Daf Yomi Shevuos Daf 34 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning. We have a tremendous amount of guests. We'll start with a father and son. What's your name again? Shimon from New York. Brooklyn, New York. Brooklyn, New York. I think this you're a son. Son. Moa. Yes. Valde, father and son history. Father on this side, son on this side in the hot seats. Who else do we have? What's your name? Also father and son. Another father and son team. Gishin. Let's see. Oh. Oh, look at that camera worker. Boyside. Check this out, guys. Not bad. So again, what's the name? Uzi Halpert. Uzi. And your Don't say your father's name. Father, what's your name? Tommy Halpert from Bora Park. also from Bar Park. He's from Lakewood. You're in Lakewood. Now you live in Lakewood. Bar Parker. We're in Brooklyn. You live Flapush. Bar Park and Flatbush. Ah. Everything else is out of town. You should know. Those are the two in town places. You're massim. You married somebody from Bar Park. The rest of the world. What's your name? I I thought I saw you here. You're from London. London. from London. Who else do we have? No, nobody. Yeah. Oh, that's right. What's your name? Wman from Wman from coming. Okay. Who else? Well, you got another one. He's hiding over there. What's your name? Sadik. You're not I know it's not Moisha. Shua. Vald. So, you just came because your father told you to come. Valdic I just wanted to show you real quickly there's a we have a par I'm not going to show this this is the only time but for 4 months TCS telecom for the Hebrew Hebrew shears it's already here this is a surprise for a Kamyanski's son Zevi married guy on the plane staging away Joseph Kletkin he was in the Alps and uh they learn he's learning Tyra you can people with talist filling Austrian Alps. He says ah [Music] so we have a that used to come every single day. His name is Schlommo Forchan. And Schlommo wrote me a whole long email. I'm not going to read the whole thing. He's the only one I ever gave a tablet to because I felt bad for him. He used to come every single day and he went to yeshiva and over there he couldn't he couldn't do the daff in his room. So called me up and he said I'm going to let this guy do the daf if if he has a tablet. Get him a tablet. So I gave him a tablet. He says basically his friend multicone started with already you know 30 something d into the into the ma and um he wants to tell me that uh his friend his friend said we're going to the beach on Arab shabas. So he said we first have to finish the daf. So they finished the daf and they go to the beach and uh they started drowning him and m started drowning and he said goodbye to his friend the whole m he's holding on to him and he said that's it. He's out. But somehow some uh they were under the water and he he swallowed a lot of water and he doesn't know how to swim and some kitser a jet ski came and pulled him out. So he says he doesn't know the shim but maybe it's because he finished the daff before he went to the beach and he decided to do the dafom forcham and mi cohenom started from tinus and mi from shiv once again rais just to show you last night we're in the middle of the shir and we got a warning you get a like a 3minut warning that soon there's going to be sirens in all of so here we are this is all of all these people got a siren besides this even down the block there's a siren here in the Bish. There's no siren in the middle of the sh. So we have it's unbelievable what's going on in the Hebrew Shir. We have 12 locations and in the middle of Shir we go in and we visit all 12 locations. Last night we had eight on the screen and it says their name in large. So we're talking to this guy in one location had one person there but the rest had a nice amount. And here they are in Benra. They had to run out in the middle of the year. We went to their location. And we saw the table's empty and then they sent us a picture. But they were learning in the stairwell or whatever it is here. Oh, here it is. Look at this. Awesome. It's Galdi. Look at this place. 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 people there. And here's Minith the guy all by himself. Yeah. Okay. Galdic, it's a start. We just started like two, three weeks ago and it's Mish. It's still going and it's knocking. Boy, welcome back. I know. Uh uh Marshkinazi just texted me right before she he said it just we just made Abdullah like we've been we've been in Mozant already for who knows how long. It seems like ages. I wrote it. It's like one of the things of living here. You guys what? You had a huh that's what we tell. Try to convince yourself. Try to convince yourself. Especially seeing all the Israelis going on the bus and you're sitting there. I know I know very terrible sponsor by anonymous monthly sponsors actual lives in honor of David Mkin of Eastern Union all the silver spring daffers Ellie Dyman for the F of Ben Rifka anonymous in honor of Marshazzi. is the weekly sponsors. I wanted to make but this is the first link I see less than 15 minutes 15 days left to yeah there's only 15 days left to we're starting I don't know if there's any gumaras left for the Hebrew but you could definitely donate for the English we're looking for at least a thousand gumaras change people's lives and if not at least bring people to the daf anonymous in honor of rebellion his family and the whole MD1 staff to continue to spare Daily sponsors anonymous having surgery this morning. Appreciation for rebellations and Mrs. Leanski art of the month rebellion the whole staff to continue to make so enjoy so many in honor of his client and marazi for all the work they do said that only took about a minute. Okay. It's not the end of the world. Here's the sh today. We have DNA evidence. How do we view DNA evidence in Allah? How do we view? You hear the question. Can we use DNA evidence? For what issue? For Meros, for Aguno. Let's say we found a DNA swab and we know the guy. This This might be her husband. He's dead. Could she remarry? How do we view DNA evidence? Show me. You're smiling. Did you write about this in this week's thing? Really? Not this week. Not this week. Okay. Three years ago. Three years ago. I definitely don't remember. Three years ago. So, we're going to see that according to a lot of the pisk today, DNA evidence is very, very strong and we could use it for many things. This is the a little bit of the that we're going to have today about the something that's very very obvious. What about a polygraph lie detector? Not so much. But you see that the the Gaia courts they do believe in DNA. They they release people from jail based on the DNA. No, they probably they have it helps murder cases as well. All sorts of cases because it's so strong. It's in in the high 90s. whatever the percentage is in the system it's more reliable than I can assist in the system says our in-house attorney who does litigation what do you do what is it called litigation litigation says it's more reliable in the American system it's more reliable than eyewitnesses eyewitnesses are dka not so reliable right even two of them that saw together correct even two of them don't do they ever have that in uh eyewitnesses are not so reliable they're We're we by the way we we also don't rely on those witnesses. Not joking. Some guy drunk guy says, "Oh, I saw what use it in combination with in combination with okay so just to remind it's to to get a grab at. You don't have to, but this is what we're going to be doing tonight." Yesterday we asked a question. Two people witnessed something. The litigant, the guy, the he wants the two witness to testify. He asked him to testify and they refuse to testify. They say they don't know. So the tells us this is only in a monetary case. In other cases, they're not. It only has to do with money. How do we know that? So there's four reasons. Yesterday we did three. Today we're going to do the fourth. Yesterday we had that says remember the double the double says it says and basically what we're going to do today is go back on all these things. So we're going to I'm going to show you what is and what is I'm just quick review. We're going to go a little bit deeper into each one says it says in the only to one. So you got to pick it's either mus or something else. It's only mus only one of these things. The obvious question is it doesn't say mus. So maybe means only forus exists not for m who told is going to talk about that. This is how we finished off. It says in theus either or either he saw with his eyes or he knows about something they know or they saw. says that only applies in mus in mus. If we witnessed money going from one to the other, we could come and testify that we saw somebody give money. Now, it's possible that he was repaying a loan. It was possible that he was buying something. It was possible that he was his messenger. But since the other guy denies it completely and we witnessed money going from him to him, so we believe that guy that was alone. That only applies by mus. You can't have, let's say, a case of where they witnessed something. They saw a guy kill somebody, but they don't know what they saw. Maybe it was a killing an Arab. Maybe he's killing a terrorist. If you don't have a ya, you can't testify about it. You can't be. And if if there's a without seeing, you can't there's no there's no such thing. You can't testify in court that you know that so- and so killed, but you didn't see with your own eyes. Even if you know but you didn't see. So that option of either or could only apply in and finally now we're going to talk about super interesting he starts off with he moves on to and then he goes to all three. So again what are we trying to find out here? How do you know that applies only in monetary cases and not in anything else? So holding like five six lines from the bottom of the [Music] base. The Torah says and the Torah says what's that I asked you to watch my item items are. So this is a just like it's referring to a monetary case. You watch my dog, you watch my goldfish and made it into fish. Whatever it is, you watch my mus. It's a simple simple you see by talking about mus. So too you're talking about mus. In addition to that I say I have a simple only we make a distinction why it's a testimony it's so you have to be so you can't be a woman you can't be a relative you can't be apostle you can't be a ganov you can't So that's the by you could be a you could be apostle and you say I swear I don't have your goldfish. That's it. you're over could be a woman as we discussed yesterday that if a person swears five times in front of he's only one because it's what does mean? He testified he testified that this is what happened. I don't know So once you testify you're locked out. You can't testify again. So all the five all the five only equal one. But even for each and if you deny again and again I don't have your goldfish. I swear I don't have your goldfish. I swear I don't have your goldfish. It's five certainly. And over there here's the over there. It's only a monetary thing. where we're more you can't be a relative. You can't be a possible you can't be a woman and you can only swear once in front of not five times and certainly the is only talking about a monetary obligation. So the ask a question and it's to remember this question because in they made fun of this. They made they said doesn't know what he's talking about. At the end, the Gar is going to discuss what what was so funny and the Gar can't figure it out. But there's there's such a thing. So the says in there's a concept where the guy that was in a car accident, he demands that you come and testify for him. He sets you up for the he asks you could you I know that you know and you say I don't know That's how it works. You say I don't know. Or you could say the difference between the two. What's the difference between if you say or you say I don't know? One is when you say it's as if you yourself said the other one is what is such a thing called we don't have it's only that's one difference that's why you can't make if I deliberately don't say I know that I have. I don't want to say it. I have to bring a carbon. So is different. Okay. Says says, "Okay, so now I'm going to go to my third lim." Here it is. It says says that's and then it says so we have it says the same word over here same word over there. So just like just like Yeah, this is the third time we're saying he's talking about a monetary case. Great. Now we're going back to the list. Okay. So now we're going to take care of this list one by one. We're done with all the way in the bottom. We saw he started out with we went to we had then we had we learned from now we're going to go to the top says what's the says that says it says that by it says we have by the way We sang this last night. You guys, you don't have to sing it. I told him this is a song. Does anybody know what song this is? Yeah. What's new? [Music] [Laughter] He likes it. Okay, good. It's like the story. [Laughter] All my stories are the story. You're just going to cop one day. Okay. [Music] The dad in the morning before the coffee such a song. Oh, here the Israelis here from the Hebrew here. So says [Laughter] that sums it up. So says to learn from from have something else it also says and what's a we had talking about what kind of is any has nothing to do with money then I'm not gonna eat a loaf of bread why is that money I'm gonna do jumping jacks it's not not money. So says and and what's enough if I learn from here I don't have to say this doesn't have to be only money it could be anything so if you recall yesterday we said we had the same question we had the question maybe and we said no why is not a but is awar says oh over there it has a kay we don't want a kay no k so now we have a third thing we have no there is a and it's not so learn from there it's perfect it lines up with we don't have to worry about a here and yet it's not who told you to learn from where it is monetary things it's better to learn from we saw before a second ago It says so we have it looks it's very similar has the same thing has a carbon so does so they're very similar in that not the same words is not the same words it's the same thing within it the same what to bring to bring a ka say have chicane. Here we have a little list to make it easier. I just threw in the the words on top. We're we're talking about you can learn from picaden which is mus and you can learn from bi which is not m. The difference is that picadin has four things that are similar to and bi only has three. So I rather learn from the one that has four. What are the four things it says the word in the same thing even so that we had already that you know you have to invoke you have to ask him for the you have to demand the and then he gives you let's say we had yesterday if the guy runs away from him if the guy's chasing him in a car beeps him but he didn't say with his mouth it's not awah the a means means it's in the past. We're it's in this is interesting because BTO is also in the past. We learned according to one man it's in the but the the main is in the future. It says the main one is in the future and it's not happening. Huh? Did anyone turn their phones off, please? This guy is on a I know what I told you. It's your fault. Yeah. They You didn't take today. No. Okay, we'll give you we'll give you a tour says. Oh, I have to drink. I don't even know. I didn't make a I guess. I hope you didn't put it in here like that with the Reb. The kid put it in and then then the Reb started behaving. Yeah. talking about. So where I have no idea where we're holding Oh. Oh, no. I'm talking about now. It's also is could be a little bit. But what's is always in the is testimony. I'm saying that something I saw, not something I'm going to see. You don't testify it's something you're going to see. So that's why it's it's more connected to but it makes more sense to go to the left to be why and therefore what it's not m okay okay okay okay screw like two white hairs okay it's good it's a good one but we did it a bunch of times you can't sing the same song every day you bring a carbon kos What kind? It's a different type of This is different. You don't bring a You don't have to add a 25% search charge. Says, "You're right. There's a bunch of things that are similar but not enough. There's only three versus four. I much rather learn from a place that's more similar because it has four versus three. We're going to have the same exact thing similar later on this. Now we have to go back to here we go ribba. What does Rika say? How do I know that's say this is only a monetary because it says in the so we're going to do eight lines of now just explain and then we go we move on to the next one which is you see like somewhere in the middle of the there's only certain things what's the case if it's a monetary thing or anything else who told that the word means mus says he's in cahoots with yeah he holds like the first one so if he holds like that we learn from so why does he need the word what's going on here oh we're going to learn from to remove one thing that is monetary one object one item in the monetary column is going to come off according to says if they both learn from like this like the song then why do I need if you have what's the most valuable thing today real estate I can't think of anything that's more valuable than a piece of real estate yeah Cool. [Laughter] Tora. Very good. Very good. I said in the monetary world, I didn't say the maybe Okay, fine. A nice building in uh in Manhattan in in Dubai. $2.5 billion. If I ask you to testify about my building that it's mine and you say no, is that money or not? So that's where the is going to be according to it's you have to it's worth money. So it's according to it should be mus. You're right. But he has a that says I got to remove one item. I'm going to remove the thing that's the least that looks the least like money which is real estate. Now the problem is but according to everybody holds it's not momentous real estate is not momentous what I do come that was the question that we had yesterday is a penalty like there's a 50 shekele penalty is that considered mus or not because I have the ability to be okay so according to it's not muscc next on the says again write since it says in the of here in the of this it says it doesn't say that you have to have both of those components it's either or says the only place in the world you have either or and it would work for us is by monetary things not by anything Even if you if the witnesses saw and they don't know and if they know and they don't see should we do it real quickly. So if Avi Kamyansski gave $1,000 to Mendy and we all saw it so we could testify that Avi lent money to Mendy. Why? Because mendy says it never happened. So once he says it, we don't see he says it never happened. So he is a haf. We already we saw it. So he's lying. Once he's lying, we're going to trust him that it was a loan cuz if he doesn't if he's not lying, if he says, "Yeah, he gave me money." But guess what? I lent him money the day before. He's just returning it. So we we trust him. So that's a without we have no idea what happened. The ad without Aria is that in front of everybody, Mendy got up and said, "I borrowed $1,000 from from Avi." Now, we never saw it. We didn't see it, but he told us. So, that's that's a that's knowledge without seeing it. That's enough. says says perhaps doesn't hold a because is the one that says there's very there's I don't know how you say it in English circumstantial evidence no like a beyond of doubt circumstantial evidence that's enough there must be a good way to say it in You have a wild male camel that basically when they mate they go crazy and the rashba explains that camels have a certain sne and if anybody sees them in the act they kill them which reminds me of a misa a guy comes into a bank this is not yum kipper guy comes into the bank he holds up the everybody in the bank he says everybody in the right now and if you see me, if you saw my face, I'm going to kill you." See, he takes all the money and everything. As he's leaving, he goes over to one guy. He goes, "I believe that you saw my face. I'm going to have to kill you." He says, "I promise you I didn't see you. I did not see you, but my wife did look at you." And you Okay. So there's something look this is not the best but you have two males uh they have this white foam coming out of their mouth and guns in a different world and they they fight and they kill each other. We had a better one but the the editor took it out. He said there was a woman in the in the audience out. Okay. So pretty soon there's like a knocks him down over there. A powerful zomb. Okay, now we come we we see this guy going crazy. 2 minutes later we see a dead camel on the ground. We all know who killed him, but we didn't see the we didn't see it happen. We We didn't see Yeah. It's like the cheetah. We saw the cheetah chasing. And then we see a dead animal. But we didn't see we didn't see the micer. It happens to be that we wouldn't be able to be testify in in uh in court. I don't think we saw the chase. We saw knocked down until he in the civil court 100%. I'm talking about in it's not even circumstantial. We saw him after. We saw him lifting after but we didn't see the it's not direct evidence. We literally saw it after. We saw before. We saw it after. We saw knock him down. Okay. I don't know exactly in how that will work. It's interesting. But everybody with a half a brain knows that this is the camel that's that's um here's the killer camel. If you hold of the of this the circumstantial evidence thing Oh, check this out. This is something that took Yoshi about six hours. Look at this ma. There's a this actually saw this happening. Here it goes. If you look at the knife, there's blood dripping off the knife. And you look at the guy, you see the blood dripping. And the guy's moving still. And Shim is yelling at him. Look what happens to the snake. Something's going on there with the snake. Snake bit him. Oh, he says something like that is six hours. He sent me the whole to show me how the different tries and how many times it took to do each scene. Okay. What progression today? Very. So it says like this. I'll see the in other words I won't see the ghoul if I didn't see. Basically it's like he's cursing. He's saying I I I I swear that I saw this. This is what I saw with my own eyes. Even in those days, people told Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Sure. Yeah. Yeah. You saw this and a snake came. Yeah. Of course. He says, "No, no, no. I won't see the A guy was chasing his friend into the ruins and I ran after him and he saw a sword in his hand and and blood is dripping right off the sword. carpet. It's not like the dead guy was sitting there in what is it called? Rigo mortise. Rigor mortise. Yeah. What is it? Rigor mortise. Rigor mortise. It's not like the guy was there dead for for a day. The guy is dying. You see the wounds. You see the blood coming out of the guy. You see the blood dripping off the knife. The guy is not even dead yet. He's dying. He's not dead yet. And and and and there's nobody around. It's it's the middle of the midbar. He's he's he's whatever. How do you say in English? Twitching. twitching and I say to this guy, "Russia, who killed this guy?" I know it's not me. It's only you. It's the two of us here. I can't kill you. I cannot kill you unless there's witnesses. The the evidence here is beyond the circumstantial evidence is beyond reasonable doubt. It's not even reasonable. It's the biggest. It's 99% if you had 99%. I do I can't kill you will kill you. It says what happened was a snake came and killed him. I asked I asked yesterday. I called him up. He didn't remember. He said, "Yeah, you remember something?" He wrote this story. It's somewhat related here. That's this is like the story. There's yeshiva he says yeshiva who was in some sort of accident and had a very hard time walking let alone running couldn't could barely walk and he read a book from a guy that writes that it's mind over matter. It's all in your head and you could heal your body through you know good thoughts and tell your body to heal itself. So he contacted this author and he said I want to meet you. gave him a lot of. So the guy said, "Okay, I'm in a some army base in America. Come to the army base." He left. He took it seriously. He left. Yeah. No, invite there. Uh so I'm kidding. He left. He did leave, but not because of me. Uh so so the guy tells him, "Go to the army. Come to the army base. I'm giving some sort of seminar there to the injured soldiers." So he goes there and it's like a few day thing. He's smooing with the guy and the guy explaining to him you have to think you positive thoughts the whole thing. One day he's walking around in the army base and he sees like a group of people sitting around the circle and the the wrestling a wrestling match and two big guys two soldiers are there the wrestling one guy had the other guy pinned down he's about to win and all a sudden this goes flying you heard what I said get back in get coming there. Okay. Oh you heard me saying there. Wow. Here, zoom in on his camera. Wow. On his phone. Mhm. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Look at this technology. You are listening. I came back. Wow. Good. Nice. That's nice. I like that. Galdic. You made up for that other thing you did. Okay. Give. So now he's in. Now he's bring him back. All of a sudden, the goes flying and knocks the soldier that had the pin. He knocks him and the guy goes off. The guy gets up. He says, "What do you do? I almost I almost beat him. I'm going to kill you." In front of pulls out a knife and he start chasing him. So she starts running running and goes around the thing and he's running and two minutes later he goes, "Wait a minute. It doesn't make any sense. This guy's a healthy soldier. I'm a and how how come he's not catching up to me? Doesn't make any sense." And he he turns around and all of a sudden like the the guy that wrote the book he comes out he said you see it was all a setup. So he wanted to show him that if he if his life is in danger he could run like it's it's something [Music] of how does that have to do with this men? You have no idea. Okay. It's always so good. No, it's within here. So it says oh fine. Does anybody remember here we have this Gar in San and Gar asks why was he bitten by snake? Snake isa you don't get sraa for killing somebody. Anybody remember that answer? The gumar asked the question. where it says he must have done something like with a or something on a different paid him for both even if you hold this works circumstantial evidence that's beyond a shadow of a doubt that you would be able to kill for that and then and he would hold would hold that that works by that if you're having without it would work let's say there's such a Okay. So I have this case a guy was running after somebody with a knife. So I have a I have knowledge without actually seeing the act and but the other part is impossible. Why? Maybe he's killing a terrorist. Maybe he killed somebody that was going to die anyways. Fine. So what's answer? What's answer? It's not possible in in in one case, but it's possible in the other case. So it's possible with a y without a but it's not possible with the without a y. It's not possible to kill somebody based on evidence that witnesses saw somebody killing somebody, but they don't know what they saw. That you can't do. But you could you could kill somebody even if you hold like that you could kill somebody based on the the knowledge with that ria that you could do. So what's the answer then? You need both. You need why do you need both? What do you mean? You need one or the other. Oh, exactly. The P says that Pik must be talking about only M. Cuz in M you can do both. either raw or ask but I have a case by that I don't need both I could have just knowledge and I kill somebody based on knowledge you're right even if you hold that you could kill somebody based on knowledge but you don't have the flip side you don't have only and the says so the cannot be talking about the must be talking about only says based on this logic what if there somebody that saw that somebody's ma is someone and the father says listen that guy owes me 50 shekele I want you to testify that you saw it and he says no you see from here that you why it's possible that you the same exact thing you saw a man chasing a woman into and you know that she's before she's not absula after but you didn't see what happened inside the so it's the same exact case as so you have a without so You're right. It works, but it wouldn't work. On the flip side, made the Goya. You don't know. You don't have the knowledge. So, you only saw the act, but you didn't you don't have the the the information. Maybe she's a Goya. Maybe she's a basis. Maybe she's bulli Maybe she's a may I'm sorry. Maybe she the whole the only time if she's absolut You don't know. You don't have information. Without information, you can't be cannot be going on can only go on regular musc. So now we're doing that whole thing over again. It's what gave $1,000 to the seen from the outside. In other words, the guy has no clue that looking at him. They're watching him answers him. What does the other guy say? And if if Meny denies it completely, he says, "I never received any money from the guy from so we know that Mendi is a liar. Of course, Meni should be to to the money and but if he says yes, I took he doesn't even know that are watching and he's a good guy. He's saying the truth. He's saying I took the $1,000. But you know what? He owed it to me. He also habi. So what if Adam testified that Abby gave money to Meni? Meni already explained it away. You shall come up here to yeshiva. In other words, you're great. This is exactly the if he denies it completely, we trust. If he doesn't deny it and he admits to what happened, then we don't trust sponsor. We have a special sponsor today turning the D innovations in honor of our sons and for learning and with rebell. And here it is global going global on the east coast. See you there. So Simon you must have noticed that's slightly quiet today. So he flew to America and he wants to be he's going to go from place to place over there. He's going to flap the what is it called? What is it called over there? Man, manage manitz. He's going there. There he is. Say something. We miss you. Say something. Put it Put the volume on. Gary, put the volume on. We see the subway. Be safe. I want to hear the subway. I want to hear the subway. You know, every day. Every day. Every day. What line is it? Don't show any. No vibers. No vibers. We're going to have to I want to hear the subway. No, just one time. The So, we heard it for a second. Lafayette doors doors closing now. You remember that? Oh, yeah. The New York subway. Fra. And I took the F train every single day. It's 1:00 a.m. It's 1. You're This always jam-packed at 1:00 a.m. The city that never sleeps. My boy, he's a good guy. Simon saves money by taking the training, donates it to MDY. Look at that. Here's a guy that donated $50,000 this year to MDY and he takes the subway at 1:00 a.m. You know what? MDY should sponsor his Uber or something. I don't we can't we can't afford him getting hurt over there in the subway. Oh. Oh, there's one more anonymous in honor of Marshin said it's the air. It's not It's not the subway. Oh, it's airr the airport. Are you sure? But it sounded Yeah. Yeah. I feel like it sounded good. Maybe he was making that sound. Okay. He's catching it live. You were saying somewhere he was nodding. Yeah. Yeah. Wait a minute. Time out. Oh, he he's Israeli. He's not He doesn't do it, but he landed in America on Wow. It's very Okay. What happened? Oh, we said this already. I have a friend that told me that he goes into his backyard and he sees a sign that has on it. So he asked what's why why did you put up a sign here? The guy says every day a guy comes from the bus stop. He comes to the backyard and does his thing. Might as well be There used to be no tree there. There was a tree. I gave you $1,000 right here by this beam. I have no idea what you're talking about. I never went by this this beam over here. I didn't go by this beam. also trace the two came. He relieved himself right there by that beam. So he's a liar. So says the you know a quick story I got to tell you this quick story. There was a you know I have I have the opportunity to be with them. There's a I have an a that his whole budget for we asked him to come his whole budget for his family for bin manim for this it was like 200 shekel that was the whole budget ser my zero they they have nothing you could understand then I I put myself into this guy's takes his family up north he figured out he's going to take you know a bunch of he's going to take tramps from here to there and he's this gets he has likeund on him. Before I met my wife, I was never in a restaurant. I ne I myself was never in a restaurant. Well, I shouldn't say never. Somebody once took me out, but I I went with my wife. I didn't know how to order. I looked at the menu. I was like, "What do you I had to pretend and she she saw that." Yeah. Yeah. It's all good. Whatever you want, you order. Kids are one of those. Here's a a never in a restaurant in their life. They can't afford a restaurant. So this is one of his kids had to go to the bathroom really badly. He's by a restaurant. He looks he walks in. He asked the the lady there, the matraee if if they could use the bathroom. She she looks around. She says, "Yeah, go go go." Gets it. Goes into the bathroom. He comes out. The manager jumps and says, "What are you doing? You just going to come in here and use my bathroom? What are you this?" And he, you know, it's all about meas. and he looks he looks at he was about to say but she gave me permission and he sees that she's turning colors and that he realized that she wasn't allowed to give him that permission. So he had a car to her because she she went she kind of broke the rule for him and he didn't want to throw her under the bus. So she tells the guy look I I was I was going to eat her. What do you mean? My family's outside just real quick but we're going to sit and eat it. We're going to eat her. Ah sorry sorry kids. He goes out tells his family they're going to the restaurant. Yeah. They're jumping up and down. They're going to they sit down the whole thing. And uh this woman this matraee she starts crying. She she tell so the guy the man says why you cry? She said that this guy didn't want to eat here and he only did it so that I don't get into trouble. She tells him the whole story that she gave him permission and so the guy says the meal's on me. He goes to the guy and says I'm giving you a free meal. Free meal. All right. This has everything to do with the sugia because they had to go to the bathroom over there. masculin. It's a good story. This is what you're saying makes zero sense. Did the guy say I never pass this beam? Basically, he said I I don't you telling me you let me money by the beam. I don't know about the beam. Of course, he he he walks by the beam every day. What he was trying to say is I didn't do a deal by the beam. Some say same story. I gave you $1,000 by that beam. So over here they stick in the word never in my life. So then say no, you were there. You did your business by this being that's a liar because he said he was never there. And so somebody else something that's important to a person. Everybody in this room probably remembers exactly where they were and what they were doing when they found out that Twin Towers fell, right? Everybody remembers exactly, you know, the other generation was when Kennedy was assassinated. Certain things when when it's important, when it's lifealtering, you remember where you are. You remember there's things that are not important. exactly where I went to the bathroom when I what I did what I didn't do as how do you remember so much he says if you saw a bird lifting up a building would you remember it yeah every piece of is like that for me it's just everything is amazing I remember so says first he says if is much lighter than why because it's So and then we had a what's a oh is different. So says good morning. So just to remind everybody who's so for that you have to go to San and you go to the monopoly game and over there it says stop they made fun of this. What was what did they make fun? Oh, the cousin is different. Why? Because over there, if somebody invokes a doesn't work, you have to do it by yourself. And over there, if you're amazed, you don't have to bring a carbon. Check this out. I'm going to remind you and everything. It's going to be beautiful. Remember, how do you know? Doesn't say anything. It talks about doesn't say anything about it only. So says since you learn one from the other. I'll remind you if you do we're not going to so don't even worry about it. But you learn you learn from oh says how do I know in I learned from so let's say theor says let's do the reverse we already did this in remember does come with the doesn't have so you ask me oh it's different they're not different so learn it here. Why shouldn't you learn it? It goes both goes both ways. If if I'm going to learn, I'm going to learn to they have the same words. I learned these here and I learned these there. So, just learn. What's so funny about that? You're right. could go both directions only goes in one direction. Why does go in one direction? Cuz one is more severe than the other. That's it only goes in one direction. The should be more than the what's and just think about it logically. If somebody can invoke a to me, can't I do it myself? Of course, I can do it myself. But that's only one way. I can't go the other way around. Okay. Okay. So then what's so funny? What's funny is that we said that doesn't have when you do it on purpose that that's funny. Why? How do I even know that if you do on purpose all the around there it says the word vanilla that you forgot and by it doesn't. So even if you don't forget you do it on purpose deliberately says for the same reason why is that funny look at this beautiful says the word when you use something from the English it says and over there look what it says in the it's only on by accident not on purpose so I'm going to learning from that's why it's so funny. Why would you learn from learn it from something similar that has that's use very very similar words says that we had other say oh so doing the same exact thing all over And I have Picardine and I have Picard I can learn from Elah which is shing but I can also learn Picard from which is also amazing. So we do one of these. It's six against five and it wins. Five six wins. So let's just do it quickly. First of all it says the word mil means it applies to all human beings. means you don't have to be cauter like that you have to be cauter is something that you benefit you enjoy because you stole the goldfish you made the filter fish it's something that you benefit you don't you don't have enjoyment it has one carbon not a carbon like it's a it's a it's a it's a one carbon and you have to bring I'm sorry you have to add 25% you have to bring the is the that it's belongings that belong to a private person and it's somebody has to demand and you deny it and we have the words on six against five is better so funny right it's so why did he why he has so why didn't he just use the same to out what do you mean once you have everything the same it's it's why is that funny he wanted to do without he wanted to prove himself with why you can't mix two things up he wanted to say I can learn this from without any help says at the end of the day once he has there's no there's no who says that there's no there's no there's no so you see that even after the he doesn't learn everything one from the other there's no ma you should learn from that there is ma says amazing part. Do we should we stop here? Hold on. I wanted to go to the Mishna but okay we'll have to stop mish in the middle of we'll just go back real quickly. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a shir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.