Daf Yomi Succah Daf 12 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning i don't know what that is but zoom is on leash massive mirrors sponsored by joel for my daughter born zion of to be named tomorrow well sh they already named her what's the name the baby's name is amir leo but she's already bringing joy to her family community thanks to rabbi barachar binowitz rabi zusha kunin and shout out to dave hagal dave hagal shout out and also this is an amazing sponsorship by mordechaim karen engagement of historic mayor catch who happens to be my nephew so my nephew got engaged to a family from los angeles and they happened to be part of the duffs it's amazing javi gravitzky oh that's the name of the girl but karen is not the father okay i get it engagement role may catch up we accept engagement notices gevaldic listen to this so first of all here's a picture you know i don't have the picture of joel because i showed it yesterday joel's learning in labor and delivery it's unbelievable joel is a very famous writer who does he write for today breitbart he writes for breitbart and this is his daughter i showed the picture yesterday so mazel tov to them this is an amazing simcoe here is david geldman from dallas making his first seal ever i'm aseptis brocas they did with us so david um of these emails they get better and better so i'm going to read these three and then i got another three that are even more interesting this is from hanan aschendorf di vraveli as we all know there's one cannot learn toyota on tish above i never really understood or felt how this is a sign of available if anything we should be learning on tishaw of the show hashem that we miss having the bass amigdos finally this year i understood the answer for one of the first times i found myself missing the ability to learn torah i missed the ability to start my week by opening my gemara and doing the dive and hearing good morning rabbi say ah in that moment i understood that the reason why we don't learn that i understood the reason why we don't learn on tishoba i learned that once one begins to get the true enjoyment of having a consistent dose of every day of learning torah the one day you aren't allowed to learn you miss it and feel a little sad about it maybe that feeling that i had was a microscopic feeling of how we're supposed to feel about missing the bassan mcdosh and i have the daf and you to thank for that thank you for helping me feel that the way i felt this dish above your talmud like joel wall something like that watch the meaningful minute today one thing struck me big time and i knew i had to start watching ellie sheeran maybe committing to the daf he said he forgets his learning i too am reasonably bright guy that enjoys learning yet yet it bothers me terribly that my memory doesn't do that great with remembering learning i'm in p.s you hear this tell me if this is appropriate to say yes p.s and as a joke as a joke i said the same thing about srili bornstein very handsome very successful big maggot cheer his wife must be the worst witch ever i mean a man can have it all right hi elsie lieberman derek belly this is jessie clearman emailing you from allow flight 004 over the atlantic we plan we are on our way towards this role of our son hashem on wednesday in bat ayan i plan to come by for tuesday morning's dayshare but was informed that you're on the way to the u.s for your sons hassan this week i am disappointed to be missing you but very happy for you in the family mazel tov mazel tov your information your sheer is rocking there's a great buzz in the gas about the sheer you are adding the appropriate amount of tavlin into the toro gevalde best regards yossi yes i am leaving if you haven't heard i'm leaving tonight i'm giving one more share the fourth year in 23 hours tonight at 6 30ish i think i hope it works out tomorrow's daf uh but you could come here to the basement and watch it on these screens i will be live in the screen i do want to give it tremendous ishikaya uh yeah i'm giving it 6 30 here here but it's tomorrow's death okay at four in the morning i texted him i said you're gonna go to sleep he said i still have one more shear to edit and go so here he is he's here in the basement without sleeping i actually got a few minutes of sleep so i'm not in the same boat as he is and here we go raboissai today is daf yud baze oh i must open this up it feels like a book it's a thick book by michael cohen to avi kamianski okay i'm opening it up this better be good better not be like a naked seltzer book or anything hold on hold on oh the original daiva de leo let's open it up repairing the damage safer laws of la shinjaro what is the ah is that like is this part of it if i was him this is what i would do i just give me an empty empty book with zero in it like nothing just the okay fine gavalic look at this you need to hire this guy for your books your books are like okay fine yeah all right beautiful beautiful ah basic shame coming to the bookstore next oh i'm supposed to read it the circus ran away to join me i scoured a 99 on my first deer shoe test after just one week in the garden once i lost the scorpion in my house and it stung me in the middle of the night after five days of excruciating pain the scorpion finally died they didn't come to me for brokers but she's looking for the children i declined hosting to see masha's met life out of fear that the crowd would think mashiach has arrived my hair is registered with israel's landmark office on shabbos mornings harrying swim to my house to get a taste of me one time eventually looked at my face and all of his typists were cured except his new obsession with me why oh i once put a black hat on on and proclaimed that it was not worthy this is the book rabbi said you should all read it okay zack cloud called dovers from mccann after all that leads on us the final final day before i go to my son's hassan in america and by the way it's gonna be tough it's go what time is it is it 25 or 29 i don't get it it's not fun i really my family's already there for like a week for me to go is there's a lot of anxiety anxiety's not a good word but this is what am i going to do this traveling you have to prepare you have to go you have to come the flight whatever i'll call you i need felix from the seaboard is that a clown donuts what about donuts it's not that it's going from place to place okay you prepare shear once and we'll talk on the way to russia zara cloud called whichever tumor mino honey mili how do we know that cannot be the mist the cloud will come out of the ground so what does this have to do with the sucker so what if it says in the positive eight galamonariats rashi says because it says an apostle shafty and the targum says rashi says rashi sticks in above not sure why but i looked inside it says that the the sukhoi shafty is referring to the clouds it's not talking about a physical structure it's talking about ananya cover once we know that it's talking about the mother says [Music] that's great if you say that the clouds that the sukkot was a cloud the hidalgo asks why is it that we have a zeker for the clouds and not a secret for the man not a zechar for the bear miriam only the clouds no very simple answer he says you see the difference what so he says much better he says the water and the bread we asked for hashem gave it to us so we don't make this we didn't even ask for hashem gave us the protection from the sun and from the elements so it's a much bigger hazard we don't ask for it's a much bigger question anyway [Music] but according to the the whole swear is because it's a cloud and cloud is not a capotoma but if it was made out of it was just a regular sukkot maybe it was made out of things that are makable toma like the highs of the the animals or whatever the signing is so here is a very famous caster from the village this is a beautiful varnish why is it that we celebrate sukkos on sukkahs if it's for the nannyakavoid and nanyakov it started in nissan when klaus walked out of the mid bar poof there's so let's celebrate it when it started what happened why sukkas can anybody come up with a shot and he says beautifully he says that covet only lasted for a very short time in the beginning so but they came back when did they come back and he goes through a heisman when they came back it came back when maestro avenue came down from harsinai on tessevov he says he came back on yom kippur sorry he came back on yom kippur and he started collecting money and it took him two days so on the 14th he said stop bringing money and on the 15 they started making the mishka they started building mission that is the day that the akavi came back on the day they started building the mishkan and therefore we commemorate it on the day that it lasted for a very long time that was when it came for for a long time and mela it comes out on sukkah it's [Music] an animal you want to think of an animal or something that grows from the ground but like mario calls it gedulim in ours because it eats and benefits off the ground that only grows and nourishes off the ground must be something that's tumor like a carbohydrate and it grows off the ground says rashi but we don't really go with this we don't use animals why not because it's not geduli minarets it's melarets it's not like a like like uh trees and grasses and things like that are menards it's from the ground so mellow it's not the same doesn't have the same kind of properties as trees and therefore we only use that kind of stuff so maybe you should use live live animals like so we had this plastic yesterday you remember this pasta this is the pasta is we're not talking about that we're going down here when you gather your garage and your wheat and your grapes says the gemara it's the soilless it's the leftover of your wheat the leftovery grapes the vines the the pits not the actual grapes not not the actual garden the straw that falls off maybe you should use wheat and grapes wine or zero yuck effects of the sacrifice how are you gonna make a wine it's a liquid again the gain says something very interesting he says that this passing don't use wheat and bread don't use wine how do you make a pseudo you make sudo out of wine and bread the tires telling us don't use that stuff i want you to use the leftover i don't want you to sit in the sun which is where where everything that grows in this world comes from the sun we need the sun i want you to stay out of the sun that's ambassadors this is the going because it's a hint to us that we should stay away from the gas measures because we're almost telling us this is i want you to connect the torah make your lemonade keva and stay away from the wine and from the from the wheat from the from the from the bread stay away from the sun that grows everything i want you to be porous from all that the leftover stuff in other words the torah oh but the mars cache of a guri and asked me if i could actually asking maybe you should use wine but what's the point of the question the point of cash is because wine is in kabul it's already it's already a food bread is in kabul it's a food no you you can't beat the wine itself it has to be the leftover parts of the wine masculine oh there's a type of wine that you could use as ha there's a place called sneer and over there they have congealed wine should i melee ghoulies they're like fig cakes okay maybe it's that um zero hamilton we had a good plastic up until now vassar beer mushroom argo reviewer comes along threw a axe into it he ruined it for us it's a good car i don't know i know i know that's the shot the toy says in the video we're all on the bottom he says i know the chat is good i just don't know how to answer it i have a i have a kabbalah that this is the chat this is the poster this is how we learn you ask me oh but there's a place near that i could maybe have to go all the way this near and grab congealed wine then i don't know how to answer it the meme is what teaches us it's not the wine itself it's not the weed itself it's not the kernels but it's the byproduct the straw the pits all that stuff another apostle go out and bring some leaves from the from the from the olive tree by ali h shem and valiadas valet marim eights of us so it says and it says at the end valet ates avoids as the gemara no hadas hanu i know eight zombies aren't they the same it's the same tree it's a little different is the same tree but it's a different type of product if they don't they have three three leaves but one is lower than the other it's a shaitan so if it's a shayta it's possible for hadassim so what do you do with it you use it for your so here's a question in the roshanim so is it a separate specie because it's hadashota and if it is i'll prove to you that it is because the turret says it twice tara says adas it's a voice and it says adas seems like it's two separate things so what's the shiloh you know they're people that use three adasam and then they lay it on they put another 20. those extra 17 whatever it is do they have to be kosher or they could be had to ask them to since our i was ready to become the message with the three it says big enough i'm not just saying this this is a much like them some you shouldn't hold but since the gemara says that as it uses to confirm it so it's another min and it's of another man then there's a history of baltisov you know how to use another man so it's not anna it's not a zekely van veyo you're using the min shaita is from the same tree so what the gemara says it comes from sukim you're not doing a mitzvah by adding hadas and schweitem you have to be very careful that when you add your adaptive you want to add extra great it's a caleb but make sure that it's real hadas and not had that shitty according to those who tried them some resharing them argue says the helium mission of the official mission sponsored by official cavilay what does a havila mean a bundle what is a bundle so tyson seems to say that a bundle is 25. there's no bundle less than 25 other china maybe three we're going to go with 25. different types of wood some you can feed to the animal not but straw wood but they're a bundle a miss sacrament you cannot use them as cool however if you open up the bundles you let it go cherise so shita so let me ask you if it's so passionate who said cheetah also you okay do you have to lift it up we said by by the grapes if you put a vine on top of a sukkot according to rav even after you snip it you have to lift it do you have to lift this this is snipping you say what you don't have to what do you say so maybe that's the dish no you don't have to the mishna says the hulan hearing sharers and you don't have to lift it why because it's just we'll see it's like zero more than anything it's a cautious zero the cooldown is good for noise if you're gonna take ha what the funniest well not everybody knows this so we have to repeat this over and over and i said it before and i'm going to say it again people think that asuka is the walls the mission is telling us the suk is not the walls the halachas in the walls and we learned vasuko is basuki's and we learned about the walls even though the word sukkah does not mean wall suki means the the ceiling so if i take the bundles and i put them in the walls it's kosher that's passion now now that we know that it's very positive but we have to know that aloha not everybody before you learn masuka knows that the walls don't have the same halacha as this you can make walls out of things that are kabutoma you can make things bundles okay it's confusing because somebody big time will call him in the neighborhood okay he's not in the doubt but he came to ask me so i understand that hold then we're learning such means how are you learning dresses for the walls the whole thing back and forth bottom line is you could use it for the wall entirety i heard two hours i learned this aloha of bundles we spoke about this last night this is the classic example i don't want to give it away but this is a classic example of task of elimination you have already a wall and ceiling you have this already in place and then you come and you dig out a void so it's puzzle this why because it's hazardous to but we don't know that yet let's pretend we don't know that allah we know that this is us we don't know why i learned from the bundle of bundles this is apostle one reason is that in those days they used to have well today also a lot of people in the backyard that had a storage shed full of their wheat or whatever they had a store and we're concerned that you have to put your sach up for what so if i put my wheat over there because i want to store it and then i say you know what i don't have a good sucker why should i spend all my time building this whole sukkah let me go to my storage facility it's all it's laid out nicely on this on the ceiling from side to side the beautiful even rain can't even get in there i'll just go in there and make a sukkot beautiful xericites is possible but it's a zero you might go into the izer which means we're talking about it now the point is that both of these things you could apply to both you could have xeris oyster on a goddess on a pile of wheat because here i put it down at the store and now i'm going to use it and i can use the passive element also on bundles i have a bundle that's possible and then i undo it so i took something it was on top of my circle when it was bipso and i i did an action to make it kosher and that's not good you have to put it on top of the sukkot when it's in a state of castros you can't put it on top of this when it's possible and then make it kosher which one is it which one goes where or maybe even maybe that's why it's not so positive says revere me oh let's figure it out ourselves oh it happens when people have their bundle on their shoulder um the option he puts it on top he has like a pergola he puts it on top to dry it out he has ahsoka what kind of sukkah says rashi limbic for his first bahamas this is not a regular sukkah for sukkas like we call sokka this is a hut for animals this is if you stop here and you didn't come to sheer you might get confused for a second rebecca just said it's this is the right song no is it how did he say it because he says if you put it on the sukkah la shem drying out that's it but went one step further and said anytime you have a bundle on your thing it's possible why because of xero so rebecca in fact is saying that our mission is that the rabbana you hear first time i read it i got all confused until you're looking around again sometimes the person's going to come from the field they're going to put on top of the sukkot that's terrible elimination which is their iso but that's not the point we have to go one step further which doesn't mention what do you mean no no no it's not your over iser you're going to get malcolus the point is that if you use it as a sukkah you're midday right you're not you're not middarabanan the tires said you're not yatsu so you have to put it on the shemsuko exactly and since you didn't it is possum of the raiso even if you undo it now if it's possible to raise though you might be able to lift it up and put it down and then it's okay with the rabbana you wouldn't may the hobbies are inside sir so now that i know that have a and the kumar continues now that i know that putting on bundles of tabi sukha is only the rabbana i mean the homies from zay rasoi it's only the abundant of xero ha the other case of gaddish is this case is the director and it's also for tassel lemonasso so if it's awesome that's illegal all i need to do is pick it up and then it becomes kosher but by having it might not work so it's beautiful you have a beauty you have a foolish or a boyfriend who says that bundles are the rabban on zero and goddess is the raisa so what's what's the shadow of a cloud he never heard it that's why um [Music] i don't understand and what happened to when you have a pile of straw there's no problem of itar xavier so in other words what kumar is asking is that this right over here should be awesome with the rabbit on and even if you lift it up it should remain awesome it shouldn't help just lifting it up where it says that's the same in the first place you shouldn't use it why the rice is sharper dummy from the mission smashman that middle rice is okay we just turned to that we based on the base wow twelve eleven daff into sukkah sponsored by the mdy the healing group for all those who need shidduchim refusing yeshua's please join if you haven't yet to helium.8minddaff.com so i will basically be in new york tomorrow tomorrow no no no not tomorrow well tomorrow's tuesday correct um today is monday tomorrow tuesday at 1 p.m in the five towns island mutual 8 12 peninsula boulevard where is that in woodmere middle of the day 1 pm at lunch if there's such a thing in america they have lunch break there's gonna be a lot of food come for the food don't come for this year you have to sign up who said okay speak to uh oh and we're going to give the following days down so if you're coming to this year don't expect that days after tuesday that it's the wednesday death so that the guys the folks here and there's a stroll have their daf on time basically the bundles are okay but by the goddess by the pile of wheat the tony in it's not a sugar but you hear this that's that's another shtick they have to stick in there mithirai so you think just by reading this with that rashi whether otherwise it's not a sook at all adaraba it's so not a sukkah that if you lift it up it becomes a sukkah whereas in the rabbana it is a stickle sukkah lifting doesn't really help omar have you done says rav so we know that caleb are makable toma and if you have a kali you cannot use it for so the two types of arrows there's an arrow that you put the arrow head inside the wood so the wood is a receptable so it's in a cava and then you have a wood that's a zucker see the two types so this nikeva wood is actually has a base cable anything that it's like a cup it could hold whatever it is it can hold the arrow so melo this is possible it's a real cleave that's makable toma you cannot use these pieces of wood however this version of the of the arrow not the metal we're not talking about metal there's no metal there you can't put you can't use metal if it has metal it's puzzled without the metal just a piece of wood it doesn't have a receptacle receptacle it cannot receive anything over here it's the metal that receives so therefore this is kosher foreska italy it's a kali what should it create it doesn't have a base cable it can't receive anything and therefore it's kosher for ska what do you ask him no because bamboo wood that has a because it's not made to receive anything so what nobody uses it for that nobody use it for that that's yeah that's not good they drink from it okay so if you do you do then you made it in the glue you're right you say naturally naturally it's it's it's born like that it's created like that this somebody went out of his way and made a made a hole in here not only that he already has the piece of metal on the side he's just didn't fasten it as we're going to see in a second says the gemara zakarian what's a big kiddush it doesn't have a base cable now the same thing exists horizontally these people don't know how to differentiate between squamous and canvas and it's not a joke this man is a big problem come on okay off color jokes you think he's still watching somebody has to write him a letter and tell him uh like give him a little chris says the gemara cave is says i'm a mario they take it out but they gave his soul i mean i understand why they take it out because i think it says cheripshito doesn't say omamara over there omar means oh let's go back we're not going back anywhere we're just going through the words here skyrim is passionate nikkei this is pasha well his position uh based kibala also maloys make kibble again he's making arrows he needs to go to war soon she's going to take these this base keyboard piece of wood he's not just going to leave it he's spending a lot of time in it so what he's going to do he's going to fill it with the metal forever lyla it's going to be full forever so anything that's going to be full forever i would think is not considered a real base keyboard it's not like a bowl of soup he's gonna fill it up with soup but two minutes later it's empty again this is gonna be full forever come ash malone that this is considered a base kebab even though you intend to fill it up you gotta slow down here oh my rabbit [Music] so it goes like this i i'm not saying that this is the perfect picture for this but it gives us some sort of an idea in the time of the time of the gemara at least over here what you don't have you don't have everything here but just understand that to take flax go take these seeds or or this and make it into this right over here a piece of garment takes a lot of steps so one of the steps is you soak it in water not over here not in the picture then you take it and you break it down you you bing it and you break it you take off all these berries and everything you break it see there you have this it's broken then you take a comb and you comb it out and finally you have a very fine thread or whatever and then you make fabric so you have all these steps says the gemara as usual we have the two extremes we we have the extreme of unprocessed at all right over here and then we also have very processed okay this guy right over here so what's that look how bad needs a piston if it's already combed and processed and according to rashi not according to all of your channel according to rashi it's makable toma foreign sula it's processed so you can't use this for ska it's a cabo tomo like anything that's no good what's next on but if you use this guy right over here the unprocessed devout like what's wrong with that it's beautiful what about hushney what is sushni i don't know not only do i not know the mother says any of them out i don't know okay i don't know that you're right right at this point i don't know i don't know exactly what it is and where it is what is it if it's beaten but it's not calmed so maybe it's right over here this guy over here it's beaten but not combed what if it's soaked villoid dieg but it wasn't beaten who's the correlate do you call it hudson i didn't maybe soaked but not beat is considered also oceane which we don't know exactly what it is and we don't know what that is a lot of times we we use like these strings to tie down our and what do they call those mats the reed mats well they call them kindness oh kinase kinase so what are the kindness made out of those those strings that you that attach piece to piece so based on this you should really be mockbit you should be mocked bit on using strings that are not processed at all so i guess they tell you if it has extra it says not unprocessed but a lot of times people will buy like cotton i don't know what like like like strings that come through from a factory and on a row those are problematic they're not the best to use because um what is it called uh no the word slipped by mine my man thank you how did you know that's my image to the circle so it's a minute to this half there's a minute two on my middle and there's a one my mid a one actual moment is also problematic i think it's fine i think they sell those those bags like very raw kind of material i think they do it's the same comment okay let's try a double dip why not says the gemaro i'm raviodo honey don't read it differently please ushwa sorry whether that's the way you read or not that's the way we are going to read it we don't want it to be thrown off anytime suche is fern okay i'm not saying this is it but it's a good the ice will cause a fern i go with this schwitzare is green green schwitzer is is this kind of thing i this you have like in every house has this no artemisia artemisia artemisia huh knock when you come every day no when i'm not here sit over there i saw you though i i i i come in to the video to see what's going on here don't worry about it honey sorry miss it makes sense no it doesn't to me okay this seems like it has a pretty decent smell anytime i no this is like uh this is very common it's a herb okay sorry let me stop him says don't use this mai tai mao keep in the sauer since it has a pretty foul odor has an interesting smell shoving luminosity you're gonna run out of yasuka we don't want you running out of your sukkos who do not do not use that's going to create a problem with smell but boys i have a wonderful day tonight at 6 30 whoever wants otherwise i'll see you after venus manu you