Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 86 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning ra a meaningful fast Everybody Somebody sent me this uh I remember speaking about this in she that's why it was in my head but I didn't I didn't say it says the some that say that you should stand when repeats says the reason is since you're supposed to have a mind and listen to and when you listen you're like the one saying it it's like you yourself are saying and when you say you must stand that's the meaning of the and now in our days everybody does whatever they want whoever sits like right over here area 8 ft from here would be a problem to sit anyway saysin dear belly to from Brooklyn looks like SED will be the first first I would finish with my history thanks to MD he's right because we're 3 days away or so from and then ex stories for 23 days so it shouldn't be a problem I started off by watching it with my on a daily basis he didn't really know who you are I S the video called what a day produced byz he called me afterwards sat here like a few days ago on the seat he called me after the words that Not only was he inspired to learn the da but he wants to start a she okay I put in an MD vter it's AES for me and my wife and sent a screenshot so I'm getting a lot of emails and things a few people sent me the letter fromon Feldman and basically he writes over there that yes ketki got a letter fromi ketki got a letter fromi saying that it's a mitzah to vote he goes on a whole thing he explains it beautifully how he thinks that kki wasn't told the whole story by and therefore he told the story no asked what to do told him to vote andelman is saying that it can't be that didn't get the whole story he say that that's what he said I'm just saying over a letter that's what people are saying I'm saying over saying over a letter somebody said somebody said had a title like you he says no he says the bris said it's a and this one said it's a he brings a whole list so maybe they didn't get the whole story whatever the bottom line is I said that I Saw's letter I go by I asked my who I think are from and they said it's a mitvah um RAB bur was just came out with a video saying it's a mitvah okay anyways it's a it's controversial thing controver said ask your Rob ask your Rob I recently no but I'm happy what I was happy from the letter is that he saw the letter like he knows he sawoski told him that he got a letter fromi that okay or whatever he he got the from um I recently found that a close relative of mine that is a real satmer and doesn't even travel to Israel is actually mdy participant as an mdy participant was not surprising for me he will probably not vote this guy thank you so much may and all you do with the new it's indeed it's very needed in world too from Brooklyn have [Laughter] too he said is a [Music] they were punching each other said because of this look at this H uh ABI check this out what's his name again Momo Momo this is Hill K son he's all out in mdy gear and it gave me an idea like it could be adults also the number one mdy theme related costume is 100 bucks that that was last year he would have won the hands down guy actually there's a guy with the with the two phones in the in the he was pretty good y what's his name falo thank you so anyways H1 $100 first place $50 second place send in your pictures you don't have to come here you can just send them in no it's not a bad idea uh tonight 6:15 C Milla right over here there's no clapping H it says over I didn't write this clapping H only the first three three and the last one this is like a it's not one and one it's not all it's the first three and the last one yeah once you get the kazak you get the kak okay that's that so tomorrow morning shears at regular time 710 on porum we learn on porm 7:10 and that's Friday M shabas regular time but regular time is changed now another 15 minutes so what is it 9:00 9:00 M shabas everything for the Americans is regular the only difference is that tomorrow at 11:30 there's a Shear in Hebrew right here in the BME there'll be wine and kala and some stuff said tomorrow there'll be breakfast tomorrow there'll be breakfast today there won't be breakfast although your cup gave you cups I know just this is ly L cup Guy this is not nice I know what he's doing he knows that I'm going to grab on to it then I'll see there's nothing in it and okay the LI boxs go together just on to breakfast he said the lit box got together to sponsor breakfast very nice um so a small announcement some of you are going to want to come to my house tomorrow on purm the problem is that I am giving Shear at 11:30 and right after is M and right after is suda and it's not soak cuz I'm going to have a lot of guests and becomes a balag during the suda so I'm asking if you want to come you don't have to come B you don't have to come if you want to come after 3:00 from 3:00 all the way to kab shabas I'm available 3:00 I apologize it's the first year I'm doing this cuz last year last year I had a i s year for the Hebrew at 10:00 oh was at 10:00 at night today it's 11:30 so I have to prepare right after ding I have to go home and learn so I can't see people there and then it's a little bit I hope you understand thanks for the understanding is sponsored and by their grateful family an Larry started learning for 32 years until he Anonymous for the unity of the Jewish people Glenn erson with Ling gratitude from Wilmington North Carolina thank you for enriching my life with M sponsors actualize sponsors weekly sponsor audit and tax season daily be en all of abadi from Lakewood he lives in Lakewood I thought he moved already um just maybe I'm not holding b e n l s h a y should have a successful easy shoulder surgery we're familiar with that one right you had surgery my son had iron had surgery marking my second da adversary and remembering my brother AI mandalam wow and Yosi started because of a back then wow wow it's it's his it's his yard site no no uhhuh that's just yesterday right just yesterday I'm not I'm not being Ma I can tell you who ruen CH rabie Berg and Ley Freeman all three contacted me that I I should go visit him I will be going visit him B today for he's a young person with brain cancer for fori and the whole MD staff to continue to make so enjoyable for so many in for all the work they do holding by if somebody kidnaps another Jew there are a bunch of things that we might have not known about so just to reiterate so the remembers you don't slip on this one when the when you see on the it says it's referring to kidnapping but there are rules so somebody like from who kidnaps a Jew is based on not really why because it says that they did you have to bring him into your own you have to work him as a slave that I don't know if they do yeah made work no they were like in a tunnel tied up not moving yeah okay if if that yeah 100% one thing they didn't do they didn't sell them that I know of and you have to sell now we're going to see that even the T admits to this I'm not saying for other reason for all the reasons and there it's a a yid that steals another yid there different that steals so certainly if he does this I'm just now I want to show you this little clip here I thought it's great okay so let's see the the says three things first you have to steal the guy means to use him means to sell him this is super interesting somebody who steals his own son kidnaps his own son what do they call in America those alerts the uh amber alert cuz that's basically a father stealing a kid usually a mother stealing a kid but there's such a thing as kidnapping your own kid I thought it was interesting did they do it on purpose that's how they call usually through is whether or not you could kidnap your own son the of it's because it's it's he's too available he's not it's like you have to we'll see the what if you stole a slave who was freed by one of the partners you have two partners that bought a slave one of them freed him so he's and you kidnap him is he considered a brother it's not a real brother so we'll see in the gar we have a picture here for a second this is the that Yoshi did back back then has a he's wearing black and white on one side and slave clothes on the other MD sock all thing this is a newer one then what happens is okay what it says in the how could he argue a it seems like comes along and says oh you have to bring the the the kidnap the the victim into your possession and use him and what about they don't say use it's the opposite of what you think if you worked him even less than a half a than a you're also according to says no you have to use it as a that that also will explain also in aa I'm sure they use them for lesson approv here bring me this thing just tell a guy pass me that thing that's if you kidnap somebody when he's sleeping what's the if you sell a woman just for her fetus you want the fetus you want to kidnap just the fetus the baby is that using the person or not using the person you're not using how can you use a baby how think about it it's a riddle how can you use a baby in a mother's stomach I don't know if you'll come up with this one it's in the stomach it's in the stomach how you using the baby what is it do what is it doing for you right now what could you do with the baby and what could you do with somebody who's sleeping says here we have a picture this is a y his eyes should be closed I don't know why he has his eyes open he's sleeping he he needed a place to sit by the bus stop so he took a Yash guy and he sat on him or he leaned on him that's a way to use him this this this this makes a lot of sense no let's say is super cold and he has a window and he wants to close the window so he takes a pregnant woman and he puts her in the window now you have to think about it if she's not pregnant she won't fit the whole window but now that she's pregnant she closes the whole window as you could see in the picture and the baby is what's closing the window not the mother think about it if she wasn't pregnant the wind would come in and that's how no but I'm saying if you Pro you're you're at a bus stop again you're at there's always the bus stop you're at a bus stop and you want to be protected from the wind so there's two women there one is a skinny woman and one is a pregnant woman so you take the the pregnant woman you put her in front of you that's stand by the woman you're not allowed to kidnap either we're we're talking about a kidnapper using my myu told me not to stand behind the woman yeah let me let me kidnap you from the front from the back how to do it I have to be now are you kidding me oh my God we're talking about a m over here we're talking about a guy how's he cuz he used this woman can I get you're right you're not allow but you usually don't get Misa here here's a sh how do you get Misa by standing behind the woman how do you get if you take a woman and you protect from the wind and you standing behind her then Mo okay huh oh thank you okay oh he can't you know that now 25,000 people are going to see the V thing we should take out theant take safer over there I don't know if he it's there I don't know if he gave it to me and see if this cash is in there what does it say the is is the kidnapper he kidnapped the victim but it says that that a man did it where does it say anything about a woman kidnapping how do we know a woman is here this over here the is is the is the kidnapped the victim the is is the victim who's the kidnapper doesn't say it it could be a woman also ish means a man oh okay so that's what the is going to say in a second right the is going to ask you a question is referring to a woman but who did she kidnap a is only a man so first of all the first POS you see that a man kidnapped someone it could be he even a woman this over here you see a woman who did the woman kidnap a man how do you know that a woman who kidnaps another woman is also what does it say at the end of the the problem is the beginning of the talks about he's he's a GH so just say this GH is is dead it's talking about the same so it says the word twice in the same so from the extra wording I know even a woman who kidnaps another woman doesn't matter if you you kidnap a man woman even how do you know those two a and from the word May from his brother comes out from the brother not a real brother and even if you kidnap a minor now here's a super interesting thing there's a way if you would ask the beler you who who quoted this this line right over that we just read he they would know how to tell you there's a trick the trick is that there's there's rules who wrote what if this comes if this POS is said in so I know right away that's said it everything everything right that it's not something that we think about this I could tell you I look at the side the boom what if it's in oh say I just I'm pointing it out because is gonna say this is this has to be if you stole you kidnapped a kid you kidnapped a person but you never sold him you you you took over a guy's house you kidnapped him and you're ready making deals and you sell him but he's still in his own bedroom he's still in his own house Potter you Potter what if you kidna the kid you're Mexico they do this y over there right I don't know if you ever met people from Mexico they'll tell you I was kidnapped my father was kidnapped Ransom right not a whatever they kidnap you they call up the M okay put $10,000 over here and then so so you do that you kidnap a kid and then you give it back to the father so there's a problem because in a second we're going to see that it's Potter and if you kid have slaves Potter so the says was saying over in front of the announcer right speaks low that other person yells it out to the says you have to remove the person from his brother's when you sell to your father you should be Potter you never took it out of his you're right you're right it's the one that says is no uh is RAB right this one that says the one that says no so here check this out we can do a little thing here this a lot of people know St Mish is who mayor this is a thousand points is who and is the difference between sa and sa is one is singular and is plural okay maybe we can remember like that I won't you guys will so it can't be since it was it was theim over there and it was was without a name of so must be so says over here and he says over here the top word on our so it's contradiction all these they said in the name I heard he wrote his P he did it in Siberia and he did it about that's what they say that he knew about and he wrote it p on it oh I heard a that um somebody kidnapped Yi kid and he called up his father and he said uh either you give you give me 100,000 shek or it's not going to be good soami said I don't understand the are you giving him food he says yeah he has a bed and a and a blanket he said yeah says gack I have another three kids I want you to pick wake up in the [Music] afternoon why would they say that you can't you can't steal your own son you can't be too easy this is too easy it's it's right there you have to happen upon it but not that it's in your house doesn't make any sense what you're saying talking about talking about and it says the word if it's easy then you're not such thing keep going what's what what does easy mean keep going there's a certain house we're not going to mention the name here's the Rashi look inside by yourself but you could look over here they don't want to mention who they are in this area they were people but this area they had a problem so there were a bunch of couples living in one house and they always bumped into their friends wives there's no but it's so somebody had relationship with somebody else's wife it's not can't be so that that that proves doesn't mean or it can't be easy I was told last night the and the said yeah that they mo usually not to go to hotels because of this this is It's a bias that has a lot of couples in it okay they prefer to take a simmer a house rbnb you impossible you're right let's go to somewhere else I know a father who has full control on the son he's not in the Parish of kidnapping somebody teaches to other people since they're always in this guy's house so they are a guy comes to you pick him up and you kidnap him the mag is Potter a slave doesn't have any embarrassment see just show you the slide again so you remember what we're talking about right we're talking about two men are having a real fight they want to kill each other and a pregnant woman walks by and was that a sound effect you have to have a Brotherhood a slave is not your brother but at the end of the day A Slave like a woman so he is he does share something with you he is a brother with mitzvah oh I got to tell you this this is a they say I heard about Stark that you ask any will say it's about this one and that one but there was a yid who was putting on Fillin to somebody that looked very not religious he had tattoos everywhere and he was putting on so came over to him and said well I don't understand you're not on you're not for and I don't know what are you putting on on somebody like that he says are you crazy this my brother who went off the D been crying about this guy for 10 years he finally now was masing to put Onan you give me a hard time what are you nuts I'm sorry two minutes later he sees this guy putting on F to somebody else so he comes over say and he's also your brother he says yeah and he's also your brother okay that's the and by us in our by kidnapping how does May the it comes to exclude slaves so now he takes the word and he learns to Li from it the same Li twice super interesting the word alone could have been enough to exclude a half a slave but since it says it also says I come to exclude him for a second time what is that called a double negative no half a slave no half a slave it's the same Li twice and therefore having it's a one exclusion after another a double negative a double negative is is is a positive I learned that there is a to steal to kidnap a half a slave let me just show you how Yoshi did it for a second first of all this is cool I'll start from here then I'll go here check this out he has that guy on his back over there thei slave and then from all these words from Le no slave you learn a and then and then again from the me you learn it oh whatever you what I'm saying from you learn it once you learn it twice so now they're down one liit they don't have the limo that we said before they're not learning anything from the word no it doesn't come to exclude slaves it can't come to exclude slaves cuz a slave is MIT like a woman you're going to tell me a woman is not your brother of course we're all Brothers all brothers and so so he's left with the and the of so what do we have now we don't have a double negative according to them because they're using one for a regular slave one for a is not excluded twice only excluded ones so according to them you poter for if it's a double negative then it turns into cuz double negative that you are but now it's not a double negative so remains Potter is pot and a slave is Potter how do you know right somebody kidnaps you get killed but how do you know you need you need another POs to to warn every time you kill somebody there's a POS warning you also how do you know that how do you know going how see kidnapping the we know that there's a betweena and we treat somebody who steals a GH of at night we treat him worse than somebody steals during the day because somebody steals at night is not scared of Hashem somebody steals in the middle of the day he's not scared of anybody so treat so here's a question what about kidnapping a person is there a difference between kidnapping somebody at night and during the day it says is a of night you think no says yes there's enough says I'm not saying everybody agrees to that huh same yeah he's not scared of people he comes in middle of the day in middle of in middle of a busy street he just grabs a guy and puts him in his car runs away sor in kidnapping there's two parts there's the kidnapping part and then there's also the selling off part so one is coming to say that and one is coming to say that one is coming one is coming [Music] to I told you about my big argument this past shabas with my niece and her friends that came for shabas and they said mean stealing I said no it's not stealing but it says in the I said no it's not and I made them crazy then it's kidnapping oh very funny this it's very different kidnapping and stealing maybe it means literally like it says in the don't steal money say that can't be we take a look at the for a second becomes obvious that we're talking about a human being and not not uh things don't kill somebody else don't kidnap somebody else you have to look at the whole at the whole par what is going on in this P what is it talking about oh it's talking about huh no it's about a person no that I don't know talking about the action the action 1 through three you're saying it should start from there Le I'm saying C we're not talking about no we exactly we're not talking about we're talking about are we talking about an object or human being is he stealing money or he's stealing a human being is to another human being objects usually yeah say okay you could say that that famous joke you could change it where a guy came into SCH like er shabas right before he saw that he had 100 bucks in his pocket so he didn't know what to do so he put it in a he opened it up where it says and he and he put an arrow so he comes shabas the money's gone and it says you should do the that's talking about kidnapping rash says doesn't mean that against people he says that's thei says which R is people okay that's okay I hear you saying the what says like you and means it it doesn't fit in so well you could start rash saying okay it's talking about it's all and then it happens to be you get me okay F we said it already oh so now here we do have another P that talks about stealing in the this is objects stealing money monetary things let's see if that Rashi works over here here this where's I have it on thing's saying over there it's not it's it's about about object okay beautiful story about the I thought it's story I don't understand that 100% but we could learn something from it he was schlepping his from City to City the sell and the train was at the platform but he didn't have enough time to weigh the Swarm you're supposed to weigh the Swarm pay for the weight and then you know put them on the you know the mail card whatever it is he he missed the train basically so guy that saw him they recognized him he said you know what he went he spoke to the to he said go go without pay just go he said no he says the train is owned by the by the government and it's their money I can't take you you don't have the right to take does have the right a guy that works there but he said no he said you don't have the right and therefore he missed the Train on purp like even though he's able somebody gave him a freebie it's interesting thing you go on the airline the guy says take your suitcases I'm thinking that we had a guy back in the day in a in Chicago everybody knew him the guy was Gary or something my mother-in-law would buy him a Romanian tray it was a few hundred whatever and he would allow 10 suitcases back then anything you want he would hold up a plane for you when my mother-in-law came he literally held up a plane for us once I I one of us forgot our passport at of home the plane didn't go until we went back home and got the passport I brought 10 suitcase is just for myself one person for one thing so now I'm thinking to myself this is this problematic Allah doesn't allow that you know the guy in there it's the same kind of thing he has within reason you know he can let 5 PBS go to let a guy on cuz he's getting a pami thing you know what I'm saying am I going to get into trouble because it's 25 years ago I it's like and it was it's not owned by the same nobody's to have beef with you since you came Lauren doesn't even try [Music] anymore so now we have a super interesting what happens you have think about it in order to kill this guy he has to do a bunch of things he has to kidnap and he has to sell who's testifying on what and what if there's two a on on two parts of it there's two parts the kidnapping 6 months later he sells is it the same a if it's different a could each one testify isn't it a half has to be combined you have to you have to kidnap and sell is it one what is it everybody was found to be a liar all four of them the two you can't kill them you do K them when you testify has to be on a full thing not on a half a thing we could get you even on half half okay so where's the here we go here's come one set of a them and they say you stole money and you bought meat and you ate so what he gets malas you see the little guy gives him malus that's the first step in order to kill him you need two steps see that's the here then another two come with the white beard and they said we saw the same thing he stole money and he bought meat and wine so now we kill him but the second set can't kill him unless there's a first set so now what happens is on the second set are they are the second set or not they need to come on to the first set or maybe no maybe the first is and the second set the second set tried to kill him and the second set is now how do we view it so he says they do get killed why because the first ones are different than the second ones they're not combining anything we came to do one thing we came to give him malus we don't care that he dies later on we didn't come to kill him we came to say that he stole meat and he and the second set they were doing a full I'll give you an example beautiful example this SM Mak sense when Adam come and say that this woman was M how do you know she M she has to be married oh so you you have to rely on two a that were at a 25 years ago that saw that she was married so you can't just come and say oh she's a m maybe she's not married now maybe she's the oh so there are two parts but each part is a separate part what is the Aiden that she got married 25 years ago and that that's individual adles and now the these ad are saying that same thing over here they're saying we saw him eat once and he should get malus boom you got malus and then another Seth comes along so he ate again something else so let's see this for a second here we go by the ice cream truck you have that said that Carl stole the have that said that Carl sold so the if they're by themselves and there's on the second guys of the white Bears they should be for the same the first set could say we didn't want to kill the ice cream driver we just wanted to give him alus but that would fly off if there's no malus for ice cream driver kidnapper if there's no malus based on the first testimony then this cash is not not a cash CU we're only saying look we came to do one thing we came to give malus if there's no malus then what did they come for they came to say we saw part of the kidnapping we saw the kidnapping and you saw the Ste the selling and the two of us together or the four of us together we're going to put him to death then it becomes one thing if there's a malus in between then it's not one thing then it's two separate act I can prove to you that there is malus and if there is malus then the second cat should get killed and the first cat not the first set that comes and says we saw this guy kidnapping we don't know who says what and I can prove to you that prove the two different sets of they don't get killed according says that they K we kill them so we kill them then this is we're dealing with death over here you're right today they're not going to die if we're talking about death it's like when there's no Misa because there could be Misa over here so there's never malus so who holds there is malus so if there is malus on the first set yeah it's not so it's not so hard if there's malus on the guys on the right then the guys on the left die why because now we split the they're saying one of malus and they're talking about death we have to kill you if it's one long there's a there's a kidnapping and there's a selling and they don't get malus then you can't kill them because you can't say that they're individuals they're not individuals they're all together you can't do them say and just finishes it off the kidnapper himself doesn't make sense say you're going to tell me he doesn't get malus so then how did get malus if he himself doesn't get malus so you have to say that of course the the guys on the left wanted or there was going to be malus the guys on the right the said that they wanted why do they why they get they get malus and they wanted to get give the kidnapper malus so they're individuals they're they're by themselves the first said wanted to do malus the second said wanted to give Misa so how could you say that the second set is Potter the second set should be just finishing it off you're right when we look at the guys on the left the guys with the white beards they are are going to die for the testimony if they are found to be on a on a cruise ship somewhere else they're going to die what about the first guys that say that he deserves he says no they don't get they don't get the death penalty because why because since they get malus they're separate from the white bearded guys and they're not part of they never wanted to convict him for murder they only wanted to convict for malus they're separate so M can never kill them it's one long thing the first Adam and the second Adam are all they're trying to accomplish one thing they're trying to kill this guy yeah imagine if you saw kidnapping you saw a kid being kidnapped you want you want the guy to get killed you go to bed and say I saw the kidnapping and the other guy's going to say I saw himself and together we're going to scream and let's kill him it's one long thing from beginning to end says here so if we go back to that ship thing here this case the first there no why because they only came to give him they didn't want to kill this 13-year-old they just wanted to warn him good get him scared we used to do something called it's a g do it it's a of here in the we used to do it I tried it for a few days a few weeks whatever certain people you did did for a while son the whole it's to memorize that based on a few things in the a few it's called have hundreds maybe even thousands of it's a crazy thing anyway so they had they they figured out that when you want to memorize something you say what you know first and then you say the M afterwards you don't say oh there's but in this in this case this everybody agrees to First everybody agrees to and like this gar over here there's everybody agrees to Something in and everybody agrees to something and then that what everybody agrees that the first set in oh I forgot to say the Turning but let's get there in a second let me just go back over here where was it here everybody ages by the on right side they never get killed why because they only everybody agrees that the second set they do die why we are separate from the first set we want to kill the second set came to kill they came to do a full thing which is to kill the is when a disagreement not a disagreement they come to say we saw the stealing and we saw that he ate the the meat we saw the first Adam said we saw him steal the money and the second said we saw him eat the meat let's do this uh turning of The Da of other Global experts in International Financial Services I didn't say it twice today Dr alen bar list house a memory of my dear Father Joseph list house on his 45th yard side that there's nothing there's nothing it life who tomorrow is organizing breakfast in honor ofi and the entire MD family if we all we have right in front of us are a that said this guy the kidnapper we only have the a them on the left the kidnapper sold his victim we don't kill them why what what did you see you saw a sale very good if you didn't see the kidnapping maybe I sold my own person maybe he belongs to me this must only go ACC the reason why I can't kill him because there's only have a testimony what the ones that are you will kill him he just explained that he could explain himself a away that maybe I'm selling my slave so how could you kill somebody like that you're going to kill a kidnapper cuz you think he he sold somebody maybe sold his own person his own slave of course you don't kill him nobody ever showed up to say that there was a kidnapping here if nobody ever said that there was a kidnapping here and you see somebody selling somebody why would you kill him maybe selling his [Music] Slave oh they did come but after these guys testified that there was a sale it has to go in order there testimony that he was kidnapped and testimony was sold you can't do testimony sold and because it's not fear for the aam that testify they was sold maybe they'll die because of this so it was not in order they came afterwards why why would I think that you killed ad that say that he was sold no there's big talk and and the Adam said we are going to go to B to testify that we saw the kidnapping so you shouldn't have gone and testified that they we sold the that's something just because they said it and they hinted to it it's nothing have a wonderful day and a meaningful fast