Daf Yomi Succah Daf 51 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] sponsored by stephen burak i'd like to thank rebelli for getting me and others excited about learning again i hope this house of learning is important that you will lead to a sweet year for all of clash royale by mirad nakash lurkforshalema good friend of his yehuda ben rocco by maisha kenzoburski before shleiman to him in honor of her belly even though you weren't able to make it as a massage last night at david's hasano that you and mdy are fully responsible for okay thank you thank you again for the mini homashir you gave the other day in our honor reverse lima big mazette should have a lot of nakas from him from the other hasan from all your kids four sleigh mobrano bass yenta devaira by joel palek from my dear grandmother essa perkell who passed away today at age of a hundred and one she's just kyle for whom the lesson of success mem testament base is relevant he said she showed kindness thought in the last weeks of her life his mother naomi pollock devoted hours every day to carrying her mother for years throughout cover providing example may her memory be of a blessing by official gross and his wife in memory of remordechai menashe ben avram samber mr marty samber patriarch of shall shells of all stars rip david samber of south bend whose officials brother-in-law rib avi samba from telestone and ellie sanders of chicago who i know very well he's the principal of very crown my two sons went there first big kufa the levia is heir of shabbos in chicago i love this email from david dimbert you remember him he came here with coffee he has a coffee thing from highland park we're alia la regal we're on daphne test talking about the middle of a realm of vinu and the idea of giving shoes to people who want to make alilah regal a huge describe to the sheer to rebellion everyone who contributes to the bay gemara campaign to someone who doesn't learn a free gemara is like a free pair of shoes an entrance to the young toivom you're putting shoes on the people who don't even understand their own dreams of aliyah this could come with that suffer david by heaven not his real email address i guess dear rebelli i would like to thank you for being one of the sole sources of light in my light in my life right now goes on to say i sharing your tsar i have a very similar situation i'm telling him now that we got past that boring stuff because who remembers days anymore when you learn the daf he's going by the daphne like similar to what you were talking about will be forever etched in my mind thanks to your dedication to the sheer despite your son's wedding i was also very inspired as you have said it was an ace the whole being of the wedding a very close second the sukadaf lament when you give the share after the share of breakfast should we pay you for your dedication merits for all your kids oh man hashem give you the strength to always be able to give shiurim on maine yes okay name withheld heavenly fee by benjamin frankel sean rivelli it's a pleasure having you toward the u.s and being able to meet you at the chevy broadcast and again live share wood mirror multi-shabbas that said having nachman by your side live in md mby is priceless i can only imagine how many lines were skipped without knocking chirping in i was wondering why they need to have another freaking buyer campaign it's enough already the more people who join the longer the line will be to say somalian when you come to the u.s next but after reading your ramba rampant on this week's pyro show i know why the ramban peric zain says his fouls will be ascension from town loosely translated if one learns and teaches they have the ability to be hazardous others and don't it is included in the order grocery shop decline everyone is behind the freaking market pain we should all be certain to greet the shrine of b.j franco mdy north woodmere claulo pratt by harry presser hello rebelli shears amazing was always on and off with the dot for a few years found you by accident have been doing it now for a month love every minute perfect mix of fun and explanations today share you really explain cloud product cloud better than any rebbe i've ever had the only thing i didn't understand was why by the reboy the only excluded they only excluded and not let's say wood thanks for your sacrifice looking forward to being part of the khaburi years to come ari presser continental casing corporation well paris is the least of all caleb it's the bottom of the bottom the only thing less than that i guess is clay galolum but that's for sure not included there's no way that you could bring a clear gull attack which barco that would be aina yeah okay but if you go in i mean the bottom of the the line is a cliffhanger you have wood you have stone whatever but harris is on the back oh and one more well we're making we're doing good here with time you though harry man my name is yehuda i'm 22 living in teaneck married have a child in the way vaser hashem getting married young men starting to work and leave the basement i want to thank you for helping me gain a real good schmuck in my learning and being conveyed in the torah by joining himself i've also been able to improve other parts of my learning style each night such nice night micro and brewer beautiful i want to share a funny meister that happened a few weeks back i was in notice a man with headphones on computer out sitting at a table alone outside the hall as my wife and i walked past i noticed a familiar face on the screen shuckling and moving his hands a lot i stopped to get closer look it was not other than yosef billiac i told him i'm an avid listener how much i enjoyed the share he told me the email thanks again rebellion coming in my learning to a new level immersion i'm looking forward to finishing many sentences with your share shots and beyond called two of you who the hammerman here he is with the eyes of billyak at the wedding now joseph is on his way to the airport on his way back there to stroll and he stopped off at the wedding and you decided to you had to you had to time snow was out of business that day no i'm saying it's unbelievable dedication you should feel safe she'll fall yosemite is now working on a big surprise for the cm which is the new song why do you keep on saying the surprise oh people want to know about it i could show it and then you say whatever no no just to hear it and to see it is i can say there's nothing okay a song what's the song who what's his name what david cohen's brother malaysia very nice all right you came at a beautiful a beautiful time we're on that noon alef which means we are 50 daft into musa 50 deaf ago a lot of people started for the very first time with us and they held out 50 long days actually very short days today is a beautiful beautiful daf we're holding the last last words on daf noon on the bays over so we're in the middle of the mahloise what is considered the iker shira and the visamigosh figure out well i think we figured out shira montichabas is going to be at 9 30 not before sleepless because there are a lot of people that do the next day including year me gold who doesn't even come to this year you again you could do it no problem you do i'm gonna be preparing the next morning's here okay so now we have a macholicus how do you what what is the toy when the turtle says it should be a shiro by a carbon by by other thing what what does it mean with a instrument a clay with the levine's mouth or whoever's seen so similar to the macholic it says incredible by the carbon tahmed who was playing the instruments they were slaves they were going so we have a three-way macholicas who played the instruments were they gayim were they israelim or these were israel not even levine but something in between the warning they weren't avadon there were israelites special families they oh sorry sorry um i'm sorry i'm missing don't get too excited avi shahayu massim la kahuna they had such good yikos that their daughters that their almanas would marry into the kahuna no questions asked yeah so he says no no the only people that played the instruments you know why a guy could play the guitar because it's nothing the main thing is the levine singing the beautiful voices whoever accompanies them with a with a guitar with a keynote with a flu that it doesn't matter it could be on on a recording it could be a guy it doesn't matter that says well no when the turtle says shiro that means instruments so therefore obviously it doesn't mean a heaven no so what's the kasha then what do you do with the middle mandola mark the man that says it's israel if it's important then has to be a lady if it's not important it could be evid why israel it should be even slaves should be able to weaken if you have if the torah is referring to instruments certainly when the turtle talks about shira it's referring to bappa it has to be singing twice is asking amazing kasha if that's the case this is just for shadow of the sun if that's the case then we had this we had this uh chart the other day you remember this chart there are 12 days that you could play the flute what are the 12 days eight days of circus let me go on for a thousand points it was the air of pesach and basil shane fine how do you come to eight days of circus if icarus the torah says you should sing it with your mouth so how in the world are you allowed to play a violin violin is just extra how how could you get to eight days how can you be mikhail chavez with a violin the target doesn't save ireland taurus says you should do with your mouth so tyson says and this is everybody wonders about this also the whole list is to play instrument is only the rabbana because you might come to fix it so there's no schwa that's that's the next line that's the next line says [Music] what happened listen some sometimes the vatim are really good instrument players and that's why they use them that's what happened was the australian never better who's the band who played in the band you ever saw that video i was just thinking about this there's a video of like uh in france so anyways i saw a murder video of three non-jews singing a schwecky song yeah yeah yeah jamaicans okay so that's what it was why do they why did they hire them because they were better than the jewish guys over there they were good they were really good [Music] doctor okay so if that was the mysore who cares why are we telling us that oh you should know there's slaves up there playing them the instruments says that's huge enough him you know with a massive when you see a guy on the stage on the band stage could i grab him and say oh you can marry my daughter you could have meister that means you're a lady or there's no raya just because you're up there maybe you're a non-jew man the fact that you're playing instruments up there means zero so i don't marry you off to anybody i don't give you mice um it's in between things you're allowed to be a swirl up on the stage and therefore you have gudiros but it doesn't mean anything that you're a lady so therefore you don't get mice or which a lady is entitled to the ten percent amanda so if i see somebody on the stage that means he's a lady that means he has zikos and it means that he could eat my sir says the gemara okay so for this right boy so we have to go back to yesterday it goes like this very very positive we have a macho it's a very simple macholicas which we add parts to so we have the flute the hollow ribbon is he says you could play the flute on shabbos say you cannot play the florence okay that's what we have what does that mean in what situation what scenario you could play a flute what stop play a flute on shadows comes revised if that's the sugi that we had yesterday and says no let me explain to you the macholic is you see the red box here the maclaurins is only in one case biocarbon that's carbon is it there isa comes whereby i see says flute you could play by a carbon when you bring your carbon cache you cannot play a flute biocarbon but by simcha's beija eva down here there's no macholic you see there's no red box everybody agrees that synchronous baby cannot play a flute on shabbos why it's just simcha it doesn't say anywhere entirely should play a flute we invented it we decided to make it all exciting and happy so we brought in a band but doesn't mean they could be deutsche shabbos with it that's rebbe raviosif his explanation of this macholicus comes your beer mia right now today and explains it differently by the way i was thinking to myself like if you learned yeshiva and you see this child like what i'm going to look at a chart for daffy me it's past but we're learning quickly and and even though it's a very simple macholicas but to add another part and also you become confused you feel like you don't have the sugya i think it's unbelievable this chart managed for me at least it made it clear for me so here's the same says that the macholicas is down here not over here not between carbon and carbon bicarbonate and carbon you remember the sugiya you know it you you you you did the 40 cu on so-called 62 groups and therefore what you don't remember this anymore okay make sense all right so run your groups let me run the groups and keep every all your comments over there with the groups the mark like this is between so i'm going to get oh you have to be nice even to the network come come here yeshua come come to the front okay so between eva and simba's bay shiva you hear this unbelievable idea it's basically we kind of entices we kind of said it this mach like is in simplest base shape can you play a flute even though then saying you win the target should play a flute but it's only there a bun on and there's a big symphony going on in the mesa mid-dash so the bottom pushes off this thing you can push off the right button because it's a major major sim card don't write me any emails i know i'm a big rush or whatever fine yeah so according to here mia there's no like using carbon please zoom in on him please garrison do me a favor i don't know if you could do it quickly but god is he's already okay but naham all very very simple mclaren when we're making a whole big deal out of this according to reverend there's no mcluck's in carbon everybody agrees that a flute pushes off carbon because it's their iso the whole machine is even in simplest ways but there's no mention of the torah rubies says flute you could play music all you want it's a simcha on chavez of course in shops of columbia what's the shyla you know what i'll stop right over here and say something very interesting very very interesting i thought i think a lot of people might know this i wasn't so clear about it imagine you walk into akkason on friday night they used to make casas friday night and you see music playing what would you say to yourself crazy doesn't make any sense you're allowed to ask a non-jew on shabbos to come to your house and play music for allah [Music] clap your hands but you're not allowed to ask for music on chavez you're not allowed to dance and you're not going to clap your hands you know the famous that you're not going to clap you know how to snap your fingers or bang on the table like drum and and if somebody does it you don't tell them not to because it's it's better that you should be showing you're not amazed what about just dancing like walking around the table like you know like the literature dance oh yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah i like that so as soon as i said it's not considered dancing and it's okay on chavez i'll tell you a quick reminder the first first week i diving here in the show in in shivas all of a sudden i couldn't believe it such a good schmacka island they get up by a couple of shabbos and they're like oh he's shoving shouting and dancing around the beam i was like this is a murder show in fact i never went anywhere else in eight years i've never dived in another show ever but the second week i was there they didn't they weren't going around the bema so okay whatever third week fourth week i'm there all of a sudden i hear the guy by going to the guys next to me listen there's a new guy coming we got to do this thing around the bema thing we gotta impress him he's like are you serious he's not even smiling because he knows it's true you were part of that going around the bema thing and pretending that you're all schmuck okay anyway fine my final if you want to see these allah i thought is incredible mamish music the whole thing because sinclair was causing macaw someone's tired you like to dance and clap your hands but you're not allowed to play the music okay so but here we are smack in the middle of a different sugar um yeah where are we have no idea where we are oh verb so going back to our beer meal this mac like is let's do it again this is not like we had yesterday that according to yo you see you could play a flute on chaps and according to hakam you cannot he says there's no mock-like is when it comes to carbon in their eyes of course everybody says you could play a flute talking about an invented kind of thing that's not an entire simplest-based shave could you play a flute when you're only pushing off at the rabbana in the basement and rebecca says you could say there will be a sweeper right and by the way this hello that i said about hassan is only applies to hasana not by cabela's shabbos and not by other mila and other things you cannot play instruments special carbon by carbon these two checks of shabbos i hold revere me and there's no magnets by carbon whereas yesterday we had revisive who says the machologist is by carbon and by simple base shape there's no math like everybody says it's awesome to play instrument mesme here according to reviosif there's no nobody that holds that you could play instrument on simcoe shiva zero oscar and all of a sudden over here look at this bryce even on simple you could be mahal shabaz but there's two parts to revisive don't forget here's we just shrugged up this part we have here the ruby cb review that says you could play instruments by simply playing shiva but there's another part don't forget this part that in carbon he says there's a machoices now i'm going to prove to you that he's wrong in that also there's no macholicus in carbon and in fact everybody holds just like this that carbon is motor and you should play instruments on chaves your carbon dioxide so now perhaps i could just be medic the whole mach like it says in the braiser the zero like is by carbon and it's okay and that's also a cash on reversal because you said that it's not okay to play biocarbon says the gemara no that's not a great cash show lame with having to give to the of the statements are reviews of tarti that is a much like zen carbon and there's no mach logistics he says now look there's going to be a tu mach like is by carbon according to home you cannot play a flute and a and then simple but you can't play flute i hold this to make like is in here so why did the bryce only mention one out of the two say two lord this is a much bigger kiddish listen to this you could play you could be just for simha when it's not mentioned in the torah because i want to have a good time on yantev at shabazyantif i'm going to be mahal shabbas and yandere together doesn't say yeah i hold you could that's a big much bigger dish that i could play a flute when i'm bringing a carbon dioxide when the torus says shiro by the kaaba the tar never says shirobai okay so that's not a good writer but i have a different ray oh how could i say that how could i say according to your ice rabbisif in the turrets you see it says materials that is a macholic is by carbon and this is a machine by simcha but it says in our mishnah basis our mission says that this is wrong there's no check mark over here you know the carbon but it seems like from our mishna that carbon does push off according to turboising two checks everything carbon and chiva with youth this has to be going according to our bonon and therefore i do have a major cache on ruby i see that to what that carbon pushes off shabbos according to our abundant current position chavez and everybody says carbon doesn't okay says my time at the amanda americas where did he get the idea that when the turtle says the word shira song it means with the instrument hashem and when you bring the eyelash start singing so what does the word share mean look at the next word david clay clay david melo there were instruments here says the gemara so that's it so you see that cheer means instruments great my time is and why does the automaton say i was thinking to myself like would i ever buy a cd that had a guy singing without any instruments but you do buy cds that only have instruments so what's the icare here maybe acapella with with drums everything like that what yeah okay whatever i'm just saying faker not acapella just a guy's voice have you ever purchased something like that my time if it was trumpets but the gemara is proving from here that your mouth is not a cli it says la mashem room the singers la shmi it's just their voice i deposit says trumpets says rashi it doesn't mean that this is a clichira the trumpets were there for other reasons it's not for it's not part of the uh the musical instruments the trumpets they they sound noises but it's not that's not where okay harmonies and all that other thing with his with with the kingdom so the kingdom are not the icar but it says in the past that with your mouth is thicker than should be like the trumpets what's a trumpet okay it's not a a musical instrument but it's a click i've been sharing fine says the halogen mishna where is that sponsored by me famous famous mishna michele ross basis if you didn't see the simplest basis you know you don't know what you're missing you never saw a simple in your life i saw them here he says that it's a combination of simcha smith and rukhnis it's a two gosh means you're dancing and having a great time but it's with the chef of brookhaven so it's a complete simcha that's that's what it means so on the first the first day of yante what's the anti so here is the best they go into the asus nation all this is not here's where the mizbeh is the kosher kadasham on this side from here on this is notion it's called as this nashim because on yomtif the women would stand over here on the balconies um as the gemara is gonna explain let me just cheat a little bit because we might not have a lot well we're doing okay but i'll just say this rebecca pressman and hasanah the mission says they were misaki in a tikkun gado they made a tremendous tikkun inclined show and what is it that they instituted the idea of mikhita's in a show there was a lot of problems going on between the men and the women first they tried to put the men inside and the women outside we're gonna see the whole it never worked there was always kalos rush so they put the women on the balcony and the men down there and that worked that's a tikkun goddle so as for maisha feinstein why are we making ourselves crazy and we have to build platforms for the women just tell the women stay home stay home what's the you have such issues every year you try to do so he says you see from here that we want the women involved we want them to come to seoul it's good for them to come to the basement it's good for them to see what's going on and we'll do everything we can to make it happen your [Music] they sat next to their wives and everyone else was on both sides of the revolution look at these beautiful manures they're 50 am tall approximately a hundred feet tall the airbus found shazam shame and each one had four containers that it was following made out of gold candelabra var basically like the youngsters he says and they had the the vessels full shelmay of the essen log it was 30 lug per head from the pants we're not talking about like remote today like you know in the iraqi [Music] rashi goes on to explain that the front we learned in yuma the front wall of the base amigos was lower so that you could see from harassing so male the light went over the wall and they were very tall these candelabras great by the way i forgot to mention there's uh okay i don't have time now say it a different time myself with the bashamtho no we don't have time okay we'll say a different time if we remember so yeah sponsored by the mdy team group for all those who need shidduchim refusing sures please join them.com in honor of my wife for sacrificing her life in order for me to prepare the shirt yeah yeah so here here here here's the picture here's how it works here's david juggling three of these in our basement without resource here oh you want me to juggle it i don't think so but rabbi said this is this is amateur this is three and rashi says there were eight of these eight some did six and then eight oh okay this is going to be good shkoyah so again it's the gas base in the rookies you have the the juggling going on and you have the shiro it's boxing because different instruments uberclay sheer beloy missport there's no there's no max to how many instruments there were ah maloys hayardo so as we know if you look over here again you can see these this circle the semi-circle is 15 steps that represented the share of mali is the fifteenth triangle and it's when you go from the azara into the ezra sunshine so here it is they were on these steps he was digging for the sheetin to get to the to dig out the um [Music] the drainage that for the for the wine and the water and he got too deep sixteen the gemara is the murderer later on two dove sixteen thousand dollars down the water went down then you need to bring the water back up see he said sure mallets and it brought it back up fifteen thousand ammo each sure miles a thousand ammo now the water is only a thousand ammo below the surface shall i move shiva and shiro here you can see if you look closely there are two kohanim right over here this shy right over here shiny connor i don't know if you need to see it over here but this shirt shirley connor that's where they stood there shirelle you share was a man that screamed out and if you remember we had rav nobody recognized him and he was saying over and and the and i forgot who the tana was he said karya gave her so rap said it means the the the guy so he says no i think it means the the chicken so ravioli he said like you're not even who are you to even argue with me i said in front of everybody all these didn't know that was rav okay fine korea talk of aruba taco true they do this three times he give them a last series then they go down the steps here we go another picture they come down the steps they're on the tenth step taku vairu taku again now a really long one a prolonged kiss so that they could get all the way to the other side so we're talking about they exited this way this is the wall that i said before is lower so you could see in all the way to the hecho they came down the stairs going this way yeah here we go the two kaihana with the trumpets turn facing everybody else in other words facing the kardashian facing this way vaamru and they said a very sad pasuk in the navy the sun so in order it was moments of disgraceful they would they they turned their backs out of this barracuda and went towards the east where the sun wasn't bowed to the sun and turned their backs to the dasha so he said we're not like them [Music] probably the beginning i would assume it's the beginning that's when they did the whole the whole um that's when they they poured and this what right right right places that's a very very interesting question triathlete is in the morning brings a good point so that means they drew the water before by alloys by allies so then the water is possible the water is lena doesn't matter stellino that's not an eight set to watch it night night comes night goes it's it's lena that a biggie side lina only occurs when you get into the basement they didn't get to the base of english they drew the water in the shilloyach and they brought it they drew it by allies by the time they got to the base amigos it was already daytime melee there's no lina just going to bring other examples of things if you haven't seen it you haven't seen it in your life michelle ross basically shiva this amazing party of simcha la rossimo you can see a gorgeous building which base amigos there's three there's the two but they make this that we're familiar with but it's written by cheney but also the by shami went through a big renovation by jurdos are we referring to that one bio we know that the first base amigos was nice in the second so melo can't be the second one i'm about to tell you how it does in fact we're referring to the beautiful building that horde is built why is it so beautiful he used green marble umar miro and white marble so it's green and white ikeda me but avne yeah it was green a little bit of blue granite going on there umar miro and white epic sofa vile sofa similar if you look at the kaisel not every stone doesn't lie directly above each other it's a little bit indented each one is indented in words somehow that enables you maybe from the back of the stone to put the cement he didn't want to put cement between the bricks like the castle today there's no cement between it and that's why it's it's really nice he didn't want to do that with the havoc he wanted to cover the entire wall with gold plating on the rabbana on chaffeke let it go doggy shop at faye it's much nicer the way it looks like now an optical illusion when you look at it different colors you kind of get dizzy like it almost waves if you look at it it starts moving this because everyone is different color like people wear these shirts you know different boxes and you look at it and also you start getting a little you think it's moving i think that's what it means over here it looks like waves leave it don't put any gold that looks better like this tiny review michele rashid brings the word metropolitan it's it's a combination of three words view means to plue stone which is the blue stone shell exaggeration now we're talking about the beautiful show and the congregation that was in it's right if you haven't seen that you haven't seen the show you didn't see the the again the covet of clients came in the sauce like a big giant palace or whatever like again something they had in uh in rome stavrov staff two rows of benches parliament show you both sometimes keflank is right double the item is six hundred thousand one point two million men adult men in one show vahayuba shiv khatri khattud roy shazov chairs of gold kinneged and hedrick they themselves imitating had 71 sanhedrin so for each rov a beautiful golden shear how much do these shares cost think to yourself the going takes out the word reboy because it's almost impossible i'll tell you in a second why rebuy is ten thousand right so each chair had twenty one kickers of okay a kicker's of for argument's sake is about 36 kilo times 2.2 for pounds times ounces i just did a quick calculation 50 million dollars that's if it's without rebuy if you do 50 50 million times 10 000 it's going to be a number that doesn't really work says the guy okay so 50 million dollars new i could sort of understand each chair at least 50 million dollars ubimulation see also there's 1.2 million people think about it 1.2 million people so you need a stage in the center the hazard and everybody answers amen and that they bring aloha from here could you say oh man like out here nobody not you're not here you hear it on the microphone from here you see sort of that if you're well at least in the same room in the same place that if you don't hear oh you don't hear the hazen at all you just see a flag you could be mistaken and say i'm with everybody else but of course if you see this on youtube five hours later me making a brachii do not say they know which brah is they also know on you zoom what it is on youtube yashin my raven they each each category person if you're if you're a psychologist you sat with a psychologist lawyers with lawyers dentists with dentists elsa hum if any other people that dealt with the gold wikisoft free aso and and silver the silversmiths if you if you wolf clothing you said why do a mamas valley make your valuables even if it'll show you go to this section and you get a job from them um major you saw it in life catalina alexandria and mike done they take out the word martin alexander whoever he was killed them all my time answer while he killed him over there you know to go back to mitsrayim and they went back to its right vienna he heard the king hears them reading it he says ah it's a ray i'm supposed to kill you because it says that a king is going to come from the distance and kill you all um it takes usually ten days together it took me only five so you killed them all i want to say real quickly the mice was over there that guidalia was in charge of clay israel and a really bad guy killed him what was his name again um small ben whatever his name was kill them and clarissa went to the navy year meal and they said what should we do the king put gedali in charge and now he's dead they're going to think that we kill the uh what should we do he says let me think about let me get a navor he didn't get an evolver for 10 days they were they were under pressure and then all of a sudden he comes with the navora and he says the unbelievable he says if you stay in arizona you'll have everything you need cultural seller but i'm only going to tell you then avoid says if you swear to me that you're going to listen to the nivo of course we swear he says but if you go to mitzrayim you're all going to die so they said that's not a navoor it happened 10 days later they wanted him let's try it my boy said what happened they died but if you cop what's going on here when did they die 650 years later 650 years later so i think it's a major your site you have to take this in the right way don't i know i'm going to get a little bit of flag we're going to say it anyways sometimes when the torus says it's my first apostle so what do you say to yourself ah i'm here ready for 600 years my forefathers are here i have a minute to live here a minute against the torah but it says in the fortune of the terrorists you have to do a hajj an effort to yourself it's not an excuse to say but my father lived there and my grandfather lived there it's before surpassing you each person has to take their own some people say but my ralph told me this is i'm not going into that but sometimes yeah if it's against them the first apostle they got killed 650 years later i think it's unbelievable have a wonderful shabbos we'll see what's the shabbos at 9 30 aguten chavez [Music] ah [Music] you