Daf Yomi Shevuos Daf 33 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning [Music] rais. How was it? [Laughter] Hello Rebell MDY family. I missed this email. I just saw it last night. I have to read it. comes from on May 27th. So just a few days before Yantiff. My name is Ben Miller and I'll give a brief description of my upbringing. I grew up in Brooklyn, New York. I went to a modern yeshiva my entire life. Shout out to Dora in Brooklyn and MTA in Washington Heights and was always known to be a sporty kid in school but never into anything academic let alone gimbara. About 11th grade, I experimented with drugs. And due to that, I gave up on sports and lost many of the good friends I've made throughout my life. Fast forward four years later, I was sitting in rehab trying to figure out how to get a hold of my life. I was left with many psychological issues from the substances. Doctors told me there was a major chance I'd never be mentally the same. This is when my tears reached new heights of kavana and I begged Hashem for one more shot at life. And after a few months, Hashem delivered as he always does. After Hashem healed me from my psychological issues, proving all the doctors wrong, I wanted to devote my life to him as much as I possibly can. Since he saved my 2023, Hashem helped me find MDY. After not taking seriously, a day in my life, I started implementing other things like mikra. Oh no, I I think I skipped. I finally found a way to learn with true understanding connection. Once I started doing the daf, I started implementing other things like mikra going to shakras in the early morning before I start my workday. I now pray three times a I read to him and do muser. And after dating for 3 years and trying to find my other half, Hashem helped me find the person for me. Today is the special day because I'm getting married. I feel I owe a lot of it to MDY. I'm so thankful. You guys are going to love this coming up right now. I'm so thankful Hashem helped me find you when I was trying to better myself as a Yid. I know Relli would want to take all the credit for this. I totally get it. Lol. But honestly, just like how marriage is a partnership between the andem and the puts it all together. If it wasn't for Hashem helping me find them and me putting the effort to give it a shot, I don't know if I'd be here today. I'll be praying for the MDY family under the Tonight. I just wanted to say thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Ben Miller Maztov Maztov you should should buy build a neon thank you so much for gant yeah so it's very interesting dam I I think it's a record I gave the shear in the space five times the same daff five times and there's some no one was here for five maybe maybe Dave were you here for all Five. No. At a certain point, ask him a question. Ask him a question. I asked him to say over the stories. I was like, I hope he wasn't listening. Certain people just getting under my skin like this is the third time. I can't say the same story three times. What are you doing here? Go get a life. Do something else. Learn a different daff. Go learn your Xiaomi. Anyway, so one of the times one of the times I gave it I didn't I didn't think I like I wasn't thinking and all of a sudden I get a message from Mark. Oh boy. Get a life message. That's a message. Uh it's starting up again. He's like uh maybe some people are asking could you just do the she because it's and I forgot about the two thing. So after after the uh the the sheir here in Hebrew which is this two shir for that day for yantive. So I gave another shar that she had a few thousand views before Yvow on Torah any time 700 views just on forget the YouTube and everything else. So I guess it was I received below 30 emails thanking me for that cheer. I didn't realize it's like important to people. They feel like you feel like what you said you watched it also. No interesting. Okay. It was the English year took an hour last night and that show was a half hour but it took 20 minutes to start the year. But okay, that's a different story. Ariel Jacob, thank you so much for giving that chantive. It made my whole day. I'm a psychiatrist, medical educator, and 3D animator. Listen to this. I make the daily 3D zikru animations, you know. Huh? No, it's not me. Okay. With a nor newborn and four other kids, I often sleep very few hours, but at least 10 nap in the afternoon during the day. Today I have after having slept 2 hours last night. In other words, he slept all night. I can't fall asleep for not not for one minute. I was he looks forward to tremendously. It's my one nostalgic yeshiva experience of the year. When I opened up and saw that you put to Marir, I listened to it with joy. Feel so much energy, headache from not sleeping. The kitser I'm so happy I listened. I probably won't be staying up tonight, but I think I would have been in bad mood despite my attitude had not been for the everyone to share. Thank you so much from the bottom of my heart posting just for me. I hope to meet it was worth justing for him. Hope to meet one day even without the get over here Jacob. I myself for the last few years because of this urim I I just can't stay up the whole night. It's very hard for me because I I like it's hard for me not to stay up the whole night. It's like what do you mean you don't stay my since I'm 5 years old I went with my father to sh stayed up the whole night and then I come to sh I figured there's going to be a minion here huge but what happens is a lot of people they stay up till 3 4:00 and then dive in the later minion. So it's it's a thing now. So, and one thing that I I don't I don't know if I ever paid attention to this, but two people told me just yesterday they stayed up till which was 4:09 and from 4:09 so that then you like then you be the thing of staying up the whole night. The night is over at 4:09. It's not till the night it's till and then they go to sleep for an hour or to the next minion. Anyway, all right. Um discovered that they say Russ Yeah. Fine. Let's just do the thing. Let's jump into Let's time how long it takes. 23 actualize an art of David Merc all the silver weekly sponsors in honor of Marshazzi. I want to donate Garas, but this is the first link I see. This is crazy for the Hebrew Shear. You're not going to believe this. They're trying to get a thousand gumar for Hebrew. They raised already 950. It's unbelievable. The the English needs a lot of help. We need more GMAR for English. MDY kids monthly innovations official. Oh, our English editor Shimmy Liowitz had a baby girl. That's I'm looking here like where the sponsors for today. No sponsor. He's in the hospital over there somewhere. Any weekly sponsor anonymous said Mrs. Art of the month for rebellion staff to continue to make so many for all the work they do. Not so bad. It was a minute a little bit over a minute. It says in the a lot of times it says the word if you know the answer to this do not answer. What does sumas mean? You hear no. What does sum? What does it mean? Anybody? Okay. Even if you know the answer. No, you know that. No. What does it mean? Huh? What does it mean? Huh? So the Misha says and Rashi says it means a loan. It means to take something and put in something somebody's hand to take money put in their hand. In other words, it's another lion for alone. We're holding two lines from the bottom line. Again, if you look at the top of the page, we're dealing with is when a person knows testimony and he swears that he doesn't know the testimony. You got you gotten reported and put past the two dots yesterday. It where on you got to the two dots, right? Where did I get to last night? Oh, I'm crying. Oh, you're saying I I missed out for the guys. Go back to the video tape. Sorry. What if you have two You have That's fine. I I'll tell you what. Whoever wants to stay after we'll do it. It's fine. We'll have There's two and two. Two Adam and two. Two sets of Adam. The first set of Adam deny knowing any adus they're and then the second uh the second two they also deny ask we should have we should have asked this in the Mishna I understand that the second uh pair of that are left over they're they're on say this because again let's remember what will say this when somebody denies testimony that causes a monetary loss only in a monetary loss. But the first pier is not causing a monetary loss. Why? Because there's a second pair- because the sec the second one obviously because they're left and they could help this guy in a monetary loss. Why are the first pair of they're not causing a loss? Why? because there's two more guys that are available to testify [Music] says the gimra 100%. So it comes out like this according to the if there's four two and two and the first cat denies it they're not they're not even will say this in this case in the it's a funny case what happened was the second pair of they're related they married sisters so their brother-in-law cause and they can't testify. So when the first pair of denied knowing anything, they were the only Adam available. Oh, you're the only Adam available. So, okay, so they're the only ones available. So then what's the says the is that both of these women, one or two, even if two, let's say, they're both on the verge of dying. So maybe I would say dummy. No, even though you all know, most of you know the joke, but we got to say it again. It's a when you say something like this. There's a guy that was gising. He was on the verge of dying and all a sudden he took he took a it hit him. He smelled the potato cook coming out of the kitchen. So he tells his son, "Go get me a piece of potato cook." So son comes back after two weeks he says mommy says for see there's three people that didn't hear it like this if this woman actually dies then they could testify but they're not dead yet they're almost dying. So that's the from the beginning. Oh, what's your kasha? They're not at age. They were craving. Oh, so yeah, that's very good. If they were related and they saw what they saw a loan take place when they were related, then they can never testify even if they're wives. So Ta says it has to be that they got married afterwards. Five. Yeah, this is a very interesting case. A seriously interesting case. When does two the Mishna says all the Mishna says this two pers the first one is must be that they were related through marrying wives uh sisters only after they saw the loan and and then they they were dying. There's a lot of stuff going on here. They're dying. They're almost dead, not really dead. And that's the and we should have figured that out when we're reading the says the we're we're holding with that are very very light very easy few already and it's you know I'm saying this because in just like 15 days or so we're starting a brand And it's going to be and start thinking about the people we got to get into this. I I want you to testify for me that so and so was watching something for me. If you didn't see this video 10 times, it's to see it again. Oh, it's not even here. It's here somewhere. No. Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Here. Yeah. I see it. I'll just I'm going to continue reading. You can you can watch it. There's a loan. And there's also also he stole from me. And wow, this is long. And he also found my bike and doesn't want to return it. They're watching 1.75. Yeah, we got to we got to like really speed this up. Oh, with the sign. He takes the sign out a second. Oh, you have a video about I didn't say this in a while. I have to tell you this uh this guy came actually this year. His name is Adal. Me and Mayor Kenny, we years ago we took a course. He's considered he used to be a pilot in the Israeli Air Force. He's a gen he's a very very smart guy and uh he gives a a course in coaching. So there's a he used to tell us that he he could manipulate your brain to to think anything basically. So he's very good at if you have any sort of fear. Let's say he's scared of dogs whatever it is he one session he can knock it out for life. So yeah yeah sure sure. So he never wanted to show us. And so one day this guy was very stubborn. He says come on show us. He says, 'What do you want me to stop?' He says, I drink Coke all day long. I have a terrible habit. I can't stop drinking Coca-Cola. I love Coke. A cold Coke. This guy was a spar. So, he says, "Okay, fine." He says, "Uh, describe the Coke." He says, "The Coke has it's like the condensation on the outside of the glass. It's like dripping down. It's full of ice. It's so gush." So, he says, "Now tell me the thing that you hate the most, Sparty. you filled the fish. He said in in like five minutes he gets this guy. He says, "Okay, okay, now you focus." Like he's putting him in a trance. Finally says, basically what he did was he told him that the Coke is gila fish. Every time he drinks Coke, it's going to take taste like gila fish. Okay? And he's done. And then he went out. So he got went to the machine and he bought a Coke and he brings it back and the guy says, "Ah, get it away from me. Get away." He's like, he's for two months. This guy, every time he came back, we asked him, "No, do you do you drink?" He says, "No, I can't drink Coke. It's disgusting. Tastes like gap filter fish." Lice after two two months of wore off. He's filter fish. Anyway, he's also eating gila fish now. Yeah. No, he has a gaper fish problem. He's eating he's drinking Coke with Gila fish. It goes together, right? Yeah. The guy that he he's not scared of dogs anymore. He bought Oh, I told the guys last night. I said these Oh, time out. Hold. If I Well, you're going to like this. This has to do with the safari. I said if the if the if if the Israelis want to stop if the Israelis want to stop every Afghan ever, I came with the Makap last night. All they have to do is bring a bunch of poodles to all every Afghan. The the US, they hate dogs like crazy. Come with a poodle. Gone. Zuckaro Gzel. Uh, one last thing I got to tell you, then we're gonna learn to There's one. Every time you go to night stroll, a go a walks in. You're going to like this. Go walks in. Any any rash y. So this guy, this boy, he hears this yam. He looks around, there's no rashiva, nothing. So he jumps into the circle. He pretends he's the rashiva. All of a sudden, he gets a tap on the shoulder, turns around, the guy says, "It's my yum. What are you doing? He stole his yum." He stole his yimazel. Yeah. These guys didn't appreciate it. Loved it. Loved it. guys don't with so after he says all these things that you have my you saw the loan you saw the gaz you saw he says they say in one chat one statement we swear we didn't see anything we don't know anything you saw my gzle you saw my gz everybody understood those who don't don't have one But if they specify and they repeat everything he said now for each and everyone now the mission just repeats itself it's three different items before Rash says it's one min in different ways money and gazel and over here. It's three different types. It's wheat. It's barley spelt. They say they swear once that they don't know anything that one denial. But if they specify, we don't know about we don't know about each and every one. Oh, so now the mission list nine different things. I want you to testify for me that so and so he injured me here. Here's the list. NZ nezek is damages like right over here damages. ious. The next thing on the list is when a an animal who never caused any damage, the first three times that it causes damage, the owner has to pay 50%. Or I want you to testify. So and so stole something from me and he owes me double or Let's say he stole a lamb. So he only has to pay four. If he stole an bull and a cow, something larger, has to pay five. Sold it. These are all claims, monetary claims cuz the the has to pay the father also. and my son hit me. So my son owes me money. Why? Because we're talking about in this Mishna B we're going to be talking about the real case of a son causing with blood. But over here there's no blood and if there's no blood he's not. So therefore the son has to pay. So again a monetary claim and they say we don't know. My friend beat me up so also owes money. Oh, check this out. With the in hand with [Music] the he burnt my my onion. Now there's no but there's so we're going according to that says that there's no when it comes to carus what's there's a greater punishment like the death penalty capital punishment so if the bez is going to kill you you don't have to pay for the wheat you you don't get two punishments but since it's not going to kill you will take care of you so you have to pay for the so in all these nine cases these are all monetary losses if you don't testify somebody someone is going to lose money and you swear that you don't know based on our mission perhaps we have a resolution to this question. Let's say there's a penalty aas. How do we view a penalty? On the one hand, we said that the only thing that foros is a monetary loss. So, how do we look at how do we view a penalty? Aas somebody the Mishna mentions some and that's what the Gumar is going to bring. Let's say you stole and the says if you steal you have to pay double. That's so the question is if you admit before you go to bed and you say I stole. So you don't have to pay the double the second portion you have to pay the the principle. So how do we view says I leave according to when a guy comes to bed and says I stole. So they say okay thank you for admitting you don't have to pay the extra the double pay the principal and go home. What happens when two Adam show up the next week afterwards they knock on Besson's door we saw this guy steal. So according to now he has to pay the he's not potter forever. He's only potter there's no according to no once you come to be it's you're potter forever. So if that's the case, says the Gimaro, we must be talking about Oh, this is good. That's Shimmy Leowitz. Very nice. I guess Yoshi did this. I don't know who, huh? It's a girl, I think. Okay. ready. Yeah, she's already drinking a bottle. She's in this. Yeah. So, where are we? I'm looking for this. All these charts. I feel bad for the editor today. Okay. So, we have one is here. Number one is what happens if the Aiden show up after the according to he's potter. We don't care that the adam show up. It's too late. Once he admitted, he admitted. Therefore, according to them, there's a very high probability that it's not considered money. It's not a monetary case. Why? Because anytime you can get out of it, you could just come and and admit your potter. So there's no real monetary loss. You have a way out. Okay? So that's step number one. We have to go according to these. Our question is according to if he admitted to something that causes him to pay double to any let's say he comes to he says I was so the 50 shekel that the t says is obviously a kas because every woman's father gets the 50 there's no oh she's worth more she's worth less it's this that it's always 50 so that means it's a now these How did they hold? Oh, and now the truth is I didn't need to put the middle just I thought it was cute because it's the same that argues on this case as this case. is the same separate has nothing to do with our but in our we learned yesterday is if I cause somebody to lose money for instance we discussed that if the aid could cause somebody to swear and most people a lot of people don't like to swear and they'll pay money to get out of the swearing so I caused a monetary loss the guy says look you could have forced him to make a and he most likely wouldn't have made it. He would have paid back the loan. I have a Tina on you. You made me lose money and therefore you have to bring a carbon. So if we take these two things together that if you admit on a can you're always whether or not come and if you hold like you're potter you're not you're not it's not true to say you take these two things together we have a question is money or not money because tacless at the end of the day the guy didn't didn't admit he could he could admit but right now he It's if you hold it's a monetary loss. It's a monetary loss. So you have no shar said in other words yesterday before cause a monetary loss. It's not like my since if he admits then there's no monetary loss at the end of the day he didn't admit. So is going to go into a bunch of some of them from our alone. Look at our Mishna. How many kos do we have in our Mishna? A whole bunch. We have, we have, we have, we have, huh? So, the is going to go through all of it. Half a damage. What's a half a damage? Well, what's a half? Where do we get half? Either you owe the whole amount or you owe zero. What's half? Half must be a penalty. So it says okay we're going to that says that it's not a we view half as money why would we view does anybody remember from what do you mean it's money either you pay the whole thing or half the answer is he should really pay the whole thing his animal caused damage so why is he paying half we have on him which you know we read it what about that His mom, okay, he had no reason to believe his his ax is going to go crazy. He's a nice he's a nice dog. He bought him. He he walks with the dog all the time. The dog behaves himself. Oh, so one day the dog ran and and caused damage. Okay, we have we have but the says very good. You only answer the question according to one Omar. According to the Omar that says that half a is a then what's the shot over here? It's a good ray that is money because the the mission says that if they don't want to testify for half a so you see according to him that it is considered money. Does everybody remember that? A lot of people remember that. What's here? We go something like this. that I don't know if that's but anyway that's that's uh here this he stepped on a on a stone the first one is regal the second one is also regal but it's a special in regal that you only have to pay half of the typical regal half of the typical amount that's it comes from the same of the cow stepping on something directly, but since it flew out like a like a pebble on a highway that hits your windchill some it's like something that you don't really it's called it's called that's we're talking about. So it's a big when the mission says we didn't anticipate this. We thought means that it's the first one of the first three times that the uh the animal caused damage. Okay, that's not a big kish. He was saying no it's he a pebble went flying out of his from from beneath his foot and it caused a and that's considered m okay let's continue somebody stole something and I have that could testify that he stole he should be paying me this money and why because it's considered money no no no you didn't understand the double that he pays half of it is the principle that's the money part over here not the not the because he didn't want to testify in the principle the same exact thing again you have to pay four and five for for a sheep for a cow again there's the principle and there's the the additional amount that you have to pay we're talking about the principle What about inn the 50 has to pay that's the embarrassment is something that's dependent on each and every girl and every it depends who the guy is. So because there's a moving scale here it depends who and where. So you see it's not it's not one amount for every person. Oh, is going to say now if so all nine cases you just establish that all nine cases are monetary law. So why do you need nine cases? Says so it doesn't really mean safe I don't think but here I put it together a quick list. It's really nine but I didn't have room here. So I just put together means in the beginning there's and at the end there's talking about is considered a monetary loss. It's talking about a guy. He claims that he he he caused me monetary a monetary loss on and that's why as we're going to see we do have so if somebody would burn somebody's godish on chabas he would be ped from paying the the godish says Then also if you burn somebody's you from paying the godish why and that's enough to be considered. So that to come to exclude that that's why the M brings ashma all the so all the beginning end and there's a lot of similarity is similar hey that's all like one category you have this all like one one category and each one each category has one it's of the other stuff and the teach that we know okay before when we said this whole thing that the the the guy the sisters and married and you didn't have a cash. Okay. It's only Tarsus. I got to say this again, but I don't know the details. So, you're going to have to help me out. This guy was trying to It's a sh Yeah, it's a Mia. It's It's in development. I know. As I was reading it, I thought about it, so I have to say it again. I I remember I said it when we were in Europe last year. It's from the Europe trip. Everybody knows the story. I remember screaming. The name was like this. But anyway, there's a guy who it was like remember that. I remember. I remember the whole thing. When you yell at me, I remember there's a a guy who's trying to make somebody next to him a buba on the flight and it wasn't going well. And then he bumps into this guy on Kipper and he's smoking a cigarette on Kipper by the bus stops. He says, "Listen, we smoo with this that why don't we just go into the sh and uh we'll make a mish for for for your kid that you lost in the he was very I think that's what that was the story." He's very What was the story? Postwar and he's very very upset for for the loss of his kid or whatever for his father. Oh, no. I know what it is. No, no, no. Here it goes. Here it goes. The father, this older guy, he lost his son. He was with him the entire war and at the end he lost his son. So he said I got let's just make a mish for your son that you lost. So he says okay fine. So they go he puts out the cigarette kullet. So he goes into the he walks over the says listen I got a guy it's a one time thing. Stop whatever you're doing. I know you're holding in the middle of I don't know what. Let's make a kelly for this for this. So he gets mole and he says the whole the whole thing the beautiful and great voice and then the father says the name of the son and he faints because that was his son it's good I ruined it and don't put it together shimmy will huh the short oh there is a short of it just put it back in uh yeah take the short oh no I just said y kippers I remembered. That's funny. That's that's that's a good story that has something to do with where are we? Oh, so in the bottom over here. Oh, Sheamra is a little different. Not really mentioned in Mishna, right? You know that my son my son-in-law the day after they got married with they married my daughter he's my daughter and I forgot I didn't have chance to to sue him he owes me 100 this not 50 it's 100 please come and testify for this and they they lied they said we don't know any testimony after being if he admits that he It's a potter. Oh, so we're talking about aas. So you see over here that if he doesn't admit on a so that that's answer to our question. We want to know is a considered a monetary loss or not. Here you see it's considered a loss. That's the we discuss that. Yes, you're right. It's a but he holds the reason why he holds because at the end of the day even on aas if the adam show up and say they testify that this is what happened you'd still be that's why it's a monetary loss there's no according to him all kos is a monetary loss because there's no way out of it even if you admit says wait a minute why you potter if the could show up afterwards why you potter that goes according to that even if the show afterwards he's still potter says we can say the whole things the only way according to there'll be a time that your what he's trying to say is no it does go according to says that typically speaking a is is considered a monetary loss Because even if you're the whole point that shouldn't be monetary because you could admit and if you admit there's no monetary loss but even if you admit the can come and and be yeah but there is a case where he admits that it's your potter that why because if there are no at all and he was ma then he would be says Shi. Oh. Oh. Sponsors. Here we go. Hinging of the D inovations LLC. In honor of my son's cal for learning san global mega. What did you lose? It's working. It's over here. Something with you. You here? No. What do we do? That's the first. Huh? Back up. Mega making answering questions great again. Anonymous in honor of Marcus Kenazi. Enough said. Okay. Not on Zoom. Okay. But it's recording at YouTube. It's recording. Very much. There's people in this room. They're on Zoom. You're laughing. So now we're going through a whole list of things that are not a monetary loss. I want you to to come testify that I'm a obvious. You guys heard it 45 times, but it fits right in there. What do you mean I need? Guy goes to the RV and says, "Rav, I need you to make me a kite." She says, "Uh, oh, just pretend. Let's go. Let's say control yourselves. Control yourselves. Pretend you never heard it. Pretend you never heard it." When Now, listen. Listen, listen, listen, listen. We're going to We're going to do uh uh what is it called? Yeah, let's make it short. Pretend you never heard this joke in your life. When I'm done, you're all going to laugh like crazy. Okay, here we go. There's a guy, listen to this voice. There's a guy comes to the r says, "Rav, I want to be a co." The rub says, "Absolutely not." So he says, "I'll give you $1,000." Nope. 10 thou? No. $25,000. R says, "Why do you want to be a coin so badly?" He says, "I want to be caught because my father's a cayenne. My grandfather's a cayenne joke." Malcolm, you never joke. No. Amazing. [Music] That was worth a short never laugh so hard in their life. Says, "What about this one?" This one I said also, but it's not as famous. This one you don't have to laugh. But the guy the guy came the guy asked the the guy to he had a kid. So he says I want to do a pin of Ben. He says uh but what do you mean you want to do a pinion of Ben? Your name is Kovich. You don't have to do a pin of Ben. He says really what a shame you should have told me and my other five kids also. We you know what it's a pella is Burman here or he stepped out I just saw him Burishu Burman he pays khan to Davin he has a minion here in Rashan he pays kan for like 400 shekel he loves kanim and by the way I don't know oh we have donn could you stay for chakras we need khan in the second three four days we didn't have a k second minion five how much you pay we're paying we pay for for 400 shel yak will become a kite Anyway, so it's kada to be a but it's not a real monetary loss. to discuss what about the truma not a monetary loss shiny ley and this I I I say it because it's a I know a ley they told me this ems the two people were learning and the told the other guy he says you know if there's there's no ley in sh the k gets a double aliyah he gets two alias so the guy says it's not true we're not like that anymore what do you mean not know I was in sh 20 he says no and it turns out he's a ley so he never witnessed it in his life Did you ever witness a getting to alias? Were you like a mil or something? Whatever. Or when you were a kid. When you're a kid before. Yeah. Says Shani Levy. Oh man. You wrote that down on paper. No, no, no. I wrote something else. You want to hear a good one? I'll tell you what I wrote down. I wrote down Oh, it's already 8:00. Fine. We'll go back there. Let's see if how quickly we get to the end of the mission. I'll tell you I'm not the son of a divorce. I'm not the son of aut which would make him a I want you to testify about somebody else which certainly we said already that's not so and so is a ley he's not a that so and so was the daughter he's talking about not that somebody's misus his own daughter says that's for sure he's talking about another case ruan shim's daughter So over here my son hit me and he caused me a real wound where there was blood. So the son said it on your greater punishment which is the death penalty. So you don't have to pay for the wheat. All these Huh? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I said these you should be in my words. It's because we're talking about a testimony about what about monetary stuff. Says so and so. So there's no mention of I want you to testify that Reuben owes $100. That doesn't say any We said already that you have to hear it from the litigant. You have to hear it from there has to be a demand to make a from the person involved. You can't sue somebody for and then then make him bring a carbon. We're talking about again does remember what is power of returning in Hebrew. Okay. Just as a interesting rashy here. Can you think about this for a second? Could I have could I give power of attorney, not me, could someone give power of attorney to his friend to sue the guy that was Mais's daughter for 50 shekel? It's a monetary loss and I want to give power of attorney to that guy. It doesn't say it here. It only says this power of attorney for cayenne ley for I'm sorry for um yeah but what about a case of says no there's no power of attorney there because the money was never his it's a brand new case you could only do power of attorney for a loan for something that the money was mine and the guy's not paying me now I do power of attorney not for a Yes. Not for Not for Exactly. Not for something new. Exactly. You can't do power of attorney on movable. That's only when somebody's denying it. If there's no denial, if there's no argument, then you can use a power of attorney. We establish and we said as if we know forgiven that is only on a monetary claim. So this is a super easy gimar. This is a this is a riddle. How do you say two o is double here? Check this out. It says in the oi that's so since it says by us the word twice and it also says the word twice. So I learned something from the is going to ask why don't they learn from from these are different things that have the word. So that's the little here means I give somebody I I I have somebody watch my goldfish. That's money. So obviously is money. We're talking about a monetary thing. That's his there's going to be three. It also says here, so this is by So it says over there also over there there's no monetary claim. It's a claim for capital punishment, not for money. and say are both it says and it says it says two eyes over there is what makes her swear she has to say amen we said it's considered that she swore over there there's no monetary claim it's only that the husband wants her to blow We're talking about that. But no like and first of all there's no and also a lot of words here right and also we can't prove anything from we don't want to use the because over there that's one that's how I know that is talking about money says the word only one of these are one of your potters. I'll tell you what. Okay. If it's monetary a money thing, then if it's not money, not is going to ask why go that way. Maybe it's the other way around. It says like we had the puzzle before, right? He saw. He knows. So he says beautifully. There's a case where he just saw, but he has no idea what he saw. And this a case where he knows but he has no idea what he but he never saw. What's the case going to explain? It's that he only saw. Yeah. It's you see from your window down the block somebody. There's this transaction, a money transaction. You know that it's a loan. You have no idea what it is. Maybe it's a sale. Maybe it's just he's doing something for you. He's bringing money to somebody else. You have no idea. But you saw it. What's the case? You saw then what happened? You could testify that you saw Abi Kamansski give men $1,000. You saw it that it's part that that's what you saw. Meni says he never received $1,000 from Avi. Ai says I gave you a loan. Now if Meny would say it wasn't a loan, I sold you my car. Okay, go home. But since Mendy's denying it and we're two witnesses and we saw that you received $1,000, so now we have to trust him because you said it never happened and he says it happened and it was in the loan. So you have to pay him $1,000 by me not testifying. I'm making him lose $1,000 based on a without a you hear they have no idea what happened. But it doesn't matter because men admits that it never happened and we say it did happen. That's the over here. It's not it's just the alone is enough. Now how do you know without seeing that's very I didn't see the loan but Miy admitted to me and totzer that he owes $1,000 to toyki. So that's it. We have the two of us could testify that he admitted without seeing it. Okay. So, we're going to stop right over here. Have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor atm mdyd.com.