Daf Yomi Succah Daf 13 by R’ Eli Stefansky

today's show is being sponsored by adam labato they're foolishly of my father double queen ben miriam who's just received some difficult news and needs a kajibar who's nissan and by arie bloom says sally that available to the corbin was winding down yesterday morning my mother's family's available continue with the laws of my zaydi al-asham giving his love for learning i'm reading this because arie bloom is a very big part of the daf and he's a big writer and he spends a lot of time writing for ora mercaz so i'm going to read this and also because his grandfather is very very into the he is love for learning i can think of nothing better than sponsoring today's share an eight-minute clip as an a leader for the shama apart from his family nothing came before his death yamiche he enjoyed many of the finer things in life but his greatest pleasure was to discuss the sugi and that is daf i've been in share with him once before i can testify that he's never happy until he's fully comfortable with the shot in the gemara you would never admit but why was he finished so many times these last weeks when it was too weak to keep up with the daffy switch to learning you shall meet with my uncle kids are you left behind the beautiful mizpah children's grandchildren great grandchildren all proud champion mitzvahs maybe emails you are dear this guy goes up says the in the booth yeah no it's uh i know what it is this one is for you sadiq i don't have it here whatever maybe you'll bring it up soon bye or eastern you hear or you know where you stern yeah ah i joined this year a few weeks ago at the end of your month to say i haven't learned the 40 years wouldn't be true i'm only 36 and i work for the mirror however the gishmaka have listening to the shirt is a geshmak that is too real to describe my whole day has become daffy me i start with listening to sheer and then i listen to khazarshi which i would love if you did every day i also find others who learned of you me and ask them questions and talk them in learning it's mamish made a new me i leave you shall i aim and try to zoom in the mornings but if not sometimes because of my job i don't go to sleep at 3 a.m listen right when it goes online i zoom in with the shabbos but i hope to start coming to base the chemist to hear it live hopefully someone could save me a seat how to introduce me in person thanks so much for everything i have a great travis uri ps i'm not a good writer leave that to nachman is there any way to call you a voice note as sometimes i need clarity from things that were mentioned this year that would be a lot easier and clearer uri stern no comment the yeah you can email questions noam is going to take those questions the parents achieve michael bamela the memory of his mother dwyer feigl bashmul and father-in-law mendoza to make it to uman this year this is my fourth year in the last 20 hours and i'm full of quickest i'm mama's bringing it up about to fly to america and i'm asking you to please daven i think she goes smoothly in terms of the sheer avi madam says like this i have to say for the first 30 plus years of my life i don't think i ever fully appreciated the loss of a migration it simply didn't work for me i couldn't feel the connection and therefore the loss of a building destroyed nearly 2000 years ago it goes on and on today after almost three months of yuma learning all about the base i mean there's the k limited replacement orientation today's keynes took on a greater meaning for me i was able to understand many of the keynote is much better this morning than ever before you often comment that learning the deaf will make you a better husband better father better this and better that today learning the deaf has 100 percent make me a better jew as i go over some of the keynotes with my daughters a better father thank you maybe may this be the last time we fast tish above all maine today's daf is david gimmel we're holding on the top omar have hanan by rovo honey hizme this stuff maybe just for illustrative purposes you could use this as high we're a little bit more familiar thorns thorne bush you can use this as ha says you could use this since the leaves keep on falling down says rashi constantly is a constant bombardment of leaves shabbat glove and norfolk once again we have the sparta we started off the almond the top words on the summit that we finished off in the morning or yesterday if you're watching if it has a terrible foul odor you can't use it as khakis and over here this is also going to chase you out of the circle because it's very uncomfortable to sit there while this thing is hitting you in the head it's mashma though i believe the ritual says this that it would be okay to put this on the wall he doesn't say the other thing but i'm assuming what he means to say is that you cannot put this stuff shwatsare on the wall ushushei because the smell is the smell what's the difference but this since it's about falling into your head into your soup so this is the problem according to abbay rav not exactly sure but i found the picture here this might do the job for us it's not the greatest picture but this is towards the bottom of the decal somebody chopped down the palm tree and if you look over here there's a lot of offshoots imagine you take this whole piece the whole circle with the offshoots somebody wants a thing the sigmar is saying that there might be a problem here that it's egged you're you're putting a bundle of wood on your sucker look here one piece two piece three pieces four piece they're all connected with this this is a nice giant rope or whatever you want to call it attaching them all so maybe it's also maybe it's putting a bundle of scrap on your sukkah and why is that not a problem because it happened with ishmael you didn't do it there's no zeras oyster over here avocado even though it's all tied together what's all prep the problem is that you might come to use your storehouse for sokka you might have a bundle on your shoulder you might want to dry it out that's that's not a concern when it's where who made this egghead not you avagov the hodar even though at a further time he went now look at this rashi explains because these guys are difficult for stuff they go upwards they drain this way that way they're not good stuff so you want to tie them down and and create a sachet of them so even though you're tying it i have to hold their one item you can't tie down one item it's already tied at the source you can't go ahead and tie it more you're not going to gain anything tying your own hair is not tying it's already attached to your head so you're going to tie it over there great you did another knot but it's already there what you're the back of your head it doesn't matter how many times you use the trunk so hello so the hasidim want to say over here that claudius troll is one clyde israel is one of sharma with a lot of goofing so mela there's no there's no need to get them together we're all one no matter who we are and where we are we're all one yeah they don't really say it i said all right again the same exact again just this time it's on on on reeds canes anything that has offshoots you could use it as even though the source brings together other stuff let me ask here here's a great example if you have a branch you have a bunch of other things coming off the branch so there's that branch of egg it's my i get all the options no everybody understands it's one piece that has a lot of offshoots so it doesn't matter if you tie it or you don't tie it again again again same idea if the reed holds together a bunch of other offshoots since it's it's not a problem i've got the other glue and even if you're going to go and take all the offshoots and tie those down it's too late already already tied it down again same idea you have the read and you have the offshoots khan and cheetah so you can read it two ways connim vidukranam two separate house two things happened there either he's using the reeds or he's using the offshoots of the reeds conor mcshit of course you use reeds that's bamboo everybody in the olden days that's what everybody used says the gemara emo economy sheldon chronium it's not conor vidukranim it's not with avov it means to say khan himself on him that if you have a reed that has offshoots like we're talking up until now miss akrumbem just because it holds everything together it doesn't mean that it's again it's a problem going to murder now flying into pesach you have murder what kind of murder lettuce now if you were with us during you know because i'm you know the big litvak here i had to mention a hundred times during sakhan that the best murder is romaine lettuce not the horseradish and then all the hasidim wrote in yeah they also used lettuce but they also used horseradish because in the high end they didn't have lettuce and they became a minute to use but the mission says that you're supposed to use lettuce romaine lettuce first okay fine but i had to stick it in of course so how do we reach that guy brings lettuce from the agam from the swamp what kind of lettuce is it it's not romaine and it's not the other types of lettuce iceberg it's agam lettuce it's the swamp lettuce you can use it for pesach fermata oh there is a how could you use it for peso azov valois of the oven now there are a bunch of azov's in the torah i left my asif at home by the door what yeah why are you sure yeah why would he say yeah so does anybody have an english art school here it says jovano what see we go by the art scroll but the funny thing is the oven yeah sometimes the english my flight is in english in hebrew okay it doesn't yang doesn't fit in here i don't know why they did that i mean they know what to talk about also okay listen it's not important the point the point is that it has another name okay it's called the azav yavan or in the hebrew arsenal and the mesifta says yavan in my gemara with the nakuda says which we don't really rely on that much but okay i bet you it comes from the word yavan it's just called yang it's the same maybe it's the same okay there's a there's a plant that's called the z okay great the point is that the tire says you should bring it azov i don't know okay the new guys don't know but i i had one i made a zip and i sprinkled it and i hit rabby schoenberg by mistake in the face instead of hitting so the azov that you use for to burn the para duma you use it the famous one is to be matar a tame somebody that touched the corpse you dunk it into the water of the eighth paradouma and you sprinkle we did a whole demonstration and then you have it for the masara and you have it we mentioned today this morning by the carbon paste of the first carbon peso you have the azo don't use any azov that has some shame levi that has a nickname you must use the original laser liaison villains of cochlear villain because the bottom line is anything that has another name a double name don't use it so melawad so over here how can you use this mirror that's called lettuce of the swamp it should be completely possible so the vehicle has a beautiful cash i mean there's five marauders in the mishnah one of those horseradish all these are shimla valleys no it says in the toyota like you're supposed to see mara yet there's five different types they're all okay fine anyone that had a name change before matantara and the entire comes along and says use azov do not use ace of royami do not use ace of yellow dude [Applause] this lettuce of the agam that was its name before matanthara it's all included in mario when the target says it meant that also it's not it's not another name that is it that's part of it there's romaine lettuce and this again lettuce and that's all when the tortilla was written that's what it meant it was in existence in those days robert hani miriso mario is playing the hyde carlo in other words this this agamar is plain old murderer you wanna what do you call it when you go to the store say give me a bag of murder so why did he call it the agamura he's just saying you know i want to be i want to speak be specific i'm telling you it's the murderer that that you find in the album that's not its name the real name is mara and melo fits in no no no no that is what in the dictionary it's called the isaiah in the dictionary it is called martyr it's how people relate to it if you want to be more descriptive you're going to say the one of the the swamp but otherwise you say mar that's what robert said omar i don't believe you until you show it to me inside gosh here it goes thank you everybody again again so if you take one one azov one piece of kavilah you take one bamboo and you you wrap it around with a string that's not considered tying it up shall i schmidt that is a big problem they discuss every discuss because i mentioned earlier today when it comes to the villa in the mishnah how much does this bring me there's 25. oh all of a sudden now the quarter says three is enough so either the ishmael is beholding the bible in xiaomi or they have other roots if you take two pieces and you tie them together is it or isn't it considered tying something together so when you when you take the azo for the mekatos this is in order to purify something that's tommy the mitzvah is with three clock three kloka means three roots you have to like you literally rip out the azalea from the ground uber ham and in each one of the roots slowly should get valium total okay this is what rashi says not in each one three but all together three give islam in other words in the center of the clachem in center of this root there's one piece that comes out so you have a total of three giveailum the three center pieces and that you have all the all the azo stuff on it [Music] cause revision says that if i'm using this and i'm sprinkling you know what what happens when you go like this over and over another person that went to the lavalier another you have a value of a hundred thousand people have to go like eventually it's gonna break off something's gonna break and you're gonna be left with two so it two is enough two is enough if you start out with three and you're left with two two is enough can you start out with two i don't know maybe we got doom of culture and the stub as long as you have a little bit of a stub you're good in other words the two and they're made out of stubs you have a cold shoe kosoka diet and so we had to have amino medicine maybe says if you start out with three and you end up with two that's good enough so maybe you could start out with two why do you have to start out with three in order to get the two ah the height and slowly limit the reason why it says slightly not because you have to have three it's not a cube it's good to start with three and if you end up with two it's also good and if you start out with two it's also good so why three because it's a special mints what exactly is obviously everybody says that three is a mitzvah you don't have to start out with three but so how i'm saying no three is market okay so we have a little bit of machaekis is it seems like you have to start with three before she says you have to start with three you can't start with two when i say you have to start off with three okay so not such a big problem we got the names mixed up we'll flip the names but the bottom line is we have a macholicus isolation ocular bundesliga mitzvah it's the opposite see who says you need to start over three and it's making robots say you don't you don't need to start with three the only reason we say three is a special midsole but you could also start off with two and that's the shiloh here is that considered the exit or not we're tying together three we're tying together two tanya you start out with two and then you're left over with one it's okay so that's very possible it's only possible when you start out with one and you left over with one as the gemara apostle harmon we just said that if you left over with juan after you've done everything you're good so why are you saying that if you start out with if you end off with one that is apostle you're not apostle says and this is interesting the only time when you start out as puzzle is like if you end up with one and if you end up with one you're kosher it doesn't mean that it's kosher means just like the number one at the end is kosher so when you start out with one it's possible a little bit of play with words when you start out with one like in a case that you end up with one but not the same when you end up with one it's okay so when you start out with one the same case then it's puzzle no we proved that we had to flip it no we have something that that says the same exact thing as rabbana we we established that robot review has to be we just turned it off you'd give one pays sponsored by the md white healing group for all those who need shidduchim refusing shoes please join them.com okay bustos you have these bundles of reeds they come in a bundle misakimbo now what about the problem of caviles moira is kabil kashm all these things here you have a bundle even though they are tied with them the the person never had intent for an outsider he's not storing it the reason why it's in a bundle like we do today you buy a a dozen eggs it comes in a certain carton you buy a certain amount of thing it comes tied whatever it is toothpicks come in a certain 200 of these it's 25 of these it's just to give you a number it's not it's not for you to store it mma low since it's not for storage you're allowed to use it for scar there's no zero sightseer here omera vabo and it's rifa durbin so you have a hut made out of aravis willow and the top has a knot and on the bottom you have they tied together says the gemaro even true to roshi madam shalom if you undo the top right over here then it's kosher but at the end of the day it's still tied says papa the character it's talking about that he undid the bottom also ravuna beretra anytime you tie something together but it's not made to carry you're not tying it together to carry that's not considered tying a bundle so the see them want to say over here i like that one i like that one i'm not going to see this you're right so look at them say oh yeah it's stuff here we we have to say something right i'm going to america any any time you have a a relationship with somebody an egg end but you're not willing to carry the burden it's not a relationship in other words like this stop being so serious oh yeah you know when when you're in a relationship with somebody you have to put up with their son with their idiosyncrasies with their with their mission everybody in other words everybody has them in chicas so the way to have a good relationship with the other person is to put up with them so there's a story nice to show you there's a guy that was famous for having an unbelievable shoulders unbelievable he's 70 years old he lived his whole life 50 years of the same woman and so the king went to visit this guy and he wanted to see the the secrets of the shalom bayes so the king knocks on the door the guy welcomes him in he's very excited a guest and he tells the old man tells his old wife he says listen go go get a watermelon for the guest so she goes she goes down to the to the storehouse and she schleps a watermelon takes her like 10 minutes to get back massive watermelon and the seven-year-old takes the watermelon goes he gives it a zest and he listens closely to here no we have a guest here what if no another one she claps the watermelon she goes comes back all schvitzing and everything takes the watermelon second time gives a whack no we have a guest come on third time he's he gives a whack he says this is a good one fine so the king says listen i heard rabid that you're you shall be says unbelievable what's the secret she says you want to know the secret come with me to the storehouse but before we go there you need to tell me you have to guess wild guess how many watermelons do i have in my storehouse so the king says well at least another two he says okay fine so they go to the storehouse the warehouse and they open up the door king can't believe it there's zero watermelons in there she says you see my wife knows my mishigas every time i have a guest i play this game she comes she brings a watermelon go boom boom not good good and she goes with it she rolls with it so oh that's the side if you can roll with me how does it fit into the words i have no idea again if you have a relationship if you have a relationship and you can't carry the burdens the the the other zach and the shigasen it's not it's not a good relationship okay he's laughing away i want you to remember me like that i want you to work on our relationship dude you have to put up with my stuff how do you give something good in the middle of a suggest of and and then this kind of scar and that kind of you come up with something better now get over here get over there get over here okay nether i won't say that story as long as okay you know i think you should get up there and say the story about the train listen the darlings is they're coming from minha they don't need to hear the story it's one of the worst stories ever okay fine says no matter what i love you still and that's why you sit right over here today yesterday last week same idea as this picture it it's so polished that the koala doesn't even have a picture for it it goes like this we learned that if you have a beam and it's further away from this i'm from new york so this so a garbage bag is where they disposed of body parts in new york the mafia so there's a maze in this garbage bag i guess the guy that drew this also is from new york he didn't put like a dead person that's not nice i guess okay fine there's a mason here if this is further away from the mace one teva this is going to shield the tomah from hitting this cli a and b the klee that's next to it is going to become tommy because the tumor roams now pretend that this picture is a sukkah here that of the sukkah and on top are vegetables mara the guy comes and brings a bunch of lettuce uses lettuce now lettuce is very thin it's going to disappear when by the time sukis is over it's gone and we're going to learn this anytime you know that the scock is going to dry out and go bye-bye it's as if it was never there even for one minute even the first day of sukkos when it's nice and moist it's not therefore so if this beam just pretend this beam is a piece of lettuce it will create tumor down below everything becomes in other words it's a good beam and then all of a sudden it says now this is almost a contradiction it doesn't provide a shield to thomas goes right through it why not if it's a beam it should provide a shield so the answer is that midday risa it's good it's a good shield so it may law if it's a good shield the toma goes down here but there are but on with the rabbit they said it's not good and therefore it's not a shield so they were making they said this should also become dummy here's a big finish we don't have to remember this so much now we're going to learn about it later but it goes it's very simple if you leave an empty space a void in your sock is gone in the middle if you put apostle zach in there then it's not three then it's fourth falcon and if it's on the side of the sukkah it's four am is why but without all those allah's if you have a bunch of murder you threw up on top of your sukkah we it acts as ear it doesn't act as possible even though you're saying it's it's food now it's possible with three talking because three problems as if it's not there and you have a skylight that's three tracking and it passes the sukkah my timer what's the reason awfully since we're dealing with vegetables they're going to dry up and dry up in the sun and they're going to fall down come on the listener dummy so right now i'm max of it i consider it as complete air and ear passes with three we're going into the beautiful sugiya of yadus the word sounds scary but it's actually not i left the other prop at home unfortunately but i have this hashem i have this this is what we call a yada handle it's beautiful a guy wants to eat a pookie you ever went to great america 10 years ago i went maybe not 30 years ago when it was only for from people on pesach no but i went when there's none from people so they they eat yeah whatever they eat this massive turkey pokey like in like like i don't know a sugar or something like they're all walking around like this at the yacht and they eat this thing it's gross shanky boy fine huh yeah i was thinking this is a cave thing yeah so this is a yacht now what does that do a lot of items have a god and the truth is that food is macabre tomo but a handle should not be macabre tomo it's not food but if you need the handle for the food you're in great america you're in one of great america is one of these amusement parks in america like this anywhere so if you know whatever you are you you're at a shabbos table and this is how you eat you're poking so you need the handle you need the handle the handle is part of the food and it's makable tumor like the food also bring if the tumor touches here the tumor will go over here if the tumor touches here it'll go over there it becomes like food even though you're never going to eat this bone now an hour surging we're talking about schaff so you have a boycott of gas you are harvesting grapes and grapes we know come with those what are they called stalks nah has to have a better word all these branches these little baby branches stalks vine no it's a cluster of grapes what attaches one grape to the other stems are that's better than these english guys with their ah okay very good he has a yacht on the spot la maison garrison is paying attention that's stickier fine wow who's that guy on the screen oh it's wow okay is that the the reverse i heard myself from that was said by rabbit friend this tisha bob he said that there was a guy that was nifter and somebody just went to simple or something i just heard a second hand so i'm missing the details so don't even bother sending me the email because i get it but the point of the story is like this some reason if there's somebody who went to like a sim card or something and all of a sudden he sees the nifter walking around obviously it's not the nifter because the lifter was lifter it's the twin of the nifter so he says wait a minute who are you i'm the twin but yeah but you never had a beard your brother had a beard he says no ever since my brother was lifter i wanted to remember my brother so i grew a beard and every time i look in the mirror i remember my brother your father knows his stuff he knows his stuff yes he said it was one of the most amazing vices no that the the it's a serious thing a person grew a beard i'm not gonna do that he grew a beard so that when he looks in the mirror she remembers his brother it's unbelievable i'm going to start calling you basie or something my little christmas basically whatever [Music] how so if he harvests his grapes and he has all these stems on it ain't no yo doings these you don't need a stem for grapes why if i'm making grape juice or wine i'm making wine do i want those stems absolutely not the more stems i have the worse it is so since i don't want it i don't it's not part of my grape over here i want it so tiad so that's all of my grapes so let's remember ravuna says only buy grapes what about wheat i don't know no he says if he cuts off a stalk of wheat ain't lo why because the kernels are not good for their food so all i want is the bottom part so i don't want the two things connected to culture the one who says when it has to do with wheat koshkin bites it of course he doesn't want the stems or what did the english people call it the whatever the le nicole the lentil comrade because it's gonna ruin the wine but mandomer bites his shameless dies but the one that said by grace this allah applies avocados but by grain you do want them to attach why the nichole the sacramento what is it called the stalk the shaft we're gonna the sheath it's gonna fly away in the wind so you need you need that weight to be there and that's why i want it attached and therefore if i want it attached it becomes automatically becomes a yad says the gemara name of the rabbination perhaps this is if you have thick branches and on the thick branches you have figs these stems then you have grapes cashew beems and you have the weed together with the kernels you know that whole thing i i said this a few times already there's a guy here in bachelors that trains dogs german shepherds to smell the bugs in the day trees and these dogs cost a hundred thousand dollars why because dates each tree produces i forgot between five and fifteen thousand dollars worth of dates a season so when you have one of those much better and on the bottom tons of dates very very valuable if the the non-essential parts of the date tree the wood if that's derived then it's kosher scott from la psula then once again you have a lot of dates and dates our food and foods it's no good for you so he sticks in here yada is in other words rashid explains when you're talking about yada's and we're talking about the macbeth what's the the part that's closest to the fruit that's the ad and he says that yad is also puzzle for for for for you can't use the yad preschool you have to have roive in addition to the ad and in addition to the food in other words the food and the ad go together here this goes together these two things go together and all the soil stuff the branches and the leaves and that has to be more than this in other words the ad this puzzle force we [Music] we can't get out of saying that according to abba who says that by wheat it does have a yad that this is however the national commander is going to explain according to him we don't know we're not forced to say this is mahogany you could say if you cut the wheat and you have intent for then the the kernels are not part of what happened was that at first he didn't want to do when he harvested wheat he had zero intent for he said i want to make money off this i want to make bread out of it so isla means he wants the kernels later on he decided he wants to use it and we're going to flip it into the others as the what happened was he decided to flip it into scraff and when you flip it into you're taking away the original makshava what he starts out he starts harvesting the sweet for food but then in his mind he did a flipparoo he changed it why can't he change it he went from food he made it into is that okay could you change something in your head no who said yes why how could you so i'm gonna prove to you wrong it was a trick question sorry shout outs okay you threw me there now i have to trust you and then you got out of it okay great i'm gonna look it up you could make maybe this is what you mean you can make a clea tummy just by thinking that it is that it's done you have a clay you're not sure is it finished not finished with your mind you say i'm done with it this the minute the moment do you decide that you're done it becomes a clique like over here we have food he harvests the grain for food so it's macabre because it's food in order to flip it and make it into sacha it's not me the only thing you can do is change it physically and think about goes on just two more lines to take action and change something it's so strong that even if you took action beforehand it will undo that action but certainly it'll undo a thought just a thought to say that it went from food to enemy does nothing zero and the story will stay it will stop here in the middle of a suggest i have a wonderful day baser hashem next year is live from new york the five towns 1pm tomorrow here is going to be on the screen at the same time 7 15 shockers before shotguns after but because i'm in new york i always go overboard 8 20 and this year you should no just keep me up by the way you could do that no a little bit five percent seven percent it sounds like you