Daf Yomi Succah Daf 06 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] is being sponsored by the sherman family few goddamn hills in memory of their father grandfather great grandfather germany germany we have a guy from germany before slaymo for our beloved son elio are not ben judith rabbi please may have ye rashform and become a ventura by jose hoffman reforcelaid with my sister sheindle bat brando [Music] in honor of rebelli yosef i know what this person is i'm not supposed to know what it is i appreciate it oh you don't know who it is we have a parent by michael ben miller [Music] this year uh so he said is there a full shleima for our son elio or el naya ben judith may you have your shamayim and become inventorial thanks to elise stefanski and the whole team for making a difference in learning shots i think you can call it sort of a revolution that's yummy learning and that's what everybody is joining this wonderful big jewish family is feeling this is a person from frankfurt germany i'm very thankful to hashem that he led me to rav stefanski and his great america's team and to be able to be part in this great learning experience we all and christ will be blessed and maybe we all be able to see them soon in our days called roland alexander yeshua friedman from frankfort hey hello rebelli i would rather write anonymously but as there are no secrets in mdy my name is shmuel kogus i currently live in haverstraw new york near near mark ashkenazi where's mark where's that that's muncie i never heard of this place it's starting it's starting to grow west hempstead is okay i am primarily a youtuber usually mutsy shops they have the opportunity and zoom brooklyn will never be muncie they would rather move past the tracks and be i started here in shop on chaba in shops chavez while working nights on a paramedic truck here's a paramedic truck for a boy's eye this clutch of stuff here he is here's the shear here are the magnets oh the screen is working that one at least that one is not okay usually we have the the charts and the screens and we have also someone there's like a hand following the gemara so if you get lost in a story something you can look up on the screen lazer hashem all come back i've never been very studious sitting through a sheer class it's difficult to say the least now my whereas manager by day and work as a paramedic on a less frequent on a less frequent basis this is the first share that i've ever been able to truly follow and focus on your explanations and demonstrations are phenomenal and truly original while i wish you said more serum daily like the conan pressman i enjoy listening to share more than once a day you hear this he's a paramedic he listens to more than once a day i went back to the beginning of bronchus and started all over my girls asked to listen to share while in the car and compete to see who can do a better good morning robotics there's a second email today i got about the girls saying good morning your boy say as one of the kids somebody else wrote his daughter goes through the whole youtube she sees it's good for us because you get more clicks like that bowing to your greatness bowing to you schmule kogus okay remember from truly amazing evening had to see him it was great once again meeting all the mdy family in person attached the two photos from the event nether there are more to come well i want to get ready for the sharing to do that safer oh it's only 7 20. ah there's more walnut timeout that's a short enough this is a very long one let me skip around there my name is michael davis i came through four years ago karen biavno second year went went to the army made aliyah the beginning of the army's learning was strong several months later it just fell apart then came january the fianni cycle telling myself there's no way i'll be able to keep up i won't get anything out of learning the classic excuses but then i saw there was a group of guys in my unit starting to dive so i decided to jump in the bandwagon it was the greatest decision ever it was this product that brought all my learning back workers i'm sorry that got me back on track with schneider mikro and my mishnahi say there a lot of people say that that the dav brings back the consistency of other things like shania mikro and mishnais oh it's going well chugging through the dive with my covers in the army unit until i got back to shiva this past ello 75 into aravind i couldn't do it anymore it's too hard kitzer art scroll chance the pond elisher and i'm in cheer until this very day what makes the story that much better is two months ago my family made it into israel from my wedding uh credible cars somebody's making a lot of noise here i can't concentrate randomly started belting out schmuck and boarding around boy's side to my great surprise my six-year-old brother responded you listen to her belly share the kid sir unbeknownst to him he got a freaking marijuana and he started so the whole spot was into it my fourth-year-old brother told me that his rebbe told him to do it also because wow it's a huge email you're welcome to read it here i'll put it up for a second what's the guy's name your talmud moycia davis oh it says on the bottom here p.s the email was already too long so i refrained from making any ponovich or gavidelio jokes my sincerest apologies he's at the scene beautiful all right here we go today is daf and we're holding six lines from the bottom of that hey almond base we just finished saying that according to abihudo doesn't have apostle to teach us that sometimes you don't understand them sometimes yes it's not in the torah but it has it's a lot stronger than the rabbana it's like a day right what is it shirim all the shrimp the river is the gazaes we're gonna see the katsitsa when you go to the mikvah you can't have any anything on your skin the water hasn't touched all of your skin or we'll see exactly says um the rice and inu depends how you sing it you can say i said no no that's not how you say shi shirin at the end of the day the shirem are in the torah what are you telling me that the sheer is that it says we're foolish in the torah of the shiro why the sieve eretz hito usa the possibility here it is you have pomegranate olives and dates this is from the southeast breakfast though the reason why the the reds are highlighted it's because the plastic starts over again eretz it says there's again we'll see again we'll we're going to be using this word actually so in in brachas we learned the beautiful that the olive if you're making breakfast whatever the olive comes before barley graves because it's the first to the second herits and vash which is number two to the second one comes before number three over here okay that's a different allah i'll upon him it says eretz hito sorry of the government of irene eretz says shemin khala possibly from every single one of these fruits we learn a different shear in the torah says rashi four lines from the bottom of nema hapasik mediver bishop khosholaritis the pasik is telling us the beauty the the schwa very strong praising eretz israel shafilu with the retorts even when we look at isurum in the torah we're going to go to the fruits of heritage so we're not going to go to the grape of egypt or the grave of the united states we're going to go to the grape the size is the grape of air disro the size of pomegranate is the pomegranate vegetable straw shifter it's israel so how does it work so the gemara now is going to take us all the way to the bottom of blah blah blah and teach us each and every fruit what shear it's referring to this one is in my opinion a very interesting one because it's not really a sheer of a hitachita wheat so all the other ones basically are the sheer the size of a pomegranate the size of a date over here it's not the size of a kernel of wheat what is it it is a sheer pita the base if a person has a house that has syracuse we actually touched upon it yesterday that the house has to have four almonds by four elements to be called the house and there's a saras in there so the the house creates tomah if you go into the house you become atomic but he's not wearing his clothing i mean he is dressed but he's also in addition to that he's holding clothing in his hands visa and allah and his shoes his sandals his rings are in his hand this brings up that story that i said a few times about kleinkanievsky i was once married crime kanewski with a friend of mine a guy that wasn't so religious at the time when i met him but he became religious and he was a photographer so i asked him if he could come in and take pictures and he took he was taking pictures also kind of he looks at him he says why is a woman taking pictures of me so the the the is not a woman it's a man he even has a beard no no it's a woman and then he looks at it and says the ring why does he have a ring like a woman he's a woman kids are don't be so don't don't get too nervous because rokan kennedy says the same thing about people that wear watches but over here in the kimbard says the guy had his rings in his hand he was wearing a ring and he took it off so i should have asked from khan kenowski that boy is to be other it's not in those days i guess men would wear rings maybe saying in these days it's not yeah signing different things okay who they hate me at so what's going on here let me just show you real quickly it's beautiful it says in the possum the haboa by us this house that has tara's call you made his girl sorry i know they're passing by heart you see i'm just looking at the screen i can read it right over there yitmo i love it that's the camera but that's the words that camera doesn't have the words if you walk into the house it becomes coming and what does it say in the next passive version if you go to sleep in the house or valley club is so what's going on here if you walk into the house if you become tame so of course if you sleep in the house if you come timing so what's going on here is that there's two shiurim there's two times two two time limits one is as you walk into the house you immediately become tummy the second one is you have to be there for a certain amount of time in order for the clothes that you're wearing to become tummy they don't become tummy right away if you're holding your clothes in your hand you're holding your ring in your hand they become tummy right away but there's another thing that deposits says here it's very nice it's a nice deal yeah maybe we wouldn't have realized we just read it okay hi your lovers caleb but if you're wearing your clothing top of that velvet mandala vista and love and your shoes are on your feet with the barista yeah here i don't have to make any diocese i was once there with my father byron kanowski and my father asked him a question so he said he told him so my father said yeah but the place is in sukkah and i'm looking i have no clue what's going on he's he's saying cool and he's saying sukkah back and forth my father said you're right okay so when we walked out i said what's going on he says no he said enough because the immortal leader says this is that he says i knew he's going to say that i i had the the but that's so i i should have said sukkah above him and he would have said hey there and then stuck so if he walks in so his body becomes coming immediately his clothing don't become tummy until what until he's there here's the upgraded picture from rooming chait this is not ruined it's upgraded huh it's upgraded means as long as it takes you on a clock to eat a half a loaf of bread approximately four eggs it's four slices of bread like two sandwiches worth however long it takes we don't know exactly how long that is that's how long you have to remain in that let's say it takes you three minutes nine minutes whatever how fast you eat two sandwiches not that it's not that quick as long as it takes to eat i have a loaf of bread but here comes the shear not just the half a loafer bed not one of those loaves you know for the healthy people wheat not whole wheat wheat reclining and you're thinking about eating you're concentrating your food you're not you're not text messaging you're not doing anything else that's the and you have something to be laughing to smear it on whatever you eat with the bread that's the shear of when the clothing that you're that you're wearing and your ring on your finger become tommy let's call it eight minutes eight minutes you have to be in the house for eight minutes in order for your clothing on your body to become tommy pras means a half we once learned khati press that's why i had to redo it because it said on the original khati press and it showed up katie press means a quarter because it's a half of the press cross means half so khati presents a quarter i don't want to confuse you but i wasn't able to i just had to start over anyway eight minutes oh that's where you got the imminent chair eight minute sheer it's a sheer very nice i got it by the way the new guys the new guys there's some confusion i think this is a 45 minute chair and there's an eight minute chair this is the eight minute synopsis the two separate things if you're new to this okay check out the eight minute eight minute staff dot com the entire match is okay and here comes the shoe that's what i said it's not the size of the gita but it has to be heat that has to be made out of wheat pasta but i passed so you even have barley bread masala he's reclining in other words it says rashi he's concentrating on his food so he eats it quicker and whatever you eat with it whether it's we once had its meat whatever but let's call it a smear some sort of something that makes the bread go down quicker next one on the list is saurabh barley this is if you have a bone of a of a mace a dead person the size of a barley what is it called a barley bean a barley erno i want to see criminal but didn't didn't go well but okay colonel me tama mago if you just touch it ube what has been masami that if you're not touching it it's in your cup on the bottom even though you're not touching it but since you lifted it you become kame as long as the size of a barley kernel about the guy going to man was a lot stronger than normally for the shackles is rive minion a a person has 248 bones so if you have the majority of the what is that 125 yeah i really didn't that was part of it on the spot and he's going to tell me i was wrong 125 bones then the entire room becomes anybody who walks into the room if the bones are in a corner over here and you're on the other side you also become tummy because you're in that oil but oil is different i only need one the the river minion of 248 or a whole skull or an entire spine gavin what's a grape today reviews so if we're talking about salads another also can't eat salads you can't eat the the peel of a grape the karzanam the the pits so how do you measure the pits and the kharzan and the salads of grapes that another who refrains from wine can't eat you replace displays wine not water so you're looking at a larger measurement it's a little bit more than water the displacement of wine is more than displacement so you take you take this uh you take this item you put them in a um in a uh a cup full of wine and he displays uravius they know what is a fig gregaris chavez when you're taking food on chaba is from rochester when we learn themselves there's different children like uh fatter is is the mouth full of uh whatever animal it is a donkey and a goat has a different amount whatever but for human beings food when it comes to food is the size of a fig remind what's a pomegranate this non cochlea balabatin shiron kiri my name so using this from a different thing if you have a cleat that's mekabul tomo let's say this is makable tumor this pla which it's not but let's say this is makaotuma and it has a hole let's say it breaks into pieces this is tame and it breaks into pieces the tumor dissipates it's no longer tummy what if it has a hole so if it has a hole i could plug up the hole see it like this look up though how big so if it's a hole the size of a of a an olive i could still use this even without plugging it up because i could put a larger fruit in there up until the size of a pomegranate once as the size of a product it's this big i'm going to toss it away what's interesting is that the gemara says it's for a balabags at home i will tolerate this cli but when you go to the store nobody in their right mind is going to buy a clue that has a small hole in it so if you're a store owner you're going to toss it even with the mashup right if you go to the store and you buy a couch and the couch has a little tear in it you're out of there you're not you're not gonna buy the but if you already own that cli you're on the couch and has a little tear you're not gonna throw it out you keep it in your house it's also your side for life if let's say your spouse has a little bit of a hazard let's say not everybody has but some people have spouses that have historians so look hila maybe you wouldn't have married her or him but now that you have her that's it you're stuck you got to live with it but wait a minute but it's not i'm not oh i'm not done yet it's going very well because here's the thing yeah there's more this is the biggest sight big biggie site what people don't realize is that whatever that sarin that your spouse has is tailor made to you so let's say you have a little bit of a cass issue a little bit of a mephonic a clean guy like like that guy i was telling you about that he wanted to get divorced because his wife didn't clean the corners so because welcome with daft puts it that into your life that woman that knows how to push that button of course that woman that knows how to make you nervous about cleaning it's badafka it's to make a tikkun so you have to realize that it's it's it's it's if you know if you understand that then nothing is exciting then you no spouse all your spouses are perfect because the tailor made for you you hear the crap it's murder thank you so much for helping me attacking myself you know what happened you know [Laughter] very good very good and you're attacking her you got that in newman wow so dr factor says you go to uma you go for prison not for hashanah you leave your family go to roshana unbelievable wow wow okay we got to talk afterwards so i don't know if you heard some people ask to repeat that i could repeat he said that when his wife yells at him i know his wife she doesn't yell but if she does say he says thank you very much you're helping me be attacking myself and then she gets even angrier wow you see how he got from pomegranates to to the wives and to ami factor his wife the whole thing eretz zeiss sherman eres shakolshi reoccusation the entire all over this throw all the children that we have in the world are kazayas where do we get it from because the terrorist says eretz pointed it out before right over here it does say eretz meaning everything the entire the whole country that's the sheer of everything we just finished saying different children all of a sudden you tell me all the shirim says means honey but in the torah divash means a date it's sweet like honey we all know what that is i mean not all if we just learned yuma literally at the end of the cefta discussing what the israelis and young kippers it's awesome to just eat onion but the shear is because yom kippur is different than eating you know it's not about eating it's about soothing yourself and what soothes a person can you serve as a gaster the size of a nice fat date almo so going back to the question you're telling me that's that mushroom it's all in the torah what this passing is not tired this is this is tyra right over here says the gemara with this version xiv does it say the [Music] said and at the end of the day the passo is there for nasmakta what was that rid of i just said i already forgot it says that what oh that who put it in the torah it's not that ham looked for a source and they found an entire put in there for home later on to pull out that source and use it but over here it's different it's and there's a source in ontario okay the the idea of katsitso is not aloha machina that you just said you said that three things i looked on you see night shirin all the skin must touch the water you can't have anything that separates the skin from the water so that's attempt number one it's coming to say that here the hero and a human being is also hides it that's why you go to the make day right you say somebody has to check your ear make sure there's no yes one here that's in a nut could create a khasitsa in other words the water can't get to all surfaces of that here and therefore but three here since they're tough you take three hairs and you make a knot the water will sneak in it's not a real hat so river keeper went the darshan all the esm and the torah until he got to esta s is a word that adds adds to what something that's in addition to your skin reminding you what else is in addition to your skin that could be sorry you're here says the gemara you're right so what is that yeah and this is very important the virtual what does divaritaria mean it says rashi [Music] so it goes like this uh i learned my lesson usually i make a chart and i show the oil on the chart and we go inviter and everyone says yeah it's partial passion so what i'm going to do is i'm not going to show you this chart we're going to learn the song without the chart oh yeah yeah i'm not going to mention the chart however i'll show you the chart afterwards and then we'll go back just for just because i love this is one of my favorite charts match goes like this we just turned to that verbum bay sponsored by the md white hill group for all those who need shidduchim reforest yeshua's please join them.8mindaf.com there's only there's two conditions not midday sorry let's get that in because devatar means middle eyes not midday [Music] there are two conditions that has to be on most of your here not your body you're here mostly you're here fifty-one percent of you here um you don't want it to be there that is ah and if you don't care there's no hatsitsu why says rashi because then it becomes like your body if you don't care you don't mind that it's on your head you have a bunch of or let's say an example would be a a wig like a hairpiece i know i know in america some bald guys they go around with this wig they think it looks natural doesn't it's a toupee so that if you're not making that's fine you can go to the mix with it maybe it's very interesting look at rashid dibra mascara have a leica goofy no good have like a goofy it's like your body if you don't if you don't care how you'll the in syfy little since you're never going to remove it so let me ask you a question i know what you're all thinking and because i'm asking the question you should know that the answer's not like you're thinking what about you go to the dentist and he puts in a temporary filling that's going to last you for six months he says come back in six months i'm going to do a real root canal but in six months i'm taking it out rashi says ain't so little you're never taking it out but what about six months from now is that considered could you go to the mikvah with a temporary filling that you're taking out it's cypher lit like when in six months no what do you think yes what so what yeah it is you can yeah okay we'll talk about it later what yeah yeah yeah yeah you don't put water in your mouth you don't put water in your mouth but it has to you can't have something wow wow you hear that dr factor who's uh who's a plastic surgeon he takes people's stitches out before the mikvah and then he puts them back in half to make it because he can't go with those stitches it's us anyway says i thought it was a tremendous kid she says since you're about to take it out in six months it's with that unbelievable somebody else i saw is mukholik i don't know who he is i know the kazanisha's but i don't know the other version he says he's i like this far though he said you don't want to take it out the dentist wants to take it out your if it's up to you you could have that feeling there for a few years who wants to go back to that so it shouldn't be okay fine you like it also hello okay great now listen to this vishainu makita love if you don't care about it it doesn't create a khatizo begos on the majority of your body that you don't care because because of the the the eraser of roiv and the immaculate valmik and they also made xero on the minority that you are mahmoud michonne ruben because of the rights of rumor macbeth if you don't if you're not following it's better for me because i want to show you why my chart is so beautiful village tsunami astragamura make xero almighty magpies make xara even further on the minority that you don't care about because of the minority that you do care about inami ah this is where it gets confusing or maybe also because you know forget it let me just show you this thing and it's beautiful it's so beautiful i said such i know when i made this because agusburgh gave me the idea to put the color in there once i did it without color but once i put the color in it's unreal let me show you why this is the isa right this is the khatis of the riser the two conditions rife and macbeth it's 51 percent of you here and you hate it it's vomit whatever it is a waste you want to get it out quickly that's a hat and they take one word from each and made it isser they took the river even though you're not magnet it's green you see they took the bad it's the majority even though i don't care about it it's not vomit it's a toupee but it takes up 51 percent of my head said no good can't go to the makeup with it then they took the second word the magpid i care about it and they they added the green to it and they said even if it's the minority it's 49 but i'm macbet it's throw up vomit on my hair that's 49 percent you can't go to the mikveh to it with it as the gemara let's take the two greens the two green words the two mother words and let's say the hacham say that's also awesome it's a minority of my body of my hair and i don't even care it's maple syrup it's cheesecake and it's only 49 percent you shouldn't be able to go to the mikvah says the gemara that's called the xeroxera that's two steps away from the easter there right it's a ruby macbook now that we know that let's see inside oh now it's going to be developed right the green and the red that's when it came out it's part of your body still i would say i'm not i'm listening i'm not a plastic i don't know it's a good kashup she get over here i gotta you gotta say the question to everybody come here they didn't hear you kasha come come it's okay he said to you devour toyota top of the top of the page there are two things and only these two things these these two conditions combined create a chat it's 51 and you care about it but if i don't have one of these two conditions i don't care it's right but i don't care and it hides it it's bottled to your body says rashi because boy here they took one word rubai and even though you're not marked with the green and they said that that's also why mishom because of the tap thing rubai hamakpit because of the halachan messina and they also made another example valmiyutiya makbid the minority they took one word makbid they put it here but they added something that's really mother miot mishom why because we go back up here again because the the law of the scene and it says these two conditions are no good so even one of the two is also not good according to the rabbana as the gemara village with the shiny macbeth these take the two greens the meal and the laymak but combine them together say this is us or because this is uh sir miyot that your macbeth is also so mean but should be also that that line right there that's why i think you need the chart this miut loi macbeth should be because of ruby macbeth you see ruby lawyer is a khatis according to rabbana so me with lloyd macbeth should be us either because of this or because of this because they both share one green word so two green words together should be also and that the governor says he goof like zero this is only the rabona and invented zero by rabbana so we're not going to take it another step further negative thanks exactly great says what why is if you have not yesterday two days ago we had a beam in the middle of the sukkah we said the walls the invisible walls should continue upwards we also had it in aravind good goes downwards good aches or pee thicker yeah over here we consider the wall going down you have a little ledge it goes down and encloses this area beloved and the idea that a wall is we or anything that has opening that's less than three is considered uh closed with akuma and a bent wall you have something that's bent you put it if it's too far away you say that the ceiling is part of the wall and it's actually a wall built crookedly so there's a very famous myself but we have to say it you'll see client reminded me of it there was a hosta that went to the river and said river i don't have a shidduch i need to get married so the river said oh if you go to the causal 40 days straight and he gave him all the instructions like i said at the speech if you ever if you listen to it go to the cause of 40 days trading dive in the same spot and the same same time of the day you asked for the same thing you have cavada guarantee yourself crosstalk goes to the castle 40 days and sure enough he gets married and he goes to the river and he says reva what did you do to me she's mama she's the worst of the worst i'm so witch so there is let me hear what you what did you do what did you do how did you go he says listen i went to the castle but i went that way and i said 40 days for you i went finished washes it's a little bit of the the day before and a little bit day after and uh and then i did that then i realized if that works then i don't really have to go every other day because there's a level you just bridge the gap and it's ruby kakuloi so i went says ah that's why you got it doi for nakumo all right the bottom line oh from here you can see a bigger story revoice i no i'm just guessing if you try to cut corners try to cut corners because you want to also cut corners you got to do it you can't be we're not into the ice design you got to go all the way out got to go and do it correctly all right we can elaborate a different time not enough time now so we said in the mishnah we have like the mission that says it doesn't have three walls look it doesn't have three walls it's possible but the third one could be a baby wall it could be one comes a long grip no three have to be proper and the fourth one could be a tether we have a major mach like it's a quantum should you need four walls just the fourth wall could be a baby type one and according to only three walls and the third one could be a baby one now we're going to have five shot them what what's the source of the mclarens why are they now i thought we would have more time but i'll say it now anyway the famous story that the vilnigan told us tell me them each one should grab them and learn it unbelievably inside of explore know by heart so wherever they go they could always hazard rip zom the legend who is on his brother who is a tremendous tremendous italy and a big time of hawaii was nifty a very young age he came to the village and he said rabbi i learned suka i know by heart inside out here so villain told him okay how many apostle sukkas are there i don't know he says i have no idea and he said how many cluster suckers are there and he said i don't know she says that's not really knowing your backstory what i'll tell you there are 91 sukis sheriffs in santa sukka and 85 apostle how do i know kaminyan sukkah with above is 91 and sukko without above is 85. okay so that was that was the thing 911. based on that it says the government like this but michael midfield what's the source of the macholic is says the gemara rebound and sabri yesh aim the messiah verb shem and sullivan a lot of words in the torah are written differently than we read them so if you take away the nakutas from this word right over here it says we put a shurike over here whatever you want to call it and we made a sukhois we make it plural but it really says it as a singular sukas there's no vav here and this word as well there's no above so it's really a single circle we read it yes aim the micro do we go based on how we read it mikra we we read it or do we base it on cyrus on how we write it here it finally says the success with a verb so that is two so very simple so we're gonna have five shot them four of them are based on this apostle rabban and savory ishmael missouri's verbs it says one two plus two one two plus two equals four hare ken arba dal hadley goofy remove this first sukkas right over here in the beginning why because i need one to teach me the mitzvah i don't know it yet and therefore i'm i i'm left with three that's beautiful three makritsas how do you make three mejitsas two regular walls seven and one attempt comes and says you don't need a full third wall make it reduce two plus two plus two is six so remove these two right over here it's one word you gotta remove both of them for the mitzvah how much do you have four puzzle challenge right so he says this four take one off take the fourth one and make it only that so it's three plus one tab everybody holds this six sukis over here because it's the way you read it do i need apostles i need a lee mood to tell me about this or the limu are only talking about the walls why because the word sukkah means that there is it's built into the word you don't need a limit for that i need one goes off already four the i have i have six minus two because i need the apostle i need the mitzvah i'm left with four but one of the four is for this i'm left now from the three make the third one so it's two plus three um says no i don't need a positive for that it says in the words i'm left with four because i took off two for the sukkah itself i'm left with four so the fourth one is the theft three plus tepa everybody say ma no why for what no the the this is for the mysteries i can't use any lemur from this not for the darshan i mean i have one it's the way i read it so this is where i read it i started off to begin with with only four sukkas sukkas sukhas plus is four welcome so if i start out with four one of them is to teach me the halakhah itself so i'm left with three and the halal zenith says take off from the third and make it only ateva um no you have three and the opposition is saying it says addative to the three beautiful vibe could i learn from this first word or not very simple myself with darshan krillos ripchiman says i use this word and i doubt you from this word mma law i only have three and the third one is the and finally just two more lines to protect us from what from all the elements well if a suka protects us from elements it has to protect us if it only has three walls it can't protect us from the rain it can't protect us from anything so obviously the tar is saying have a sucker that's four walls says the fourth wall could be a baby wall but i need four walls from rain have a wonderful day mark and uncle phil it was great having you come more often you