Daf Yomi Succah Daf 14 by R’ Eli Stefansky (Audio is good after 1min)

good morning wow unreal look at this so look long this it's not to be believed unreal unreal you know i have a i'm very i'm very fond that it's not even the word i belong in the five towns really i grew up here i spent a big part of my childhood here i went to darche my father was a rebbe i went to the bungalow colony that's where i fell into the pit so i really love farakku and i was talking to my wife if we ever make a yirida which is possible you know she still talks about it every single day so the five pounds is one of the short list that or miami i don't know talk me out of my i don't like miami whatever i'm coming to miami though i'm coming okay now i was just saying that i grew up in paraguay and i i looked at the same street on the same street as uh a lot of my i'm so close in heart with the kids that i went to school you know 31a first grade second grade so i love for rapport it always brings that great memory my my brother lives here and um so i got off the plane and i went to daven and then i went to the bagel store i live in the bagel store of course i bumped into somebody i never met before you watched this year and then uh i see a guy making a short stop is i'll be here abby don't see me here he is there he is he gets out of his car he comes rises i notice you in the bagel store hi i know you share but i met a guy there's actually two people i met in the morning [Music] and to me it's very sad just very sad because when you work you're working sixteen eight you don't have 45 minutes in a day to learn to die like i didn't want to boast to him you know the whole guy in the book and everything like i just came off fish above the fortune room on a flight i barely slept i have to give another share and you don't have 40 minutes please now it's not fair because i really enjoy it but you know i thought he gave 40 minutes he took the mustard he promised he's going to come but when it's layla no if i can do it anybody can do it he's going to come together oh you know you know what's interesting that my phone has all my emails so i guess we're not going to read any emails i was counting i printed the emails and i printed a picture of a pitchfork you know why everybody knows what a pitchfork looks like right besides one guy in the room yossi klein where is he you know what a pitchfork is where are you no clue right that's why i printed it out okay so somebody has to show them enough you have emails no all right today sponsorship anonymously by common of the five towns welcome everybody back to the five towns also you huge welcome to two new members in the white thanks to the new gemara initiative yasi klein both friends of mine who died with me henry ness and reb akiva look void i don't know what it says here but maybe it says on the occasion of his wedding oh yeah that's your cousin it says tough nun meeting today wednesday 21st of july simcha 10 30 p.m at kinlos gardens london wow from russo of many years referral groskov river fall he hates red river fall hates when i call him reb the extended eisenberger family liverpool schlemmer for grandpa mordechai nissan ben who is on his fourth magazine exclusive the many black amari learned and it feels from his many children grandchildren great-grandchildren may have a speedy recovery all made and once again from this is the anonymous course okay say how many if you want otherwise i might get uh emails what is this calming's email wow oh he says he's going to come soon blah blah blah blah blah blah blah i'm sparing you the whole thing blah blah blah blah blah comment of the five towns great email all right i if if new to the share i read 40 emails from comment of the five towns he sponsored hundreds already every time it comes with a very long email so all right america is amazing the bagels are great the people are great the schools are beautiful are this world is much better so come to remember chemist i'm telling you it's the way to go you could ask jonathan olsen is in the house by the way also for marriage this role he's the one that got me on to meaningful people nahi gordon is in the house you know you know how many people who here saw meaningful people and started this year because of meaningful people four people five six people in the crowd including nachi gordon wow six people in the crowd started learning the feeling because of meaningful people that's a tremendous close-knit should be very proud of yourself and jonathan austin who put it together that's just in one room so amazing okay rabbi we're holding a middle of a very interesting sugyo if this is not your cup of tea there's many sugars in shas that might not fit exactly how you like it some people hate agatha i don't know why they do some people hate drushes the word hate is strong thomas tyres scares them this is going to be over in 15 lines you see there's a mishna smack in the middle of the page and we are talking about yada yada yada ice is a handle of food basically of anything could be a handle of a clay a handle a pot does it have the halal of the pot does this have the halal of the fruit so we're smack in the middle of a sugar rabinashi says that everybody holds this is grapes grapes are different we said yesterday you can make a distinction that grapes when you press the grapes you don't want any of this stuff this is no good for the grapes so you actually don't want it so if you don't want it it's not part of the it's not part of the food if you do want it then it's part of the food and if you if a mace touches this grape the stem also becomes tummy because that's if it's the odd but if you don't want it then if a mace touches the grape it does not transfer to the handle okay here's another handle in case you don't know what it looks like cherries are amazing in america i don't know why but they're something else not to talk about because oh now i'm going to get the guy oh you just talked spoke lush and hard about the pairs of very strong okay everybody turn around that's coming from the five towns calvin from the five towns big big supporter this year did a lot steal him and all sorts of stuff okay so now we're holding the gemara says like this according to menasha we could say that everybody holds and when it comes to wheat if you cut wheat for the the the shaft of the wheat has nothing to do with the kernel analytics so then where's the macholicas in wheat so says something very very interesting the macholica says what happens if somebody cuts the wheat to eat it we cut it to eat it he wants the entire thing and then afterwards he says he wants to make schach out of it so wants to say that just thinking your mind because i gave a whole speech just a few days ago that's all in the head yiddish guy is all in that the same thing the same person could go to sleep and be behind big mitzvahs by thinking that he's sleeping in order to have kaijus together for daffy aimee and he gets that much more mitzvah a person just lay down in bed and go to sleep watch a movie and go to sleep they're both going to sleep if you have that extra shovel right before you go to sleep you get that mitzvah why not think about it same thing with food eating say i'm eating these grapes they have caught us whatever okay so this person thought in his head that he wants to use it the wheat for food and then he said you know what i have a sucker i need to cover my sukkah so he switched it in his head could you switch it in your head says kamar you can't switch it in your head you know why because once it becomes a cli then the only way to unswitch it is by taking an action now it's too late already to to think thinking is only good when it's a blank slate as the more brings them you can make it a cli and decide that this piece of leather i'm done with it i want to i want to sell it i want to use it okay so now in my head it became a click once it became a cli it's much more difficult to undo that the only way to do it is to show that you don't want it you break it you cut it you do something okay so now we have to understand rabona that's where we're holding now how is it that according to our button let's see the gimbal inside now like we're five lines down amelia maybe this idea that you need to you need to do a an action take an action in order to undo it that's that's going to clean availability but you know this little thing over here is not clear this is insignificant so sometimes i need it for my food sometimes i don't need it so maybe over here it does work to undo something like that in your mind no but nah that can't be call you all these hawks should be sustained now we have to understand what the word besan is the gemara of course is going to explain but it says that if you have any handle of food including this well gairen is grain so he did a basisa to what whatever bessie says it's star very icy basically he broke it up the ocean everybody says it's not good and hitler so you have a bunch of grain and you have it's tied with a string and he did besiso swamp shot is you undo it think about it did you take any action in the grain there's no action in the grain what's the action in the string there's no action in the grain but since you untied it you show that you don't care anymore about the whole shaft you don't care they could be separate so that's very similar to what tamar shadow it's a very light action it's an action that's not in the grain itself so my mela maybe also if i think about it that's also enough so that shop here the works hello omar might be awesome he trampled on it he broke it up oh that's a real action in the grain michael maymar so how's it over here that going you could just undo it with your mind how could i undo toma or khloe with my mind it's a clear writing says you're right you can't undo a clue with your mind what's talking about that he actually broke it up that's what it's talking about what we learned yesterday that is the first he made it for food then he made it for but he broke it up with his mind with an action how could they say that it remains a yad he broke it he showed he doesn't want it to be a handle anymore so why would you say that he took action he broke it and he undid the previous makshava one makshava was i want this to be a handle then he comes and he staples all stampedes it breaks it apart so isn't that showing that he doesn't want it to be a handle says kamar no dhamma grip you always see the snare rib yo you see me tama revere says by the ya the yad is matama this becomes tommy and smetama if tuma touches this it goes into the grapes i need to eat some of these rather have those cotton candy grapes you guys in there just roll they sell cotton candy grapes they don't look like gardening but it tastes like having amazing stuff but it's closed oh maybe it's not but they're not washed but it's still kadai slimy it's not 100 cotton candy it's not bad so by the way slay me klein sponsored today's event so you should have all the food amazing stuff biscuit [Applause] you know come here slay me i have a problem there's a guy here his name is josie klein he's not going to want to come to the front i need you to grab him and get over here doyle needs to see what you look like bring him over here look at him he's turning all colors get over there you'll see y'all see make it look high with me come on boys [Applause] [Music] [Applause] it's unbelievable we're standing with godless you're slimy you gans put it together it's unbelievable unbelievable slimy get over here where are you going this one guy it's amazing this is the aussie client that we talk about so everybody is capable of coming up with ideas to increase tire in this world here's a great example get over here go for everything no i want one for me though that's him jonathan you're next all right now we can learn torah oh so one of the emails i wanted to read to you comes from a guy by the name of you ask me not to mention his name and he says i love your shirt i'm going to another share i can't stand all the jokes i need a serious share i'm going to search for another share so i want to tell him you don't need a search every other share is just like the one you're describing if you want to share that come here and stay stick around okay he doesn't like this then we stop in middle okay too bad says the gemara like this we're middle of the others that's why we got to step a little bit take a break he says these the others that we're talking about become tommy hi my some why time of the day i see has it been lockish so goes on to pitchfork is like a it's like um for the haystack you know it has a handle it has like four or five big pieces of metal and you grab the hay and flip it and you toss it so if it doesn't have the the long shaft to it it's very difficult to control the kernels they'll fall right through the the fork uh what are they called the tines jesus times these tongues i think the times what no times yeah and punish these at times but over here we're talking about why do you need this the whole shaft of this car of the of the weed is great so you could grab it by the shaft it's very difficult to remove all this haka it's just a bunch of kernels or whatever okay goofa so for this it's conducted to see rashing four lines down from the wide lines smack in the middle and the rashing i just thought it was cool shout out to maori says rashford that's my rebbe for the mission it's the middle of the saga if the kumar is bringing a mishnah the word goofa is weird doesn't really belong let's go back to the middle to the main part that we discussed let's explain a little bit about it but if it's a mishnah says rashi i never saw the word goof on a vishnu says rebbe told them all mighty robbie i'm just saying because even rashid had a rebbe even around she has questions and israeli was smarter than him or whatever at the time at least knew this answer told him it's because this mission is in the harass shaymin the mission in the tires doesn't have a gemara villain for russia it doesn't have anything that explains it like a regular missile it's like a islamic force that's why this word gufa does make sense under these circumstances because it's a mishna in the harris so anyways it says like this mufa khali all this influential sausage rice all handles a food they did the sesa and now we're just gonna we learned this already so this is really easy all the way to the michelin tires all you do is open up the the string that's holding it together bishop they realized that the time realizing if you say that you you just all you did you didn't take action you didn't break it apart that's why basically says everybody's coming i might be tired what's the reason why luggage okay same word for word that we said before six lines of freebies unravels and here we have three lines of agatha and then we're gonna go into another studio a much easier suggyo about boards interesting legend by yitzchak is like a pitchfork that what i love is it happens just like this pitchfork flips the grain from side from place to place within the goyard heisiger in english silo something like that okay so too could flip guys so we're also thinking in a way so we all the ms we all really have marty dab or shaun alayhim you better get ready tomorrow this year in chicago you're going to be there i don't care what time i don't care thumb two thumbs up okay get the boys together chicago is the weakest city in the united states and it's not gonna be like that anymore it's terrible go there three enough people show up and y'all bergman it's unbelievable he's mean-spirited into rahmanis there's a rabbit they used to call every one of his hasidim what's going on so one of the questions came over and said you called me inside yeah so listen to this rabbit i have a i need this type of sounding okay fine but the bottom line is and we could all with the proper trilo you could flip it says the halogen mission of sponsor the official mission sponsored by official miss sakura in minnesota oh it's a shame i don't have the picture to pitch for because i wanted to show you my son-in-law is here everybody say hello to mayor jacobs he's in the back okay so he printed i maybe i shouldn't have mentioned today now i haven't printed me out this pitchfork she comes back with a piece of paper half the size because that's the typical printer black and white it's america this is our destroyer boy's eye in america black and white pitchfork shock isis anyway hashem i left it there nissarim you could take a look what a nester is a serious piece of wood so according to your review though that's okay miss accommodation to review though mayor oyster why because we're going to see xerath stigra guess what in those days this is what your house looked like it's not like today that they came up the invention of tar and shingles and who knows what and it's as close to water tight as you could get it put it very close and when it rained no little came in so it's also to sleep in your house and use it as ahsoka why because the third says get out of your house go into the sukkah but the wood is good for but it's xaira says river mayor remember your oyster no san allah what if he put one piece that's fourth for him now the gemara is going to qualify this according to who does this go according to review though this is go according to the mayor cheryl uberwatch so everything is good if you see the picture in the red you cannot sleep under the red because that's where the piece of wood is but the rest of this is good says the gemara of course we have a shiloh here what's an answer mission doesn't tell us so anytime you have a question like that what's an answer what's the answer so according to rav this is in above four that review that says i don't care how big the necessary is it could be five feet wide kosher so the whole mach like is is above four machine learning opposite from four and up everybody agrees it's puzzle four and below is kosher now that gemara's gonna have to deal with schmoll unravel fits into the prizes by the way at the end the gemara is gonna bring a bryce that says exactly like rav and a bryce exactly like shmuel so their macholicus is actually based upon tanayim and there's no real resolution this so again above fort falcon pretty pretty wide something like this rabbi huda says it's kosher according to rav and according to shmuel above ford's falcom everybody says it's apostle now what's below fourth falcon iguana is going to qualify that right now if below fourth is going to mean between three and fourth why because anything below three is already lava it says it's fight less than three oh it's just a regular piece of bamboo is also less than three all right this is in other words between four and three that's the whole shuttle according to shmuel my timeout anything less than three is perfect although i saw some acronyms say all the way from lakewood and moisture are you guys related but you just happened to walk in together you know iron am i sure she should come to the front here we gotta get over here we got to talk about you for a second also in the middle of the year come come come to the front so my time at khan about menino from three to f uh moisture this is sad to go over here without getting paid works every day for hours on our hammer cause he has close thousand subscribers that's our newsletter so you straight after moisture please subscribe now ironers get over here all the way from lakewood it's going to ask for iron for all you do all your traveling all your cu your get-togethers it's very much appreciated you shouldn't her bar go back to your seat all right next time come on time i know you're from lakewood what oh today's share was also put together by dr biancon schwartz by ellie berman where is he right here that's right you're gonna get over here mandy greenblatt and rematic groomberg the famous ou user of mother he's here in the house also everybody's there it's unbelievable it's unbelievable okay listen if you're new to the share you'll start recognizing these names oh you user and jonathan austin who doesn't want to come to the front jonathan why don't you come to the front for a second none it's just an opportunity to get to meet everybody i'm telling you guys needs to see who you are it's a handsome guy like you should come to the front right away right away you girls want to see you i'm like oh no get over here come [Applause] on before before you get i'm going to do three lines god no quicker delilah's waiting people on youtube they don't know what's going on here someone like him robocyte seriously here's a guy that made over a hundred phone calls to make sure that i get onto meaningful people he called me 96 and he called ngaki for and yaakov two no it was a whole thing to go and come and when i'm going then my flight was canceled but he had one thing in mind he wanted more people to join torah that's it that's all he had in mind it's unbelievable another guy with with with hakma and then he got us to the ceo and the place by the kaiser jonathan just in case you're not on all right the seder besader okay i have no idea what time it is and they complained that i just saw they said every time i go to america the sheriff go longer than normal and they have a they have mignon they have too many on them and this is smack in middle it's a 45 minute slot when do we start they might have to speed it up because it's not live actually we're doing it for america this time okay we looked in the mission if he puts here one piece of wood that's fourth wide in your sukkah kosher now i forgot to mention by the way oh very very important piece how did i forget where is the kosher rashi explains that it's kosher close to the wall because anything within four amis of the wall of the sukkah is kuma so i could put anything within those four amas even a four tepha piece of wood so it says another necessary tactic underneath it but according to rav that says even more than ford's there's a mandala that says it's kosher named ruby hudo about the echo cheryl a milotian doctor for interview though why can't you sleep underneath it says why are you right according to review you can't miss out is there alcohol save our son or mayor that whole thing goes according to your mayor only and according to you though you could sleep under the fourth board there is no limit to how wide the piece of wood could be according to rav toshma is dining we know that cheats are what so if you have two small sheets they are mitstariff starfin to make so two sheets make a suk of puzzle to make the shear of whatever you need to make the circle puzzle and shane is sorry two pieces of wood are named star because like it's two pieces of bamboo five pieces of bamboo they don't create a tier if you don't combine them and say oh i have a giant piece of wood that's how we do a sukkah we just turned to udala on base sponsored by md white dylan group for all those who need shidduchim refuse yeshua's please join tilum.8mindaf.com remember i'm having a song by the way we're only going to try to go like to like 10 lines down from the bottom because i hope i'm right i don't really have a chance to look but it looks like a very very short test and base so we'll save some of it for tomorrow schneiderlin afternoon sir mayorals no difference two pieces of wood arm and stuff says we're trying to prove one over the other is it true that above for him according to shmuel what does it mean it's tariff because anything above four everybody holds his apostle miami styrofoam aside from laraba you have two pieces of wood that are two you put them right next to each other what's the difference if it's one large piece of four it's welcome with two small pieces of tutva him they're mistarif hello rav don marbushies but according to we have a problem hey dummy what's the case here according to rav these are just pieces of wood loyola we are talking about pieces of wood that are for but we're not talking about the tirf that you're thinking 10 minutes okay we're not talking about the tier that you're thinking we're talking about a different zero like we mentioned before four amis off the wall is considered akuma i could get away with anything on those four amas so if i put a bunch of pieces of wood that are four wide they're all possible and i bring them all the way out off the ball more than four atoms are they my styrofoam now that's the question of the gemara not whether peace smack in the middle of the sukkah is a mistake because we are talking about four pieces so that's not the question the question is from the side listen and some want to say different they start off with the trick according to schmoe that above ford's everything is possible my midstar from start from our bodies whoa get over here [Applause] everybody this is yeshua and price you might have gotten texts from him from now on you can ignore now you know what he looks like just ignore this guy got you by the way this what about the dog is this duff that's not the diaphragm give him some food wow where's your where's your shirt wow two in the morning wake people up i don't know who these are phone on all the guys from brooklyn over there geez look who's behind you sonny holloway okay i got your video i got it he learns tomorrow while he's skateboarding in the skate park left the show one of these days give all the good stuff [Laughter] great so listen to this the murray over here starting over the trick understanding that we're trying to do it cereal over trying to combine pieces of wood to make four almost let me make four to make four amis by the way just a little trick ar ba usually means amaze and our ball usually means are both okay fine so bishop right from there elvis what do you mean according to me who who cares how many boards you put and how four hours from the side it's just regular there's no difference between a piece it's not that's one inch the piece is five feet wide it can't be with star if it can't combine to make a soul in regular bamboo sticks says i did the cover of the name starfin the washington is not good remember says it's mysterious and it's good i'll review the aim at starfin he was just messing around with the russian but really it isn't starring mean the same thing but aim and styrofoam would mean they don't combine it's not that they don't combine it's perfect that okay so the lotion is just because we may use that watch and he he also uses that lotion how do you give us a rav thank you very much well nothing but just brings a bryce this is exactly word for word like raph and then another prize is his word for word like wool not really fear haggai was in the round we have a bride so sick called minnesota somebody used planks of wood cedarwood shane by my body they don't have four falcons it's great yes here over here it says that there's a mandolin who holds that more than fourth him is kosher who says that rav so it's a perfect bryce of lightcraft comes along and he adds to that it was a terrible time when the game said no circus we had a trick we brought big planks of wood gaium are used to nice bamboo and the the kindness or whatever it is when we brought these big planks of wood they had no clue they're building a sukkah we put it in the on our porch and replace it with it [Applause] of course of course they didn't say anything and you could do that because let's think about it is a piece of wood this big awesome no it's said they don't want you to sit in the house by mistake so they said all these pieces of water are no good so sit there at the bottom so that's the famous question do you are you do you do the rabbana when you don't have a choice you don't have a choice the game are forcing you there's no stock available the only thing they sell at home depot even like this year right the prices of wood went up like crazy two by fours uh thirty five dollars uh you know it used to be 199 how much is it today fourteen what fourteen dollars nine dollars still crazy stuff right so let's say they don't have any more wooden home depot cove whatever the only thing available is this do you use it but said it's not good took away the exercise when it's uh i think with zero review says no one's our bottom put into zero it's like zero and the fact that they used it it shows that there's no limit to the size of now anything about fourth everybody agrees is no good sick and essential is interesting same washing as the prices be forced to something completely different opposite if i take cedarwood that are planks of wood she is from our ball and therefore it's direct obsolete according to everybody's puzzle ellie we need another smack a picture and a video from this corner right over here have your phone you have to send it to us if we can show that it's unbelievable over here oh man you know why because the guy that makes the coffee let me climb not your shower price you started yeshua you started remember poison review the max listen to this so end of the story foreign is below four but above four it's possible okay fine i guess i missed all these beautiful charts that i brought for marriage to stroll by the way gary vamos's son came to my house unbelievable coach broco gave me a great idea so why am i spending 10 15 minutes a day printing these i took i paid gary's son and he printed all 500 of these 550 i saved myself 11 hours unbelievable got to delegate so some of these are a little extra fine let's see what we need here pockets and shoulders wow wow all these crazy i forgot we have pictures where boy says dean him down the middle you want to see his dna great wow it just keeps on going okay but here's here's the important picture that we're talking about right now here's a sukkah oh yeah i don't like what he did here oh yeah yeah yeah no it's good fine the sheet that's right i don't like this one this one is the better one okay this is what we're talking about romero says like this if you have a sucker if you have a sucker that's exactly eight amish wide 48 so you do it like this you put a plank of ward in the beginning and a plank of wood at the end fourth falcon this is where mayor who holds that fourth is 100 no good only rebuda according to rav says the fourth falcon is okay so what you do is you put a plank and then you put real squat a plank real straight plank real stroke so over here you're going to have doif and akuma to this wall over here you're going to have different akuma to this wall the vacuum is going to come out all the way there but when you reach the center you have two pieces of regular schach each one is fourth falcon wide together it's eight fakhem how much stock do you need for a real sukkah seven so eight is more than enough the center is a perfect sukkah the fact that i have all these planks of wood it's not the end of the world because it's different akuma let's see it inside um yes benefit in between each plank of wood is a space of a plank of a wood and in that space chamonix okay fine end the story this is the kosher sukkah according to a mayor interesting it doesn't have to be exactly the size it doesn't have to be this this it's just an idea you don't really need eight you can get away with seven okay here is a very interesting case um this we had basically that if you put a piece of wood within four amis of the wall you cannot sleep underneath it i gotta tell you because slimy clown is in the house here so i got to tell you the joke i didn't ask him for supposed to say this joke it's a it's a stock but since he's here he's going to be michael and shem of all about i just thought it was great somebody told me this thing he said it's a mammogram switch lightning it's mama's genes that the banishers don't sleep in the sukkah would be walking and hating on suckers they'll be pulling up pajamas on every corner and saying come to ride into soccer [Music] all right here you have giant planks of wood there are four wide but they're only let's say three two him thick so he did a trick he flipped them sideways they're on the tall side so the the you don't have four to falcon anymore what's the allah what do you think think for a second is this kosher or not if they were flat they're puzzled so i want to make i want to go like this unflat unflatten them now they're standing up they're not for talking is there something wrong with that on the one hand you could say that it's possible at the end of the day because it was light as possible so just because you flipped it over maybe it's like a piece of metal you can't flip a piece of metal this way that way so we have them here of course they went to visit him the two who say that it's kosher went to visit rev on malay i thought today about what happens when you flip the staff on the side all right he says apostle like not like you guys but like ravuna and he explains to them because these pieces of are like pieces of metal that are puzzled it doesn't matter if you flip them or not nothing has changed what would you tell your friend if the daughter of nothing said like you yeah i told you so much i told you he's going to say like me why do you bother asking him like if you were to explain it to us like he did we would have asked him did you ask me for a reason you just asked me a lot i told you the bottom line is it's interesting because i'm pretty sure this woman sent me an email right before i got here she said she wanted to understand why is it that in a different suggy it's these people i'm pretty sure and rav right now was in charge of the sook of the regulator and he took them and he put them in the sukkah that had sachin down low she wanted to know that's not nice to do if and she said she let me client's example she said i i drink call of duty swell my friends have never offered me hall of fame why would you do that that was your shiloh the answer at a different time not here rabbi said thank you so much for joining beijer hashem you shalom you