeurs and everything but they're not in a circle so you have nadova over here and tickling hatterton over here they're not next to each other and they have to be next to each other okay i stopped my car started i shot this all the way from america so i could keep this it's hard to keep but whatever got it here yaakov look at the size of it okay then we went into so so we went into the the idea that contributor from these these 13 shai fries according to a buddha you don't have akatas in here it's all laila because we're concerned that he might make a mistake he might confuse the two he might mix them up i think mario says at the end we're talking about all the way at the end of the suggyo that we're concerned that somebody dropped money what happens if somebody drops money into the pushka that says kinim and it's kata's money and then he dies and we know for a fact that he died not a suffolk you know he died so now you have 50 people that put khatta's money into the pushka and we know there's one person in there that put money into the khattas postcard but he died now you can't use any of the money all 50 go to waste why because that the owner died and if the owner dies you can't bring it if you can't bring his you can't bring anybody else's that's we where we're holding right now says the gemara um six lines from the bottom the nivra arbor what's the problem you have a pushka with 50 piles of money and one of them you're concerned is khata's money that the guy literally died you don't know which one it is so grab forza's that's the value of a carbon cartos of this bird and throw it into the water chop it up grind it up either you throw it into yamamela so it goes to waste if you're going to throw it into the regular ocean chop it up throw it into the ocean so nobody can find it mma law i'll do something called breira retroactive clarification i love that from them very good from the art school retroactive that i knew clarification was a good one you could be viral in my freya you could go you could say retroactively this money is what this person put in now all they were trying to discuss how can you do that what comments also a bunch of comments fell into the pace of liquor food so i'll take out a bunch of it and say retroactively this is what can't do that or other so they this they they discuss this and they say that when you donate the money you make such a tonight it's unconditioned if something happens that you could undo it aquaponic let's use the idea of breira again let's pull out from the whole pushkar forzas the value of one bird katas and say this bird this is this is the money i don't know for sure but now i'm gonna retroactively say this is the money that the guy that died threw into the pushka and that money i am going to throw to waste says that's very simple rebuttal doesn't hold of the idea of breira and now digimon is going to go into just two places and figure out where does he say that there's no bravery he can't go retroactive it is what it is where do we see this idea element it says somebody buys wine from akushi what's a kusi akushi a bunch of people they have it similar nothing really changed people came in from different countries entirety stroll we're not sure exactly what their status is are they real garen or not real gary we know one thing for sure they were not jews when they came there to stroll and then they got punished the lion started eating them so out of fear they became gay remember was it sincere or not sincere are they real gayrim or not real game okay so let's assume that the real garum well even if they're real gay rim they didn't keep everything like jews they were very makel and they had different things different that so now you buy wine from acoussi you have to give it true muslims the problem is today whatever it is or if shop it's not air shops you don't have a cleat you can't pour the wine into anything you can't do it you you're on a trip you buy you need a drink you buy wine now what do you do this is eight so now the acoussi is slightly different than amaritz the picture of amarett akuzi takes true mycerius for himself but won't do it for other people it's very interesting texas goes through a whole thing okay they are not making it on the israel if they even see the mixture they don't care to trip other people up so they'll sell them things telling them that there's trump semesters they don't con they're careful with ghazal but they have an excuse for everything it's funny how nothing has changed byron had their about everything guzzle no it's not guess why is it not gazelle because there's no person that i'm stealing from it's all the queen in the world no client is coming to me and asking for it there's no tv great and another reason is i didn't take the truman yet so nobody could be too bad if i didn't i didn't separate it yet and finally they have a drasha not that not only are they mur heter but they're tamid they're navel and satora they never saw they they have a drosha bajata villa the guy that eats it he's the one that has to do not me so they don't take the troubles of mysteries so melee you have to take troublesome isis what do you do he stands and he says we're going back to our favorite thing true muslim maestros if a person has a bottle of wine he has grapes he has fruit he has to take or troubasomes what does he do so he only has to take one kernel for truma and give it to the kind but he's a nice guy nice people they do either one percent two percent he's large two percent sandwiches he left with 98. so from 98 he takes my serration 10 percent of that 9.8 so again true mcdouble is to the kind my surregion is to the levy 10 delivery then after he's done with that he the levy takes trumus meister from that we're not going to discuss that because that's not his problem we're discussing what the israel has to do it takes truma the miser and then myself shiny mice are shiny on years one two four and five of the shmita cycle he has to take ten percent and give it to himself he brings it up to you shalom and he he has a party you go to restaurants he eats food steaks whatever he wants with the money if it's too heavy it's too much for him to carry so he transfers it to cash to money and then he takes the money and he and he goes up to your slime with the money and with the money he buys whatever he wants to buy over there so this person schneiden shani austin la hafris hareen truma two percent that i am going to give in the future its future that is truman daphne aleph don't miss it asara myself ten percent goes to the lady not today tomorrow right now i want to drink i don't have where to put it in the future i'm going to give 10 percent to the lady tisho meiser shaney nine now i only have 90 left so nine ten percent of the ninety what's ever left i'm giving meister cheney my society on years one two four five and a nine on one two four five on three and six is meisser honey now he could do one thing right now he doesn't have a klee so he can't pour the wine in but one thing he could do he could take care of truma smizer of maester cheney you could take care of myself anyhow with cash so he opens up his wallet and he says the ten percent of wine that's in this battle should go into this cache so now mice or shane is taken care of whatever he could take care of he takes care of and that's what he does so he takes care of maestro shaini however the truman and the micer what goes to the cayenne and what goes to the levy the israeli took care of that he didn't take care of that he's going to do in the future and that's okay divi rebbe mayor so what does ramer hold we hold breira why right now he drinks from the wine in this wine there's ten percent micer and two percent truma and he drinks it what did he drink what's not true what's not my sir how do i know it's all mixed in because breira breira tells me that retroactive clarification when i get home and i have a cli and i pour out ten percent in the clay and then another two percent another glee that's what i meant to say that was the truma that was the micer i could go retroactive and today i could drink and not worry about it there's nothing mixed in what came into my mouth has zero trauma and zero miser because of the idea of breira it's an idea that we've discussed many times in shas and here it is again and every time we discuss it it's the same sugya that's according to ramer now we want to prove that according to rebi though he doesn't hold breira so romero says this is a good idea this is a good trick you want a drink now returning to the afternoon involvement base by the way this doesn't count you can't what we have a great rally of the rebuttals no braver alma embraer otherwise why would you why would review to say you can't do this trick let him just separate the true meister say it and then do the actual separation later on and we'll know le mafreia retroactive that that's what he was separated says the gemara it's not a good rayo dilmo shani hossom it says my first over there a good idea of why rabindra doesn't hold of it omro loyola mayor rabihuda ripchiven and rabiosi they told her mayor he atomido there's a major problem what if the glass bottle or the leather pouch that that's holding falls on the ground so schmetters into pieces and then you can never separate the tumors and nitrous and then retroactive retroactively it comes out that you drank devil aren't you concerned what do you do yeah the problem is not of breira the pro braver would work if you could get to the finish line and get home in one piece with the battle important maybe they agree over here there's a concern maybe the battle will break and if the battle breaks and you didn't do chromosomes retroactively because you couldn't it was impossible it's on the floor nimto choice it follow my freya that you drink devil and we don't want you to drink tavalama freya so melo we don't allow you to do troublesome stress lima freya m ibaka says remain i'm not concerned the guy's going to be careful it's a far-fetched concern i don't have to be concerned about such a thing however from their question that they were concerned so perhaps rebuda does not does hold the breira only in the case of wine he doesn't hold that you can do trims from maestrous and say it's retroactive because over there we're concerned that the battle will break hello says the gemara have another rayo miditoni the tony ayo and ayo is brought down a few times in shaz but all with this halacha he only says so here's the case going back to ireland is that if you're in your house or let's call this the end of the city your house then to the city you're allowed to walk 2 000 ammo in each direction on chavis that's it you have to stop after 2 000 so there's a trick what's the trick the trick is you put a meal down 2 000 from your house right over here put a challah an egg that's your meal and now you have 2 000 ammo from your challah going that way what did you do you didn't add any ammo at all you have the same amount of ammo what you did is you shifted the picture so this was the center beforehand and you have 2000 ammo going this way and two thousand ammo going this way now you just shifted everything now instead of the house being over here your khala is your house your kainashvisa over here and now you have two thousand ammo this way and two thousand ammo this way but guess what you cannot even go one amma this way you're stuck this is the end all you did is you took this picture you shifted it over this way or you shifted it over this way so the mars says we have a situation you have you have two tutorial coming to give it russia on chavez and you don't know which you want to listen to daily one is coming from the east one is coming from the west so what do you do you set down two aruvei trumen now it's awesome to use two with whom you can only do one so what do you want to do you want to use breira you put down two and then when you decide which time you're gonna go to then you're gonna say oh retroactively on friday that's the a-robe that i placed this one is cancelled i'm using this one when you decided on shabbos because i'm going retroactive we're getting there in a second that's that's the next case so did anybody ever have a promise you in their life did anybody ever come out of trump you did you may have i was in a camp i might have said this but it doesn't matter it's there's not enough time else i'll make it quick there was no nice and slow my parents decided to send me to a camp a sleep-away camp in niger's trial there's a reason why they don't have sleep away camps here they're not very popular because of this myself it was in kamehameha it's a seven day camp so right away i knew these issues first night we're on a sleep away trip somewhere and we had a guy a guard with a machine gun so he says who wants to volunteer to watch the night shift it's me i get the old machine yeah you can tell the machine gun okay you get from two to three so somebody wakes me up at two o'clock i'm walking around with another 12 or 12 years old with a machine gun loaded fully loaded machine gun walking around and everybody's sleeping in sleeping bags and also we hear noise and we got really scared it turns out it was like a horse like grazing over there okay great the following morning we go to nachayudia there's two ways to do it you could either there's like a how tall 10 meters or something 20 meters he says eight you say 20. it's by the joe by the jump the run how many the run says it's eight it's eight eight meter most people they come this way and they jumped eight meters into the water there's a pool on the bottom and there's a waterfall that's eight meters but we were young we were only 12. so he said you you are gonna swim across this water body of water and then climb up the waterfall there's a rope there you climb up disaster kids are drowning i'm not exaggerating the whole camp has to cross not half the kids don't know how to swim who knows how to swim over by the water and as we're trying to get to the other side this guy a yeshiva boy on top goes one two three and he jumps it's not funny because he never came out in front of the whole camp he died he drowned in from the whole camp cancer disaster after disaster this camp was a disaster come shabbos now yeah i'm not exaggerating we watch the the army come and take take him out find him take him out meanwhile we didn't have any water because we ran out of water so we had to drink the water the water from the pool but there was a dead bat in the pool it was it was disgusting it was it was terrible situation kids are so much shabbos mice is for the guys in new york so on shabbos me and my friend decided to take a nice spatier so we take a switzer we're about a hundred feet out of the camp like the komamil like we're going through the fields and also i don't remember who said who was like wait a minute what about we heard about something and we're 12 years old we don't know what two thousand hour now two thousand i'm thinking now two thousand amma is four thousand feet it's almost a mile i don't think we walked them out probably a hundred maybe twenty five feet it's like so we went to oscar garage the whole thing could we go back to the camp there's there's another community there all i remember is a team money rabbi with nana t the whole thing and he gave us some sock and i think we made it back to our camp that was my experience with the trum never had enough how did it get to the guy dying in a pool i have no idea somehow okay in america it doesn't really happen the whole thing because it's like from from the end of the community from the end of the city here in arizona maybe outside of pajamas if you start walking over in the mountains it might be a problem really says arie that in gimel they used to they had marks in the tree to tell you that that's what trump is very nice okay oh upstate in new york upstate in the mountains exactly but it's five two thousand am is a long distance three thousand feet okay yeah but still the law it's kind of it's a hike okay gevaldic okay another something no okay right there it says like this the tony ayo review deutsche so the mars is like this if if this hakam is on an angle i don't remember saying this in aravind but i noticed that in rashi here says balaksan i just thought that he doesn't know where he's coming from but no the has the way to get here and here in his room he's on an angle you just don't know he's going to show up to the right or to the left that's your thing if it's just the direction is is you don't know what direction it's not to not and you're going to choose i'm going to go to rebeccava and not tour of mayor that's not what's happening it's one rebbe kiva he's over here and he might decide to come and surprise everybody on the east side of the city or he might do it on the west and then you're doing two a ruben that's okay valvina ball and we asked what how do you have one that could come from one so that's not because because it has to be it has to be a mathias it's that he is there it has we'll see in a second because it happens you just don't know what that happened the embryo when you have tutorial common like in this case you say it doesn't work you can't pick and choose you can't decide on shabbos whichever you want to use because you don't go retroactive limits you're going to marry me and breira so what's the difference so this one also there's no braid what happened was the showed up it's just you don't know the it's there it's just your lack of knowledge so mama when when did this era of when did it happen not on chavez you put down the area of our neighborhood shabbos it's actually kalanirov champions you said i'm going to put an area of wherever the hakam showed up he already showed up on friday so it's not a question of breyer it's not a retroactive it's a you just found out on chapters which one of your a reuven worked but it worked on friday one of them on friday was no good one of them worked because i said i'm i want the a roof that's closer to the rov that's the one i want to work on friday night on shabbos so it's not a question of of breiro what do you see from here that if these two tamil ham review the holds there's no breyro you don't say brero if there's two of them this case right over here review this says no it doesn't work why because i cannot decide on java is which area i want to use that will be retroactive clarification and retroactive clarification doesn't work according to review though so here's a rally that it doesn't work so let's go back you have a box full of money and in the backs there's a few coins that were deposited by a person who died and he said that that money should be for khatus and you don't know which coins are the one that from the person that died and which 25 000 coins are from all the other women who gave birth and and and and and want to bring their their their kirbanis for your lead that's from verzava and azava and make the the whole thing so why don't they do retroactive why they say let's pull out four coins four zuzia and say that's that's that guy that died the answer is because ruby huda doesn't know the breira he doesn't know the breira okay now that he doesn't hold the breira let's go step back so but he does hold of xiva you could write because look at all these ciphers each driver has a name each driver has a name so now it's just going back to the whole graduate this works these names work so if the names work so then why here's the mars original question then why according to who though don't you just write down two names on these two bases why is he so adamant that there's only one maybe there's two and one says para and one started and there's no not going to be any confusion just like there's no confusion in the base i make those 13 there's no confusion so then i have no confusion for two what's the problem let him just write down the name there is sibo says digimon but he holds that you could write and writing works not that you could write that the writing works yomaki purim and he's working really hard says if you have two bases and you put down both bloods why are you putting down both bloods because you want to do everything with your right hand and if you only have one base you have to start holding one and carry one and putting the one down you're using your left you don't want to use your left it's much better to have two bases but because he's in a fast state he might grab the the wrong one do you like because if you don't come out to the savara that he's fasting and he might make mistakes because of that but likes utter why do you need writing it's very passionate you a bull has a ton of blood and you have to grab all the blood and a goat has very little blood so one weighs 25 pounds and one weighs five pounds it's positive he's going to he's going to feel it like if you say well yeah bull has a lot of blood but he didn't receive it all in the clip that he has to receive all the diamond fish anything that didn't show us yeah he has to receive it it's better but let's say it's spilled most of it so now they're both equal in weight they both weigh the same amounts he's not going to realize and that's why you have to write it but there's another difference the blood of the bull remember when we had the five types of gold one of them was called pyruvate or something what was it called dam not power but maybe how did you do on the test good giveaway they took another test 30. i hope they all got 100 i hope somebody came over and said i got a hundred one of the coil guys because they give the answers afterwards as you walk out the united states i didn't get any wrong well let's see if they cheat a little bit if their shoe is going to give 100 or not razor shame yeah i'll be happy to pay that money the blood of a bull is much redder it's a deeper color like that gold the best gold par vanu i think it's powerful so you must come on to the svara and even though they're way different they look different he's still going to get confused because he's fasting because you go up on a on a bema the beam is higher than the show and always went down as a couple of stepped down in the ground so we're talking about i am kipper there's a hazard unlike today that we have all the magazines fancy that's that they had their they had to remember this is the all the suggests of the hazard making mistakes and he gets confused what confused didn't they it was about and he said so he's talking he's saying the avoider of the god oh in the basement and he says says that through two of these faces two he put it on the second one and then he says he takes the blood of the bull and puts down the blood of the goat who says that that's already revealed that there's only one otherwise you put them both down and then you grab one you don't have to do a switcheroo on my leg sorry says well you're mixed up you're confused he's in the middle of davening screams out [Applause] wow i didn't notice it and notice it now it says that it brings it into i wonder if that's seems like that's at least in the rambam is brought down like that okay that there's only one stand like ruby hudo alla perez now he's done with the two sprinklings inside the hey hull inside the kashi kadashim which was between the poles of the orin the sprinkling over there the bull blood the goat blood now he repeats the whole process outside of the doctrine why am i bringing it because of the next part whatever you did before inside the kaiju kardashian repeat step by step what do we have last night one's rika towards the top of the orange but obviously it doesn't touch darren it falls down on the floor and then seven more on the floor and he says but that's how we do it okay so that exact process happens again what does it say [Music] just like when you're inside the korean we do one on top and seven on the bottom from the bull's blood the same thing you repeat again interesting we had a spider here last night and he said that they do say ah but what and that's that was uh yeshua's father-in-law said he pointed out that ashkenazim for some reason we have to find out why we only say aksbachus three times and we're gonna say what so question is why do we say it only twice as we see here there's four hazards like that okay inspired them say it four times right that's what you said spiderman go through the whole process four times so mindlessly whatever sitting in trouble over and over let's go cut in half boom next the glimmer we just put involved yeah a month of sleep because they're not even keeping you you think they'll get a break no no they have to okay the same thing that i have for the gold i lied to those guys in new york they thought they have a break they're going to go home 10 minutes earlier if i went to the vanguard and asked them a question it says i believe it was in their hearts it says that you have to act like a kanji he only has a million dollars he's happy with his million dollars so he'll make two million dollars what is the how could it be how do you make sense of that no anybody have a terrorist listen to what the villain says bill online says it's talking about clients wrong hashem is happy even though christopher is not aya they're not the best he's happy with what they are he's happy with them right now we have us come to the vanguard you looked at me no no i saw you contemplating your head but you scratched okay says the gemara like this not doing the proper things you think the skinner cannot be with tomo no the screen is there with the tmaim with the way as they're acting as is that's how kojiboko is says the min what does it say on the side it's not a min he's uh yeah and it was taken out because of the censorship okay so this dookie tells you hashtag i could tell that you are all tommy and mela there's no shrine between you why you got to give me credit to pull it off a two-liner almost and to finish at eight zero zero yeah come on one of the biggest focus of all time [Laughter] everybody have a wonderful wonderful day is [Music] huh ah don't forget to take a good picture really what's their names do you remember their names on second could you see it around you guys how come you're not there why are you at home is forever oh excuse the guys in new york they're leaving their phones ask him if he's still doing that oh yes thank you [Music] [Laughter] since i can hear you ah everybody's muted besides new york i see what's going on here this is terrible we have to meet new york is everybody ready i'm so proud of you all for coming yeah you're sure very proud of us for coming mark nothing's there no way you're a good boy morning morning that was muted you