Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 97 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Hi, good morning. Good morning. All right. So, to today's sponsor, 70 days ago, exactly 70 days ago on Shabas, I read an email. It says like this. Hi, I followed your every year she every day through Shabas 19 when I was taken to the hospital with corona at 42. My first scene was made while me and my dad cried at the Puram Sudo with a minion in Kadesh Rebelli. I have fallen behind now simple my mind is far from clear and I'm still hospitalized in NYU. If you could find it in your heart to have me in mind when saying to Hill would mean so much and he says I am one of the many members of your secret Kabura. Thank you Schlami Klein Crown Heights. Here's a picture of Schlley Klene in NYU with Oxygen and from that day on. We said a lot of him for him and uh a friendship developed. Here's the the guy from Crown Heights, Lavicher, and the Litvak like they like to call him, the Missnaged, whatever they the Grunnik from Panovich on the other hand. And we I feel a great connection to him. I see him a lot on Zoom. I call him out a lot. He actually sent me coffee which never arrived. And it's amazing what the bond of Tyra because we have such a divide. I remember going to to Crown Heights when I was a kid. I I mentioned I stayed there for a few days and I went to Fabran the whole thing and I was looking for some sarum from the GR and they told me there I don't know if it's true. They said look the G never accepted the the bala. So that they don't want sparring from the GU although the the Lutvox I know for a fact they they very much respect the Batania etc. I hope that's not true about the but anyway let's say it is doesn't matter this bond of Tyra getting together different people from all different United Nations United Nations so we have the grunics and the labavatures so here today Klene what's that yeah hold on let me just look it up here yeah says like this in honor of my wife Khan's birthday, my partner in life and my rock. Without her support, I would never have been able to make the commitment to learning the daff every day. And for that, I'm truly grateful. May she be be benched with a great year full of joy, good health, and all my love. So going from this is what he gets his wife. I don't know. I'm sure he got her other things, but it was important for him to dedicate Tyra from Arenic to his wife. It's unbelievable where where we're coming here now. It's not from a granic. It's of Israel. But yeah, you get the point. Also, I heard I wasn't told by Rabi Shamberg himself, but I heard that Ravish Shamberg made yesterday. His granddaughter got married. So, a tremendous maze Klein on there. I don't see Schli Klein, but okay. He's probably there somewhere. He works He works late, so I don't know. Not all He's usually on on Sundays. Okay, real quickly. Um, dear Rebellia, first of all, I would like to thank you and everyone else involved for everything. You don't understand what the sheer is for me. Second of all, today we talked about the crush. It came up that they were heavy. I thought you might find this interesting that Galinsky in Pares Pikud see attached makes a very simple. He says that if the crushim were amma wide, amma by one and a half armor, amma is two feet by three feet wide, wood. Imagine a beam 2 by 3t, 18 ft long plus whatever three and 2/3 of a ton. Three ton and 2/3 almost four tons each carriage. Simple. That's what he says. So extremely heavy and most likely necessary to have more than No, it wasn't solid. Solid solid crush him. Um, okay. This we'll just read tomorrow because we're running out of time. We have to we have a lot to do. I just want to say that it's a great time now to send in your emails. If you have a great story about how the DAFF inspired you or whatever, a good picture, a nice email. Great time to send that in to DAFF bramma d afgmail.com. We have this year right now on Zoom. We also have it at 9:15 at night Israel time. So that works out to somewhere like 2:15 1:15 in America. Okay. Best now we are holding. We have a lot to accomplish today. Omar Rabhuda Omar 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 15 lines from the bottom. Today's guess what this week's par going to be reading it in two days. What's the gather of what? What did he do exactly? Who was he? What is he? We're talking about carrying on chabas. Guess what? According to this man, the Omar the ate him. What he did was he walked in for that was the big that he did in the Bryson says to in order to get the wood he had to cut it. He was he was a gatherer. He gathered the wood. So it's one of three things. What's the difference what he did exactly? Look at the rav the remember we had also the migill is in the time of the gumar when you couldn't write down you couldn't write down the gumar if you heard a really interesting you wrote it down and you hid it so nobody else could see it until rebi came along and made the gumar the he found one from and it says the are 39. So, don't get excited yet. Thear is going to fix this up. But it says you're only one if you do all 39. How could that be? We must have had this at least five times in this. It says in the the 39. What does it say? It it tells you the number 39. And the asks, I know how to count. I realize that my sore throat, my cough, whatever it is, is not going to go away until I go away. So I need to like take like it's just shear after she's never going to heal. I just every day I say okay tomorrow it's going to get no still sore. So if I try to sing it's going to be sore. There might be a song coming up get ready get ready opposite. The reason why it says 39 is to tell me that if I did all 39 39 in one awareness. So we have to fix it up. Out of the 39, there's one they don't get for which one is it. Go figure it out. But one thing I can figure it out. If at a and he got mis so that's for sure he get mis for that's all I know so hold it he was on so obviously this is not telling you that So whatever you hold, that's what you're going to hold that you are. There is no suffic in that exact item. Who was the Mishk? The famous the daughters of came to Rabenu and they said it seems like he deserved to die. says in the he sinned but we don't have an what do we do with the so who's the who's he died because he was whatever he did he did was they told him don't do it and he continued carrying he continued cutting wood continued So the word bidbar and bam midbar I was I was curious when I was reading this. So it says midbarbar. So I I typed in midbar came out that it says in the bidbar 60 times. So each one is exer shaba. I was just thinking maybe I don't know I because I didn't check all 60 but maybe these are extra. All the people that died [clears throat] were in the midbar, right? So that's why it's extra. They were in the midbar. So why is it saying auidbar? I don't know. [clears throat] Yeah. Yeah. That we're going to get into that now. But even there's a mess. It has to have like a unique word. It can't say it says over here and it says over here. So I mean it says hundreds of times. It says and or it says Hashem. Hashem here and Hashem there and great. It has to have a unique word. Is definitely not unique. In fact, the whole is called. So we should do from whatever. So learns this very interesting. He tells him you are going to get punished because of this pick your poison. If you are right that it's in fact very interesting you see for a fact that the doesn't name him by his name and it gives a call him the knew his name and could have mentioned him by his first name and when when came they mentioned him so you're going to get a den for that and what about all the other things that your mgala from the seems like the specifically wanted it hidden vimlav and if It's not I don't even remember. where we had a beautiful Rama that says that he made a on ruin with the dud remember that and then the Ram says that he dreamt that Ruv came and said thank you for saying thehat you're saving me everybody said that I I didn't and there was the discussion whether the dead people they are insulted if they if this is not but we did have a gar in fact that somebody made fun of I think it was and He got the guy as he was walking a beam came and hit him in the head and killed him. See what it says. Anyway, well over there the says who cares? But there is a thing of you get punished for saying a rumor, a wrong rumor about even though he's dead, you're going to get punished. Yeah. Why? Were you here when they said that you have to go like this? You have to and a guy sent me a whole email afterwards that he was in a stadium or somebody's in a stadium and he saw a guy take his jacket and go like that. He went over to his he started talking to me. Yeah, I think it was no that was Goldstein. He said over the yeah [snorts] but what are we going to do about like you ask what do you do comes by tradition you get it from your your rebi you can't just make it up he didn't learn it he didn't hear from his rebi so you have to see this tyus amazing tus the only tyus But did get it from his for all of they knew there's 476 let's say I'm just throwing out a number whatever it is 223 says wait a minute this doesn't fit into my 223 he did a real quick calculation went through the whole sh this one is extra it's not here and you you can't add one you can't oh your rebi heard it it's too there's only x amount I wish I knew the number but that's what says he refused to accept it so it's exactly like you said there's an exact amount not only there's exact amount you have to get it from your you don't just make up oh they ate kal there it has to be exact and you get it from your rebby And all the shabas we learned by the way were all it's not something that came up later on in life and you know in the time of the they made up these are kabalas that they got generation from generation. So why did die again in this week's par they went up to the mountain to fight they weren't supposed to they had a inspiration to fight that was his now what he's saying here and Rashi points it out that it's much less it's not the biggest it's it's an every anytime a coach says don't then you do but it's not like Shabas it's not on the same level as Shabas Fine. In other words, don't be mighty lies and say he did a he wasn't a shabas. He's a shabas, right? That was like the first thing we said in Shabas. How do you define a Jew? So he was okay. He was he went up the mountain. It's not like he's not Shabas. Similarly, bomb was upset at Miriam and Aaron for saying we had the whole the other day. Why? Why is separated from his wife? How could you talk about? What does it say? Bum was mad at them. Both of them, not just Miriam. Even got a same exact thing regardless you're going to get punished for what you just said if you write the didn't say so said about didn't want you to know about you you're making up a story about but it's a great proof he says yes they both got yelled at but Only Miriam got the looks at Miriam and he sees that she's what is it mean? No, he himself had it but he was done with it. He was already moving on in life and he looked and he saw that she still has the difference between Aaron and Mary. They both got it but Aaron had less daysish. You know, you know what this means when this is I got the you know what's coming up, right? They always do this. It's like they give you the story, they read the email before you know they give you the the the famous the famous concept. somebody is he suspects somebody that's kosher says so and so did something wrong he gets punished physically don't suspect people if you don't know for a fact don't suspect maybe people say it wrong whatever for user somebody that's kosher says to go redeem he says no they're not going to believe me who are you they're going to say who who why did you say that how do you know that is not going to believe you knew the future and knew that they are going to believe him no we need a song. Since we didn't sing, how come you're not helping me? Who cares? All right. Beautiful. Beautiful. Brings back memories from You see, he wants to buy another item. Every day. Every day. Yesterday was a computer. Maybe. Maybe. First. I need a better mic. Then we'll get a boom mic. You mean no nobody heard anything? They just heard me sing. Okay, great. They are believers. The the the descendants of believers and you think you're so great and you yourself are going to have. How do you know that they are believers? They believed the descendants of believers. Where did it happen? You didn't believe in me. It says you get punished. Put your hand inside over here, your chest. Pull it out. And what's going to happen? Sarass. So you got sass. The good measure the the the award that gives comes quicker than than a punishment. He took out his hand. He put it in and only when he took it out it was. So what what do you see here? So if you look at the PK real quickly I thought it was just for this says in the P he put it in. You see it's already in his. So then why does it say he took it out? Where else did he take it out? It's already it's in. So this extra word comes to tell us says the extra word tells me that from within his already healed it was only when he took it out. When he when he went like this then all of a sudden it turned into shell. It wasn't shelling in here. It wasn't white. It was regular. Then he took it out and ah didn't turn over here. I don't know the exactly you know hurts. It's painful. Maybe the pain stopped immediately. We felt it already when it was inside just to show that the concept that comes before. So Aaron makes a snake out of his staff. So then the mitz imitate it and then his staff goes ahead and it swallows up all the snakes. What's wild? The snakes. Was it a snake or a stick? Says it was a stick. It went right back to being a staff. And that staff swallowed all the snakes. So that was an interesting another nace within a nace because a snakes does swallow crazy things, right? Snake swallowed a alligator. Snake swallows humans. So it could swallow snakes. It's not. But that a stick swallows other snakes. That's if you have on one side and on the other side and you have in the middle and now we're going to go into beautiful idea here where is the exactly is the between under and what's the we had this idea already And I'm sure you already are starting to notice that most of the ideas that we have, we repeat it and it goes through sha like that. You have it's not like a one time thing and you put it away. What's like there's a lot of people now that want to make aliyah because it's destroy talking about aliyah. What do you go when you do aliyah? You go to um what is it called? What's the ministry of of absorption? Yeah, the the absorption ministry. So means it's absorbed. It's it's it's as if it landed in midair. So it's flying through the in slow motion. It landed it landed in. So that is could you say such a concept? The idea that it landed while it's still moving in motion. Is that something you could say? That's as if it landed. So the is within where it is but above it's not anymore. What is that called above now? So you're asking if above 10 is not. So how come your every time you carry because that's what they did in the it's even though it's a because it's above. The question is whether or not you learn throwing is throwing similar to passing the beam over this four ton beam to your friend or not. Right now we're saying no there's no connection no connection with between throwing and passing they're two different things and I don't learn throwing from passing. So above everybody's going to agree it's below. Do we say as if it landed sorry maybe perhaps no the whole is the opposite above and what's the argument and and by the way just sticking in for a millisecond. I don't want to confuse the just a rashy here that when the Mishna says not like we explained in the Mishna that that's referring only to explain it's going to be according to everybody above. Fine. Now what's the second side? Perhaps the is above and below that is whether or not you learn throwing from passing. passing. We know passing one beam to another person in is throwing the same thing says yes it's the same thing no but under the everybody will invoke this concept of and therefore or even will agree that you are okay this is an old question that was wondering about told him listen it's very simple so now what we're going to see is three three things going on here two are very similar two are going to say that the isn't whether or not And the other one is going to say no. The is whether we say is like it says if you pass something from and there in the middle. But look what it says here. What was wrong with the would say period? What's itself? What does that add? Oh, itself comes to tell us says we're dealing with under it's literally not above. It's so from this it seems obviously is under which is now if I want to argue on this I'm going to just have to explain away what the word means which the does later now what is the between says under and say under you are what's going on here did he carry it or throw I'll prove to you that he threw it because carrying if you're just carrying it for carrying something above. But we had this gimm five days ago on Shab what the the the not the head the um the MBF they were carrying it under which was we made a whole two/3 below and but was above and we said right there's three families always carried things and they carried it above 10 this says that It's cannot be referring to carrying talking about throwing and below. Why? Because you don't learn throwing from carrying. And therefore above in other words above everybody agrees I do not learn throwing from carrying but below do we say that it's as if it rested even though it didn't rest. Now we have another opinion here. If you threw the item even above, but the word would seem like that it's below the physical. Where's the physical below that? Even if you throw something below, it's doesn't get any more than that say cuz you threw it. Fine. So the is here is if if you learn from and this argues with within three agrees why what is that called it's like there on there even though it's moving above Why? It's not anymore. So here too is of between three and 10 because below three is above 10 is not between three and 10. Do we say above 10? What does the word mean? Again, again means it's only listen to this. If I throw something from even if there's no in the middle that's why you need that's what is to get away from that. So even if I have I live next to my neighbor and I throw a ball into I have a sh to see is holding cup if I throw a ball to but by mistake I didn't realize that I'm very weak then it landed in what's am I for anything or not that's where used to sit What is that called? Anybody remember? Huh? And are saying because so there's a better word for it. What is that called in Gmorra language? We have to get this mus. It's called a miss. Masik means if I lift up a knife from the ground because I just want I want the knife. If I want to bring it home and by mistake I cut a branch completely potter. Why? I had no intent. I had no it's not. It's not that I wanted to do this and it went here. Over here is mass says Rashi. Fine. We're going to get there. I just wanted to see if the was holding in what? He he intended to pick up the knife. He intended to pick up the knife but he had no intent to cut the branch. He intended to throw it into which would be a potter. It landed in which was if I intended to throw but I had no intent. It's like me walking to shaw not knowing at all that there are ants on the floor and I killed one by mistake. That's a massage. It's like trying to cut a big branch and cut a little I hear I hear you have a rashi. You're asking a question. You're saying I'm shocked. You're asking What's the case? Should be but and he landed by mistake in middle. He thought he could get it over the highway. He didn't realize that the highway is a lot wider than he thought and it landed in no intention to throw it in. Fine. Says says the price here above above is only if he owned both properties because the whole of from going from one property to the other property is it's needed over here. I don't need because I own both properties and that's and the whole is between three and 10 exactly like the said before. So we have a good to if he owns both then it's to throw from one to the other perhaps this should be a big cash we learn there's two houses on two sides of in the name of they say now it seems like you know it's pretty obvious that he owns both of Because it says a second later. Why would say you're allowed to throw from one to the other? Because he owns both of them. If he owns both of them, Raf says in that case it's to throw from one to the other. I just said in the if you own both of them. So the is a steer to Rav says that's different. One is above the other. It's really hard to judge your throat. So he thought that he's gonna get it there. But it's lower, it's higher, whatever it is. And that's why he missed it. So since it's hard to to gauge the distance, yeah, you're standing on top of a mountain, you're trying to throw down, you think you could do it. It looks, oh, it's just a valley and then you realize that, you know, it's three miles away, so it lands short. So what are you going to do? You're going to go get your ball. You're going to go retreat. You're not going to leave your ball in the middle of a valley. Go. That's a problem. On this Rashi points out, and what about the fact that I was now I thought I could get it all the way to but it landed. That is a says where do we know this thing called? Wow. For all of we say love it, love it all day long. comes up all the time. But how do we know it? Just so you know what is we had this a bunch of times. This is this tool a planer. In other words, since cannot be perfectly even, they didn't have those uh $2 million machines that that put pavement on the ground to the millimeter. They didn't have the the roads went like that. Go to Ukraine or whatever. What's going on? So yeah, it look like this. So it can't be. So there's going to be bumps. We'll say with everything within that is considered flat. You can't plain it down. So why did you limit it to 2.999 three above three also maybe? The famous if you guys remember from Yon's uh a guy makes a wall but this from the bottom of the wall of his suka to the floor. What does Yonyi have there? You guys don't remember y the goat. The goat could go underneath. So that's a of but what's the connection over there to to bumps? There's no bumps. Nice flat surface. What's the difference over there? It's simply because there's no if physically doesn't separate anything. If the cats in the neighborhood in those day they had goats. Today we have cats. If cats can go in and out, they don't even realize it's they don't have to duck. They just walk right in. That's not a Okay, so let's go to another ayah. What about a case where the of the goes within three of the top of the again no connection to having a flat surface on it's a concept of evoking love. Rash brings another case. You have it today. They sell these sukas because people is that a suka cannot flap in the wind. So all these material sukas have issues. So what do they do? They sell you a kit. They put these ropes within three one rope and then another rope and it's nice and taut. They they don't move in the wind and I go from this rope to this rope. Rashi brings that case down. Case in what about that? What does that have to do? What does that case have to do with having a flat surface? I'm using a concept of love that everything that's within is connected. Nothing to do with flat surfaces. We're on a vertical surface, not a flat surface. Says, I think we knew this already now says it's don't try to figure it out from and logic. This is that's it. So now we have a reverse case. I don't know if you remember this is all the way from Shabas. Remember I found this picture, beautiful picture of uh well there's another guy in China that's even more interesting picture a real stubborn individual who refused to move his house when they were building, you know, a 10-lane highway. So this Nebuch guy has a house smack in the middle of 10 lanes and he actually built him like a ramp and everything to get in and out. But here's a nice picture of a of a guy's house on his own private property. And here you have massive highway, three lanes in each direction. So he goes from throws a ball all the way over a house and it lands in. It's hard to fathom such a thing. Where do you have two that are parallel to each other? But here, nice case, very rare, but it happens. It's a serious even has a a house with a with a with a roof as the is going to say in a second the whole is when there is not just four walls but four walls and a roof. Why says Rashi? Because then it's it's stuffy. So, it's not like literally there's things all the way up to the roof, but the fact that it's dark and stuffy that fills up the room that fills up the room. Then when I Is it more interesting my the way I look on the TV? The hands. Oh, you like you like the the the delay. Like if you don't get something, you look right to the screen and then you it's quick. I get it. I look better. I like skin the TV thing. Yeah. Fine. So he says that if the house this house you see this in this picture beautiful it has a roof. So if the ball passes over the roof then I have cluto then it's as if it landed in this full area of huh? No. Yeah. That's crazy. You know what an army you have to have to do that you know it's like a stadium. like a stadium. Well, the stadiums are surround kind of. No, it's certainly uh Well, that's Yeah, that's okay. Fine. Interesting. says the good amazing thing in this case that I throw a ball from and I'm telling you the ball landed in and then it went and continued and went into so what do I have I have a stopover so if I have a stopover I got two things one I went from to that's called and then from to that's It's a little bit reversed, but fine. We get the idea. The idea is that two things here. Let's turn the page. Tomorrow I'll read an email from a guy that says you don't say turn the page. You say turn the daff. You guys agree? Not agree. Turn the page. I'll tell you why. Because whatever. So in this case, what's going to happen? Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Okay. Today's sh is going 20 minutes over time. The is what? Because we learned yesterday the Torah talks about only don't bring from but over here the part is that's so you're telling me that two if you do with again is three because two and the extra is three is 36 36 + 3 39 this tells us 39 Why? And therefore anything else you said your says in this case in this case this beautiful picture says that's not true. That's not what was said about completely something else. It's not on Rebi. His name is not even Rebi. Let's push the blame onto and if we push the blame on we don't have a contradiction. Now we know for a fact that Rebi says you're only 39. We don't know that Huda says it. So if I could push this onto say too nowhere else in says you only have one I don't have such a problem. If I throw, it's talking about throwing. He did two things here. He went from number one. Number two is that it moved for we know that if you move in with four. So it says over here. Now what does it mean? I think wants to understand that it's why because if you're going to tell me he's only that that's impossible because and they say means nothing zero at least one He did one of going from says that's not a great perhaps says one and say zero why zero like you guys were saying before that you need and he didn't do his what going I wanted I wanted to rest right away at the end of the day as it moved got into got it it rested right away and his happened as soon as it crossed the border since I don't say this concept of so it never rested and if it didn't rest he didn't want it to to to rest 20 ft away from the borderline. He wanted to rest immediately and it didn't happen and later on we're going to see guy tried to throw four and went to eight. What happens perhaps holds there's only one carbon here but I don't have a rebut holds two carbonas so who so what's that we had this already in our so if you're putting on the loom you're putting the the chassis these strings what happens a lot of times you know they become come entangled. So you take a tool and you untangle the strings or once you have on the loom you have your your your material going, you bang it a little bit. You give it a a few clap claps and it goes back into position. It's nice and taut, not too taut, whatever. So comes and says, "You say this 39, I say this 41. is when you put the the thread right through these holes in the loom. That's the same thing he said. They said that's weaving. That's part of the weaving process to push it down that he did the weaving and he pushed it down and he's told the obvious answer. He didn't do it together. He did he did the by himself and he did the uh the medactic by himself. And never says that you two if you do weaving and pushing down the thread you don't get two. So what's the between and you have to call two different names and two different and therefore I have 41 of that I have to bring 41 carbanas according to the most I could ever get to is 39 carbanas has the word he adds what is he adding he's adding Fine. So, let's stop here. Middle of the line. We'll stop here. We'll continue tomorrow as a shorter D. Bas will catch up. Have a wonderful, wonderful day. An a bridged version of Shir Mali. Hello. How you doing? Good to see you. Any movement? How do you know? It's good enough for somebody. It's all for the best. You mean that for rent? It's good. Thanks.