Daf Yomi Weekly Review Class Bava Basra - Pages 39b to 46b at Scheiner's Shul

okay welcome everybody would also like to welcome all our listeners on Torah any time um welcome welcome we're going to start today T all the way at the end of the D and we're going to try to get until towards the end of the BL let's jump right into it the name of wants to say that if a person makes a we learned this already last week that you need to make it either in front the two people in front of three people here we saying you need to do it in front of two people however the is that you don't need to write what's thees that even though the person did not command them to write it they would still write it why even though however that's regarding same thing would be with a what's a is a person that's getting forced into a sale or something that he does not want to do he goes to to a them and he tells them that he's getting forc and says it has to be it's not considered and it's worthless however a person that he owes money to somebody then regarding since it's since if it's going to end up being is going to end up being himself therefore you have to say what about which is that's also it's good enough the top of [Applause] the that is also going to work in front the two people and you do not need to say however is if someone wants to be what he does is he goes to bz if for whatever reason the a are either going to Medina they're leaving what you want to do is you want to be with these you go to and three make a however it has to be da three because if it would only be to then all it is is and it's not going to help you it's gim it helps like a and it's going to work and that the when said all these he could have said it at one time the reason why I didn't because it was said at separate times we broke it up says he anything of all these things that we just said what me is the scenario of why because if you're telling me that and that's why I'm able to do it even though then you should need why does two help however the struggle is if it's not a have to say it why because it's a on that so why why don't you need to tell him life he's happy that he writes it therefore he does not need to tell them that's why they could write even though they were not [Applause] told both want to say that if a person comes over to you and asks you to write to my do it has to be a person that he wants to write my dog against someone who's not going to listen to toz why because otherwise on you riding my dog why don't you take him to bz like a mench therefore unless he's such a type of person we do not write him however AR they say even such a person like us that we will listen to We Still write a it's very possible you're not gonna be able to get the time therefore would even write for some that has to be that the a need to write what they know about the scenario why it's considered aness and if they don't write this the case behind it the story it's not considered so simple question what are we talking about if you're riding or he's just letting him know that he's forced there's nothing there's no reason that he has what to gain by running my V then we can understand that a person is desperate for cash he needs cash flow he's going to sell something at a very cheap price so what he does is he writes a a do and then when he when he's able to recoup and get his cash back he makes believe that there was never a Sal he has what to gain so only as me we can understand he tell me so what is the scenario we're talking about so where's the scenario there was a person who gave his par to his friend for three years what happened was after three years he forgot to make a and the person in the took the took advantage of that and he went over him and he told him as follows if you sell it to me no problem I'll pay you the cash I'll pay the fair value however otherwise I'm going to take advantage that he never made and I know I could get saying I it off you such a scenar my da explains what's going on is as follows to give a little more context the person in this scenario knows he's in a situation that the person the par this is holding something against him and he's able to tell him you go over to the person quietly and you tell him no problem I'm willing to buy it for you before that you write him a and you say what happened you give the whole history and you and then you come in front of the person and you ask him to buy it in front of the ad so if he buys it in front of the ad again it's the biggest R now you can because you already officially bought it a different time how in the world would you buy it against in such a scenario would take effect and it would work to protect him against this person trying to scam him regarding taking advantage of him not making the two do a person that rights we're going to explain exactly what he has to say what not to say then it's not considered a good we say the person did not want to give it to him what is that case he tells Witnesses go hide and write the in such a case we do not say it's a good he doesn't tell them explicitly to go out and write such a such a case it's considered it's not a good what is the difference between these two answers the case of sto he doesn't tell him anything so according to the when he doesn't tell him anything it's going to be because as long as he never told him anything it's fine he didn't tell him to hide according to lnas however it's because he has to tell them explicitly to go and write such however [Applause] says is not going to help to give it to ruin as a mat however it's going to be helping to protect that other people can't get this mat either someone like shim later on says made a mistake and he learned it from an incident that happened and he tried to learn from that however saying it's a to there incident that happened there was a person that went he wanted to marry a certain woman no problem if you write to me o who's a very wealthy person he says give me everything I'll marry you however it's very important to note that it wasn't a in the that has to do with but otherwise if it was you wouldn't have what to handle regarding incident later so other I'm not willing to marry you so he went and he wanted to go and right he really wanted to marry her comes the and talking third person what's going to be with me the Tells Witnesses go to this place go R it to the after you ride it to then go right to the is so afterwards they found out realized what was happening and the is realized what was happening what happened was they got married the reason why is not is because since he wrote it the was quite clear that he was forced in a position to write it in a scenario write then you don't want it to be however in it's a regular scenario when you give a lat that's not a we do say that you're willing to be magnet to this [Applause] person what is we said ear we have was and that says we're rather however we are and therefore however we don't take it away and that's we explained this earlier that the whole point of a just a support that on its own is not a doesn't be kind of anything rather helps that we don't know who's saying the truth we have two people we have a mar com saying in the field below to him we have here for three years so usually we learned the case of is against you therefore in a scenario after three years where it's common to lose it then we would give it to the however that if there's no [Applause] whatsoever we're going to say that you cannot get this car and the's gonna ask on this what are you doing no one told me anything not however he says he sold it to me he gave it to me as a gift or father sold it to me we're see but a person coming he's his father rather is going to be for him because it's unexpected that a person should have to know there's no expectation that a person should have to know regarding the business dealings of his own [Applause] father maybe the scenario the reason why he said such a thing of and he didn't know that we're going to tell him on his own that maybe he had he lost it going we find we T open up the mouth of someone that's mute that we don't say such a thing and we're not going to T it for him and consider which stands forah there those two incidents were about to say that there was a flaw and they moved their boundary marker into their neighbors field let's jump into this m what happened was had a flood in his land he went after the storm he went and put back the fence in his neighbor's boundary I'm going to see it was a mistake also afterwards they realized what happened that it was a mistake and he put it in his neighbor's boundary so told him you have to give it back go put it back where it really belongs so he asked him back says I already have a who you going like we don't passing like them we passing like so what is going on I know this he was helping me put it back in my in his own property in a deeper Space by mistake if you would have known as your neighbor's property you wouldn't done this just like you didn't know therefore it's a regular and you must give it back that is the with now we're GNA say a very similar incident regarding ra if had a store in the Z that and it knocked off the it knocked off all the boundary markers and it pushed it and he went since everything fell and he went to fix it he put it in his neighbor's property he put it in a the boundary the fence in the neighbor's property also Comm made of Yuda they went in front of Yuda also I see went the neighbor he was upset he saw what happened he brought two [Applause] witnesses one witness was saying we're talking about saw there's a bunch of Rose one witness said he pushed into his property two rows and one witness at three rows amay zil you says at least pay at least move back two rows cuz there this two going in least he gave it at least two who you like who are youing like this and he answer back I'm [Applause] going we have [Applause] on two sets of Witnesses in a scenario we have two sets of witnesses they're both being saying the exact date and time what happened with happened however the only argument is really how much money was borrowed then one says one per saying 200 one saying 100 so what are the even on one ACC if you have one set and and both of the are saying regarding the money so that's who we're going like in our scenario we have one set of and the boat saying at least two rows going inside therefore you must remove you must remove the fence at least two Rose I could bring you a letter from so he wasn't so impressive when he go bring me the letter we'll talk till then there's nothing to discuss and you must remove you must go back to roast let's continue was a person that was living in the attic for four years after four years the owner of the house comes back finds him my what are you doing in my house I bought it off you told me bought it from you they went in front of and he said as follows he's willing to say as long as you find me a witnesses that could say that the original person you say you bought it from was living there at least one day then I'm willing to give you somewhat of a credibility to what you're saying but without one day there's no credibility going on whatsoever put it in your hands otherwise I'm not going to do it was saying I was sitting in front of my uncle the says it was and it's very interesting he was an uncle from his father and from his mother they talk they were step siblings they married each other and brings us from aor in saned that's a common thing that people buy and flip very quickly they don't have to live there that's what they do for a living however was able to perceive from what he was saying at least if he's willing to say that I that I bought I saw R I bought it from buy it from you then could have easily said that I bought the prop from you because he was there for more than three years we're talking about he was there for at least four years that you need to have somewhat of credibility and he needs to be there at least one one day says in the and the a you don't need a something you need and that says right away doesn't like this say maybe don't need anything not a or and and this is what the saying I was for my father therefore the doesn't like to say that another say a person when he buys property he not willing to throw it then we could understand that even if a going to tell me needs a witness at least the witnesses that he was there for at least one day that we could understand however to say does basic investigation before he buys a property it's very to say that he was totally scammed that even if people talk that he had a property really maybe thought his father had the property but there was really no credibility to that what is means measuring what happens if he's able to produce witnesses that the person he bought it from was in the car with the measuring stick that's good enough and it's no different like he was different one day it's very common that a person that's what they do they measure the property and they see if it's a good business deal or not so there's no R whatsoever and you would have to produce witnesses that he was there for at least one day according to what the two dots [Applause] M we're talking about a scenario where you have four people involved you have Ru shim so let's explain this what happened was is tining as a shim is saying he bought it from ruin and he does not have AAR even though when it says Kar it can be that shim has AAR that he bought it from ruin otherwise there's no there's no question that he's the original Mar he bought it however shim doesn't have AAR however Ley has AAR that he bought from shim and after one year yehud has AAR that he bought it from Ley so there's two stars going on that was every year there's three separate people as long as there's AAR it's considered a and the main reason is we're understanding when there's AAR going on there's a call since there's a call if you were you should have been since were however it sounds like only but if it was a it wouldn't be a so the basic understanding is cuz Aiden doesn't have a call therefore I never knew that I I was supposed to be so this is this really true of says regarding and the only reason why you could be able to be is because there's a call it's very clearly that is a call so why is RA saying that the scenario above of only with the that which mean to say is there's a difference by is there's not a call that's ha there's no reason to spread that people are doing the sale however it's enough public knowledge that if you do basic basic investigation a basic inquiry you'll hear that he sold the property so if he's a then since it's not hak he doesn't do any quiries if anything he sees that he's keeping there's no one there for more than a year if anything it look suspicious however regarding M before you buy property regarding you do a basic question to see if anyone bought it and a basic inquir Rel the result that was really say regarding how we see otherwise however only so what are we saying comp me know can be it's G to help us CU himself even how could you compare the two you can't compare why not it's very it's very normal procedure when a person that borrows money he's at a bad State usually and he doesn't want to tell anybody he maybe has to bring Witnesses but he doesn't spread it because people are going to know that he's needing for money businessmen are going to take advantage and it's going to lower the prices of all his properties like that his properties don't lose value however when you sell anything he tries to spread the word like that there's more bids on the property if anything goes higher therefore you can't ask me [Applause] from is not going to work because it's very as long as there's a star or even even even if there's a you the scenario father ate the other for one year and the son had it for two years or the other way around or even a scenario then comes the third year so we clearly see that that's the only reason why we can understand is because the should have known that there was involved I'll ask you a question says if you ate in front of the father one year or this is the other way around where you're the person going into the car or even in a or even ate in front of the father then he was died son was even fr for six years the person sold it over here when a person who's sitting in a car and the son that was sold there was a call going out you should have held on to the even though he sold it to he sold the entire block of he didn't real if you would explicitly mention in the sale the s that he's in should have held on to the we're going to learn now nothing to do with rather simple if a person's holding on to something we tell you I'm right now the new owner and now the mission is going to talk about scenarios where it's not so black and white it's not so simple someone who's a Craftsman like we call it whether he's a tailor whether he's a phone repair shop whatever it is something that makes sense while you have the thing on you or even we're going to go into cers administrators of property because it's very reasonable to understand why they're holding on it we're going to see in on specifically the back and forth to understand whether this or not husband and wife they use it whether it's stuff they use or father for son however the whole Shadow we're talking about these cases is however some wants to give him to do something gives a gift or they split they want to make a k that should be firm somebody doesn't have dies what happens as soon as he dies everything becomes he then's gonna explain in the as long as he fixed something he locked the door he built the wall and therefore it's considered it's we have different versions how to read the mishna is it just to give a little there's a is much more of AES that would not have vers it's quite obvious why this suit is sitting by the repair shop by the tailor it's very common we do buyout so we split a property the second I'm holding on to the property fully for a few years we can assume fairely that you did a buyout and it's taka yours so we have a more wouldn't have however would have says they could be with each other we're gonna see that's the whole next and they also become those three things whether it's aness or cave with a head in an order when there was times was persecution really say says is not coming to tell Us's only how could you say says and that answers it's not why what's that mean in a scenario where one place where it is a kazaka where you held on to completely and one place where you don't have a kazaka is where you held on to it half of the better field says the one field was able to produce much more so let's explain this one line to give a little context of what's the mean some want to learn there's two extremes it's two exact opposites some want to learn when do you have a is when you're in the however in a scenario where you split the property the second the person splits and he gets the better half you have a kak and some learn the exact opposite when you have the property for half you don't have but if you gave him the whole entire property completely then you do have so what's the beer why would one hold the answer really is two words annual investment what's that mean what the really becomes when they're involved do they care about getting an annual return every single year so the that holds that there a he holds have an annual investment therefore if you gave so and completely for three years we say he has a in a case where you split it very nice he's getting a better percentage let's say a 15% return the first three years the sh because he has the better field and the next three years he'll get the %. that's that Mand however the other Mand holds the other haisa holds you know when you have a kazak when you have a kazak is when you're in the field only halfway however when you're in the field completely then you don't have why they hold a person doesn't need an annual return however a person's not willing to give more of annual return to rather they split it equally so if he's in the S halfway then he has however when he's in the that's when we want to say that he will not have a the basic we're trying to explain is do a person need an annual return or not based on that we can understand want to say the both cases we're talking about the should have had the entire property when does is when we learned in the Miss already where it talked about that's when you have you should split itar was so small it didn't make sense financially didn't add up what to do is to have the as a it made sense that you'll get it for 3 years I'll get it for 3 years in such a scenario it's not a goof that's what the was right is considered what are you come to tell me say it why you telling me a very interesting way of talking to tell [Music] again to give a little to understand the is that we learned this extensively what's the na there's two Naas one Naina is when he goes into a that's not meant for trees it's meant for a grain and he plants is he only gets his however that's one point so he ends up he's on the bottom side another point is what happens if he enters the property means it's mature crops it's almost ready to get harvested basically all you have to do is just cut it on such a case if it's you don't get any in it that's one point however when it's we say when I invited you in to come take care of my property part of the is yes some of the crop is ready it's mature but I want you to finish up the job and you'll take your fear prophets it's worth it for me so is a that goes don't tell me that he gets two points he's going to get like a he's going to get not just his expenses he's going to get full profits number one and if he walked into the other was mature produce he's going to get that Al there's one question Food For Thought is is how do we really understand over here the the argument back and forth between the is I'm tining so why should I if I'm tining not that your nus I'm tining that you have this for three years and I get the other three years so what's it mean I would only have a din of like a like I get only somewhat of my I should get the whole entire thing according to you complaining that I am not a that I'm a the whole entire is to me so how do you really understand you have of or that he only get like an um okay the M says the could be made on each other simple question how could he tell me as long as they never really split up the car he's really gaining and he's really being made for himself of he [Applause] writes I have nothing to do with this property so still doesn't have very nice you did a you talked says it's like you know you're hoping however to do I'm let go it he didn't say anything on that you made a k with it made a k with it then therefore the what help to make a k you still it still helps that since this was once since this C was yours very nice you let go of it but the people that you have your could come and take it from this and therefore you won't have we're going to see later you're not going to have on that you accept right away text us what's mean me from anybody comes and says this is not ours You're Gonna Want to protect this property and stay where it is that only people like about people that come from me otherwise is this really true that a person does a helps why are we not for something called collusion well people make games with each other they say we call it sometimes we figure it out let's do something and then we'll figure it out afterwards we find the says the was stolen from the city all to be involved if you could just get away with it by letting go let two people just say m is just scenario do whatever you have to do and then get away with it whether it's not the point everybody has to listen to everybody listens to therefore even if you try saying you're be try to bring another a person says I want to give a for the city the exact two people we're talking about you can't be person says I want to give him M for the for the we learned this extensively does that make sense why should the have to lose why do we call because we all need it we're if this a set annual fee of annual everyone has to give $180 a year let two go and give their pledge give whatever they have to give their du and you give what have to have to give and should be dying there's no set and therefore you have what to gain because the pot is full even when there's ever we all know this because once the part is full it's full we're going to understand that eventually everyone's Fe is going to go lower because there's a surplus of public funds we're going on to we're saying questions this is ready shouldn't be why do I have we all know and we're thinking in the how many the very crucial we're thinking that you're getting half and I'm each one's watching on the half of each other and that Republic says no I'm going to watch today and you're going to watch tomorrow that even though we know that a verbal commitment is good enough and that over here itself the commitment is only happening later then it's not considered turn we're about to go into this next little BR but it's quite extensive and it's going to go until all the way almost a full entire blot so let's break it down we're going to see raes and all these two this this one very small specific but it's quite extensive we have a that says if a person sells a house or a field why now we all know basic B understanding usually means responsibility doesn't mean doesn't mean return basic understanding means I'm accepting my myself responsibility okay the says then you're not why right away the a very simple question what's the difference betweenin verse on that we have so let's let's let's try to say this outside and then see inside were talking about very specific case again there's four people involved there's Ru shim and the is going to question why do we have to say it's all these cases why let's take it step by step Ru shim shim was overheard complaining that Ru is lying Ru is a gospel went so sh and then what happened was ruin sold it to shim shim is holding on to the car now comes yehudah and he's M and he's saying it's his field so according to shim in his head he has two people he has to deal with he has to deal with Yehuda and he has to deal with ruen in the future so over here in such a case you're shim cannot testify against Yehuda we're gonna see what the testimony is but he can't testify against Yehuda because he's because he wants to prot protect himself for r that is the basic case of the therefore it's talking about and such's you know what the case of the is not that there's no witnesses that he stole it because otherwise would have a question rather that's shim his tiny that he stole from him now comes the and he's shim is to go against Yehuda to attack Yehuda cuz eventually we're going to say why is happy that it stays where it is because in the future he going to go against if you're telling me that it belongs to once he's admitting that I ever belonged to Lady how in the world in the future he's going to be able to go against R and that all he's really saying is whether he's going to be he's not really defending Ley and ruing all he's trying to do is give out a kna punch to yehuda's testimony whatever bullets you're going to use for Le knock it out from ru really knock it out from UD you're gonna have again gonna have to bring aen that belong to you and the whole thing is a fraud the that we say right we all learned this concept we find this in however the does throw in that the wording over here is the opposite it's really we didn't want to play with the words everyone understands that is better is the opposite that yehud is the problem and it's much easier he's going to see that it's going to be much easier to deal withu that's one ter B they both have y that's going to work and keep it if he's holding on to the property and shim has a that it's going to keep in the property however shim and y's a are quite equal when they come to B it's going to be what's the when you have two peers of against two separate people and we don't know what to do they're both Tiding something whenever you have two people coming to us and we don't know what to do because they're both bringing ad and could be very nice we have to leave it status quo what is the status quo wherever the K is we leave it so Z so what's thear tar T say I don't want shim stinging themselves I don't want Yehuda having the K because if Yehuda is going to take it away from Ley by knocking that Ru it's come at Yehuda is going to have the K and it's not going to help my because even the adn't going to bring we're going to leave it status quo we're going to leave it by yehuda's if he's able to knock out Yehuda if anything he's going to come the and then if any day Yehuda comes later to try to knock him out it's goingon to be again Gonna Leave a status quo it's going to stay so now the's question why are we saying what are we saying we're saying that sold it to Ley and then comes Yuda why are we going so complicated say Ru did to Ley in the exact same scenario you have Ru shim take out Le and you have Yehuda so why can't it be that Yehuda is coming against Ru and that's the case why do we need a involved very simple question that answers by the case of the saer we're gonna see that it needs specifically to have a m involved since it's metal we're going to learn whenever there's a and that's what the helps it helps you're not gonna be able to get it back and therefore you're not so why therefore we needed the case the safer we need the safer to be very nice helps that you don't get back the object you're not going to get the part ofal the money the money value he's not going to be and that he can get back so we're back to square one why hey the we learn to stand who steals and he feeds his kids so now the questions okay so you're getting all confused you're telling me there's a guy be Irish say the case is talking about Irish very black and white Ru took it Ru died now we're talking about a Irish and more than that clarifies the question that we agree according to the people that hold is only extension of the father doesn't have a no then we can understand this case what are you going to say another question on what's the what's that mean just say in the case of shipment can't be made because it's that's his whole goal is to get it back you can't get it back because of these two question that's part of because of these questions we knock out we're not saying is not like rather we're not going to put the on that for that with the concept the way rather want to say he himself come take it therefore he's that's why testimony that's only we're talking about in a case that it's not why is it not it's it's because there's no call and more than that will never make two points first of all no one's going to no one's going to want to buy Matalin right there's not black away you can't really find anything about it that's number one and number two it doesn't even make sense to put a she against matal it's very easy to hide doesn't move K really Ain Exel it's very easy to put a lean against the K G say what do you mean the person writes could take all my clothing even that's it's when he has you could take it away second he sells it that's means you're designating a specific place where to get your from says you sell it which is very distinct like humans right we could it's more than K it's more than just Cara we're going to see that has a call that you're able to tell and EV you're able to tell everyone looks different you're able to tell [Applause] one has a call one doesn't have a call it's nothing to do it sounds like has nothing to do with hak it's not going to help you're right that they do bring down it's Haka but it sounds like it's more has to do with a call everyone understands this person specifically he looks different we can understand why there's a call and is a however a her a specifically a no one's going to be able to tell therefore you can't be from it even when there is a still another issue with such a thing person however throws in there's two points we need to know because usually it's so unless you explicitly write that it's not like and you mean it then it works because and it can be what we call like a Certificate of Insurance sample sometimes you have to just send out samplesample just means you're going to copy from it it has to be a real star that has my mus it and has something use so back to the question so could be very nice so why we're back to the question why in the world can you be on that ansers we're talking about where you bought it and immediately sold it there no now we know that there's no there was no on it maybe it's a scenario where the she is going to be on the future he's basically saying in the next three months whenever I bu here we can see right right we had that child from here we can clearly see that it's not very we're talking about scenario where the is saying we know for a fact he never had the continues back in this question he doesn't however the question is very even usually means if comes and takes away the no problem that's part of the risk you lose your value you bought for that's why I gave you a discount because there's a chance comes up is going to come and take away the car however if it comes out that you were scam and it was never even your we're thinking nothing you owe me money because you're a scammer so the back to the question why you not because you have to remember back we're talking about a case where someone's coming and saying never belonged to you that's the case we're not talking about we're back to why is not considering we're talking about this means say this we know that the parent of this we're talking about specifically where he was before there was even has to be like that otherwise again for collusion so we're talking about where he's always been talking that it's a that for sure belong to you that's part of it what you're buying I think what we call it the lemon or something right you're buying something that's worthless and talking mine what it's a risk that's part of the RIS that he's taking you got a steep discount for that risk let's go through this case what is this case talking about other then he's going to go back to get this tell me the guy's broke has nothing left what do he care no one else is going to tell he has nothing to take he's totally bankrupt and that aners you're right has no other still he doesn't want to be considered a Russ therefore he wants to pay up his right what to help there's someone going to lose money someone's losing all their all their money so either way and that he answers to himself he convinces himself he says no you I don't consider yourself because that was part of the deal the person that lent me money he has nothing to lose he has nothing not nothing to lose he had nothing that he should get hurt in the process therefore I don't want live [Music] the people that go up to the people that go from they should all know this to say a guy pulls up Hest he grabs it away and says it's his he has to help him to retreat to get it back however when we're part of this we're talking about when is the have to get involved is when the is saying that maybe the guy is right I don't recognize this animal that it was yours you're reminded to me that this guy is just being a bully and he's being a regular honest now a king of all what do he want me to do another point is when a guy is a GH when a guy comes and steals what is he doing with the sadle on the donkey if he takes the Dunkey in the saddle it shows that Tak is a GH he's taking everything however if he comes and only takes the donkey beli leaves in the saddle he's saying I'm not a g this Tak belongs to you but thear is mine it's giving somewhat a credibility to the that he saying he takes we say he's you don't have to get all my time every knows the their mouth is full of on the right hand there's nothing do you can't get involv now we're gonna get into the next with the says I'm going to try to explain it as much as possible it's quite heavy the really the argu andab says when does the only time is when he got witnesses testified that he got the that he gotor this this suit let's use the case we're talking about a suit by a tailor let's try to stick to one case we're talking about the guy is aing that the suit is sitting by the tailor however if the suit even though it's sitting here today we see it as long as it was not given to him we don't know how it is he now very crucial to understand this that is a fundamental argument we're see Raba Rab's timing is that Raba is saying that even if we see the Cara we see this not Cara we see this suit in the tailor since he can say there's many many tailor M alone there's dozens just because the suit is sitting in my place is not a ride that you come to me you never shop by me you always go to other people so that is enough to say I'm no different than a regular person is when this that he gave it to him how to you to fix that is what going to see in a moment this is how we're learning it that's how I learned it two days ago okay what's the help why is it even if he gave back a testimony Witnesses if no one sees it today he could easily say so why I don't understand why is it no so that's why it's not GNA help if I give it back if as long as this a it's not going to help because I either way have to give it back a so I can't I don't have AIG to say okays what's and he answers him back you sold it to me you gave it to me as a gift it's worthless and he has to get back if he says that you told him to give it to me right away for tomorrow what's the difference of the and the what's the difference if you the one specifically that sold it to me or you told the to sell it to me what's the difference the're both shouldn't make a difference between and it's coming through somebody else we're talking about that the is not the one who sold it them rather saying Le has now says to you told couldas so that was the point so this is the clearly says the case of the he in the case of Russ in the case of the we're saying the case is he saw it so what the case let's bring the take it away because it was a case he saw it very clearly there's no as long as he sees it he could take it away so that says that he has to be and that [Applause] says going to tell me and then he answers I don't have I would be believed with the with the of what happens in a very specific case you go you brought your suit to the cleaners now you have an argument how much you made up to owe him you made up2 I only made up a dollar so now what do we do so as long as the Talis is still in the um shop he has to prove it that it's one otherwise he gets two however what happens he gives it back so then it depends if it's still on the time just like we learned regarding the there explains that a is and all the other things he has to juggle he doesn't remember if he paid him they're relying on what to get so now this is's question what's the case if you telling me there was and was there when he gave him this object this clothing let's ask what was the price what was the wages they made up clearly we're talking about there's no And even though they saw it what say this is he could just say much the wages and that says no the cas because he could have said he was the one who sitting there is to ask this is talking to be knock out the says so just to give a comparison whenever the doesn't we have to say a typical person has a in the exact same scenario of what whether it was then who you have goes through now very clear that's a very clear very feir what's the case tell me those Witnesses so if me so let's say I'm not a rather I got I'm a stranger but I have witnesses testifying that have no choice to say there no there no me I have I have a I could have said I bought it say one last point a is going to argue on if to put it down very very in a basic level the really is is how do we look at when we see a something in the shop if you have a suit in the shop Z wants to say this let's be real let's be logical this suit is sitting in the cleaners it's obvious to Fe it's very fear assessment to say let's be real you got it you got it it's to fix or to clean has a tin back he says as long as you cannot prove it to me how I got it I have a to say that all you are this is you not a by me since you're not a by me therefore that's really what my understand the basic is if a person can such a thing let's go right we're going to go in one last what is a person goes home he went to a place he sees he's wearing somebody else's suit can he use it me while it's a very famous famous question says if you got it from the cleaners let's say or even though you look at your suit you recognize it's not my suit the you can continue wearing it until the owner comes back and changes your suit we're assuming there was exchange that happened be going to wedding what do they call theer right the people you give your your your suit your your coats in the winter and you come home you see somebody else's thing then so again a wedding for example or so simple question why the case by you could why when you come home from a wedding you can't on that say we just saw it earlier who his uncle from his father and his mother he's answering the question he's saying the difference is that by um people get on it's on commission there's such a concept that plenty of companies even today they sell clothing on commission so since this um has many suits in a shop that belong to him where he commissioned to sell it we're going to assume as a followers we're going to say that the person you're wearing the suit is Tak doesn't belong to Y it's his suit that's meant to go for sale so why did he give it to you cuz your suit that you don't have he by mistake gave it to somebody else and we're going to see what's the difference how do you know when it was a mistake or not because why that this is maybe just like he gave you the super mistake why is that other person he's not able to wear it and you are able you are able to wear it we have to be and that's what we're going to say right now when the himself gave it to you then it's very feir to say that it was a mistake however even he himself when he gives you the suit back you're now to wear it he says take this suit when he tells you specifically take your suit because we're saying he's making a mistake and that why it's not Asal and now answer now just to give a little more clarity why it could be two people someone else is wearing your suit but when he gave it back he said take your suit so he knows the someone who's really wearing your suit knows wait a second the take your suits oh so this Tak doesn't belong to me I'm know to use it can you you remember that he said take a suit and we're going to say it was D and we're going to say that the suit I'm wearing Tako doesn't belong to anybody and therefore I'm able to wear let me show you the what do they do they make themselves look into Ser you come back to the woman he say can I get my TOS back he gives you a stare and he says I don't know I don't know who you are never happened so what happens shows him I have witnesses that recognize a suit and it's very similar to my suit now again the witnesses of they're not saying 100% it's your suit because then there's Witnesses rather they're saying there's a suit that if you bring it out we'll be able to tell we need a closer look no I can't show the privacy policy I should show you just because you're complaining we respect our customers that's where you see their I can't show it let's go see it if it's true I can't you Hipp policies right because says that when you see it with but if it's it's just a guess and the say let's bring it out then you can't do it thought for a second said let's try to see if we could even fool the he's going to make him fool he's going to fool him to make him believe there was a raw why the tells him okay I got it you're trying to you're trying to play tough with me I might why are you holding on to my let's let's be real because I have money for you right I owe your money so let's take out the suit let's value it then you're going to bring Witnesses quickly to see that the suit's yours take how much you owe you let's be real the suit I don't owe you $1,000 the suit's worth $1,000 owe you a few let's evaluate right you don't know what you're talking about these people these are a a fool a scammer could smell another scammer and then he says he smells right through your roots he knows that you're really trying to play on him and he tells him don't worry I already don't need your evaluation the people before you we already evaluated the suit and between me and you without the a the suits much worth much more less than what and back to but hypothetically starts talking that hypothetically and these are there's no hope in getting out of it you might as well give up okay one last point of the M says a sharecropper does not get why is it a either gets a half or whatever it is whatever the minig but they don't get the whole entire for the past three years you're seeing this holding on to the entire you know talking about we talking about very specific it's a generational gener family is going back many decades that they were the artist involved and such arst was talking got normal that they used it already for a few years the trust goes back decades and it got to a point where they already made up that you have it for a full few years cuz establish one point it's p to us you're always going to gain by having one person have the entire s whenever you split the course eventually go higher so when it gets to the point where you really trust if it makes sense to RS about the office he could have it for a few years then I'll get all the prophets few years later if there's an orus even about the office an orus if he totally subcontracts everything 100% every last point he's not even involved in the then he has a person is not going to let the Aris 100% subcontract all the work because he's not in the car he's already not involved doesn't have so much so much Nas to make sure that the property is going to produce a lot however um um however if you delegate you yourself are on the property rather you delegate some of the work then you don't have they bring down over they bring it down that he's making him that yes it's quite common he can't handle the work the fields got bigger and bigger got too much for him he had to sub he had to delegate some of the work but since he's on the carco he's going to have it's not a he didn't feel threatened to be one last what not on that he said he could be made say not it's really dependent if Theus has what to lose if he didn't get his share his crop yet and he still didn't do the Harvest cuz otherwise the field is going to get taken away from him however in a scenario where the Harvest already ended the Year we're at the we're at the break and he already got everything that could be made two points first of all he could always find more work there's plenty of arim out there that you know that need his services and the other point is he's not even 100% sure his job is secure therefore he could be made we're going to pick up next week base