Daf Yomi Succah Daf 18 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabboissai oh you guys don't know about that chicago lily nicholas and of course i have to see if there's any new let's see if there's uh i should have checked this before but chicago says everything is safe here we go oh today's chair is being sponsored by barchaine cassell my mother lucille bass garrison on her second yard side yogi and freda loshinsky on the brisk this morning of their grandson born to yaakov the toyo the hopeless i just met yogi for the first time by the kaiser amazing guy but kamianski successful surgery tomorrow from eliza a lazar ben elka on a complete and speedy recovery reforeschleimo all right so this email directly i'm going 100 anonymous which will become clear shortly he had to go through the whole shtick of creating a new email further i was introduced to you sure last year before myself serving from a friend of mine due to covet and the lockdown struggling work family and all of life's other obligation i wasn't able to stick with the daf do me a favor get me some water i'll repeat the starter room saw him scrolling with you got through a number of death at the start of each resetta but just fell off and couldn't make it stick bar hashem was able to successfully finish meseka's humor with you and the hebra at the start of every sector in your spiel you talk about how that will improve your life your family your panasonic etc an oval or overall training on you how to stay consistent with something which will impact all areas of your life when i heard you mention that at the beginning of sukkah i realized that since april when we started yuma the take-home income in my business which i remained flat for the past two years had more than tripled more business income and profit the reason was simply due to more opportunities that appeared to me as we continue going through the messerta you know what that means if he tripled his income he must must give all the meister tim diy there's no shot look he's saying it's because of mdy it's not shyla well if not mdy he has to go and give it towards spreading torah no mikvis no souls for this that this is money that came from tyra for spreading torah hashem i'm hooked on the dive and will hopefully be able to continue with the income trajectory as we move through shots it's totally true what you say that's not about the doubt it's about the army staying consistent getting through the 60-day mark to make this a habit which also has been scientifically proven with books like atomic habits and the power of habit also this means another beneficiary to daf is uncle sam and the irs through the higher taxes i'll pay now perhaps sometimes and me we are going to get some of this some money to hook some more people to tiger perhaps sometime you can do a master class on how to reduce taxes through real estate i'm hooked for life brave not my real name sam brave sam brave diravelli since covert hit we haven't sent our kids back to school thank you very much it just seemed like an oxymoronic thing to do in the beginning when everyone was still getting sick and then we were introduced to a new mentor in our lives who's been guiding us on a whole new way to live it's been a quite a journey special seeing my son self-motivated learning of things he wants to learn feeling loved and supported by us building a deep bond with his father and learning this is a mother writing and so much more however one thing that i've been diving about was for hashem to send our son a kiva solomon some way to feel more more connected to the community in hebrew now that he's not in school and so one day i was in the park and i met shashana bilyak that's jose billy ex-wife whose son was there and it came up that he goes to the to the sheer and how he's motivated and excited by it so knowing that nothing's stopped i mentioned to my son i decided to give it a try i want to thank you so much for value for being the answer to my filos and really feeling that missing peace for my son imamish looks forward to waking up and to run out of the house and connect and learn i'm so grateful to you that you have created for what you have created hashem bless you this one more here actually let me show you a picture of a tsadek that i saw in new york he says his name is dovie newman i just i was just at the woodmere shear this afternoon and really wanted to say hello but i did not have the time to wait in the long line last time i was on such a lie and was to wait for mickey mouse it was a long line i had actually i autographed a few gemaras it was very interesting i just want to introduce myself dobby newman as i'm new to this year and thank you for what you do the sheer camaraderie the energy at mdy is truly unique here here's dolby your voice i i i remember seeing him in the audience over there also keep talking about how great eric's troll is maybe my wife will agree to make the move one day to make my dream come true hope to see you soon in new york again dovie dovey and finally we have time for one more it's listen it's sunday it's a very short dive today de ravi stefanski must have your son's wedding i don't know how to pronounce this guy's name julian partousch something like that i don't know welcome back to chicago started in the viewing of the beginning of the current cycle first time for me is never went to yeshiva but always had an admiration for tire and those who learn it i discovered a share a month ago and keep telling people around me about it the amount of preparation all these details are amazing thank you for everything you're doing i live in chicago i was wondering we'll be doing the daf yeah me share open the public is he here today julian here today hello somebody tell them about where we are from tomorrow on we're going to be at hydro everybody knows what hot rove is upstairs there's wi-fi there right good and there's going to be food over here is a little schweck but in khadrav they hook us up with food nothing again now he says just finished listening to daf youth gimmel and you mentioned that you'll be giving share from new york not chicago my mistake all right somebody let this guy know that we are in chicago now i met i can't tell you how many people i met uh over shabbos by the way i met uh you know estherson so his brother is the magician from boca by the way i have to say freud from boca talking about boca but there's so many guys on these undercover guys that are watching this year here in chicago i met at least 50 people that watched this year in chicago we have to get them together we have to make some khabur we have to get get-togethers maybe go to the milky restaurant something you schmack here we're going to go from the worst city in america to the number one that's the goal right now seder that is the goal i'm not going to let this stepbrother doesn't come here he watches the show every single day ahri who else i saw in chavez yeah listen you know what he said he's right in a way that's what my partner who also watches this show every day but benson won't come he said why would i come you're so slow in real life i'm used to it i want to have speed this guy's at the add fine we're holding david zion on the base by toshima i guess they heard the word for they weren't sure is the fourth before amis that's a joke but there's a big difference between fourth fachem and four amis that's the macholicas tashma sikh we know it's good that most of the daft today is all things that we learned already we're familiar with in this massachusetts arms we learned this also cedar beams that are our fourth wide record well this goes according to shmuel remember shmuel says according to everybody if it's over for it's apostle but if they're less than fourth falcon remember poison who might be may here top of your chest understands this as a very simple case we had this you all familiar with the gemara's answer but just let's pretend we never learned this before if between each beam you have the width of emptiness of the size of the beam so what do you do you put the only way i could pass a beam is if it's four almost wide eight feet huge shimaki i understand why this is a good sukkot makes sense but according to the mandarama that says that if this fourth with even the middle of the sukkah it goes right through your sukkah it splits your sukkah in half and now your circle only has two walls this wall and this wall or this wall this one goes right down the middle cut your stuck in half i'm mike sherra so what good is it if you add a bunch of goods so the answer is you probably recall this beautiful case where the sukkah from side to side is eight amas 48 to get to the center takes you 24th very good what happens is that the center if you look closely are two pieces of scrap you're going to start from the side put a board then put a board board and then you start from the other side boards four times six is twenty-fourths fahrenheit four times six on this side's two right six times fourth falcon fourth balcony vanessa fourth welcome you do that six times that's 24 24 plus 24 is 48 that's the size of the sukkah here but what happens is since you meet in the middle in the center the middle is going to get two pieces of sag which is eight eight is more than enough for a kosher sukkah because a kosher circle only needs seven two seven twelve by seven what about the rest since it's less than four hours it becomes kosher out as a different akuma we're dealing with a sukkah that's exactly eight hours we have nester so the kumar is very exact the way it says it there's a plank of wood upsal remember cellulosic sal means kosher we had this we already know this case and then you're left with two pieces of smack in the middle that's two times four falcons eight that's why it says that it's kosher question can you sit underneath these pieces of right over here these the the scrap the small ones you say no so today because we have a very short daf i like to do as many rashes as possible inside including this one because of that var that i told gary that that that much of chavez that he came to learn and there was where was it there was no video up because he came on sorry on shabbos when we had a shirt there's no videos i told them hashem considers all the days the hundreds of days that he came and he wasn't learning because he's busy with the video it's as if he's learning why because the one opportunity that that he had to learn torah without a video he came to learn and he actually learned today that we have a short daf the one opportunity that we have to learn rashi we're going to learn rashi and because we're going to be making all the days that we didn't learn rashi as if we learned rashi because we just don't have the time on a regular date so here we go it's rashid mask that's four lines down but we're not going to go from the beginning so rashi says smack in the middle of the rashi it's a long one hiluka he goes into the whole thing very simple then he says you should not sleep underneath the planks of water so if you want to be medic a simple duke it's only under the place you shouldn't sleep but under the sach rashi is saying that you could sleep there are those re-shining will argue arashi and say that even under the other all the way through this entire thing is deven akuma so this is interesting according to this you're light asleep under the daiva nakuma the kosher dive in akuma the wall that's made out of your let us sleep on the desk is rashi from the center to the wall is less than four hours because we're talking about a sukkah that's only eight hours total when timer says you're actually even sorry from solomon you're holding with me it's like i don't know 15 lines from the top of rashid it shouldn't be kosher in the middle this is in the luck after sukkah so ask rashford question you're telling me that it's because everything is four four four in the middle you have eight but what if everything's three three three so the middle is going to be six so come out to the middle is not a kosher sukkah so what the whole silk is possible what do you guys think the whole thing is possible says rash you know the opposite the whole success every piece even the boards will be clustered in this case you see the reason i'm reading this rash is because it's beautiful to the shot things that are not in the gemara right here it says sharing the entire culture even under the planks of wood if they are less than four fahren then they are they're they don't possibly sukkah and you're allowed to sit underneath themselves you don't have a single individual place that sports for him and then mela i can use the entire sukko beautiful okay next omar bye new allah so we are going to learn two al-aqsas now two two types of we're gonna start out with a regular sukkah you have a regular sukkah that you have three of ear and we said ears the worst of the worst she comes about with a trick you have ear that's three twakum i have a way to do to make you sucker kosher reduce the air put one bamboo right down the middle of all that ear and you're good to go even better says whether you put a piece of bamboo that's kosher baby spuden where they put a metal tube for in chicago you know everything here is all electric and everything has to be in conduit because of the unions the rest of the world everywhere else in the world almost you could throw wires right down your in your house it'll cost a quarter of the price you just put the wires right through the wall everything's good but in chicago first you have to put a metal tube and you put the wire through the metal tube okay i just thought i would point it out because i used to bend those tubes and that's how i made a living for two years okay so if you put a metal tube down the three of ear have a meal that's in a big circle and a regular sukkah however so here's a picture a nice high soaker that has a bunch of ear on the top right over here and you put a beam down the middle or a pipe down in the middle of it everything is cautious however says abayo [Music] if you use wood to reduce the gap it's good why says rashi because now i can invoke the concept of lovehood i have less than three trim of empty space bishop who didn't have a mute but if i put metal pipe down the middle like in this picture it's not a reduction and it passes the sukkot so let's look at rashi inside beautiful rashi right in the middle of the page i'll give you 10 seconds yeah bishop says why is the silk apostle i don't have three twakum of ear and i don't have fourth of metal so what exactly is passing the sokka mio kevin they give the problem is that i have three talking that are not kosher not that i have three talking of absolute i have only four twelfths and three that are not cultured so these streets fake him are considered on their own and the three two cannot go together with the fourth to give me a seventh the problem is that i don't have enough kosher stock that's the problem the problem is not that i have three take bad or fourth the problem is i don't have seventh welcome of gutshot that's the problem says the murderer of my time in the mandala are in love with benson why in the world it's beautiful we're going through nice sookies now what is the reasoning behind them that says that in middle oh sorry did i skip yeah um yes i skipped a lot better that's sad that's why i skipped in there just roll by the way because when i was giving this year for eight years in chicago so a lot of times i used to skip on purpose and nobody said anything and i finished the share stewie davis is going like this i remember those days he didn't say anything because he also wanted to get out of there quickly so i'll skip five six lines at a time and see if anybody's listening and nobody's listening right there i tried out ninja stroll and immediately they jump on me like hawks i did it now by mistake nobody said anything chicago they're very polite they don't like to they don't he did say it he said it quietly how does it help me it doesn't help me fine he made him under his breath here says an amazing all this thing that we just said look at these pictures and this picture doesn't matter whatever picture you look at you see how they drew it they drew the air all the way on the side of the sukkah not smack the middle and all the way to the side because that's the allah right now i can reduce a gap that's three tava with a piece of metal or wood but if it's smack in the middle the sukkot now i have a machine [Music] one says that i could say the concept of lovehood in the middle of the sukkah why not love it means i bridge a gap the street love adventure no you can't bridge a gap in the middle what is going on here so i saw some roshani explain lovehood is what else was said with loved good aches those are all in a wall so perhaps it's my normal saying love it is also on the wall i could do the pizza shop sukko because love it on a wall but love it was never said on the ceiling according to this mandomer very interesting i can say love it on chavez the the bringing together but only here's a fascinating thing listen to this let's say you are on the side of your sukkah and you have more than three space you know what let's go viktor to see this it's beautiful but we need a little bit more information for it so now that emojis goes and says why do where do you see that you say love it in the middle and where do you see you don't say love it in the middle so if you are with us by irivin first of all this is what it looks like when this ear space a gap smack in the middle great picture hook is silkes here even if you have a mavoi very simple i'm always in those days people had front yards in front of their houses and they dumped off into an alley i always always tell them about chicago in the alleys because in new york they have no idea what you're talking about an alley but here in chicago they have this road service road behind your house it's called an alley something like that it's not part of the register robin it's more for people to get together here looks something like this so here you have here's your house here's the house here's the clutzer in front the bikes and everything in here and it goes into this corridor called the mother there i see a lot of carry here why because it has three walls rabonan said that it's right into the survival you see the walkway here versus so so that somebody shouldn't come and walk or carry from here to here so first of all you do whatever but we're not talking about that we're talking about the lucky and the cairo kaira is a beam that goes from side to side remember that whole mishna we started off from a sector with this you have to reduce they can't it can't be above 20 am fine we're not talking about is just a piece of wood that goes this way it's a very thin piece of wood we're talking about a kyra what if the kaira doesn't reach the wall okay so if it's in within three it's faker and we say love it but here's the allah that's important to us what if the two chiros they almost reach each other in the center do we say love it or not now here's that look of love it in the middle it's not by the wall it's smack in the middle so if you say love it in this case then this might know a hole they could say love hood you could say love it in the middle. the first case is the kaira doesn't hit the wall and this is our case because two [Music] i could bridge the gap with lavod and three two more than three talking i need another kaira so over here you see that you say lava in the middle isn't that a great riot shining kairos the rabbon on since this whole idea is durable let's see rashi beautiful shani kaira the collision of moby ville of the rabbanu the whole idea of mavoi and uh and a roof is only the rabara they mean the rights with the rights you can carry there he'll kill him i love this line that's why i wanted to read this rashi inside the hey master of amethyru the same people that made the isser they'll make a kula and say you could use two kairos don't worry about it use lava but when it comes to the dairy sofa rice okay since it's the right so i don't say according to this amanda omar loved to bridge a gap in the middle my time at the mother all my in love with benson and what about dr mandelman that says you cannot say love and where did he get it from this not there's a mission in our allies so the way tomo works if this is that person here there's a dead person in new york all chopped up in a garbage bag oy that's right oh yeah every dead person is zoe this case is a little sadder because he's in pieces in a garbage bag and tomah moves it's wild it goes everywhere if there's a roof so it'll go it'll go everywhere in the room and anything in the room becomes tommy besides whatever is directly below the skylight because the skylight doesn't have a roof and the tomah could only run around where there's a roof so in this case here's the skylight directly below the skylight is tar but the clear that's next to it is tommy because the tumor from this bag goes everywhere so right then and there we have the raya why because look at the skylight why don't they say love wood and bridge the gap and close the skylight halogen and therefore the tumor should go in the entire house including this plea this red clay should become tommy and pretend that the skylight doesn't exist through lovin all it is what are you saying so whatever you do up to three twelve what's your name again what's the name of your kid amy come here tell that you love me he's asking a very good question oh well you can only use love for a cooler not for comrade who says this is not saying it's tommy okay very good it's good casual he's asking we only say lovable we isis we brought texas the other day that you only say beloved in order to be matched in this case we are going to this thing if we close the skylight with lava interesting kasha very nice okay we gotta think about it we have to make the home in chicago you hear this or maybe i'm just a big on mars i don't know the answer okay mashing negative guitar mashing now we just continue with the mishnah it's interesting that there's absolutely no difference between the two cases gonna get to us in the mishnah rashi points out in the mission over there there is a big difference between a tafe whatever is below the skyline is star tumor can i get aruba by school guitar and if the tuma is underneath the skylight the entire house is tahar but the problem is the same not the problem the ray is the same according to him why don't you say love and what's the answer the answer is i cannot prove anything from tuma because tomo that's aloha that's a special allah and we cannot bring araya from tuma to other places in the torah okay so now if love would doesn't work in the middle it doesn't work in that we're just saying this one man that says love it works in the middle doesn't work in the middle right if love it does not work in the middle listen to this very interesting cop so there's there's a gap on the side of the sukkot where's that picture any picture here that we had before wherever it is not this one this okay let's say this picture so there's there's three falcon of ear right on this side okay we'll make it better the bigger big sofa three twelve are over here listen what happens he wants to make his sukkah kosher so what does he do he goes ahead and puts zach down but he has to be careful why because if he puts his truck down next to the wall you can't say love it in the middle according to this mandomer listen you hear what's going on if he has one piece of bamboo left in his garage and he wants to make his sukkah kosher he should not take that bamboo and put it next to the wall because next the wall is not he's not going to gain anything because there's still a gap of tutan let's say and you cannot say leveled in middle of a sukkah and this is the middle of the sukkah y because there's one piece of bamboo and then the rest of all this so when i'm looking at it from the top it's still in the middle so what is he supposed to do he's supposed to take that piece of bamboo and add it to the rest of the sach and now the gap between the scraf and the wall is only truthful and that's okay you could say love is you could say it from the wall to the but you can't say it in the middle it's very interesting hop what happened over here okay just thought i'd point it out what else another very very interesting aloha that you don't say lovered from in the middle of a sukkot how much what's the gap yes almond what is the gap you have bamboos going if i don't say love in the middle of a sukkah what if there's one finger or a half an inch between the bamboos from side to side of my sukkah says the rama you're sukkah's possible you know how to eat underneath that gap even though it's this big but since it goes from side to side of the sukkot it's puzzle so what do you do what's the way out of this if you're using slats and they have a gap according to what we're saying you cannot say love it in the middle of a sukkah it doesn't say what the mount is it says less than three two maybe it means a fingers worth a half inch i don't know what so one eight says to take a muted on what i don't know why is the mark playing around okay mark stop uh stop fooling around over there gary okay i'm muted again who's muting me who's muting me mark what's going on here somebody muted me you muted a gun how's it how's somebody able to mute me okay no i'm muted no thank you okay listen you do me here sit over here and just unmute it every time it goes but turn turn turn the volume on there's no there's no need to have volume on this one why was your volume on yeah one okay but here meanwhile i'm i'm unmuted so it's good stick around there just sit over here and see look look to see if it's muted okay fine so you hear the it's a raboisa you have a bunch of bamboo that's not touching each other even if it's a a pinkies with so what do you do oh no thank you i can't see it it's right over here i'm on top over there and bark hashem now i'm unmuted okay so very simple later you take one slat of bamboo and you go across the other way smack in the middle that's one one way the other way to do it is if you hold that you need at least a tefl width of ear because the tether is of there are mother doesn't talk about that but some hold in the ramah in that idea that you need at least a tava to pass all your sukkah otherwise don't worry about it but nevertheless if you use these slats it's something to think about allah myself if you're using slats you should try to put something at least going across one piece going gross smack in the middle let's go invite them shaman how are you we're middle shear how can i help you stop hello everybody says gary say hello to gary he's not talking but he's saying okay i somebody if somebody wants to speak to him yeah okay hello it's a very good question could we talk about it after sheer right now tell him to go on now oh he has a good passion now it's 7 15 ready to stroll and we're still middle of sheer we're going to be done in five minutes but they could go they could look the at the at the end of it and then you play the rest before okay i can't argue with you on the middle of a share now that we're recording for a couple thousand people we'll argue a little later no or you want to argue now uh you want to go back to sleep don't go back to sleep we need you bye okay talk to you tomorrow um so we did the aruba thing when i remember the magical guitar if you have a house that has a giant skylight in the middle shera or melafona baby small burby i see remember me from alberta i see rabiose was the one that said and he had one of us and all five sons were giants one of them was small a tremendous tremendous time rebbe parish could you explain a little bit what just any size skylight perishable this is what my father rebecca said our bomb is shiro it has to be within four elements of the wall great no big killers there darjeev if you have small fish that are kosher share your ladies what's the concern the concern is if i have a bunch of small fish what if i have within the fish non-kosher fish oh my the front of your schmallbury i see rebbe parish please explain what you're talking about this is where beyonce said shabbat complaining asura if there's small fish from this place there are social marketplaces depends what the places the type of fish small fish that comes from bhav is kosher mai tai mo elements from the diffi mayo if you'll say because they're very strong currents the high this non-kosher fish doesn't have a spine so therefore it doesn't even exist in a place that has very strong currents is that true we see this plant even on kosher fish in currents maybe it's because these small baby fish cannot exist in salt water by the atomic union leslie kilpei since it doesn't have scales not true there's plenty of non-kosher fish in saltwater ellord [Music] sorry in this whatever this lake over here that you're you're catching a fish the the silt the mud whatever it is doesn't exist so that these non-kosher fish that we're talking about that look you know my entire life wherever i went oh you're stefan ski oh you're related to dagum tuna because dagging tuna is a stefan ski company so what was the stick about dogging dog and tuna they were able to take tuna without all the rats and dolphin meat and all that stuff that a lot of other tunas weren't so careful with it's a thing like if i'm gonna take all these little baby fish you're gonna have some other non-kosher fish sneak in there but in this kind of place whatever this place is i'm not so concerned above bob doesn't have this mud on the bottom so it's fine but today that these other rivers dump into above so you're getting all the non-kosher fish from the other rivers we're not going to get into it but it's a big shiloh you know new york got a big problem with the with the with the worms in the water different things like that today we have a different problem i love strawberries for instance strawberries i know a lot of people they it's very difficult so they ignore it but you can't ignore it the prowess they're worms in these strawberries so you have to soak them in soap and water twice and take a toothbrush it's a whole asic if you like them you gotta work for it but they're issues it's just very interesting that these these worms they grow in water depends how they grow if they grow like in standing water it's fine if it's an ocean it's not it's a problem the kids are they all discuss it new york and their beautiful piping and everything okay sesame you have these overhangs in front of your house and you put now so you put sim are these pieces of wood that are separated from each other less than threes sorry so if you guys look seeming shayara shane lopsim but if it doesn't have these pieces of wood that act as a wall a biome oh my rover says it's parcel about your machera why that has so i dug out this picture i like this picture better from aravind i'll show you the picture that they have it's not bad peter you're recycling means that this edge right over here provided that's a tavak wide will come down down and create a wall what is that called good aches it's in the same allah of good comes down says abaya here's the picture over here i have invisible walls three walls that come from the edge of the sadr of the overhang particularly the seismic yellow [Music] oversized him what if i had three walls and one of the walls fell down so now the third wall should be particularly oversized so i saw beautiful why does it say hypnus should say if a guy built two walls why does he say in a situation where he had three walls and one of the walls fell down perhaps the shot is because when he built the walls he had no intent to use the ceiling as a wall so maybe in such a case i don't say it so he's saying even in a case where he had three walls and he didn't want to use p-thicker he didn't want to use this invisible wall because the ceiling was already you couldn't tell that there's a ceiling there because there's a wall there but then this the wall fell down and it it's now the ceiling shows i could still say peter versus him who cares oh and what about this case it was built like this and according to tana to tarab this is 100 kosher to carry on in chavez it has zero walls i'm using all four walls all four walls pete dickery oversized says the gemara oh people are going to be walking through it that's not a kosher circle it was we just turned to the customer base sponsored by the mdy tillam group for all those who need shiddu refusing us please join the hill.com layman we've looked at the ravaged move gershon don't worry about it it's a short daft so we'll start a little late it'll be fine later bye bye to the ravish more coming for you perhaps we could say something tomorrow that this is the same as the earlier the early american the first ever rhymed that ever existed rav and shmuel right because rav was a little bit of a tan a little bit of an amir he's the last of the tanoi this man right here in this case you have an exaggera smack in the middle of an open field ralph says pete thicke will drive recites him on all four sides the most you go is four hours in other words you cannot carry there at all so i just want to point this out over here this this is the the picture from the color of shawn but interesting enough that rashi points out i thought we're going to get to rashi but we're running out of time if there's one wall even according to small we're going to say p thicker yari versailles it's only because there's no walls at all i don't say peter yeah oversized let's do three more lines even though we're late he's going to kill me why not so mark was that garrison that that muted me and muted me just because he's mad says if i could say that one could go like both of them and one of them not so i say this according to shmuel everybody agrees there's no macholic in an open area so if he says in an open area and he says that what you don't you can't carry this at all so cool amoled pleague everybody's going to agree that you cannot carry you can't you can't use it for a sookie either keep please i buy a carafe i buy so basically what we're saying is that schwa says it over here even in the case of an asadra this guy which was created to use underneath he still doesn't say peter gregory versus him certainly doesn't say by sukkah but rav and rabb will say no that abayo will say like ralph but rubble will say no the reason why over here in this case of a open what is this called an assad why does raf say you're allowed to carry air because these walls or this whole thing was made to carry underneath it but by asuka think about it ahsoka you're cheating you're using an overhang and the overhang is made for under the overhang but it's not made for walls that go into the into the courtyard you got what i'm saying here let's look at this real quickly okay this overhang is made for this direction this direction it's not made for this area over here you want to make an invisible wall and use it for the area in the middle it doesn't work says rashi why says the gemara but as you explained if there was a real wall then i could use it for both sides i can't say oh it's made for the inside not for the outside i can make a sukkah and using the outside exterior wall of my house but i cannot use an invisible zine wall when it's not made for this direction it was only made for that direction amazing rabbi sai have a wonderful week we'll see you basically tomorrow at khodrov at 8 30 p.m turn this off you