Daf Yomi Succah Daf 38 by R’ Eli Stefansky

today's share is sponsored by the kessler family daughter and sister cancer patient now diagnosed with kovid and by shirley bernstein not pornstein bernstein libyanism [Music] i forgot how to pronounce it you told me once how to pronounce it and now i'm drawing with my boy side it's unbelievable it was very difficult i'm not going to lie it was very difficult jumping around from city to city traveling from my sister to america from america to this from this but it was worth every second was unreal the experience yesterday in los angeles getting to meet the fever there this guy i mean lazarian he took me to the khasana which was i don't know 40 minutes away and he stayed the entire house i was sitting in his car and refused to move i said i'm going to uber a big deal no son i was done in los angeles waited he got another car he borrowed a car a nicer one a bigger one big kids are unbelievable so i took the red eye for those of you who don't know when they're strong maybe they don't know what a red eye is i took the 12 o'clock flight 12 a.m and it arrives in new york at about 8 a.m the kids where you get you're supposed to get like three four hours of sleep you touch taste how it is especially when you have the back back seat so it was murdered like a flight to say the least i got murdered amount of sleep and and here we are because we're doing the daft there are no days off but i'm saying it was worth every every second to meet you in los angeles to meet up in lakewood to meet everybody everywhere zomboleo who do we meet we met the guys in the five towns the guys in borough park the chevy brock has the cat murdered okay the easier hashem if they let us back interest roll we're going to be flying back there destroyed sunday night also going to be a nice trip sheer right before catch a flight the whole thing so we have here just a couple of emails yeah i don't think i got it i didn't if i did it's it's by the front door somewhere you do you talking about the one that you that you got me [Music] so does that mean nobody heard a word on youtube or they hurt a little bit it was it was okay but it's much better now okay thanks better late than never okay but just in time for the uh emails oh i was saying on youtube raboni sai is that i had a tremendous experience meeting everybody the chevro is a tremendous physique for everybody is great rebellio just wanted to compliment you on how enjoyable is to learn to share i learned the dav as part of the 5 40 am adasi for the past four years started watching a minute bronchus i started listening to other daf shirim that are nice but nothing close the enjoyment of learning in a share with a good group of guys so he's saying it's not to share so much as much as the camaraderie great group of guys that being said you're sure something else ever since i started watching in the middle of shops i'm hooked and even now when i'm back to the regular 5 40 a.m and that's this rolls here where's this place i don't know where he didn't tell me where it is i'm supposed to know where that's his troll is okay i still watch this year sometimes before and sometimes i gave eight years of adafiomi in a dacis role but that was in chicago so he must be in a different place something refers on adapter but i watch it every day now he says i have a joke that i'm going to meet some of the magidish room that i listen to because he listens to the shuriman two times speed i met a le bavitch guy very very geshmaki guy in los angeles who watches for mcd shurim at two times speed i asked him who's the best one and he said the other guy no he said you're all good you all have different miles okay but he watches at two speed so he says that when he meets the magistram he's gonna greet them he's gonna he's gonna tell them it's so nice to meet you in one speed the best part is that even when i can't make the regular share i always have rebellion i never fall behind even on vacation i know it's real hard work to put a real share every single day it's good it's much appreciated p.s i would really appreciate if the whatsapp sheets were uploaded before 5 40 a.m new york time oh he's in new york that's wrong in new york by i can't say his name because at the end he writes anonymously written by anonymous his name is salomon b solomon will call him he's a he's a buffer i love these guys these young guys that love they learn the dav it's called daffy me changed my life for the better shalom alaikum rebbe i wanted to let you know that from the start of success amazing entertainment interesting stories i just can't get enough of it sometimes i even stop in the middle just to hear the story over again so in turn i will say a story about myself from birth through sixth grade he never had a love for learning but kitser is in seventh grade in 2019 so today what is he he's in ninth grade really kid sir he started to do the duff he's going through yomishir the kitzer then his rebbe told him about the haburashas program i believe it doesn't call khabib shots but that you has her last week's death the week the month before this before and okay he hopes he's going to finish us like that unbelievable he's doing a lot of hazaras and he started doing aerodynamic with yuma i could say the cycle changed the my way the dow for the and since i always did the death i now i know i and now i can't go a day without doing that and it's in my routine i make sure to make time for it sometimes i finish late at night and sometimes i finish really just depends rabbi so we can learn from this young kid he's a young kid no matter what he always does the daf if it's late at night early in the morning now i am happy to say that that is part of me but i don't think i could have done it without you and all your physical stories kept me going i owe you much thanks thank you rebellion the homies bacha for all that you have impacted so many of us anonymously written anonymous raboisei here we go we have a very very easy dafterday daf lamed hesse so holding the last line on lomzano bay is omer billie silver oven visaymo rabiosi parsvillo zois oymeres shiore mitzvo magusa perons we're discussing the shaking of the lulula we do it this way dude that way and one of the reasons is to get rid of the bad rujoys the bad do so you see from here that's yuri mitzvah the leftover of the minster the part of the mitzvah that's not market if you don't do not or let's call let's say tenufa of the animal it's not market if you don't lift the animal up and go back forth you can still it's still a carbon that's apostle so you see shia mitsumakis have piranhas i guess maybe what the gemara is trying to say here is a cava climber if the the side part of the mitzvah the the part of the midsole that's not super important it's not making the mitzvah if you make the broccoli lululemon you don't go in all directions you still yikes yet that part has such power to stand to have to control so to speak the winds and the hurricanes and all that that's the side part imagine if you do the real part of the midsole the part that is market how much power that has charity the lifting and the shaking of the animal is the side part of the myth and it has the power to stop the bad winds and the bad dudes the same alohas of moving the the animal back and forth in all directions and the ashkenaz front right back left go in a circle up down or if you're not satisfied i'm not even going to attempt to remember how they do it it's uh some somebody told me it's it's it is a picabola it's to the right up then to the back left down okay whatever you're all laughing because that's how you do it there's very few oscars on now most of the guys on boro park all right omarovo foreign and then you would say a very very famous line with seth [Music] this lulav should be an arrow in the eye of the saturn i actually found the picture i don't know if it's appropriate for the sheer it's not mamish the satan it's like a guy dressed up for the southern so this is whatever it's it's an arrow in the eye of the saturn says the yamaro vlad milcy it's not appropriate to talk like that you hear this if you start out with the eight zahara with the saturn he's going to be moisture nephesh he's going to be moiser atsuma whatever that means says rashi he's going to take it to the next level you don't start up with him right now he's cool what are you telling him look satan i was able to be making the mitzvah even though you didn't want you tried everything you tried to trip me up you try to give me a bad lulu if you try to give me the it's a harder that i shouldn't do it i should just drop my credit card let somebody else i did it i haven't begun i did i did it myself so he's going to step it up one more now she knows how to step it up don't start up with him just you could think it don't say it because if you if he wants just like your moisture in that fish he also knows how to be moisture at smoke left it again official mission of sponsored by official the four shleima of those two hoiland that he has in mind a person was traveling and he didn't have a lulu so when he comes home he should stop what he's doing and he should shake the lulu is going to discuss this it seems like two different things here if he wasn't able to shake the lululeve in the morning you shake it in the afternoon you could shake the little of all day as long as there's sunlight you cannot shake the lulav at night so if you haven't done it in the morning it's okay to do it in the evening says you say that when you walk into the house you grab it off the table even though you might be eating you might be doing something you have to be mafic [Music] we have by shabbos that when the time of mineral comes and you're at the barber you don't have to stop there's certain things you don't have to stop you keep on going so we're going to have a a problem between shabbos and our michelle herb shops [Music] what's the difference between a lulav and esrig and minha abaraf safaro and the gomorrah is going to keep on coming back to this rafa safra says of saffro avakasha on the one hand it says they have a little of an asteroid you come into the sudha it's the middle of the meal you should stop stop what you're doing stop eating shake the lulu on the other hand if you're eating a meal and comes you don't have to stop so if sanford says when you have to stop by lululeveness by us because there's no more time you look at the clock it's almost you gotta go so you have to do the midsole over there mr chavez is talking about this time in the day omarova maikuchu why is rav safra being mahalik the way it was this time it's not time dilma hodday right so bonna what's the cash of a club when you have a mitsubi right so a lulav it's the rice so you have to stop what you're doing yeah you have to stop the meal that's why everybody's just stopped over there they're talking about a minha milk is the rabbana so you don't have to stand for the rabbana let me explain to you my father used to do this to me all the time when i was a kid i used to ask akasha and he wanted to raise my spirits it was a klutz kasha she said oh let me explain to you what you try to ask over here you're asking based on the rambam in sphero that you know the showing already macholic so he took that rambam he asked them yeah i hear what he's saying it's a vowel to get casual anyway so rav safra says no that kash is not true but i have a different one lukashi khan is the best let's ask a question from the rice under the rice i forget about forget about that that uh there are bon minha i have another question right here and now we're in our mission of between a lullaby and a little of a question the first part of the mission says when you walk into the house you stop right away if you didn't shake the little live in the morning shake in the afternoon almo lori mafsik it seems like you take your time you didn't do in the morning chill out until the evening then you do it for like that comes out of saffro yes in our mission one day rise against another right why is it when it's the rights of lula visa you have to stop right away and then the second part of the mission is to the rights of lulav and you don't have to stop you don't have to you wait until after the answer is because the second part of the mission is talking about this plenty of time so take your time yes this is the right so but you'll do it later when there's no time left in the day you better stop whatever you're doing and do it right away maybe what it's talking about it's a good idea to stop and take the lulu villoiposic but if you don't do good things you're not into it you don't bend everybody nevertheless you have the opportunity to do in the afternoon what the mission is trying to say is listen you should shake the little of right away and as we said yesterday you should shake it but that's a hammer it's reasonable mitzvahs not saying you should get up but that's the first thing you should do in the morning instead of looking at your cell phone and then the whatsapp you run to the sukkah and you shake the it's reasonable that's that's if you didn't do the then you could go the entire day throughout the whole day you could do a little like a lot of women you see them like running around at three three in the afternoon oh i didn't check lulu okay it's still time to check lola zero oh sorry my question is [Music] so then what's the cash what's the contradiction there's no contradiction in the mission what are you asking a contradiction there's no shadow between allu level one one one one part of the mission is telling you what you should do and the other part is telling you if you didn't do it then you have all day long no so let's take it back you know what the question is like we thought all the way in the beginning that the question is between lulav and minha we asked the question why do you have to stop for a little love and you don't have to stop for men and you told me that's not a good question why would the casual the obvious answer is because milk is only the rabbana and lulu is director so where does the question even start she says look mario i'll tell you what the question is the question is between a lullaby but love is only there i bought on in this particular case that would be a great question why would the casualty raise we're talking about let's call khala maya to make it easier that midday right so you don't have to shake wull of every single day of yante said that we shake every single day just to commemorate in the base in the in the time it is amigos they only used to shake in the base i make this every day but we don't have vision leaders so we shake every day just to commemorate that so when the shaking of a little is it the rabbit on now it equals minha minha and lulav are in the same playing field and the question is why do you have to stop for a lull of which is a durabana because we're talking about halloween and not for me she says and that we say okay because this time in the day it's not time of the day i'll prove it to you we're talking about a guy that's traveling who travels on young tim you can't travel iante you can't go out of the room it's awesome so we're not talking about a guy that's over on the surim we're talking about a guy that's traveling behind there how is he traveling he's traveling because it's halamite this is mishari end of story great the official mishna sponsored by official famous idea that i could hear we do this every single shabbos one person says kiddush and everybody that listens is yoita it's as if they're saying so we're very familiar with this concept right here in shaas in order for me to be mighty you you and i have to have the same level of health in other words if a woman is not hiv in the mitzvah because it as my grammar so she can might see a man who has a key of their eyes and if a person is a cotton so he's for sure not hive at all so of course he can't be mighty anyone etc so therefore me show you ever the evidence like isha in terms of mitzvahs so let's say this child is reading the hallel for the adult so he cannot be you'd say from a cotton there's no idea of the cotton is saying i'm going to be it doesn't work like that but he just repeats the words after him you hear this red boy sign if a child or a woman reads sukim for a person and he repeats after that person after that child he is cursed so let's see rashi rashid you see by the white lines because it's his fault that he doesn't know how to read you can't blame your rebbe you can't blame your parents can't blame the system you have to blame yourself why don't you know how to read because you didn't take the time to read and therefore you are cursed says rashi the imam but if he is a learned person who knows how to read him when a person uses the wrong messenger the wrong shliyak and tells a cut and read for me and he knows how to read so he also deserves to be cursed why why are you sending such people to represent you this stem as a as a side note it's one of my pet peeves especially in america there are many many people that don't know how to read properly and when i saw this rashi i was shocked because i was okay they don't teach it it's not their it's not a first language hebrew and the guy gets up there for the ahmed and he starts something he barely breaks his teeth and then he swallows words and he pretends that he's saying the word when he's not saying the word he goes imagine if he read an article like that in english you know because the english teachers when i was a kid there's such sticklers you have to say like this and pronounce it and and this and he gets up there and he imagines the ms please if you said that in english they'll throw you out of class well hebrew it's okay why because us americans we don't know how to read so rashi says over here if you don't have to read it's your problem and i think i really think because i know i worked on my crea a lot myself just took a thing you just has your hearts are over you get better at korea even at an older age what happens is people get get in a rut they're six seven years old they don't know how to read so they keep on going they push through school with not knowing how to read and they fake it and then this and then they get them become adults then they get aaliyah then they tell them to read after and hashem iraq and he can't say a pasuk like i read after a few times come over to me what you prepared it no i don't have to prepare after you just i just read it with the time why it's second nature okay so i have a little israeliness in me and all israelis for sure they know how to read but uh i don't think it's an excuse i think all americans should practice the reading based on this rashi i was shocked when i saw this tavi la mera you get cursed it's your fault you don't know how to read nobody else's macro you say if you have an adult adult is saying it for you by the way if you're chronic like my father i'm a chronic but not as stark as my father so the gra in hollow doesn't say anyant if he does so this is not doesn't apply them but when you say a half a halo the girl holds you don't say the borrow the bracha no brock in the beginning no bracha then so every single hallow my father runs over to the khas and you see him running you'd be mighty me and then you have all these mahmir they go like this so the khazen understands right okay who he's dealing with and they're mighty that's what's going on here they say the bracha the guy says amen and that's it so so what happens is that if the the hazard is going to say the entire thing and that's how it was a lot of people don't know how to read back then and we're going to see in the gemara so how does hal start off how it starts off hallelujah that's the first first possum in if i can find it here here we go hallelujah [Applause] hallelujah hallelujah hashem that's the first thing right hallelujah so you repeat hallelujah then he says and what do you say and that's how it goes keep on saying halal the people say twice they double it over like we have in our halo serum sugar we say twice so that you go with the minute liveshift if the mirror gets to say once once the last paragraph in the hollow you say you don't say depends on the minute but the last bracha you say in other words over here we go by whatever the minute is i got an email uh today from rabbi badner i forgot which one because we have a few bad news maybe i don't remember anymore where he backs me up when i said that he's supposed to say kaddish after after uh davening and he says initial also the rob is very macbeth kaddish in fact and he brings the he says you're right says that even people that have parents should say kaddish at that point if their parents are michael them because it's not for the parents it's for the davani he says he doesn't understand why that rabbi said that it's not the minig it's not a shadow of a minute it's a shail of aloha okay listen to this a child could make a break of his father it's like how how could a child who only has the rabban on may be mighty a father that's kaiv midday raisa what's the answer the answer is he cannot he could only be mighty his father in a dirabanam because when i'm made to you i can only be mighty to you as much as i am yet i can't be mighty you more than i could do so if i'm a katherine and i could only do it there about on i'm being made to you there about what's the case that a father is yet to do for instance if he's benching only on a share of their abundant he ate and he wasn't satisfied you only binge when you're satisfied i wasn't satiated i ate a kebato but i wasn't satiated therefore the son who's he's hive to benchmade he's able to be mighty's father unbelievable you hear this a nine-year-old kid sits and says and the father sits and listens and he's yighty why because they bought their abandons a person who lets his wife bench for him it's obvious because he doesn't know how to read if he doesn't know how to read he's cursed go learn how to read there are no excuses is anybody going to take that seriously are they going to say stam i'm hacking in china okay listen i truly believe that every american is a guy that doesn't know how to read a hundred percent could improve his reading and you'll write to me in your emails i listened i haz it over i didn't repeat it and i'm much faster and better now anyway so going back now it's a shanda sometimes going back so now here's how it works hallelujah you say hallelujah hashem you say hallelujah just one word you say one word then he says the whole apostle hallelujah hashem and when he's done you say hallelujah then repeat the whole join we want to says the gemara we want to hold on to the minhagrum that we used to have we had menage when people didn't know how to read and not by the way not too long ago that that's what i heard about about shantou that the bashantha was very busy with with people that literally didn't know how to read there was a lot of illiteracy going on they didn't know how to read in those days and you would take them and dance with them and these people were talking about only 300 years ago he imagined 2000 years ago when there's no no they didn't have khadarim they didn't have these things there's a lot of yeah to come to show there's a hazard said for you ah so my father is in los angeles now so i was able to uh lower the temperature we're at 71 not bad we're getting there yesterday 80 degrees he's watched the sheer not everybody okay we could we can hear how is like to say foreign even a person who knows how to read beautifully he should repeat afterwards and say hallelujah so i see your side it's it's a mitzvah this is what we do we repeat now what about the rest of the apostles the first possible he says hallelujah and everybody just says now we're going to a case of an amma right and i'm a ritz he doesn't know how to read and an adult reads for him [Music] fine so if you're not married and you don't know how to read every posing that the guy says you say hallelujah to what you're saying i'm i'm part of it so that's we have a lock of the guy is a is a bucky he knows how to read nevertheless he should say hallelujah we have a guy that's he should say i look on every apostle and then we have what's up with that why do we keep this minute we all know how to read so let us just say how from beginning to that we have siddhurim in those days they didn't have sedum everything is about pests so they had even more trouble mikanche mitzvot lannis roche proclaim there's another thing that when you start let's say basically swallow me with trying so you answer with that rosh perrick you say bethesda's robinson that's an indian also not just every time you say the the first paragraph the taste is wrong okay there's such a concept so what [Music] okay you have a minor reading for you so you have to repeat everything you can say hallelujah from him you have to repeat the whole thing that's why khan says and we say word for word what the cousin says we don't rely on in other words we don't rely on akata so what about okay you have the right to say it twice everything why because of the concept of shimer kaina when the chasen says you heard it with your ear that's number one you heard it you said it it's as if you said it once now that you're repeating it after the chasen now you just said the puzzle two times one time you were yield to 100 percent just by listening and the second time you stamp said it you see bermuda you could say a puzzle twice it's not a brahlavatala it's not stam shaming you're allowed to say a puzzle twice [Music] now the cousin says the words you see what's going on here because there's so many different things going on here on the one hand we start off hallelujah you say exactly like him hallelujah just one word then you say a whole puzzle and then you say a different word so what's going on here so the bar is saying it's just telling us that we used to have a minute two thousand years ago we had certain monogamy and we want to remember those monogam so we do a little bit of everything at one point the cousin says one word we just repeat one word another point he says five we say five one time he says one word we say a different word why again to show the minute what's the minute she's he says i don't need anything else so what am i saying something else hashem hashem his bar is enough for me i didn't do that in the beginning of halal when he said hallelujah i didn't say hallelujah hashem i repeated what he said because over there i'm learning a different kiddush here i'm at the hideus of shimaya this is a concept of shrimaya korena it's a very very very important concept it's not getting us on every day rashi brings an unbelievable example think about this what happens sometimes i get annoyed i look in seoul i see a guy comes late to show right so he's dying when the hazard is right and the kha'zin gets up to kidusa everybody's jumping college college college and this guy is saying reforeign is he doing the right thing or not you're the question if the hazard is saying she's saying kedusha or everybody's screaming oh man you hey shimmy rabbit what are you supposed to do you're smacking militia monastery says you cannot stop and listen why because if you stop and listen it's exactly as if you said omega it's as if you said college college college but you know a lot of stuff in middle school when i say college college college you just made a break in middle school and yesterday rashi argues rashi says that since it's such an important thing it's called it's kadusa you have to be silent stop whatever you're doing you're middle of shema stop and pay attention to what they're saying and you'll be saying who's that like what should we do rashi in this case rashi yesterday was this today's rashi that's the mission brewer passes like that if you're a middle schooler in esre you're davening teises points out by the way he says obviously the best of the best is to do it with the zebra and that's why by the way a lot of one of the halakhas i don't know if everybody's familiar with this it's a famous allah if you come late to show you should probably not start schmonastery you should probably wait until the chasen starts and then you do shimonese with him to the point that when you get to kedusha you could even say the with the khazen so you don't have to miss out on do so the biggest problem that the mystery board talks about is maiden because if everybody bows down maiden and you don't bow down you're in chemaquileno somewhere or you're past maiden then it doesn't look good it looks as if you're not agreeing to to bow to hashem so that's why madam is the most important one to do with everybody to bow so you make sure that your maiden coincides with the cousins about them and you bow the hazard anyway it's it's that we we need to know in this show also another important thing i get annoyed at my family when i'm making kiddush and they're joking around they're laughing at each other smiling like hello it's shemaya if you listen then it's as if you said the bracha if you're not listening you're not paying attention and you're playing who says so that's the coming suggest what happens you heard the whole kiddush you heard everything but you didn't say amen ignoring it unbelievable it's a whole list you don't really see this often in chats i guess if you're going to take action to show that you don't want to be i'd say then you're not what if you're just standing still you didn't do anything you didn't say oh you didn't stop standing how do we even know this idea of shimaya koinong says the gemara from this apostle very much yo so it says like this they went into went into the they went in and they found a safety torah and this is they opened up the safety room and this is what it said in this avatar it was talking to the king the king was there yeah you you're gone the torah that they opened up and was read to the king was speaking to the king he got a shock of his life he couldn't believe it right that's what they do at the it's called guerilla you open up do seven times and whatever the positive says or does it at the oil whatever it says they open up the safety boom talking to the king hashem is but it says over there that the king read it but the problem is the king didn't read it like shafan shafen read it maybe you did read it who said maybe they both read it your heart softened and you'll be nich when you hear when you heard these things it says that he heard it and he didn't read it don't don't tell me maybe you read it maybe he did read it but that's not what's going on here it's from the fact that he heard it and it says that he read it mela you see me to always listen carefully and be yo carefully have a wonderful shabbos and a financial have a wonderful week thanks for joining so late in the day of shabbos your bunch hashem should bless you all you