Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 55 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning [Music] ra nice nice camera work over there you know that a when you look around the room and there's hardly any people in the room that means it's raining outside it's m um ah maybe there's a lot of people up very late at night there was I heard there was something going on in the middle of the night here in a lot of yesus were learning through the night a lot of the learn through the night a beautiful picture that somebody took of Joel M at theel he didn't even know that it was taken Shati yesterday something very interesting happened first time I received four pictures of the same thing of four different people four different pictures here check this out first one is Isel Goldstein learning on a plane and then he says thank you again so very much Mandy for inspiring me and many of the cl to use up your travel time properly I've never had such a good and accomplishing feeling in my life is now we have Mo that is M us all as I got into Manchester Airport on Sunday morning I downloaded the home M when I landed in JFK I finished until then the next three days on the way to work I finished the having my family around the table at the and each one of my younger kids getting up and giving a small speech his children got up and gave a small speech about the importance of learning while traveling is something no money can buy thank you Mo a million times over this our Bo say is the one and only Yan sitting with the peasants in the back of his private [Laughter] jet I don't know what business class that is but it's not what I fly on this like Emirates or something something uher beautiful he's doing the da this a Zigler is on the plane on Zoom not knowing that somebody snapped a picture of him he didn't send it in he's doing the shear on the plane gra was one of the only times ever I heard like the um who was making the announcements on the plane said please do not use the internet for with VPN where for Zoom calls and you know it was one of the things they asked not to do uh no harwitz on the plane so four people in one day I don't know what this doesn't show that he's learning but I'm sure that's what he meant Bo said check out this beautiful video Yeah you could see I tried I tried I zoomed in I zoomed in I couldn't figure it out he's watching Minnie Mouse no I'm just kidding okay [Music] SM I'm not trying to I'm not I'm not trying to the energy in the air we're ready for shabas Pumped up like [Music] crazy it's going to be an amazing amazing I AMC I'm excited mdy shabbaton the everyone together all around the world learning Torah meeting each [Music] other those are all videos every sing one of those box the video [Music] being part of this is something that you you can't put into words and I'm just wow and just random people coming over and sharing stories about their lives and feeling connected mdy rounds of worlds in one place singing dancing talking to each other like they've been best friends for life wow what a shabat and I use the shabbaton as energy for the rest of the year all I can say is that you can't even explain what it is until you're here it's not human possible what did I just experience insane I was blown away I've never been to events at all like this ever dancing and singing I think that was the best part of it started singing songs I became an emotional W I was crying so much I couldn't even continue singing [Music] everything was everything was perfect everybody should make a bigest St to come because it's life changing really is it's a shabas of a lifetime you don't want to miss it it was so special to be here and I look forward to being here next year resem don't even think twice sign up for the experience of a [Applause] lifetime let all it all right I hope I didn't hurt anybody's feelings didn't say anything about yeah we show the food um should we talk about Shi okay next y grot thank you so much for all that you do all that you and MD family do for am you mentioned today's da that you gave the sh in the airport and room made for people with anxiety for flying perhaps I can provide a different point of view which I already mentioned I don't know where and how but I said it in sh the fellow donated the funds and made this room did not know about the da or MD but knew that rebell will need a quiet and comfortable space to give a d here on 28125 so made sure that there would be a very comfortable and super quiet space you said no one was there wheni needed so that he can Z we often in the well that in the well that worked out mindset Hashem loves each and every one of us in every single aspect of Our Lives has been orchestrated by him to be what is best for us when something works out is only because we have the eyes to see it but that doesn't mean that when things go the way we were not planning that it didn't work out loves you and us benefiting as your so revealed in your life and may we all be to always have the right eyes to see how around us you're toing from across the [Music] pond um dear belly this morning after landing in new workk I went to DAV Shak oh I like this one went to D in Lyon New Jersey after approach me and asked me if I do the D with MD I told him yes but how do you know but how did he know he told me every time he sees a new face every time he sees a new face he tries to recruit them to mdy I was very inspired and remind me that we are all one big family sincerely tal Duell I would like to express my feelings about mdy family and yourself the past 7 months was not easy at all 6 weeks my grandson was in the hospital then in home the do kept me going all this time shifts day shifts that D became my best friend and biggest support it brought Sim and relaxation thank you now to the m the support we got from so from many many MD men and women consistently asking Ding and always there for just to look up at the sponsor of for the she ready to help in any shape and form all may we only hear you may get hooked to I checking out family was making a today and reminding the that on well Thursday night in it's to go just to see we're expecting over a thousand people in one room here in for the first time they've done it in New York in Brooklyn but Nevers let's see what happens and Thursday night I said that all these questions after share yeah um this rabai is real this is going into the back right over there for the there's 24 cobbies in there that are going to be rented on a yearly basis for yourin that's the only place that people are going to be able to put in we are looking for a sponsor it is $30,000 to sponsor that piece and you get your name on it lus um and finally the grandson of who I just read his email forar memory AG 70 and for 32 years until he was nter for the unity of the Jewish people wow so he started at age 70 and he finished four Cycles Fromm wilsher thanking Hashem for the release of aie Rosenfeld he should have a complete recovery what say it's not P it's a it's a lot of trauma that the body takes of being secluded and by yourself and away from the family for so many months sponsored by H YK which has just learned means h ventures in honor and for the success of all our clients the yard of second day sponsored 40th yard side of ab Diamond sponsored by his family the art of the month and the whole staff to to Makey so many I told Yi just this morning I realized that the art of the month is is much more expensive than the M we were trying to go like to to pay the salary I think we should just lower it to $3,600 a month maybe there will be more takers because right now it's about $166 a day so in terms of value it's almost doubled in other sponsorships like the the sponsor and the Turning of the D sponsor so he said the to make and the of the mon in honor of for all the work that they do we are holding yes that where we're holding I don't want to make a mistake here I wasn't 100% here yesterday I was here but I wasn't so much here my head was spinning I didn't have my coffee yet when the receiver of then there's a certain age there's a minimum age with a somebody's doesn't matter what age even a one day old you're over we have what is the minimum age to be over on a human being here's a sh that you'll scratch your head but the gor actually talks about is it possible ra say check out this question it's unbelievable you're not going to even believe the answer to this question it's it's different than what you think can a person be over Aras with his own self can a per you hear the question can a person be boil himself that's that's a question we're going to be dealing with and the the answer is fascinating says R you must be at least 9 years old to to be the receiver say you have to be at least three years old we know and we're gon have a today that the minimum of age for B is 9 years old by a boy for all is for for everything to be woman for for everything everything anything that has to do with be you have to be at least 9 years old so if the giver has to be 9 years old the receiver also has to be 9 years old no it doesn't have to do with the boy it has to do with the age of the girl we learn the whole idea it says in the of it says so it mentions is and we know that a woman her minimal age is three so M it's 3 years old by a boy also that the minimal age is we're talking about we're not talking about any we're talking about a person who he only from nine and above this other I don't know what but there other so there's another part of the I actually in the Hebrew she I started here last night because it's a new topic what are the ways that you're with a be in two ways the regular and not natural way and a woman who's with an animal also she's in both ways argues says the says so she's both ways natural and [Music] unnatural when a man has relations with an animal by by doesn't say the word says we have to remember this because thear is going to argue on him if the be is the receiver then there's only one way to do it so how many ways do we have total between is and is we have three two by is one by is R papa says the opposite but he also remains with three and at the end the is going to say no it's four it's two and two it's always two it's a hard piece understand perhaps it means a little bit little that I understand there a woman has some and AAW it's it's put it this way between humans and animals animals they have certain Seasons that they make it's not a thing that they they typically do so but a woman yes so she should only be for thead and not for the certainly not with a human being since anyways it's a over here for an animal so you should be an animal in both ways how many do we have total three but we have a br that says there's a total of four whether it's an animal it's two whether it's the in a cave it's always two that the the receiver Z the kid is is at least 9 years old now it says that when it comes to an animal is even there's two ways with an animal and a woman who with an animal also so either way you dissect this this will be a question either who says that by be there's only one way and over here say there's two ways and the also that he says that by there's only one way and in fact we see that there's two ways so we have a in all of let's see the the is and it says the wordes is with even her what's her it means just to touch doesn't mean to finish the ACT even the beginning stages of what exactly is exactly what let's just call it touching so the question is do we have that same just touching your that's it without finishing an act what's the question of course it says in the says and We Know by a woman it means even the [Music] beginning are over on the the least amount just to touch so very very simple check this out there's another POS this is the same word her and this is referring to an ant and from your father's side starts with the mother your mother's sister your father's sister your a and it says the the of Hera now once I see the word Hera byid then I take that to all R an ant to daughter to to what AA it says it by NE it's by everything how do I know it's by everything because there's a heish called R she brings it it says in another for whatever I see over here it's by all them so if by whatever I see by goes to all of them it says the word so why do I need the word I don't need it so since it's extra so then we had this yesterday the day before this is one of the but one of the if I if I have a POS I don't know what to do with it so I'm going to use it for another topic it doesn't say anything about by an animal I'm going to use this by an and use it for for an animal says I don't like it so much why cuz an ant and a beo they both Aras but they have the different categories what do you get for what's the what's the punishment remember the Skil same punishment as Z Skil what's the punishment for an ant it's not so why why are you putting if the Torah really wanted to give me to talk about har by an animal why did why did the put it in in a c category is completely different by an ant should have put it in a category of something that's similar to it in terms of the sorry person with an animal get doesn't make sense they're going to put it by if you're ready okay I'll take it that you didn't want to put it in this POS you want to put it by something else going to learn from something else but at least it should be similar just yesterday me I think he came up with himself I'll share with you I think it has to do with this that um where do we see in the toy the the concept of a birthday you asked the question why did the T pick pirate T should have picked somebody else B I don't know why why AF birthday by Pirates he says beautiful says py thought he's a god gods don't have birthdays so what do you see you see that to have to make a birthday even if it's against your hashkafa you could still make one you always make a birthday no matter what that's that's what our wives think right as no no I tell my wife 20 times I don't go by the English birthday because that that has to do with somebody that we don't really believe in how many gears after his death whatever why why am I celebrating that no birthday has nothing do with that birthday has to do with you have to make a birthday regardless of your ASA I'm going to give a shout out to my son who and my daughter-in-law who this explains a lot I think my wife donated that cake it's not cheap but our our it's already year believe it or not remember I just went to Florida Sophia Russ she's a year old so this is what they do in America you make a party for it it has nothing to do with the kid like because the kid I don't know if she was eating pizza is you have to you have to Mish make a no this is the it's right over here while I'm showing this one of the guys that came to this year last night Shi he's in charge of's Cav he has a I don't know if he's in charge but he has a hotel 3 feet away from the C so he was driving what to Oh I said the C next to the Yeshiva thank you right across right next to the Yeshiva he has a hotel two days ago happens to be's birthday by the way somebody just asked me here let me just say this I listen to all the males but what is the new granddaughter's name from Park City Utah she only be a s maybe others the entire world is created just for me and then it means you were created to help me learn the D so how can I miss your amazing sh for the entire world is created for hour even if we were thousand miles away AI from Brooklyn my my granddaughter from Park City her name is adir and this is It's M over here okay K you get the idea it's just a if I'm not there I might as well show the thing oh fairy fiz galic where's that I got to show you this this is crazy cuz he came to the sh yesterday this was his car a moose a moit his car not a moose in in barus but next to the zero injuries but he has a picture what a moose looks like in case you want to know what a moose looks like it weighs about a ton here's the car you see the car it it hit the windshield and landed on the trunk so it messed up their trunk and then it ran away yeah it got up and ran run yeah all right [Music] so why does it say by ant says this let's go back this is 100% extra why because it says the same exact thing about not being with an ant it says it in in so why does it say it over here in p we learn every takes every single word from here that we we'll deal with every single word here is extra including the word so you can't ask me now but but is is a um is a cus you're right it's cus but we already have extra POS we using every word fine if somebody is himself what's the why you me with questions that are impossible so on the side I blow it up for you so you see it says the ri says you made me nauseous your question is making me nauseous oh my says R let's Okay you you want to you want to talk about let's talk about it how is it possible how is it possible the only way that this is even possible is if the a is Lim if the a is not limp it's impossible so but that's that brings another problem what if somebody is boil somebody with a are you or well it's so person who's boil himself with because that's the only way to do it you well listen to this this is crazy but if a person does this let's say by mistake it touches just by mistake you twice why you're the receiver and The Giver at the same timeus so check this out so this is very nice we didn't have this last night taka means a stumbling block you were you were tripped up by this animal this animal caused you to be over why are we killing the animal it's a it's a shil in lumus why are we killing the animal are we killing the animal cuz the animal tripped you it brought an AA to the world because of the animal so let's say if this picture right over here caus somebody I destroy it this tree is an aera tree I have to destroy it because it brought a or no the Shila is because it brought col is not about the animal it's about the person that did the a it brings a it's a it's people are going to see the animal say oh you know what that go did here here's a kid even spitting at the at the person at his statue they point he said this guy was so the and the dead guy because we killed him already he's dead it's just a statue of the guy that died on him so the Tor says let's kill the animal so nobody talks about the dead guy so here comes the question what about a guy that was over the the the this the sister a go couldn't care less they're proud of it oh I married three donkeys I have no problem so the bush he doesn't have but what does he have he has takala he has this guy this animal brought a very to the world the guy is over the guy every every is on this so maybe we should kill the animal because it brought an is to the world not because of the bu but because of the takala not because of the color because of the we're going to have the same question in Reverse what if it brings only bu but no iser what's the case Bo I think for a second how could something bring AB but no iser anybody anybody new aw so let's see this real quickly this this might help us a little bit for the Su how do you have to col you have the only way to have and not to have an A without is on purpose because a Jew automatically has AA no matter if it's on purpose or not on purpose so can't be a Jew at all must be talking about a GU on purpose how do you have bu without a a only Jew because a so so to have is not even never has to have without is only a Jew it's not a did it by mistake he didn't know that it's or whatever happened so if it's there's a big smart and tricking and everything and so just made her touch the tree didn't actually speak to her so what was the problem with the why did he get punished so this reason he says because the color that came through the snake that caused the woman to sin but you see you only got punished he didn't get killed so we only punish the to show that it's got punish the by by Reel if whoever didn't hear oh now we have we actually have microphones we have a microphone next to him it's kalash but okay basically he's saying that this is what the says that the got punished not because he he pushed a woman because he brought there's a that happened through the and that's why he got punished but not killed okay but thear is asking here do you kill an animal for the only without and do you kill the animal for col without the now we're at question number one you need both the and the by a there's only The Stumbling call there's no he doesn't have a perhapses without you could kill the animal just for stumbling upon the animal the animal causing an a you kill the animal even though there's no tries to bring a from here and argues on him here's the by a tree you take a tree that you destroy it completely you uproot it you destroy you go crazy on it you burn it but it can't even eat it can't drink it can't smell It's Not a Human Being destroy it burn it eradicate it get rid of it why because human being stumbled upon it because of it this tree a person didn't so a person who makes somebody else get death brings him to to something terrible so an animal who caus a person to to sin like that with a be we should eradicate the beh just like we eradicated a tree so obviously see you look at this and I have to say I can't go by without saying so if a person brings somebody he learns on a plane and he doesn't realize what he does he's learning on the plane another FID walks by and impressed and says oh I also have to learn like a guy told me I don't know maybe within the last two weeks a guy said I was on a on a plane and the guy next to me was not as from as me he tells me probably he looked at his Zam and decided this guy's not as fromis him little does he realize that this guy learns and he learns and this guy's busy with other he has a nicer yamaka maybe a frommer yamaka so to speak it's bigger and larger but learning H he didn't take him he didn't take the Mah exactly you didn't take the mahaj he was watching the movies with the mahaj he says I I really want he told me B I really wanted to watch movies the guy ruined my whole flight and I had a he came here to say hello he say I had a I had a learn I had a learn this guy he M made him learn to instead of watching movies but I'm serious you don't know what what what what you do Mandy didn't know when he learned in the airport and and guys you don't know what you're doing you give people num mus new mus we have to start a new trend learning on the bus here learning you know I people do it why you drive learning on your scooter learning on your bike or if you're a pilot learning where you're flying what you do learning while you SK as the I don't understand anything that's a stumbling block any animal that caus you to so if you bow to an animal you should destroy the animal it should be user to a Jew and you should kill it there's no such thing because if a Jew bows to an animal you don't make the animal AER you can't Asser an animal through bowing to it so if a GU does you should ask her say however but even if let's say you don't have two Aid them you have one aid but this this animal should become user like like we have by by reveal just the actual Act of being with an animal asers the animal so when you yeah so what what's going on here in this line is that is saying I agree to you that a GU that's with an animal you have to kill it but not because of what you said what did you say why why does say they have to kill this animal because there's taka says no it's not because of it's because of the col and this is also fascinating by saying a go a the is so much by a go why is it so much bu because he first broke hashem's word hasem said not to be with an animal second all him self did a disgusting thing the two things combined you have to kill the animal even though you're saying to to begin with that a go doesn't really care go is not so in other words the outcome is the same you kill this animal that's with a but for different reasons says because don't have that much a tree doesn't have that much at all we're talking about animals since we seen this really cares about animals always has animal where do we see that has animal CU in order to kill an animal you need a Bez of 23 and you need real aen a tree is a tree no you're not going to bring a tree to B of 23 you just chop it down and then destroy it so I have to be careful before I kill this animal since some sort of enjoyment for this animal so that's why he gets killed in other words it had involvement I don't know if the word is enjoyment as much as involvement but beh there's nothing just stood there nobody touch it nobody anything so you don't kill it how can we destroy a tree it wasn't really involved in if you're going to compare a tree to an animal why would I destroy an animal because I destroy a tree tree doesn't care if I chop it down an animal cares now if you are a tree hugger please don't write your emails now whatever okay said 23 cares about it so if you go back to the m check this out it says the M ask a question why is it that an animal who didn't have a with a person has to die what did the animal do the animal was inv the animal didn't have a choice here so what does the M say the the key word here is believe it or not we're going to go back to this the says and then is going to change it no no no it doesn't mean it means call over here is not both yeah yeah hold on we're getting there that's the and then check this out that's the ratio look what the says I have another [Music] reason that people that are animals going to go in the marketplace so if you read it carefully this animal and that guy so basically zo is a lotion of taka and pl the guy that's dead is a lotion of so the sa is talking about both so the does a very simple thing here and that's all the way to the bottom of b m simple since the safe is talking about both the reason why I kill this animal that ask why should I kill an animal what did the animal do the answer is because he did two things wrong so what's the Raa what's the first in the mishna can't be that the r is saying two things the is saying oh because of two reason and the saying because no way the sa says col it the ratio must be talking about one out of the two that's the in the one out of two you get to kill the animal but which one out of the two says is enough to kill it the said well I'm not really forced in a corner I could get out of and say that means calling and not but the r is definitely only one the save is definitely two the problem is that all the way since we can't put the the the mission in the corner I can't figure out if the Mish the is talking about so I'll never know until M comes when do I kill an animal for one thing is it or only coling I'm going to explain that's a good question I'm going to explain says 100% face value it says M face value you kill an animal for we're going to get there in 10 20 seconds is B so must be face value what's so that I already explained here let's let's look at this how do you have without only a how do you have without the only a Jew and this answers my question I ask you a question if a GU had relations with the animal do I kill or not and what's the's question because it only has without call do you need B here without a is a good reason to kill an animal here the by itself boom kill it you're right that I'll give you the sa is talking about both no the is talking about a not face value and what's the case of without says the is talking about without but how could you tell me such a thing it's so farfetched the answer is in this chart itself why in the world will I say that the m is talking about which only takes place with a GU it doesn't make sense the Miss is talking about a GU what do I care about G the end of the Miss is talking about is so the beginning of the talking about is we're talking about is you're right it's a very very very for but nevertheless I have a reason to make that it makes a little sense basically what the is doing here is not the is not saying that that's the real saying I can't force to say that means face value because for me it makes more sense it's not face value that's talking about is not a in a second not in a second in about 10 minutes the is going to flip it and say no it is talking abouta but I'm not for I can't force it either way what was the's question oh so now I have the reverse question what happens when I have col I have a big without any a how do I have a big without an a a Jew that was with an animal he's not going to get punished for it it was a m a mistake a guy turns on a light yeah here's a good example I just thought you're in sh 200 people having the shabas you lean on the wall shut the entire sh's lights off what is that a tremendous bu without a AA you don't get to I can't give you skila for turning off the light by mistake but the whole show looks at you like H yeah yeah you know what I'm talking about the same idea correct this Jew is embarrassed but or perhaps you kill the animal because you have one out of the two you have the without Thea or perhaps you need both Thea and so this is super simple until the mishna oh spor thank you Global experts in International Financial Services should have this G repeats itself but in two ways first we're going to talk about the minimum age for Bea for a girl and the minimum age Bea for a boy it's basically the same same question same answer okay let's go now she's Roy she's already three years old so therefore one of the three ways to be woman the first Miss is so if her father gives her over to another man so she's every time we learn these Su I get emails how's it possible okay time of the gar one thing that I always like to say that the time of the gar there was such famine and such sour CL people we we had sugus tremendous sugus inas when a guy gets engaged and he didn't really he's not with his wife yet and he he met up with her two days late who has to does he have to give her Theus of those two days a whole who cares give her the bread and the no we have a whole I'm not to give you I'm not married yet that they didn't have they P didn't have what to give so one of the things they used to do is you see this all time they would give their daughters away to men just you take care I can't she's going to die it's like to give a a kid to orphanage it's not the right thing to do but that that was the only way to for survival it's like intz they give a kid to to Christian family just survive I don't know what to do now we're going to die you take her I don't know fine what the oppos you don't mind kids cuz you don't have money oh by the way what's happens you don't marry your kids cuz you don't have money just what H you don't Mone you can't afford to marry them oh today yeah today is Right have money can't afford by the way in Yemen I don't I remember when just maybe let's say 100 years ago they married their kids off at 3 years old because otherwise they would bring them to the to the Muslim whatever so they're married married married okay so you start asking questions okay don't go don't go too get too involved over here we're talking about this girl had the worst worst situation ever her father marries her she's three 3 years old 3 years old in three months her husband dies and now obviously they don't have children so now she falls to her brother-in-law so the brother-in-law is kind of because she's and anybody has relations with her is this is this a whole by the way before I do this beautiful Su what's her name come from Mii Beach North Miami Beach you saw my father's did the whole thing every day really all right send regards you probably I'm sure you speak to him more often than I do it's hard hard to get a hold of him I should really call him taka okay Bo say check this out we we just had this recently AA we'll talk about we're talking about AA it's the same thing as Ana we'll talk about anida anida herself is what we call aat she's the source of T in Tom when a a touches something what does that thing become one step less it's always one step less so becomes a re however when she sits on something let's say she sits on a couch on a mattress even if she's not touching the mattress even if it's 10 mattresses below her she never touch them they all remain the same exact thing called aat what what I call Med m now anid who's with her husband the boo let's say even by mistake that guy becomes a full-fledged nid the Tom of a what we call an aat just like her he becomes aat yet there's a huge difference look what happens to him yeah everything above her becomes aan that's normal what she touches is a this Bo guy he becomes aat but the mattresses become what we would think should become they become one step less a reine that's normal the fact that an sits on something becomes like her that's a huge what if Ana touches her husband he becomes a re he doesn't become a aat it's just through be so says the gar this three-year-old since she's royala and she's Aid because a girl could become a one day old so her becomes let's say she's 2 and A2 years old this is all argument okay don't go crazy don't send me emails now 2 and half years old is just touching an it's not considered because she's not soing he becomes a that's all saying over here a threey old plus so all the mattresses become if this three-year-old gets married to she eats Trum because she's fully married through the beer if she had relations with a he made herle to and anybody that has relations with her let's say her brother father they die but she's pot why she po because she's only 3 years old oh this is what we're looking for and an animal with a girl a three-year-old dies this is a case of a big bu Anda everybody's going to say you know that animal was with that girl but she doesn't get a because she's only three years old so here's the answer to our question we as the question what if there's a and no takala the answer is you kill the animal you don't need both you don't need AA and a Taka here's a case a girl had says tremendous since she did it deliberately she is over a three-year-old a 5-year-old is over on her and only her in other words theed her from the death penalty because she's a but a is a is a so she she did it on no [Music] she when it so here the uh they say this story about I I only knew it about the but yesterday I read it about the they completely ignored but they say about the V that he saw his mother he saw a mother nursing a baby or something he saw the baby like hitting the mother lightly so the vill ask his mother he says what's this of the kid so the mother said you did it also when you're that age he says I did it and he that he he had tremendous sire and he did CH for it they say that he I think he went to G on it I saw the yesterday did the same thing same story every rebb did it okay whatever huh I said yesterday did it and the said no did it so there's a there's a shil here what so [Music] and the says no it's only the reveal with and he says because it doesn't make sense that when the was given to that we stepped down we only stepped up so if we had a and and and even that same thing applies to uh to human beings today as well but not and not other just says the oh so now we have the same exact again let's do it quickly he's n years old so therefore all the things again he could acquire when he's 9 years old get but he's not old enough to give a has to wait until he's 13 and he has the same is consider becomes the same t as her like in this picture becomes but the mattress is a her mattress is a he if he's a m he makes another woman POS through his relations because it's a real relation he's 9 years old and he cannot she does not eat trumo because of him with the animal cannot be carbon and the and you get because of him any relations he has with they die because of him so you see the animal say this is a case of excuse me without a why is it a cuz he's only 9 years old yet you kill the animal he did it deliberately so there's there is so if doesn't die let's just go to so we have the mishna the sa [Music] says end of the says the two reasons and so we said if the says two reasons so the r can't mimic the sa there's no reason why the M repeat itself so obviously the is saying one out of the two kills the animal which one is it so if you look at the first line of our what it says first line we're talking the simple meaning like said the simple meaning now we're doing the opposite not the simple meaning and why would I not go with the simple meaning because it makes a lot more sense in the mishna because the only way to have to color without color is a and we don't want the M be talking about a we want M talking about only that makes more sense I can't force it you're right is both but is one not the coloring part it must be have a wonderful day