Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
good
morning rabbi
live from miami
unreal
today's share is sponsored by joel and
umella wall is that i just pronounced
again
i wish they hadn't kudos in english and
gratitude to hashem on the birth of our
new baby
haim zanville shout out to my new
brotherhood
at eight minutes what about zoom
apologizing for the way i read his joke
i have no idea what he's talking about
susie rosenberg apology not accepted
susie rosenberg your side of her mother
nechobas rabbi from yehuda allah shalom
first cousins david steinloff
from montreal and jay spitzer i know
well
from toronto lazer nishmas their
grandfather joseph
on his 28th yard site and
the turning of adaf is by michael
how do you pronounce his name inspired
it ben
or ben whose birthday it is today
happy birthday who couldn't come because
he is
not feeling well unfortunately with the
famous whatever okay
he's a big supporter and just so
happened
yesterday i had no idea i was going to
be here it was you sure aaron price's
idea by the way when he walks in pretend
he doesn't exist
because he loves walking in smack in the
middle of it i'm serious
when he walks in nobody say a word he's
going to make a whole thing we're not
going to say anything he's going to walk
in we're not just
pretending he's not it is shtick okay
um a tremendous akara satov to yeshua
aaron price
for giving me this idea to come here i'm
so happy i did
i know it's a day before uh we're doing
a big uh
chavez offroad hotel and uh my wife
doesn't know i'm here yet
when she finds out i might be looking
for a place to stay
she's in new york and i left my kids by
themselves
but say that i'll be back at one o'clock
by one o'clock this morning
they will be in bed i promise she'll
have no clue
uh yosef biliak is here with us for
boise
he edits the videos
his sons are over there they do the daf
every day
it's incredible tremendous tremendous um
supposed to be here what do i have to
read here
which one oh
yeah by michael menmel in memory of the
of his mother devour fago bashmuel and
father-in-law
and in the merit to make it to uma rosh
hashanah this year
nice he's excited he just converted a
bunch of people to breast lift his
gavali
um as you know i have a place here in
miami i haven't been to
uh in over eight years so it's great to
to at least see that for a few minutes
um rabbi say i want to tell you like
this we'll start off
we had a hot impressment he's always
been pressing me to do human share
hummus here so in his honor and in the
honor of
miami i just want to tell you a quick
vart from the parish that has everything
to do with
miami miami
is maybe the first place that so many
people got together
about a month ago gathered was a
gathering of achtus a gathering of torah
and by the way tremendous yeshkaya to
the soccer family
for giving the place to us and they call
this the official
mvy headquarters now
i jim himself is not here but it says
brother sandy
is here we have the source of having
uh becky saka she now she's freeman
we're hosting her and her whole family
tv the friedman's from detroit so
if jim's not here at least against him
so describe to them but anyway
here in miami we created this new idea
that i don't have to be here
i don't have to be giving a share the
island could get together
and the amount of feedback that we had
from the miami guys was incredible
and i read over these emails from people
that just were inspired being here and
inspired to see people that they know
from shul
that are also doing the daft together
with them and it just
the camaraderie in the actress was
incredible and we hope that bazer hashem
this will continue on a monthly basis
and it'll continue in other cities you
know i was trying so hard to get the
guys in chicago to get together the most
i was able to get is 35 guys look at
this and one
like this i don't know we have double in
that here no it's unbelievable
the boy said by the way you could eat
there's a lot of food over there what
are you guys waiting for
catered catered they didn't go to stone
bagels but they catered it
unbelievable so i want to tell you real
quickly this week's parasha it's
unbelievable
that and i'm happy that i came here so i
have something to say at my son zofroff
and i know he's not watching so it's
okay
the pirate ship does somebody have a
hummus here
that's a hummus beautiful i don't want
to
whoa it's one of these it's a lot of
english going on there okay
listen to this this parsha has the
secret to yiddish guide in it
and it no less than three times in this
parachute
the secret it's not it's not a it's not
a secret that we don't know
we're very familiar with the secret uh
it's perique has possible
and to fear him so that's what it says
there it says the secret to yiddish kind
and that's it this is this puzzle
us as jews we have to go in whose ways
then it says again in perhaps
let's see if we can find it here we go
what is that asking from you
with all your heart and all your soul
so what does it say again has become
he's supposed to go to college and to
love him
he's not asking for a lot just to fear
him and to go in his ways
second time and the third time you
should listen to this while the
the reading the torah did somebody just
walk in no nobody
yeah yeah uh come on time next time
it says like this leave don't don't
don't uh don't threaten
come on time you're in the middle of a
share over here come say hello to the
island but next time comment time no
so why'd you come on time if you gotta
go this is a stick right by your side he
loves coming in this middle
everybody say hello to you sure bryce
what i tell you
every time hello
it's good but it's all your fault that
i'm here and finally
positive work like a bomb guys it was so
beautiful he had no idea what to do with
himself
this is the first time 20 times it comes
in the middle of the sheer and everybody
says whoa you sure this is the first
time nobody even cared
in miami that's right beautiful you guys
are unbelievable you don't have what you
just did for me such a tight you don't
even have to get new guys to this year
that was such a favor you have no idea
okay finally in mafter or
both it says like this
hashem
you have to clean anyway that's the
secret that you described what does that
mean
who gives and gives and gives to others
it's the assay of yiddishkait
that if you wanna be a good jew
you have to have a havas khinam you have
to love
other people and give to other people
and this comradery right here rabbi
says why three times allah has three
times the same exact thing basically
because once you reach a level in either
sky don't say oh i reached this level
and i'm here and i do hesed i do 10
hours a week
i said oh if you reach that level and
you want to get to the next level and
they have to do 20 hours of khasit
you have to increase that aha
which i'm looking at mark ashkenazi on
the screen talking about his kingdom and
all these people
this is avaskin right here when we get
together
not just for torah but the camaraderie
the the
khabir shaft the reyos the akhva it's
unbelievable and rabois
should continue and continue in beijing
not only in miami in
all the cities in america all these
thousands of people
i'm i'm not i walk in the street uh i
see i watch your shirt so why don't you
come live yeah
there's a concern of ahava over there
so we have to bring them back we're
gonna make them do chuva in chicago
but right this should be this is going
to be an example
for all of america we have a true all
main
tremendous amount of people here that
are gathered not just for torah but
for the camaraderie says the gemara oh
okay
we won't read any emails today we
already did that
here camaraderie i want to see one
picture of camaraderie here's aaron
hirsch
and jose mivora also from mary's destroy
getting together not even knowing each
other
like michael banchitri told me he said
he
he he feels like he knows mark ashkenazi
like
like for years they never met and
they're talking about being at each
other's home
it's that camaraderie that comes through
torah through this and
should give us that we should just
continue and continue to grow
says the helicopter the official mishnah
sponsored by official
top of the bay's brand
[Music]
now what is the gemara is going to
explain
it could be medullaris like it's a
little
weak it's a weaker kind of sukkah
that you have to have more shade than
sun
if it has more shade than sun it's
kosher
where else did we learn this allah
more say than son first mishna
over there it says that asuka is now
that i have more
sun than shade like they said it says
more shade than sun okay
that's the more i'm just i'm messing i'm
asking yeah you're right the first
mishna
the first mission says
but over there it says it differently it
says hamas says no good
or here it says is good
so if you're a gemara you're going to
say that's very different what happens
if it's exactly 50 50.
that's why i scream at him but i'm a big
shot because
i said right away it's the first mission
and then i saw the kimura says no it's
not okay
if it's very thick like at home
so don't be concerned that maybe you
might
stay in your house you know in those
days we discussed it they used to have
nice planks of wood in the ceiling that
are cautious
really but the tire says you must leave
your house and go
into asuka so even though it's a kosher
appeal but it's us or to stay in your
house you have to leave
so they said you can't there's a concept
called xerath thicker
so maybe this this you put it on so
heavy
you might mistake it for your house next
year
no you let it stay there you can't see
the stars
shayra you know we all know oh it's so
heavy you have to see the stars
uh i'm thinking out loud here maybe the
shot is
stars what stars stars and i i kid you
not i heard this in faraway i heard a
older guy like a guy in his 80s probably
telling his friend he says i just saw
this whole program about the stars like
he's
like like a person who's never heard
this before how incredible the universe
is
you know how it's infinite it just goes
and
you can't you can't even fathom it it
just doesn't make sense when you start
thinking about how many
billions of stars and each star is
millions and millions of
light years away from here like that you
have to see the stars you have to
realize that there's a bunch of
the world stamina okay
says gamora miami duvallas what's this
word medullas
in hebrew medulla is we know what that
means but
with the vase is a little complicated
so raf says it means
it comes from the lotion dalil
it's it's a little weak it's uh
it's a poor man sokka it doesn't have
enough money for
it looks something like this okay
shmuel comes up with a much more
sophisticated aloha he says
it's like this one piece of haka is on
top and one is on the bottom
just he did two layers of how far away
are they from each other we'll see
khan is just a it's a much better
picture shmuel i'm saying
just it's a cool it's a cool concept
so he put the pieces over the gap
so what's the difference it should be
good no
rav based on
how you read the word
that it's it's a it's a poor man sukkah
or
me bubble that it's it's staggered
then it makes a difference in the
mission how you read the missions
the whole the whole it's just one line
there's a sukkot that's medulla it's
missing
and if it has more shade than
sun then it's kosher ushmoton
says it's two alajas
it's a lotion of bilbo staggered
veterinarian
that what if it's a sucker that's bobo
it's staggered it's kosher a second i
agree to rap that if it's silas
kosher okay
omar abaya
we're talking about a staggered i don't
know if you guys could see this these
pictures they're amazing pictures
the difference between the two sides of
the two the two
steps
if he staggered it in a way that there's
less than three for him and if it is
less than three falcon we always say
what
lovehood
[Applause]
and it says rava okay even if i agree
with you that it can't be three two
but that's only if it doesn't have a
width of a tether
available
look at this picture same idea but the
pieces of
are much wider so if you have a wide
piece of
now it's a if it's a tether
when it comes to tomah and everything
else
is io so what if it's oil
so it's a makham khashov it's something
khashov and therefore
i'm making a fist i just real i didn't
see this but joseph was telling me
if you watch it this year online so when
we're talking yesterday about the fist
of benavita
he put the fist right through the screen
and he broke the screen kind of thing
the cool
stuff okay anyway yes regardless send it
to me
so now we're learning a new word but we
learned the concept already the concept
is the old concept this is the concept
of good ah
you bring a majita downwards this is
slightly different and that is that
you bring the whole schacht down until
now we're talking about good asexual
that if you have a a small strip of
something i could bring the whole wall
down and pretend that that strip
goes downwards or let's say
i don't know i can use a hummus use this
let's say this is the face this is what
we have
so the whole thing goes down the face
goes downwards
great but now we're talking about now
we're taking the whole piece of
and we're putting it down we're bringing
it down that's khawaidrami it's the same
it's the same allah because mushroom
this one concept that you can go
downwards you can bring things down
but now that we're talking about we're
not talking about wall we're not
creating a wall and and pretending
that the face of the wall goes down
we're taking the whole piece of
and bringing it down we're fitting in
the slats over here
you know what i already made this before
we'll use it
here the two slats they're just going to
go like this the
the two levels the upper level is
chavoid rami just
goes down and fits into the gap and
we're good to go
says the gemara
omarova no i mean allah
goes like this my boy is a very very
simple suggyo
these are the
the beams what are they called the
joists
i used i used to build right i forgot
what's the
they this is how we built today as well
you have these joys today
they're thick they're the two by eight
so two by twelves
and you run them in one direction and on
top of that
you put today we put plywood but what
they would do
back then is they would put smaller
slats you know like the oak that we have
the two and a quarter three and a
quarter
on top of this you know like running
this one and on top of that
they would put what we learned in the
mission of mazeva it's a layer of
cement or whatever it is and that would
it would make it watertight
they had flat roof says rashi it wasn't
on a on a pitch
so they had to be really watertight
so let's there's hardly any hidducham
here that we didn't learn before
it's very very simple so
if this is my beam right over here this
guy
and i have tuma underneath my beam
and this is a tephach so the tumor hits
the beam
and doesn't go past the beam so if i
have something on top of the beam
it's tar yeah
not only that if i have tumor over here
and i have a cli on the other side of
the beam the tumor travels through
underneath the entire beam what about
this beam over here
it doesn't travel over here why because
i have a gap forget about this thing i
just did it so i could hold it
but i have a gap so tomo doesn't jump
from here
to here i have this gap
so certainly what's on top of this beam
doesn't come to me whatever's underneath
this beam is not tummy
my toma is underneath the beam it just
makes this
whatever's underneath the beam tummy
that's it whatever's on top of him
start what we're trying to get to is a
very interesting allah
and that is that if i have
two stories of beams and they overlap
each other like this
they can fit into the gap let's see it's
the wrong way no it's not bad
okay if it could fit like this
the two stories the second floor and the
third floor
if they fit into each other and they're
one half wide
and the gap is one thing wide then guess
what happens
the toma
the tomah that was underneath one beam
over here
spreads everywhere it's as if
the entire ceiling is closed because we
do have a drumming
we bring down the s the second floor
into the first floor
it fills the gap halographically and
therefore no matter where the toma is
it's going to spread that's the bottom
line of the sogya
and it's only if the slats the beans are
wide
and the gap is at that wide and they fit
in perfectly in there
as so and veiter gigan so let's see
inside
you have these joys of the first floor
and aliyah is the second floor
they don't even have the cement final
layer meaning they also don't have the
layer before that which are the small
slats
means that they are
this is sideways but they are opposite
each other
they can fill in the gaps
then anything underneath that one beam
is completely torment because the
torment travels
underneath that one beam but the tumor
cannot jump over to the second beam
because this is a gap there's an ear gap
in between
[Music]
if there's tomah between
the the lower one in the upper one
everything is
tummy so if it's on the first floor
then it's tummy until the second floor
agave but any if the toma is situated on
top of a beam
where does the atomic go upwards to the
sky
until it gets stuck until there's a
ceiling somewhere which there isn't
so it goes all the way up to the sky so
if somebody is
that's it today very careful about that
what route the plane takes a whole
mysore spectacular atom i'm not very
familiar but
if it goes over basic forest and the
tuma
in the base cars is turmeric meaning you
put the body
and then there's dirt right above the
body and there's you don't have a tether
gap
so what's going to happen is the tone is
going to burst out of the grave and hit
the plane
and that's their concern the kohanim
that literally don't
travel on certain airlines because they
take certain routes and
blah blah blah speak to them and then
there's this picture going around if you
if you've ever seen a guy in a plastic
bag you saw that picture
he asked for brazilian what to do he
said put stewardess comes
sees a guy in a plastic bag of course
he's wearing his hat and everything
you know
he got the special bag that fits over
the hat and everything
he's in there with the oxygen thing i
don't know how he did it
kisser that's what he decided to do i'm
not advocating that i'm just saying that
if you're a cayenne you got to be
careful about this tomorrow suza that
pops goes
all the way adler kia tommy hi
noise i kid you not like somebody like
rip schoenberg who's
a coin from london but he knows his
stuff he goes on
he knows it from his app he knows
exactly what route is taking and if he
takes that route
it goes eastward so it's not going to go
over tel aviv uh cemetery but if
sometimes they they make you take off
west and then
then they make you turn around and it's
a big problem fine
if the upper ones and the lower ones
were the same size
and there's two underneath one of the
beams here's the big
kulantame everything is tummy agave
and if the tomb is on top of the beam
connect the other key
of course anything above the tomah
exactly above
is taught me not everything on the
ceiling only directly above the atom
how we learned
so this is what we're trying to get to
this nakuda right over here that it must
be a teva rav is trying to prove
that could be lower down but if it
wasn't
it doesn't go come down where does he
see it he sees it from tuma and we want
to say that whatever
applies in tumor for anaya and tuma will
if it doesn't have a tefl then whatever
is underneath that beam and
only underneath that beam is
and everything to the side of it is
completely tired because there's no
connection between the beams now almost
says robo
right this is such a complicated sugyo
look at these pictures by the way
i'll show you all the pictures i don't
know if it'll help you or not
here are the beams here's
tuma in the bag remember the guy's
chopped up in a bag
dumped down by the by the mafia and
here's the tomah so if it hits a beam
whatever's on top of the beam is tar
because the beam creates a kazito
if there's a clue right next to it not
by not only the beam but
by the ear gap it's star
but if there's a click see the cleaves
within the data
lines in other words the cli is
underneath the beam somewhere underneath
the beam
then that clay is tummy
this is just the rest of the sorgy if
you have a cleat on top of the top floor
tar if it's a top if it's a tava now
let's see how we did this uh
this guy
huh let me see if we can find something
good here
okay so you did it like this here you
see all the beams fit into this
to the gaps of air and therefore the
entire
orange area is atomic if there's tuma
anywhere in the orange
right over here then the entire anything
any cli over here over here over here it
will become tell me why
because we take all these slats we put
them into the gap
halogenically it becomes one roof and
therefore
anytime you have tuma under one roof
everything in that room becomes
tommy
by the way i'm talking about ravi
schoenberg i saw this before he sent it
out but it's just a very interesting
shiloh
if you go to a museum and have a mummy
in a glass case and he brought examples
in london they have the museum of
science or whatever so the glass might
not be
is it's not heightened for tomah and
therefore if you go in there the entire
room is tame does a guy admit to
like a jew a certain summer shot him yes
it's supposed to be there forever it's
never meant to come out so therefore
the doorways don't act as kids it's a
whole torah if you want to look at it
he wrote a whole shekel tara about it in
our hammer kha's
newsletter that's coming out this friday
um or you could look in the back of the
mesifta also discusses a lot of
not as much as he does and he has a lot
of pictures and he has real mummies and
he shows the
dead people that are mummified they look
like i don't know he
brought some i guess it's a famous guy
in england mars sitting on his chair
chilling out they they just embalmed
them whatever okay
or different bones they found from
thousands of years ago create tumor to
the whole museum
or even if there's an overhang on the
museum
on the outside if you walk on the
sidewalk you could also become tummy
says the gemara
look at this oil on my boy's low battery
mode we have to hurry up
tell me when it goes on again a
technical difficulty now now we could
appreciate
what gary does every day he takes care
of all the stuff the whole setup that's
why it took seven minutes to set up he
does that
you'll save the guys okay
where's he sure he didn't come back he
really didn't come back
he came just for the occasion also his
flip-flops and his
what do you got we need does anybody
have an
iphone yeah
i'm good yeah it's a garbage it's my old
phone
that it goes from 20 to zero in five
minutes okay so we'll just hurry up this
year
position it better here like that
better okay
anyway which is good access is only if
you have it
all this for
is that a fact that if you don't have a
tava you don't bring it down how long
ago
we learned
wow i have all these printed here i have
no idea what they are but i'm showing
them to you
there's more we printed it we spent the
time
here you go you see there the turret is
not on top great
next and i schlepped it for marriage to
trump
whatever i came up with this this took
two seconds
thank you yosef and michael for going to
the store and getting this with the
razor blade again we're going back to
cairo we started the museeta with this
we're going back to that base
kairi you have a mavi which is you have
all these
courtyards everybody lived in a bungalow
colony over there and they all dumped
into this mauve
alleyway were concerned that you're
going to carry from the mother into the
surroundings so they made you make a
hacker a beam
or a lucky and we had exactly this case
what if the beam doesn't reach the end
so we use lava yeah it's because of
the guys because it doesn't reach the
other wall
or this case right over here
two beams they don't meet in the middle
so
is of the opinion in the entire i don't
know what you see
this was a waste of print instead of
three thousand it says fourth
how do you know it's the same to me
but in the picture it says four talking
with
and therefore it could be it could have
a gap of fourth we just turned
to khabeh's omen bay sponsored by the
ndy to hillary group for all those who
need
please join tillem.8.com
you also have you'll stand by the door
you'll get them there
but he lives there half the year no
[Laughter]
get over you stroll get over here
the whole the whole the whole chair
should get over here that's what we
should do
we're going to take rabbi say don't
leave seriously before you leave let's
take a group picture this is going to be
i'm going to send it to new york we're
going to show those i mean to chicago
let's send those
shows in the chicagoans what it means to
get together for tyra
oh you're all invited in new york
there's a massive chevy broncos
uh next thursday so this coming sunday
is my son's wedding visa hashem
in chicago and on thursday mark and the
clever are making a massive share of
broca's we want to beat we want to at
least get 300 people there
beautiful stuff okay so if you're there
if you you're going to be in new york
hop on over hey lovely carriage
oh i'm talking to the new yorkers i
forgot if you live in new york now
sign up and be there
okay here we go this is what we're
looking for
if you have two beams coming across
and each beam is a half a beam
in other words the kaira usually has to
be atefact
but you don't have a tether you have two
beams that are a habitable
what do you do like
a react is a brick is it have a brick
a brick is three by three so a half a
rig is
one half by three so
if you could if you could hold up a
brick
wow i just remembered a mysore seriously
i i was taking a life guarding course
as a teenager in one of the camps in the
middle of the winter
torture torture the water was
what i didn't do to get that
lifeguarding job as a lifeguard in camp
myras
and there was
an african-american there one is
african-americans all
muscle for him to float
you you can't even imagine the entire
time he couldn't he could he just sunk
to the bottom
sunk to the bottom the final thing that
they gave us was i don't know if they do
this today
gave us a brick there's a brick and you
have to hold a brick above the water and
tread water for a minute
the guy cannot do it and he spent the
entire week in 40 degree water whatever
it was
we were we were dying there the whole
week it was like
towards a couple months before the
summer was it wasn't like snowing but
it's freezing the water was
every time he was shivering and blankets
the whole thing and he went through the
whole course and the guy wouldn't pass
him
because he could not hold a brick
above the water for a minute why because
he's all muscle
he just kept on going down and he
okay anyway but this is not water and
this is not a
although we got two colors over here we
we're covering all races if you look
over here
we have a brick and if the brick if the
wood
could carry this brick could tread water
with this then it's a good
koira it has to be strong enough to
carry it
now together we only have a tefl the
brick is the third and a half
fine we can deal with the other habitat
if it could carry it i'm showing you the
wrong picture
ignore that i just showed you this i
just showed it to show you that there's
two colors here but if you look closely
over there you still have the same two
colors
it's just to show you that there's two
pieces of wood they did a great job
because they literally have to
touch each other the random say
so how would they make a picture of two
pieces of wood touching each other and
show that's two pieces okay so they want
to emphasize it
if they are strong enough to hold the
brick so it's as if it's a full tough
act what's the difference after that
is considered in love
and if you can't hold the brick
chocolate vicaria
that's a beautiful picture somewhere
this one they don't have to be touching
each other
if you could put a brick that's three
two him
long from one side from one
kaira to the other then it's a good
kaira that's considered a cairo
great
great case one is up and the other one
is
down they're on different levels
so that's basically allah that we're
discussing now
good
you could bring down the the upper one
to the lower one
we also say good asic but i i didn't see
it here
you don't say hawaii
foreign make sure that we already said
and that was in
daf bay zamadalav the cairo cannot be
above 20 amis
so if one of them is above 20 ammo like
the white guy
no good you cannot do downwards because
it's already too
it's too late it's in the wrong spot
okay another picture why not i by the
way i forgot to tell you
28 pictures today 28. it's this thick i
had a sled from chicago
and this is a below 10 fahren this guy's
below 10 fahren
you cannot make him go upwards and come
to the malcolm hexer
but if both of them are within 20 amis
in the in the proper
above 10 and below 20 i'm reno drumming
you do say rabbi drami avagov
a boy these beans that are going across
how big are they
less than atef why if they were a tafak
then we wouldn't have the whole sugya
you could close the gemara
a cairo that's a typha is perfect so
we're talking about a deficient cairo
one that's less than a teva one that's i
have a deficit let's say
and with the other one it's a full teva
and i'm telling you
how i draw me i could take a upper one
and a low and bring them together
new you see that you don't need a full
tether in order to go downwards rather
says you need a tepha
and over here we say you don't need it
you have to answer and say it like this
very interesting
um
you have to say that we're like this
we are three talking away from this guy
three two away that way
to the side and to the down
and it's all within three two him and
like this i could
so here's a big kiddush i could go
sideways and downwards
sideways i do love it downwards i do
have it
and that's what i'm doing over here
since i don't have a full tether i
cannot say hawaii drama that's what the
gemara is trying to say here
okay next suggest
we're only going to go to the mission i
think what time is it it's five to eight
we're almost good
yeah but i'm not going to go i'm not
going to pick myself up and walk out the
door and leave everybody sitting here
we got to take a picture we got to say
hello to everybody what
it is are you joking it's i'm happy
about it what time is my flight delay
though
anybody know a good divorce lawyer
i told her one o'clock now it's two
three o'clock kid's gonna be running
around
by the way brand new house first time we
slept it was last night
kid's by himself i'll be back in two
don't worry
y'all i'll be back at two okay this is
we don't do for torah so worth it no
so now that kumar has to have his
question the gemara does this all the
time we had it just a few days ago the
classic
question you could infer from the words
of the mishnah hokkieya
it says if you have more shade than sun
it's a good sukkah mashma that if it's
50 50
no good you have to have more good than
bad the mishna says
it says in the other paragraph we're in
the second paragraph the other perk
means the first paragraph meaning
the first first mishna of messiah
which it says if there's more
sun than shade it's possible
but if it's 50 50 it's kosher what do we
do with this contradiction
likashi this contradiction right besides
not just
i'm nitpicking i'm always imagining
fifty percent is good although there's
management
is not good i'm trying to explain to you
why the mission repeated itself what
good is it
we already learned everybody that
learned the first mishna many many
children
that are six seven years old know the
first mission of the sukkah it's a
famous mission it had they're in the
all the those uh colored uh mishnais
that they have today everybody knows
there's a lot so there's a sugar that's
on the tenth falcon it's
so then why did the mission have to
repeat itself the mission never repeats
itself
so in order to it's another way of
saying why did you repeat yourself
and then kumar is going to say lori
kashi
very very important you saw it
if you have 50 percent on the top
meaning where this
is guess what's going to happen on the
bottom the sun ray spread
so if it's exactly 50 percent on top
you're gonna have 51 percent on the
bottom
and therefore it's no good kamela mata
but if i'm checking
the bottom where is it
here okay very similar
i hired gersh and ben moshe's son he's
14 years old
to print these for me so it's hard for
him to differentiate i told him you know
you don't have to do every single one
some of them are reciting he did a great
great job he saved me
at least 11 hours i think 11 hours of
printing that's how long it took him it
would take me longer
anyway so over here if you look on the
bottom
it's 50 50 so you know that on top it's
solid
and those are the two mesh nice omar
have papa
haina damarinchi and this is what people
say jesus
christ is one fourth of the israel
in fact it's actually one-fourth the
size so if you have people say there's a
saying
if on top there's a hole yeah sometimes
you have like a crack
you're in a pitch dark room and there's
a crack and that's what wakes you up you
know it's not
you're not getting the sun the size of
the crack it comes through the crack and
it
it goes like that you know it hits you
it's four times the size as people say
and i didn't have time to to develop
this but you could develop it on your
own
i'm just going to put out the word and
you're going to think about it on
yourself by yourself
when it comes to rochester you do a
mitzvah one mitzvah here
the ramifications the way it spreads out
people
uh you learn at that affair you learn to
daf your children see it your friends
see
it there's other people that are doing
it you do one thing over here
you don't know what kind of sakai you
have it multiplies not four times a
thousand times over
says the gemara mova coming back
if you have enough it looks like a house
that's
laid on heavy i'll be saying
even though you don't see the stars it's
kosher
and quite
if you can't even see the rays of the
sun
then this is not a good sukkah corn to
be so say nevertheless it's still kosher
robot is such a pleasure being here
thanks for hosting
beijing we can do this more often based
on your commentary map
it's shamash and visit in person
thank you have a wonderful wonderful day
mark look what's going on over here i'll
put it on youtube
it's unbelievable
yeah yeah if we all can get together
before the shy people run away i know
those people
the guys that in the picture they
pretended in the picture but they hide
behind the guy right
let's come let's get together let's show
we got to do this for chicago
just for chicago let's get together
you