Daf Yomi Weekly Review Class Bava Basra - Pages 32b to 39b at Scheiner's Shul

okay we're going to pick up from going to try to get to so we're starting from bottom of bottom of the was eating from a and a call was going out that he's eating who's the belong to belongs to so tells easy tell me what's going on what is the what's the background of this story so tells him what happened was this I originally got it from the father as like we learned M the was in the place of Sur the way they did although is that every year got deducted therefore wasn't ribus because it was a set fee that every year and eventually the loan would go back by returning the field without making any payment so what happened was he had this originally got through top of and he had another loan that wasn't based on and the years of the over I mean I told myself asked me if I GNA give back right now the car to the assignment I mean I'm going to answer to them that there was more money that was owed to me as an extra loan I'm going to have to make a that I the father owes me another loan and didn't want to make a he was a big he never wanted to make any even if it wasem rather he told himself let me hide this I'll eat up enough another year or two whatever the loan was since I'll have AIG I could have just said I bought it therefore I'll be believed just like I'll be believe who then by me saying that I have another loan I shall be believed and without such a Cas either so that was that was that was what he was thinking tells no you're making a mistake you were never able to say that you bought the as a that you would have t you bought it you wouldn't have been believed why not since there a call that the land always belong to the father therefore he never had a therefore you have to give back to therefore when they get old they you shall deal with them we say later you wait till you're to sell it that's only you do it from and another important point you have to mention is that the call that was coming out you have to say that the call was already then when was the call already in the beginning when the rash was holding on to the because that's a is tying it back a is saying there was a CO coming out and the the since you know's no bigger so you see from you would have to say that this call was even before thear like that he can never a now it wasn't so simple it wasn't a it wasn't a first generation now we know we're going to see there's no such a thing as a with unless he's a g so was tin he's a I am the closest relative for example I'm a second cousin another person pulls up and says I'm closer to you so what happened was since we don't know what we're going to do who Tak belongs to we like is going to say by we're going to whoever strong is going to win it and that's T what happened is that other person not was able to get the through called however after a year or two a year or two he was he came back to and he says to him that he is gave back should give me back the P that he was eating until now on that answered him back this this is a person who can say who are you relying to get back and this person this that gu he's the one who's telling you now now that you are learns it as his is he's giving you as a argued in this it said no you has to get back to the why since he wasn't now he has to give it back and the brings the gear which is which is what happened was he was able to prove with witnesses that he was a car and the other person wasn't a car so we have a therefore we could take him but regarding the P there's no there's no reason to pull away the P therefore he's able to keep the entire Paris that he ate in the future and brings out that hold that why not believe it he says you can't differentiate if you're going to give back the then you must also give back the pis top of the two dot we have a we have a person Ruben comes with a on on top of the top of the AL both pulling up and they're both saying that it belonged to their forefathers ruven is able to come up with Aiden that says it belong to his forefathers and not only that part of the is he's saying that he didn't sell it the shim's forefathers however now he could say he doesn't have to come out to say his forefathers however Ruben has Aid him going against that mik because Ruben's part of this is like that he's saying that he never sold it to so what do you do now therefore he's believed with since your is going against is that he's tying that it's not your forefather that's part of the and you're arguing on that so it's continues there's a person tells his friend my so tells what are you doing in my [Music] field I bought it from you and now I I have and I threw out the star he said you know what I'm G even go find aen to prove it and he went he thought he could find aen un Fortune was only able to find aen that he ate it for two years so now he had to get back to K because he had no a in three years so that because of that he has to give back both he has to give back the car because he doesn't have Adas and he has to give back the pis why because in two years there's Noak and therefore he won't there's nothing to do about it it's unfortunate that he couldn't find aidis and therefore he has to give it back says it's a new thing says it's following however if he says I'm only anus either I'm anus or I bought to use the P for up to amount up to a certain amount of years the is he's and therefore he's going to be believed to give back just a s then he guy doesn't have to pay for the pis yeah he have to bring Adis that's the whole point he only was able to produce a for two years okay didn't review this say we're going to see this later takes a size certain type of night knife to cut dates it's either a basket they bring down their or a ladder or a rope actually in order to get the dates on top either a ladder or a basket to get those dates I'm going to go and go cut why it's a certain to walk over to a certain person's and take it and even if he's not in town the was when he comes back from town he can M for the whoever the he is towards we're getting towards the bottom of the of the already so a person it doesn't have the but to walk over to se pis and to eat it and is it doesn't have to be that he takes a ram and starts screaming what he's doing even it's good enough it takes a certain he's going to get embarrassed if the owner comes back and throws him out in every case then why don't we say this and every time you get a person walks into the en field and he takes the should be believed with we saw this we explain in we explain this very well that there's a of therefore he's not belied say the same thing by the Paris also they should have person they didn't make therefore he's believed by default with by saying person tells his friend what are you doing in my land I bought it from you I have so what happened was he was able to produce one witness for three years if you would find another witness he would be able to get it with want to tell him front they want to say this is the and we would know that he doesn't get the car because only producing one eight that's not the sh however we thought we could compare it to the so of it's a very famous let's let's go into it what there's a person that grabbed took from a silver bar they went in front of was there now the person that was originally hold on holding on to the silver bar was able to produce a witness that he grabbed it that he grabbed it so he was might what happened was this person this G that grabbed the bar he was M says yes I grabbed the silver bar however belonged to me on toped how can we pass such a so is being and he explains what's going on over here we have three scenarios where we wouldn't question the we would have a very clear answer if there would be two aen coming and grabbing two a he was able to produce two a that saw him grab the silver bar there's no shw that he's not NE you would have to give it back cuz you not you're not allowed to walk over to someone take it away from him the person was a he would be believed so in that scenario it's not a shil another scenario where it's not a sh there's no therefore we'd be believed with AIG could have had AIG that he could have said therefore he's believed with AIG by saying it belongs to him that's the second scenario and the third scenario is even when there's a if he would have stayed quiet he wouldn't have been he would have been able to make a that he did not be he could make a to be ensure that he did not take away the bar so in any of those three scenarios we don't have a shil it's the is P that he would be able would be able to solve it however here's the problem we have aning he's not arguing on this rather he's so what do we do to make him pay cuz you're telling me he's he stole it that can be there's no saying that he grabbed it ah you're going to tell me with AIG you want to part with AIG that can either work that what that he grabbed it he was minded that he grabbed it so he can't go against this some taking out these words of that of this that he becomes a golin but we're going to learn that since he takes he becomes a Goin therefore he can't make a told him regarding this that what what should he do he should make a he has to pay why because he's once you can't make the you have no choice but to pay so this is what we thought is the case where a person produced One witness for three years it's why because again you would have all these three scenarios in our just like if we break it down for example if you have two witnessing saying that he was there for three years it wouldn't be a sh if there would be you be able to be he would be believed however in such a case where he's since his going against him is saying he ate the par he has no choice but to pay on that tells him making a mistake me you can't compare the case of why not in the scenario of the pl the person who bar got grabbed he's the one bringing this witness to go against you therefore if you would be able to produce another witness that he grabbed it would be two a saying that he grabbed it and he wouldn't be able to get it back he would be able to get it back however here this Moxi in the field right now is going against the maram he's trying to bring to Aid them however he only found one eight if he would find another eight would give it to him so let's give a little explanation a little more context to understand is saying we usually find the concept called whenever there's cannot force you to pay rather what he can do is he can force you to make a so it's very crucial to understand what a b is trying to say a b is trying to say say is the purpose of an is to get you to pay however if you can't pay there's a level before of however if the whole concept the whole purpose of these or is going to make you not pay then there's no such a thing as a there's no middle ground shu is only a piece to get to pay that's the whole concept that's what AB is trying to say that over here they a is not coming to make him pay rather he's coming to and based on that understanding we can understand why this is not obligating to make a rather how it's the case the case of our field however instead of bringing AOS for three years he's bringing AOS for two years in such a case he's T bringing he's going to come out he's going to end up since it's only two years even if there would be two a those two a if anything would affect them and he would have to pay even with the two therefore we could compare it to such a case but we're going to try to move along when we did we did it much more at length now we're going to start the famous case OFA what is an ARA ARA is a ship now where was the ship top of the first the first words where was the ship so the the ship was phip no one was a because we're going to see in a second that we all know and quick bring out this point that it can't be talking about because otherwise it be however we're talking about a case where there's no there's Ruben and Sh and they're both fighting they're both saying that it's their ship saying it's his and saying it's his ruen pulls up the best and he says he tells hold on to this why have a in the next Village and I can produce those a so give me time and I think we would give the sh even if we would give we would give him only up to 30 days so so what's it's based you're going to see m in a moment and what is the when B does take the ship if they would take the ship would they be might it since we're going to see the is going to be called all that's a scenario where bz doesn't get involved but once BZ takes the ship now they're obligated to Tako find out who the true owner is we can't throw back into the streets and therefore based on that b is obligated to hold on we can understand the holds that even if cannot produce aen we will release it back to them and the M like the scene and the reason is because if bz is going to take it take it away they're never going to be able to release it has a Vanetta he's only thing he's going to really gain is that yenim is not going to get the ship he Tak doesn't own it his only his whole purpose is that shimz is going to take it he's tin is producing can't produce this's going to hold on to Forever and the only thing he gains Dr is the ring got shim not to get back his ship so what happened because we're going to see in a moment that he holds like our Papa that even if would take be says there's two options either that if they both agree even they both agree to say you know what we both agree we both tiny we can find therefore we want you to hold in then going to hold it on or in a scenario we passing like like sorry like so did not find so they said let's release it back like we just explained the because once took it now they have obligation not to release it to the [Applause] [Music] public okay let's go V they both tiny it belongs to them we don't know who it belongs to let them fight over it then we explain this when we explained already last week what the accomplishment called we explained some and others that explain that the true person says able to prove it better someone is called is going to fight harder we went through it what's the Milo but that's where now what is the kind what is there's a person scenario then also has AAR that and we're going that there's no times that the the person who's giv the is that should only kick in by therefore they're both coming to us with equal ground they both have AAR very clearly saying that what that they both got AAR so what do we do what is the what we do is however is going to say that is going to CL what according to is says we try to figure out who is who it makes sense more that Ruben would have wanted to give it however T doesn't like that t rather want to say whoever he wants he could give it to him however so what is the is that is rather if we say it's going to come out that one of them is 100% getting so we evaluate what's better rather one of them not get 100% or get and do but to ask the question the question is very simple why you can't compare the two cases in the scenario there impossible we're never able to find it we're never able to find who the real owner is going to be because they bought that's what happened rubben the however in our scenario we're going to be able to eventually someone's going to be able to produce a that is is the real owner that's why so comes out thear is coming out that a scenario where you're able to find out that we don't say rather we say Sor whenever you're able to find out the we say called only in the case we're never able to find that we say if so if that's is that really true we have another case where you're able to find the the scenario it's a very famous to see this we have very famous the case is that and the and the and the the Rashi explains over there we're talking about that we don't know which R was it was and he sold he did AIP in Sunday morning they only ended up pulling up Tuesday Morning by Tuesday morning it was a power MO Tuesday morning there was ready aad so when did this animal give birth did it give birth before Sunday morning when they did the or was rather afterwards and therefore it belonged to ready to shim however in such a case what are we the seller the person who owned it originally saying that only gave birth it gave birth before it did only afterwards and therefore it belongs to me what do we do in such a case we in such a scenario which is the which is is the over there it's possible if come and tell us when the animal gave birth the animal gave birth on Sunday mornings no shil belongs to the owner otherwise if they can gave birth on Monday or Tuesday then belong to the so what do we see over there over there we're able to find out with a this we still say that what that says by they both have something called either belong to the person ring it dining ofai or it could belong to shim but it can't belong to both so let's give a little explanation what is so we're trying to say way understand the case of in that scenario of a there they both have a v in the mother therefore the it's all based on the kid we can understand that why therefore we have belongs to we're g to come out the of have nothing to do with each other one of them is a one of them is coming from nowhere he's making all a store and he wants to steal the so in such a case we're going to he's coming out of nowhere however learned even if you take away the still even without their therefore such a concept we would pas over here one of them is a he's coming out of nowhere they only based on their we're g what happened was a third party came and started to take advantage of the situation he saw Ruben and shim fighting over he realized that no one really has adus he figured let me take advantage let me jump in and comes the third person and grabbs the the what do we do now he's able to keep it even though he's not tining anything the other two have no a to prove that it's their he took advantage of the situation we're understanding from B not take hands are ti they have no way to pull it out of this third party because Ruben and shim the two people fighting originally never brought R to produce that was there what's what's it mean since you took this third party came Le came and took it away from ru shim there he has no choice but he can't give it back to Ruben and shim just like by we saw by same entire concept that you don't want to be able to once you grab it away you can't give it back unless you know it's a that's what it mean he's never able to do like we're going to see later regarding the someone who fools the measurements of a R is never able to do Chu so here he can't do Chu because he doesn't know if it belongs to Ru he doesn't know it belongs to shim therefore that's what it means says the the m is able to produce a that the mar himself took a basket of Paris and put it on the shoulders it's the biggest that he is not the marama if a person walks into a he wouldn't do such a however is Tiny the reason why I helped him is because he's a regular an he bought theis however after years then the has they're going to question what should he do how could he be what should you do in such a scenario where a person goes and all he is is an or he had the the what should the do be because he's not a golin should be what should he be he's going to say everybody should know that Ru that's all he is is he all he is is an and we're going to see in a few accepted and he's going to use it himself to later what should a person do when he's going gonna bring what is we explain that after for example a person lent you AOL $100,000 he makes a deal every every year it's going to take the dock $10,000 and after 10 years you're gonna get back to without and but why is is because you have a problem with ribus we learned this when we learned you have a problem with ribb and the answer why there's no real issue of Ribbit because you're paying a set fee and there's a risk involved some years it could come out that it produces way more than $10,000 but some years since it's last therefore it doesn't make a ribb so it's however what could he do how could that be this scenario whatever person's going either an or is holding on to the field that he's tining he bought it from an from a that's how he has the field is he's like an that what what is the of he's not able to say I'm here for three years and I threw out the only time you can if your person steal boys saw from a go he has to hold on to it only and there is a way out if when he buys the s from the guy he tells the guy I want to see your bill of sale if he sees his star we're gonna see he's G to be amigu that otherwise if he didn't ask the guy to see the only thing he can do is hold on he'll never have the only thing you do is hold on to thear and the reason why doesn't have a because if a person goes Ru the par goes and takes away from ru ruen is gonna be always afraid to be therefore there's no the only way you can prove however told me that he from you believe so right away that doesn't add up if the himself would say that he B he's not believed how's the help ring saying that I the guy told me the guy himself is could be a g and he's not believed this what it means if the person says I saw the guy bought bought it from you then he's believed why he has AIG that he could have easily said I bought it from you based on that Mig he's able to get we saw this earlier person takes the scyth or a basket or rope whatever means like we just learned it that a person doesn't have the to walk over to and start cutting off his dates if a person the only part where he was holding on to the property was from the outer fence even though belong to ruing there was a little part of a property it's still not what's going on is as follows a person had a property of an acre wide what he would do is he would put a fence 10 feet towards his property sprinkle some seeds and whatever grew grew and why what was the purpose he did it for the animals he wanted to be that when the animals would come and take they would go for the outside they would go before the fence they wouldn't try to jump the fence and they would eat whatever grow he didn't put too much energy and there was part of his why he did it so if such a person takes that he doesn't have a why not whatever you would have ate either way the animals would have take it therefore I didn't see a need to protest for person eats since it's there's no purpose of me being either way I'm not gaining anything therefore it's not a the point of whenever something's not is if a person should have been and he's not you don't have that because either way doesn't carees bring however we Lear the like we find such a concept that all these stuff is either way it's not says says why what is the case of is that he quickly went and took the produce cut it off earlier so since he wasn't like therefore he's not however he's in a place the valley that there was a lot of then and they all had a lot of animals so it's very normal to have should means it's a very field it's not growing anything it's also not because a person doesn't care about it too much and therefore another field in a scenario where he produced he put in a corn he only was able to produce a cour again when we explained that we tried be that we're talking about a person who really has plenty of feels he's not he only is going to be when he's to lose it but he sees it's not really producing he's not he says let the guy enjoy for now be later therefore it's not a [Music] since they were very very very powerful people they couldn't be by us because we afraid to and if you take from them also you can't have a because they are not afraid they don't need to make a they have no problem walking over to you and taking it by the two the says that is that really true don't have Master because it moves so there's no ride that end up in your field you know end of the field because the dog or the cat straight into your So to that able to move it like shouldn't be you're right they could get that's we're talking about we're talking about that he's a baby and he can't walk then he has because he's not you can't walk since the mother was working there you would have said what maybe the mother was working then she forgot it there a mother does not forget her child in that house therefore the only reason why we should say it's there because he taka sold it question the bottom of a person has these goats that these goats went and ate bar of a person so the owner of the go of The Barley went and held onto the goat let's say the goat was worth $100 he was tying that he took more than $100 worth of the goat he took $200 worth of the bar soim you could hold up to the value of the gold till there you have AIG more than that you don't so what's the why do you have say that you're holding on to this animal say bought what do you mean they were talking about goats you hand it off to the very nice the royya holds on to the goats the Shepherd that was the man they used to take the goats the outside the field very nice he's holding on to that but however in the morning and the evening when he would come back and return the goats that enters the village he would let it go and each goat would find the owner there was there were thieves over there so the the shepherd when he came back to the Village he taka didn't leave it by the entrance rather what he did was went and knocked on the doors and made the owners got it back that's why now we're going back to the end of the Mna where we where we saw and either 15 or 18 months holds we need to have 18 months three months in the first year full 12 another three months we're trying to figure out what's let's say the means that since plowing is not a good that's why you need a full however therefore it's good enough more than a month to make the plowing that can be why why do you have to come on the whole entire month and come on the 14 months even one day could be 12 a year and two days the first day the first year one day and the third year another day because that's more than enough time to do the [Applause] plowing a person doesn't get a until he finish he does a full production which takes three months therefore you need holds it's good enough even that grows in 30 days is more than enough time some hold that plowing is not old it is trying to figure out who the says a person plowed for a year his Z bed or he and he planted for two years so one of the three years is plowing or even that we're coming to tell us why you telling me even plowing to years is to tell you however what is a person wouldn't walk to Y watch him y plow his field and stay quiet therefore and be and you by not being the Feld the answer is tells let him take out all the splinters and everything from when he's plowing all he's doing is help being the entire field okay they they asked could he teach us what is is good enough a field with two days they all say say going to say that so why you running to One Direction over the other let's go through it that we know our clearly says that it's not good enough a year and two days but where do we know that ra is going to hold it's not the name of this is and what's mean why you come tell me three years the light to show you that it's got not good enough the plowing is very clear we see that ra holds it's says three harvesting of and you do three harvesting of grapes or so we clearly see what's the difference between and they both hold you need that's we're understanding doesn't take a complete three years so according to it's because he's doing three harvesting even though it's notus however Rob is going to hold you need all those scenarios follows wants to say from we can see as follows that let's just give a little context is saying two separate one is he doesn't hold you need even without that's the you can get that's one clearly argue however there's another that were trying to say maybe RAB I'm not going to argue what is that that you don't need an entire field at want shot 100% production in order to establish it as part of the K because we see clearly RAB rabish even by the case of Z helps the so as long as you do part of the field it helps in the entire field soar is going to try to BU is going to try to say that what we're going to try to pull out that are going to agree to the second of that what you don't need 100% production so let's see inside if a person had 30 trees in a so you had 75 7500 Square three right three si what is 2500 so he has these 30 treats he ate 10 in one year three years even we're gonna say it's like why just like you're eating by that all the 10 even though it's only 10 which you're going to see in a second it's going to help for the rest of the field which makes it very understandable now it's only we're going to say that you able to take 10 the other 20 did not produce did not bear any fruit but the second it bear fruit then you should have took it another Point that's that's one tonight another tonight is means to say it has to be spread out it can't be on one strap 10 That Grew otherwise all will say is that you have not the rest so just to give a little background and what's flying over here is when a person sells a field with gim is we're going to see that everyone who holds you get the surrounding the Elon what happens when he only sells two not three that's one we need to know another is when a person sells and there's trees in the is that the trees are secondary and it's all what's is going to be is when he separated to two to two different buyers Ru he sold the trees shim he sold the car so it's very clear that shim is not getting Theon even they usually would get because he sold it to ruven the so what's the Shar the Shar is this ruven that sold the trees does he get along the trees or not so person sold to Ru in the trees and the each one you got the we're going to see the Tiner back and forth and you got the however you don't get the under the if that's really true that ruing that got the not going to get any that really true that he gets nothing what's going to happen when a r dries out that really Mak sense that he able to kick him out as soon as the animals as soon as the trees die out the part of the is that even in a scenario where he sold them G in a regular case he gets over here not how does that make sense that you're getting by me my trees are only for a period of time it's only temporary we're GNA go with rather first gonna get the around the tree that means to say is we were talking about a second ago where a person however it's that if I'm the and all I did was selling the and I left the myself there's no sh I'm going to get the we're going to see the later still going to not afraid that the person you sold it to is going to cause you issues because it doesn't damage the property around it since by trees top of Since By trees it's going to damage around you're nervous that if you sell car you know you know what your buyer is going to say he's going to wait a few days and he's going to start complaining that you're ruining what he bought so therefore to avoid that what you're going to do is you're going to sell the carcass surround the trees not to damage the car that that would belong to the buyer otherwise the if not therefore he doesn't do that now the explains what happens the person sells the trees but he keeps the for himself so it's see the was talking to man where you sold let's say a s and you sold a pit in middle of the sod so it's if you sold even a to get to the pit holders know what do you mean how else could I get to the field you want me should throw away money get myself a path however says and he's gonna have to buy back to get to the bar person sells wants to say that second not really even the we just saw a second ago there says he doesn't get here he's gets why that's just like by me I don't have any trees even though St I would get the trees and says way therefore we not it's not and let's go stand straight rather L packed we say we always learned that a St is 250 square arm for every BW so it's 10 for basa we saw that then eventually when it grows ends up turning it to three we uproot it then we end up doing 833 and a third we saw this when we learned to however so that's a normal to grow what happens instead of putting 10 he stuck it up with 15 is the stopped up a regular with 15 instead of 10 you don't have a why the reason why you don't have aak is because we're going to see in a second because we're going to say you're G to have to remove it very quickly whenever person selling as you how could he ever be what's the case of Asa case ofast so it's very it's overgrown it's you stuff it up and then you cut it and you you remove it you replant it elsewhere so how could you ever be if you if you sell a field stuffed up with trees with 15 trees even in a regular case where you sell it with 10 you get the Kaka however since it's stuffed up and therefore what's what's the H what's the difference now that it's stuff you must by default you have no choice to remove the trees very soon so I say I never had D to S you the the 15 that's only temporary you're going to have to cut it and remove it because it's going to be too overgrown therefore you don't get K wants to say it's really we find this why where do we see this we find this by a car now this is regarding some mixes gets malus and it'ser to eat the food however it has to be when it's however if it's a single Vine might be we don't get there's other now every caram would have doas for the plows to go back and forth that's what that's what Tes a car however if there's not do amus it's hard to say it's a car rather you have to look at as one big Vine and it's not M like a Vineyard so what happens when you don't have four [Music] am because it's not it's considered one big piece it's considered it's not for it's not it's only let's say gim we look at the middle ground like it's not there cuz either going to have to cut it for your plow we're not therefore it's considered like we want to say because according to you would say it's good you would get the when we look at the stuff it's it's not there person who sells a to his friend to he sells the all the way underneath all the way on the ground so it's again is learning it theam is learning he's he's buying it all the way on the ground that if he wants he can replace when the trees die or dry up he can replace it that's the way theam learns it t say has an issue with this TI the re has a problem that can't be later on we're going to clearly see that you don't get K so the re wants to say that is learning however this he is that he can't do a is the and that's when ad is learning that he gets his CL that the his neighbor can dig um underneath the tree why you tell him you get in the C against the tree just like when a person sells this saffron this type of thing that there clearly he gets only this use it then he has to he only gets the then he has to leave once the pay is dry up he's he's gone so to over here could should tell him so to over here he could tell him just like over there we would remove the saffron after die so to over here he should tell him that you cannot replant the tree talking about he's tining that he bought the of the underneath that's why he wasn't careful on the have this is what we were telling earlier what do he do by an and and he said you should be just like that accepted that he's going to use it as for other people to ask questions because asked the question what what should he do and he know he answered just like I learned from a few moments ago that gets he gets to keep back the without any money how could that be that he sold him either just a saffron or we find out by the also all he did was sell him the in the there are three lands in they're separate as follows the that what person opposite way around it's not considered until you are in the exact same place whether says no why do we have you know why I think it mean Spain could be all the way in Spain which is takes a full year to travel you'll take a full year till it comes public knowledge then they'll send the are going to go to Spain and let them know that Ruben's in his field what's he gonna do it's going to take it's going to come right back he himself is going to come running to get to kick out the mar that's why he need three years the's going to question if he himself has to come we're going to see if re the he himself has to come back or not however that's the whole point that that's why you have enough times with M you would say should be because there's plenty of time what is what's the problem make but again people are gonna find out about it and that's why it's not good enough if he's in then time the Mist should explain you have to be so what's the issue so what's the [Music] problem we find it today we're in Wars so with Wars there's no way to be why you have to mention even it doesn't sound like you if it's it's considered that it's emergency that what it's Not Gon to help to make now we're gonna go into the he's running away whether he's running away we're see let's jump right into top of the again review is going that and since it's not good can't be can't be so therefore I'm he has to make a in front of him what's the problem what's coming to tell me ready what is not a good enough that's that's why himself does himself but he was questioning you that what is going on what's the problem of him what's the problem exact same question he clearly said that it's good enough what's the problem coming to tell us saying even in a scenario where you're telling two people that cannot go and we're going to see that we're gonna see that later we're talking about people that can't do it physically so and it's still consider that even in such a scenario it's a what is he talking about what shot he holds it's okay so he says he can't be and it's not it's how could they both why that's we're trying to say why you just running away from your people that owe that you owe them the money that even if an economic person runs to different countries everyone knows he's there he's not able to get it they can't pull him away from the courts but he has no problem beinga his location where he is therefore he's going to make him however where he's talking about he killed someone he doesn't want the relatives of the person he killed to know about it therefore he's not going to be malala's location he can't make a m that's where he hold that the bottom what is the case of we've been speaking about M from day the whole per but what does it mean a person just goes around and saying ohen is is a it's not considered however that sitting in my car stole it from me and he's a big go we're gonna go into in a moment tomorrow I'm G to take him to B that's however the brings down what happen if he doesn't say that he's going to take him to bz so brings down that if he doesn't say he's going to take him to B all he's doing is and everything and it's it's not consider and therefore he's not going to get it however they bring down thean brings another from he says that even if he doesn't say it's still good enough because it's POS he's going to take in the B he doesn't need explicitly say now we're going to go through bunch of scenarios we learned this stuff yesterday and CH is going to go through a bunch of scenarios whether it's a good or not a good M what happens if the the M that's making says don't tell how could it be a he's he's tell him straight out not to tell him you're right himself to the he's not going to tell him explicitly however he will tell him to his friends eventually get to him we did ask yesterday it's hard to understand why is it not a Gil in the marama that he's afraid if someone's T stealing you would go over and let him know that he's in my we did question this why is not a Rea on the mar we tried answering that the is always really on the of is really it's up to him to defend it the mar has to defend this the second he does he loses Theo why he lost thear by default he goes to the marama even if the marama didn't make the the best it's really on the defendant on the to prove it more that's what we can understand even though he didn't make the best it should be considered okay what happens another case the responded these two people responded we're not going to tell them we're not going to tell them so therefore you should go make their now you know you didn't do go find another people to make no we're not going to tell him specifically but we're going to tell our friends in the he says don't let don't let it out of your mou don't tell a soul whatever I'm telling you it's highly confidential no problem he trusted him but you're not accomplishing what happens without him asking they just respond we're not going to tell anybody we're going to stay quiet we going to stay we're going to stay quiet not tell which means to say very nice a lot of times you'll mention the guy make him feel comfortable you can tell him don't worry it's even today we find it's very you going tell a person today don't worry I'm going to stay quiet however since it's not highly confidential information and he didn't explicit tell you what's going to happen eventually over time you're going to by mistake let it out and let people know and therefore it's going to come out that is that really true what do you mean in a scenario in Spain which it takes the years far it sound like the Mion that the mar himself is going to come running back and more than that when we said the Mish in the da we explain that it makes sense that he's coming running back CU how else what's the chances that you found found the Shar coming that day and a quickly making immediate return it could take a while till you find this so based on this TR that's what we understood that he himself coming back he's going to come back right away that's why specifically three years and not longer and make and then eventually get to him that he himself should go back that he himself should go back and be able to get all his payers and everything he's losing otherwise it's going to be much more harder to pull it away and get back whatever the person think because why else would he question it that can be so what is going on why did he ask this question after he heard it from that's when he was able to he held like that now he holds when he question him ever tell us how many people does it take to establish you need to tell as long as you tell two people it's consider you need to have three people not two is more we're going to see find this in then when you tell three people comes a everybody knows about it which means just by talking therefore one holds two doesn't hold and therefore that's what that is a is not it's good enough two threes that's what it takes to spread therefore you need that you need to have a you need it for since it's not therefore you need to have two people you're going to have to go over to the person himself to give the have is the two people to give G to be able to bring that he was need three people it is a good need three people to spread the around so why I need why do I need three that if not for the it even be one would help so it's he even one so why three there's no such thing as three is once why two for three it's enough to spread but under three so comes up the is really how many does it take to spread according even one so it's one or three however therefore you need make some in property there was three people sitting there and says there three people and needs three so he made year later he thought he need to make a every year you don't need to make every year it's good enough once every three years however some say it wasn't those three answered want to respond every three years you must continue to make a new I'm so if you'rein how could in the world could you establish after three years even four years later we never in the world hold that if a person's just because the guy's a Goin we just say we don't know who belongs to maybe belongs to you or the we don't know you have a of because he we have to give it back just like he's making once why should I have to change he already established everybody once you should know that he should hold on to the forever and ever you have to go every three years the the way we learned after three years a person just eventually doesn't hold especially actually mean eventually a person just loses on it's very hard for a person to hold on forever and ever it makes sense why should hold you have to make a every three years let's finish with this in a scenario it's every three years if you're sticking to your story which is Ru is a Goin whatever your story is it could be M the could beis whatever your story is it has to stick you can't change it is the problem with people that lie is they forget what they said earlier that's what he's saying however you forgot that three years ago you said a separate said he's a you're showing that and therefore says he loses his all his um okay next week we'll try to pick off from the last line