Daf Yomi Succah Daf 09 by R’ Eli Stefansky (Audio gets better)

[Music] family it's really bernstein is sponsoring lily nicholas my great aunt created razor bass avraminska and mental pilgrimage sponsoring the first time in washington polynomials and modified binder [Music] benchrag five-ish on his your side the true role model for me the ceo by learning daffy me i hope i bring him chunachas cecile bergman and the parents of hoydush michael benmela in memory of his mother fagobas schmuel and father-in-law and in merit to make it to uman rosh hashanah this year i got a i got a mad email from uh from i guess a brussel verse so hopes we made fun of woman you took it like that also not at all i didn't make fun of women there's another okay whatever raboisai do me a favor don't fall off the bandwagon through shabbos and tisha bob that's when they saw her gets us it's these days welcome mati moti middledorf welcome comer levy both from kutzler they're back and welcome robert links also from remember chemist on top of the hills for coming i forgot to mention i myself am flying out on monday night in other words it's going to be a sheer monday and then comes all the fun stuff giving shiurim while traveling in new york in chicago wedding chevy brachas it's going to be fun they're going to be shurim but this individual he's conflicted in casablanca dear daf abbey rivelli always says the best gift we get him is mortal medium so i convinced several people to try the 8-minute death initially it was going great and they loved it and then my recruits started sending angry texts that they were falling behind because my guy was only posting videos every few days it got even worse when they made that shut down for about a month and my friends blamed me that they were no longer learning unfortunately i had no choice or referred to a valley's nutella medium to the death review of another magician now that the aiming of death is back on schedule should i recruit my friends back to the 8-minute dive where it is likely that the videos will stop again when revelling travels to america next week your help with this dilemma is greatly appreciated sincerely conflicting casablanca i don't have to tell you i would love to do it every day and not miss sometimes it's just impossible right get your guys stating casablanca get your guys to watch the whole shirt that basically hashem will never stop and if it does somebody else know i'm fixed or banana will jump in and do it this one is by avi garger he's a big sadiq who's trying to convert me to nusa fired every day he puts a scissor he changes out my nationalist inspired and then he says however you pretend not to be a rabbi i'd like to prove you otherwise one as numbers prove you have over five thousand seed them two you have a beard three you see them in the beard they're gonna go away at the same time people give you money you're a miracle worker you claim to have no diver but well no it's not true is that like you're ever you see now the guy's gonna say hey that's the guy's it's your fault not mine you go collecting all over the world you have to buy them to go by the name of yeshua and you're safe and you started saying stories about edmonds when rebelo says a broccoli there's a whole lot of people that say oh man and i believe there's a picture of him wearing a shimo no point of asking you to keep this anonymous as you'll tell everyone my name avi gargier rabbi says i still have a story about javi there's a there was a story i set over because i it was the middle of the sugar i don't know if i explained myself well i was like people complain about silly things and look what clients were allowed to live through and i brought as an example i didn't like explain myself i thought it understood but i'm thinking i i think i missed that one line but i brought an example of the the story in york in england and 150 yiddin had to commit suicide to avoid the game i got many emails about it so i'm just going to read parts of three of them it says like this there are you have a new talmud and so taken by the sheer you're so on target by the way p.s stay in the car ending not going back david was incredible now just a little adjustment the castle where they were where they were in was made out of wood not the castle that i showed in the picture okay then comes ralph roskoff who's uh who's a teacher he teaches the stuff he says the kharim that i mentioned was not to sleep overnight i've heard no responsibility for the authenticity that ribley gorowitz would wake up bakarim when they were on the train traveling through york you'd wake them up because it's a harem to sleep in york the flowers planted are daffodils which have six petals so they planted these flowers they covered the jews over there and listen to this one rebianto i don't know how to pronounce his name of yogni york was about twice this who died at clifford's tower one of the bali teices died in that tower and who was he how do we know him he's a talmud of reventan he wrote omnam ken haitzer which we recite a call injury knight and finally this is a very long one i'm not going to read the whole thing here's somebody from the cleveland show and this robbie schoenberg mentioned to me right after sheer that in the early 80s there was a supermarket the sansberry supermarket wanted to build a new store in new york and they started digging and they found many many bodies and they realized that the name of the place there was jew berry and that's where they buried the a lot of the yiddin and some of the the victims of that night he goes viktor viter they did a whole the buried them beautiful the whole thing and then he says i can't read the whole thing but next morning we heard on the news that the minister had caught fire in the night and the minster the minster had caught fire in the night and the all and only the oldest part of the building was burnt incidentally this part that burned was built originally financed by ju tax probably paid by these cadation who have been buried that very day koltov david hansbacher all right we are holding daff tess i do want to show you a quick picture of our good friend yes huh oh boy said this is a good morning raboisa if you want to hear pay attention to the screen all you guys i probably know it here it is on the screen you ready there's no volume actually there's a double volume if you really listen closely that looks good that's from the scene there's 120 i see okay find a different type we're kind of late this is jonathan austin on a plane learning torah once again a lot of hannah that the islam is learning in places that they typically wouldn't have learned without that feyemi so here's jonathan jonathan by the way i have our aura here when you have a giant gemara with a lot of hebrew letters in it even if you wear a baseball cap people know that you are jewish zoro okay um a very interesting protest there's no more seats beautiful beautiful no so we'll build out this way so a couple of things as a follow-up to yesterday two follow-ups yesterday i mentioned because we were learning the math and the gemara has the interesting cache i said it might be like a klutzkasa and i said explain that this is how the gemara that's the style of the gemara interestingly enough i found tyson's here tess just today this morning with aleph deeper masculine lazy sukkah four four lines down where it becomes y the first place where it becomes wide and twice it says like this the alpha gave me cory even though he knew this reason it's the style of the shas the farish dwarf to explain its words derek has it goes into cash interest doesn't mean it's a real cash it doesn't really mean it's a way to instead of explaining it it says question answer question answer but it's not a real question okay now something amazing literally amazing he's going to blow you away yesterday when i was preparing the sugya of pi i remembered i said once a village and i couldn't recall it and i couldn't find it and i have to share immediately i have to share monty franco and some other nougat what's your name ari what arie green a new guy welcome him who's sitting actually right next to monty right now he's been here for two years in the minion and he just started showing up this year who's here also he's sitting by smaller one they both came over to me and during the day i received numerous emails again and it goes like this we're talking about pi and this is the genius of the vilnigan you're not going to believe this where is the whole positive of pi and the possible amsterdam yamcha were a bunch of bulls in the basement 12 balls and there was a mic on top of it a square then a circle and the tire describes it the positive describes that's where we learn pie and what does the positive say says and we read it but it says it in the apostle hey you see over here without any kudos but we read it so it's a cree and exiv 30 in other words we do three times the diameter it's 10. it says over here 10 but if you take 10 and go three times times three equals 30. this is how we know pi right and we said it's not exact and well how could it be the gemar but we said like tyson says we're trying to teach people and do quick math and ponovich so it's one times three you're not going to go into the diffractions says the villain gun i don't know how a person thinks about this stuff and how you come up with these kind of calculations yeah he did not this is different no you didn't do it on the toilet he says like this the way it's written is 111 khuff hey without the hebrew just the word but we read it so 111 versus 106. if you take 111 divided by 106. 106 divided by 111 you come out with 1.04717 this is the villain going 300 years ago this is what he came up with times three because the positive says a cav you time it times three times three is pi to the fifth placement you hear this this is pi shift pi 3.4151 what one four okay one four it is one five i just did five because i rounded it out anyway it's four seven nine i'm not joking light duck so i don't know how often you could take two numbers and and and get come up with that calculation this is the only going in the party to explain why the posix change from cavoy to cave within that possible pie only they've only going okay next question if you're in ahsoka on circus and you want to take a piece of meat that's stuck between your teeth are you allowed to go to your scalp and pull off a little piece of scrap and use it as a toothpick hey question number two is could use it as a baseball bat i don't know you guys in england can use a piece of style of a baseball bat cricket bag yes no yes anybody what's the answer no why is it it's mukta what's this sir is it this is the rabona there iso anybody today we're going to learn that is the eraser is the eraser to use any part of the stuff what if the scotch fell down the whole circle fell down then it turns in to a issa de rabbot okay now we can finally start today's death says the mishnah sponsored by this is the official mission is sponsored by official by the way if anybody wants to sponsor mishnais they are available for sponsorships yes we do that the new guys yeah we sponsor we sponsor the attorney to pay whatever anywhere to make money so i don't have to run around the world and collect money sokka yoshana talking about collecting money we have the most phenomenal kylo and why do we have a kylo because i learned in that kylo and they learned the daft and we throw ideas off each other and they help me out with the shares so they're actually part of the share and i don't know everybody scored but i know at least two of them because that's the only those are another per yakim got a hundred i think he got one two months ago a hundred a hundred on the issue probably from the only people in urgent role that got a hundred under test and a very very few people getting a hundred on the digital test and here it is and you look down here you got a 98 on something else in 98 i'm sure he does a lot of stuff mr brewer incredible guys anyway he's getting the bonus 100 is getting the bonus he he walks out don't ask he has a lot of bonuses what i gave him a donation i gave him this letter i don't i don't have a good memory and i don't have time for khazar i have to prepare i used to take the test i spoke about it differently we got to learn the mission an old sukkah we're going to see such a meeting that you built 30 days ago without lushma porcelain um now older soccer obviously we don't passively we'll see in a second they say you can't use a sukkah now what do you do if this was built more than 30 days before sukis it's considered the oldest bishop saying apostle basil says what's what's the significance of 30 because 30 days before yantiff darshan so if you're going to build a circle within 30 days you most likely built it because you had in mind that what the rabbi already spoke about the halakhas and everything so you had kavanagh to build it the shema pleasure just points out here very important according to this mishna a older sukkah is kosher we go like basil not like bishop but we all know that if you have such you should go like this you should lift it up so taisis says that's your xiaomi based on your xiaomi so i looked it up in the you should lift up because we don't pass in like bishop it wasn't gonna be silly in fact you don't have to you shouldn't have to but we pass it you should be mahmoud lift up only one teva not the entire sukkah and if you want it could be less than a tif i'm even a sliver as long as it's the length of the entire sukkah [Music] if you had in mind let's say pace of time you're going to build a sukkah for the mitsubishuka then it's kosher everybody agrees my time to be shaman why do you need le shma building asuka and we're talking soccer what does sukkah mean sukkah means doesn't mean the walls right because everybody's walls are probably five six ten twenty years old talking about this that's the main part of this not every arab that builds your house has in mind that you should have a sukkah they don't care so we're talking about this my name is very good there's a possum we learned something else the the word of the sukkah of this is us you're not allowed to use your scott for any purpose so how do we learn from this apostle where do you see this that there's a issue to use anything he explains so he's playing with the words a little bit means but now he's saying hag means a karba there's a card that everybody has to bring razor shaman comes very soon this is sukkas we're gonna have to bring in carbohydrate we're gonna be oil syria real carbonace 500 bucks a pop each person in the family so just like a high giga is has gdusha to it until you shift it you can't do anything with it it's kadaish that same kedusha goes into your sukkah so if this conducion in your circle you can't [Music] so let me ask you a question so sukis is over now what happens to this it remains kaddash a kara button remains cottage until you do something to it you have to redeem it you have to it doesn't just so the [Music] it just dissipates as soon as circus is over okay but nevertheless there's a isr and not a director but there's an issue to to to misuse it to treat it not nicely to step on it and there's a story that there's two bachram that went through shiva and they went to to get a fahrer and one of them was like the top guy in the yeshiva and the rashida didn't accept him except the other guy it was with the khabit shrine thank you thank you and they asked him why this guy's been suing he said because he noticed that when he walked out of the out of the hair he you don't wow what happens whatever the guy decides he wants to leave the sukkah up for five years does the does the douche dissipate so this is not actually a maclaugus according to the movie room does according to others not fine right hello [Music] everybody agrees you can't use the scott for a baseball bat to beat your kids says it's a play on words you read it let's say a person never made a sukkah he shows up he's traveling whatever it is and he needs to make it so can you build the sukkah says yes that's not built for seven days it's not a sukkah zero not even for one day so what happens according to ebaliezer if your sukkah falls down the middle halamite could you rebuild it you're not rebuilding a sugar for seven days the only rebuilding is still going for the three remaining days is that okay raboisei yes it's okay even according to believer he says if you start out at sukkah for seven days and it fell down in the middle you're allowed to continue you're allowed to rebuild it obey silva let's lose the review marava we have reviewed we have reviewed the all over hundreds of times and he always quotes rav and also right here on the spot rashi explains in case you didn't know that and then he would go around and telling everybody maybe rashid sticks in a little kuda here he waited until his revenue was dead and once you sniffed her he went around to tell everybody his torah okay now we're going to sit if you make good citrus from leftover pieces in other words as you're making the fabric you're making the fabric you have left over strings you have leftover stuff one of the things you do i you could see it like in a sack today and i saw i know in america you see in sacks sometimes there's a little of a bump what happened is one of the threads ripped so they take it they just tie it and they keep on going so it's a little thicker and certain that's called the kites so he's making a fabric and he's done with the fabric and also he has a couple strings hanging out it's not good senses why for only one reason the reason is because it's not le shma he didn't make it for for the census let's say he had a mind to make those extra senses comes out it's mother according to rashi so this right you think you have to have a hole and take go to the store buy packet senses but no as long as you make these strings that are coming out of your bag and the shema it's okay these are all leftovers in but if you have like balls of thread laying on the floor shear up you're allowed to pick up the balls of thread ah you didn't make the balls of thread for its senses you don't have to now you're inserting them into your baghead leshma and that's caution now so rashi explains here this same ravi huda was going around saying his torah to different people from from his rebbe raf and he bumps into shmuel he says you know what raff said rav and schwall right the door rav was maybe greater than so raph said he tells he tells shmuel what rap said yeah he went he went to he went afterwards first round and shmuel was only great because rav ordered him a favor kind of thing okay whatever and and ravioli says shmuel told me i have an assistant it's not true even leftover string that's on the floor you cannot pick it up and make it into this is why the be in a tv he holds you need the weaving of the this is also the beetle shema not just the insertion into the beggar as the gimbal if so if basilo this is rav obviously rav goes according to missile so wouldn't if you didn't have any intent that this should be a sukkah it's a good sokka no macro this is special that requires the small intent it's going to say that if i steal asuka so according to the ritual it's only a portable circle that it could steal if a guy has a silk on a pickup truck and i steal the pickup truck then i'm not going to but you cannot steal something that's attached to the ground because targeting zealous real quickly the first rebbe of gere i'm saying this covered mandir about because he's related i don't know if you know he had 13 children and basically 12 out of the 13 i think it was 12 10 to 12 for sure 10 maybe even 12 would nifter while he was alive terrible terrible stuff and he used to tell people that at one of the levias he said somebody whacked me my back and i turned around and i saw is my friend says sometimes you get a whack in the back you look around it's like somebody you hate so you get upset but if it's your friend he's excited to see you so you turn around because your brother gave him a whack in the back and he turned around so he was excited that's what he said he said he had this thing that he could be menachem people that have source in their life anyways says now that you know the room he says that zoya says that asuka is there to take only the good things of the yid to take the good but if you go and do so but if you go into a sukkah that's zula then it doesn't have the ability to take the good it takes the bad also that's that's not good for you that's why asuka zula is possible okay [Music] you can't have a stolen period since this says the gemara has renamed him in fact there's another policy that says it the zula submarine okay fine so now we know that the la shmoop is not by success this says not soccer returning to testimony sponsored by the mdy the healing group for those who need shidduchim refusing insurers please join that 8mindaf.com the official mishna sponsored by official oh i forgot to mention the schedule there will be a share right here in the basement which tomorrow on chavez one hour before milkha i don't know what time it is and the matze tish above to shiuru the first one is going to be where we're holding and that starts at 10 o'clock i know it's late you don't have to show up if you don't want i'll be here unfortunately with the second chair i don't know how i'm going to do it because i don't i don't perform well after tanism to sure we have to do to make up so we have something video the same shirt that i'm giving a shot as i'm going to do after the share on monsieur says the helicopter underneath the tree this is very common problem there's a lot of branches everywhere a lot of different things what does it mean it should say it's possible it's as if you made your sukkah inside a house the mother is going to explain why using such a long lotion it's unbelievable imagine without this safer from colorado i'd probably sit there at night building these models to be cool this is a lot cooler it's a lot nicer agave i don't know if you ever had this but my children at least in chicago they had just remembered there's a kid in chicago talking about the nine days kid in chicago killed by a car uh less than a day like a day ago unbelievable sounds just saying every year nine days but the kids in chicago they build these models like every kid builds another so i had to sit there every year and build for my kids all right fine suka agave you can sit in the upper one right it's less than 20 ammos it's an upper one we cannot sit in the bottom one because there's a positive that says you cannot have two how far away they from each other that's a different discussion in the gemara review this problem is a tree like this you have a tree that has a lot of shade so it's providing the shade and it's fossil shade why because it's but when it's very sparse like this there's barely any leaves here it's barely creating me so then it's kosher okay this this sugar for instance is nigel maison very important stuff rashi actually brings one case but here in arizona you live in an apartment building and the person right above you has laundry lines and the laundry lines maybe there's love between them so all of a sudden i have a piece this big it's a beautiful al-lajas about it there is no lava like that why first of all some some say love it doesn't work if you want to be mahm and ruin something it only works when you need it but some say that it doesn't work because it's not it's not providing the shade it's only but we had in america a lot of times you have you have a branch of these massive oak trees whatever they are they come right across the surfa you have to know [Music] there's a reason why the missionary is such an interesting lesson this is what it's coming to tell us that it has to say a lot of his advice is going to see soon that a sucker inside a house and a stuck on the trees learn from the same word so a house typically the roof provides more shade than sun so too this tree that we're talking about in our mishnah is the same kind of idea it provides a lot of shade more shade than sun aston mark who cares even in a case where it doesn't provide any shade not any very very little shade [Music] at the end of the day you're combining puzzle that's from the tree together with kosher stuff now rashi and tyson's learn just to understand very simple they both learn that the bottom sukkah doesn't have enough it itself is hamas together with the tree it becomes becomes enough shape that is the proud master gemara you're using the puzzle to create kosher stuff that's not going to work why because if the if the sukkah has enough so then that little branch is coming over is going to be buffalos nothing it's not going to do anything for me even if i remove whatever's below it i still have enough scrap the other richard and learned differently fine but anytime rash and tyson could agree on something that we're good enough for that they the other richard i'm learning that whatever the tree is over you have to cancel that part of this half okay talking about this case right over here oh by the way here's a beautiful picture i noticed afterwards they did a really good job in terms of what i just said in terms of rashi if you look closely you see that's kosher over here but it's not really touching there's a lot of gaps here together with the tree you have a nice amount of scar says the gemara this is what we're talking about we're talking about he took the tree and he intertwined it with this you don't really see the difference it's mamish it's one piece because tyson points out we're going to have the mission later about shippuden you have pieces of metal they go through the sock it makes this puzzle because over there you can see the metal over here it's all green he took it and he just went like this it's it's within the apostles within the kosher and therefore what the the the apostle becomes bottle birth comes back you guys are thinking this is a major hydras what's going on why should it be kosher the water says milo meredith so if you take the puzzle and it's about to arrive in the conscious ha see there was a great kiddush listen let's let's just back up one second so you understand a little better in order to have silas you need 51 shade let's call just for for argument 51 shade what happened was you only have 50 shade one little tiny leaf attached to the tree is going to push you over to the 51. says gemara if it's inside your 50 percent it doesn't do anything i don't even look at it who cares so yes i got it from it but it's 100 bottle it's one out of 50. now you understand it better you're not going to remember next year to intertwine anime you're just going to let it go five feet above commercial maybe you're not going to intertwine them that's the right word it says you take the grapevine vest at last here's the grapevine here's a grapevine and you put it right on top of your sukkot in chicago where is zoho there's a restaurant on the van i always pass by this restaurant and i was wondering what it is and finally i see there in the gemara i don't have a picture of that restaurant i forgot the name over there it's a non-kosher restaurant but they have this literally looks like this outdoors they have just a canopy of gourds so i guess the gourds these pumpkins whatever their vines they grow they they climb these are we're talking about climbers over here ivy grapes and gourds okay so hitler a gourds glass vesaki soys ivy by the way very not good idea if you live in america to have ivy growing up your house terrible terrible idea it grows very very quickly and it destroys the mortar in your brick islam as a contractor i'm telling you and then you took like in this picture if you look closely you'll see that the vines are underneath and then he went he puts on top he has the puzzle because it's character and he put his heart on top if it's a lot more cautious on he snipped it on the bottom so it's no longer that's kosher what's the case when it's still attached to the ground and you didn't mix it up with the questions of course it's possible you're getting to this according to entices again you're getting to the kosher squad only so of course it's possible in that case by hitler he did mix it in with the kosher and that goof is the that we don't make exactly that you might not do it next time so if so what's the us by a tree it's the same as that case he took the tree now the same enemy with the heaven come and mixing it into kosher straw so that the kosher straw should i think you can't do that commercial you could why i don't know really but you could next case why is that awesome so bringing a pausing that says in the past you shouldn't have a second to have another circle manage like that otherwise what's the problem you have two schecks that are kosher it's double it's an extra goods what's the problem no it's great to have asuka welcome from uh it's great to have two sukkas one on top of the other over abner don't forget we had the other sugiyah how's it written the torah without a vow it says it in singular so it says you should sit in once okay not too i may be i hold yeshua mikra it's the way i read it says on the bottom the last little line everybody holds that there's a reason why the torah wrote it differently than you read it the question is what's daycare but i can't avoid the fact that it says in singular so i'm going to learn all right says what do you mean if i want singular no because the client is over the playstation all of you you should send that you don't want all classrooms anyone's looking it's gonna be a problem all right everybody hear me uh he's published think if we stop here just pause for one second how do you make both circus the up and the bottom according to everybody caution think how's it possible it's a riddle how do you make both zuku's puzzle how do you make the upper one kosher and the battle one puzzle and how do you make the battle one kosher in the upper one puzzle a riddle okay if you're watching the video pause try to figure it out yourself absolutely what is the case what are the four cases promising when the bottom sucker doesn't provide enough shade it's possible so it's not a sukkah at all so i can sit on the bottom one because it's and i could sit in the top one because it could hold me up why not so in melo we have two sukkahs the upper and the bottom one are both kosher what's the problem mindy oh okay fine but it's for the riddle you don't like this kind of riddles trick riddle why it's a sucker that has ha it's just puzzle scrap ugly but physically it is hello the guy is sitting on the second floor what he's sitting in the mid-air he's sitting on the second floor he lives there's two families living there i'm answering there's two circas it's two physical circus there's a family the freemans live on top and the cones live in the bottom there's two families living there and they both are yotso it's not a sukkot but physically exactly how's it possible is one stick with two floors and they're both questioned that's it okay that's how it is well you know are you arguing with uh right now also this guy did wrong whatever okay fine it's not a good riddle how do you make bottom puzzle you're going to divide it they both have good shades so the batter was for sure apostle why because the master mamma this is also not such a great rate of why because it's a trick the upper one is above 20 amps okay so i found the way that the upper one is possible by itself because it's above 20 ounces punch the tonic cherry valley on absolutely and sometimes the bottom one is kosher but the odd per [Music] but the other one doesn't have enough so again you can ask me the same questions it's a good circle fine now the only way this trick works is kai meets our value of the cabinet vibe is the classroom why they both have to be within 20. because if the upper one is above 20 you hear the hap then it's puzzle it's above 20. and puzzle sky is going to be starving to the bottom it's going to make the bottom puzzle you know what should we stop here i can we just do one more line absolutely and the upper one is within 20 ammo have a wonderful they and shabbos and a meaningful fans you