Daf Yomi Shabbos Daf 44 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Oh Oh all right both sigh good morning I don't know I've heard a whole discussion about YouTube I just got a message from David hogao who's watching from California YouTube he said if you hit the playlist you could get it even before it actually uploads because we're having a lot of troubles taking many many hours I think it's still didn't upload from last night's cheer that's what he says it works for him hit the playlist try it out alright so today sheer well first of all today is the tenth day in the ER can't really see it but there's a nice background here it's the today's daffy beautiful job by the seltzer boy rythmic mu today shears being sponsored leaving knishmas get in the bath well I actually knew her she was in my building I believe this is mrs. handsy bodenheimer the bond and ions used to live in our building it's Nachman Seltzer's father-in-law he should be somewhere over there in the screen I don't see him exactly but maybe some areas Ribera how you doing this trauma should have an alias she's a wonderful woman it's her first yard site IRA's mode is the only child a Holocaust survivor and left behind more than a hundred the sentence all chime rate Tyrol mitzvos that's unbelievable in today's generation to have every single one that's a tremendous tremendous horse when some should have an ally Oh a continuation of yesterday we had a different bow leave a mishmash and here's a continuation Lelouch mass I'm been Rafal very beautiful and Victor lighter Abraha bastard before Victor lights turned off removing bench line mr. Peres and Tino been moving the hor-aha and we also have a continuation I just left it here for dr. Epstein by the way Robbie Bourdon I'm if you would have lived in my building I would have had you on the on the main floor well first for naught then we have on the second floor we have only two residents but both of them are part of the shear roofing shade of course who does the eight-minute nap and dr. Epstein and who else that's it third floor who's below me no they don't do it how about let's let's hang this up here so you got four customers from this from this building what do we have here today to explain these English Maths here second part of the art side that my mother allowed Shawn had for her mother's pajamas apparently the Germans emulsion mom took advantage of the fact that the families and the extended families were together around the times of jung-tae them and I'm COFF Nisan after Pesach in 1942 they came back for another four members of her family and that's what you have over there the Tiffin box and three members of her sister's family and teen Ike who's only he was how old he didn't have a name a one-day-old nephew one day old nephew t-mike Ben Rubin from the moncavage Danish Muslim through rabbits are kind and shamans should all have an ally oh this is fraud from SID Wellman Reb le being a worldwide maggot cheer you got to keep the beard looks great and it's Holi Sid from Toronto Sid Wellman he's not on right that's somebody else that's another all right Paul so Melissa Nepal hold on I'm looking boo Simon colony's dangerous that Simon arrived Paul so i'ma let him fall I don't see him but look at this we got the Weiss fishes from England they wake up at 4:30 in the morning so this is uh I don't know if I I told you guys I saved them a watch from the scene we had watches for kids and it has the little empty white emblem on it so one day when the little white fish I think his name is small he comes tired to stroll I'm putting this aside for him Rabelais here's another one thank you so much for all the efforts put in this year just want to let you know that I get much enjoyment watching you steer from clean-shaven to Stubb waiting for the day when you'll have a full-grown what's with these guys full-grown beard wishing you and your family a Kakashi over Samara a friend of Iram feinstone Chicago I have a voice and this is Jay Spitzer I thought I saw Jay on there Jay Spitzer from the Toronto on there I thought I saw him maybe somebody else yeah here is Sean Malik and Jay how are you what are you English because I heard like an accent or something over there oh you are Canadians the Canadian accent I threw me off okay I got it okay yeah sure Clara Valley enjoying your share especially a multi shabbos when I join in on zoom so for you it's what's a shot as you're saying right now it's was a child's about you you miss the mustache I was here last night and you're doing the Sunday I got it just the question is - why do you shut down the YouTube recording right after the shear ends and you don't keep it going for the tehilim or the shoes of the heavens oom as a guy who watches primarily on YouTube would be nice to hear the stuff that continues once the official shear is done just wondering and if you could change this that would be great thanks Jase Pizza Toronto I mean the answer is because it doesn't look so good on YouTube when the shear is two and a half hours long and people look I don't want to do this year it's two and a half hours long they don't realize that well 25 minutes is emails and only 10 minutes of learning and then the rest is all schmoozing at the end so if I left it on I don't know if somebody has something to say about that I'm willing to hear willing to change it I have no problem I just thought the little the less time it is on YouTube the better for somebody coming in afterwards he says Oh 45 minutes okay I'll do that cheer if it says an hour and 20 minutes it might be a problem you hear Jake you hear the title years okay what there's other stuff like you're saying a lot of you want to check out yeah I noticed if you go back in history all the serum that have like they're over an hour they have very few views nothing to do with the shear of course that's through ten minutes you know I'm just saying fine Johnathan's the fans can good morning how are you today is Daffy mm valid we're starting from a brand new Mishnah six slides down from the top myth how to linear kadosh we are talking about this candle right over there means the lamp and if those lasers was made at an earthenware I had I bought I was I think I was ripped off once you know like as a tourist you go through the old city and a guy came over to me and then my tour guide said this guy he could trust him and they sold me one of these straight out of the base time Mick Dodge one of these guys it was very very inexpensive for the eye but I think somebody just took it from my I looked for it it was in my closet the other day and before poor and after Portman's guns I don't know what happened anyway one of these the very popular here in there just roll you find them in all those archeological sites you put the oil in here what is this this is a new kind of Mokpo we're gonna be discussing a little bit today called luxor maximus meals it's disgusting it's full of black soot and all oil who nobody wants to touch it MOOCs and maximus meals so it says like this metallic tool in their crush if it's brand new out of the box it's not MOOCs in Muhammad's meals it's not disgusting it it's a brand new earthenware Avalon but not an older one according to that a camo it's mutts amok my seems shimmy nightmare regime in Wichita so II oh here's David Feinberg he's showing on the screen what one of these looks doesn't look so nice to me maybe he's never used fine but that doesn't look good your kid made that no that part is me as I see he's showing that the where the flame comes I'm saying the whole thing if it's soaked in oil day night it's a pretty disgusting thing looks about that nobody wants to touch it I knew it's a new category marketer I'm assuming I'm their culinary talents Shimon is the one who was Mako and mucked so we had yesterday doesn't hold of MOOCs in math my sister he says no there's no such thing as MOOCs and Maximus meals nah that's not Mach 2 we're gonna see there are a few MOOCs is that he does agree with but MOOCs and Maximus Mears is not one of them therefore call an Aires natal to win I could carry I can move this lamp on Shabbos hoots I mean I never had Dalek Michalis if it's burning right now this minute then I can't move it why not why can't they move a canvas burning right now very interestingly Rashi says on the spot shame on your table on there cuz maybe as you move it you'll extinguish the flame by mistake so right away on the side I go if it's Union points out the marshal points out that this is not the most kannada kumari Oh thinking more goes away from that so what is it Oh Robbie jerseys Playa weird I had your thing here where was it oh here you see people are so kind look at this I got a present an ounce of salt Irish amis why because this special salt Jersey came all the way they because he just had a baby's busy with his new baby but he had that he had he had the intent to make me happy on Chavez he gave me he couldn't afford a whole cup you know this stuff is very it's hard to come by but this is already me Vishal salt so there's no issue of pouring this salt and also he didn't want to insult my wife it was a lot and it would say like listen something's wrong with her suit but this is just enough for Shabs I didn't use it I left it is very kind mellifluous Shabbos document base based on big Marta based on that Sookie came all the way to my house and delivered you Squire Krueger's II I see you on the screen turn yeah I remembered Thanks oh look at this any time we go over a hundred people on zoomin I have a special I know because we spell extra money to get more than 100 and then Gary's thing no we don't have a hundred yet we're at 30 no not in a few days we'll have a hundred so Barham 124 people on zoom so every dime it's worth it so goes like this over there and this to me the end of this circuit says that if you have a candle you should not carry it why because the candle it's a busses Ladouceur the flame is matzah and and and the rest is holding the flame you're holding up the flame that's the most gone over there so why does Raschi say over here show me a Kaaba so the place is young he goes into sometimes you're a she likes to quote the have a mean of the so yeah it's not really accurate it's just telling you what to have him you know okay fine the bottom line is that according to Shimon you now that I carry a lit candle but once it's extinguished even if it was lit Danish mushes it's not a problem a corner of Shimon he doesn't hold books and Rahman sister amiga this got slightly been atrocious it's considered Akuma the only issue is show me how according to the half Amina or buses okay who's mean I met naradhama Shabbos terrabona now the gamers just going to go through the ship is similar to what we have in the Mishnah matau to linear Kadosh evolution you could carry you could move a brand new lamp there's no mooks of maximus meals it's not me yet evolution Divi review yeah okay fine but the same thing is there a difference uh-uh oh we're to find it yeah okay ablution did we really syrupy who does basically saying what the town of comment says that a used lamp as most of Maximus meals you shouldn't you shouldn't be made out to lunch opposite smoke so the mayor I'm an remainer doesn't hold of me us similar trip Shimon but a little different he doesn't know the meals Karl an heiress matado Lynn herzman inertia dribble Shabbos oh is this rep Shimon no what is he saying he's saying that if this candle was lit baina schmagges then i can't i can't carry it anymore rip shimon only says if it's lit right now Romero says even was the Benesch mushes it was the parish mushes what is that called it's MUX amok master there was an issue down here and sensors moxa during banished Marsh eyes it's got sorry in the cooler Yuma it's moxa for the rest of the day shimmy nightmare and this is eruption we have in our mission hoots man I never had dirt like the shadows it has to be lit right now in order for to be mocked it was lit banished marshes rebbi shimon doesn't have this migas that's really cool uyama so we have three cheetahs sailor coughs aw if it was extinguished Mutola so remain a rib Shimon says once it's extinguished it's no it's not looks anymore just because it's moxa banished marshes doesn't continue to be mostly for the rest of the day Ramirez's know if something is MOOCs are doing Benesch much lies let's get sorry the libel interesting we're gonna see a little bit in rips shimon it changes not changes but there's a he qualifies it a little bit more later and ruby hood of course holds of meals so forget about MOOCs and Maximus yes sir there's another problem of Maximus meals something that's disgusting an example is a graph sure ray yeah if you have like one of these pans for for waste human waste also MOOCs and lifeless meals disgusting a lot of times you have in the meal you have like leftover food mostly Michael Cimino's it could be a problem with the certain times you can take it out because you don't want to create an issue in your house on Chavez so you can move it you could get it out of that you can put in the garbage can whatever about Kosuke Roo Bosh luscious it seems like there's a continuation of rip shimon if it's a very large cup meaning it holds a lot of oil that will last me throughout the whole Shabbos lie is the same my mom you're not permitted to move it at all and we're gonna see what that means variably as abruption annoy me miss topic min Han arachova whose ribbon laser Arab Simmons father right the trick question rabbi Shimon webalizer be rebbi shimon rebbi shimon that were talking about the rebbi shimon who says he's very lenient when it comes to Moktar and there's no Maximus meals there's no Muktar discuss a Danish pushes its console akuma however it seems like he says that if there's a lot of oil in the clay and now that I'm moving on Chavez comes remilia's or his son and says mr. Bergman and arachova woman as chemin I'm at a flip of a field with a shiner Doyle I hear this even while the candle is lit we're rich women would say it's a sir you now lad oh because of semi Habba buses all that says the Rivoli hazard if it doesn't extinguish the flame at all then I could use the oil as its lighting that's a new one even as it slipped it's burning and it doesn't extinguish let's say the oil is dripping from the side whatever I could use it Oh a bi or rebellious river shipments of a locavore Bajada people as it holds like his father in one thing o polical a Bahadur and he argues with his father and one thing sobbing about how they he increased his father the last name mocked up there's no maximum Assessor there's no maximum atmospheres that agrees oh poor girl her father and he argues with his father de la voz of our cover in Licavoli as we learned with Shimon holds that as the as it's lit as he's moving around you can't touch it like hover like but if it's lit you cannot use it if it's already extinguish you could in you could use it view survivor gather like Abba Ribbon Lea's her son halls that even when it's lit I could benefit from the oil since the Gemara wait a minute maybe it's not even rip Jimmy that holds that I have a court about Russia's lawyers even we just learned that if it's a large cup you shouldn't move it manna honey all the sudden written says in a large cup you can't move one son he loves of Mukta Amarula say fast on the review though it's not rubbish ending its review de review that doesn't hold of MOOCs at all so it doesn't matter if it's a large group of small cup I'm gonna see this is an argument here but according to hula this is not even in rip it doesn't make sense there's a machine doesn't all the mostest who cares it's a very large cup full of oil naturae who is it the famous review them review this says there is Mukhtar so it's a large cup a small cup it smoked some oak to finish mask if Lamar Sutra but my Sutra is a bomb question this explains why we said to begin with Ezra Jimmy he Hakim my evo it says a small carp is not booked a corner of Shimon Ivo but Kosuke of ashes larger vessels magazines in common that makes sense in the corner of Shimon that he starts off saying small is not mocked Ivo but however a large one is much what if you tell me it's already Hooda so what's album small is matzah however a large one is mocked so it doesn't fit everything is matzah what's Apple Apple doesn't make sense ello my risotto so therefore master just says lord I may be Shimon yes it is rebbi shimon but either way you're gonna have an issue here one on the one hand you're gonna have the prom with a vowel and then you have a problem to understand rep Shimon Deepika Shari be Shimon Ben there's Luther the title of a novel Hannah did a fishy Laurie so he says like this he says rip Simmons says that there's no Mickey this cut sorry if something is MOOCs of during Danish smashes doesn't necessarily mean it's mostly for the whole Shabbos there is a case where it is most if it all Chavez if you have that much oil in the Nair so in your mind you read gave up on that in there you're saying this thing's gonna light for the whole Shabbos then Rebbe Shimon agrees the me GU discuss all the banished mushers it's got surly Cuomo because it's a case where he took it out of his head he put it on inside what does this cuts I mean he doesn't wanna have anything to do with it what since this is a case where it makes sense that he doesn't want to be anything to do with it for the entire shop is why because there's enough oil in it for the entire Chavez so even rebbi shimon admits in such a case that meager this got started banished much choice it's got Sully Cooley i'ma but typically it doesn't hold that typically if if let's say we had yesterday the case where you have a chick on a basket so if that chicken is on the basket for two minutes during banish washes if you hold me this cancer the banish motions is concerned Cuomo that basket is mucked up but according to him it's not mope - why because the chickens gonna jump off the basket right after Danish washes but if rebbi shimon understood that that chicken is gonna be on the basket the entire bit entire Shabbos from beginning to end even he admits that Myka discuss olivine and schmagges is concerned Coolio mom he just says typically doesn't happen when does it happen in our case when you have a tremendous amount of oil you know those seven-day yard site candles something like that or a regular yard say can last for 24 hours so in that case he says listen the guy he understands if he lights it now he's never gonna be able to touch it because ruby shimon holds that when it's lit you can't touch it on Chavez so he knows in his mind that for 24 hours this thing is gone so once he was Beitel from it he's Maxted he put it on the side then he Herman agrees according to Mary Sutra that it smoke so as the Gemara wait a minute but Tanya moisture at 7-7 air should Ricardo sir what do I do with all the leftover oil leftover oil it says in the Bryce aw I'm not allowed to use it variable Shimon math here now it says Cara car is a large boat so it seems from here even a large ball rip Shin says you're allowed to use it on Chavez Hassan Carter do need in there so you have to say the car it means a small ball similar to an air how the car do me the Kois and over here when we're talking about coins Cora I rush this these are three large vessels over there and that price it means a small one just the interesting point what do we do with leftover oil from Hanukkah lights you'll either use it or not so if you look in theis vus the it's like when it comes wide she'd been average of acara us through that twice first three lines in he starts off saying by Marie de niro conical card Loyola inaudible an air Chanukah is for the Mitzvah not so much for his benefit and enjoyment ever for surah nisa well machine copy boosted in a sense of Jacob oh and he doesn't want to go ahead max of the camera limits when he sets it aside for the Mitzvah when their Shabbos line Auto Sabo their Chavez is a mitzvah but you also light it for your benefit right it's shown by a creates light in the house yeah your shipment sabishii Travis he wants it to go out look at mutter and therefore he makes a distinction between their shafts in their Chanukah no Carla goes only for the Mitzvah Shabbos not Oh Miriam zero yeah like seven lies from the bottom I'm Arabs area Paul my chili cool boy be Shabbos you have a candlestick it's a good thing I'm at home now all by myself I don't even have mayor today candlestick this is a from when we got married no don't don't don't judge me on this thing I think it the last time we polished it was also them but this is a candlestick is this meals this is not meals we light on it you could touch it no problem it's not me else it's not a piece of earthenware that's soaked with oil the point is that this doesn't absorb anything this is metal debris I'm Mattie Ross or the Divya I sir motors the mark plays a game according to read mayor that doesn't hold of me oast over here he says it's a sir over there in the case of a cliff terrace where a mayor says it's not mucked up because I don't hold of MOOCs Michael Cimino's over he's gonna say I hold it schmuck some affluence is sir and review who taught that says that it's all sir by the small candle that smokes in Rakas meals is gonna say in our case in a candelabra that it's not mocked so the maemura as the Gemara the Rebbe who the books of our hands mislaid MOOCs and muffins Easter last night wait a minute review that doesn't all the MOOCs a mock my sister while he say its motor why is it candelabra nah MOOCs according to a Buda he's the one that smack me always more than rebbi shimon ok yes mayor who doesn't hold of meals holds a Visser but who says to flip that who says that if you hold of meals you don't hold a visitor that doesn't make sense not only that about Tanya Ruby who though I'm a culinary schemata isn't a tool in hoods me nightmare she's leaking baby shadows if it's a metal candle your ladder you let up move it on Shabbos but if you lit it on Shabbos it's a certain mentality or on Chavez because the books are my kind of sister can't you write you have to change it around a little more heat by Ramirez area permit you to get all of the Shabbos if you lit this finish my choice debacle officer there's a concept but most MOOCs on Mac master this candelabra was a issue at one point in time and therefore I extend that is sir from banish motions all the way throughout the entire shadows like we go I love and if I did not like with it the backhoe motor since there's no MOOCs and Michael sister Venus washes so it's mutter for the entire Shabbas alright so we learned a little bit about MOOCs in my first meadows boxing match my sister Alma Ravi who'd oh oh my rev review the famous rabbi yehuda says the name of Rav hold on what does it say here who know ok me Tashi $1 Moyes based on what we learned yesterday with the bed and today we're learning him out of bed they were very busy with their beds they were constantly putting stuff on their beds I shouldn't be talking because we have a guest room that I find that you know but the printer before Shabbos has to leave this room on the bed you could use you know bet is a nice flat surface you only have one or two tables at home but you have many beds along have different rooms different things so you use the bed what are you gonna use the bed for your money because you don't have a bank there's no such thing as a bank this is 1,500 years ago so where do you put your money on the bed now notice the word mattress doing the garbage with a million dollars remember the Holocaust survivor and everybody's searching her mattress in the so in those days they were smarter they didn't put it in they put on top anyway they didn't have mattresses they had I don't know what they had they had like a little that straw there's no in and out it's like okay but it seems like they did have yesterday we learned they had carry on me today they'd lift it up to their beds on eggs so yeah they had some sort of something fine yeah I don't know what the money is that why it's on the bed okay in the bed but it says Yi Sado what is heated oven he just set it aside he said this bed is gonna be for my money he or put money there he used me yeah cadet he designated it in his head that's all meatless you had a llama is also the toddler Wow so I'm not gonna move it now I wanna move it here comes to Isis very important Isis here the bottom theis is on meter sheet another - oscillate or nearer the field at CERN goo for audit Cermak i'ma ah sir so it's two new concepts very important concepts when it comes to mocked up and if you learn submission tests in the mission we're always talks about these concepts MOOC Simha has a litter goof over climb a meaning if I need to lay down on the bed I need goofer I need the actual clean this CLE this designated money bed is MOOCs are great but that's what I need it I need to take a nap my shop is net it's very important so typically if I have a hammer the hammer is a cleaner laughter it's a it's a it's a vessel designated for to build the house but right now I need it why do I need it because I want to crack open a coconut so it sort of grew fuzz motor now becomes that booked anymore but this bed even though I need a nap it's mucked up I can't use it why because anytime you have booked a Magma's gufa it itself is inherently mukha like money then you don't have this Heather of the term goof for you loser from a climate let's say the hammer is on my seat might cheer and I want to sit down so I pick up the hammer and I toss it all of a sudden is no Mook so bye-bye why because that's a collisional after laser it's a clean it has function other than building it could do other things but money has absolutely no function it's zero the only thing you could do is buy stuff and right now it can't buy anything in Chaves so it's not better than a stone in the street where a stone it's Muslim Mohammed's gopher it has no purpose other than throwing it on other Jews or whatever but it doesn't have a purpose so it doesn't have a purpose then it's MOOCs are Magma's gopher and if it's MOOCs Amaya's gopher I cannot move it let's serve goof I would serve no climate that's what place it says mirrored that feel it's a goof up or it's earth McCoy mom also I was now allowed I'm not allowed to move it even if I need to lay down or move the bed why the kimchi dilemma is chauvinism tomato soup - much barbecue had such choice it's just like those trumpets we learned another so you know there have no purpose other than making sound and since his Shabbos I can't make sound with it but remember the shofar is different the Schieffer if I could use the chauffeur as a cup of water then all of a sudden doesn't have purpose and then I could use it I could move in the third groove employment fine next so now I'm talking about a bet let's go back to the so you talking about a bed that a person designated it for is money also the towel to lie now let it move it Maes faith not only it's wrong lovely it's nice Akasha a thousand-aire hot dose a below your son I'm allowed to move a brand new candle why how could I was a brand new how could I move a brand new candle you just told me that a bed that I designated for money I can't I can't move on Chavez and a brand new candle in a box what do I do with a brand new lamp lamp not a candle a lamp what I do with this thing this brand new in a box I could move on Chavez why why is this any different than a bed designated for money this is also designated to light a candle which is also avila y'all Shawn says look at the surprise definite Alain Vaes see what's going on here you're getting nervous about 11 minutes don't worry about it we have a 45 minutes oh dear look at these spices in my bison oh man there I told you about my Rebbe later he had a ruler I was like this size and he would put it on his Gemara and if the ruler fit in the Tice's that we learned that it was bigger he didn't learn it here so these all these places we would have to learn anyway oh man nerd the law have either a lamp is manufactured for it sir he let him think about Charlotte doula but if I didn't light it it's not muck to meto the la flaca veto but a bed is made to lay down on to sleep on my college game certainly it shouldn't be moved it just because I designated in my head shouldn't make a move to suzugamori le eat American tomorrow we have to again another la eat well he ate my we had one before our have you dumb Arab this is what RAF said meet the Sheik and Allah boys so depends listen to this there's two stages two conditions here if it's a bed that's designated for money and he put the money on it before Shabbos then it smokes out by the way we had a very similar suger with filling remember it's filling bag if it's a bag and he put the money in it he put filling in it or he didn't put he's me off at it for filling but he never put his filling in it and they did put it to him could you put money and they could use it for other things we had such a sodium broth as anything yeah you remember somebody remember this a kiss fine nobody remembers great well nobody wants to show off that they remember meet this you can tell my cynical em eyes so if he designated it on Tuesday and put money on it on Tuesday then also the top two on Shabbos even if there's nothing on it it becomes MOOCs of why because he already showed that he used it lying the f11 boyz now let me ask you something what about a candle I lit a candle on Tuesday this thing was lit on Tuesday can I move this on Shabbos you're saying no those I'm saying you know could I you could I move this on Shabbos rubbish Schreiber says it depends well yeah it does depend based on what we're saying now listen to this he wasn't me accident so similar the person takes money puts it on a bed and takes off the money off his bed just cause he put money on the bed doesn't mean that it's worth to me it's a goodness because this is a lamp it's made for lighting nevertheless it seems like you have to be mean Yahud it and you have to light it and since he only lit it that's not enough core-drobe shimmy according to the sagir so noch amol meet the chief Adela Moyes if he's me actually designated it and in the other Moyes any any physically went and he did what he thought he's gonna do also Tata then it becomes mucked up line earful mi if he didn't put any money on it muddled it out the law then you're allowed to move it on Chavez no you eat another Moyes now this is the law if he didn't do a code yeah Sheila Moyes also the top law then if there are physically money on it if there's money on it even though he didn't designate it then it's awesome and alarum eyes Mutola tout the law Oh [Music] in the end do an action because if that has numerous actions so if you want to make them all I didn't know what I know I didn't make it up though this is what I learned this is I didn't I didn't make if I on my own I would never say something like that you're right doesn't make sense to me that much that's what I'm saying it's a killers to me it's a finish look inside you'll see read Rashi whatever where did I see it I saw it somewhere Linea Hilaire mais mutt early Catalan later dilemma initially memories are sold out alone in a lab boys wonder that so if I didn't designate it it depends if there's money right now it's moot if there's no money not MOOCs and now but this is a very important line here who should I hire you a little bit of schmutz what does it mean as long as there's no money on the bed Danish Muslim Chavez comes in but if there is money on the bed when Danish monsters came in they say this cut so diminish monsters it's only yah okay the fact that somebody took it off a guy took it off a kid took it off it remains Mukhtar okay so now the Gemara is gonna bring a very interesting Soviet of mockney a wheel and there's a lot of details in this so you know the bottom line of the question is that we just said that if something's under banish much choice it's mucked up and we see from here that even if it's unfinished mush it's not mucked from locally anymore says okay that goes the corner of shimon that doesn't all the moxa so that's the question that's the answer again we have a place that says that if something's on there banish mush it's not mocked up okay that's what Shipman regime it doesn't all the books on Venus muscles what's this smoking mockney is a wheel a wheel this is taken from them sifter the wheel in a table this guy right over here this is she dough that you sit this is where people said things sit in this box the law says that if something is large than 40 saw if it takes up the volume of 40 so you put this in a swimming pool and more than 40 saw of water come out of the swimming pool in other words it has more than 40 cell value according to a SIL you measure the value with the outside the outside of the CLE you don't fill up the inside according to be Shami fill up the inside so according to me SIL that you if this is more than 40 saw it's not Makabe Tomo I could go into basic forest with this I could I could sit inside here and go over the curve Arlen and I'm not coming the question is what I love to do the wheels have are the wheels part of this or not part of it now if the wheels aren't part of this muck knee of this cheetah if the Muk Li the wheels are not part of the cheetah then it's very interesting then the wheels would be macabre Toma on their own if they step over a grave or something they become Tom a and the rest doesn't become Tommy because they're not connected so if these wheels are what's the word they can be detached they come off they come apart easy whatever they come apart like a wheel on a car comes off then the wheel is not part of the Box it's not part of the car so if I Drive through the basic Flores the whole box is not Tommy the wheel becomes stomach now another a LaHood the reverse also let's say the backs doesn't become Tom because it's less than 40 saw the back says Tommy but it doesn't it doesn't get to mow over to the wheel because the wheel yes it might be touching the box but a clear that touches another clear doesn't become Tommy they're not connected the bottom line is they're not connected if they if you can remove the wheel from it so says the Gemara inside must everybody has it McNish Allah now another very important thing is I don't I didn't take the picture but this wheel similar to our wheels today I guess of the car that they're hallow so it's not a solid piece of wood so it has a pipe because you need to have what do you call it a it has to be able to accept money it has to be a clean otherwise if it's a piece of salad then then it doesn't work this whole this also yeah so okay so you have a wheel miss Manchin ish Metis if you could come off ain't keyboard law so it's not connected it's not considered one piece with the wagon vein so therefore if this tomb on the wheel that Toma doesn't go to the wagon if this tomb on the wagon it doesn't go to the wheel vein and embed ASIMO if I were to try to measure 40 saw to see if this thing has 40 saw and it's not macabre Toma I must remove the wheels before I put into a very large swimming pool because just cause 40 soft water comes out that's with the wheels I can't count the wheels the wheels are not part of it then max LS eMobile amazed so Rashi says something they find the very hard to understand Rashi I'll explain as much as I know and I understand and you see I have this tool here and if the tool is over the basic four eyes then the tool becomes stomach but if there's a wheel here so since since the wheel itself is Makabe Toma then the tumor goes up into the into the school and become stomach if it's part of the wagon then it's then it could protect the tool from Toma but Rashi goes in and I don't understand it at night I didn't find a good Shaffer he makes a difference between whether the wheel is higher up than the wagon or lower down in the wagon okay they say it's hard to understand Rashi they may tell t-mobile amazed vainglory noise of the Shabbos bisman Shoshanna noise so you cannot listen to this this is an amazing ilaha if there's money in that hallow of the wheel then I can't I cannot move the wheel it smokes it's full of money unbelievable if the wheel is part of the wagon then I could move it why because it's bottled to the wagon the main thing is a wagon it just so happens that a wagon has a silly little will full of money but that that's not my concern but since the wheel is independent of the wagon and that will has money so the wheel is moocs and I can't move it so I saw in the mr. Brewer amazing finish here that's Niguel a mices sort of if you take this concept it's almost the opposite of what you would think so if a guy has a wallet sewn into his pocket what would you say it's full of money on Chavez could I move it you shouldn't wear it that mr. Bruce does he shouldn't wear that because he might come out you might you might be mentality Mike going through is just a rabbin on Chavez but forget about wearing it can I take it off my bed it's money it's officer to move we said it circled McClain white saucer to do a job but it's sewn into my pocket it's sewn into my pants or another example it gives you have a desk that has a money something that that's made for money you know a little like a little little built-in thing so built-in and sewn into the pants is good why because the main thing is the pants the wallet is secondary so I can move my pants but if the wallet is not sewn in like most of us don't have sewn in wallets but some of us might have like a little zipper pocket for change that says the mission boards okay but a wallet that's not sewn in then all of a sudden now you're carrying a wallet the while it is independent of the pants I cannot move those pants off my bed [Music] that's that's someone that's something that we're talking about yesterday of busses the buffer a servomotor it's a little different it's different no we were talking about oh yeah I hear you saying it same but is it it would be much better if you had keys that are attached to your pants you know some people have those matters have those special key chains and they're it's stuck to you you know it has a little thing that comes in and out they love that thing so if it's glued on to your pants then you're allowed to move your pants on chiapas but these are different keys have a different issue that's a cliche Molecular is sir I'm talking about a were smoked I'm talking about money money is the worst of the worst because it has no purpose what can you do with a with a shekel on Chaves what are you gonna do with a with a dollar bill on Chavez nothing can make it a paper airplane with it what are gonna do use it for toilet paper what are you can't do anything with it so it has no purpose aqui has a purpose you could turn on a car and Chavez and drive to the hospital or whatever I don't know you could do something with it fine I'll go up on him I'll just throwing out that hit it I thought it was a beautiful idea that if it's sewn into the pants then it becomes butter to the pants even though it's money if it's not sewn into the band's so the same thing over here if the wheel is part of the wagon then it becomes bottle to the wagons so even though it has money I could move it if it's not attached to the wagon it is attached but it's independent of the wagon because it comes on and off then it's not part of the wagon and smirked so it itself is Mook tonight it doesn't come back to the wagon I can't move in on Chavez let's go right there in alone I've gotta finish my choice so what do you see that even though the money's on there and finish my choice I'm allowed to move it and we just said it if it's there I'm finished much as I'm now to move it I hear it even he the Leslie MOOCs are I'm sure there's an all the most administers the Rav here view this feeling and Rav hold that there is moksa banished much noise now very interesting very important Rashi here very important the last ration the page a hey Rev Germany will be mostly has a MIDI money you can't do anything with or multi-rib is Shimon to item all of austere ah all of a sudden we find a case of Shimon a Greece Tomoko I know you spoke about before if it's mega this could say it for the entire day but here's a MOOC that rebbi shimon admits to all the other MOOCs is written in argue with reputed normal turn on books of Eastern omics is that this Muslim Ottomans goofer that has zero purpose a stone on Shabbos even according to Shimon is mocked so because it has no purpose rip shimmy just doesn't agree to the concept of this cat sorry but vanish Masha she's got slightly cooler imma let's just learn a couple more lines here okay now mr. Brad Arabic you the sphere light Dom the raft cream you this is really like the rat holes I'll give you that holds our MOOCs of this concert - monsters roam around beneath in there I got big deck of shadows being eaten there and there I got me that go beyond - this is all so amazing - the exact opposite of what you'd think if you have a candle you could put it on a tree on Chavez but you cannot put it on a tree on turf now - gonna tree and Chavez is also maybe need to know why yeah I'm just I'm aware of you who w this relay I know there shouldn't be charged the yontiff if there's a concert of Myka discuss oil abeyance motion sulukule i'ma so therefore I am NOT gonna go on my tree on Chavez I have no concern that I'm gonna go and start breaking branches off on Shabbos why because this candle is mocked uh why is it milk stuff because there's moksa banished much mostly for the whole Shabbos so put it on a tree before shadows but I yanked if then I'm an allowed to use a candle so I'm gonna wanna light a fire I'm gonna want to light my cigarettes I'm gonna go climb up a tree and start breaking branches on yontiff soma may let's Oster to put a candle before yontiff but that only works if you hold of the kinds of amigas cut so you finish mushes le I'm mr. Bashir in severe leigh-mallory sha dismally on turf so you see the Rav holds like your Buddha with the concept of meetings concerning the banish much choice it's that sorry the cooler yo mo have a wonderful day we'll see you tomorrow - I'm at 7:15 no I will get us with some pilum you know [Music]