Daf Yomi Succah Daf 16 by R’ Eli Stefansky

maybe michael and brockos no merkel merkel and broccoli i'm going to call that for mordechai surpassing an honor of his birthday this friday you dalai banachimov and they said they wrote a whole email that i don't have with me unfortunately but they wrote that he's a big big masmud and they wish him a lot of brochures a commemoration of the other side of my two grandfathers moisha biako and khai and ben yosef and my wife's grandfather imanov and shmuel all which were nifter on the 14th above several years apart by a frying wordsman to my brother wartzman and my nephew abe in honor of his bar mitzvah this shabbos dear rebelli i'm a huge fan of yours and your daf i finally understood why you're not allowed to learn on tish above uh this is amazing that was such a mix of tiring ps i cannot wait for the next time you come to new york so i can be there live pirates of heydesh in memory of his mother fago bashmoreland's father woman aka mendoza and the merit to make it to umar is a short of this year oh boys i listen to this email by ishai rothman their belly before the gemara initiative sugar i hadn't opened up the bar since i looked to shiva and got married that was almost three years ago but as you said in a share a few days ago a freaking mother caught my eye and made me want to commit now i look forward to whatever free time i have so i can turn on your sheer and open my gemaran style before i join you share i felt i was wasting my time day in and day out but since i joined even though it's been only a week and a half well it's already two and a half weeks since he sent this i feel like my day in life has meaning because he sent me another email today it's helped many assets in my life home and work alike thank you rebellion for all you doing inspiring people like me to learn then he writes another email today it was absolutely incredible pleasure to be able to meet you in woodmere i'm still blown away by how small the world is and that you're aaron's father turns out that he's my son aaron's roommate from norfolk virginia i knew there must have been a relation and they realized that i'm originally from norfolk i moved there so hearing that you're from here is very cool can you please pass my warmest regards it's been a long time since we were at whack yak i mean forgive me for asking is he's the one is he the one getting married either way mazeltov koltov shai rothman from for rockaway i still don't have my printer so i'm just going to read this off from here um this this is from husky rosenberg from simpalo brazil it says like this third belly the the the name of the email is why should it be why shouldn't we be zoeka for what i would like to tell you again a big ishikaya by the way this i don't know if you know if you've ever seen there's a video called the magic of of ellie and he's in it so if you want to see what husky rosemary you had just upon him a nice nice uh grayish beard so he says he and rip ari napla listen every day to your amazing clear shoe one thing we want to ask you that sometimes someone in your present audience especially if nothing seltzer makes a comment jokes and even close caches everybody laughs lol including you but the outside listeners zooming youtubers have no idea what's going on la manigaura my suggestion is that at least when it's a good cashier joke it said it can repeat it to the outside audience i do but 99 of the time it's a klutz cash it's embarrassing for the person that i asked it it's embarrassing when somebody i don't want to mention names argues with tanoyam and amirahim i don't repeat it why would i repeat it you mentioned a couple of times that eating drinking sleeping you could also perform a mitzvah if you have good kavanagh in mind two interesting things about it this is very nice once i heard from that the words it has all have youth k depends on your cavanaugh [Music] there was once a kid he says that astros is mizaka we have such a burden the the malamad that was there with the kid wanted to bury himself there but said it's a very good question and the answer is that the glim also eat drink and have children honor their parents etc but gain nothing out of it but we hid them doing the exact same thing we get sky if we have cavanaugh that's why was mazakas with these ministers we love your share your stories your jokes and the whole mdy family culture from brazil husky rosenberg all right our boy sign now i'll go back to the zoom i hope it's still on if you were wondering why i was staring at you guys because i was just reading the emails but now we're going back ezra abrams is on from australia what's that you don't want it in the side you want it like this no i can't do it okay here from over here here how about this way okay the voice i today is daf design we're actually holding six lines down we made some progress yesterday in beijing hashem today we should finish the entire deaf design and start tomorrow bran so goofa and if you recall just just the other day rash asked the question why is he goof on a mishna gufa is when amirahim say something and we want to go into what mariam said caleb if you used uh remnant of garments shattered tattered oh i can't even say his name is going to be voyage if she davis is in the house why why why why why get over here good job so a guy had a coat a jacket a nice something that was my cabo toma then it was ripped up into little pieces shmatus and he used it for my beloy caleb what does it mean omar bio we explained it yesterday each piece is less than three fingers by three fingers so somebody asked me a riddle i'm not exactly sure that he's right but it's an interesting riddle i have two great riddles here how is it possible that a person has a sucker with and it's possible somebody comes over them whispers something in his ear and the sucker becomes caution she says this kimono right over here what happened was he used garment that's exactly three fingers by three fingers this this size and he it's possible right because it's only three fingers it's possible because he's a wealthy guy but somebody came and whispered his ear by the way he lost all your money so the second he loses money he's a poor person for a poor person three by three is a good baghead you can use it as a as a patch in mma it's well it's possible so for carrot it would have to be for carrot then well somebody told me won the lottery you became wealthy okay whatever great but that's not what the guy told me so matalonia but over here we're talking about it's less than three fingers by three fingers of less than three fingers last year here's another riddle i heard a while ago but this is a very interesting riddle has it passable that your sukkah is possible but if you say a specific a very specific capital to hilum one peritoneum your sukkah becomes kosher it's a real it's a real thing it's not a joke that's real it's real you say one capital to hillary and your sukkah becomes kosher so i'll tell you what the capital tell them is and you have to tell me why it becomes kosher mismo you're makable shabbas on yourself and therefore what how is this how does it become kosher if you make your sukkah out of the um or out of a lucky so we said if it's kosher for shabbas it's kashmir sukkas but it's not kosher during the week so when you're recognized by saying shabbos then that sukkah becomes kosher okay great enough with the riddles for now thank you for watching there's a mat she or l the leftovers i have a b and so just to explain maybe i didn't explain enough you're talking about clothing that used to be macabre tumor and now it's not makable too many more but nevertheless nevertheless it's not good for because it once upon a time was it was a clean it's like zero something like xero and by the way in all xeros and i mentioned it before all zeros of chromium if you are in a situation where there's no sukkah but a sugar that's kosher based on xero like all you have is less than three it's boys so what do you do don't go into sukkah at all that's what i have i'm in a very bad position that's all i have available what do you do so that is you go into the sukkot but you don't make a bracha avaba so you have left over of this mat over here what's the shear six by six it's no longer a mat you shouldn't use it for martial and a mat made out of reeds if it's not made for laying down on because it's very large it's not a klee it's made specifically but if it's very small or smaller it's the size that people used in those days sleep on so it's tommy madras it's like a it's like a bed so you can't use it for sk it's my cable tumor i don't care even though it's it's um it's large it's a big piece should have used it for ska this is mama's nagelam i said so it's another kind of riddle but very very important aloha very you go to a pizza shop and they have a sukkah and the sukkah is made out of a tarp and a tarp is puzzled for a sukkah it blows in the wind a wall like that is not kosher for a sukkah right everybody agrees that that kind of wall that blows in the wind is not a sukkah so what do people do they use straps i'm saying it as if people know this i've seen a lot of circus go like this okay but we're learning and we're going to do better this year we're not going to use these suckers that flap in the wind but what do people do they use these straps or strings every less than three fakhem they make these tight strings they they don't flap in the wind and mellow i have a good sukkah every lesson three tv is a sukkah here's my question you go into the sukkot you go into this pizza shop it was made by some amarettes not even a from i don't know maybe maybe not even jewish the guy that made it how's it possible that this sukkah and it happens all the time is one hundred percent not kosher i don't know the rama says it's not kosher why is it not kosher it has the straps it has everything what yeah so no the the walls don't have to walls are not important only the style so i'll give you a hand that's what we're about to learn what's the problem with the height of bagadesh how do you make this sukkah that's tas of illuminati by putting up the schacht first and then strapping down these straps after this that would be a possible silk according to rama has anybody ever thought about that you go to these restaurants you don't care it looks closer to you it has nice strong straps but wait a minute it depends when you put on the straps if you put on the straps after you put on the schacht so it's tossed a little bit awesome because you have a sucker that's a little higher a puzzle because it flaps in the wind and only afterwards you try to make a costume with straps it's very interesting so here's the picture of a goddess one of the best of the best greatest he has a haystack that's a hundred percent not kosher there's no walls there's no nothing and he went and he dug out in the haystack and he created a void um that's only when the haystack is top to bottom completely full but what if within the haystack there is a void that's the size of a sukkah seven by seven and one type of thick here's a picture here's the void one-two tall only so what happens very very interesting the top over here is creating a sach on this void this void is a good machine because it's a television oil when it comes to tomato so now all i have to do is remove the inside we learned aloha that if you have a sukkah that's ninth tall i could dig one tefak into the ground and make it 10th welcome it's not considered explains rashi why because tax of elimination is a problem when there's a problem with this if i put on puzzle and then i it's it's i put on a vine and then i snip it so it's possible then i made a kosher taste of lemon but over here the brown was the walls the walls weren't tall enough the walls were nine and i made them ten the shock was always there this khaki never moved here the top piece is always the scrap that's the thing preventing you the sock is very thick who cares how thick it is it was always there and it was always kosher it was always miss sake it always created shade on what on the one tavak right over here and that's enough because the tavak is enough for an aisle so that's amazing allah now the khasanesh points out and i have a i have trouble with the khasanesh i didn't think about it a lot but kasich points out that maybe rashid didn't really mean seven by seven that the whole void sp7 says a very a very important allah that we're gonna learn and that is that if you have a small socket that's seven by seven and all you have is four him and three two are not kosher it's a kosher sukkah because you have the roy of kosher so he says over here also you don't need seven by seven void all you need is four by seven let's say okay not going to get into kazinich but an interesting point but if you have a one void that seven by seven the shear of asuka raises sukkah it's not a problem of i'm allowed to dig out more and make from one type of because there's already a that's creating shade on and now we have a bunch of freebies over here we learned the same exact thing if you dug out in a haystack but we have a contradiction hello you have to say to explain the contradiction you have to say where there is a te fact already then it's okay when there's no type of it's not okay and another freebie ikeda ramulei mirama and some use it as a question same exact thing but instead of uh answers the question we have a contradiction there's no contradiction when there's a void of a teva in that haystack already then it's kosher it's not taxable let me know also official mission is sponsored by official you get it official official the official mission of spanish wednesday mata shilshoe is a lotion going from top to bottom so if there is there are walls that come from the top to the bottom i saw you jump when i said the word social i don't know why okay the famous i don't know if you guys are everybody's seen the the yoni uh mishnais so if there's a gap of treats for him and that's enough for a goat to to make its way through the sukkah that's not a good a good diaphragm you know it's not a mojito when animals can come into your sukkah that's not a machine it's not considered a different img but if it goes from the bottom up so the bottom is completely closed great picture over here to emphasize the point if it goes from the bottom to the upwards and this tenth and there's a huge huge gap over here it's kosher why what is this called this halacha anybody remember go close not good but good asic acid goes upwards but very good yosef that's the point it's the same thing goes upwards that's what you said good when it goes downwards so good asset means that it goes upwards it fills in the gap it continues and that we said all you need is 400 feet in the air well that's a different shiloh 400 might be a problem ruby i see i make a shame says this is also a good good sukkah i disagree even though not only could a goat get through here but uh but a cow could get through here it's kosher according to evie i see why because unluckily i say good ah it goes downwards says um do we say on shabbos we have this in arabin if you remember there's a beautiful allah over there if a person has a porch over the water i wanted to print it but unfortunately i don't have my printer yet i saw it today i saw my printer it's not hooked up so you're you're suspended you have a beautiful porch on the water imagine you live on the water but you want to drink the water and chop you want to draw water on jarvis what do you do you make a box of walls you make a hole in your porch and you have a box and these bat the box goes downwards halal all the way to the water and it creates one resource remember that that's what we're discussing now same idea if you have a hanging wall does the hanging wall go downwards so we have that by shabbas and we're trying to say that the same allah applies to sukkah it's not awesome so where do we have dialogue so here you have a pet a water pit between two katseras two people owned this now there are bonang you're not going to carry forward unless you make a rule katseros so you can't make air containers rashi there's no door there's no there's nothing going on here all we have is a wall fruit can't make it but i want to draw water but i cannot draw water why can't i draw water because i might be drawing water from your culture i can't carry from yokatsu to my culture so what do i do so says the gemara aim in [Music] seems like you see the gimbal over here doesn't it's not guyra's baby model it's not three ways to to fix the problem it's two ways two very simple ways basically you you create a wall inside the pit either la mata in the water close to the water or lamalo above the water okay this is a real you see this wall right over here a hanging wall so it's not touching the water but it divide divides the water and i luckily the wall is going to go continue down into the pit through the water separate the water i am taking from here is going to grab from there okay that we spoke about an air event we're not going to get into that just means that it has to be within the pit within the walls of the pit you can't put your wall on top like this wall that goes through the hutzer okay now why can't this wall right over here serve as a wall it's tenth why is this wall no good the guy on top because it wasn't made for the purpose of separating the water it was made to separate the concept and we can we cannot use it for water purposes not a problem says he could we just turned to the design of the base sponsored by the mdy talent group for all those who need shidduchim refusing yeshua's please join tillm.8.com also on top means even okay because basil will say it has to be in the water you're showing that it's there it's touching the water okay which i say you can even do it on suspend it on top why do you need to make a special wall like so over here down here why can't i just use this upper wall that's enough that's all i need i don't need to make extra walls one tend to have a wall on top is enough and i like will go down good access will go down into the water so is the same allah as a sukkah if i have a wall all the way up there 20 feet up in the air but it's tenth it'll come all the way down and create a majita for a sukkah for me it's the same halacha what's the difference if i make a tent and allah goes right through my my bar my well right down the middle or i have a tenth and it goes right down the wall and it it closes off the wall i don't think a goat not a goat but it closes off the wall says ruby i see the higher they're saying the same thing but of course that's the gemara's job is to show us the distinction between two different alakas we have to figure out what could be the distinction between shabbos and soccer review besides a hanging wall is enough it's considered a wall can you make a distinction lawyer view the seven electorate of you i see will there be a server like your view though just because you say that doesn't mean you agree that the same allah is in yokosuka and just because he said in sukkah doesn't mean that dialogue is in chavez why lloyd reviewed the sabbath review over here awesome the whole problem to carry from from one side of the well to the other side of the well is only is it the rabbana you let it carry from one house to another house with their eyes so hammer are the ones that said we have to be careful you might carry from surrounding so you have to make an error of kazeros you have to make it ariel but over here you need walls midday so you can't create these funny walls and make it at the rice of the sukkah shabbos will be matter of funny walls because midorisi you don't even need walls so you want to use them for the rabbat and it's okay on the flip side you could say valeri the so i'll permit a suspended wall ava shabbos this is not this problem over here of a bar which is on the rabbana but the in general shabbos is a very humber that is a skill you can get the death penalty for it so i have to be careful with that i have to do real walls so i may look don't compare with the review the review of their reviews there was a story in sipari in the city of zibari and everything that went into pyrie went based on the rashashiven tsipoiri who was the residency fiery rebbe yaisi how did they pass kin that you allowed to use the suspended wall and see pyri when you just said ribby says only in sukkah not in shabbos and in separate they try to use a suspended wall on shops [Music] because he had a son it's very possible rebi himself was more macro and said no maya has been the wall only applies to sukkah not the shams his son came along after he was lifter and instituted all of the shops by the way stop since we're talking here the very interesting kumara in massachusetts it says he said on himself i had five huge sons arose them five tanoans that came out of these five beelines how do you what kind of lotion is that so anyways india you shall me the bible he says one shot we're not going to get into the israeli says he had five ibamas he had five brothers that died without children and from each one of those ibamas he had one child and here's one of them review islam just uh to explain who i mean we have ribs but over here we're talking about it's not the father it's the son as a hara now question is mai maisa what happened what happened in sipari the ki usur abdi omar they once forgot to bring the same what happened was explains in those days they they were worried about the game and the guardian would come and look for this severe torah so they'll literally hide the ceva toro in different houses every week in another house so nobody can find this avatar one week they forgot to bring the civitar right before shabbos and it stayed in the house now you can't go and bring the whole minion into the house tiny little house and not in the show so what do you do or pierce dinim the next day they came and they put sheets on top of these poles and the sheets didn't go all the way down to the ground they were suspended merci toys same story that we had today the views of itary vakarabay so what's going on here here's the story if you look closely here are the sheets here you have all huts are a lot of different houses and because it's awesome to carry in here because of all the khatiris what they did was they isolated the shull and one house and all the other houses have nothing to do with this place now if i walk in this corridor right here i'm good i'm not part of the concert and if you see over here the sheet doesn't reach the ground so this is a suspended wall and it's in pyri and they said it's okay i thought the rebbi she only said is allah and now you're telling me this works even on shabbos they're carried i allowed them to carry cemetery from this house into the show it wasn't really it was his son but that was the story i asked the gemara just let's talk about the story for a second how do they come and bring a sheet from another house it's carrying you're telling me there's no mojito how what happened was it was already there it says pierce it's a little bit of a problem maybe pierce is on friday why was there i don't know maybe if it's neatest who knows women this is the women's who knows but they had these venom and they used it on shabbos even though the even though it didn't reach the floor tyson doesn't like it so he says that we're talking about a lie right here we're talking about creating a wall on chaves oil right but because of this tysos there's some very interesting halachas that are important what happens if your falls off on yante falls off you don't have a sucker now what do you do you create you should not be able to put it back on your tip why because you're creating you're creating oil oh you hear what he says kevaldik so the true pascans you could do it with a guy a god could do it the primo gotham says that happened him once that asuka fell fell down and he he wasn't michael they brought a guy he didn't didn't say anything because he managed he had no way out of it he said however listen to this interesting thing there's a spirit in the mr brewer the one place he says you're allowed to do it they go in one place that says not and they want to answer that if you never put up your you forgot your negligence you didn't put up stuff then you cannot use a guy because you're negligent if you did everything you could and then the wind came and blew it off that's not your fault i'm going to allow to put it on in chavez but not if you didn't do it so i'm just pointing out some alafa's that are interesting too all you li i'm just imagining my head like you take this uh roll of plastic or something it's it's four wide and you go you know how they they wrap you know boxes and stuff with the stuff that you have like four poles and you go you do this one wrap around you shook a book that's kosher why it's only for its the answer is you put it smack in the middle and i have a total of ten four plus three on the bottom is seven plus three on the top is ten and here is what it looks like mma law if you're cheap and you don't wanna build a whole wall so this is what you can do and you have a 10 foot 10 sukkah so all you need to do is put one strip right down the center and make sure it's a little less than three twelve from the bottom so you have love it a little less than three is wrong with the dab you have a lovely bam tent we mentioned number of times mao the same says the more beautiful i would think had love with marino on trey loved maybe you don't institute love it twice maybe it's only once come on i could say love it twice that's a big finish okay we had love of the you know parsnip alimed all these things strings fine you could say more than once vey marcellus very interesting cash it says muffers and bryce saw that if i have a mat that seventh wide i could use it as a wall i put it three twelve away from the bottom let's say but it says mafurish that i can't do it twice i could only do it once it says that the the man has to be seventh vaccine why does it have to be seventh vaccum it could have said fourth for him and i could do love it twice the answer is i can only do love at once seven plus three equals ten i can't do four plus three plus three ten only seven plus three that's what it says here tell us very simple answer that's talking about a very large sucker a regular sized sukkah a regular sized sukhoi you can't institute love it twice it's more than 10 it's a hundred thousand so you can only do it once you can either do it by the top or by the bottom and even if you do it one time and it's far away from the top let's say you do it uh what do we have here not this one sorry this you do a strip of seven it's three twelve i'm away from the top so total of ten and then i'll do a good access or like this one right here same exact thing i do a strip of seven three dragon from the bottom so now i have set a 10 total and i do good asic going up what else do we have here okay next i can't do love it twice i could only do it once um but so so if that's the case that i'm instituting love it over here that's what are you telling me loved love it i heard a hundred times already why do i need another time says um this that i could use love or upwards and i'm telling you i could go downwards and i don't care that an animal could get through here a very large animal more than a gd that's the not the kiddish that i could close this off with a level but rather that tenth from the top is enough to go downwards what time is it terrible what i need a clock i need to slow it down no there's no knock on seltzer nobody's asking questions nobody's saying jokes what's going on david something [Music] tall has to be tall for our purposes it's tall ah for for who was it rosenberg he asked does it mean tall or tall it doesn't mean wide over here it means tall oh ellie dykeman put on the beautiful picture that i was looking for is that you ali that put it on on zoom here let me show the island over here the picture that you just put on this is the picture i was looking for i i love this but i just like it the guy's mom is hanging out in florida over the water and and he has he builds four walls and he's able to draw water from yeah yeah this is an aravind a lot of people lately were writing emails that aireven they thought was so hard and this but with the pictures they were able they made it through easy we had over 700 pictures in everyone omar reby okay so now we're talking about oh good points sure is over almost don't worry about it it's not perfect all done okay if you have a wall that's fourth falcon wide and you distance from the from the other wall streets falcon so now you have a total of seventh that's all you need the seventh fakhim to make a kosher wall um it's less than three the the shear of asuka is seven like bishop might be shy may say that it has to hold roy boy and therefore seven i saw a very interesting thing from bianchi the talmud of the rajba is something to look into the beautiful thing what's the shear of asuka says the gemara seven says the tamil of the rashbow that it says it's referring to the seven yom tyvim goes through the seven young tavern we have shabbos plays you have shot him and it goes through each yantev that each yantif is about seven is seven days seven days of israel and seventh for him in the sukkah everything is about seven there was seven and ani are covered that sukis is based on it was we're in a box six sided backs right plus one ana covered in the front leading so seven and nine are covered shiva's amine we we're using three adasim two arrows and it goes on and on and on it's all about seven and then of course you have the eight minute daf i don't know how that is tomorrow i think we should do shir right here in this room at four o'clock if anybody's available i can't prepare quicker than that i know it's before chavez if anybody can make it great a four o'clock here which would be five o'clock in new york you guys up to it of course ellie dyche will be there and shilling climb will be making his channel if you want to see schleich climb making challenge chavez and zoom be here schnitzel that's what he makes whatever he's doing something every time on earth chavez he's running around this kitchen with the with the screen on but anyways thank you for for coming thank you for the support rabbi said bring your friends you know there are more people there yakov calvin did a great job brother davis there but there's more guys here where's simcha man they'll bring the islam next week josh rosen bring my stepbrother ire kushner you know my stepbrother ire cushion of course you know that was another zone bcd ahri irika is the lawyer how long am i in town i'm in town uh my son's hasanah is on sunday august 1st and then right afterwards we are probably leaving for new york city ross by the way if you haven't seen in new york there's like i said yesterday there's about a hundred people in woodmere but we are doilam is planning a nice chevy bronchus in my son's honor and uh there'll be a it'll be nice it'll be a lot of entertainment and stuff music and good food and uh just a it's a place to get together and meet islam nothing nothing nothing serious maybe afterwards there'll be a cheer for everyone to stick around but for my son and escala it will be light a light kind of thing they'll be in a hall because of look for the details bazer hashem that will be on august 5th i think it is on thursday whatever thursday comes out august whatever i think it's fifth yeah anybody yeah mark august august 5th okay the boys i have a great shabbos if i don't see you matsi shabbos uh what time is this monsieur shabbos here 9 monsieur chavez no what's a regular like and they have to dive in my river so it's 9 30 10 30. it's late about 10 30. you