Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 57 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning rap boy what's your name from Zigler how are you gal who else do we have here no two guests Al it's also great is leaving today Joel he a guest he's not a guest he's not a guest all right gal um tomorrow morning B there's going to be a very very nice breakfast time to bring your friends help them join on TUV Tu big breakfast fruits Z I mean fruit omelets fruit pancakes in today sh you mentioned a couple of times that he has a on the way I said it's not on me Rashi says this I was just saying was all from Rashi um this person is looking to sponsor next Wednesday and his uh his father his father went to ponich and his name this person's name is who's probably turning over in his grave he says my brother's also [Music] named he's just trying to show that he's a real West hemston New York I've been with you since listen to this and never missed a thank you Lester BL for bringing me in so uh the Hebrew we have three boys from n school and the re sent in these pictures because these three boys are all part of the she guys I want to show you what happens at night in you're not it's already going on for a little [Music] bit need a larger screen [Music] here we Goa check this out there is a new good morning good morning this is very hi everyone we're excited to announce the establishment of the mdy Mexico group and it's truly incredible we enjoy listening to this room together every day for those who can't make it daily they listen on their own several participants who joined hadn't studied much gamar before and the impact has been transformative two members have shared how it's changing the lives and W even mentioned how it has improved his marriage his wife told me that during a cruise last week she was amazed to see her husband learning to D every night before heading out to enjoy the evening she expressed how happy and grateful she was calling it a miracle come join us in person whenever possible and spend an amazing hour each day with us enjoy the breakfast and dinners we're planning and most importantly witness how your life and your family's life can change for the better says MOA marovich from Mexico we look forward to welcoming you to our group War regards moi marovich moi medal stor mexico.com mdy Mexico scan the QR code to join themy Mexico WhatsApp group or email me at that place above description automatically generated [Laughter] um is Goldstein every year pushes this initiative I'm happy to to be a and that is Pur is in exactly 31 days so grabs and learn last year many I don't remember it's in the hundreds grabbed easy and you go you could even watch it on one and a half speed two speeds or you can do it on your owned start learning and Contin 32 years until he was the respons for the unity of the Jewish people the by Glenn esterson with love and gratitude from Wilmington North Carolina thank you for enriching my life with gr the yides of their fathers thanking Hashem for the release of Ari Rosenfeld Aon benind Esther g k of the month $10,000 sponsored by H YK Hill y Kam kamansi the ventures in honor and for the success of all our our clients Joshua wvic leov my holy I need some help over here fromn what's that for real from SKC why is it spelled s ch no English would be s n no so that people like me could SC scan schedules it's connected Ando kazakov voice like do me a favor stop sending me in these hard names if you have a hard name sponsor some other person's share please art of the month for for and the whole MD staff to continue to make so hold on second okay I won't do it again and the whole MD staff to continue to make so many and in honor of Yi Kazi for the work they to doai we have to catch up a lot over here so you're going to pick up this the pace a little bit question good thank you how come we don't make a when we give I just I just had a chat CU you don't do it with your whole heart maybe you don't have you again how come we don't make a when you give so we going to see a very nice and here's a fascinating thing when a Ben a Ben goes to war and takes aast to who is married to somebody else and what is is he over what is what kind of he took a married woman and but she's a non-jew we have correct so what was the ion so this is going to really shake you up it's something you what how do you know fet did you learn the da did yeah I know but did you learn the da so how do you know it G is stealing somebody really so all is GLE very good that's the answer okay do you still go to that sheer though I just want to know do you go to another person's shears you used to go to somebody else's Shear not anymore iar the ah okay in war that could also be what you take all their other stuff okay somebody else's wife is gazel war in war who says you have a right to take okay says the we're holding you have it like where the lines get wider smack in the middle that's where we're holding ask are responsible for to make and everything that's last week's par there 10 different mitz that had the seven that we already spoke about yesterday let's go through them again real quickly we have and then we have and and and in addition to these seven whoa look what number seven is in our chart and over here it says that in addition to the seven we added so we have a little bit of a problem so it seems like didn't have up until then they added another three for a total of 10 do we know so check this out you should keep where command you like command you by like he command you in the past you're right there was denim beforehand but they added three more things they added that until then that a typically doesn't need a bezin of 23 like a Jew he doesn't need Aid all he needs is one Aid he doesn't need he doesn't need a warning but he had beforehand so they added these three these things it seems like that they added the whole idea the whole concept of it's not true they only added these three Provisions in they did add a whole new chapter in the called the fact that I could tell somebody that stole they has to pay 100% more than what he stole or 400% more that's that's a that they didn't have before it should say they added to the there was already and they added to the not as if today a brand new thing for them yes they did come up with something new called that you have to establish a bezan in every every in every city and in every whatever pel means what every should be a you tell me didn't have this to have a it says already just like had this had this he takes out from the last two we had in the last two we have well we have denim the last last one and five is bem he takes those two out and he puts in in the last two cus and clim okay he takes two out and he doesn't have came afterwards by they what do they have before the seven was ser and climb like we had on top of the and what are they that we have that we have and these are the two new ones so you asking me why was denim added afterwards it seems like they hadim before no they did not have before he didn't havez he had one mitah don't do was also warned not to curse C just said a second ago that this three things that marish had it's cursing and as he telling me that if you look over here he took out the two and put in the bottom two ser and what about and not in his list ask theor I don't understand if you're going to go with this beautiful P that Yoshi did yesterday this whole PUK one of them is the first one is the second one is how does he learn this he doesn't believe in this at all which the is going to say he doesn't so how does he have seven where did he get seven from says he does not learn this at all so what does he learn check this out here's a whole list every single one of his things in comes from a special the first two are the same exact and then it just keeps on going each bird with its own thing and that's what the is going to say here I learned it from its own unbelievable yesterday we started cheer at 7:30 after all the I don't know what happened with the emails today we already did I don't know a whole bunch this like a this is like two D in Bas that we did already and now we're holding on so let's see how much we could do in 33 minutes actually do a little l so we're looking looking for two and the first two on the list it says by the people got how do you say in English not destroyed they were corrupted corrupted oh corrupted was your fancy word abominated no no no they they they did a they did they did Abomination I like corrupted simpler and better so these are the two things that we just said on top of the list one and two I it's referring to now that's very nice that the have all these the problem is like we saw before that says all the seven so now what does what does he do with these extra each and every one thear is going to tell us what he does with it oh Yoshi actually did a nice chart he had extra time yesterday so he did one of these charts if you go all the way to the right so what's the Bryce going to do with it so see I have a question besides certain people in the room and those who answered yesterday and today can't answer anymore they're already actually you could answer when uh he's uh he's accused of killing somebody can his brother testify against him before him can his brother be the one he only need one Aid could his own brother testify against him I know you're going to say oh he's a guy he doesn't have he does have doesn't have but his own father be his judge his own brother be his judge how what do you say anybody nobody yesterday I think Ariel did something like he did like when I asked the question nobody answered so he did like a bunch of um Cricket crickets and that's what it was somebody heard yeah that's something like that crickets like sleeping okay so what does he do with this I have the whole what are we going to do [Music] the is telling us what did what did the do what's the problem with oh they they were on that's why they got punished not that they're getting we're not talking about we're just telling you history what happened over there how do I see to as you can see now we're moving on to the third thing in this list now what's the first br going to do with it I need to tell you that they get killed with a sword each and every one of the a you could eat all these or maybe G I give you all the grasses all the things this is what you could eat but not the the vegetables of a garden meaning you can't steal so if you look over here this P it becomes very understood without this it would be a little hard to understand what the it says in the beginning of the anything that moves you could eat all animals like just like I let you eat the greens and the veget now you allow to eat meat so it's not telling you that you can't steal it's telling that you allow to eat meat okay every where do you see that had not to eat limbs from a live animal we have a and what is the that learns everything from what do they do with this so when you read it simply I had I had to correct some people in the K because they read it simply they forgot to look at rash so you created oh it comes to say that you're allow to eat a Sher no there's another one word they have to stick in there it comes to say that you're allow to eat a of a Sher the a of a sherid so I just want to point out one quick thing it's a it's a public service announcement because we're coming up on Tish onat Tu Bish no that not not yeah tuat so tuat a lot of people eat all sorts of fruits and vegetables so I'm not a big fanatic but when it comes to um strawberries I notic a lot of people buy strawberries and they eat them I'm telling you the OU forget the the the the places in America say it's almost impossible to eat strawberries I eat them but you have to soak them and you have to put soap and it's a whole process you have to look online how to do it and you have to cut the top off cuz this really this mus in them they have little tiny bugs that you could see visible and this is in a lot of different things like figs have a lot of problems even dates the the the the the not the M the other ones they not M usually doesn't I've never seen I'll tell you something else they were telling me I said uh some people told me when you eat cashes you have to be you have to pop them open and and you so I'm like these guys with the and I actually over the years I found a bunch of times if you buy good ones then usually not but if you buy crawlers mamish worms that crawl in there so be careful yeah don't huh yeah I'm talking about tubish now tubish fruits be careful Ser I don't know I'm I'm really curious if there's somebody that has like a real good hat there for strawberri I've seen people from people they tell me stop with you rash just did I didn't see okay what he is more M and what does he say that's what I'm asking new so thank you for don't need the soap you don't need the soap but what does he say new the soap it you don't have to so no but we're here in front of everybody so what just say you wash it cut off the top you don't need to soak okay that's say I'm not trying I'm not trying to to to to come up with I'm just saying the basic Basics okay at least when was the last time you soaked your strawberries you look like the type of guy that's last night with bleach all right did anybody take a pencil and write that word in the gamar over here means cus how does the learn cus he right he took out two denim and put in cus instead where is he learning from we have we have to multiply you can't multiply if learns does he do go ahead you will multiply it was a wasn't take each bird with by itself make sure that the the Eagles are by themselves the pigeons are by themselves you see don't mix up animals it's just telling you about companionship about being being it's normal an animal feels comfortable with its own species don't mix species up so this is also a public service announc this is what I love to do when you're go onim make sure that you're American and they're not Israeli okay it doesn't work well I shouldn't say that well my mother's not alive anymore my mother was American my father's Israeli so maybe let's let's pick two different things don't be Tam and asazi and Lish sometimes it works it does but it's not I'm serious just normal keep the species together Chicago New York is also not the best idea sometimes it works 30 years ago how many years ago I should have told myself you mean I'm out of Chicago now you kill for three things what's so this is wow if you were to say the three things You' say and what's the one missing here instead of put cursing so but the is going to add at the end I can understand killing some we get you want to tell me you learn it out from so then that should include all seven you should learn the other six from this one called we know where did you get two from you tell me you have the the famous is so we see that there's another two at least that have this look double that's the famous the the barbecue the the the marshmallow so why did you leave if you have is that we had yesterday so should add two to listen should be four that you kill him from four you're right we do learn from and in fact we do kill for four things what you really kill so it seems like that we go down when it comes to we go down one level for something kill a Jew for you only warn you don't kill him no no no we warn him warning is death once he warn not to do something he does it kill him you don't need you just warn they are you they say that you kill for everything in other words you kill he steals a bike you kill him we teach it to you from where what which one of the seven do we know that you kill somebody so all seven are the same thing what you really kill for stealing I mean it come out that you kill every single I mean who wasn't right seriously I'm saying this from the list of it's it's hard to find that wasn't one of the seven here includes says the problem is he's stealing somebody else's wife stealing so this is a curious because it says and so two things that are similar to gazel and stealing some somebody's wife and Anda what's similar what's not gazel and similar where do you have a situation that's almost either it's stealing or it's not stealing what's similar to stealing so is going to explain later now it says like this KUSI simple if one cusy steals from another cusy I'm being careful what I'm saying here yeah lar says cusy I'm reading a cusi you could stick in any word you want in there but if one steals from another certainly if ausi steals from a Jew AER now what does AER mean a is not just a strong language AER means like you know it's AER to uh take three steps backwards when somebody's D behind you it doesn't seem like you're killing somebody killing the is going to say yeah means killing you kill him cuz he stole from a Jew but a Jew that steals from a so it says rash you right away on the spot who slow down don't start making a ter here don't tell people in I'm not going the city us because in fact it's a beautiful story from the ruged TR who's known to be a very very straight well he's a very straight shooter you know every Rob that came to him he would the famous mice with raron Cutler when raron Cutler was young he went to visit the r and uh he was talking to him learning and uh so Ro was like wait a minute he impressed with him so he said who are you he says I'm a balos from he said ah for Bal inut your learning is not bad cuz he used to like knock he was such a genius like he used to call people different names anyway so a partnership came in front of him he had a Jew and a non-jew come to him for D and the GU respected him and whatever he pass him they pass him so the guy starts off saying the Jew stole from me stole from me so the r Winks at the jew when the guy wasn't looking Winks he says tell me what happened you ripped him off stickles he says yeah yeah so then the r started yelling at him he said you're not allow to you have to give back the money whatever you stole from him give back right now he convinced him he thought the Jew thought that he was on his side he winked to him and he like KN he told him he was in yish that's what it was he told me yeah yeah yeah he like oh the understands me so give it back to him right now to steal from the from the now if you're right that that not a a who steals from another is so why does the use the worder it should say not is the wrong word says tell why it says very simple because of the statement we just made now you want to say that a Jew who steals from so I wanted to tell you but in fact means death penalty ask but that doesn't make sense because within the same BR it says what I want to say specifically that the person I don't use a funny and called I say it straight out what do you get for killing if it's a that kills another go or he kills it doesn't say it says so I'm telling you that in within this when I want to say the word I want to explain that somebody that I don't say I say says listening well yeah of course over there when it when it talks about death about murder I can't use the word m I have to use the word Potter and not what so come out means oh a Jew is allowed to walk around in the street and start knocking off C's heads that doesn't make sense so this is going to shake you up if you didn't you just came for this is really going to shake you up you're going to you're going to ausi and a Shepherd a Jewish Shepherd check this out we have a oh I forgot to show you this first let me show you the shim yeah shim and the the turtle is not the turtle it says it really means a toad there's a toad and there's a frog okay this I'm going to show you for 10 seconds if you little quey you shouldn't look at this in China this is sometimes the eat anyway that's garnish I'm not going to tell you what they really do but here check this out you have a guy you have a Shepherd this is a Jewish shepherd He looks but he's Jewish Shepherd but he's a Shepherd he's a shepherd of bakus now we know that it's also to to um to graze Bak but he didn't listen he want to make a little money so check this out he's screaming they want to they want to they're attacking him so you just walk by you don't you don't even uh you don't pay attention you don't have to save him if this Shepherd is in a m of Sak he might lose his life he fell into a pit keep walking you believe this another why cuz he's over on this is of however you don't have to take him out of the pit you don't throw him to the Wolves you don't throw him in a pit and this applies to as well you can't throw ausi into a pit so may you can't say the word m means you're allow to kill him obviously you're not allow to kill a cusi if he's in a bad situation you don't have to save him so therefore since it can't say the word m so it says the word poter okay next he said there's something similar to to stealing but it's not really stealing so Ty number one is here's a you have a guy ausi that's working in the Vineyard here he goes he eats grapes from The Vineyard let's say he's a g of him you kill what what season is this look at this if I can find it oh here he has a if he works he's allowed to eat as much as he wants you're not put it in the you're not to fill up a box full of grapes you allow to eat so if it's if it's what I take it home oh you let it eat an MD but don't take it home in a boxal wow poet Pockets yeah that also trust me we've seen it all somebody remind me he says you know why you have trauma because these guys came to my house I'm and they literally they walked out of my house with full bottles of liquor they just walked out they saw they took from the table walked out these These are stories repeating stories I don't know if it happens to anybody it only happens to me I'm the only one that notices it I need stories exactly for the story is worth it now I can say that's not a good story I need a better story something that's not it's at the end of the season where you're picking the grapes the says it's if it's not at that season and the your worker walks in there and he starts taking grapes G it's regular stealing so what is the that he gets killed every knows that that a I should say ID worshiper ID worshiper steals also why is it when a steals from a Jew less than a why is so what this means that the Jew typically is less than G what's AED today a quarter he stole 10 cents if you have an employee who steals 10 cents from you you you're not going to you're not going to sue the guy you're not going to even call him in for uh for whatever it's called called just want a quick story of M that I saw recently from ribash cuz it was actually in the news now here in AR 13-year-old kid committed suicide last week in school because the kid was bullied so they had a a situation where they were bullying a kid it's a real thing bulling a kid and the kid went nuts the kid mamish lost his mind he became a sugar like they had to put him in a mental institution so the kids in the class felt really bad and they went terribly they said what should we do like we were trying to ask him said you can't ask him he's a he can't be so he said what you should do is wait until he dies and goes go to his cave and ask him a so what we have to wait 80 years now and what if we die before him so he told him that you should have thought about before you did this in other words that's the only way to be to get a m m if you made a guy M you have to wait until he's not M you can't do it so some Israeli yesterday had a great you should kill him and now you be tell you that's said that's a joke okay you're right the Jew is eventually when the Jew found out the guy took from shocked that his own employee took this thing and that chock that s is enough to for him to be soash says remember you're going to love this he says over here he says that typically speaking a Jew has you have to give it back but the doesn't have that so when you do you could erase the wrong doing that you did but AI doesn't have a way to erase it so says rash once at that moment the Jew doesn't have the right to be he could be it doesn't help when does it help the I could erase the past I could go backwards retroactively he didn't steal anything retroact can be I don't have the right to be because there is no so if for one moment he's that's it sorry I can't help you out can't be could be yeah exactly you're right exactly I I think you're right I think there's always a element of in every yeah exactly well there was a for a moment and that moment it's it's over it's finished you can't take it back it it turns into kind of thing that this we had many times in what is stealing stealing is to take out of somebody else's pocket $100 but if you owe the the guy worked for you and you owe him 100 bucks and you didn't pay him you didn't steal you're just not paying that's similar to stealing and that if does he's for that even though he didn't take money he's just like giving money he's like a a kind of a Thing If a does this to another fellow or he does it to a Jew but does it it's don't take from here the same thing how do you have something that's similar to stealing somebody's wife the case is that a slave and he said I'm giving you this sh as your wife and then he he regretted it and he was with that sh so since he gave it to his to his it's like stealing from a Slave so you see he could actually steal from a slave and this could be a for [Music] reparations it says that there's there's there's nothing similar to killing why cuz either you killed somebody you didn't kill kill him I'm just thinking now out loud there something similar to killing like embarrassing somebody in public it's similar but okay it would maybe there's a famous shil why not [Music] huh what so it's like it's like similar to me okay but I don't know if a would be he says I have a gal thing that's similar to killing but it's not killing that May somebody is chasing his friend wants to kill him we had that whole with and everything he could save his life by shooting him in the leg but he shot him in the head by mistake not by mistake on purpose I just want to point out that this is the only time in sh that this name is is there that you have a t by the name of and it's just interesting that it's the same the son of sh who was very involved with being from his father okay so Rashi over here says is this the Rashi yeah so Rashi says something interesting it's close to being such a [Music] thing it's it's not when when a when a a does it to or to Jew but if a Jew instead of shooting him in the head in the leg he shoots him in the head he would be Potter in such a case but by AI would not be Potter and according to she says it's m so I I got this email because I mentioned it from IR fredman he says firearm self-defense laws in in most US states allow you to use deadly force when there's an imminent threat of severe Bly injury death Most states do not require you to retreat even if you have the ability to treat without because I said over there guy says I asked a question guy says stop eating cereal right now otherwise I'll shoot you so there some that say okay get up and move away he's right in America that doesn't work if a guy comes steal from your store and all he wants is money and he has a gun you're allowed to kill him because you don't know many times they turn around Afters they decide okay let's get rid of the evidence let's get rid of this witness he's holding deadly force you're allowed to use deadly force against him he's not reallying yeah you don't know their mindset it's no different than someone who says give me your wallet I'll shoot you yes he can give the wallet and hope he goes away but if you complied does it eliminate the threat 100% can he still shoot you of course there's still a threat until the bad guy's G or he's neutralized so in America American law the answer to the sh would be that you can shoot the guy who present who presents the eat cereal or get shot threat regarding shooting to injure shoot in the leg versus shooting to kill when you're faced with self-defense defined by above you need to defend your life by eliminating the threat so America is the opposite of Israel in Israel if you could shoot a guy in the leg and you shoot him in the head they'll put you in jail in America it's the opposite if you shoot a guy in the leg and you don't shoot them the head then they put you in jail why seriously cuz you feel threatened enough that you need to use deadly force you have to kill him if you're able to shoot him in the leg and he's not a deadly force meaning he can't lunge forward and kill you then why do you shoot him in the leg run away do something else it's a it's a if you feel so threatened cuz right there's a certain like 10 feet a guy could easily jump in a second and kill you if he has a knife doesn't do enough it doesn't stop a guy most of the time he get shot in the leg you don't even feel it I didn't I sh in the legs I don't know that's why you never want to shoot in the leg since they likely won't eliminate the threat most firearm self-defense standards as well as police standards teach to shoot Center Mass in the center of the T to stop the threat quickest if think you can stop the threat fully by shooting in the leg you'll have a tough argument that the circumstance leading up to your shooting allowed you to use deadly deadly force to begin with so anyways if you're in America and you're faced with this situation go for the head or the center Mass he's saying cuz the head is hard to hit but but head if you could do head he's that close head but not so so says over here all similar you could you could well over here it's different this is like Israel law if you could but we're talking about knives and and um and what do you call it Spears little different you feel like you could get him in the leg and eliminate the threat whatever could eliminate the threat do if you don't have to kill him B where are weal Global experts in International Financial Services Anonymous in the sa full of like we have today whatever you could kill a with one judge one witness you don't even have to warn however this is interesting a woman doesn't work here but this is super interesting even your own brother his own brother even his own [Music] father kills a unborn baby a Jew that does I think in next week's par know you he's he hits the the pregnant woman and the Uber money but he's not on is a singular judge I saw like he's acting like an animal that's you don't have to warn one say to exclude a woman but it says his brother even your own brother could testify against you or for you even for The Unborn it's with the point is it's within a human being not outside of the it's within this comes to say I just want to tell you the the how do you say that in English the Minister of Justice here in Israel wanted to make a new law about uh abortion and the RAB were very against it obviously and uh one of the rabam that was going to approach the minister was the son of and he gathered the raon and he said we have to D in AAR that we should have success in this meeting so they go to the meeeting and everybody introduced themselves and he said he's the son of rine so he's so no you go what do you have to say I want to tell you a story he says there was a couple that came to my father Rari LaVine they had argument and they said whatever Le paskin that's what we're going to do the wife said the wife said I want to keep the baby the husband said I have to go to medical school I don't have time for this I don't have patience for this I don't have the money for this I don't want what does the r say the sat down and explain to them how beautiful another another baby take care of you when you get older was masing and then he tells the this guy Tamir that was his name the Tam he says you know this this this guy that that that he says who he says you you yourself this is the baby that came out of that that that thing that was my father he says no way it's impossible he says yeah he called up his mother from the spot he says ma is it true that you went to she says yeah it's a so then said if so I will never let this this law pass under my when I'm here this will never happen so they left and all about him look at the say listen you had such unbelievable story you have the ace so what do you what do you have to dve you said we have to dve and you pretend he says no story here story story you still need for the story to work okay say said not we until now we were saying that gets what he's saying no says so check this out very nice the way we read the is that that is after the word BM the the the Uber we're talking about The Unborn Child great he says no I want to learn it like this put the comma over here it happens to be look at the K it's right there botom that's where the K is you know the in [Music] in isas and and things like that yeah but okay actually looks like uh let me see yeah that's okay fine but I'm reading like [Music] this that the second you you read it which type of which one of the four misas happens with inside the body from within the body itself not like chopping off a head Etc and why not Benny no why the ear stops kids from within the body not from the outside Source that's the what a woman is not tells of I know what I have commanded who so so that includes women also just make sure ah yeah continue it it includes women also law yes the refers to women as well but there's two parts the sons of they have and when it comes to the women they have to do they have to do above and beyond learn means literally so this explains the question how we don't make the answer is because everybody in the world is so it's not it's not a to us it to the whole world is that what he says the that's guy might not accept the Mone might not accept the money that's what they saying yesterday it might be a half hold on let's go according to you so if a kills he doesn't die you're going to make such a deal that it doesn't apply to women you're right from what we said before that a woman cannot testify she can't that's a good deal but we have another we have another part of the that everybody is included in women so look at the PA for a second seems like that the idea of Z is only of of of being faithful is only to to to men he has to be but his wife could go around no both of them are they're both [Music] in here another secret talking about say is twice to include the let's see what the base here says I'm pretty sure oh yeah so you take this from from the side it says every time says we said yes here this yeah where was it g here G is Layar so I learned from G why I need another this is talking about when but when with a Jew then we change typically speaking you should get whatever you hold but once you go with the of a Jew so whatever the Jew gets if a Jew gets Skil you get Skil where where does not is not but if he's over with a Jew he is there's only one case starts off saying that now you have to treat the the like a Jew just like a Jew needs a bezin of 23 he needs two doesn't make any sense one One D no all of a sudden he was over with a Jew so now you say he might not have to die because he need to you didn't find to him you didn't he might not die CU you need to warn him you didn't warn him that doesn't make any sense and engage Nao that the doesn't believe in engagement he only believes in being with his wife is gonna say so since he doesn't have that he's not over with but since the Jews are in it then he's going to get SK like a Jew on what we're on with a Jew you give him why should a get he should get whatever usually gets what does usually get whatever is for him he gets his thing what happened was she was a realiz according to the but not according to a then we flip it the same thing like we take him with and we give him if you look at the you are she's doesn't say you're married her that's what they on they don't believe in that they said that's not considerations and therefore we do considerations so we give him Mis like a Jew have a wonderful day