Daf Yomi Succah Daf 54 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rob boyce [Music] massimi sponsored by the saka family in honor of the yard side of ahiyabad becky saka which is on the 22nd of hello mena shama having a leo becky's our relative my wife's cousin yeah my wife's cousin not the one that was lifted the one she she's named after this woman you throw maisha in honor of our son yehuda wine ribs bar mitzvah today mazel tov manchester mdy participants in honor of rabbi bernard david rosh habura mdy manchester in anticipation of the mdy manchester cium so manchester is going to have a scene there is hashem for for slayma for yehuda ben rahul close friend of mirad mccash mink sponsor for the beta campaign there's a bunch of sponsors actually and just the other day somebody sponsored five thousand dollars anonymously and two and a half thousand dollars anonymously but there's still room he's the main sponsor this is a logo and any money that's left over will the next mistake and the next the kids are so talking about the sumim i have uh five rsvps here we have our cm here in rbs wednesday evening september 1st just a few days from now location prussian hall which is next doors the brand new hall 8 p.m america followed by the seam and entertainment men and women are invited rsvp by right after lucas we just informed islam it's really for women too it's a good thing my wife's not going to be there please my wife just flew back to america please use the link below to help us gauge which knight will work best this is the miami seaum they're looking for some uh involvement so miami wants to do a serum and now we have toronto seoum wednesday evening september 1st location i blouse house i don't know if i should say the address arie blau why you want to go there you're going to be in toronto we might have a guy there okay be in touch this is going to be a viewing of the sheer the last half of sukhov followed by our own hadrian and cium looking forward to greeting everybody mdy new york new jersey area see them thursday september 2nd location ycq is chief of central queens free parking premises at 7 30 followed by the ceo what else oh london invites the island to see him wednesday september 1st the aviv restaurant 7 45 p.m till 10 p.m all right so everybody look up your people like in london you go mdy london gmail.com great now oh yeah we're a boys sunday night eight o'clock where at the skin anything less than 10 people we don't we don't announce arie blau hi rebelli we're organizing right around the scene on wednesday that is uh at his home uh 113 glen park avenue the program will start with a group view of the final foul everyone's invited okay thank you to marcus kennedy price for helping to get the word out also i know you like pictures i'm attaching a picture of my 10 year old son ben and i doing the daf with rebelli last week while back country camping in the interior of algonquin park in ontario canada we were five hour canoe ride from civilization and completely off the grid no electricity best of all no cell service doing the daf has guaranteed that no matter where we go where que veya itim la toiro making terror a focal point of our trip and i'm grateful to you and the mdy team for making the daf and terror so engaging no way chicago is having a cm what a shocker i want to see this happen okay this is gonna the voice i we've seen we haven't seen a bigger nest than this 10 and up it has to be at least 10. yeah they have time you know how many people watch this year in chicago steve jakubowski watches this year he wouldn't show up to a live share you want me to call you out i'll call you out my own step-brother aria kushner watching everything didn't come uh thursday september 2nd basic nessus ashkenaz of chicago what is that i don't know what do i know what that is what specifically maybe it's the wrong name 6212 north lincoln that's why it's like crazy what's going on they do it in the wrong place time 8 p.m to 9 30 p.m estimated cost free [Music] wow what is 6 600 links okay so here's uh arie blau on his canoe next is canoe cave de la toyo your talmud ari blau toronto canada unbelievable here he is with his son with a campfire uh good morrow i slept with him in gemara five hours away from civilization and of course can't get away from the cellphone what else do we have here oh so i don't know if you guys recall there was a guy i'm not going to say his name now i said his name then but just because he's doing a seam with a lot of people and whatever we're going to keep it on the loadout his name is akiva remember f something oh she said then that it all started 44 days ago when david zlatnick f200 was finishing dispatching for atsala 12 am in the morning and he said his life is empty this guy akiva and he says do the dove and i'm like okay it's gonna change your life and i did it and it's now 44 days i haven't missed a day i've never i haven't learned like this ever in my life one year in 11th grade i had a rabbit that was like you bring schmuck to toro i did not open up gemara since 11th grade i wake up every morning waiting to get onto youtube wow badly you changed my life thank you okay so this was the um the email we read a while ago he's back he's back judah is back unbelievable we did miss you and that by the way he gets up uh for sleepless for in the morning it's not a joke so rabbi said listen to this so this akiba is making us see him for probably the very first time in his life maybe he made one eleventh grade i don't know but he hasn't made a scene in many many years he's making you see him now he invited 50 of his friends one of his friends is the guy that introduced him to the dab double zlatnik so listen to david zlatnick he's already purchased 30 arsenal gummers with the whole letter inside with the sticker and he's coming to the sea and prepared he thinks he's going to recruit 30 guys i'm just saying here's a guy he's a cool guy he's a with a guy he's a successful guy there's no boucha you come there with 30 gemaras how many guys did you recruit why does everybody ask yourself how many guys do you recruit so i looked at the list there's hundreds of people that signed the bar hashem for beta i was a little disappointed from the hundreds of people that came and says where they came from you see the world news and matzah and the email and this and that i want to say maybe 15 people came from friends it's very each person all you need to do put it on your status it doesn't even take any time it doesn't take effort you put on your status you got it you did it you're on who else here who else anybody status what is the status you you just put in your book or something all right how many guys did you get they keep on leaving okay your partner you attack i brought some guys i remember it's not good for them what i don't know what's that i really i was talking to somebody listen the only don't yeah hold on a second will you have a medicine hold up he's right okay i just want to tell you one one short mice you asked me if why it's not in my status so one day um i started getting these phone calls from people what's wrong with you like and this was like a year and a half ago it's ready this year was pretty large i watched the video of of a firecracker um some some uh a manufacturing firecracker place in china that exploded and it was so large explosions a few blocks away that you see the the whole thing and it was coming towards the hotel and the people videotaping were cursing in english and somehow i watched the video somehow it got on my status i pushed the and it went into like all my contacts i'm like this is the magazine with the all the nipple pad going on what is wrong with you my daughter called daddy take it off quickly like what where how what is status how do you take it off anyway that was the first and last time oh we got to put the right thing on okay very good our boy said here we are today is daf nun dalid and we are only two lines from the bottom of base so we added between review huda whether each sound of the shauper blowing is considered its own mitzvah so you do kia true or kia is that one mitzvah or three the mission says that this 48 coils max the most you could ever get to in any given situation is 48 pilots according to bihouda he agrees this 48 kylies but the only disagrees that it's considered 16 mitzvahs it's 48 divided by 3 and not 48 individual missiles now today's daf basically is like a riddle if you want to play the riddle you could try how could you possibly get to more than kylos what day of the year could you pass and get to more and go through different scenarios and different things like that and different alohas along the way now this is says you cannot stop you cannot you can't take a break you can't pause between a kia and a true or the light clown you could breathe that's about it but you can't take a nice break and that was one of the things that matteo was teaching me when i was trying to blow the schweifer and that's why he says it's not so positive that he did it the right way and he's probably right in terms of i did the cutoffs too the breathing part probably i messed up on i have no idea i think he told me afterwards that there's a there's such an issue and i did it in one long thing i don't know i have no idea yeah you're welcome but we had 11 people and that's what it was come on is the one that says that it's one mitzvah true is one minute so make sure you don't make a break in between you can't can't take a nap in between one mitzvah it's one minute so you take it you do it kia immediately it's true and immediately because it's one thing if it's three separate mitzvahs you can take a break do it kia go home come back do a true that's not a problem it's different says definitely the same affiliate maybe what it means don't take a break it means don't take a serious break or like a nap like a spatsir why because there's amanda ahmad called ruby who says you could take a nap in between kids [Music] that we're not going in rabona we're going in ruby huda that has to be rivkahana means to say it has to be in one shot without any break at all not a giant break and not a medium you can't have any break at all if you want you could look at rashid masculation this is what i mentioned yesterday's because i had to see it inside three lines down hey what does the tires say what do you need a blow sholish only three sounds two two two two two and two that's it three sounds this challenge is another three this challenge let's jump right in another three a total of nine toilets that's it i've didn't face what it today do we do more mushrooms fake it the true because of the suffix that we have what a true is it okay that's the shiloh says um maybe perhaps you could take a larger break who told you that the the ain't being killer true means no break at all okay in my vlog club look at the words it says the le on the bottom of of daffodil game along with base the last like the last line it says the light clone zero break roger just says zero doesn't mean zero zero you allowed to breathe of course you don't have to suffer but you shouldn't take a break oh here we go so we said if it's heir of shabbos on sukis in the middle of sukkah's friday falls out of middle circus they're going to be 48 sounds so here it goes all the charts and i think there's six or seven of them they're very simple the is very very easy the top line is always the same sounds of the shofar of every day every day you have the same 21 nothing changes and therefore on all the charge is going to be the same we're not going to change what are they three when they open up the gates nine which every single day of the year we have atomid there's nine and we said they say a certain shear they all bow down they blow again they see the shear they go bow down again okay and then nine of thomas are back so very simple nine plus nine plus three equals twenty one now remember we had a whole suggestion about the shira malloys remember we blew a shauper on the 15 stairs of that correspond to the toilet and we said why is that because put the piece of earthenware in the ground and the water went down sixteen thousand hours then he had to pull it back up fifteen thousand dollars so he said fifteen pound so why is it not mentioned in our mission over here we spoke about these trumpets they go down either they go there five steps or ten steps remember we had a taiku you sure iron price learned the sukkah 40 times i think it was a lot of times he told me that it's there's only three takeovers in circles something like that okay whatever you can look it up taiko is it do they go there but it's not mentioned in this mission here it's not in this list look what it says here we have that are have to do with the water shower eleon chartactine filling up the water next to them is bayak and then we have the mussoff of sukkus and because it's heir of shabbos we have another six that to tell people leave the field that's three field house and then another three when shikia comes along okay so that's six fair shabbos what's missing here from the list right down here this agave or when they put the rava by them is beth it should say shira malloys three that would work they go down the stairs five stairs or ten stairs and they blow the shauffer why is it not in this list says the gemara on here so on a typical day of sukkah it's not arab shabbos because there are shabbas you have i i mean yeah you have the muslim and the whatever this list only has the water part twelve twelve hisokas which is char elion relion that's nine what is the other three machlokis it's three on the stairs it's the three when you put around or vitamins b okay so our mishna goes according to blessed yaqub don't ask me a question why it doesn't mention the sharia malloys because our mission is verbalizing we always pass because it's a total of 12. there we have a kabbalah whatever it is it's going to be 12 sounds of the shauper how you want to divide it you divide it any way you want europe lesbian i'll give you divided three by the number bedrooms divided by um by the shira malice giving the talk out of series oh i'm sorry my time with the rivals what's the spoiler behind it so he says look he's talking about the sharim you're already blue from your 21 every single day you blow for opening up gates the series let me taka so why do i need to blow when he's coming down the stairs i love shiro it's not a it's not a gate sharny connor's a gate but five stairs down what is that ten steers down it's not a gate it's better to do it by the miss beach bonus however given the talk of limitless what is what is what are these 12 have in common that they're all part of the nisa hamaya now the mizbeh has nothing to do with it some say because it's in the path of where the water is going it's going right through the shire and economy down the stairs fine rashi says has nothing to do with anything it's just a place that we picked five stairs down another three kias great mom rebecca came from dorad he brought up with him he asked um question why does it say that the the sons of aaron they blow the trumpets already says it that they're blowing so what is which tomorrow we're going to slug up but today we're going with him and that is allah and he explains what he's saying in other words if there is shabbos yantif so there's two musafim there's the muslim first shabbos and this carbon was the preactive so you'd have to blow nine for shabbos and nine for yantef the gemara goes away from it that's not how we pass it but for today that's what we're going to deal with music is uh nine kiss for most of is for every type of music so now we have akasha what's the cache so that was this list right over here that area of shabs that falls out here we go you see right over here are shabbos that is in the middle of sukis a total of 48. here's the problem in the mission that says the most you could get to is 48 well guess what i have a way to get to more than 48 how if you are right that every carbon muscle you have to blow ninth kias listening why are you doing friday do shabbos and now you have what do you have why oh very good so you're saying it's only 51 why because you have to take off so look at this chart the six of error of shabbos you have to warn people to come out of the fields and out of these stores close the stores get rid of those six you're putting on nine and getting rid of six so you only have three extra 48 plus three equals 53. okay says you'll never get more than 48 kias if shabbos not if every sukkas has a shabbos in there somewhere there's two moose often one for shab is one for sukkas times two times nine eighteen plus the rest of the stuff you have fifty one or makes a nice try but he gets slammed right away all right he says you see this 21 the 21 you have to remove three and if you remove three you're back down to 48. why do you have to remove this this is not part of that void that's not part of the carbon it's to tell people get ready tell the question to get ready alarm clocks are not the chavez part of the carbon is like the shabbos so take off three if you think of three you back down 51 minus three 48. says montana hashtag he's making he's making flour it's not even good flour he leaves his stuff in there it's it's it's not pure flour first of all there's a problem with what he's saying it says in our mishnah look at new game element every single day what does every single day mean shop is included so in chavez they did have three keys for shaaram it says in the mishnah though it's another problem in nami nino even if you are correct that there's only 48 in other words shabbos and sukko here these two are the same let's say these two are the same number they're both 48. shabbos oh wrong one shabbos and they're shabbos they're both the same they're 48 guess which one you should pick you should pick this one why because this one has two hidushim and this one only has one enamel why does our mission pick this one air of shabbos that's in the middle of sukkas it's a lot better to bring this as an example of 48. you if you're telling me that it's only 48 great let's i'll roll with you but the mission should say in this case shabs in the middle of sukis why is so that's number one which by the way you also have over here same kiddush but the second condition you don't have [Music] look over here to musaff and most of the shabbos muslim that's a huge criticism tomorrow we're going to slug up so i should say this traditional mishna that anytime you have a muslif you give it another nine blows why why did we pick arab shabs instead of shabbas in the mishnah al-ahmar guess what ever better than you life agreed with me i didn't even put in rib zero because it's such a it doesn't really hold rob his question is so strong that if just to if you want to memorize not that it doesn't belong the mark has all but to memorize the come out of this it's not in there um what does that mean 12. we are not mentioning any of the twelve all these guys all the threes for shari ali shah talking not it doesn't exist bishabbas why the buttery tuva so now if you have 51 minus 12 you're left with 39. we don't do it on chavez it doesn't push off shabbos the we said there's no yeah so melo then you don't even have 48. i want to get to the most the mission brought us a case of the most kiosk and that's 48 your your idea oh we'll leave us with 39. ask the gemara well uh okay the list according to you that anytime there's a carbon moss of you bring you you blow the soy for nine times so guess what coming up in a week shabbos rosh hashanah not really shabbos roshana but guess what there are three museofim did you know that on rosh hashanah you bring a carbon registration because roshan is it's we read it what's the words so there would be a total of 3 times 9 27 plus 21 equals 48. so i have another case of 48 kias so why did i pick area of shabbos the falls out of sukis and not shabbos versus because over here i don't have this of that we don't blow the shauper on the stairs i blow the strifer by the mizbeh i want to tell you that that's a better question for me says gemara but you didn't answer the question automatically i'm listening listening i didn't say say rosh hashanah and not shabbos or arab shabbos i should say this one i didn't say that what i said is say both of them why can't the mission list two when the mission brings an example bring two examples and shabbos versus shannon they both have 48. why is that not in the mishnah says the gemara tony this year because the titan doesn't go through all the examples i bring you one example you'll realize that there are other examples but that rule or that excuse and turrets only applies when there's more than one thing that you're leaving out if there's only two items then the mission always brings both if there's three four or five i bring one and figure out the rest says gemara mai shir the high shear but what's the third thing i know of two i know of shabbat sukkas and i know of shabbos rosh hashanah two that you blow the show for 48 times what's number three says the gemara shir pesa er pesa the what so here's her face off hmm airplay sound i didn't print it okay no i did print this but i printed it wrong for this fine error face off ignore this for a second the bottom thing erif pesach it says air of shabbos okay so you have the 21 that's a constant i know let's just let's use this for a second air pay south forget about shabbos airplanes ah so we learned in there were so many people bliya and hara that brought the carbon face there was not enough room for them to do something so they split they divided clouds from the three groups and there's so many people per group that they said hollow they repeated how three times so every time they said hallo they blew the chauffeur so one group said the hallow they said the kids are there's nine kias per group and there were three groups right because they did true for every hallow times three is nine because they said all three times and you have three groups again there's three groups if we take each group each group said how three times that's how long it took the shack all the kirbanis do all this riku whatever and each time you say hallo you say it's kyo truth kios that's three carlos times three halos is nine times three groups they repeated this three times so you have again 27 27 plus 21 equals 48. so here's another case of 48 excuse forget about this guy on the bottom says the gemara even in honor of my wife yeah i did on purpose she says review the holds that there's so few people in the third group they never said hollow three times they barely said how once even the one time that they said they never got to ahafti but they still blew the schaefer because you blow the chevy right before hollow so they got three kias so how many are they missing they are missing six because the final group is missing two hollows two house times three is six so mainly you have this for rib yehuda you have nine plus nine plus three missing six so it's 42 not 48 hour this goes according to you the that is 42 key is now 48. now what's the very big problem because yesterday if you look at the gemara yesterday what does it start off saying the gemara look at the umar and that from giving him base where it says gemara it says mas nissin de la kiribuda bam our mission that says 48 sounds cannot be reviewed though says that you have to divide it by three it's only 16 sounds because each one each three is one mitzvah so how are you telling me all of a sudden that this is where you our mission doesn't even go like now islam has a i heard a vart that the third cat is called katatslanum the lazy ones why are they lazy says some rebel or something because they never got to hafti kish mashem if they got a haptic ishmael rabbi schoenberg likes it okay fine block review though kim no whatever the lotion here is like review our mission is not reviewed though that's not a good question maybe holds this idea of pesach there's only 42 keys now 48. but it doesn't hold like reviewed in our mishnah that through kia is considered one mitzvah he holds his three mitzvahs like our mishnah but he holds that there's only 42 kills on earth and that's why it's not mentioned in our miz so then why doesn't out why does our mission have not mentioned rosh hashanah shashana give us two cases all because this is the third case what is the third case of shakhalu what happened there i hope you know what maybe it did printed i didn't print it hey stop what am i looking for uh here we go this one right over here okay air of pesach the falls out on heir of shabbos arab shabbos we have the six shoifroys to tell people to come out of the field and close the stores and not be mikhail chavez that's six so according to rib yehuda it adds up exactly to 48. you took off six because you're missing two from halo and you only had 42. so you add a six and now you have 48. so in this case you have 48. so the bottom line is i have three cases i have the case of our mishnah arab shabbos and sukkas i have rosh hashanah you ask me why it's not in the mishnah because they also have this so now i have two cases that are not in the mission of the ton of bashir the the tana gave us one example you figure out the rest as the gemara the emojis it says the most you could get to in the kids are 48 below oh here this one right over here erev pesach which we already established is how many oh no we didn't establish it that was the chavez 42 according to your buddha which is also shabbos it's now 42 plus 9 for the most of the shabbos equals 51. and if you are who say that arab pastor is 48 because they have all the hollows and everything is intact with the halo it's 48. so 48 plus 9 of music 58 57 say because it doesn't exist every year it's very difficult to find this case that area of faith that falls at anashabas it's once every who knows how many years something that's not every year i don't want to talk about it says the gemara wait a minute that's the that i i got you a little bit the the example of our mishna which is falling out of middle calamari somewhere arab shadows okay that's the example of mishnah it doesn't fall out every year like that now i don't understand that mars caches so well maybe someone will find it in north london like yes it might be a close catcher too it's very shriek to have this it's so ancient not to have this we're going to give an example it doesn't happen but that example is once every over here to have every place that falls in shabbos is very natural to fight so what does he want to say the old calendar that we're using all the dates are mixed up so don't pay any attention to any dates just pay attention to these circles if circus falls out on a friday circus you see the red thing circus is this is friday this shabbos this is sunday if sukis falls out over here then the next friday is radius meeting at teres it's the eight you see number eight so mellow i have i have a way that every shabbos doesn't fall out on sukkas says good morning that's not true it never happens why kim miglia young i'm very shabbos if that would were to happen if kaham saw it's about to happen such a case in other words i'm just thinking i think what i thought if it ever happens then it's something that's not shaykh and i wouldn't even mention in the mishnah even if it could happen once every 25 years listen mark says it never happens not even once in every 25 years why because if this were to happen let's back it up where does yom kipper fall out if sukkos falls out on a friday that means rosh hashanah fell out on a friday and if rosh hashanah falls out on friday 11 days later is yom kippur which is on a sunday what happens that's a big problem we don't want to have shabbos and yum kipper back to back because what if somebody dies on chavez his body's going to be there for two days it's really bad stuff also rashi says the vegetables start spoiling we don't want that either so may allah say this is about to happen they won't allow it to happen they won't allow rosh hashanah to be over here don't make it they'll push it off they'll do 30 days so that your should fall out on a monday my timer keep it thinking like you're under virgin is very shabbos if that happens if you haven't have a book shop then young people fall out on a sunday and we can't have that um do we ever push off or you can keep it like that but it's craving for him listen to this we have a big macho which we learned back in the day what happens to the tamid the uh the avarm the khalavim that have to be burned on the misbehave so here's shabbos your macro the carbon tommen goes every single day on chavez also when do you burn the the khalavim if they're left over i am kipper according to this mandomar why because himkipper has less kedusha than chavez bernier i am keeper new do you see that your kipper is back to back with chavez argues on that rebic evo rebecca says him keeping champions are equal lingadusha you cannot burn the khal of him from shabbat and you keep okay barbara zero kaveen bay rav biblava will have abraham when i was there by raven bubble he said sanyo or they said maybe he said this this concept that was they wouldn't tell people oh stop doing melaka it's almost shabbos because nobody does keep her so there's no point to do as aka right before shabbos um is the one that says shavum kippur are equal in the dusa the bottom line is you see that yom kippur and shabbos fall back to back says the gemara that says that you me our mishna that says that you push it off you push off yom kippur never falls out on a sunday goes according to goes according to rabban are the ones that say that never happens in other words if ateris schwarz falls out on a sunday this year i know automatically only according to hyrum that shus next year is going to fall out four days later on a thursday why because there's 50 weeks in the year 50 times 7 is 350. the year has 354 days so there's four extra days every year so what happens this year on a sunday happens next year on a thursday and it never changes according to there's always a month that's 29 days and then a month that's 30 days the six and six and that never changes no matter what even if you're concerned about the dead people being there for two days we're not going to change it and if there's an extra month in that in that uh year so let's think about it how many days are there in a month 29. the the mover is always 29. look at our homes now seven weeks uh four weeks divided by seven days is 28 this should be 28 days but there's 29 that means it's an extra day to the calendar so instead of having four days difference from year to year so now we just added a fifth day okay so says the gomorrah fight should we stop over here where's my nakam stop over here but then every day we're going to fall behind a little bit okay make it almost drivers have a wonderful day rabbis i have to apologize to the guys in zoom because of sleekess i want to join the elements which we're starting right now so i won't be able to join the islam have a great wonderful day [Music] ah [Music] you