Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 45 by R’ Eli Stefansky

we're live now on new code words let me just make sure that we're good all right rabbi shai terrible terrible suggestion terrible now boys they don't forget today is the 11th day of the Sphero I have a suggestion that's right that's right Yakko you could come on after the emails it's fine whoever doesn't like the emails tune in 5 minutes later or a voice I we there's nowhere to go this is your Tyra we're gonna learn a few extra minutes nobody is gonna get sick from it it's all gonna be good I could've uh crib Ellie all you guys could tune out right now for this email it's fine I'm talking to myself where's Gary who's supposed to be here helping me out with his phone but he's not here I'm here by myself this goes back to the guy I believe from bar park I'm not gonna mention his name but I think it's a beautiful email I'll be honest over the last 13 years I lost my appetite and learning and sadly decided to throw in the towel embarrassing now at age 40 came I came back and you are playing a big part in it as I enjoy to hear you sure and all the goodies that comes with it the kits are get shocked my son also learns with me - Daffy so far every day and you have a lot of brush on your head without even knowing you got me very busy the Shabbos and this is very important oh so I guess Gary's on his way here because I see the everybody is a another muted very good okay somebody's immunity rabbi let me let me finish let me finish my email please thank you just mute mute yourself please thanks I'll share my findings so he was very busy with undischarged he's very busy with the halacha regarding pudding uncooked salt and a hot plate of soup on Chavez so here's my findings this matter so basically he says I'm not gonna read the whole thing but I'm very impressed that this individual who hasn't been learning for many years he sat down and he gives me the whole thing - prima gardener mr. Breuer oh the shreya shava skill Xhosa and then all at the end first of all he says like this I didn't like this line he says I'll share my findings normally I would not have the hoods but to write in a locket to you as you know it anyway that is too soon to have volume again I'm just a simple real estate guy that I give a shear steel you send me whatever you want and I make many mistakes but since us if anyone has info about the matter I took the jump and he says all at the end my own bucks for it's a very long email not gonna read the whole thing obviously as most people want the soup served as hot as possible therefore the server's rushing to serve as fast as possible that reduces the problem of serving of the serving spoon becoming a Cleary shine if it's inside for a while we're not leaving the serving spoon for a while uh-uh because we're not leaving the service mover because he's saying that since you're rushing to dish out the soup that the other of them doesn't become a clear vision sight so first of all the Mishnah brewer himself has the contradiction the mr. Brewer adopts I'm right in the beginning that a ladle is a Cleary shine and later on he says it's like a cliche McLeish lishi the minhas Hitchcock who's the dye in the the guy bit of the of the dad's rabbi Weiss he writes the missus Hawk he says that maybe the mr. Brue in the beginning was he said there was a Suffolk between whether it's a clear Hashanah cliche nice oh he's macula densa clear region and afterwards he had a Suffolk whether it was a cliche miracle easy shoes make alon that the husband is says that if you put because I become an SI I don't know where he's at but I become he asked you saying that a little is not a clear each hi AVI so the cars inertia says that if you put a ladle into a pot of soup that's on the fire that automatically becomes a Cleary shine it becomes like the path and if the pot is off the flame then it becomes a cliche knee I put the vault and a fact thank you our friend from I don't know where from seems like from barbed wire okay in your house that's how it goes I guess what you're saying you have to do it like that I don't know I never really wanted what if you put a ladle into the soup pot that's on the fire what I love is about now that put a ladle in me I don't know okay but that's how what that's what he says obviously there is maybe maybe I'm not deaf maybe I'm not deaf it's a no but I gotta feel a lot of cook so that's what he says he says the difference between clear it's a classic cashes it must be a way that you could put a ladle in there on the fire otherwise what's the alright bus knob it's already 722 that's getting antsy now we're finishing too late oh you see very good so corn to that you see the cousin is hold it's okay on the fire but why time is Italian times come o'clock I mean house all these are lockers will he talking about alright just a short thing I didn't want to go on a big rant here but this guy sent me an email like last week which I read and ended he says about his friend that one of the kind of we kept him on the derrick with the sheer and I didn't add it it's not a lot of time now either but real quickly it's time to throw it over there in my opinion and this is known stuff but it just hurts me to see that our I know these these kind of guys like these conceding that they feel or Litvak so or whatever it is you feel that you're stuck in your new group and once you come out of your group you might as well just go off to their kind of thing it really bothered me now it's thinking about it that today the lines have blurred you know I've been in debugging in Borough Park where a guy would be embarrassed any Litvak energy shoul be embarrassed to beat it a to management as ray so where I see them are you know that there with Aveda and Fela and there's Fela doesn't look like Teela and then the look facts learning doesn't look like learning and the lights are just blurred I see them I'm learning better than the looked facts and the listening better than that I see them and then you have one of my best friends from Chicago he I don't know if he's what he usually watches I hope he's not watching today we'll find out in a few minutes he's a modern orthodox guy so he has the the knit yarmulke and the whole thing and he diamonds in a matador attack shalini maybe a few of his coffees are slightly modern or next but when I want to bother in my tongue hey you're more Chi ready than her ad anytime I go on a roll I used to go with him to visit my trip my properties he's a bank owner three hours of debris Tyra constant just talking and learning the entire time he always has a son's name on his mouth he that was vez seeking he's more Hirini than than all the hurry them that I know so he wears that kind of funny imma gonna he calls himself so the lines are blurred so all I'm saying is that this guy just just hurt me to see oh because I'm stuck in min catch or whatever so that's it I have to it's either me catch or go after them this other there's other facets to either scribe person could be like a that Shannon just doesn't go by the Hat and by the yama combat at this alright let's learn some Tyra Daffy mem hey what what are you saying alright is it is is it not muted today Gary what's going on I see smiling you're all excited nothing more laughing hey I'm an Alf so we just finished saying a big finish that sometimes Muktar mega diskette soybean and schmagges it's got solid Akuma this homra right that if something is mocked the during manish masha is it makes it MOOC sir throughout the whole Shabbos even if it's not bigger than doctor let's say if a candle is extinguished but since we moved for a few minutes of any schmagges that candelabra smokes it for the rest of Shabbos that could actually be a cooler we said we're for Shabbos if you want to hang up a lamp on a tree so on Chavez you could because you take this kinds of Mickey this case are you been - much it's got surly cool I mean you're not gonna climb up a tree you know better than to go fetch your lamp we're on yonder if you could hang your lamp on a tree but that's because Rab goes like review the and Moksa now says like this we are holding like seven lines now the Rav acuity light bob almond a derive this rad really hold a groupie who the emotes up the ass rap mouth abdullah shrug of the konnyaku so the Canuck saw Makaha barbershop so you have a Hanukkah candle in the time of the hub or him you're scared of the guy he's not gonna kill you necessarily have eager girls just asking about you i guess you're here all the day what am I supposed to do is not straight hell he Dyke me from New York City no he's saying something le that what is he screaming oh oh maybe saying this this no no he's saying this I didn't hang this up okay let's close this door that's what he's saying it doesn't matter there's no sponsor today and the 11th David I'm er okay thanks you thank you rep le Dagon from New York stays up to the Year this year so you have these car Bartley comment and cause some bodily hardly to take some of your money they don't allow you to light the Chanukah lights and you lit a tariff Shabbos you decided to to light the Chanukah candles anyways now you remove it on shops a little sharper dummy it's okay so see see that we hold a group Shimon there's no Mook - why did why did rather loud to move the cat shots not Shani you're talking about an emergency you don't matter it's a car no we're concerned that the guy we're gonna come and beat you up so for that I say you could touch Mook to Tamil era Africa Hannover of a she'll Arab like rough kind of told and reveille she told Rav hockey so that's a lot that you let him move candles after Shabbos although this is a very famous saying I see them I think like to say this a lot it's used slightly out of context could die you rabies Chimel is my color the shots at hawk where's the more say that losses really like reviewed oh but fish I said hugged you have a war you have you have you have an enemy that's gonna beat you up so you can move the candles on Chavez but there are people that they use this oh can i you rebbi shimon listening problem chest of hawk if you have a sorrow in your family you could go to rip shin-bi your haver and daven etc they use it a little bit it's it's taken from here from this this is a line in the Gemara it's also in Deaton it's a little bit you know cause he was retired sort of Cudahy rebbi shimon listen follow me shot hot okay do we actually me client on today anybody see Shlomi client it was a tremendous inspiration straight I only noticed him after she was over he's the lab amateur from Crown Heights that was in the hospital for a very long time and after Shearer he told us how he almost lost his blood the whole thing is struggle and he didn't know where he was for a week and he ate one banana a whole thing he went through it but he's not on okay most of tremendous it was an inspiration to see that he was there we dive in for him and he's up and alive dr. kemar Biman a rich lucky Schmerber O'Donnell he theme she's rhombic ARCA so now we discussed a mooks a corner of Sherman Sherman is very make Olomouc it doesn't hold it this much we had yesterday that perhaps he does now perhaps he holds of MOOCs of money which is MOOCs and Maximus buffa the money itself has no other purpose but to buy there's nothing else you could do and also you would hold of buses that if that money was on the wheel of the money of the wagon side hold the buses but it doesn't know the other muxes most uh that the the MOOCs it comes in during Manish mushes it remains two methyl shops that he doesn't hold them different MOOCs as he doesn't hold off what about so now we're gonna narrow down more what exactly what what kind of MOOCs it does he hold of what doesn't he hold of by rich luxury icon on heating she's rhombic Erica you put kernels into the ground now Rashi point around these kernels didn't take root because if they took root obviously you cannot take them out on Shabbos because there'll be culture but you put it into the ground you would like to be a dying you said I don't want these kernels anymore I want them to grow wheat she's wrong back Erica who Bateson shiitakes and Terra guerrillas mouth also something you set aside you said okay you you chicken take this egg sit on it Mau he less than Mishima MOOC to hate to delete a few bird I hate indeed after me died a mistake MOOCs perhaps since he pushed it away literally with his hands he said I am planting these kernels I don't want anymore so maybe remember Shimon admits that this is moksa yeah we had yesterday according to one cheetah then if you have a very large vessel of oil which that oil is gonna last you through the whole Shabbos so he set it aside even according to him and according to one cheetah that's booked because he knows he'll never use that oil so similar to this he set it aside he put in the ground I'm never gonna see that kernel again so maybe that smoked up oh he did my life now or maybe no it's not moco on my leg Ain Mook to lube Chi Minh le chemin chip an Arab Bashar should die like so rebuking an answers and no let me give you the hug Dora of moocs it's only in oil that lights high over hook 2 limits what sorry hook so Leroy so the Gemara understands very interesting some are even goriest ving hoop to Lisa right with a vote and that makes a big difference but understanding is the same big Marv understand that there are two things here this hooks alimentive ah this is oil that I'm lighting for Shabbos candles that's a mitzvah sure can straddle them it's my sub it's a mitzvah and also it's awesome it's a flame the combination of these two things a flame or isser and a mitzvah that's what rep Shannon says makes it Mach 2 but if you put a curl on the ground you don't have those two things so it's not muck to ask the Gemara of the leslie hooks the limits of us are wait a minute so you tell me you need two things you need mucked up that you set it aside for a minute spot plus the actual thing is mucked up the actual thing is it is sir like the fire what about if you have one of the two you only have let's say a mitzvah according to what you just told me it's not book to equipment you need two things together but Tanya oh that's not true cyclical huh saw a person made a Sukkah the issue of Akram in any beautified it he what's the word no he put decorations on it it should be chromium he put some colored clothing on it who's denied me - erm embroidered linen Vuitton by guys him like an artist wrong you go to the store you buy those decorations it says yeah he decorated thank you decorated it and there's a straw you could go to the store and you have the special Christmas decorations it says only Christmas and they and they same you had for nobody knows how to read English so they so Manish what you put on your Christmas tree so you take those decorations if you don't know better and you put in your suka at guys him not a fire second you know i don't know if you ever been to these suckers people do this those day peaches skated almonds very my name pomegranate berry Kili shall I love him and then clusters of grapes factorial she bought him and they take wheat bun the week the I know is had he put wine on your circle you put it in a flask and you hang it up on the stop Shmuel name oil whose law says and flower now what does it say also the stopping them add my toy younger Moffatt we actually had the suki enough of Bayes it's an amazing finish I don't know if a lot of people know about this but we learned it there and we'll repeat it again noise Sokka the decorations of a soaker are Muktha you set them aside for the Mitzvah of suka and therefore they are mucked so even on column might you might be able to touch it it might not be like the mix of a real books on Shabbos but it means you can't use it for anything else so if I put a picture of a God allow my silk I can't just take it and use it somewhere else it's muck to for my suka I was max it for the Mitzvah it's interesting right like a little plastic thing becomes Buchta for the Mitzvah I set it aside for them it's an important word here that we have to notice is also the stopping them at Mitsuru on the back right you now leather use the decorations until the altar bathroom which means until after simplest IRA why now I understand that on circus I can't use it because rip Shimon holds and we were saying this Cossack interruption trying to prove because retrieving holds that it smokes it for the Mitzvah what about the last day of yontiff what does Simkin start I have to do with anything so we have to say me GU this cat sorry banished my choice it's got Sully coolly i'ma write it continues into the inter inter surface tyre but guess what rep she doesn't hold me against cats I finish motions concern de cuyo so it's very wild there's a wild line here at the end of theis is different masculine materials of provincial hog and pleasure says venir Larry did the math showy serious have bright say Yount of our growing legassik Europe shimon crazy that line and just and know'm if you learned this sugar yesterday you prepared beforehand and you didn't know this place is just for that was worth listening yeah you tell me you didn't learn this something I see you ready from your face okay okay you did you did learn this okay you didn't listen it's Corona there's a lot of excuses fine you know why I'll tell you why there's no cars are shots you like to anyway fine says the game are you here what's going on here so that's a side point also stopping me would sell you out the background will go according to review they're not a chrome d'etre but the point is that all these decorations are MOOCs are boom in my direction mini now this is also very wild how do I know that what I just read is rip Shimon I'm trying to prove the RIP Shimon holds the concept of Musa with one out of the two things if I just set it aside for a mitzvah even though it's not Austral look a flask of wine is not MOOCs inherently it's not a flame so why is it mucked up because I set it aside for the Mitzvah so in other words rip Shimon holds that this moksa even one out of the two conditions just setting it aside for the Mitzvah why and how do I know it's from Shin so look what the Kumar does here and Rashi points this out it's very important the good Mar brings a whole nother bright so that says the exact same thing with rip Simmons name so then what I need the first Pricer I have a Brice of with rips woman's name so just ask me question lock rip Shannon says in the bride so with rich in his name there were Shimon says that all you need is one condition I bring the second bracelet to prove that the first Bryce is eruption it's a beautiful question Rashi points out an amazing thing though he says all the time throughout chassé when it comes to Bryce's the best Bryce in the world is repeal rapira be Shia so the first Bryce that was written by repairman Ruby Shia so it's much better for us to get AB right so that's that that's accurate and we're proving that that Bryce is accurate with another brighter that's not as accurate but it has room Simmons name in it okay fine well reminder simony right and when we're saying rip Shimon by the way we said shipment it's home everybody right right Shimon rush B Trimble it's almost like vomit we're going to be able ten people going to go to this cave of this year jiminy the Tony Ricci a barrier I see McCann may there be a written on a note that makes when I sue Kobe on developing a sonic law now the first line here we're talking about a sucker onion TIFF what young Tiffin at circus okay just regular simple Chattanooga Morrow we're talking about Pesach Schwartz young turf Rosh Hashanah I have a sucker and I wanna take a piece of wood out of the suka I want to make a fire because it's yunda if I want to cook my food I cannot touch my silk or why because I'm breaking my sucker that's called Sai sir it's uh sir LM in that summer Club Raji sticks in it's not just a pile of wood next to the sucker I'm in a summer claw I'm just saying Pasha shot means it's holding up the sucker it's like leaning on the sucker but if I remove a piece of wood the sukkah is not gonna fall down so I'm a look that's not called sorry sir I could use that word very mean Matier we're not gonna go into all the detail the point is the corner of Shimon if it did fall down he anticipated that it's gonna fall down it fell down so now I'm not being overrun sy sir but the issue is the quantity who the the wood is mucked up because I wasn't allowed to take the word because it's slicer and according to him and there's no halakhah of MOOCs on this world if the souk is no longer there and there's no problem of size sir I could use the wood because women doesn't hold a MOOC so the shopping Masuka the hag mechag she Asura and everybody agrees that a sucker on suckers is a sir why was i smacks it for the mitzvah of sucker I'm pay sir there's no there's no myths of sucker sorption it's exactly who's the word but on suckers I'm saying that my panels of wood are for my mitzvah and even if it fell down I cannot use it says eruption beam hiss no lair and according to Donna comma if he made it tonight and he said I want to use my let's say my noise Sokka I want to use my decorations how call the feet no fine the bottom line is you see for Soviet regime insensitive Mook sir when it comes to Mitzvah I set aside something for a mitzvah okay so why actually we said that you need two things bike bike handle you need two things you need to set it aside it's set aside for Mitzvah and it's a flame and that's why ribbiting says it's smoke because I have two things over here you see you don't need a flame all you need is a mitzvah Susan come are you right you only need one thing cane chairmanship and Erica I mean on what we said in the beginning of the Sookie day you need two conditions what I meant is one condition it should be similar to flame high elbow hooks are limits vaso hooks are you sir the main point is that it's it's a mitzvah so rep Simeon holds of MOOCs of Mitzvah that's what he holds hopefully surah decorations our MOOCs are a flame on Shabbos is MOOCs and not because it's a fire but because you set it aside for the Mitzvah about locus narrows for for showing values it Manama a better return on Ain MOOC so the regime and evocation ship in every show should really so before it says look rip shin holds a MOOC to when it's similar to candle high of the hooks of the mitzvah sorry what's the point that it's not so because of its myths we set it aside for a mitzvah and therefore hook silly sorry but the point is one hooks elements foster and therefore it's awesome unraveled Amishman a MOOC to live Shimon hello Greg Rose Fatima Kimball van in case you don't know what it looks like these are a Gary why don't you come to my house now that I see you on there why don't you come to my house and set up a real camera these are grapes set aside in the Sun you see all these guys over here also tremendous amount I don't know if you could see just sitting there drying up in the Sun as soon as it hits the Sun you can't eat it anymore they they're spoiled grapes in the Sun says they can morrow when it comes to food there are only two items two items only figs and grapes the two items that as soon as he put in the Sun you can't eat them anymore and condition number two is I put it in the Sun I pushed it away with my hands I was going to be a dynamite I don't want this anymore I am taking this I'm designating it for raisins raisins so I have two things here first of all I pushed it away with my hand second of all they're not edible fregley tomorrow me that Queen annoyed whoa other foods well Tanya also put a name okay that's the that's what we already spoke about Greg gross that's telling him what I said Helen the guy who put it on the roof last name burgers ban oven we discussed those are called raisins voicemail and goggle eyes I don't see Mookie y'all like Jasmine if he says he designated specifically to eat you could eat it on Shabbos otherwise it smoked oh but the questions from here the Hannah told me about fire second peaches the hi Shane so looking Rashi kaboosh in convinced so we have that in English here's a quince okay so you don't know what it looked like and had an abraca said one yeah yeah okay so it gives it what's his name Toma is gonna bring me a quince tomorrow well what's okay no I don't need I don't need I don't need quinces will be shocked mean a pay raise what's his name no kazeer uh I forgot his name around okay got me the salt glad that's enough for this week Rosie Rosie Rosie yeah Square I'm Sharmini Peries Manny even reviewed Oh Michael if that may be adaiah mystic MOOC so now who does it go going to review the holds if I didn't push it away says Rachel doesn't mean I didn't push it away I put it in a storage facility a storage facility says Ruby who da and makes him look though I don't want it anymore I don't need it right now that sucked so but I didn't I didn't see I'm done with this forever I'm gonna take it out in a month nevertheless it smoked oh hey that'll be a die in my coffee and certainly a quince that I said okay I want to I want to make it I want to what equality I want to dry it so that's considered it'll be a dime I pushed it away certainly to be mocked la-la rib jiminy so obviously this coming to be much hardship hindus that even according to turkish women its Mukhtar so ye tell me condition there's only two food items grapes and figs now you have quinces you have peaches loyal arabia who though no cause contributor but let's recall a it's a special kiddush by food sagar that Hamina keep in the cockles but also learn about as mana since he's eating it he's showing that he really is interested in this food he keeps on nibbling on it commercial on cuban hell on the gag assumed clear isolated that item you now you know once i put it on the roof even though i'm I'm mashing from it it's still considered a saccade ass he's saying i don't want this anymore I'm done with it and becomes it becomes MOOCs so again there's no Raya so we're stuck with rich women only two foods are mucked up they are figs and raisins when you make a grapes when you make raisins and these are the foods that we said doesn't go according to him it goes to contribute but and the finish is that you should know food even though you're eating from it and it looks like you don't you're not trying to set it aside it is considered it has occurred that according to review with them all right so what do we have tackles bottom line is we have that according to be shaming even though I set something aside I pushed it away with my hand it's not mocked so I need two things according to German I need it should be like a raisin I push it aside with my hand a and B it's not really laughs gila once it sits in the Sun for ten minutes it's spoiled so I need two conditions what about if I have the other condition I have that's not royal Aquila but I never pushed it away with my hand what style of event Biman Arabs Shimon by Rebbe Marathi now look at these look who's asking the question rebbi shimon the son of Rebbe that's important because the Gemara understands because he asked his father this question that he believed his father holding up Shimon why why is Rebbe son asking him about the sheath of rib Shimon because his father Rebbe holds like like rip Chinon that's how the grammar understood otherwise Rebbe son wouldn't have any business asking his father exactly how rich women held who cares that look it's not like him but because I'm asking I'm curious what rip Shimon is saying then to me that means that you my daddy ready you hold the corruption okay so what did he ask impacts in late tomorrow these are types of dates that never never become real fruit and the mail is not edible the shameimaru but he was never dyed to be a diamond you have food that's not edible but he never pushed it away he never set it aside and said I'm not eating it by itself it's not edible but he didn't set it aside not eat on my leg a Mook Taylor Shimon and look great guys fitzy mu Kimble bad no you need to conditions you need the he'll be a dining and you need not ready laughs Eva and she'll eat tomorrow only has one or two as the Gemara the Rebbe Leslie Mukhtar so now we could understand what the Kumar's question it that's rash explains the Rebbe last name up to all because his son asked him that he was like your Shimon so you're assuming that he doesn't know the MOOC so as the Gemara what he meant Rebbe holds him up the Rebbe halls like maybe who though so now that the motors question makes a little bit more sense a lot of sense it fits in but now and it says Ain Maskin hold on okay says the missionary mask him be sure that in this I mean Barrios so a month of you later shaft an animal and we learned in Hulan the way they do they used to give the animal to drink a lot of water and that would assist them in removing the skin to hide since the Mishnah you now letter give an animal to drink or to share an animal at Summit Barrios if you have animals that just wander out there and the Gemara is gonna tell us exactly what I mean maurices mug is what it is the point is that you were misty up that's from this animal if you have an animal if you have an animal that you know you you're gonna eat onion t'v see you later shafted but you have an animal that disappeared a half a year ago you haven't seen him you don't know where he is all of a sudden on your third shot him I like him oh here's the place was the name of the animal let's climb us to ashita know why because you had no dance on him you already must see a dance you see that he can't use it a mash can you show that to me some Barrios the wild ones the ones that go out in the mid bar you can check you're talking about a cow right I always have this picture in my mind like this ranch in where was it in Tennessee over there like thousands of acres and they and they use the helicopters to maneuver the animal you know huge animals all the way there you never see him he's way miles and miles away from alayhim that animal you can use Miss Barrios Ave a mask in vishuddhi mr. Pisces the domesticated ones the ones that come home that you could chat Nathanial 11 virus completely passive the nurseries be reveal what's considered a mid bar he goes out right now in our school phone right after Pesach when the rain stops and he comes back when by the first rain he hears us leaves for the entire summer he's gone by sighs what a domesticated one cuz she also is very good at home boys Valona sweet at home every night they come back they they don't distance themselves more than two like at home $2,000 they don't dismiss himself that far they'll go 10,000 arm away but they at night they always come within 2,000 ammo of your house all of this these are details what's the point Rebbe I'm er a Luthor a little by ceasing ah Rebbe sticks in his two cents in other words Rebbe is involved in this mellitus and he says now everything is considered by C's but when he says this will go into what he says when he says its meaning he holds a MOOC - he's saying hands up - just looked up and let me tell you what it says of that when it says a - but it's not it's a - so he believes in this whole Council of MOOC so this whole Sookie is only this whole mission is only going to review the document so you see that Rebbe holds a MOOC - and he says a LaBella basis ain't a thang the Elohim is barrios what's considered a myth bar culture Royce but off our it goes out to the pasture main classes leash elitism of which never comes home not in the one through nine the summer I guess you own it somehow it says your name on it but they'd never come back that kind of animals is ready you must see if that it's mucked so you cannot use it on yonder so what is it does Rebbe hold them up to or does he not all the books on the one hand we see his son asked him about rib shimon so he's very curious very soon so he doesn't other moves on the other hand we see that he holds them up to the mark gives us three possibilities here you buy the same ahan inna me he Gregor is very this is very typical style of mother to say these kind of answers if I say Manon honey Nami kagura's it's EMU kingdom you answer number one when the animal leaves and goes like Rebbe said for the summer in the winter then it's exactly like a raisin why because you have to you have two conditions here first of all you don't you'll be dying you don't get out of here leave my barn go on your own don't come back and number two it's very difficult to get him back how you gonna get him back then no it's not like your raisin that's not really lucky look but it's very difficult this radish eating grin back so I have two conditions that make it very difficult and therefore even shaming agrees that are a myth Bari animal is considered mocked so that's answer number one so in fact Rebbe holds a crucian that is no Mook so but if you have the conditions like a like a raisin then he does hold of Mook to the other answers say no the boys a mullet Varvara shimmy comer I'm just trying to figure out how to Chipman holds Leila sphere like I read don't hold like a persimmon but you in rip simian I'm gonna explain rebbi shimon that a mid bar means this and a by c means that I don't know like that babe I say melody render I bought uncommon low he's talking and like review the sheet though lately the last name looks a cloud oh I admit term Shimon that there's no mukou it's who idly me ass they'll the others depends on has to be revealed advices needle could you at least admit to me that an animal that doesn't leave forever it comes back after half a year don't you agree to me that that's considered a domesticated animal look half a year it's in the it's in the barn say comment review this is no robot around relay law miss Boris Nino I'll call bottom we cannot prove from here that rebbe hold of moksa cookies just talking in review deshita a court could be huge pocket matters don't see that there's no mooks it just happens to be that this kind of animal is Moksa know right I'm a rabbit behind armed rebel enough so now he's seen the name everywhere my local human they said the comedian said that lockers like a machine me over a building rocky Obama named SABIC Rio now typically during inch as we said according to Titus how Sabah could mean Eliana V or where specifically it's Natalie oh no first of all he has a name Saba karana Varela sir Raja either came from Korea or from Saraya but he's asking regulation and a question it should be the opposite right rebelling should ask he asking a yah no big question yes Mary O'Donnell he knows should time to go over small talk to Larry Shabazz can I move a whole chicken coop I have this small little thing like we had the other day in the picture a little box for my little chickens can I move it I need I need it smoking or I need the actual chicken coop look so goofy McCleary my on my leg from us we a little attorney : so it's meant for chickens citizens for chickens so it's mucked oh so what are you telling me that rebuking holds a caption it rubbish even says there is no Mukta and the chicken coop will never be mocked Oh oh very saying the chicken the chicken coop was mucked up so we're gonna have to come up with a reason why even according to Shimon this is Mukta now the chicken and the coop the box is smoking - why is the box mortar so as we mark under my skin on the is beta fryer AIDS oh it has a dead chicken it so typically a chick I could feed to my dog but says Raschi if the chick was alive and well on air of Shabbos I think we should see rash inside it's a beautiful ratchet ratchet did we master this belfry mates since Rashi the Assizes may huh look co-op nebula classic oh I forgot overfishing McAdams and available version it says I could give a dead animal to my to my dogs honey me Liam sue Kenneth says Ranchi that's when the animals are about to die so I thought about it have a brie ally but a chicken that wasn't supposed to die of Shabbos delay I have a diet a metalic love him since he didn't have his dad's on a killer they didn't feed it Vibram she made me Shabbos Nami don't have the item at the club says Raschi that a corn Chinon since he never thought about it I cannot feed it to my dog tremendous finish this bear fur makes me to Lamar Bearer I mean my mich made around about the time she died soon that's all great according to the schita that says I cannot feed something like that to my animal Ella migrator of yours wish me the revolver of Shimon I feel about kind Shimizu not like what Rashi says that even in a case where he never had intent to give it this dog this is a sheet that says I can still feed it it's not mocked on scimitar Michael I'm a mer so why is this chicken poop Muktar alright and they want to say by the way each time as a so we know where we're holding what about that oil have you had a corner of Shimon a lot of oil a lot of oil what's the what's the smart to be mohabbat wean a lot of oil derricks you will that that smokes because he could light the whole Shabbos and this chicken that dies that's not mocked they say because a lot of oil he was like to be a dying he said right away Arab shops I don't want this oil but a chicken who's never done he thought it's gonna live he never knew that it's gonna die how am i skin on B this Bay bait sauce so we have to say another shot wider it be I couldn't say that according to him in this chicken coop is Mukta because it has a negative was born on Shabbos and that's not bad so Shimon believes in the MOOCs of my lad oh that's if he believes in it Vollmer of now from a man distantly MOOCs are insane no time the last thing MOOCs are less they know you like a corner of Nachman Richmond doesn't hold up nor that why because of Nachman kindness interruption the guy knows that he's gonna have a neck tomorrow it's not a finish to him he anticipated it according to him if you anticipate something like you said a second ago even if he anticipates the death of his chicken it's also not it's not mocked so so since he fight so there's no no not according to rip Shimon in rib now says the Gemara the is bae bates SF right yeah oh if you have a chicken and an egg that's the worst of the worst why it has absolutely no value you cannot feed it to a dog says Rashi because the dog won't eat an egg because of its shell you won't eat the shell and that chicken side is certainly not valuable for a human being so male it's worthless and even in that case rip Shimon says it's mucked up it's no different than money money rip Shimon says his MOOCs are when a zero value Iraq money and a dead chicken an egg so you're asking me what's that Allah have a chicken coop so I'm telling you that since a chicken coop I can anticipate that they'll be dead chickens in their eggs mamela that chicken coop becomes a buses and it's also to move that's what Roberto means answer was as a result we're abusive I'm rabid and I love the Kirby who da so one one man dollar says they're beautiful says specifically that love is like a view that there is mocked should be lady I'm a local creamy don't you love when there's my locusts what the my focus is like Hannah Atkin maybe keep it says this below this is this comes up biases that looks like if Heba comes reverses that love was like your losses I didn't get anywhere I still have the same alike is that had before fine so yeah well might know where this is really beautiful and said that love is like you though and review my lady says but that love is like you've Shimon alright guys if Hydra dorm arab-american on Mifflin our morality of Shimon they ribbon says they say that walks up Shimon what does that mean they say I don't say I say on Reuven lately feel like I hold down lockers like we'd be like they're not so if they'll offer I'm sorry that love is like rebuilding says that looks like you de ribbons talking he says they say that was like your shipment but I myself returned on I passed him like a Buddha that holds him hooked up oh I hold of moxa then Roberta doesn't have to say an answer in the chicken coop that there was a dead chicken in the egg he holds a mocked up so regardless that whole chicken coop was mucked up it's set aside for devar Mizoram it's not it's mucked up only I buy your Loretta Yosef that like this was a real turn-on tribute oh so this is an interesting question the Kumar's question it's very dark thick in other words why do you need a combi maja dish that this is what Rebecca done said its posture that rebel hadn't held like Ruby who though you're the question why are you telling me that Rebecca no Passons like yerba Hooda it should be very obvious from the following story that it holds like a beer though and the gamora's answer is that from the story it's not obvious I could say the stories talk about something else okay what's the story or about her last seen some people gar ZAR by me I think her amaravathi igloo the babe abdomen kafir they went to a certain place the norm in our Tod limit Arab a Sevilla kilt Allah so you have this candelabra fell on the coat of Rebbe ABBA Revathi and he didn't pick it up and move it because he held it smoked so maybe he walked away he told him in that sad what every day but he didn't he didn't touch it my time my lavish under Abasi time with everyone obviously because we know that r Abasi is a time whatever be reckon on maybe I'm gonna give you this really this may look tough so from this story you see there be other holds a MOOC too cuz this town it didn't want to touch the candelabra oh well a man at the camera is that's not a good right if you were just to say this story I wouldn't know what Ruby often holds because I could be don't like and say that that story is talking about a very large candelabra and there's a new mixer called cleave a Amaka an app because of a MOOC saw a Visser when our - I need the river Coconino reversi Hirsch lucky Schmidt take them in know your oh honey tell us via the archives Moodle taught law if I can move this can live with one hand it's it's light then I can move it on Chavez mache all of us a little too low and two hands you can't as the commercial explain cause he's given MacLean variable in our own way no no alibi no Kariba Shimon have a menorah bein it'll be on the ark until just a lot of Austerlitz out to law so here you go we have that story happened by a candelabra candelabras are different the time and my rabbit varies the diameter value Hoyle volume prevail on mockery and this story similar there's a similar MOOCs are called MOOCs and Mathematica Sarkis I'm not saying it's the same thing similar let's say the example they give is the knife of a mile or I think a very expensive piece of silver a painting nobody touches it from the fact that people are very careful only by a brisk meal or whatever or they don't let people touch it on the wall that's most of my console sorry kiss I don't move it this is similar I have this beautiful heavy piece of candelabra I don't move it it has spot this is where it is when the a knuckle try to mess with it I yell at them this is fat so male it smokes over here I don't want to move it that's a new MOOCs are called labellum Oakland tomorrow gonna continue seeing that love of Kabir McClane have a wonderful wonderful day no I'm why do you know [Music]