Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 69 by R’ Eli Stefansky

we seem to be okay all right good morning everybody today is 35 days no mmm come in translation by Shane Kamisha voice but I'm air la Mer today's shear is sponsored very interesting one today this is our sponsor I have no idea where this is seriously yo se probably knows the Sun came up this morning and most of us are still breathing or sorry and most of us are all breathing anonymous I don't know maybe it's David Brandis from from South Penn Avenue David once had a yeah Cova 19 and he sent us a whole email that every breath he takes is a gift from a Shem I don't know but if you want to send your your sayings anonymously please do so we'll put them on than the other board as well what do we have here today give all the good stuff first of all it's unbelievable so yo oh I want to read that email taco let's get there where was it funny oh here hello wle Stefanski this is a foul battle of been introduced to you that I haven't seen my shots blah blah blah blah blah a whole wrong I reclose he goes to the shear of rabbi Schwartz he did a scene with his son Broca's miss with Rabi Schwartz I wasn't here DAF whatever he misses I love this one here's it this is great my first team I did with my son since Perot and I listen to live zoom Davi I mean with Rabbi le monde sewer he's bringing the competition okay listen will will quote the competition here and I listened to your death I just have question regarding Chavez Duff 67 where disgust is not proper to do the Garcia stuff the the hook is a Murray thing is to do certain things during preparation of food but we reached iris in the morning we discussed preparation experience so you say grind thoroughly how they cater hated heartache yes so where it's proven by the Kairos it works you do it but where the dark game Irie it's not proven it doesn't work the reason why I'm reading this email is because I started off the sheer with a question I never got to the answer and it's a very interesting question if you say things from the Gemara you do black house from the Gemara certain dark hammer from the Gemara brought down from the ricky vaguer than my real it's assert to do in our days why because people are gonna say hey you did all these things you took seven pegs from a bridge and he took seven pitching it took seven ashes and it didn't work so they're gonna make fun of the tiger and that's a problem you're causing people make fun of the tiger comes out very interesting that to say a lack of forage in the Gemara is austere but to say a lack hash from a guy down the street that charged you $5.00 that would be motor it would seem the reverse that's what came out from that so yeah I just wanted to point that out here's another email last one for today it's a very long one okay we're gonna do here higher building I sent you this what's at first but then if ever you meant to rob a pill chick by the Deaf discussing the mask is when I wore the mask I said I had a Rebbe attaches a picture and video of rob a pill chick pretty sure the same one who mentioned as though she gets dressed up a real stoner that's the guy he dressed up for like bomber through barbecue this she would tarnish night look at this so here's my Rebbe from pre 1a still alive and kickin still wearing masks just two days ago just two days ago Rabi pull chick who ever went to Carolyn Stalin who ever went to I went to Carolyn Stahl and also believe it or not in part apart but I also went to dr. Tyra that's where he was my Rebbe in p1 a used to wear a mask every day he's dressed up for like volume air just to be nice I'm half people unbelievable in Flatbush in New York where my boy boys go to yeshiva took my son's there today amazing another person sent me an email this morning I'm not gonna have time to read it and he spoke to him about me okay that will be maybe tomorrow took my son's there today for this is a finger to send you a picture pretty sure it's the same I pull cheek he's kinda are still going strong with the same energy personality I don't know what is that forty years ago I was in more than forty years ago I was in pretty one a unbelievable on another note love the sheer haven't missed the Daffy on the Fulshear on YouTube sorry not a zoom guy or on an eight-minute dive since Broca's C did eight-minute and the full sheer since Broca's I'm adding a sheen for approximately 15 years always been striking Barcia but never felt a commitment to Tyra like this before before I started you share 129 days of never missing a day of learning because of you unlike times I've been I've overslept cabooses etc is an amazing thing wow so yeah that's what the Daffy M is all about the first day Broca's we discuss this of never missing a day of Tyrol so he is counting a hundred and twenty nine days of never missing a day of learning and we have cabooses in lump this and all the stuff and I'm not putting that stuff down but the difference is when you have all these conferences a lot of times you don't learn on Shabbos you oversleep the caboose oversleeps his wife gave birth and you fall out a thing when you do the Daffy you're doing it every day you with clients really doing everyday this amazing thing PS I thought I was into my hair but you put me to shame I need a haircut yes looking forward to stopping by iris for life shear once crown is over but will not have the full just coffee as I have this I have to disagree with everyone who does enjoy this stuff is pretty bad listen if it's pretty bad so you're gonna have to step up to the plate and bring the good stuff we have no problem this is what we could afford right now looking forward to stacking with you on YouTube tomorrow morning David Z Flatbush New York okay great let's jump into it amazing singers today so when it comes to a mr. Shabbos or allowed to be swim let's talk about Chavez there are three components really to Chavez there's the life that the tire says don't do a certain thing then this this or chorus if you do it B Mays it you get Carter's forget about the ski line a them Curtis you do a bit shy gig you have to bring a carbon cause she's learning Korres she goes as hottes so three things you have the love you have the chorus you have the carbon so when I ask you what does it mean to be a shy guy you did something inadvertently what exactly did you forget so we're gonna see the most amazing schita of moombas which we started yesterday Moomba says if a person is very aware that what he's doing is uh sir he knows I'm not allowed to cook on Chavez but he's just not aware that if he cooks by accident he has to bring a carbon okay he's missing one of the consequences but he knows what he's doing his awesome that's a show gig could you believe it a guy he's doing in a very Benes it he's sitting on the on the stovetop and he's going like this and he says what I'm doing right now is a hundred percent also the Torah does not allow me to do this and then somebody says hey by the way did you know that if you do by accident you have to bring a carbon sis no it wasn't a winner oh this guy's a shy gig chugging so what does he bring he brings a carbonyl that's to bring a carbon because he didn't know he has to bring a carbon incredible sheet oh now we have ha common in Holland we have two cheetahs Rubio canary sluggish revenant says as long as he doesn't know the main consequence of death - Tremaine called chorus which is not mystery - oh man it's worse than me finish line it's Curtis if he doesn't know that that's a shaking okay that's mixed that that makes a little bit more sense he's on the pod he's going like this he doesn't know he's gonna get killed soon I'm gonna show my his son is that are gonna die it's terrible stuff so that's striking I'm Jewish location says what we always understood to be shagging we were kids shaky means he doesn't know that this is a mr. love that it's in a very at all and he doesn't know that this Mesa he doesn't know anything he's a shy gig he's completely unaware so just to recap a little bit of what we said yesterday we'll try to recap more of it from not tomorrow but at the end of today's that we have time real quickly moombas tells Rubik eva i have a heck ish i can't compare a shaked amazin because in the same area and just like mace it has an awareness had an awareness so to Shuggie has an awareness ask sim rebbi akiva let Mesa go step further and show you that you're wrong ah if mais it has an awareness mais it has an awareness right now are you gonna tell me that somebody that's a psychic he's doing something by mistake he has an awareness right now says mama is beautiful yes that's exactly what I'm talking about he has an awareness right now and he's a mistake that's the Gemara so now that's where we're holding right now that sound tell someone that was on the top six lines from the top Velma Mumbai struggle mine so what exactly did he forget if he knows what he's doing right now is wrong so what doesn't he know she going to shock a big car bomb he's just not aware that what he's doing is wrong they didn't have to bring a carbon if you did it by mistake even though he's doing right now but on purpose but if he did a bad mistake you'd have to bring a car bomb that he's unaware of that's considered us chugging unbelievable killers Robin on she gets carbonylation of Chicago what are you talking about not knowing that he do but sure he's not even doing sugar he's doing amazing now and just because he doesn't know the consequence of a side thing that if he did it'd be showing you he hasn't really Cartman that's considered shot you no way your abundance bug of MIT so how much does you have to forget in order to be considered a show game that we have a mahogany luggage reverend remark even chicago be korres f out pc hazy be love all he has to not know is that he gets this terrible thing called chorus they're gonna cut his life short maybe I'll go to his sons whatever chorus he doesn't know that I thought P she hated Balam even though he knows that what he's doing is wrong he went to say there he knows that it's all said to cook on Shabbos us to do this and that in Chavez he knows all these things he does it anyways but he just doesn't know the consequence he was not very weird they never taught him in school that for doing that without witnesses without a straw you get chorus of course if there are witnesses and they warned them who get Mesa in bezants kilo fish lucky charm are actually easygoing beloved cars this everybody probably feels familiar with and enjoys this one wish luck wish what's a shy gig he doesn't even know it's uh sir it doesn't know it never he never he never learned the halacha of buyer he doesn't know that it has to be ultimately sorry less and then and it has to be be clean doesn't all these things he he thought that the buyer is this and it's not that so ok but he made a mistake in the laughs and he made a mistake in the cars Omar over my time is Abram luck is on my craw it says by the Nazi who sins I shall I see us a no go go you have to be Glarus this word is good it's part of the pasta I shall I say Oh son of go Gabbar Singh actually he's going to love the car is Shiva seems like he made a shot yeah he made a mistake both in the live and both in the cars from your throne on high crawler of shri mahalakshmi other like so what does it be return undo scenes from the plastic that he made a mistake in both mean by early look at this on your may i'm Haaretz if you look at the words it says may mr it's from the people from the common folk but what's from it should say mr it's all people that are over how you doing good morning my my second third cousin how are you it's good to see you jonathan may i'm are aunt's prattler moomer amazing a local and it makes a lot of sense this ilaha if the guys off the Darrell he's am omer and he does in a very by mistake he doesn't bring a carbon why not because he has no mistake this guy even if he went over and said hey Joe don't do that aveiro he'll do it anyway it just happens to be that he didn't know that this is awesome but if he knew it was also he do it anyways that's not a considered a shaggy shaggy is a person that if he would have known that it's a sir he's a nice from you then the town listen by the way buyer had tamaño that's wrong oh sorry I didn't know he stays away but guy gets off the derrick he does it anyways and then later are you tell him hey by the way you're doing Trueba today but when you when you were you did had to mana you have to bring a carbon she tells you what do you mean even if you would have told me then that that that's at mana that's also I would have done it anyways I don't care about you describe then so I'm not gonna he's he doesn't bring a carbon today may Emirates from the people of the nation not all the nation not mu Martin had a moment okay it society we've shaming Allah saw a mission of Shimon a shadow he says sent obese Greg of our shame has shocked me the AUSA here hash of me does he may be carbon a cigar so if a person does Shuvo when they tell him that's the type of person that brings a carbon let show me the other side may be carbon shaking oh sorry great turn on by the way if you pay attention to this little sugar over here then tomorrow we're gonna have this same exact sugar word-for-word maybe a slightly different point but the sugar is the same for the next ten lines not we're gonna have a mission of very soon in this pair of ice Malacca lies are buying cassavas there are forty minus one malakas valve enum bow and the famous question manana lamellae do I need a count for you then the mission doesn't have any extra words so why does the mission to tell me oh there are 39 take your finger and go survey a fire escalated over and you get to 39 obviously the mission is coming to teach us something what we review anything on I found this fascinating that we're bringing rebellion on Rebellion's shocked and we're gonna ask Irish luck ish from your vehicle on Sat I mean he's argue with your bacon on but basically this is the only shot this is what makes sense this is he sing this over problem very often on Sheamus on Columbia Helen method Kayaba Calathes Martha's closely evidence says I'm telling you hitters that it's possible and the most you could ever be over is on 39 the most a person can bring in one Shabbos is 39 per bonus it from one awareness and one swoop awareness he forgot all these things you didn't know about 39 malakas he brings 39 car bonus now we have to point out a very basic thing to understand this line and that Rashi points out if a person doesn't know anything about malacca Shabbos he doesn't know that there are 39 malakas he doesn't know any of the 39 0 what is Shabbos what is what a Shabbos Shabbos is don't know what a Shabbos means I cannot do Malacca he doesn't know that there are malakas that you can't do so therefore for this individual there is no Shabbos so then what does he is shaking what's he is showing about if a person knows that there's one melaka one melaka you now let a plant on Chavez but he doesn't know 38 of them so he has the concept of Shabbos and he made a mistake on 38 malakas but if this person doesn't know that you can't plant on Shabbos he has zero then there is no Chavez for him then he is not a shaking he didn't make a mistake on 30 on 38 he doesn't know their Shabbos there is no kinds of shots that's what the Gilmore is asking here you understand this concept that if it's zero then there is any Shabbos for him if it's one of the Shabbos and he made a mistake on 38 but if it's zero then there's no Shabbos ask the Gemara that's the matin you have to understand that they couldn't understand the next three lines carvaka office of africa is a Finnish cafes law how in the world could you get to 39 this is our den Shabbos if she gets malakas the only way to get to it laughs IRA is that I don't know that what I'm doing is is austere in other words we'll see laminar rebuking on the Omar team in Chicago the chorus okapi she has it the lab say he's in the lab Mishka is looking going the other way the Shabbos belong a corner biertan makes a lot of sense we said the corner babe what's considered a Shia anybody that doesn't know that what he's about to do the consequences cars he knows that it's a sir he just doesn't know the consequence of cars so here I have individual the nose of 39 Malacca Zara sir he just doesn't know the consequence on those 39 lockers his cars perfect he has to bring 39 sheep imagine guy walking with a truckload of sheep into the base timing those great la louche luck is so what do we do about rich lucky share Ellucian luckiest on my a cheese gig blab uber car has the other little shop is been my accord they're sluggish that in order to be a soggy you have to forget the love and the caress so in all 13 i melaka see that he doesn't know it sir and he certainly doesn't know that he's gonna die from it so then he doesn't know Chavez what is Shabbos he doesn't know what chatters okay the river asks maybe knows that you have to keep chef to do kiddush but that's not Chavez obviously Chavez's the is syrup shops these summer showers so he has no idea that there is shy to see can be a shy gig right it's like the guy that we had yesterday that grew up in North Korea doesn't know the concept of Shabbos he's not a shy guy he doesn't know he doesn't know that this 39 melaka so he can't be a shagging in it answers the Gemara amazingly the other bit woman violated arabic evil if a guy there's a 40th thing rabbi sign it's called home i'm not a lot of walk i'm a lot of walk two thousand dollars from my house not a not a not a centimeter more okay this is a different picture from that llama Dalit if I make it home if I make it Arif to come him I could walk another two thousand hours from here great answers the Gemara he's aware of come now what's come different than everything else a corner of a kpop whom is it the Raisa if I walk more than two thousand I'm as I'm ugly they're icing okay so it's forty malakas says Rashi no because even the corner of akeeba I don't bring a carbon I don't get it sit there right so but I don't bring a carbon so therefore very good a guy knows that this is at home so now he's in the partial Shabbos he knows that there's something called Chavez what is austere to do all he knows it's austere to walk mm amis more than 2,000 hours and he's over on 39 other voice and the 39 malakas that he didn't know then he brings through nine crabbiness you're asking me has the password for a person to be internet about us because it's a 40th malefic old home according to Rebecca we don't passing like that we don't passing that home is there right so we pass and come to the rebuttal great let's keep on going we're doing great Montana load the Turner up on on okay this is a bracelet that says what is the depiction in the dictionary when the dictionary talks about shrugging what what is it struggle busy busy Zosia Mamet IRA this is the most obvious in the world if a person doesn't know that it's Chavez and he doesn't know that this Malacca is awesome so he's planting seeds and he thinks it's Tuesday and he doesn't even know that planting seeds is awesome perfect show you Haizi Bozell was there a person he knows that today's Shabbos he has a calendar he has an iPhone and he's and he knows and he learned that he has the oneis book and it shows that you know how to plant seeds zu email mobile time that's the perfect case of amazing Oh what about these three cases one out of the two hugging ashab is visiting lockers he has no idea that today's Shabbos he lost track of time but he knows had he known that a Chavez he wouldn't have done it because he knows that you know a lot of planting now that a cook or the opposite chugga-boom law has basically this is I guess more common he knows exactly today's Saturday he knows his Shabbos he just doesn't know that you know how to cook didn't know oh but this is the case we're looking for listen to this case boys Sean Murray Danny similar Havasu row I know very well that this is also I went to school of Eleni - hi I'm Alec carbonyl oh but I don't know the consequence of carbon no who says that who's the one that says that if I don't know carbon I am a psychic that's moombas the tremendous killers harmonica moombas says the Gemara this bryson must be going according to moombas nobody else says cajamarca with moombas they say not knowing about a carbon is not enough to be your psyche not know car s of course they're beautiful is not is a shaking and not knowing about the laughs and cars is a show you according to your sluggish but not knowing about a carbon when you do bit shy gig is considered a striking when you did amazing again should I say those words again not knowing that you have to bring a carbon while you while you doing something amazing not knowing that if you did it but Shuggie you have to bring a carbon that that's considered a sheikha quarantine moombas it's unbelievable Amara bio how called mari de Machaut sb3 she was beetle what she was beat a person says either he swears in the past or he swears on the future falsely he says I did not eat pizza or he says on Tuesday I ate pizza and that's a lie he didn't eat pizza or he says that in the future next Monday I am NOT going to eat pizza and he eats or he says next Monday I'm going to pizza and he doesn't okay so it's either in the past or in the future what does he do if he's over Bechet gig he brings a carbon Olivier grid and that's a huge kiddush to say that a person has to being a carbon on a laughs that is not be chorus if I did it on purpose I don't get cars so to tell me that if I adjust a simple laugh alive without any cars I have to bring a carbon unique in the Taira kiddush says the Gemara I call my name wars but now the question is we just finished saying what is the show again Chavez either you forgot that you have to bring a carbon or according to Remini forgot that this chorus according to your stalker she forgot that this car isn't alive so what striking when it comes to schwa there is no chorus inishmore so what did you forget according to the earth enough the only way to be a shy gig is you forgot the chorus but there's no chorus what do I do now how do I get to how do I have a case of a shagging by swearing says abaya how come my team is she was beat to it therefore everybody damn it's when it comes to schwa Shanghai of Amalek carbon Archie is balagia ball says Rashi forgot that he swore when he ate until he forgets the laughs not that he forgets that he's high of a carbon or lebih eyelid he forgets that it's the lab of it says the Gemara come by the man rubee - on and has to be rebuked or not because there be other than Hall typically what is considered a shy gig something that forgets Paris over here there's no car s so rebuking on is the one that has to take it down a step and say wait a minute when there is no current now I admit that the shy gig is when I forget to laugh not the car is now I'm gonna go like you're sluggish if there's no grey row there's no other option here there's nothing else to forget the only other thing to forget is well there's two things forgetting that there's a carbon and forgetting that there's a lab but the third condition of car is we don't have it because it doesn't exist so every other one's gonna have to admit that over in this case chugging means somebody who forgot that there's a lot since tomorrow cheeto obviously Kiko maratona Cody cars Roberto said it's a lava when it's available when the cars is there so I'm telling you that Chucky means when I forgot this cars a lot of the lucky car is light by the way this has anybody seen daddy Kornbluth I haven't seen him in a few days [Music] what what's the silent and what in what case we're talking about the love and the Korres if you forgot what day let me think a second you forgot what day it is figure out what Daisy has to be in carbon for every Shabbos no no no okay so on what case are you talking about that can't be in the 39 malakas case that's a different case that's a shy gig in in the day that so that you only bring one carbon that's it you're limited to one we're talking about malakas now that on each Molokai of a carbon what what's the right she gives malakas forgetting the days now she gives in lockup that's not shaking malacca that's forgetting the day so for every shops that goes by said the first Mishnah and clown bottle every times it goes right you bring one carbon cuz every week you made one mistake we assume that during the week you forget it out but we're talking about malakas now I'm the Malacca what did you forget we're dealing with the Malacca specifically not on the day she gets the I'm okay see being one carbon for that chugging not knowing the kinds of the Shabbos you bring one for your entire life we're talking about not not when it comes to the Malacca wouldn't you forget yeah so David what's the answer about my question was you're dead okay fine hope he's well he's here okay I just don't see him cuz you know what I should switch the screen for a second oh the same people on the same screens every day I become he on skis on the wrong screen today supposed to be on screen number one it's not there okay great uh areas he's on screen on three that is daddy car movie came late today are you've a void to you I avoid okay fine and you don't even have to walk anymore daddy quorum you used to walk a mile in every direction and today he's in the real hobby somewhere and he's like okay so the amar or maybe everybody's early that that's what happened or Hashem 119 people on zoo says the Gemara like this so according to a baritone obviously we have to switch gears we have to say that the showing is that he forgot the love since Gemara so what's the footage of course what's about trying to say sake that if I mean Ohio bhai of carbon Kido shoe debacle atari-kun washes on lab the micelle a carbon since it's such a huge hitters that a person brings the carbon are levy I read on a lab that's not associated with a car waha my see and over here you bring this carbon she struggled with carbon Avila high of maybe the carbon is like a chorus sort of thing is a huge hitters so maybe over here if you're gonna say that if he forgot that carbon all of a sudden reveal Connor would admit to moombas even forgetting the carbon is considered a shy gig no your turn over here is going to say like your sluggish forgetting the lab is a shrugging forgetting the carbon is not a chugging come a smile on let's turn the page that some tests all mode Bay's anyways the bottom line is that there's my likeness of moombas and how common goes even in Shores be to may say we're gonna we're getting up to some crazy signature beautiful surgeries and jobs really fun and exciting stuff Mason a zoo she gets was beating the shower now this is a very interesting a la floor as you point out when it comes to schwöre you have to know what you're doing you have to know you have to be aware of what you're saying so when you make a Swart to the future very easy to mess up I say I am I promise I swear I am going to eat pizza blah blah blah on a certain day and something happens he doesn't eat but when he said this sure he was very weird he has to bring a car but try to fit that in in Reverse it doesn't work how did he make a mistake he said I swear I didn't eat pizza but when he swore he didn't know that he did that he didn't pizza he didn't know it he's missing from his in from his awareness when it comes to he'll - whoo he's putted on that sure the person is so convinced that he didn't need but he completely forgot that's not called a short biggie he didn't make him stay he just wasn't aware he was missing part of his brain went dead and he said the wrong thing that's not a short shot that's not sure was b3 so how do you how do you get to a shy gig on the past says the team are wrong she got she was bigger - ah she might need a knee she was do a thorough I've lady Adam have another carbon I like hi I'm an emu buzzy okay so according to moombas it makes a lot of sense he said ashore in the past he was very aware that he ate pizza and he's swearing he didn't eat pizza so that part we covered he had a complete awareness so why is he a shy gig he didn't know you have to bring a carbon that's she does moombas or let's not hurry nowadays some people take this out let's say we put it in it's not really everybody says it's not a real new lotion it's just a way to understand it a little differently in layman moombas Rita according to moombas this movie project actually become hard enough kiddo Shu Ouma she gets carbonyl she girl could the traditionally college game obviously according to moombas this works if you forget that there's a carbon that's considered a shaggy over here there's the Big Finish allah rabbun ani perhaps even rub on on in this case typically your opponents say that in order to be shaggy you have to forget about either the chorus or the lab in the cars depending ribosomes over here in this case of schwoz b3 they'll admit to moombas that if forgetting a carbon is also considered a shy gig the thief Dadaab idea of that because the body just said a second ago that everybody admits when a commis Tosh was be totally forgetting a carbon is not a shaggy over here it says before getting a carbon is it showing you vomit bio how come I didn't the true mo okay let's talk about rumor for a second if a person designates fruit for a Cayenne he says this is the true mo for the lady ten percent for the lady two percent for the client whatever it is and he goes and he eats it he if he either deliberately he gets me so bad a shamayim different than cars question accorded their birth on who says before that forgetting about Carter's is considered a shaggy what about forgetting about me simulation I'm saying will equate the to me TV show Miami Karnas my flake is a pyro if a person eats true ma inadvertently by mistake he didn't realize he put it aside and his wife came and ate the fruit that he put a psychodrama his wife has to bring Karen behind she has to pay the exact rumor that she ate by mistake plus a high mesh which means fifth in Gemara language it's a in English it means 25% great not going into that it's millibar and not really God all the tyrant it's the same it's always all these things are always middle back says the Gemara I call my debate room oh she ain't high of a male high man actually he's going be loud Sheba everybody's meeting everybody myths that comes to true moe you don't bring that fifth unless he forgot that it's a sir how called by the my Ruby - on sheet aw so over here thick mother is saying wait a minute ribbon only said there's a lot of shaky when it comes to Cara's bite rumour there is no chorus so obviously he has to say that shaking isn't something else shy gig is in the laughs like we said before Hey - the lucky cars like er marry beautifully for the Icarus in Chaves that this chorus he forgot chorus in true me that there's no car so what is there instead of cars there's something called me simulation man not the same thing why is it not the same thing because hard as if you if you do car if you do a very big currents you can I have a carbon but shaggy not necessarily by Truman that you get musician man you don't bring in carbon it's different head to the bucket cars light side of the mouth the same a Mesa with Malcolm Carson madness right it makes a lot of sense thoughts look death is death so it's a few years apart whatever but it's definition might I don't think that they're equal and if you forget about me simulation Magnum it's the same thing as forgetting that Cartersville miniature mine no he's choking me sanam is a kind of commercial reverse is not true me sub I'm a comparison where this that's probably what you guys are thinking what's the difference what kind of death penalty he gets the both Minister Abadi and the both death do I care what age he got it and all the different conditions death is death and if I forget about the death penalty minestrone I am that's that should be enough car ass enough shy gag the home age but Malcolm carbon cryin he finishes it off faces look they're equal in the other shops you have Curtis on the one hand if you do it by by by the Mason and carbon hottest if you do Bashar you and true MA same exact thing miss Alicia mine if I do it on purpose why mesh if I do by accident hi Michigan's carbon they're identical they're interchangeable so if I forget Lala is according to humming that forgetting chorus ANILCA Shabbos is considered a shy gig so forgetting me submission my in and hillcrist rumor is a shaggy everybody said one of the most incredible singers I love the suyo or Ivana hi am i Hollis by mid bar they need a master Chavez guys walking in the desert so let me just give you the background how I see this story guys on a ship he wakes up one morning all sunburned he's laying there he looks around he realizes that he was shipwrecked he's knocked unconscious and he's now in the island all by himself looks around he does nothing he doesn't know what day it is he doesn't know where he is he doesn't know who he is his day just started to get worse it's not enough that he almost died and he doesn't know where his family isn't he doesn't ought to get home he doesn't have a cell phone nothing zero he has a much bigger problem the problem is that he's Jewish and he's hired to keep Shabbos so what does he do every day could be Shabbos could be showers right now could it be mahalo Shabbos and we're gonna restrict him so much that every single day he has to be careful perhaps of Shabbos a big big stars so here's a cartoon stamp to uh says what day is it says it's about the yummy okay good thank you great he's holding a gumar rabbi said that's not an iPad it's a positive Gemara it's it's it's the iPad that a bigger gear has it's the Gemara that having our game is okay fine so it doesn't they both don't know where they are they don't know what's happening now you see the coconuts on that tree over there are they allowed to climb the tree and bring down a coconut or two coconuts so here's the crazy answer the answer is how much does a person need to sustain himself so he doesn't die the bare minimum and the answer is I didn't do the research I'm gonna tell you right now it's three-quarters of a coconut I'm just saying whatever a coconut one confident they're allowed to climb up the tree and take down one coconut only everyday and they have to eat enough coconut that they're just about to pass out keep themselves alive bit symptom let's see it inside but we're gonna get this soon before we get there when a shop is what Chavez Halima hollows my meat but we need a master Chavez - she she yummy mummy Shami am i hot so what he does is the following day they wake up the following day they start counting six not today says Rashi because I don't know maybe I was makalah Shabbos today maybe in the morning I had a shipwreck and I was already going like this and I was as I was fueling up the ship not today tomorrow I start counting six days six one two three four five six I make those notches on the palm tree I go like that in the coconut tree and then on the seventh day is Shabbos here Bravo you may know miss Sharma Gary McLeod today is Shabbos or tomorrow is Shabbos right now is Shabbos tomorrow Chavez or - shisha and then I come from there six days but my committing in matters of our curiosity Lila that's the world the world was created six days of weekday and on the seventh well Chavez when my avocado Mauritian when the other Mauritian woke up on the island called ganado and he woke up what's going on the next day right away was Chavez so shout us right away and then he keeps six days says tomorrow makes me hurry my love but there are many of their most in shadows wait a minute how does this fit into the bright Sun it says he forgot what they was mushara EMF of the shisha he should keep one day for every six days what does it sound like my love - she show me show me a method for every six days he keeps one meaning first you should keep six weekdays and then once happens lie you know what I could be done like a little bit and say neshama a metal do - shishun maybe it means first you do Shabbos then you keep six Yaqui it doesn't fit into the words miss Sharma your metal Doshisha I should say miss Sharma your mouth hunt who - she should be barely the wording is off okay that's problem number one problem is too much bigger problem by Tonya this is before surprise that says my husband and I believe we need a mimosa Shabazz what do you do it says no forest miners shisha first he count six Oh missionary I'm effort only then you do Shabbos like bring us at shall i l'm not like other Mauritian seal to the remember after you've to major major problem i just want to point out a beautiful thing here how many times have we said these sukham or heard leave soaking every single Shabbos I did a little bit math I heard them over two thousand times in my life 2.5 thousand times so let me ask you questions okra see I'm a shot as the Koch Oh Shh the comm tabloid you should work six days what if I don't feel like working six days is this a Mitsuda rice at the work six days I'm retired I I won the lottery I have to work six days question number one question number two but a seasick Alma laughs Defoe do everything everything I don't want to do everything I want to do ninety percent what's coma last fo and then it says we have Ashish hours that's Emily careful has anybody ever paid attention when we make kids look at these questions the most simple simplest questions in the world like static whole melaka on Shabbos don't do anything okay these are the questions you know ask these questions the Vilna Gaon simple questions let's go back to for a second o morado because you're the most acute a parent of so sorry what is this dude on the island do he works every single day bar my whole exam if somebody is on and unmuted and I can hear them I hear the background by Maori ma value yummo lame-o's so every single day he works besides in shops now what's she doing Chavez should he die on Chavez what is he supposed to do Suzie tomorrow Dov in Metro sleeper no space he words double on the day he thinks his Friday with Dilma mad mall Chavez hobby but has no idea what de Chavez so maybe he's working on Chavez double L on this De La Jolla my sickle yummy yummy Salerno sauce sorry every single day he does exactly what to live to sustain himself and not a little bit more he can't say oh it's a weekday and I'm gonna work for eight hours and grab ten coconuts and 45 dates from a tree he has to understand how much it takes to sustain him and not a little bit more every date that he takes more might be through Shabbos as the Gemara value mmm I'm in Calais so if he's working every single day the same exact amount he's taking one coconut per day then why is it Chavez the kaduche of a doubt though he makes kiddush and Abdullah says Rashi only for the point to remember Chavez that he shouldn't forget if he's on the island for 25 years he should forget the Constitution others want to say from this Gemara that you can make up your own Shabbos even on a Tuesday there are bars whatever question how does he make condition of dollar just to remember kid addition of dollar requires shemish m you can't make kid the show on a Wednesday you can't make up dollar on a Wednesday maybe you can make up dollop on Tuesday but not on Wednesday the answer is once Cohanim tell you remember Shabbos then then you make abraca they're the ones that tell you to make a bra they tell you to make a bra to remember Chavez you could do it but wasn't this beautiful varta the going sense that these tsukimi referring to our case in our sugar soccer is the mushaf is like a toy remember what day it is because if you forget the calendar if you remember then you can work versus a coma laughter how you could work as much as you want you don't have to reap one coconut you could do 25 coconuts call me laughter ho shakes you see I'm Tavo you don't have to work seven days like the Gemara says if a guy's stranded on the island he has to work seven days everything a little bit know if you remember what these chávez's then you could work tabloid then you're allowed to work on six not a few to work you're allowed to work only on six ube MSV Lesage the co melaka then even that little amount that one coconut you're not allowed to do if you remember what they chávez's so tomorrow my rava in my you're mocking me to say I'm sure it's a boy if a person recognizes the day that he went out he doesn't know Java's but he knows that three days ago he left the port he knows so what is he saying to himself really that three days ago was foreshore net Chaves I am NOT gonna leave on Chavez I'm Jewish I didn't leave on a journey on Chavez so I know one thing I know that three days ago wasn't Shabbos therefore every seven days after that I could do Malacca I know for a fact that thing is not a not a shop as day when Chavis is I don't know as the kymaro I said malefic or I'm cool like cheetah no big finish so I know that one day out of the week is not job is great of course I could do Malacca every seven days after that I'm out the same he keeping the Shabbos later nothing with Malan shops and I'm really nothing wait a minute typically has anybody ever flown besides no one fix has anybody ever flown where you leave well no I'm leaves on Thursday he gets here on when it's circus because he sells a star game in America era of Erev Shabbos a few hours before shots okay sometimes but whoever leaves on a Friday nobody needs on a Friday so maybe I'll say listen if I remember that I left three days ago so I also know I didn't leave four days ago I didn't I don't leave I'm Friday Sycamore that's not true he Nami Nami become she shops in Norfolk now he's a loose relay yes okay I could take a flight from ben-gurion and Landon a lot and a half hour great yeah okay fine I'm saying us normal people that we live in New York in Israel we don't do these flights so yes you could do different things I always saying but listen what the Camorra says so maybe he didn't leave on a Thursday night Nami become cheap shops in Norfolk he obviously left on a Thursday Lucia in a minute right now so he should be allowed to do two days melaka marshmallon Zim in the mission Damascus a yard Oh we'll make her even Norfolk what if a guy got an amazing glitch on Dan's deal he found out that there's a roundtrip ticket from New York to Israel for 220 bucks and that requires him to leave on Friday you do it ah he's gonna land the bendin and then in Tel Aviv 25 minutes before shot it'll come up with all that air in the world it's possible if you find the right bus the right shall chay-ara the right Caravan he might have done it and therefore you can't take that for granted that that day is let's just finish up the death let's go this is easy so ya be there a key shops so so real quickly we had in the first Mishnah that it's passable person brings one carbon cactus for his entire life when when he forgot the whole idea of Shabbos or he was born into a society that doesn't know Shabbos one carbon visit there's a person that brings one carbon for every single Shabbos what is that a person that forgot that today is Chavez he didn't forget the idea of Chavez he knows about he just forgot that he lost track of the day he lost track of the calendar then he brings for every Shabbos a stigma who told you why where did he get this from maybe the guy that was born and every single shop is he was over maybe he should bring a carbon every Shabbos who told you citizen Marcos we have a contradiction in the soaking famous pursue Kim Min Island we all arrive nothing buddy about O'Meara of Nachman I'm a reviewer at ray Crowe exceeding the first positive Chaminade sauce of Shabbos well we say it every Shabbos in singular the charm Ruben a stroll and sash a bus one and then it says it shops a side dish moyu in plural contradiction do you keep one child as you keep all the shop Boston locates at the chambre saw such a Boromir a physician buses army says Rashi since we have a contradiction the tire gave her common the ability Villa emotional haha Manila Heidi and miss vara hi Bashar Shabbos the hottest doggy had the tire gave her common the power to decide logically which possibly was applied to what and logic dictates that if a person was born into a society where there's no concept of Shabbos so how many mistakes did this guy make his entire life one mistake but if a person knows the kinds of the Shabbos just he forgot what day it is how many mistakes did he make every week is a new mistake and therefore the second positive shops a site is Maru is referring to that guy that forgot every Shabbos Shamir I was hired by Bishop so he's - marushin your office local chaves chaves masculine laughing buddy it's look at the Robbo anyways rock bass looks is the same exact thing he just learned it from different he reverses the sukham but I did the same took these chicken learned it on their own and they decided which one is what Bashara Bearnaise sauce washable schmira has the cold showers of Shabbos each and every Shabbos you should be over one of a row it's a Shabbos and next sharpest is wrongly believed since Travis and the tribes after that is determination Travis and the pausing accept so he said the shmoo should have insufficient up assignment the opposite the target tells us plural meaning all the shop us is exactly this guy's entire life are wrapped into one and on that is how the outcome is the same a guy that didn't know the kinds of the Shabbos beings one carbon a guy that knows the kinds of just he forgot that today is Shabbos he brings at one carbon for every single Chavez in Shabbos have a wonderful wonderful day [Music] first of all the mountain no no no she spell yeah everybody's muted you can unmute yourself if you want let me ask you did you see did you see did you see the cartoon you notice the cartoon we what oh my gosh I apologize somebody ended the meeting