Daf Yomi Sanhedrin Daf 54 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] good morning [Music] ra this is where the emails go this is where the sponsorships go soab today is one of these days I woke up at 7:16 when the year is supposed to start at 7:10 I came quite late and uh we didn't do any of the email of the sponsor so we're going to do it now but as has his little plans we had tremendous that byak actually during Shear but I didn't notice him we have with us a tremendous human being his name is Don fredman sitting right over here next to me Dan I don't know if I said this in the English here maybe yeah I think I did show his his picture Dan went through a very hard in his life he went he had the m and he went through all the treatments and throughout the whole he learned the da and today he was inspired and he gives a Shear in hisa famous Yesa here in and he gives a she not he gives a Shear every day he does a Shear with pictures and and all sorts ofak stuff graphs and um his friends came one night when he came to the she his friends came four or five guys and they told me how great the she is so I thought oh they're doing him a favor you know it turns out he has 30 guys every single day 30 guys come and they they listen to the she from him he does about a quarter of a number to day so this tremendous inspiration many people should do what you're doing he said I have the to give a Shear let me give a shear and he's with that being said I just wanted this's hardly any emails for today but this is a picture of mdy for life this is in Florida this I'm going to show during the she uh yard side and with that let's go straight into the sponsors everybody here pretending that we're part of the shear here you could zoom out on them you here's Hill doing right over here you see this ah this is not part of the she is walking all right what we going to do now you're gonna have to edit yourself and we even brought in he could do the there's no laughing during the the sponsors grandson of start learning for 32 years until for the of the Jewish people by Glen with love and gratitude from wilington North Carolina thank you for enriching my life with you guys the most important part of the she that most people go to sleep you came to hear it unbelievable thanking from wel for the release of Ari Rosenfeld Aon benind who a big part of the Year learned five while he's incarcerated sponsor by hyk the guy sitting right over with his fill in ventures in honor for the success of all our clients Kam what's the Y for that's your second name h y kamanski h YK Steven Rubenstein in honor of yob Rubenstein becoming mitv that's the and the day sponsor in the art of the mon the to make so many in the art of the month in honor ofi for all the work they do and now we're going to jump ahead to the thirding of The Da ofat in honor thank you Global experts in International Financial Services anonymous we're holding in the middle of a beautiful one of these we do all the interesting ones and the uh the ones and the Pim ones and today ones we do all D we had a su like this if a person was M with his own mother how many carbas does he have to bring he did how many carbas does he have to bring so according to he brings two according to he brings one garnish just black brings one so yesterday we were dealing with why does he bring one so first wanted to say because it says it's an exclusion only one and the said but what do you do with and then the said is an exclusion just one not two we're going back to but with a new four lines from the bottom because I woke up late could put in my Pim that I wanted to put in okay what is this ah like a like a shot okay so it says the gar like this we're going to take this p and we're going to break it down to three parts first we start off saying thatas now if the words if we just take the words us think about it okay don't do any just you're reading the POS for the first time you're what does father so who's who you the is with who with your father that's the the in fact that's how are going to learn the nothing to do with your mother doesn't have to do with your father's wife it has to do with your father your father like uh like the son of n with nothing to however that's why reuta holds that you're only of one because he learns the posing that way he he learns it differently means your father's wife why you might because he learns like we'll see once I have that it says it's your father's wife it doesn't say anything about her being your mother you're over because it's your father's wife how do I know that you're over if it's your mother who is not your father's wife how's that possible Ana that your mother never married your father she had you without getting married so now we're doing something else before we said you're over just for your father's wife now we're saying for just her being your mother so it seems like your over on here you put like a big K and the third part of the p is so once I have the first two steps I have the now I have a third part of the no you're not over on the two on being and you're only over on that answers the questions we had yesterday on it's not just an exclusion of it's after I know that this and then the comes and says cannot learn from the word that was one of the questions we had yesterday what they should also learn it's an exclusion it's only an exclusion when I have an inclusion if I tell you in the same POS that you're over on two things then I can make it an exclusion and say no you all over on one but according to the beginning of the p is not even talking about a woman it's talking about your father himself so there's no exclusion here so what do you have you have the beginning of the POS says you shouldn't be over with your father directly then the POS says you shouldn't be over with your mother okay that's it and then the going to learn that on Two And The is going to explain so basically what we're going to have here all the way to the mishna is is a su where charts are not going to really help because there's too many too many basically are not arguing on anything they're only arguing from where did we learn everything they they take they use the same words but each one learns from this from a word a different thing and at the end of the day they come out with the same ideas besides one they're arguing are you over a mother but we're going to see mus like there's something called and the says you get punished you get has to warn you so here this POS tells you the warning this POS tells you the the the the punishment and raban say no this one is the punishment this one is the warning but that's the whole they don't argue they all they both say you need a warning they both say you need a punishment they both agree what the punishment is just from what word do you learn it from so now we're going to see a lengthy that says the same exact that says the same exact thing that we just said now R just points out you should just know that happens to beud who are we trying to figure out rud so once we see this in this that's exactly what R says is exactly what review said to explain himself when it talks about a person who's over with his father's wife it has to be a man you can't be a little kid who's over with his father is Potter in other words you can't you can't punish him is you're over on your father's wife even if it's not your mother let's say he remarried somebody he has two wives Five Wives you're over on all the wives this is still speaking and how do you know that if it's your mother who was never married to your wife you you were born out of wedlock you're she's anusa how do you know huh to your father was never married to your father what did I say okay yeah a mother was never married to your father here these are the words that are extra and from here you learn that if it's your not only your your father's wife but your own mother or which is not a father's wife you're also so some of this stuff we're going to have multiple times like this the word means maybe mean another one of the four we also have by what's here we have a nice picture of he's remote controlling this N Out of the Grave or something he do he does magic with withas it's a type of Magic the main B so we said yesterday that it says so anywhere that it says here you can see the over here so you get whatever so too is say so this he told this to me a long time ago I like to say this in his house every time he tries to punish his kids so of course what's the first thing that happens when you try to punish your kid your wife steps in so his his wife always says she says this you got talked to him in gar language you can't give a kid a punishment unless you warned him before way I don't know if he's gu not such a guest guest how long ago okay that's it's not within the last three days do what's your name from wow very nice okay welcome back well you live over here next to the I should have guessed okay everybody's in okay so we have a warning where do you I'm sorry the the punishment we said May is a punishment Skil where do you see the warning everything in the Tyra needs a warning not not to the person to the Tyra the Tyra needs to warn you that's how it works every every o that you get there's going to be a double lotion somewhere and this so all the way to the m we're going to see this like three times what do you see see what you see so here argues and here he says it again that does not mean your father father himself it means which is a big [Music] later on is talking about the wife of your father says it say it seems like your father's wife so it doesn't matter matter whether she's your mother or not how do you know if it's your mother who was never married to your father as we spoke before that's the second part of the that's your mother without being married to your father when it comes to the warning the tah made the your father's wife and your mother in the same category oh but how do I see it in the punishment phase just like when the warning we made both of them the same the father's wife and your mother did the same category by the punishment your mother who's not your father's wife you're over you get punished finally and this is all the same this all the same that we started off with the last Last Words the exclusion of you only get one punishment one carbon you don't get punished for the for the second thing of being it's your mother but you don't get you don't have to bring a carbon for her being your father's wife I don't know if this is is it ready here you know what I'll go this thank [Music] you so they start off the whole POS differently and they explain means with the father there these two seem to be the same why do I need a double why do I need a second POS says to be over twice let's say if a person didn't know it's his father whatever it was he didn't know it's he didn't know it's a did not know the is going to say one second go is just to be nice what it really means is a Jew [Music] and once again here's the same exact thing you're on you're not let to be with your uncle but you're also over on rud is not reud it's Ina right he lived way way after reud so yeah we started the da with reud now we're talking about rabud who says that over with a father over and says ra let me explain rud obviously we're not talking about a go he says the word we're talking about he didn't know it's and we're talking about carb should bringas from being with his father is just to say to say to say it in a nice way in a clean way there's a a priest who noticed that business is very very weak they're not coming to confess anymore so he he thought to himself you know probably it's because people don't want to confess like really big AAR so he made code word he said if you do this big big AA terrible AA you call it uh throw up throw up come you tell me you threw up and you don't have to like specify listen to here so he had a he had to take a break one day so he asked his his friend say could you step in could you could you take over he says sure and uh the guy sees a lot of people and when the the priest comes back he says new how did it go he says I don't know but it seems like you have some stomach virus or something going on in fact your son came here and he said he threw up five six times this week it's not your Vol you don't get it the Israelis laugh like crazy you guys are pre the preon we only laugh at the funny one I said B they should take um a side by side of the Hebrew give uh what's his name the shimmy who's doing today shimmy or Ariel you're doing it I give you some a job so the punch line of that after that okay it's not the joke it's the time of the day it's not the delivery it's the time of the day it was the delivery sorry it's the the same delivery we could we could be that sorry listen I'm not going to throw out my other jokes here this is a we got to go straight without any jokes he the new guy if it's not a [Music] Jew even have to kill him so what are you telling me Oh you should know the for being with his father talking about Drew and something very interesting because they talk about this you know we had these before what happens if somebody who let's say they have to give him they give ska and miraculously on the way to the to Barum or he's hanging all a sudden gets comes does whatever and he gets do you have to kill him again so could be I'm just thinking now here this could be you might have to if a guy's two so you only did one so now you give the second one what oh you're saying that it's not so POS what so he has to he has to remarry his wife what does he have to do who who told you here we go I just mentioned him on Friday right my story was on Friday okay person who made a huge change in CL yeah says was guy that was struggling with and said don't worry you still [Music] you're still what not doing it yeah so you still okay he still war around the worst so we see the same thing it fits right into the Su with a mother you over two or one over here see like RAB over two some say this does not go like that what that the reason the reason it can't go like Ruda because take a look at this at this chart again one says the second is wait a minute says is not even talking about it's talking about your father's wife so can be Ruda course to only over on the top not the second and some say no it could go according to you get two why because is going to learn from the uncle the uncle this is the uncle right this two by Uncle so should be two by father wait a minute what's the problem with that how could I give a guy because of so there is could [Music] like but how is he your uncle because he's your father's brother certainly when you go directly to the source to the father who brought you that that relationship to your uncle certainly should be with this [Music] is so why why because what if you let's say you you want to make somebody pay money because of a you had a okay you owe $100 and then you fig out what you did as a mistake so you go and give the guy back the money whatever but you can't kill somebody or give somebody malus because I came up with a spar and tomorrow when I figure out my SP is off my whole din is gone so how I'm going to take back I can't give him life again so that's why they say also sh see a lot of people a lot of there some people I know I know a person I'm very close to he doesn't e he's with learning the problem is what if the next day you figure out that is no good how do you know the warning so I I don't know I don't even know there's literally 50 charts here which it's hard to use any of them let me just see if I I could find this one no this is a okay what does do with after the father dies she still considered the wife of the father but you need you need a warning for that ver so how did R learn that idea that once the father dies is still a warning they're not arguing they're just arguing where do we learn it what words do we learn it from from the end of the you see on this chart review the top right corner learns after from bottom left corner same thing learn from and what does he do with now that seems like you can learn something from this what does he do with that she's not an is when it comes to the son so you're not you're not a carbon for the part we're going to see that even if she let's say remarries let's say the Father the father dies and she remarries somebody else and the son comes along and has relations with her he's not wait a minute the father's alive or dead doesn't argue in the you're right it's a very good but in the there is that argues where's the penalty component of a father's wife learn we had before a few extra words those three words so that's where they learned the the penalty part for a father after the father dies she still remains right no no goes away besides including remains there's a penalty from this from these words of how do we know that for a mother who is never married to the father that's what we had yesterday that learns from these words here it is so we're done with that says that if a person has relations with his own daughter-in-law he also here look at the it says the describes her as something else also she's a daughter-in-law and both of them says you should be for third thing the reason why opposite they're one and the same even after the where did you get that from Rashi he's reading Rashi that what even after yes that is true but I didn't realize it goes here that what even after the Sun dies obviously she remains a Kala I think we're going to have that later as well there's a story with it's a long story I'm going say the first part that there was a a rumor about a cipher in town that it was misana with his daughter-in-law so the called him in and he of course denied it so the said you're s for yeah he WR so he took his Quil and he wrote down the he say now WR whatever what's the and he couldn't write he just he was trying he couldn't write he says okay you were M and he punished him or whatever says the M person is over with a and a woman who's with a they get the it's a question in the what sin did the animal do why should the animal get punished here they say in a guy was running away from one of the camps and the guards saw him but the guards they said let's see what the dogs could do it'll be fun to watch the dog dogs I've saw a number of times I don't advise it but you could see on the the cops whatever it is the these different thing they show in America they go the they have the k9's a few times I've noticed that they could catch the guy they're only 3 feet away from him but they like to to let the dog do it CU then the dog grabs on and they pretend that they can't get the dog off you know like for three minutes the guy's crying like a two-year old screaming he says listen well you're resisting you're resisting stop resisting and if you stop resisting will let the dog off no but you're still resisting and the guy's screaming okay okay now we'll then they take the dog out so they wanted to see how the dog chases this guy and short off the dogs they come they run they chase the guy down and right when they're about to catch the guy the guy takes out of his pocket a few pieces of meat and he gives it to the dog and the dogs they stopped they started eating the meat so the guards were so upset they took out the gun and they shot the dogs they said what do we need dogs like this a dog that doesn't we have all these dogs we train them for so long finally we finally get a guy that's running and he can't even take the guy they shot the dogs I don't know I don't even know what happened to the guy the guy from the mice seems like to let the guy go but somebody took an animal didn't a with an animal so what did the what did the animal do because this person had this animal did something that caused a person to be to sin is that color also like that with a even if our hands would be you know if somebody sinned with a GU even a you'd kill the just because there was a sin done through the through this so you have to you have to kill the animal you don't want adal going in the street and people going to say oh you see this animal this is the animal that so and so Ruben get killed because of AA that says came to him but I know I once had a similar story so I I I kind of relate the story I once donated a a caravan in a certain city here in AR it's like a um how do you say car a prefab trailer for show and uh they told me that something like this happened somebody gave her for somebody to put a prefab Caravan sh in his property and then one night some teenagers whatever a Misa that happened in the Caravan not a good thing happened in the Caravan so the guy said we got to I want the Caravan out of here so he said I'll make sure it never happens again I'll put somebody this we'll lock it up he says no but every time people walk by they're going to say see this is the Caravan that was a very so they went to Res from from this gar you see that if people are going to talk like that and say hey this thing had a a so you can take it down how do you know that you get if the one that was over the was a minor he was below he doesn't get punished if the person that the a was done to the receiver was a you also get punished with even the gar today is still going to tell us what age there a minimum age either three or nine it's always a terrible thing but to get Mis it has to be a certain age it says by and this is a this is something that we learned for the whole for the whole the way to be over is there's only one way so the when theah says which is plural the Torah is actually teaching us for every in the just like over here by so anytime somebody's all you're also over don't say it doesn't count it's considered full-fledged is coming to explain itself it teaches us for the rest of the maybe somebody could put a sign on the door say that is a little later today feel bad for the people coming or not how do know like we have and here also says we found out that there's a punishment how do you know there's a penalty have another no not another so every act has the giver and the receiver so how do we know the the receiver how do you know he's we have a shouldn't be a and says is refering to is the for the receiver comes with aend he says listen that exact same that we learned before the word could also be read in other words says I don't need the because I can learn from the exact same just it's the way I read it the same three the four letters there comes out tremendous according to by the way shim just put the sponsorship do me a favor put it over here you know what I'm going to read it after after daving I'll just say it after daving do that so we're going to see in a second whether you over two because if you come from two different you're in one awareness do you bring two carbas or one carbas if you learned it from one word and that's one carbon but if you learn from I know that with an animal he gets if the The Giver is a minor below he doesn't he doesn't get doesn't matter how old the animal is even if it's a one day old animal you still over but a one day old child is not considered a until he's a certain age so now we're going away from the it say so we have the penalty for The Giver [Music] theer since and this is one of the that this is one of theum of that what if I have a and have absolutely nothing to do with this because I already said this so I have nothing to do with it for the giver because I already learned that so I use it for the other guy for the so now I have the the the penalty where's the warning okay that's for one person where's the so now the wants to use the same I learned by for no again he's going to do the same exact thing he did before but with a different word it says five letters I could also read it over here I have for the if a person in One awareness so this doesn't necessarily mean this happened within the same minute it could have happened the same year one day he was over he was The Giver the next uh two months later he was the receiver but he didn't even know that it's AER he from where he comes from this is M so he's a so how many does he have to bring he has to bring two why as we said it's two separ however only he doesn't learn from he learns from the same word it's the same word it's one carbon if in one awareness one month he was he was The Giver to the B the next month he was the receiver again same exact thing it's it's one it's one [Music] say why very good cuz he argues on this whole when it comes to it doesn't apply doesn't apply to an animal it's with humans so if if according to you not get the word thees so now according to you're going to have a problem he learned he learned the warning from that now what is he going to do where's the again I have the SE if I'm not going to use it for the giver I'll use it for the receiver and the used of a giver instead of a receiver I have everything already it's ready made the The Giver already has the penalty and the warning so too the receiver has the penalty and the warning a person was the receiver for in one awareness according to why because they have and you have this word so it's two separate is one for the this for the why because he's the receiver where do you learn receiver by a human being where do you learn receiver by same said before I have extra so I don't know what to do with it so I'm going to use it for the receiver like we said before so according to you have two you have and you also have person in One awareness again it doesn't mean the same minute can mean in the same week same month same year same life he just didn't know it's AER he was he was the giver and he was the receiver and listen to this guy he did four things he was the giver and receiver both in it's only three because KES is double it doubles upes so you have two regular pluses so that's three but according to why it says I learned from that the giver and the receiver and it says also what's the word over there but it's the same word for both so it's two should we stop over here have a wonderful day I apologize for the L